Mike Evans consistently being like the 9th best WR in the league for a decade straight is wildly impressive but it also means he peaked as like the 9th best WR in the league
I don't think the question is if Mike Evans is a first ballot Hall of Famer.
I think the question is how many receivers in NFL history are in front of him. It ain't many.
It’s so funny that Anthony Davis, in the middle of his prime, is going to be at the All-Star Game to be honored as a top 75 player of all time but not to play in the actual game