I can’t see any differences in the settings for the two sitemaps in Rank Math. However before I reach out to them to query direct, I’ve attached a screenshot link to how the two taxonomies are setup via CPTUI. I do see some differences in the vernacular in the right hand column.
Do you see anything further here that may assist with troubleshooting?
Thanks in advance.
https://barftime.com.au/elementor-landing-page-4659
The other taxonomy created with your plugin is /pet-sitemap.xml
This is the one showing a 404 “HTTP” Site Map Can’t be Found Error in GSC
I’m using Rank Math for my Sitemaps