ethclient: allow passing AuthorizationList to calls by colinlyguo · Pull Request #31198 · ethereum/go-ethereum

colinlyguo · 2025-02-17T18:09:33Z

This PR adds the AuthList field in toCallArg to support eth_call and eth_estimateGas of SetCodeTx.

Some unit tests are added in this PR (containing uncovered cases, e.g., ErrSetCodeTxCreate).

fjl · 2025-02-17T18:22:34Z

We have been discussing this. At the moment, it doesn't feel very useful since you need a signed authorization in order to invoke the call. It's not super convenient. And it's not really necessary to override an account with code via EIP-7702 in eth_call because it already supports arbitrary state overrides in Geth. And the new method eth_simulateV1 supports overrides in all clients.

colinlyguo · 2025-02-17T18:36:10Z

We have been discussing this. At the moment, it doesn't feel very useful since you need a signed authorization in order to invoke the call. It's not super convenient. And it's not really necessary to override an account with code via EIP-7702 in eth_call because it already supports arbitrary state overrides in Geth. And the new method eth_simulateV1 supports overrides in all clients.

aha. I see and thanks. IMHO the main intention for this PR is not to overwrite accounts but to return an accurate gas estimation. e.g. bundlers may need to estimate gas (if the bundle transactions have some delegation submissions. I learned this from here. Though they might be written in other languages, too). In the meantime, it doesn't make it worse to support AuthList here, haven't thought of any side effects.

btw, do you think the added unit tests are useful here? might tweak some if duplicated.

colinlyguo · 2025-02-25T11:28:34Z

added some small fixes, pls take a look again. cc @fjl @s1na

buddh0 · 2025-03-07T09:35:16Z

I think it's an useful feature

colinlyguo · 2025-03-14T18:38:58Z

Asking for reviews (maybe further updates are needed or some things are unnecessary?). @s1na @fjl

clabby · 2025-03-25T15:13:33Z

What's the status here? This is useful to have - we've resorted to a shim above eth_estimateGas to manually include auth list costs in the meantime.

colinlyguo · 2025-03-26T10:36:59Z

bump. @s1na @fjl

s1na

LGTM

s1na · 2025-04-23T16:43:22Z

Renamed the field to AuthorizationList to keep it consistent with the API field.

s1na

LGTM

…thereum#3048) This PR adds the `AuthorizationList` field to the `CallMsg` interface to support `eth_call` and `eth_estimateGas` of set-code transactions. --------- Co-authored-by: colin <102356659+colinlyguo@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: Sina Mahmoodi <itz.s1na@gmail.com>

This PR adds the `AuthorizationList` field to the `CallMsg` interface to support `eth_call` and `eth_estimateGas` of set-code transactions. --------- Co-authored-by: Sina Mahmoodi <itz.s1na@gmail.com>

Add AuthorizationList field to CallMsg and toCallArg to support SetCodeTx in eth_call and eth_estimateGas APIs. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31198

* chore: update Go version to 1.21 * feat: implement EIP-7702 set code transaction type Add support for EIP-7702 (SetCodeTx) which allows EOAs to temporarily delegate their code execution to another account. Changes include: - Add SetCodeTx (type 0x04) transaction type and Authorization struct - Add anzeonSigner for EIP-7702 transaction signing - Implement delegation designator resolution in EVM - Add EIP-7702 specific gas calculation for CALL variants - Update EXTCODE* opcodes to handle delegation designators - Add prestate tracer support for authorization list - Update t8n tool and tests for SetCodeTx Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30078 * fix: complete EIP-7702 authorization marshaling and eth_call support Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30926 * refactor: improve EIP-7702 API naming - Rename Authorization to SetCodeAuthorization - Rename SignAuth to SignSetCode with key-first parameter order Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30933 * fix: rename SetCodeAuthorization 'v' to 'yParity' The API spec requires the name yParity. Based on: - ethereum/go-ethereum@73a4ecf - ethereum/go-ethereum#30936 * refactor: rename AuthList to SetCodeAuthorizations Use SetCode prefix consistently in internal APIs for the authorization list, as a follow-up to SetCodeAuthorization type renaming. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30935 * refactor: change SetCodeTx.ChainID to uint256 Change ChainID field type from uint64 to uint256.Int in SetCodeTx and SetCodeAuthorization for consistency with other chain ID handling. Also removes unused json/gencodec tags from signature value fields in DynamicFeeTx, BlobTx, SetCodeTx, and FeeDelegateDynamicFeeTx. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30982 * fix: correct chainId check for anzeonSigner Use zero value check for SetCodeTx chainId validation. This aligns with cancunSigner and londonSigner as well. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31032 * fix: initialize ChainID in SetCodeTx copy method ChainID should be properly initialized and copied in the copy() method to prevent nil pointer issues during transaction processing. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31054 * refactor: remove EXTCODE* special handling for EIP-7702 EXTCODE* opcodes no longer need special overrides for EIP-7702 delegation designators. The delegation designator is now returned as-is. Implements EIPs#9248. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31089 * feat: add EIP-7702 SetCode transaction pool support Add SetCode transaction handling to legacypool: - SetCodeTxType validation with Anzeon fork check - Empty authorization rejection - Authority tracking and conflict prevention - Account slot limit for delegated accounts and pending authorizations Note: tx replacement is not supported in go-stablenet. Tests are adjusted to expect ErrAccountLimitExceeded instead of successful replacement. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31073 * test: add setCodeTx reorg test Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31206 * refactor: move setcode tx validation into legacyPool Move authorization-related validations from common validation to legacyPool since these checks are specific to SetCode transactions. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31209 * fix: fix error logs flood caused by removeAuthorities Fix removeAuthorities to only iterate tx's authorities instead of all authorities in the pool. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31249 * refactor: reduce allocs in transaction signing Add sigHash method to TxData interface and move hash computation into each tx type, reducing allocations during signature operations. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31258 * fix: reject gapped tx from delegated account Add checkDelegationLimit to reject transactions with gapped nonces from delegated accounts. Only one in-flight executable transaction is allowed for senders with delegation or pending delegation. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31430 * fix: exclude 7702 authorities from eth_createAccessList result Exclude valid EIP-7702 authorities from access list generation result. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31336 (which resolves ethereum/go-ethereum#31335) * fix: data race in checkDelegationLimit Add delegationTxsCount method with proper lock to fix data race when accessing auths map in checkDelegationLimit. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31475 * feat: add EIP-7702 protection to blobpool Add delegation limit checks to blobpool: - Limit senders with delegation/pending auth to one in-flight tx - Check reserver for authority conflicts - Refactor AddressReserver to Reserver struct with Hold/Release/Has Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31526 * fix: slot limit check and update comments - Skip slot limit validation for tx replacements (same nonce reuses slot) - Clarify cumulative balance validation skip reason: fee delegation compatibility * fix: allow tx and authority regardless of admission order Check reserver for authority conflicts to make authorization validation independent of admission order. Authorities must not conflict with addresses reserved by other subpools. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31373 * fix: fix data race of txlookup access in test Reset txlookup fields directly with proper locking instead of assigning a new lookup object to avoid data race. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31641 * feat: allow passing AuthorizationList to eth_call and eth_estimateGas Add AuthorizationList field to CallMsg and toCallArg to support SetCodeTx in eth_call and eth_estimateGas APIs. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31198 * fix: fix data race of pricedList access Use Reheap() instead of assigning a new pricedList to avoid data race when clearing pool state. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31758 * fix: resolve incorrect prestate for EIP-7702 authority accounts Before: Authority accounts' prestate showed post-authorization code/storage and incorrect balance/nonce due to wrong capture timing After: Authority accounts' prestate correctly reflects state before SetCodeAuthorization is applied - Refactor EVMLogger to pass env in CaptureTxStart instead of CaptureStart - Capture authority accounts before delegation code (0xef0100...) is set - Preserve original code/storage while restoring only gas from balance * feat: prestate tracer lookup EIP-7702 delegation account Parse and lookup the delegation account if EIP-7702 is enabled in prestate tracer. Implements ethereum/go-ethereum#32078 Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#32080 * refactor: expose sigHash as SigHash for SetCodeAuthorization Rename the private sigHash() method to public SigHash() method to enable external signing (e.g., MPC signing). Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#32298 (which resolves ethereum/go-ethereum#32297) * fix: resolve test failures in tracer and blobpool - Add tracer lifecycle calls in runtime package - Fix EIP-7702 and blobpool test configs * Revert "chore: update Go version to 1.21" This reverts commit 71e90d7. * fix: support AuthorizationList in simulated backend gas estimation

* chore: update Go version to 1.21 * feat: implement EIP-7702 set code transaction type Add support for EIP-7702 (SetCodeTx) which allows EOAs to temporarily delegate their code execution to another account. Changes include: - Add SetCodeTx (type 0x04) transaction type and Authorization struct - Add anzeonSigner for EIP-7702 transaction signing - Implement delegation designator resolution in EVM - Add EIP-7702 specific gas calculation for CALL variants - Update EXTCODE* opcodes to handle delegation designators - Add prestate tracer support for authorization list - Update t8n tool and tests for SetCodeTx Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30078 * fix: complete EIP-7702 authorization marshaling and eth_call support Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30926 * refactor: improve EIP-7702 API naming - Rename Authorization to SetCodeAuthorization - Rename SignAuth to SignSetCode with key-first parameter order Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30933 * fix: rename SetCodeAuthorization 'v' to 'yParity' The API spec requires the name yParity. Based on: - ethereum/go-ethereum@73a4ecf - ethereum/go-ethereum#30936 * refactor: rename AuthList to SetCodeAuthorizations Use SetCode prefix consistently in internal APIs for the authorization list, as a follow-up to SetCodeAuthorization type renaming. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30935 * refactor: change SetCodeTx.ChainID to uint256 Change ChainID field type from uint64 to uint256.Int in SetCodeTx and SetCodeAuthorization for consistency with other chain ID handling. Also removes unused json/gencodec tags from signature value fields in DynamicFeeTx, BlobTx, SetCodeTx, and FeeDelegateDynamicFeeTx. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30982 * fix: correct chainId check for anzeonSigner Use zero value check for SetCodeTx chainId validation. This aligns with cancunSigner and londonSigner as well. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31032 * fix: initialize ChainID in SetCodeTx copy method ChainID should be properly initialized and copied in the copy() method to prevent nil pointer issues during transaction processing. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31054 * refactor: remove EXTCODE* special handling for EIP-7702 EXTCODE* opcodes no longer need special overrides for EIP-7702 delegation designators. The delegation designator is now returned as-is. Implements EIPs#9248. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31089 * feat: add EIP-7702 SetCode transaction pool support Add SetCode transaction handling to legacypool: - SetCodeTxType validation with Anzeon fork check - Empty authorization rejection - Authority tracking and conflict prevention - Account slot limit for delegated accounts and pending authorizations Note: tx replacement is not supported in go-stablenet. Tests are adjusted to expect ErrAccountLimitExceeded instead of successful replacement. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31073 * test: add setCodeTx reorg test Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31206 * refactor: move setcode tx validation into legacyPool Move authorization-related validations from common validation to legacyPool since these checks are specific to SetCode transactions. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31209 * fix: fix error logs flood caused by removeAuthorities Fix removeAuthorities to only iterate tx's authorities instead of all authorities in the pool. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31249 * refactor: reduce allocs in transaction signing Add sigHash method to TxData interface and move hash computation into each tx type, reducing allocations during signature operations. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31258 * fix: reject gapped tx from delegated account Add checkDelegationLimit to reject transactions with gapped nonces from delegated accounts. Only one in-flight executable transaction is allowed for senders with delegation or pending delegation. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31430 * fix: exclude 7702 authorities from eth_createAccessList result Exclude valid EIP-7702 authorities from access list generation result. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31336 (which resolves ethereum/go-ethereum#31335) * fix: data race in checkDelegationLimit Add delegationTxsCount method with proper lock to fix data race when accessing auths map in checkDelegationLimit. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31475 * feat: add EIP-7702 protection to blobpool Add delegation limit checks to blobpool: - Limit senders with delegation/pending auth to one in-flight tx - Check reserver for authority conflicts - Refactor AddressReserver to Reserver struct with Hold/Release/Has Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31526 * fix: slot limit check and update comments - Skip slot limit validation for tx replacements (same nonce reuses slot) - Clarify cumulative balance validation skip reason: fee delegation compatibility * fix: allow tx and authority regardless of admission order Check reserver for authority conflicts to make authorization validation independent of admission order. Authorities must not conflict with addresses reserved by other subpools. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31373 * fix: fix data race of txlookup access in test Reset txlookup fields directly with proper locking instead of assigning a new lookup object to avoid data race. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31641 * feat: allow passing AuthorizationList to eth_call and eth_estimateGas Add AuthorizationList field to CallMsg and toCallArg to support SetCodeTx in eth_call and eth_estimateGas APIs. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31198 * fix: fix data race of pricedList access Use Reheap() instead of assigning a new pricedList to avoid data race when clearing pool state. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31758 * fix: resolve incorrect prestate for EIP-7702 authority accounts Before: Authority accounts' prestate showed post-authorization code/storage and incorrect balance/nonce due to wrong capture timing After: Authority accounts' prestate correctly reflects state before SetCodeAuthorization is applied - Refactor EVMLogger to pass env in CaptureTxStart instead of CaptureStart - Capture authority accounts before delegation code (0xef0100...) is set - Preserve original code/storage while restoring only gas from balance * feat: prestate tracer lookup EIP-7702 delegation account Parse and lookup the delegation account if EIP-7702 is enabled in prestate tracer. Implements ethereum/go-ethereum#32078 Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#32080 * refactor: expose sigHash as SigHash for SetCodeAuthorization Rename the private sigHash() method to public SigHash() method to enable external signing (e.g., MPC signing). Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#32298 (which resolves ethereum/go-ethereum#32297) * fix: resolve test failures in tracer and blobpool - Add tracer lifecycle calls in runtime package - Fix EIP-7702 and blobpool test configs * Revert "chore: update Go version to 1.21" This reverts commit 71e90d700023db9fc1e0a272d7ffb9207ede738f. * fix: support AuthorizationList in simulated backend gas estimation

* feat: EIP-7702 Set Code Transaction support (#42) * chore: update Go version to 1.21 * feat: implement EIP-7702 set code transaction type Add support for EIP-7702 (SetCodeTx) which allows EOAs to temporarily delegate their code execution to another account. Changes include: - Add SetCodeTx (type 0x04) transaction type and Authorization struct - Add anzeonSigner for EIP-7702 transaction signing - Implement delegation designator resolution in EVM - Add EIP-7702 specific gas calculation for CALL variants - Update EXTCODE* opcodes to handle delegation designators - Add prestate tracer support for authorization list - Update t8n tool and tests for SetCodeTx Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30078 * fix: complete EIP-7702 authorization marshaling and eth_call support Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30926 * refactor: improve EIP-7702 API naming - Rename Authorization to SetCodeAuthorization - Rename SignAuth to SignSetCode with key-first parameter order Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30933 * fix: rename SetCodeAuthorization 'v' to 'yParity' The API spec requires the name yParity. Based on: - ethereum/go-ethereum@73a4ecf - ethereum/go-ethereum#30936 * refactor: rename AuthList to SetCodeAuthorizations Use SetCode prefix consistently in internal APIs for the authorization list, as a follow-up to SetCodeAuthorization type renaming. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30935 * refactor: change SetCodeTx.ChainID to uint256 Change ChainID field type from uint64 to uint256.Int in SetCodeTx and SetCodeAuthorization for consistency with other chain ID handling. Also removes unused json/gencodec tags from signature value fields in DynamicFeeTx, BlobTx, SetCodeTx, and FeeDelegateDynamicFeeTx. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#30982 * fix: correct chainId check for anzeonSigner Use zero value check for SetCodeTx chainId validation. This aligns with cancunSigner and londonSigner as well. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31032 * fix: initialize ChainID in SetCodeTx copy method ChainID should be properly initialized and copied in the copy() method to prevent nil pointer issues during transaction processing. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31054 * refactor: remove EXTCODE* special handling for EIP-7702 EXTCODE* opcodes no longer need special overrides for EIP-7702 delegation designators. The delegation designator is now returned as-is. Implements EIPs#9248. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31089 * feat: add EIP-7702 SetCode transaction pool support Add SetCode transaction handling to legacypool: - SetCodeTxType validation with Anzeon fork check - Empty authorization rejection - Authority tracking and conflict prevention - Account slot limit for delegated accounts and pending authorizations Note: tx replacement is not supported in go-stablenet. Tests are adjusted to expect ErrAccountLimitExceeded instead of successful replacement. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31073 * test: add setCodeTx reorg test Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31206 * refactor: move setcode tx validation into legacyPool Move authorization-related validations from common validation to legacyPool since these checks are specific to SetCode transactions. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31209 * fix: fix error logs flood caused by removeAuthorities Fix removeAuthorities to only iterate tx's authorities instead of all authorities in the pool. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31249 * refactor: reduce allocs in transaction signing Add sigHash method to TxData interface and move hash computation into each tx type, reducing allocations during signature operations. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31258 * fix: reject gapped tx from delegated account Add checkDelegationLimit to reject transactions with gapped nonces from delegated accounts. Only one in-flight executable transaction is allowed for senders with delegation or pending delegation. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31430 * fix: exclude 7702 authorities from eth_createAccessList result Exclude valid EIP-7702 authorities from access list generation result. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31336 (which resolves ethereum/go-ethereum#31335) * fix: data race in checkDelegationLimit Add delegationTxsCount method with proper lock to fix data race when accessing auths map in checkDelegationLimit. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31475 * feat: add EIP-7702 protection to blobpool Add delegation limit checks to blobpool: - Limit senders with delegation/pending auth to one in-flight tx - Check reserver for authority conflicts - Refactor AddressReserver to Reserver struct with Hold/Release/Has Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31526 * fix: slot limit check and update comments - Skip slot limit validation for tx replacements (same nonce reuses slot) - Clarify cumulative balance validation skip reason: fee delegation compatibility * fix: allow tx and authority regardless of admission order Check reserver for authority conflicts to make authorization validation independent of admission order. Authorities must not conflict with addresses reserved by other subpools. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31373 * fix: fix data race of txlookup access in test Reset txlookup fields directly with proper locking instead of assigning a new lookup object to avoid data race. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31641 * feat: allow passing AuthorizationList to eth_call and eth_estimateGas Add AuthorizationList field to CallMsg and toCallArg to support SetCodeTx in eth_call and eth_estimateGas APIs. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31198 * fix: fix data race of pricedList access Use Reheap() instead of assigning a new pricedList to avoid data race when clearing pool state. Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#31758 * fix: resolve incorrect prestate for EIP-7702 authority accounts Before: Authority accounts' prestate showed post-authorization code/storage and incorrect balance/nonce due to wrong capture timing After: Authority accounts' prestate correctly reflects state before SetCodeAuthorization is applied - Refactor EVMLogger to pass env in CaptureTxStart instead of CaptureStart - Capture authority accounts before delegation code (0xef0100...) is set - Preserve original code/storage while restoring only gas from balance * feat: prestate tracer lookup EIP-7702 delegation account Parse and lookup the delegation account if EIP-7702 is enabled in prestate tracer. Implements ethereum/go-ethereum#32078 Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#32080 * refactor: expose sigHash as SigHash for SetCodeAuthorization Rename the private sigHash() method to public SigHash() method to enable external signing (e.g., MPC signing). Based on ethereum/go-ethereum#32298 (which resolves ethereum/go-ethereum#32297) * fix: resolve test failures in tracer and blobpool - Add tracer lifecycle calls in runtime package - Fix EIP-7702 and blobpool test configs * Revert "chore: update Go version to 1.21" This reverts commit 71e90d700023db9fc1e0a272d7ffb9207ede738f. * fix: support AuthorizationList in simulated backend gas estimation * internal/ethapi: include AuthorizationList in gas estimation (#33849) Fixes an issue where AuthorizationList wasn't copied over when estimating gas for a user-provided transaction. * test: fix EIP-7702 t8n test expected output * refactor: remove redundant nil check --------- Co-authored-by: vickkkkkyy <vickyaviles847@gmail.com>

client: add AuthList field in toCallArg

6139430

colinlyguo requested review from fjl, holiman, lightclient, rjl493456442 and s1na as code owners February 17, 2025 18:09

s1na changed the title ~~client: add AuthList field in toCallArg~~ ethclient: add AuthList field in toCallArg Feb 18, 2025

s1na reviewed Feb 18, 2025

View reviewed changes

Comment thread internal/ethapi/api_test.go

tweak

1d5cae8

colinlyguo requested a review from s1na February 24, 2025 12:20

s1na reviewed Apr 9, 2025

View reviewed changes

Comment thread core/vm/errors.go Outdated

colinlyguo and others added 3 commits April 10, 2025 00:38

remove 0xef0001 || accounts[0].addr unit test

d82bb03

add 0xef0001 || accounts[0].addr unit test back

e26ecee

Merge branch 'master' into client-add-AuthList-field-in-toCallArg

f4ac996

colinlyguo commented Apr 16, 2025

View reviewed changes

Comment thread core/txpool/legacypool/legacypool_test.go Outdated

Update core/txpool/legacypool/legacypool_test.go

4c793da

s1na previously approved these changes Apr 17, 2025

View reviewed changes

rename to AuthorizationList

ac9313d

s1na dismissed their stale review via ac9313d April 23, 2025 16:42

s1na approved these changes Apr 23, 2025

View reviewed changes

s1na added this to the 1.15.10 milestone Apr 23, 2025

s1na changed the title ~~ethclient: add AuthList field in toCallArg~~ ethclient: allow passing AuthorizationList to calls Apr 23, 2025

s1na merged commit 846c14e into ethereum:master Apr 23, 2025
4 checks passed

buddh0 mentioned this pull request Apr 24, 2025

ethclient: allow passing AuthorizationList to calls (#31198) bnb-chain/bsc#3048

Merged

colinlyguo deleted the client-add-AuthList-field-in-toCallArg branch June 7, 2025 10:32

eomti-wm mentioned this pull request Jan 8, 2026

feat: EIP-7702 Set Code Transaction support stable-net/go-stablenet#42

Merged

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

ethclient: allow passing AuthorizationList to calls#31198

ethclient: allow passing AuthorizationList to calls#31198
s1na merged 7 commits intoethereum:masterfrom
colinlyguo:client-add-AuthList-field-in-toCallArg

colinlyguo commented Feb 17, 2025 •

edited

Loading

Uh oh!

fjl commented Feb 17, 2025

Uh oh!

colinlyguo commented Feb 17, 2025 •

edited

Loading

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

colinlyguo commented Feb 25, 2025

Uh oh!

buddh0 commented Mar 7, 2025

Uh oh!

colinlyguo commented Mar 14, 2025 •

edited

Loading

Uh oh!

clabby commented Mar 25, 2025

Uh oh!

colinlyguo commented Mar 26, 2025

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

s1na left a comment

Uh oh!

s1na commented Apr 23, 2025

Uh oh!

s1na left a comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

5 participants

Conversation

colinlyguo commented Feb 17, 2025 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

fjl commented Feb 17, 2025

Uh oh!

colinlyguo commented Feb 17, 2025 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

colinlyguo commented Feb 25, 2025

Uh oh!

buddh0 commented Mar 7, 2025

Uh oh!

colinlyguo commented Mar 14, 2025 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

clabby commented Mar 25, 2025

Uh oh!

colinlyguo commented Mar 26, 2025

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

s1na left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

s1na commented Apr 23, 2025

Uh oh!

s1na left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

5 participants

colinlyguo commented Feb 17, 2025 •

edited

Loading

colinlyguo commented Feb 17, 2025 •

edited

Loading

colinlyguo commented Mar 14, 2025 •

edited

Loading