Current American guidelines for managing gender dysphoria in adolescents untrustworthy. Don’t acknowledge the very low certainty evidence regarding alternatives and do not make the very guarded weak/conditional recommendations appropriate for such evidence
Gordon H. Guyatt
4,370 posts
Promoting use of the best evidence and patient values and preferences to inform optimal clinical and health policy decisions. threads.net/@guyattgh
- Great article: frequent mistakes people make in interpreting p-values, confidence intervals and statistical power and how to correctly interpret. Enhanced my understanding of comparing two results and relation between CI overlap and stat sig differences. bit.ly/3kWcKaF
- An advanced EBM evidence pyramid acknowledges that randomized trials sometimes yield only very low certainty evidence and that observational studies sometimes yield high certainty evidence.
- Just published: ground-breaking study of over 23,000 RCTs in Cochrane reviews. Trials hugely underpowered for true effects. Consequently, “statistically significant” estimates seriously overestimate actual treatment effects, can’t trust them.
- Our group has developed an inventory of all estimates of minimal important differences for all patient-reported outcomes known to humankind and rated the credibility of each MID. We are keen to work with anyone interested in using the fruits of our work. doi.org/10.1016/j.jcli…
- Nice paper on what one can deduce about p-values from looking at overlap in confidence intervals between two independent means. Many do not realize there can be considerable overlap in confidence intervals and p-value still appreciably below 0.05 bit.ly/3y5HkoG
- Best compliment ever received as mentor: student telling me he was sure I was treating him as special - until he discussed with my other students who all felt the same way. Worthwhile goal to set oneself: making all students feel as if they are getting special mentorship.
- With my daughter Claire on her graduation from McGill university's Arts and Science program. She'll soon be off with two friends for a two month tourist adventure in Southeast Asia.
- I was asked to prepare a very brief introduction to GRADE for new members of a WHO guideline panel. The 11.5 minute result could be useful for any guideline group wanting to give their panel members a brief bird’s eye view of the GRADE process.
- Making a distinction between evidence-based and consensus-based guidelines is both misguided and misleading: all trustworthy guidelines demand both rigorous evaluation of the evidence and a process to reach a panel consensus.
- Recently published #JAMA #Users’ #Guides for #Guidelines best around for navigating the way to identifying and using a trustworthy guideline. bit.ly/3rz9Mff @rominabrigpet
- The patient revolution 1 A paper from the most brilliantly original thinker writing about #healthcare today. Victor Montori tells us about careful and kind care and how caring for each other is a social determinant of health. bit.ly/310ROcA @vmontori @patientrev
- #SampleSize calculations are a hoax. Sample sizes seldom approximate requirements to detect small important differences. True determinants: feasible recruitment, available funding. #Clinicians, #guideline developers: ignore authors’ superiority thresholds. bit.ly/34TZb76







