When dealing with threaded comments on a blog in HTML5 would you expect “threaded responses” comments to be nested <article>’s ? Or would you consider even the “threaded responses” simply another <article> within the scope of the blog post <article>?
Example A:
<section>
<article>
...blog post...
<section id="comments">
<article>...comment 1...</article>
<article>...comment 2...</article>
<article>...comment 3 in response to comment 2...</article>
<article>...comment 4 in response to comment 2...</article>
<article>...comment 5 in response to comment 4...</article>
<article>...comment 6...</article>
</section>
</article>
</section>
Example B:
<section>
<article>
...blog post...
<section id="comments">
<article>...comment 1...</article>
<article>
...comment 2...
<article>...comment 3 in response to comment 2...</article>
<article>
...comment 4 in response to comment 2...
<article>...comment 5 in response to comment 4...</article>
</article>
</article>
<article>...comment 6...</article>
</section>
</article>
</section>
The topic ‘Threaded comment in HTML5’ is closed to new replies.
(@beingzoe)
15 years, 2 months ago
When dealing with threaded comments on a blog in HTML5 would you expect “threaded responses” comments to be nested <article>’s ? Or would you consider even the “threaded responses” simply another <article> within the scope of the blog post <article>?
Example A:
Example B: