Dear OUAT/Rumbelle/Rumple/Belle/Robert Carlyle/Emilie de Ravin fans,
(WARNING: SPOILERS as of Season 4, Episode 13: "Unforgiven," first aired March 8, 2015. If you're not caught up, please skip down to the last five paragraphs--if you count the P.S. as a paragraph--which contain my main point. I have marked the one spoiler in that section.)
I watch Once Upon a Time because I still think Lost is one of the most brilliant TV shows ever, and ABC originally and continually references OUAT as being "from the writers of Lost." They even frequently re-employ actors from the Lost cast on the show and throw in Lost "Easter eggs," despite the two shows' bearing almost no resemblance to one another. Far from being THE writers of Lost, as ABC tries to mislead us to believe, OUAT showrunners Adam Horowitz and Edward Kitsis wrote only 21 out of the 121 scripts for Lost; Lost was created by J.J. Abrams, and the head writers were Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse (generally referred to by fans of the show as "Darlton," and "A&E," as fans of OUAT have taken to calling "Adam and Eddie" for short, seem all to happy to try to follow in their footsteps by talking about the show, giving interviews and letting out little hints of things to come while keeping others secret, but also going to great pains to explain the inconsistencies in the show and placate unhappy "shippers" whose fan-fiction ships fail to become canon; however, with the back and forth of Twitter now prevalent, they are receiving what appears to be an unwelcome amount of unwanted feedback from disgruntled fans, and Eddie Kitsis in particular seems to be defensive and disgusted by the viewers' lack of appreciation for his vision).
( Why I've lost patience with RumbelleCollapse )
Therefore, if my disdain for the way Rumplestitskin's character has gone from an intriguing, complex, and even tragic character to a mere plot device, played by an actor who is far and away the show's most valuable asset and does his best to knock every scene he's in out of the park despite the futility and total lack of respect for the audience's intelligence by the show's creators, writers, and producers, being cheated out of the Emmy and recognition he deserves (in fact, many fans have said Robert Carlyle is the only reason they are still watching OUAT and if he left, they would stop watching!) causes YOU to believe I am spreading "hate" towards Belle or Emilie de Ravin or any other actor or character on the show and/or I have followed you because you are a Robert Carlyle or Rumbelle fan, please do not get angry with me. Simply block me and/or tell me politely that you wish me to unfollow or block you, and I will do so so that you won't have to see any of my opinions again. People often follow me without asking me first; sometimes I follow others without asking them too. I didn't know it was bad etiquette to follow someone without permission or to reply to a tweet you thought the other person might agree with. Further, I may respond to comments that someone I'm replying to has been mentioned in. If I don't remove your Twitter address from my reply, either it's an oversight, or I thought you were part of the conversation and didn't want to leave you out. Your disagreement with my opinion doesn't mean I bear any malice towards you. So please leave any false assumptions and attacks at the Troll Bridge.
The bottom line is, Once Upon a Time is a fictional/fantasy TV show. The characters and stories on it are imaginary. The actors are real people, and I would never criticize them directly. There's no reason to criticize people who are just doing their jobs. ABC, on the other hand, cares about the show's ratings, and if it has good ratings, they obviously want the show to be renewed. I am a writer and fiction connoisseur who's taken writing classes and enjoys interesting and well-developed characters. [SPOILER:]Rumplestiltskin was once an intriguingly ambiguous character on the show--originally, according to his back story in Seasons 1 and 2, wanting only to do good and protect his family at all costs, even laming himself in the mistaken belief it would protect his son--only to be presumed to be and falsely labelled a coward because his father was one, including by his own self-centered wife Milah. Now it seems like his romantic history is repeating itself.[END OF SPOILER]
I express my opinions and constructive criticism on Twitter because (1) showrunners are always asking viewers what they think; (2) I want the show to succeed and perhaps even garner an Emmy like it showed the potential for in Season 1; and (3) I want Robert Carlyle, who is locked into a five-year contract on the show, to have the opportunity to portray and help develop the complex character of Rumplestiltskin that garnered him so much talk of an Emmy nomination in Season 1, particularly for my favorite episode, "Skin Deep," the popularity of which (at least among Robert Carlyle fans) I don't think has ever been matched. People even wish him a happy anniversary for that episode on Twitter, and it's clear that he appreciates it and is proud of that episode because when he thanks all the people who remembered, it is one of the very rare times that he tweets nowadays. I and many others believed that his lack of a nomination for Season 1 would be rectified in Season 2, but it wasn't and, at this rate, is unlikely to, which disappoints me very much. I'm disappointed in the writing, but I bear no hatred towards any of the show's actors, characters, crew, fans, or even the writers themselves. In the end, Once Upon a Time is entertainment, not anything serious enough to warrant such an extreme reaction as hatred. However, if I am falsely accused of "hating" and/or being attacked by the people I had previously believed to be my fellow "dearies" (otherwise, I wouldn't have followed you or mentioned you in a tweet), I may possibly lose my temper and react irrationally towards you, just like you probably would if I did it to you.
Thanks for understanding. I welcome friendship and discussion, even if we agree to disagree, with other "Dearies," Robert Carlyle fans, and other people who share my interests.
PS: Grr, I'm having trouble replying to comments and keep getting an error message. Sorry! Hope the problem will be fixed soon.
(WARNING: SPOILERS as of Season 4, Episode 13: "Unforgiven," first aired March 8, 2015. If you're not caught up, please skip down to the last five paragraphs--if you count the P.S. as a paragraph--which contain my main point. I have marked the one spoiler in that section.)
I watch Once Upon a Time because I still think Lost is one of the most brilliant TV shows ever, and ABC originally and continually references OUAT as being "from the writers of Lost." They even frequently re-employ actors from the Lost cast on the show and throw in Lost "Easter eggs," despite the two shows' bearing almost no resemblance to one another. Far from being THE writers of Lost, as ABC tries to mislead us to believe, OUAT showrunners Adam Horowitz and Edward Kitsis wrote only 21 out of the 121 scripts for Lost; Lost was created by J.J. Abrams, and the head writers were Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse (generally referred to by fans of the show as "Darlton," and "A&E," as fans of OUAT have taken to calling "Adam and Eddie" for short, seem all to happy to try to follow in their footsteps by talking about the show, giving interviews and letting out little hints of things to come while keeping others secret, but also going to great pains to explain the inconsistencies in the show and placate unhappy "shippers" whose fan-fiction ships fail to become canon; however, with the back and forth of Twitter now prevalent, they are receiving what appears to be an unwelcome amount of unwanted feedback from disgruntled fans, and Eddie Kitsis in particular seems to be defensive and disgusted by the viewers' lack of appreciation for his vision).
( Why I've lost patience with RumbelleCollapse )
Therefore, if my disdain for the way Rumplestitskin's character has gone from an intriguing, complex, and even tragic character to a mere plot device, played by an actor who is far and away the show's most valuable asset and does his best to knock every scene he's in out of the park despite the futility and total lack of respect for the audience's intelligence by the show's creators, writers, and producers, being cheated out of the Emmy and recognition he deserves (in fact, many fans have said Robert Carlyle is the only reason they are still watching OUAT and if he left, they would stop watching!) causes YOU to believe I am spreading "hate" towards Belle or Emilie de Ravin or any other actor or character on the show and/or I have followed you because you are a Robert Carlyle or Rumbelle fan, please do not get angry with me. Simply block me and/or tell me politely that you wish me to unfollow or block you, and I will do so so that you won't have to see any of my opinions again. People often follow me without asking me first; sometimes I follow others without asking them too. I didn't know it was bad etiquette to follow someone without permission or to reply to a tweet you thought the other person might agree with. Further, I may respond to comments that someone I'm replying to has been mentioned in. If I don't remove your Twitter address from my reply, either it's an oversight, or I thought you were part of the conversation and didn't want to leave you out. Your disagreement with my opinion doesn't mean I bear any malice towards you. So please leave any false assumptions and attacks at the Troll Bridge.
The bottom line is, Once Upon a Time is a fictional/fantasy TV show. The characters and stories on it are imaginary. The actors are real people, and I would never criticize them directly. There's no reason to criticize people who are just doing their jobs. ABC, on the other hand, cares about the show's ratings, and if it has good ratings, they obviously want the show to be renewed. I am a writer and fiction connoisseur who's taken writing classes and enjoys interesting and well-developed characters. [SPOILER:]Rumplestiltskin was once an intriguingly ambiguous character on the show--originally, according to his back story in Seasons 1 and 2, wanting only to do good and protect his family at all costs, even laming himself in the mistaken belief it would protect his son--only to be presumed to be and falsely labelled a coward because his father was one, including by his own self-centered wife Milah. Now it seems like his romantic history is repeating itself.[END OF SPOILER]
I express my opinions and constructive criticism on Twitter because (1) showrunners are always asking viewers what they think; (2) I want the show to succeed and perhaps even garner an Emmy like it showed the potential for in Season 1; and (3) I want Robert Carlyle, who is locked into a five-year contract on the show, to have the opportunity to portray and help develop the complex character of Rumplestiltskin that garnered him so much talk of an Emmy nomination in Season 1, particularly for my favorite episode, "Skin Deep," the popularity of which (at least among Robert Carlyle fans) I don't think has ever been matched. People even wish him a happy anniversary for that episode on Twitter, and it's clear that he appreciates it and is proud of that episode because when he thanks all the people who remembered, it is one of the very rare times that he tweets nowadays. I and many others believed that his lack of a nomination for Season 1 would be rectified in Season 2, but it wasn't and, at this rate, is unlikely to, which disappoints me very much. I'm disappointed in the writing, but I bear no hatred towards any of the show's actors, characters, crew, fans, or even the writers themselves. In the end, Once Upon a Time is entertainment, not anything serious enough to warrant such an extreme reaction as hatred. However, if I am falsely accused of "hating" and/or being attacked by the people I had previously believed to be my fellow "dearies" (otherwise, I wouldn't have followed you or mentioned you in a tweet), I may possibly lose my temper and react irrationally towards you, just like you probably would if I did it to you.
Thanks for understanding. I welcome friendship and discussion, even if we agree to disagree, with other "Dearies," Robert Carlyle fans, and other people who share my interests.
PS: Grr, I'm having trouble replying to comments and keep getting an error message. Sorry! Hope the problem will be fixed soon.
Current mood:
frustrated
frustratedThe music within: "Follow You, Follow Me" by Genesis
5 comments | Leave a comment
annoyed
disappointed
incredulous
Enlightened/strangely aroused
contemplative
exhausted
GRRumpy