Skip to content

Expose %(file_old), the filename before a rename or deletion#1132

Merged
koutcher merged 1 commit intojonas:masterfrom
krobelus:file_old
Oct 4, 2021
Merged

Expose %(file_old), the filename before a rename or deletion#1132
koutcher merged 1 commit intojonas:masterfrom
krobelus:file_old

Conversation

@krobelus
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

This improves interaction with external tools that require file names.

Implemented by extending diff_get_pathname.
We don't handle prefixes like "diff --cc" when computing %(file_old),
because we can't tell yet if such a line is "old" or "new".
Git only uses these combined headers for binary files, and other edge
cases, see: PAGER='less +1206' git show 75ae10b:combine-diff.c
Anyway, this is not really important because %(file) already has the
correct name.

An alternative (partial) solution would be to change %(file) to the
old filename but only for deleted files. I decided against this;
while it would be convenient for some basic scenarios, it hides
information which makes scripting more difficult.

Another, more general solution for these kinds of problems would be
to allow to pipe the raw diff to user scripts.

This improves interaction with external tools that require file names.

Implemented by extending diff_get_pathname.
We don't handle prefixes like "diff --cc" when computing %(file_old),
because we can't tell yet if such a line is "old" or "new".
Git only uses these combined headers for binary files, and other edge
cases, see: PAGER='less +1206' git show 75ae10b:combine-diff.c
Anyway, this is not really important because %(file) already has the
correct name.

An alternative (partial) solution would be to change %(file) to the
old filename but only for deleted files. I decided against this;
while it would be convenient for some basic scenarios, it hides
information which makes scripting more difficult.

Another, more general solution for these kinds of problems would be
to allow to pipe the raw diff to user scripts.
@koutcher koutcher merged commit 5a23214 into jonas:master Oct 4, 2021
vxsl pushed a commit to vxsl/tig that referenced this pull request Mar 18, 2026
)

This improves interaction with external tools that require file names.

Implemented by extending diff_get_pathname.
We don't handle prefixes like "diff --cc" when computing %(file_old),
because we can't tell yet if such a line is "old" or "new".
Git only uses these combined headers for binary files, and other edge
cases, see: PAGER='less +1206' git show 75ae10b:combine-diff.c
Anyway, this is not really important because %(file) already has the
correct name.

An alternative (partial) solution would be to change %(file) to the
old filename but only for deleted files. I decided against this;
while it would be convenient for some basic scenarios, it hides
information which makes scripting more difficult.

Another, more general solution for these kinds of problems would be
to allow to pipe the raw diff to user scripts.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants