Anatoly Vorobey posted at FB (in Russian) about a novel I’d never heard of; I’ll translate what he wrote:
Jo Walton is a contemporary writer of fantasy and science fiction whom I have not read until now. Lent is a book set in Florence at the end of the 15th century, and its protagonist is a Dominican monk. The first part of the book—a pretty substantial chunk—is virtually indistinguishable from a historical novel (and a very good one, to my taste), containing almost nothing “fantastic”; but then, something happens… it would be too much of a spoiler to say more than that.
An interesting and original idea, wonderful prose—and, most importantly, in terms of the quality of its historical immersion, the book occasionally reaches the level of Patrick O’Brian (the highest possible praise from me). That said, there are some serious flaws—for instance, […], […], and even […]—but to my mind they didn’t outweigh the charm of this novel. Recommended: 4/5.
As you can imagine, that impelled me to read it, and having finished it, I’m in something of a quandary. Like Anatoly, I don’t want to spoil the plot turn, and like him I was somewhat let down by what followed it, but the first 40% (I read it on my Kindle) is so spectacularly good I’m eager to recommend it. He compares Walton to O’Brian, I’ll compare her to Hilary Mantel — I haven’t been so immersed in a carefully worked-out Renaissance environment since Wolf Hall. Furthermore, the portrait of Savonarola (for he is the Dominican monk in question) is as convincing as Mantel’s of Cromwell or Merezhkovsky’s of Machiavelli; for the first time I find myself feeling actual sympathy for that much-maligned fanatic. And it is a sterling example of religious sf/fantasy, not the most common subgenre; I would put it up there with A Case of Conscience and A Canticle for Leibowitz, though pretty much any seriously Christian reader is going to find it heretical, I fear. (The word apocatastasis crops up more than once!) All I can do is quote a couple of paragraphs from chapter 2 to give you a sense of the style and let you decide whether to give it a try:
[Read more…]
Recent Comments