This last week I recalled an experience I had many years ago, back when the internet was “newish.” Even in the early days of being online, I gravitated towards forums and locations where I could chat and discuss topics of all sorts. My interests then were slightly different than they are now, though there also remain common threads such as sciences that I still follow.
Now, even then I was no stranger to the concept of a “flame war.” The internet has always held a bit of fire and allowed for that unleashing of anonymity to negative effect. But as social media still hadn’t been invented, forums allowed for a bit of funneling and moderation.
Anyway, as I said, my mind lately has been cast back to a particular even that took place in 2009. Social media was on its way then, but that’s not the point of this particular memory. No, this memory concerns a particular incident on a forum regarding an experiment NASA performed on the moon.
The experiment? Creating an “explosion” on the lunar surface via impact of a satellite. The goal? To see how much water spectra (ice, technically) was found in the resulting debris plume, so that NASA could know how much “water” they might find and “mine” from the moon, both for a potential base but also for use by other space projects (as it would be much cheaper to ship water up from the surface of the moon than from Earth).
Okay, why has my mind gone back to this recently? Well, because of a comment in a forum where this was being discussed. Someone showed up, in all seriousness, incensed by this experiment and its results. Furious, because as they put it, NASA was going to mine out the moon with this project. They’d devour the entire thing in a hunt for water, and then Earth wouldn’t have a moon anymore.
Some of you are already shaking your heads. Obviously, the concept is pretty ridiculous. Technically possible … but only with the sort of megaproject scaling that would put mankind halfway to a Dyson Sphere already.
But they didn’t know this. They were afraid and angry.
So why did this memory surface all these years later?
Continue reading