I was raised Christian. Protestant, Reformed (Liberated), to be exact. I didn't think we were very strict, but your mileage may vary (actually, it's one of the ways in which it is so easy to see within our family that different children from the same family grow up with different experiences; my sister definitely deals with religious trauma. But I digress). We were devout, though; church twice on Sundays, catechesis on Tuesdays, youth group every other week on Wednesdays for a couple of years as well.
There was this family in our church who was way stricter than we were; they didn't have a TV at home, for example. And when Harry Potter really rose to fame, it became very obvious that Good Christian Girls would not read that Pagan drivel (I keep finding it ironic how someone whose work I was hardly allowed to read as a kid is now pushing such a traditional Christian agenda; but I digress, again) but would read Narnia. I'm not even really sure how that fact became so obvious; my parents let me read pretty freely, but it must have been something I picked up from things I heard around me in church and/or op-eds in our Christian newspaper.
It will come as no surprise that I, at that point already an enthusiastic Harry Potter fan (discovering the book series just before the hype) and a PDA'er besides, quickly decided I would not read Narnia.
All that to say, when I finally did pick up the books a couple of months ago, mostly out of this feeling that with how much I'm enjoying portal fantasies I wanted to give this quintessential example of it a read, if just to pick up on references and stuff, and besides, I needed something easy on my mind, with all the move stress and everything, I was aware this would be a Christian book. I knew, vaguely, it was a Christian allegory.
My friends, nothing,
nothing, could have prepared me for how very. not. subtle. Lewis was. I think part of me still expected it to be something of a well-known and -accepted interpretation of the story, like it was a hidden meaning that was clear only on close read.
As I kept reading on, I just kept on being bowled over by how obvious it is, from start to finish, up until the point in the last book (spoilers, I guess?) where everyone is saved except Susan because she'd stopped believing in Narnia and yet no one cares, because hey, it's heaven and everyone is happy and who cares about non-believers anyway? They just stop existing. (I liked most of Narnia just fine. The final book though made me a little nauseous.)
I did go in publishing order (the omnibus I used actually was organised in chronological order, but I find that extremely weird, so I sort of jumped back and forth to read it in the intended order). I *adore* Lucy. Funnily enough, I've read the last one almost a month ago and there's not much scenes I specifically remember, but I do remember the one where Lucy sort of meets the mergirl. I felt that connection in my bones (is there any fic about them? I feel like there should be). None of the other characters really stuck with me, though I did like Digory (interestingly enough, I do think The Magician's Nephew is one of the better Narnia stories; I just think it's a strange place to start; just because the bible starts at the creation of the Earth, doesn't mean the Chronicles of Narnia has to start at the beginning).