









Normally, the big news of the week would have been that Bradley Manning was sentenced to 35 years for giving away classified documents in one of the largest prison sentences ever handed down for breach of confidentiality. But, that rarely seems to register as all the transgender issues, confused messaging, childhood trauma is brought up at trial, and the declaration made that Bradley Manning is no more – and Chelsea Manning is who we are really talking about. While media outlets fight over he/she (and the really loser one’s just keep referring to her as “the soldier”) (that’s you, Fox News), I am left to wonder if there is any real power in her purpose left.
To me: it is tragic Chelsea Manning grew up in an alcoholic home, had gender issues, and was in a hostile work environment. However, none of that explains or excuses the choices that were made. I would have been more impressed if the defense stuck with the “I believe in freedom and was trying to stop the war. I’m willing to pay the price for my ideals.” line than “I couldn’t help it, I was all messed up and no one helped me.” line. Many people have lifted Manning up as a HERO fighting for transparency and fairness. But I don’t think you get to be a hero if the reason you did it was because you were confused and unfit for duty. Then, you’re the goat.
It comes down to this: Chelsea Manning chose to give up those documents and should go to jail. She’s not a “transgender hero”. She’s not a patriotic hero. She’s not even an hero sandwich. She’s also not the scourge of the military or everything that’s wrong with the Army. She’s a human being, making her way. Her cred. as a catalyst for anti-government thought is over. She wasn’t making a stand. She was standing in la la land. There are now too many issues to raise the flag cleanly. It’s time for Chelsea to fade into her sentence and deal with her issues as best she can.
Edward Snowden, on the other hand – his time in the spotlight has just begun.
Point of Education: The proper thing to do is refer to someone as the gender they tell you. As such – Chelsea Manning is and should be referred to as “she” from now on.
Posted in Administration, Chelsea Manning, Communication, Edward Snowden, Fox News, GLBT, Image, Politics, Wikileaks
Tags: Beagles, Beaglez, Bradley Manning, Chelsea Manning, Jail time, releasing documents