Thanks Paul. I am still using SHIELD (awesome plugin btw!) but I had to turn off gasp because form some reason it doesn’t plug into custom forms and instead I am using Captcha by BestWebSoft for that purpose and it works perfect.
The issue mostly is not the login but the registration for which GASP needs to integrate with custom form.
Anyways – I found a solution 🙂
Actually the plugin is working fine I just tested it.
If you read the full instructions on the link I provided you earlier I think it will give you an idea why you think it didn’t work for you. Because you were logged in!
For the general public who is not logged in the old theme will continue you to appear even after you have activated the plugin.
I think you might be able to do it using theme tester.
