My rating system:
10 – life-changing, an all-time favorite
5 - average for what I read
1 – terrible; why did I finish it?
Maid: Hard Work, Low Pay, and a Mother’s Will to Survive by Stephanie Land – The book is exactly what the title suggests. The author is a single mom and she’s trying hard to make ends meet, working as a maid. I loved the book. It was a straight-forward account of being poor in America. There was also an element I found fascinating in that she cleans houses and thus gets glimpses of her clients’ lives. Reviewers on Goodreads, however, were torn and lots of them trashed it. I….don’t understand? Maybe a few times the book is repetitive, yes. The author does make a couple bad decisions, but doesn’t every human? (The bad decisions seem to be deciding to have a baby when she had no means to support one, and using a tax refund on one or two frivolous items). I didn’t find her remotely whiny or playing the victim at all. I thought it was an honest look at living in poverty in the US today. I guess I just viewed this book way differently than many Goodreads reviewers. Grade: 8
Tell Me How It Ends by Valeria Luiselli – This is a very short (100 pages) book by a teacher who also translates for children fleeing gang violence in South America and seeking asylum in the US. I just wish everyone could read this and understand more about why people risk everything to come to the US. Sadly, migrant-haters will either never read this or just wouldn’t care if they did. (Sheesh, sorry to be so pessimistic). The book was well-written and captivating. Grade: 8
The Truth Will Set You Free But First It Will Piss You Off by Gloria Steinem – Two short books in a row; this one can pretty much be read in a sitting or two. My quick summary for this one is that it was inspiring and easy, but also not very earth-shattering. It’s basically a collection of quotes and brief essays from the legendary activist. I gotta say that a lot of it was dated. I do like that Steinem includes quotes from “friends”- other activists, especially women of color. I would’ve liked to have seen more (or even, some) trans or nonbinary voices. But despite the book’s flaws, if you’re a long-time activist like me, it’s a good read for some comfort and inspiration. And also, she is 85 years old so maybe her book doesn't seem nearly as dated as it could! Grade: 7
The Queen of Water by Laura Resau and Maria Virginia Farinango – A novel based on a true story. Maria Virginia Farinango is an indigenous Ecuadorian, and as many girls in her situation, her parents “give” her to a middle-class, lighter-skinned family to work. She is basically somewhere between a servant and a slave. As you can guess, she manages to her pull herself out of her situation. I really, really wish this had been a memoir instead of a novel. As a work of fiction, it just doesn’t compete with really great novels, but no doubt Farinango’s story would’ve fascinated me without the attempt to turn it into a work of fiction. Grade: 4
Sissy: A Coming of Gender Story by Jacob Tobia - The author is a non-binary writer, performer, and activist. Their memoir is great! I've read plenty of memoirs by LGBT people, and I try to think of what makes this one stand out. Maybe Tobia's witty writing, which at times is hilarious. Tobia is also very big on intersectionality and they bring the concept to the forefront when needed. I'd say they are a breath of fresh air! (Also, sidenote, I'm watching She-Ra on Netflix, and I coincidentally learned that Tobia voices a non-binary character on that show. Very cool!) Grade: 8