Handle multiple inplace update input output aliasing#7023
Conversation
|
@alanwaketan @wonjoolee95 I think this one is ready for review. |
| auto input_tensor = bridge::GetXlaTensor(input); | ||
| auto output_tensor = bridge::GetXlaTensor(output); | ||
| output_tensor->data()->alias_id = input_tensor->GetUniqueId(); | ||
| if (input_tensor->CurrentDataHandle() != nullptr || |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I guess we can always use alias_id?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
haha that's what I thought but actually no. Look at my example down below
// x.tensor_id = 1, x.alias_id = 1
x = torch.randn(5,5).to(xla_device())
// x.tensor_id = 2, x.alias_id should be 1
x += 1
xm.mark_step()
// x.tensor_id =3, x.alias_id should be 2 since input tensor id will be 2
// for this graph
x *= 1
xm.mark_step()
if we always use alias_id, the alias_id of x in second would be 1, but we need it to be 2.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
in the second execution, input tensor id is 2, we need the alias ID to always match the input tensor ID. In other world we should not carry alias_id across mark_step.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
This is a bit tricky, even the underlying buffer is aliased, we still create a new PjrtBuffer object for x after the first mark_step. That DeviceData object(wrap about pjrtbuffer) will have data_info with tensor_id 2, since x's tensor id is 2 after the first mark_step.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I guess resetting alias_id after mark_step is probably very complicated. This is more like a simplified way to achieve that. Assuming IR/outputs becomes DeviceData/inputs.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
we can do that too(reset alias_id to tensor id after processed the input_output_alias info). That might make this code less confuse haha.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
That sounds like a good follow up, but feel free to skip it.
|
Will this go into 2.4? Any chance it can be backported to 2.3? |
|
This will be part of the 2.4, we don't do dot releases so it is unlikely for this one to be in the 2.3 release. |
Fix the bug where if inplace operation is being applied multiple times, the aliasing won;t happened.
Consider the case without this pr
During the
mark_steptime we check that input buffer hastensor ID1, and the outputalias idis 2, hence it will skip donating input buffer of size (5,5).xla/torch_xla/csrc/xla_graph_executor.cpp
Lines 1249 to 1253 in d123585
xla/torch_xla/csrc/xla_graph_executor.cpp
Lines 1261 to 1269 in d123585
Alias ID should track the tensor ID of the input buffer, not the tensor ID of last base.