Skip to content

🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline#14629

Merged
arvinxx merged 3 commits into
canaryfrom
arvinxx/fix/cc-disallow-askuserquestion
May 10, 2026
Merged

🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline#14629
arvinxx merged 3 commits into
canaryfrom
arvinxx/fix/cc-disallow-askuserquestion

Conversation

@arvinxx

@arvinxx arvinxx commented May 10, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

💻 Change Type

  • 🐛 fix

🔀 Description of Change

When the desktop app (or lh hetero exec) drives Claude Code via its -p --input-format stream-json non-interactive mode, the CLI auto-rejects any AskUserQuestion tool call by self-injecting an is_error: "Answer questions?" tool_result inside the CLI itself — before the host has any chance to surface the questions.

Reproduced locally with the same flags the desktop driver uses:

// 1. assistant emits tool_use
{"type":"assistant","content":[{"type":"tool_use","name":"AskUserQuestion","input":{"questions":[...]}}]}
// 2. CC CLI synthesizes an error tool_result
{"type":"user","content":[{"type":"tool_result","content":"Answer questions?","is_error":true,"tool_use_id":"..."}]}
// 3. model falls back to plain-text questioning
{"type":"assistant","content":[{"type":"text","text":"I'd be glad to help, but I need more context first..."}]}

So the user pays for a wasted assistant turn (191k tokens / 10s in the reported case) and ends up with a stuck-looking tool card and a plain-text question anyway. This is a known upstream limitation — see anthropics/claude-code#10400 and #29733. Anthropic's recommended fix is the SDK canUseTool callback, which the CLI subprocess flow can't reach; the documented CLI workaround is to disable the built-in and replace it with an MCP-backed tool (oneryalcin/claude-ask-user-demo).

This PR ships the cheap half: add --disallowedTools AskUserQuestion so the model just asks in plain text from the start, no broken tool card. Two spawn sites are patched in lockstep:

  • apps/desktop/src/main/modules/heterogeneousAgent/drivers/claudeCode.ts — desktop IPC path
  • packages/heterogeneous-agents/src/spawn/spawnAgent.tslh hetero exec path

Both carry the same explanatory comment so the flag can be removed when the MCP-backed replacement (which will bridge to LobeHub's existing lobe-user-interaction intervention UI) lands.

🧪 How to Test

  • Tested locally
  • Added/updated tests
  • No tests needed

Repro before the patch (CC 2.1.138):

echo '{"message":{"content":[{"text":"Use the AskUserQuestion tool right now to ask me what color I want","type":"text"}],"role":"user"},"type":"user"}' \
  | claude -p --input-format stream-json --output-format stream-json --verbose \
    --include-partial-messages --permission-mode bypassPermissions

Observe the auto-injected is_error: "Answer questions?" tool_result immediately after the tool_use block.

After the patch (or with --disallowedTools AskUserQuestion), the model emits a plain-text question instead and no broken tool card appears.

📝 Additional Information

Follow-up: wire a local MCP server exposing a lobe_ask_user_question tool that bridges to the existing lobe-user-interaction intervention UI; that brings back structured options and removes the --disallowedTools flag.

…o-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.
@vercel

vercel Bot commented May 10, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for GitHub.

Project Deployment Actions Updated (UTC)
lobehub Ready Ready Preview, Comment May 10, 2026 4:00am

Request Review

@sourcery-ai sourcery-ai Bot left a comment

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Sorry @arvinxx, you have reached your weekly rate limit of 500000 diff characters.

Please try again later or upgrade to continue using Sourcery

@dosubot dosubot Bot added size:S This PR changes 10-29 lines, ignoring generated files. feature:agent Assistant/Agent configuration and behavior feature:tool Tool calling and function execution provider:claude labels May 10, 2026
@codecov

codecov Bot commented May 10, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Codecov Report

✅ All modified and coverable lines are covered by tests.
✅ Project coverage is 65.85%. Comparing base (ecaec1b) to head (90d3fbd).
⚠️ Report is 1 commits behind head on canary.

Additional details and impacted files
@@           Coverage Diff            @@
##           canary   #14629    +/-   ##
========================================
  Coverage   65.85%   65.85%            
========================================
  Files        2890     2890            
  Lines      250469   250469            
  Branches    24206    25062   +856     
========================================
  Hits       164952   164952            
  Misses      85366    85366            
  Partials      151      151            
Flag Coverage Δ
app 60.07% <ø> (ø)
database 91.81% <ø> (ø)
packages/agent-runtime 80.48% <ø> (ø)
packages/builtin-tool-lobe-agent 83.41% <ø> (ø)
packages/context-engine 84.00% <ø> (ø)
packages/conversation-flow 92.43% <ø> (ø)
packages/file-loaders 87.60% <ø> (ø)
packages/memory-user-memory 74.74% <ø> (ø)
packages/model-bank 99.94% <ø> (ø)
packages/model-runtime 83.69% <ø> (ø)
packages/prompts 70.31% <ø> (ø)
packages/python-interpreter 92.90% <ø> (ø)
packages/ssrf-safe-fetch 0.00% <ø> (ø)
packages/types 4.86% <ø> (ø)
packages/utils 88.02% <ø> (ø)
packages/web-crawler 88.29% <ø> (ø)

Flags with carried forward coverage won't be shown. Click here to find out more.

Components Coverage Δ
Store 66.98% <ø> (ø)
Services 53.86% <ø> (ø)
Server 70.86% <ø> (ø)
Libs 55.22% <ø> (ø)
Utils 82.51% <ø> (ø)
🚀 New features to boost your workflow:
  • ❄️ Test Analytics: Detect flaky tests, report on failures, and find test suite problems.
  • 📦 JS Bundle Analysis: Save yourself from yourself by tracking and limiting bundle sizes in JS merges.

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.
@dosubot dosubot Bot added size:M This PR changes 30-99 lines, ignoring generated files. and removed size:S This PR changes 10-29 lines, ignoring generated files. labels May 10, 2026
Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
@dosubot dosubot Bot added size:L This PR changes 100-499 lines, ignoring generated files. and removed size:M This PR changes 30-99 lines, ignoring generated files. labels May 10, 2026
@arvinxx arvinxx merged commit e3cace3 into canary May 10, 2026
50 checks passed
@arvinxx arvinxx deleted the arvinxx/fix/cc-disallow-askuserquestion branch May 10, 2026 04:15
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 10, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 10, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 10, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 10, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
@arvinxx arvinxx mentioned this pull request May 12, 2026
Innei pushed a commit to Innei/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 12, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
emaxlele pushed a commit to emaxlele/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 12, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
arvinxx added a commit that referenced this pull request May 12, 2026
…o-decline (#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
lezi-fun pushed a commit to lezi-fun/lobehub that referenced this pull request May 13, 2026
…o-decline (lobehub#14629)

* 🐛 fix(hetero-agent): disable Claude Code AskUserQuestion to avoid auto-decline

CC's built-in AskUserQuestion self-injects an `is_error: "Answer questions?"`
tool_result inside the CLI in `-p` non-interactive mode before the host can
surface the questions, so the model falls back to plain-text prompting after
a wasted round-trip. Add `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion` to both spawn
sites (desktop driver + lh hetero exec) so the model goes straight to text.

To be revisited once a local MCP-backed replacement is wired to LobeHub's
intervention UI.

* ♻️ refactor(hetero-agent): share CC base args, opt-in partial deltas

- Promote CLAUDE_CODE_BASE_ARGS in `@lobechat/heterogeneous-agents/spawn` to
  the canonical source of truth for invariant CC CLI flags (`-p`, stream-json
  IO, `--verbose`, `--disallowedTools AskUserQuestion`); export it so the
  desktop driver can compose on top instead of duplicating.
- Pull `--include-partial-messages` out of the base. It's now a
  `SpawnAgentOptions.includePartialMessages` flag, off by default so
  `lh hetero exec` standalone/sandbox runs don't pay for delta noise they
  don't render. The desktop driver opts in (chat bubble streams live).
- Permission mode stays caller-specific: desktop hardcodes bypassPermissions
  (always user-mode), the package keeps its root-vs-user branch for cloud
  sandbox.

* 🎨 style(hetero-agent): pass spawn-args builders an options object

Positional list grew to four args with mixed types — switch to a single
`BuildSpawnArgsParams` object so call sites read by field name and adding
future per-agent flags doesn't push every other caller around.
@arvinxx arvinxx mentioned this pull request May 18, 2026
arvinxx added a commit that referenced this pull request May 18, 2026
# 🚀 LobeHub Release (20260518)

**Release Date:** May 18, 2026  
**Since v2.1.58:** 208 merged PRs · 209 commits · 16 contributors

> v2.2.0 introduces the **Chief Agent Operator** — an agent that runs
itself end-to-end. It self-iterates against its own output, assembles
sub-agent teams on demand through the heterogeneous runtime, and drives
a unified task system that knows when to pause for a human. Self-review,
AssistantGroup, and tasks/scheduling all converge into one operator
surface.

---

## ✨ Highlights

### 🎩 Chief Agent Operator

- **Self-iteration exits Lab** — Agent Signal's self-review pipeline
ships proposal actions straight into briefs and auto-executes the
approved follow-ups, with prompts hardened against eval. The operator
now critiques and re-runs its own work without a human in the loop.
(#14769, #14583, #14647, #14882)
- **Auto-formed agent teams** — Heterogeneous AssistantGroup gains
Monitor-style signal callbacks, read-only SubAgent threads with
breadcrumb headers, and a thread switcher. The operator dispatches
sub-agents and you can step into any branch to see what the team is
doing. (#14859, #14658, #14845, #14715)
- **Task system as the operator's runway** — Claude Code surfaces task
tools, AskUserQuestion freeform notes, and a dedicated `waitingForHuman`
topic status; `lobe-task` exposes `setTaskSchedule`; the scheduler is
hardened (maxExecutions cap, sub-10min heartbeat block, race-free
SchedulerForm). Long-running operator runs no longer go silent and stop
themselves when human input is needed. (#14870, #14639, #14713, #14865,
#14853)

### 🚀 Cloud & runtime

- **Cloud Claude Code V3** — Repo picker, GitHub token flow, and
sandbox-aware context bring cloud-hosted Claude Code to feature parity
with local; cloud sandbox completion now triggers the task lifecycle
end-to-end. (#14568, #14822, #14681)
- **Heterogeneous agent multi-replica safety** — Subagent threads,
ingest refresh, and parallel-tool counts now survive replica swaps
without losing parent_id or rolling back tool state. (#14897, #14631,
#14806, #14838)
- **Built-in tool lifecycle hooks** — `onBeforeCall` / `onAfterCall`
land on the built-in tool runtime; sub-agent dispatch moves to
`lobe-agent`; self-iteration aligns with the shared inspector pattern.
(#14719, #14715, #14827)
- **Knowledge base RAG unified** — Client and server share one
`KnowledgeBaseSearchService`; KB files preserved on `NoSuchKey` instead
of silently lost. (#14673, #14501)

### 💬 Workspace experience

- **Home daily brief + recommendations** — The home screen opens with a
linkable welcome, paired input hint, and a recommendations module
sourced from the operator's hetero action library. (#14589, #14645,
#14770)
- **Chat mode + redesigned action bar** — The chat input gains a
Chat/Agent mode toggle and a re-pitched action bar with icon-and-color
action tag chips. (#14774, #14903, #14846)
- **Documents tree, optimistic** — Document tree creates, deletes, and
inline renames now apply optimistically; the agent-documents index hides
web crawls and switches to a table layout. (#14714, #14292)
- **Branded MCP inspectors** — Linear MCP tool calls render with the
same branded inspector as the built-in Linear skill; CC MCP and built-in
skills now share inspector code. (#14864, #14884)
- **Bot identity gating** — Device tools are gated by sender identity,
the activator bypass is closed, and Slack mpim plus Discord DM
regressions are fixed. (#14634, #14664, #14733)

---

## 🏗️ Core Agent & Signal Pipeline

### Self-iteration & Agent Signal

- Self-iteration graduates out of Lab, with service, tool, name, and
concept structure unified across `agent-signal`, `prompts`, `database`,
and `builtin-tool-self-iteration`. (#14699, #14769)
- Self-review now proposes actions to briefs and auto-executes the
approved set, with eval-verified prompt hardening. (#14583, #14657,
#14647)
- Self-iteration built-in tool aligns with the shared runtime +
inspector patterns. (#14827)
- Agent Signal prompts adapt their response language and avoid blocking
agent execution. (#14890, #14775, #14882)
- Receipt descriptions now carry an Agent Signal marker, and self-review
hinted skill documents route correctly. (#14764, #14895)

### Heterogeneous agent runtime

- Subagent threads render read-only with a breadcrumb header and thread
switcher; SUBAGENT badge dropped, indentation tightened. (#14658,
#14845, #14783)
- Multi-replica safety: ingest refresh restores tools/model from DB to
fix parent_id breaks; new-step assistants sync across replicas;
subagent-tagged events no longer leak into the main gateway handler.
(#14897, #14631, #14838)
- Fetch-triggering events are deferred to keep parallel tool counts from
rolling back. (#14806)
- AskUserQuestion is wired for Claude Code, with auto-decline disabled
and a freeform note input on the cloud side; `waitingForHuman` is a
first-class topic status. (#14639, #14629, #14870)
- AssistantGroup gains Monitor-style signal callbacks; project skills
surface in the working sidebar and markdown preview. (#14859, #14896)
- Cloud Claude Code V3 — repo picker, GitHub token, sandbox context;
credentials alert and disabled input when not configured. (#14568,
#14822)
- Cloud sandbox completion now triggers the task lifecycle end-to-end.
(#14681)

### Agent runtime & context engine

- Built-in tool runtime gets `onBeforeCall` / `onAfterCall` lifecycle
hooks. (#14719)
- `CompletionLifecycle`, `HumanInterventionHandler`, and
`stepPresentation` are extracted from the runtime monolith. (#14441)
- Per-tool timeout is honored end-to-end for client tool dispatch.
(#14817)
- Compression budget accounts for `tool_calls`, reasoning content, and
tool defs; `call_llm` forwards tools into the budget. (#14813, #14837)
- Pre-flight context check now fails fast for OpenAI-compatible
providers. (#14824)
- Malformed `tool_call` names are recovered instead of finishing the
step silently. (#14577)
- Sub-agent dispatch moves from `lobe-gtd` to `lobe-agent`. (#14715)
- Hidden built-in tools now appear in the system prompt @-mention list.
(#14823)

### Agent tracing & operations

- New `agent_operations` table and runtime persistence for every
hetero-agent operation. (#14416, #14736)
- `signOperationJwt` issues 4-hour signed operation tokens. (#14586)
- S3 trace snapshots are zstd-compressed; DB `trace_s3_key` aligns with
the `.json.zst` suffix; legacy `.json` fallback preserved on fetch.
(#14807, #14860, #14826)

---

## 📱 Platform & Integrations

### Bot / Channels

- Device tools are gated by sender identity. (#14634)
- Activator bypass closed and device-access checks converged. (#14664)
- Slack mpim supported; Discord DM regression fixed; Slack connect +
slash commands repaired. (#14733, #14591)
- Bot channels, bot watch, bot callback service, and system bot
reliability fixes. (#14847, #14796, #14570, #14784, #14649)
- Online Messager scaffolding. (#14755)

### Onboarding

- Home daily brief with linkable welcome and paired input hint. (#14589)
- Recommendations module sourced from the hetero agent action library.
(#14645)
- Chat onboarding passes request triggers via metadata and preserves the
resume request. (#14770, #14798)
- Discovery turn progress gated by phase, with a reminder on stalled
discovery. (#14842, #14833)
- FullNameStep back button rejoins the shared prefix; ModeSwitch hidden
in production. (#14898, #14760)
- Agent marketplace folds into the web onboarding tool. (#14578, #14672)
- Onboarding interests stored as keys instead of free text; early-exit
skips marketplace and drops CJK prompts. (#14624, #14598)

### Model providers

- Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite cards; Gemini schema sanitizer drops
non-compliant `enum` / `required`; zero `cachedContentTokenCount`
handled in usage conversion. (#14604, #14740, #14567)
- DeepSeek-V4 model cards and pricing restored to official rates.
(#14110, #14911)
- ernie-5.1 and spark-x2-flash support; Grok 4.3 `reasoning_effort`
support. (#14643, #14731, #14642)
- SiliconCloud catalog synced with API; duplicates removed; reasoning
params adjusted. (#14464)
- Minimax derives `max_tokens` from context window to avoid
`ExceededContextWindow`. (#14814)
- aihubmix uses the full models endpoint for a complete list; stale
empty-apiKey test dropped. (#14511, #14669)
- Stream parse errors are enriched with provider + model context.
(#14636)
- Visual content parts are consumed in the server runtime; video image
references move to a JSON object. (#14637, #14900)
- Google function call magic `thoughtSignature` now attaches to every
part, not just the last turn. (#14904)
- Service model assignments settings added; model extend-param options
removed. (#14712, #14607)

### Built-in tools & knowledge base

- `lobe-task` exposes `setTaskSchedule`; task scheduler hardened
(maxExecutions cap, sub-10min heartbeat blocked, SchedulerForm race fix,
rapid automation-mode toggle stabilized). (#14713, #14865, #14853,
#14801)
- KnowledgeBaseSearchService shares RAG runtime across client and
server. (#14673)
- KB files preserved on `NoSuchKey` and orphan documents/tasks cleaned.
(#14501)
- Document tree gets optimistic create/delete + inline rename. (#14714)
- agent-documents index hides web crawls and switches to a table layout.
(#14292)
- `lobe-clarify` and SKILL.md frontmatter parsing/edit validation are
unified. (#14566)
- AnalyzeVisualMedia inspector + Portal HTML preview refactor; HTML
preview restored for AssistantGroup messages. (#14777, #14811)
- Branded inspector shared between CC MCP and built-in Linear skill.
(#14884, #14864)

---

## 🖥️ CLI & User Experience

### Chat & Conversation

- Chat mode toggle and redesigned chat input action bar. (#14774)
- Action tag chips switch to icon + colored label; ActionDropdown closes
on sibling-open and focus-out; submenu uses native header/footer slots.
(#14903, #14802, #14901)
- Action bar padding equalized around the send button; skeleton shows in
action bar while config loads. (#14846, #14656)
- `useCmdEnterToSend` is respected in thread & task inputs; send button
enables after pasting into thread/comment input. (#14850, #14816)
- TopicChatDrawer state preserved during close animation. (#14803)
- Only the last assistant block animates during markdown streaming.
(#14906)
- Right working panel no longer auto-collapses on chat mount; home agent
config fetched so knowledge toggles reflect in UI. (#14883, #14834)

### Tasks

- Task scheduler, hotkey, comment, and TodoList polish. (#14707)
- Add Subtask button & card baseline aligned; activity card stop run;
task agent manager polish. (#14848, #14559, #14569)
- Task template skeleton CLS reduced; task page placeholder copy
refreshed. (#14788, #14704)
- Task agent model snapshotted into `task.config` at create time.
(#14670)
- User-feedback card, task card polish, and Run-now context menu in
markdown. (#14727)
- Inline skill auth in recommended task templates. (#14676)

### Navigation & Layout

- Tab bar gains a Chrome-style divider between inactive tabs. (#14892)
- SideBarDrawer & header layout polish; nav ActionIcon sizing unified;
TodoList encapsulation improved. (#14762, #14692)
- Desktop header icons, sidebar density, and task menus polished.
(#14724)
- Standardized header action icon sizes. (#14717)
- Chat topic title length increased; copy session ID added to topic
dropdown menu. (#14659, #14595)
- Heterogeneous agent topic rows regain indentation. (#14783)

### Other polish

- Usage token details shortened; tool execution time formatted as `Xmin
Ys`. (#14849, #14641)
- Tool arguments display gets word-wrap toggle; long tool-call params
wrap instead of truncate. (#14706, #14640)
- Editor stops showing per-line placeholder once content is present.
(#14852)
- Visible divider between queued messages; intervention confirmation bar
polished. (#14593, #14587)
- Credit top-up copy refreshed; auth captcha retry copy refreshed; brief
recommendations layout polished. (#14821, #14561, #14871)

---

## 🔧 Tooling & Developer Experience

- Dev-only feature flag override panel. (#14565)
- `__DEV__` define replaces `process.env.NODE_ENV` in the SPA. (#14696)
- Agent-settings drops Meta/Documents tabs and restores `inputTemplate`.
(#14874)
- `local-system` forwards all `grepContent` params and moves the
executor to `/client`. (#14888)
- `lobe-task` and `setTaskSchedule` exposed. (#14713)
- Memory user-memory benchmark agent config and source-id extraction
schemas. (#14779, #14778)
- CLI man page drops stale cron entry; `clearMessages` hotkey removed.
(#14709, #14906)
- Skill docs simplified; cloud heteroContext gains sandbox TTL +
public-repo fork push guide. (#14785, #14761)

---

## 🔒 Security & Reliability

- **Security:** Sensitive comments and examples sanitized from the
production JS bundle. (#14557)
- **Security:** Inactive OIDC access rejected. (#14674)
- **Security:** CASC `new Function()` template replaced with safe string
builders. (#14751)
- **Security:** Sign-in captcha flow removed in favor of safer flow.
(#14573)
- **Security:** Desktop local file previews restricted to safe roots.
(#14789)
- **Security:** Image binary capped at 3.75 MB so base64 payload stays
under the Anthropic 5 MB limit. (#14711)
- **Reliability:** Neon/Node pools get error listeners to prevent Lambda
crashes. (#14606)
- **Reliability:** `paradedb.match(...)` replaces hardcoded normalizer
in memory search. (#14590)
- **Reliability:** `PlaceholderVariablesProcessor` errors carry
diagnostic context. (#14741)
- **Reliability:** File storage upload checks are serialized; multiple
account link bug fixed. (#14829, #14562)
- **Reliability:** `ScrollShadow` replaced with `ScrollArea` to fix a
React infinite render loop (error code 185). (#14689)
- **Reliability:** Embedding token cap enforced — long memory queries
are limited and truncated before search. (#14757)
- **Reliability:** Embed binary blob guard + oversized output cap in
`local-system.readFile`. (#14602)
- **Reliability:** Windows npm CLI shims resolved before spawning
agents. (#14772, #14720)
- **Reliability:** Vite pinned to 8.0.12 to avoid the rolldown 1.0.1
preload regression; desktop runtime externals split from native deps.
(#14804, #14776)
- **Reliability:** Old lobehub cron job removed; WeChat URL rules
dropped from web crawler. (#14630, #14633)

---

## 👥 Contributors

Huge thanks to **16 contributors** who shipped **208 merged PRs** this
cycle.

@hezhijie0327 · @sxjeru · @hardy-one · @Bianzinan · @brone1323 · @YuSaZh
· @Wxh16144 · @arvinxx · @Innei · @tjx666 · @neko · @lijian · @rdmclin2
· @sudongyuer · @AmAzing129 · @rivertwilight

Plus @lobehubbot for maintenance translations.

---

**Full Changelog**:
v2.1.58...v2.2.0
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

feature:agent Assistant/Agent configuration and behavior feature:tool Tool calling and function execution provider:claude size:L This PR changes 100-499 lines, ignoring generated files.

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant