Fantastic day dodging rainstorms, but warm reception on the doors for @NurulHoqueAli1 in Aberdeen South. A man who knows Aberdeen and its oil and gas industry inside and out. Great so many colleagues joining in support.
6. A frustration is that this big test of the new system only happens once in a term. A one off sample size to evaluate is always going to be limited in a mechanism that is loaded with personality and circumstantial biases. Many big problems will persist without gov change.
5. The real pressure lands on the governing party. Partly because that’s where the problem of pliant sycophancy has come from. But D’Hondt lands large number of Convenorships with them too. Find space in the ranks not just for internal dissent but genuine competition?
4. 16 Convenors out of a Parliament with 108 available Members is pretty tough. Every Cab Sec has at least 5 shadows. So extract a further 45 including leaders.
3. The numerical constraints on the system are acutely heightened in fractured parliament where the broad cost to parliamentary performance of groups of giving up front bench capacity is high.
2. That challenge was always going to be more likely in private party domains. Can a candidate command very high internal group support? This should still result in better outcomes.
1. The system adopted would only ever have resulted in improved private decision making other than situations in extremis. Eg: putting forward a very controversial candidate is now more difficult and subject to additional challenge.
I do believe that the reforms to SP Committee Convenorships are a step forward. Today they broke into the wild and are rightly a matter of public comment. A few points:
🚨Apply for the Nutmeg Academy.
We're seeking the next great voice in Scottish football content.
Read more about our paid, season-long apprenticeship covering print, digital and broadcast football media below:
🔗 shorturl.at/w63Oc
You don’t get better football writing than this. Gone too soon but never to be forgotten.
The ball sails over Kelly’s head and it was happy birthday Ralph.
We're remembering Ralph Milne today, on what would have been his 65th birthday.
In our very first issue @mrneilforsyth wrote what remains one of the most-loved articles we've ever published.
Read it here now: nutmegmagazine.co.uk/issue-1/rememb…