Skip to content

fix(tui): gate multi-edit in review mode#1647

Merged
esengine merged 1 commit into
esengine:mainfrom
GTC2080:GTC/fix-1639-review-edit-gate
May 24, 2026
Merged

fix(tui): gate multi-edit in review mode#1647
esengine merged 1 commit into
esengine:mainfrom
GTC2080:GTC/fix-1639-review-edit-gate

Conversation

@GTC2080

@GTC2080 GTC2080 commented May 24, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

What

Route multi_edit through the TUI edit review gate. In review mode, multi-edit tool calls are converted into pending edit blocks and no files are changed until the user applies or discards them; mode changes also update the live edit-mode ref immediately so switching from yolo back to review affects the next tool call.

Why

Fixes #1639. The existing tool-call interceptor only handled edit_file and write_file, so multi_edit fell through to the filesystem tool after read-before-edit checks and could mutate files without the review gate. Mode changes also updated React state before the ref used by active tool calls, leaving a short stale window during in-flight turns.

How to verify

  • npm run verify
  • npm test -- tests/review-edit-gate.test.ts tests/tools.test.ts

Checklist

  • npm run verify passes locally (lint + typecheck + tests + comment-policy gate)
  • No Co-Authored-By: Claude trailer in commits
  • Comments follow CONTRIBUTING.md (no module-essay headers, no incident history)
  • No edits to CHANGELOG.md — release notes are maintainer-written at release time

@esengine esengine merged commit c848df3 into esengine:main May 24, 2026
4 checks passed
@esengine

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Thanks @GTC2080 — clean fix on a real review-mode bypass, plus the stale-ref tightening was a nice catch. Extracting the gate to its own module made it actually testable. Merged. 🙏

esengine pushed a commit that referenced this pull request May 24, 2026
…moved, persisted usage stats, plan dispatch gate

Headline themes:
- Desktop: bundle the CLI-hosted React dashboard, retire Tauri+Preact duplicate (#1418)
- Config: drop preset abstraction; flash/pro are direct model selections (#1657, #1630)
- Stats: persist cumulative usage to session meta + auto-restore on startup (#1667, #1680, #1643, #1628)
- Plans: editMode="plan" enforced at the ToolRegistry dispatch gate (#1681); step advance fix (#1629)
- Context: fold once at turn start, drop pre-flight + byte-ceiling (#1642, #1646); collapsible compacted card (#1649)
- Subagents: per-skill flash/pro override + Settings UI (#1632)
- Desktop polish: sidebar drag-resize (#1688), responsive collapse (#1585), copy/edit overlay + msg-history nav (#1645), Esc closes modal not turn (#1685), QQ tab isolation (#1672), DiffCard for edits (#1662), theme-aware highlighting (#1655), system events toggle (#1654/#1650), macOS TCC inheritance (#1614), dashboard.enabled (#1612)
- Dashboard polish: persistent session URL (#1586, #1589, #1599), theme-aware highlighting (#1664), IME confirm-enter guard (#1689), code-fence lang fix (#1677), vendor chunk split (#1587), markdown table h-scroll (#1562)
- TUI: Alt+S input stash/recall; static history isolated from input rerenders (#1635); legacy mouse drop (#1637, #1648); multi-edit gated in review (#1647)
- Diff: SplitDiff column border holds under CJK (#1686)
- MCP: workspace roots passed to servers (#1625); codeCommand honors mcpServers (#1603)
- Config plumbing: (baseUrl, apiKey) resolved as a tuple (#1658); stale model id self-heal (#1663)

See CHANGELOG for the full list.
@GTC2080 GTC2080 deleted the GTC/fix-1639-review-edit-gate branch May 31, 2026 10:43
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

review mode edits are ungated when switching from yolo

2 participants