Posts Tagged ‘palestine’

Israel’s Kristallnacht — And Minnesota’s

January 21, 2026

“Kristallnacht” was the 1938 German Nazi pogrom attacking Jews with violent atrocities. (My own forebears got out months earlier.)

The word came to mind while reading a January 19 AP report which begins, “Israeli settlers rampaged through a Palestinian village in the West Bank, setting fire to a series of structures . . . in an overnight onslaught that has become a common phenomenon in the occupied territory.” Accompanied by “the sound of gunfire, screaming and barking.” Homes and cars were burned.

Israel’s military said soldiers were searching the area to make arrests — but none were reported.

Such vicious unprovoked assaults upon ordinary Palestinians have indeed been constant. Perpetrated by racist religious settler fanatics believing God wants them to reprise the Old Testament’s conquest of Canaan slaughtering its original inhabitants. Israel’s regime, captive to these extremists, hardly pretends to restrain them. Only going through the motions, as in this latest episode at Khirbet al-Sidra, reported above. Practically no settlers are ever punished for such crimes.

They apparently see an open door for them, while the world’s eyes are on the far greater ones in Gaza, with over 70,000 killed and most housing there destroyed, the population reduced to starvation and wretchedness. While Israel works to impede humanitarian help. Warring against the UN’s Palestinian relief agency, whose headquarters have now been bulldozed, Israelis whooping in jubilation on the rubble.

At least the Gaza monstrosity had the pretext of October 7 and continuing Hamas enmity. There’s not even any such pretext for West Bank settler savagery.

“Never again” was the line after the Holocaust. But these Israelis are themselves taking a page from the Nazi playbook.

And then there’s Minnesota, likewise with ethnic “others” singled out for brutalization. Today brings an AP report about U.S. citizen ChongLy Thao, of St. Paul (whose family had escaped from Communist Laos in the 1970’s). His home was attacked by a brace of masked ICE agents, with no warrant, breaking down his door, pointing guns at his family and screaming at them. Thao tried to get his ID, but the ICE men said they didn’t want to see it.

Instead, they handcuffed him, in his underwear, took him outdoors in frigid weather, drove him away, then exposed him outside again — and demanded his ID.

Later they drove him him back, viewed his ID, and left with no apology.

Broadcast video of other ICE operations shows shockingly cruel brutality. Its gauleiter Gregory Bovino insists everything they’re doing is lawful, proper, even “moral.” Kristi Noem’s DHS justified the Thao attack as having sought some sex offenders — one of whose first name supposedly matched that of the owner of a car borrowed by Thao’s son. AP’s report finds nothing connecting any sex offenders to the Thaos. So the regime just makes stuff up — as usual.

Why aren’t all these ICE pricks’ violent crimes prosecuted by local law enforcement and grand juries? Certainly Renee Good’s murder should be. The regime says it won’t allow Minnesota authorities to impinge upon its own investigation of that case — an investigation which the regime meantime deems unnecessary. They also say all these federal officers are immune from prosecution. Utter bunk. This is still a nation of laws where all government personnel (though not, apparently, the president) are accountable to the public and not free to commit crimes with impunity.

Or is it?

Should Trump Get a Nobel Peace Prize?

October 12, 2025

Trump may have finally managed, after flailing around erratically, to stop the Gaza war. Even a broken clock is right twice a day.

Still, it does appear his actions have had the effect of halting the carnage — a very big thing. If Arafat got a Nobel there, should Trump?

He touts himself as a great peacemaker, asserting he’s resolved conflicts all over the place. Mostly bullcrap. He actually infuriated India by falsely claiming credit for resolving its recent hostilities with Pakistan.

It’s not peace Trump loves, it’s only himself. Thirsting always for praise; and obsessively craving a Nobel just because his bête noir Obama got one. It might seem clueless to imagine Europeans, who largely despise him, would so honor him. Yet all his peace efforts are in service to that quest born of ego.

But altruism is a human conundrum. Most good things we do are ultimately bottomed in making us feel good about ourselves. Or avoiding bad feelings for not doing them. Pure altruism is rare. Trump differs only in being so transparent in this.

Israel’s September air strike on Doha was thought at first to kill any chance for peace. However, it seems to have made Israel even more of a pariah than it already was, shaking Netanyahu. With Trump’s newfound fed-upness pushing matters over the line, leaving Netanyahu unable to blow him off.

Hamas, meantime, seems to have basically, finally, surrendered, realizing that continued fighting was pointless (or worse). But maybe the Doha strike played a role there too. Israel didn’t get the leaders it had targeted. Yet those guys may now have newly feared for their own lives. It could be just that simple.

Anyhow, Trump’s role was important and might seemingly be Nobel-worthy. But there are some big caveats.

First, we don’t know how things will work out going forward. The matter of administering Gaza is very fraught, reconstruction a challenge beyond immense. Who will pay for it? Israel, in justice, should be made to pay, but good luck there. Meantime, rogue Hamas bitter-enders, and others radicalized to hate Israel, could make a lot of trouble; another October seventh-like event could blow everything up. While Israel’s Jewish zealot movement is still running amok in the West Bank.

And Trump’s ostensible achievement regarding Gaza should not be viewed in isolation. For all his peacemaker posturing, he’s actually done much to wreck a global order that for many decades kept the peace (more or less). He’s weakened America’s network of alliances; weakened the UN; legitimized Putin; ratcheted up enmity with China; slashed foreign aid, presaging great numbers of preventable deaths. He’s slammed the door on refugees. And his tariffs have seriously damaged the world’s trading system. The latter a very big thing that should weigh heavily against any positive achievements he might claim elsewhere.

Further, here at home, Trump is anything but a peacemaker, inciting divisions, hatreds, and violence (much as he blames opponents; remember January 6 and the pardons). He’s sending armed troops into cities, stoking conflict rather than soothing it. And the lawless depredations of his ICE thugs are hardly peaceable.

Finally: regarding a Nobel peace prize, should character and morality count?

I Don’t Hate Jews. I Hate Israel

October 3, 2025

On October 7, 2023, Hamas atrocities killed about 1200. Since, Israel has killed at least 66,000 Gazans (half women and children), injured 170,000 more, and made life hell for the remaining 2 million.

October 7 capped two decades of the Israeli regime’s facilitating Hamas, to sow discord among Palestinians. That Netanyahu regime is controlled by racist religious fanatics, believing God gave them the land exclusively — every inch. Using October 7 as a pretext to achieve that vision.

By bombing and shooting Gazans, demolishing their housing, and intentionally starving them. Israel denies anyone goes hungry. Claims that Hamas steals food aid (pretty well debunked). Set up a sketchy supposed food distribution system, with daily massacres of dozens of people trying to get that aid. Denies that too.

Help from outside is kept to a trickle; Israel has blockaded an international aid flotilla, and arrested hundreds of participants. Global authorities have officially declared famine in Gaza. Many hundreds already dead from starvation. It’s hard to see how most Gazans can get any food at all. The death toll almost certain to explode in coming months.

Such are the atrocities committed against civilians by Israel’s military, violating international norms of warfare. When not denying grisly war crimes outright, Israel’s regime promises to investigate and hold people accountable. Almost always a sham, a recent in-depth analysis by The Economist found.

Israel has barred news media from Gaza, to hide what’s happening. Nevertheless, at least 200 journalists, risking their lives to report there, have been killed during these two years — a death rate far exceeding that for any other 20th Century conflict. Most in Gaza deliberately targeted, i.e., murdered, by Israeli soldiers. Israel typically makes unsubstantiated claims that those victims were terrorists.

Israeli West Bank settlers, meanwhile, in the vanguard of the Jewish zealot movement, wage an escalating violent pogrom, virtually with impunity, against the 3.4 million indigenous Palestinian inhabitants there. Israel has just authorized a huge new settlement.

Now it has ordered around half a million Palestinians to leave Gaza’s main city, for a distant “humanitarian” zone. A better descriptor might be “hellhole.”

Many have suffered repeated past expulsions. Many are too weakened by hunger, injuries or sickness to travel, and most have no means to do so, except on foot, if they even have shoes. Leaving behind what they cannot carry. In comparison the Biblical exodus from Egypt was a cakewalk. Israel’s Defense Minister warns that anyone not going will be considered a terrorist, to face the full force of Israel’s military assault.

To justify all this, Israel keeps intoning Hamas! Hamas! Hamas! As if there can be much of it left, after two years of this holocaust. Or — are Israelis, by making themselves more hated, Hamas’s best recruiters? Are they preventing an October 7 repeat — or ensuring it?

Yesterday was Yom Kippur, the “high holy day” when Jews fast to atone for sins and reflect upon them.

I still see lawn signs declaring, “We Stand With Israel.” The U.S. regime does, complicit in support and supplying weapons; punishing and trying to deport people who speak out for Palestinians.

Hitler killed 6 million Jews. Israel has slightly more Palestinians to deal with.

Who ARE the Palestinians??

July 31, 2025

“Anti-semitism” means Jew hatred. Jews being Semites. But you know who else are Semites? Palestinians.

An oft forgotten fact. But wait, there’s more. How are these people, such enemies, actually related?

The story Israel’s Jews centralize is reclaiming their ancestral homeland. Lost to them for two millennia, after their revolts against the Romans failed. Sending them into exile, into a diaspora, mostly in Europe, while interlopers moved into what had been their “Holy Land.”

A good story. But it isn’t true.

The origins of European Jewry (my own) present an historical conundrum. One theory has us mostly descended from the Khazars, an East Asian people, whose Khan (around 800 AD) converted them to Judaism. DNA evidence seems to refute that idea, instead tracing most European Jews to the Levant, i.e., the Middle East — a region much larger than just the Biblical Holy Land.

From which they were not somehow expelled en masse by the Romans. Though subjugated, most would have had no reason (or wherewithal) to relocate to distant realms. Roman rule was followed by their successor Byzantine Empire, and then, in 638 AD, by a Muslim one. Meantime, recall that Christianity had originated as a Jewish sect; the earliest Christians had been Holy Land Jews. After Christianity became the state religion of the Roman and then Byzantine empires, that faith duly reigned in their Judaean province. Then supplanted by Islam when the Muslims gained control.

While the Muslims did exhibit some intermittent tolerance for other religions, in the lands they conquered it was generally a good self-serving idea for people there to go along and adopt the Islamic religion now culturally dominant.

That’s the backstory of today’s Palestinians. Their ancestors were the Old Testament Hebrews — the Semites — who turned Muslim. They didn’t take over the land, they’d always been there. The true inheritors of the Biblical Jews.

Over 60,000 of them have so far been killed by Israel’s Gaza invasion, with around 150,000 injured, overwhelmingly civilians, a great many of them women and children. Israel’s claim of scrupulously avoiding civilian harm rings increasingly Orwellian. Dozens are being killed daily just queuing for food aid (in the last 24 hours, 91 people). Israel admits only to “warning shots,” but it’s obvious soldiers are wantonly massacring Gazans because they can.

Now starvation is really setting in, with children especially affected. Blaming this somehow on Hamas is Kremlinesque nonsense. Unless something changes drastically within a few days, tens of thousands will agonizingly starve to death. Israel uses this as a weapon of war — not against Hamas but Palestinians collectively. The extremist religious fanatics of Israel’s regime have exploited October 7 as a God-sent opportunity to realize their demented dream of ridding themselves of Palestinians once and for all. Gaza’s societal infrastructure has been thoroughly obliterated. The plan is for its surviving people to be confined into what can only be termed a concentration camp.

Israel’s regime claims they target just Hamas, blaming all the carnage and death on them. At this point, even if some vestige of Hamas still exists, can it be such a threat to Israel as to justify the horrific rain of destruction and death it’s inflicting on innocent human beings? Insane even from the standpoint of Israel’s own true interests.

It makes anti-semitism look almost rational.

Trump: Mister Human Rights

May 22, 2025

Talking to Xi Jinping, Trump did not criticize China’s horrific human rights abuses against Xinjiang Uighurs, around a million put in concentration camps. In fact, Trump endorsed that. Meeting Israel’s Netanyahu, Trump had nothing to say about Palestinians’ human rights. Indeed proposing his own ethnic cleansing.

Then he had a chummy session with El Salvador’s dictator Bukele. Then in the Middle East said nothing critical to any of its authoritarian rulers; certainly not Saudi Arabia’s MBS, who ordered the dismemberment of a Washington Post journalist.

The word “transactional” is often heard regarding Trump foreign policy. Meaning it’s all about “deals.” With no concern about human rights — or morality more broadly — supposedly trumped by interests. As if it’s in our interest to align with dictators and screw longtime allies. Such amorality weakens America.

Then South African President Ramaphosa visits the White House — and Trump is suddenly all Mister Human Rights. Yammering about white farmers’ land confiscated, even their “genocide,” with “death, death, death,” and impunity for murderers. Even playing Ramaphosa a video of a song about killing whites.

Sung not by anyone in his government, but an opposition rabble-rouser who he’s battled against. Everything else in Trump’s indictment was likewise nonsense. While South Africa does suffer much crime and violence, victims are mostly Blacks (not whites, who often have resources to protect themselves).

How deeply sick it is for Trump to choose this one phony human rights issue to posture about, disregarding the all too real atrocities against Uighurs, Palestinians, and so many others. But those all made the mistake of choosing the wrong color or religion. Trump rants only about supposed wrongs against white Christians. His sole human rights concern. Grounded (typically) in lies.

He’s also made a big show of welcoming white Christian “refugees” from South Africa, with five-star treatment. While slamming our door against virtually all other (legitimate) refugees.

Apart from the obvious racism operating here, maybe South Africa actually incurred Trump’s ire by cozying up to countries like Iran and Russia. Well — nah. Trump himself does that. What may instead have riled him — speaking of genocide — was South Africa initiating a genocide case before an international tribunal, against Israel, for its ghastly Gaza atrocities.

And speaking of atrocities, and human rights —

Britain’s previous Conservative government pushed a vile plan to ship refugees to Rwanda. Even paid Rwanda millions to take them. Thankfully, the plan never jelled, being slapped down by British courts. And the government obeyed them.

But meantime we’ve heard much about the Trump regime sending migrants to El Salvador’s hellhole prisons; violating judicial orders. The latest (details are murky as I write) is sending people to South Sudan. Here too thumbing a nose at judges’ rulings.

At least Rwanda has a well organized government (too much so, many think). South Sudan, in contrast, is a hot mess, wracked by violence, with a government whose writ does not run far. Dumping non-African migrants there —even assuming the wildly mendacius Trump regime is not lying in calling them “criminals” — is sadistically cruel. What are those people supposed to do, to survive there?

Might as well just put them right into gas chambers.

Ethical Jews Must Renounce Israel

May 1, 2025

My neighborhood still sports some “We Stand With Israel” lawn signs. This confounds me.

I grew up Jewish, my mother escaped from Nazi Germany. Israel was a bright shining light. Embodying the hopes and dreams of a people who’d suffered ages of persecution, culminating in a mass genocide. “Never again,” we said.

Did that apply only for Jews?

A recent article in the American Humanist Association magazine discusses “Contemporary Humanistic Judaism.” A movement basically excising all supernatural superstition, including God. Reconceiving Judaism as grounded in a people’s history and culture, with an ethical philosophy springing from that.

“A sense of purpose in life comes from positive affirmations of human dignity, reinforced by . . . emphasis on human power, knowledge, and responsibility.” Further: “a diasporic minority experience encourages sympathy for other minorities and advocacy for human rights.”

Yet the article is silent about the crucial ethical challenge unfolding today specifically involving Jews.

Two powerful forces mess up people’s moral thinking: religion and tribalism. Which of course go hand-in-hand, a deadly combination. Regarding the latter, I recall the 1990s Balkan conflict. Serb crimes seemed obvious. Yet I was struck that no Serb voice ever denounced them. Tribalism.

Hamas’s October 7 atrocity was horrendous, killing about 1200. Israel has a right to defend itself. But that does not justify indiscriminate assault upon a civilian population, killing over 50,000 and counting, mostly women and children, while plunging millions more into destitute misery, their homes mostly bombed to rubble, with humanitarian aid largely blocked (and often itself attacked).

Israel’s claims of trying to minimize civilian harms smack of Kremlin lies. It’s increasingly clear that civilian harm is the really the point of the thing. Israelis venting hatred upon Palestinians, not just in Gaza, but the West Bank too. Treating them as sub-human vermin — just as Nazis saw Jews.

Claims that all this is mere collateral damage in a war against Hamas ring ever more hollow. The very name “Hamas” becoming like a bogeyman. Is Israel truly combating it? The war’s horror is one gigantic recruiting poster for Hamas, radicalizing a generation of Palestinians to mirror Israelis’ hatred. A futile endless game of whack-a-mole. This is insane.

Not all Israelis back it; but the nation as a whole seems all-in. Epitomizing the anti-reason consequences of out-of-control tribalism mated with irrational religious fervor. A big part is belief that God decreed Jews must have all this land. Well, a few millennia back, he did tell them to take it all, killing or enslaving the existing populations. That story was fictional, but today’s reprise is all too real.

That Jews were themselves comparable victims of a “never again” genocide just decades ago makes it especially grotesque. What did they learn?

“A diasporic minority experience encourages sympathy for other minorities and advocacy for human rights.”

Another piece in the same magazine cites the Sermon on the Mount — “much kinder, more compassionate, more humane. Blessed are the merciful. Blessed are the peacemakers. Blessed are the poor.”

Oops, sorry, that guy’s not in the Jewish Bible. (Though he was a Jew.)

Israel was indeed once a bright shining light, standing for values congruent with humanistic generosity of spirit. But alas that humanist project has gone completely off the rails, betraying every rationalist principle it might once have embodied.

No ethical person can abide this. If you think it’s God’s work, you need a different God. Those of Jewish heritage, like me, given our ancestral history, should have a special moral responsibility here. We must finally renounce the monster that Israel has become.

We Are All Gazans Now

February 7, 2025

First Greenland, then the Panama Canal, even maybe Canada. And now Gaza. Though crazier yet, seemingly a more serious notion (at least in Trump’s broken brain).

At his first appearance with fellow criminal Netanyahu, Trump called Gaza a “demolition zone.” And who demolished it? Netanyahu. Trump said it’s a killing zone where nobody can safely live. Who’s made it that? Netanyahu, standing right there, grinning. The scene made my head explode.

Trump says America will take over Gaza (Netanyahu seems favorable) and make it the region’s “Riviera.” And the Gaza Palestinians will have “far safer and more beautiful communities, with new and modern homes, in the region. They would actually have a chance to be happy, safe, and free.”

In Trump’s “Rivera?” No, that will be for different folks. Gaza’s current inhabitants would be “resettled” to their “more beautiful communities, with new and modern homes,” maybe in Egypt, or Jordan.

I have been to those countries. Few of their own people live in Trump’s promised paradise. Rather mostly in slums. Palestinians would face squalid refugee camps. But Egypt and Jordan are refusing even that (though Trump threatens to bully them into it).

Israel says it has begun preparations for the Gaza exodus. While the whole rest of the Middle East is horrified, believing this would destabilize the region with a couple million more permanent refugees, aggravating enmities. Totally against America’s interests. Never mind our now having to fight Hamas — and the cost of reconstructing a Gaza reduced to rubble.

And it would be an American crime against humanity. Gaza’s inhabitants don’t want to leave, knowing better than to expect “new and modern homes.” The right term would be ethnic cleansing.

That’s exactly what Netanyahu’s regime wants. Increasingly ascendant in Israel is an insane extreme right-wing Jewish nationalism aiming to somehow disappear all Palestinians. They want to restore the settlements in Gaza withdrawn in 2005. In the West Bank too they’re mounting an under-the-radar pogrom, making life hell for the Palestinians there. Violently assaulting them and throttling public services like hospitals. Trump has the Israelis’ backs.

He’s even decreed sanctions on the International Criminal Court, for deeming Netanyahu a war criminal. Most of the world has condemned Trump’s move.

Meantime, the Trump-Musk administration is trying to dismantle America’s government and civil service. Through illegal means, like the employee buyout scheme, coupled with intimidation. Not a plan for bureaucratic reform, but destruction. The whole federal architecture has been handed over to the world’s richest man, a proto-Nazi jerk with conflicts of interest galore, who also controls a giant social media megaphone. What could go wrong?

Musk has already literally shuttered the USAID program (labelled “evil” and “criminal”), firing and locking out employees and stopping its programs. A hugely fateful rupture in U.S. policy, taking a sledgehammer to our national interests, scarcely even debated in the public square.

Many Americans do hate the idea of foreign aid (vastly overestimating its cost). And a 2009 book, Dead Aid, by Dambisa Moyo, showed how much is wasted or even deleterious. Yet, if not pure altruism, it does serve our interests. It’s “soft power” sowing goodwill, strengthening our valuable alliances, a pillar of the post-WWII world order. And some of it is truly beneficial, like all our efforts against disease, such as George W. Bush’s highly effective PEPFAR program combating AIDS in Africa. Now too killed by Trump.

Meantime, we’re getting into trade wars with Mexico and Canada — some of our best friends in the world. Or at least they were, pre-Trump. The real winner from our blowing up these relationships will be China.

Meantime, here at home, not only has Trump targeted undocumented residents, he’s virtually slammed the door on all immigration. Even stopped help for refugees previously arrived. One organization, the U.S. Committee for Refugees and Immigrants (with a local Albany operation), was left unable to service people already their responsibility.

Meantime, we used to think deportations were just for non-citizens. But Trump is deporting citizens. Made a deal with El Salvador to ship Americans from our prisons to their hell-hole dungeons. Is that legal? Does that even matter anymore?

All this wreckage of our institutions, traditions, policies, and civic culture will be hard to put right. Especially with a citizenry so mindless, even a saner later administration won’t be able to get that toothpaste back in the tube and rebuild what’s destroyed. Gaza a perfect metaphor.

My wife and I have been sharing an ancient history book. Reading aloud of once-great Athens’s “drift into both cruelty and folly,” I added, “like, in later times, America.” She said those words prompted the same thought. Though it’s not a drift, but a plunge.