Merged
Conversation
ff5cf15 to
52d34bd
Compare
This includes: * Remove only_clingo and only_original fixtures * Remove _old_concretize and _new_concretize * Remove _concretize_together_old * Remove _concretize_together_new * Remove any use of SPACK_TEST_SOLVER * Simplify CI job
Spec.normalize() is still there, since it's heavily used in unit tests
527b7aa to
34f9363
Compare
tgamblin
approved these changes
Aug 10, 2024
Member
|
Thanks @alalazo ! |
diehlpk
pushed a commit
to diehlpk/spack
that referenced
this pull request
Aug 14, 2024
The old concretizer is still used to bootstrap clingo from source. If we switch to a DAG model
where compilers are treated as nodes, we need to either:
1. fix the old concretizer to support this (which is a lot of work and possibly research), or
2. bootstrap `clingo` without the old concretizer.
This PR takes the second approach and gets rid of the old concretizer code. To bootstrap
`clingo`, we store some concrete spec prototypes as JSON, select one according to the
coarse-grained system architecture, and tweak them according to the current host.
The old concretizer and related dead code are removed. In particular, this removes
`Spec.normalize()` and related methods, which were used in many unit-tests to set
up the test context. The tests have been updated not to use `normalize()`.
- [x] Bootstrap clingo concretization based on a JSON file
- [x] Bootstrap clingo *before* patchelf
- [x] Remove any use of the old concretizer, including:
* Remove only_clingo and only_original fixtures
* Remove _old_concretize and _new_concretize
* Remove _concretize_together_old
* Remove _concretize_together_new
* Remove any use of `SPACK_TEST_SOLVER`
* Simplify CI jobs
- [x] ensure bootstrapping `clingo` works on on Darwin and Windows
- [x] Raise an intelligible error when a compiler is missing
- [x] Ensure bootstrapping works on FreeBSD
- [x] remove normalize and related methods
Signed-off-by: Todd Gamblin <tgamblin@llnl.gov>
Chrismarsh
pushed a commit
to Chrismarsh/spack
that referenced
this pull request
Aug 16, 2024
The old concretizer is still used to bootstrap clingo from source. If we switch to a DAG model
where compilers are treated as nodes, we need to either:
1. fix the old concretizer to support this (which is a lot of work and possibly research), or
2. bootstrap `clingo` without the old concretizer.
This PR takes the second approach and gets rid of the old concretizer code. To bootstrap
`clingo`, we store some concrete spec prototypes as JSON, select one according to the
coarse-grained system architecture, and tweak them according to the current host.
The old concretizer and related dead code are removed. In particular, this removes
`Spec.normalize()` and related methods, which were used in many unit-tests to set
up the test context. The tests have been updated not to use `normalize()`.
- [x] Bootstrap clingo concretization based on a JSON file
- [x] Bootstrap clingo *before* patchelf
- [x] Remove any use of the old concretizer, including:
* Remove only_clingo and only_original fixtures
* Remove _old_concretize and _new_concretize
* Remove _concretize_together_old
* Remove _concretize_together_new
* Remove any use of `SPACK_TEST_SOLVER`
* Simplify CI jobs
- [x] ensure bootstrapping `clingo` works on on Darwin and Windows
- [x] Raise an intelligible error when a compiler is missing
- [x] Ensure bootstrapping works on FreeBSD
- [x] remove normalize and related methods
Signed-off-by: Todd Gamblin <tgamblin@llnl.gov>
tldahlgren
pushed a commit
to AcriusWinter/spack
that referenced
this pull request
Aug 20, 2024
The old concretizer is still used to bootstrap clingo from source. If we switch to a DAG model
where compilers are treated as nodes, we need to either:
1. fix the old concretizer to support this (which is a lot of work and possibly research), or
2. bootstrap `clingo` without the old concretizer.
This PR takes the second approach and gets rid of the old concretizer code. To bootstrap
`clingo`, we store some concrete spec prototypes as JSON, select one according to the
coarse-grained system architecture, and tweak them according to the current host.
The old concretizer and related dead code are removed. In particular, this removes
`Spec.normalize()` and related methods, which were used in many unit-tests to set
up the test context. The tests have been updated not to use `normalize()`.
- [x] Bootstrap clingo concretization based on a JSON file
- [x] Bootstrap clingo *before* patchelf
- [x] Remove any use of the old concretizer, including:
* Remove only_clingo and only_original fixtures
* Remove _old_concretize and _new_concretize
* Remove _concretize_together_old
* Remove _concretize_together_new
* Remove any use of `SPACK_TEST_SOLVER`
* Simplify CI jobs
- [x] ensure bootstrapping `clingo` works on on Darwin and Windows
- [x] Raise an intelligible error when a compiler is missing
- [x] Ensure bootstrapping works on FreeBSD
- [x] remove normalize and related methods
Signed-off-by: Todd Gamblin <tgamblin@llnl.gov>
FrederickDeny
pushed a commit
to FrederickDeny/spack
that referenced
this pull request
Aug 26, 2024
The old concretizer is still used to bootstrap clingo from source. If we switch to a DAG model
where compilers are treated as nodes, we need to either:
1. fix the old concretizer to support this (which is a lot of work and possibly research), or
2. bootstrap `clingo` without the old concretizer.
This PR takes the second approach and gets rid of the old concretizer code. To bootstrap
`clingo`, we store some concrete spec prototypes as JSON, select one according to the
coarse-grained system architecture, and tweak them according to the current host.
The old concretizer and related dead code are removed. In particular, this removes
`Spec.normalize()` and related methods, which were used in many unit-tests to set
up the test context. The tests have been updated not to use `normalize()`.
- [x] Bootstrap clingo concretization based on a JSON file
- [x] Bootstrap clingo *before* patchelf
- [x] Remove any use of the old concretizer, including:
* Remove only_clingo and only_original fixtures
* Remove _old_concretize and _new_concretize
* Remove _concretize_together_old
* Remove _concretize_together_new
* Remove any use of `SPACK_TEST_SOLVER`
* Simplify CI jobs
- [x] ensure bootstrapping `clingo` works on on Darwin and Windows
- [x] Raise an intelligible error when a compiler is missing
- [x] Ensure bootstrapping works on FreeBSD
- [x] remove normalize and related methods
Signed-off-by: Todd Gamblin <tgamblin@llnl.gov>
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
3 participants
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
The old concretizer is still used to bootstrap clingo from sources. If we switch to a DAG model where compilers are treated as nodes, we need either to fix the old concretizer, or be able to bootstrap clingo without it.
This PR takes the second approach and gets rid of the old concretizer code. The idea is to store a few concrete specs, in JSON format, as "prototypes", and tweak them according to the current host.
Dead code is removed. In particular 527b7aa removes the
Spec.normalizeand related methods, which was used in many unit-tests to setup the test context.