
“Right now I feel guilty to be alive. Why? Because I’m wasting it. I’ve been given this life and all I do is mope it away.
What’s worse is, I am totally aware of how ridiculous I am. It would be a lot easier if I believed I was the center of the universe, because then I wouldn’t know any better NOT to make a big deal out of everything. I know how small my problems are, yet that doesn’t stop me from obsessing about them.
I have to stop doing this.
How do other people get happy? I look at people laughing and smiling and enjoying themselves and try to get inside their heads. How do Bridget, Manda, and Sara do it? Or Pepe? Or EVERYONE but me?
Why does everything I see bother me? Why can’t I just get over these daily wrongdoings? Why can’t I just move on and make the best of what I’ve got?
I wish I knew.” - Sloppy FirstsIs there anything worse than being a teenage girl? (The answer is no, and, if you don't agree, these books are obviously not the right books for you.) For Jessica Darling, adolescence is the bane of her existence. A girl who is likely too smart for her own good and now trapped in Pineville, New Jersey, without her best friend Hope, who has just moved to Tennessee, Jessica hates everything.
Everything. Despite being relatively popular, Jessica simultaneously despises her social circle but doesn't want to end the friendships and be alone. She is the complete opposite of big sister Bethany (11 years her senior and her mother's favorite) and no one in the family ever mentions her brother Matthew, who died in infancy. Her mother is determined to make Jessica into another Bethany and her father, who constantly calls her "Notso" (as in Not-So-Darling,) is obsessed with Jessica's track career. It is downright overwhelming for Jess, who really just wants to be left alone (but not
too alone because such is the life of a 16-year-old girl.)
Enter Marcus Flutie. A known drug addict who slowly works his way into Jess's life following a series of hilarious events, Marcus provides Jess the outlet she needs - someone to talk to who cares about something more than the banalities of high school - while also driving her nuts because she doesn't know how to define what they have (and she also doesn't want the friends she doesn't really like to judge her for hanging with someone like Marcus.) What comes to a head on New Year's Eve sets the tone for the person Jessica is going to become: a girl who puts herself first even when it breaks her heart to do so.
“As much as I don't care about those things, I think it's human nature to not want to feel totally insignificant.” - Second HelpingsThe second book in the series finds Jessica nearly a year later. Now a rising senior, Jess is still desperately hung up on Marcus and trying just as desperately to pretend like she isn't. While she still misses Hope, she has rekindled her friendship with childhood best friend Bridget and is eagerly planning her escape to college. Though it has never truly occurred to her before, Mac, the instructor of Jess's summer enrichment program, encourages her to consider writing and writes her a letter of recommendation to Columbia. Jess is all set to flee Pineville for Morningside Heights...and then 9/11 happens. Now terrified of the city, Jess decides to apply to schools she doesn't particularly want to go to in order to feel safer but Columbia is still constantly in her head.
Jess has her first real relationship with Len, the other class brainiac and Marcus's best friend. Marcus explains he wants Jess to be happy and has been pushing Len to be with Jess, thinking it will be good for both of them. Like many teenage girls, Jess is a bit obsessed with being "the last virgin" at school and her thoughts on sex and relationships are explored in detail, particularly how eager she was to lose her virginity to Marcus and her reticence to lose it to Len. Unlike so many teen heroines, Jess never worries or slut shames herself; she is clear in her desire to have sex and isn't ashamed of it. If anything, in her relationship with Len, it is she who initiates sexually, and it is she who gets painted as being "sex crazed."
The end of the second book finds Jessica realizing she needs to do what makes her happy and not rely on what makes her parents/friends/anyone else wants her to do. Jess loses her virginity to Marcus, gets accepted to Columbia, and makes peace with high school, which is something I think everyone has to do at some point.
"Why is it that the most fundamental life lesson — LIVE! — is the one I continually forget to put into practice?” Charmed ThirdsCollege changes who you are. But what's more, college changes who you
think you are. And for Jessica, she finds that maybe Pineville and high school weren't the source of her problems, which opens up a whole other host of problems. At college, Jess is finally confronted with the incredible amount of privilege she has grown up; while always considering herself to be an outcast, her dorm mates point out she was popular, involved in everything, had 2 boyfriends and was wanted by the most popular guy in school, and was a track star. It startles Jess to realize the image she has painted of herself doesn't necessarily fit what other people see of her. Jess also starts to do what a lot of people do: she starts to conform her personality to those around her. We see this when her best friend from college visits Pineville and Jess begins to mimic Jane's traits.
Jessica also realizes, despite all of her proclamations that she and Marcus would last and not be one of those high school couples who break up over distance, her experience with men is pretty limited. One slip with a guy she didn't even particularly like ends her relationship with Marcus, but Jess spends the majority of the book (which spans all 4 years of college) obsessed with him even as she pursues other options. She flirts with an affair with a married classmate, she engages in a truly terrible relationship with an emo philosophy major two years her junior, she has a one-night stand with Len, but through it all, Jess thinks of Marcus.
But even for all of her romantic angst, Jess is also unsure of what it is she wants to do with her life. A psychology major who chose her major without any real thought of a career (much like so many of us) and now looking down the barrel of a huge amount of debt, Jess realizes she has no desire to become a clinical psychologist. Though she continues to write in her journals, she was too intimidated to go out for the Columbia newspaper and her one attempt at writing - an internship with a Brooklyn hipster mag that ends in hilarious disaster - was a single article her editor tried to pass off to her former nemesis Hy. It is only through Mac's intervention she thinks of writing again.
This book is easily the least liked by most fans, but Jess's quest to find herself in college, at times, rings painfully realistic. Jess is self-involved and arrogant and thoughtless, wrapped up in her own bubble, but I can hardly think of anyone who wasn't like that at some point. Being away from home and trying to navigate everything is overwhelming, and Jess is nowhere close to perfect. By the end of the book, she is trying to fix things with Marcus and hoping to handle the future with a bit more grace.
“Most of my friends from Columbia are going on to get advanced degrees. And why not? A Ph.D. is the new M.A., a master's is the new bachelor's, a B.A. is the new high school diploma, and a high school diploma is the new smiley-face sticker on your first-grade spelling test.” Fourth ComingsTaking place over the course of a week, this is the first journal of Jessica's which is written
to someone, specifically Marcus, who proposes at the start of the book. For Jess, who is trying to start her life in New York City, the idea of being engaged to Marcus, now a freshman at Princeton, is not an option. What's becoming even more clear is Jess has outgrown Marcus and coming to terms with that is the least of her problems.
This is my favorite of the series because it shows how shitty and difficult life after college really can be. Jess is now sharing a basement apartment in Brooklyn with Hope, who is a master's student by day and a wedding photography by night, Manda, the high school classmate she hated, and Manda's girlfriend Shea. Jess is working part-time writing for a psychology journal and part-time babysitting her niece, and her quest to find full-time employment with benefits is downright impossible. She quickly realizes a bachelor's degree in psychology gets you nowhere, and Jess does not want to go even deeper in debt for a graduate degree when she isn't even sure what she wants to do. Jess feels adrift for the first time in her life without a goal to work towards, and, for an uber-achiever like her, it's an entirely disheartening feeling, especially when everyone around her is going to grad school, getting engaged, and having children. Jess is also starting to realize her perceptions of her parents are still skewed, and, now that she's older, she recognizes there are far more complicated dynamics at play than she originally thought.
Perhaps the best part of this novel and Jess's narrative is everyone's reactions to Marcus's proposal. Jess is unsure what to say; she doesn't want to get married but she's afraid a refusal means the end of their relationship. While Bridget, Bethany, her father, and nearly everyone else seems to support it, it is only Hope who has the guts to tell her the truth: she shouldn't marry Marcus, she shouldn't
be with Marcus, and their relationship has always been unhealthy. Jess recognizes the truth in what Hope says and politely refuses Marcus's proposal and ends the relationship, putting herself first and finally moving beyond their relationship.
“Gone for a while
Hoping, always, to return
If you will let me” Perfect FifthsThis book is the only one not written as a journal of Jessica's, and it is also the only one to have Marcus's POV as well. But though there is an argument that could be made about how this series has always been about Jessica
and Marcus, this is still Jessica's story. Set four years after the end of
Fourth Comings, Marcus is about to graduate from Princeton and Jess is in charge of a storytelling project funded by Hy. They are simultaneously the people they have always been and people the other doesn't know.
What's so wonderful about this book (and man people
don't like this volume) is it emphasizes how much of a stranger the person who once knew you best can become. Though Jess ostensibly has it all together now (out of debt, money in the bank, a successful career, about to enter Teacher's College at Columbia), she still feels 16-years-old when it comes to Marcus. We find out she and Marcus have had zero contact since she turned down his proposal, but plenty of gossip has reached her ears. Her success professionally has come at the cost of losing touch with many of her friends, and she is feeling like a failure for missing the flight which will take her to Bridget's wedding. The conversations she has with Marcus are oddly polite, unsure how she's supposed to act with him now.
There's no handbook for adulthood. And while it's great to finally see Marcus's POV and see how he has struggled as well in the wake of their separation, it is Jessica's evolution (and, in some cases, lack thereof) from the sarcastic 16-year-old we first met to the 26-year-old we end with that is the true focus here. Jessica was able to recognize in the fourth book that being with Marcus was what was stopping her from moving forward; they needed the separation to figure out who they were without each other. It is only when they are both who they are meant to be that they can be together again. And when Jessica wakes up at the end of the fifth book, happy, successful, and hopeful for the future, you can truly see that Jessica has grown up, not necessarily how she thought she would but in a way that has made her a strong, capable woman.
“Excuse our appearances. We are taking apart yesterday, to make way for tomorrow” Perfect Fifths