Looking for input:
The vendor contract for the Commander panel includes a *surviving* non-disparagement clause, which means it limits what I can say about them forever, even if the contract ends.
I don't mind the NDC, but I'm uncomfortable with it in perpetuity. Thoughts?
Gavin Duggan
1,078 posts
MTG Commander Rules Committee founder. Computational Biochemist, Gamer (Ultimate, Poker, Destiny) creator of the Eternities Map and Planechase draft.
Joined February 2010
- Hot MTG take: Stifle should be reprinted (renamed) with a cost of {W}.
- Replying to @genomancerSince "I think WotC is doing a bad job of managing Commander" could reasonably be considered disparaging the company, this seems kind of important... and they've said that ALL members of the new "RC Panel" will receive the same contract, no exceptions.
- Commander RC preview card for #MTGNEO... a nice beater and card advantage engine which survives wraths. Thanks to our friends at WotC for providing the free sneak peak!
- Replying to @genomancer(For the sake of clarity, I'm optimistic they will do a good job of it... but I want to preserve the right to be public with that opinion if it goes wrong)
- The design of this card is so absurdly perfect that it's difficult to believe it was made to order. @GavinVerhey which came first, this card or the idea to use Suspend as a central mechanic for the Tenth Doctor deck?
- Emergency Unbanning in Commander: Exodia, Zubat, and Longest Road are now legal.
- Just received an unreal, honest-to-goodness awe inspiring alter from @ShivanArt. Come watch me blow up everyone's world with it on tonight's twitch.tv/CommanderRC stream... omfg so happy :)
- This week has taught me a lot of things, but first among them is this: Our moderators are amazing, crucial to our function, and resilient beyond reasonable expectation. It's not an overstatement to say that I love them and appreciate them more than I can say.
- One thing that has become clear from this weekend is that the twitch.tv/CommanderRC stream is going to be ok, even thrive going forward. I've made a personal goal to keep it going, and the number of people who have offered to help has been heart warming.
- Replying to @James_LRRYeah, I don't want to cast them in a bad light... I think it's just legal boilerplate, but ...
- Replying to @GregorySablanSeems fine, honestly? Cultivate isn't "we all play the same amount of magic", it's "I get to play more magic than you"... ramp isn't sacrosanct and countering it seems legit even in casual games.






