docs(#19): full rule-audit table at docs/rule-audit.md#27
Conversation
Every MUST / NEVER / HARD-STOP from CLAUDE.md, .claude/rules/*.md, and workflows/*.md mapped to its enforcement mechanism (hook, agent, prose) and labelled mechanized / partial / advisory / deferred. AgDR-0001 captured the four-hook decision; this doc captures the full audit that was explicitly deferred from that PR. - 73 rule rows across 9 sections (git mechanics, workflow gates, code review & PR quality, AgDR, ticket vocabulary, code standards, role activation, deployment, onboarding) - 26 mechanized, 6 partial, 36 advisory, 5 deferred (to #15, #20, #21, #22, #23, #25) - "How to use this doc" section documents the changelog-vs-new-AgDR rule of thumb from AgDR-0001's thinking - CLAUDE.md Quick Reference adds a link to the new audit doc Pure docs. No hook changes, no rule-file changes, does not fold into AgDR-0001 (which stays historical). Refs #19
atlas-apex
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Code Review: PR #27
Commit: 2dffa8a29147baad0b3d5ac6b2bc2841ad62e6a0
Summary
Pure-docs PR adding docs/rule-audit.md — a 73-row audit table mapping every MUST/NEVER/HARD-STOP rule to its enforcement mechanism, plus one Quick Reference row in CLAUDE.md.
Checklist Results
- N/A Architecture & DDD: docs-only, no code
- N/A Code Quality: docs-only
- N/A Testing: docs-only
- ✅ Security: no secrets, no code
- N/A Performance: docs-only
- ✅ PR Description & Glossary: present and thorough (6 terms defined)
- ✅ Technical Decisions (AgDR): N/A — no new decisions; correctly references AgDR-0001
Issues Found
None blocking.
Cross-Reference Results
1. Completeness: 73 rows cover all 8 rule files + 3 workflow files + CLAUDE.md. Two minor DDD prescriptions from code-standards.md ("Value objects for domain concepts", "Domain events for side effects") are not individually listed — defensible since they lack MUST/NEVER language, but worth noting if the intent is exhaustive coverage.
2. Hook attributions: every hook filename in the table matches a real entry in .claude/settings.json. Matchers (if: patterns) align correctly with PreToolUse/PostToolUse/SessionStart events.
3. Partial classifications: all 6 justified. Composite workflow gates (2/3/4), ticket vocabulary, pre-push reminder, and IaC review — each explains which sub-part is hooked and which stays prose.
4. Deferred tickets: all 6 references (#15, #20, #21, #22, #23, #25) verified open. The 5-rows-vs-6-tickets discrepancy is explained in the summary paragraph.
5. Changelog-vs-new-AgDR rule of thumb: clear, actionable test ("would a reader who only saw the new state understand why without re-reading the old options?"). Consistent with AgDR-0001's post-ship amendment pattern.
6. CLAUDE.md Quick Reference link: points to docs/rule-audit.md — correct path.
7. PR quality: glossary present with 6 terms; title format docs(#19): valid; single ticket ref; Refs #19 used (appropriate for QA-state workflow).
Suggestions (nice-to-have, not blocking)
- Consider adding the two missing DDD lines (value objects, domain events) to the code-standards section for completeness, even if marked advisory. They are style prescriptions without MUST language, so omission is reasonable.
Surprising
The footnote system is well-done — six footnotes with cross-references to AgDR-0001 rationale. The [^coverage] footnote explaining why framework-level coverage enforcement was rejected adds real value for anyone forking apexstack and wondering "why isn't this a hook?"
Verdict
COMMENT — no blocking issues. Thorough, well-structured, accurate.
🤖 Reviewed by Rex (Code Reviewer Agent)
📌 Reviewed commit: 2dffa8a29147baad0b3d5ac6b2bc2841ad62e6a0
Summary
Full rule-audit table at
docs/rule-audit.md— every MUST / NEVER / HARD-STOP rule across CLAUDE.md, 8.claude/rules/*.mdfiles, and 3workflows/*.mdfiles, each mapped to its enforcement mechanism (hook, agent, or prose) and classified as mechanized / partially mechanized / advisory / deferred.73 rows across 9 sections. This is the documentation artifact that AgDR-0001 explicitly deferred: the design decisions were captured in the AgDR, but the complete enumeration of which rules are mechanized vs advisory was not. This PR closes that gap.
Refs #19
Counts
What changed
docs/rule-audit.md(183 lines) — 9-section table with a "How to use this doc" header explaining when to update the table and the changelog-vs-new-AgDR rule of thumb.CLAUDE.mdQuick Reference — added one row pointing to the audit doc.Ambiguity calls documented in the table
partialwith a note.partial.pre-push-gate.shis a reminder, not a runner. The actual pass/fail is per-project CI. Classified aspartial.Non-goals
Glossary
Test plan
grep -rn 'MUST\|NEVER\|HARD.STOP' CLAUDE.md .claude/rules/ workflows/count matches the 73-row table ± deduplication🤖 Generated with Claude Code