On December 13,the night Aleppo fell/was reclaimed (delete as appropriate depending on your stance), I was lucky enough to view a showing of Sea Sorrow, the new documentary (her directorial debut in fact) by Vanessa Redgrave, actress and staunch activist for the refugee crisis. It’s due for release online next year, according to Cambridge News. Here’s my thoughts on it.
Sea Sorrow is an essay-by-film that juxtaposes the current refugee crisis with the fight for human rights in the wake of fascism after World War II. It’s a clear call to action for citizens to stand up for the principles enshrined in the various conventions for Human Rights and Child Rights ratified over the past 60 years [fn1].
Whilst there are glimpses into the struggles faced by modern refugees, including a highly emotive clip of the attempted rescue of fleeing people from a dinghy in the Mediterranean, it seemed that the majority of screen time was dedicated to celebrity activists. That’s not necessarily a complaint. I had felt that there was little point in preaching to the choir of Cambridge, but Vanessa Redgrave herself addressed this point in the after-show Q&A: even the converted must be re-inspired, must be supported to maintain their fight, because the fight is tiring. The celebrity activists provided this motivation. Vanessa emphasised the importance of the arts as a means of expression and therapy, a belief echoed in the film through poignant passages delivered by Emma Thompson and Ralph Fiennes. Ralph Fiennes’ performance of the dramatic speech by Prospero in The Tempest, recollecting the events that displaced him and his daughter from their prior life, was a powerful illustration of the very real dangerous passage that thousands [fn2] of people have been forced to take to flee their home countries:
PROSPERO: My tale provokes that question. Dear, they durst not,
So dear the love my people bore me, nor set
A mark so bloody on the business, but
With colours fairer painted their foul ends.
In few, they hurried us aboard a bark,
Bore us some leagues to sea; where they prepared
A rotten carcass of a boat, not rigg’d,
Nor tackle, sail, nor mast; the very rats
Instinctively had quit it: there they hoist us,
To cry to the sea that roar’d to us, to sigh
To the winds whose pity, sighing back again,
Did us but loving wrong.
…
MIRANDA: How came we ashore?
PROSPERO: By Providence divine.
The Tempest, William Shakespeare, Source: http://shakespeare.mit.edu/tempest/full.html
Emma Thompson read out correspondence from Sylvia Pankhurst published in the Manchester Guardian imploring the UK Government to stand by their promise and take action to permit entry to Jewish refugees being exiled from central Europe. The parallels to the current situation were clear enough: the British Government is once again being called up for inaction, even on their insufficient promise to take in 20,000 refugess over five years [fn3].
Whilst I found the transitions between chapters of the story – a full-screen shot of a rustling thermal foil blanket – clunky and distracting, and I found there was insufficient focus on the many volunteers hard at work to help (they’re an inspiration, feature them! [fn4]), the overriding message was clear: activism must continue, the desire to help must be sustained, the fight will be long but it is vital. As Andrej Mahecic, UNHCR, pointed out, the film humanised the numbers. Every single datapoint in the refugee crisis is a person.
[The Geneva Convention] cannot be swept away for the sake of short-term political convenience.
Lord Alfred Dubs
There were high-level solutions on offer: Peter Sutherland, UN Special Representative of the Secretary General for Migration and Development, demanded a common European policy that provides access for vulnerable people to all countries in Europe; Alf Dubs reiterated that the Government must pay heed to the Dublin III regulation that supports the asylum claim of refugees with nuclear family residing in the UK, and of the Dubs amendment that extends asylum eligibility to unaccompanied minors [fn5]; and there was a call to help at the other end of the crisis (campaign against war as a method for change, stop selling the weapons used in these wars). The (lack of) action by the UNHCR in Calais was called out, but I felt that the answer given was particularly interesting: the UNHCR is under-funded for their work in the low-income countries currently taking the majority burden of the refugee crisis, so it is difficult to justify allocating resources to projects in countries with wealthy governments (with these governments primarily responsible for taking action).
The plight of child refugees was a key point in the discussion. With the Calais camp having been dismantled at the end of October, many unaccompanied child refugees are believed to have gone missing (read: fallen foul to traffickers; Interpol estimates 10,000) – whilst many of those that were distributed to centres round France are still waiting for their asylum claims to be processed. It was estimated that 387 children who were in the Calais camp were entitled to be relocated in the UK; they haven’t all been brought over yet.
Finally, there was some good news: Dan Ellis, of Cambridge Refugee groups fame, announced that the Cambridge Rotary club had recently handed him a cheque for £9,000 following a charity auction of promises. This will help Cambridge Refugee Resettlement Campaign to attain charity status, as Cambridge Convoy Refugee Action Group have just succeeded in. Thanks Cambridge Rotary!
If you feel moved to act, especially given recent events in Syria, here’s how you can help:
Offer to house a refugee / family. There have been many offers to help in Cambridge. However, our city is currently hosting only nine refugee families due to the inaction of our Government in resettling people (plus, it’s particularly expensive to do so here). Nonetheless, it is important to maintain and build on the welcome that Cambridge residents have offered, to show the will of the people here to contribute. The accommodation you offer must meet necessary requirements for it to be offered to a refugee family. For more information, and to offer your house, see links at Cambridge City Council, Cambridge Refugee Resettlement Campaign, Refugees at Home and Rooms for Refugees.
Foster a child refugee. This is not something to be taken lightly, but if you think you can offer a loving and stable home for an unaccompanied (and likely traumatised) child, please see link at https://www.cambridge.gov.uk/syrian-refugees or sign up at http://www.cambridgerefugees.org/fostering. Successful applicants should receive training.
Become a visiting friend to an unaccompanied child. Training is on offer to support adults to befriend, assist and support refugees resettled in your local area. For more information, the advice given was to contact your local authority. Pledge to help via Cambridge Refugee Resttlement Campaign; and explore the offerings at Cambridge Ethnic Community Forum. The National Youth Advocacy Service was also recommended as a good place to start for learning how to help vulnerable young adults.
Contribute to the welcoming atmosphere via Cambridge City of Sanctuary and Cambridge Ethnic Community Forum.
Learn about the rights of refugees by registering for Amnesty International’s free online course. Then tell others.
Help fundraise for Cambridge Convoy Action Group to support volunteers travelling to France and Greece, and/or go yourself to help sort donations, prepare food, and more.
Donate Phone Credit for Refugees and Displaced People to enable vulnerable people to communicate with their loved ones and access vital resources and information on their smartphones. This is the easiest way for you to help right now, and it’s extremely effective.
Explore the info and stories at Refugee Action, the Refugee Council, the UNHCR stats portal, Parliament’s research briefings, and the Shaw Review on the detention of vulnerable persons (including asylum seekers) in the UK.
—-
Footnotes:
[1] Vanessa Redgrave specifically drew attention to:
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948
The European Convention on Human Rights, effective 1953
Convention on the Rights of the Child, 1989
Further, the Geneva Conventions were brought up, given the refugee crises have been due to war.
[2] I couldn’t find a total number of people who have crossed the Mediterranean Sea; help / sources appreciated.
[3] In 2015, the UK Government expanded the Syrian Vulnerable Person Resettlement (VPR) Programme to take in 20,000 syrians by 2020 (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/472020/Syrian_Resettlement_Fact_Sheet_gov_uk.pdf). As of June 2016 (the latest official stats I could find), 2,898 Syrian refugees had been resettled in the UK (http://www.refugeecouncil.org.uk/what_we_do/refugee_services/resettlement_programme/refugee_resettlement_the_facts). There are currently 4.8 million Syrian refugees living outside of Syria, with over half in neighbouring Turkey (http://www.unhcr.org/uk/syria-emergency.html). A further 8.7 million Syrians were estimated to be displaced within Syria in early November – this number has likely changed since. Overall, there are over 65 million displaced people (read: forced from their home, with 21 million classified as refugees) worldwide (UNHCR stats).
[4] In fairness, the film included a conversation with vounteers in Calais, including Liz Clegg of the Women and Children’s Centre at the camp, and made a point of highlighting the heroic efforts of Greek citizens to bring onshore the many refugees that arrive on their coastline each day.
[5] Thanks to FullFact for clarifying the difference (and it’s very different) between the Dublin regulation and the Dubs amendment at https://fullfact.org/immigration/ask-full-fact-dubs-and-dublin/.