I just had this idea to create a backup space outside of Twitter for my writing on Ukraine. NO SPECIFIC REASON, completely out of the blue.
So, if you are interested, please subscribe and share my (free) substack:
As a Russian-speaking person of color who was born and raised in Ukraine, I believe that I am in a position to speak on the issue of nationalism and neo-Nazism in Ukraine. A long thread π
Is Ukraine an ideal country without racism?
No.
Does the Ukrainian far-right have political prospects?
No.
Is Russia an ideal country without racism as they imply?
No.
Does the Russian far-right have political prospects?
It already is a fascist state.
The Russian empire erases the culture of its colonies. The captured lands are renamed Russia, ethnically cleansed, and/or forcibly assimilated. For Ukraine, this manifested in several genocidal famines, and a centuries-long policy of elimination of the language and culture.
We hear about it a lot. What we hear less about is how much Ukraine has improved in recent years. Ukrainians have elected a president whose campaign was based on unity across identities. And this president is of Jewish descent.
For example, the media often mention the ultra-right regiment of Azov. Its founding year? 2014. Date of Russia's attack on Ukraine? 2014. The current rise of the Ukrainian nationalist and far-right movements is to large extent caused by Russia's expansive aggression.
As I mentioned, I have experienced racism in Ukraine. But, having lived in the US and Europe, I can say that I was much more likely to encounter institutional racism abroad than in Ukraine. In the last decade, I felt safe in Kyiv (before the full-scale invasion of courseβ¦)
My father, Naeem, was an Afghan who moved to Ukraine in 1989. He has been working at a Kyiv market for the last 30 years. After his death about a year ago, I painted his eyes at the place where his kiosk was. Now his eyes have become witnesses of this war.
Photo by Alina Smutko
Same as with Russia and many other countries and peoples in Eurasia, BTW. If you want a quick tour of Russian colonialism, this thread is a great start:
when foreigners casually drop βbombing of kyivβ these pics always come to mind. this is what #RussianColonialism did to chechnya and grozny when they tried to leave the empire in 2000. a war crime of horrific scale, but the rest of the world was like βmehβ, so moscow continued
Russia used to be an authoritarian state, but now it has all the features of a fascist state. Totalitarian propaganda & censorship, popular support for violence β all of this is a portrait of modern Russia.
To talk about Ukrainian nationalism, we first have to establish the context of the relationship between Ukraine and Russia. These are not just countries sharing a common border. Our relationship is that of an empire and its colony.
β¦and defensive nationalism, poised to preserve traditions and identities.β Defensive nationalism is common to peoples whose identity is in existential danger.
Now, let us look more at the far-right movement. As in many European countries, there are right-wing parties in Ukraine. But unlike places such as Hungary, Italy, and others, in Ukraine, such parties have tiny support.
statista.com/chart/20094/naβ¦