fix: BufferedMutator close() waits for all secondary flushes to finish #110
Conversation
074e0d5 to
c876cf1
Compare
prawilny
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Looks good.
Reviewed 2 of 3 files at r1, all commit messages.
Reviewable status: 2 of 3 files reviewed, 1 unresolved discussion (waiting on @mwalkiewicz and @prawilny)
bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x-parent/bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x/src/test/java/com/google/cloud/bigtable/mirroring/hbase1_x/TestMirroringBufferedMutator.java, line 455 at r1 (raw file):
for (int i = 0; i < numRunningFlushes; i++) { bm.mutate(mutations); // Primary flush completes immediately, secondary is blocked but releases one permit on the
Is this comment precise? Don't we set 4 * size(operation) as threshold for automatic flush (it's a conjecture) so that it isn't flushed immediately?
mwalkiewicz
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reviewable status: 2 of 3 files reviewed, 1 unresolved discussion (waiting on @prawilny)
bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x-parent/bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x/src/test/java/com/google/cloud/bigtable/mirroring/hbase1_x/TestMirroringBufferedMutator.java, line 455 at r1 (raw file):
Previously, prawilny (Adam Czajkowski) wrote…
Is this comment precise? Don't we set 4 * size(operation) as threshold for automatic flush (it's a conjecture) so that it isn't flushed immediately?
I did set it to 4*size to prevent automatic flush, I want to perform it manually, which happens in the next line.
prawilny
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reviewable status: 2 of 3 files reviewed, 1 unresolved discussion (waiting on @mwalkiewicz and @prawilny)
bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x-parent/bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x/src/test/java/com/google/cloud/bigtable/mirroring/hbase1_x/TestMirroringBufferedMutator.java, line 455 at r1 (raw file):
Previously, mwalkiewicz (Mateusz Walkiewicz) wrote…
I did set it to 4*size to prevent automatic flush, I want to perform it manually, which happens in the next line.
I don't remember what happens in the code but isn't what you wrote also what I wrote?
I feel like you just contradicted the comment - it states that "Primary flush completes immediately" whereas you just said that the argument to getBufferedMutator "prevent[s] automatic flush".
c876cf1 to
9a3802b
Compare
mwalkiewicz
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reviewable status: 0 of 5 files reviewed, 1 unresolved discussion (waiting on @prawilny)
bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x-parent/bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x/src/test/java/com/google/cloud/bigtable/mirroring/hbase1_x/TestMirroringBufferedMutator.java, line 455 at r1 (raw file):
Previously, prawilny (Adam Czajkowski) wrote…
I don't remember what happens in the code but isn't what you wrote also what I wrote?
I feel like you just contradicted the comment - it states that "Primary flush completes immediately" whereas you just said that the argument to getBufferedMutator "prevent[s] automatic flush".
What I meant by "automatic" is "periodic", but manually calling flush() will perform the flush. I've added a comment explaining what is going on.
prawilny
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reviewed 5 of 5 files at r2, all commit messages.
Reviewable status: all files reviewed, 1 unresolved discussion (waiting on @mwalkiewicz)
bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x-parent/bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x/src/test/java/com/google/cloud/bigtable/mirroring/hbase1_x/TestMirroringBufferedMutator.java, line 455 at r1 (raw file):
Previously, mwalkiewicz (Mateusz Walkiewicz) wrote…
What I meant by "automatic" is "periodic", but manually calling
flush()will perform the flush. I've added a comment explaining what is going on.
Reviewable claims (about TestMirroringBufferedMutator.java) that File not in pull request at selected revision.
mwalkiewicz
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Reviewable status: all files reviewed, 1 unresolved discussion (waiting on @prawilny)
bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x-parent/bigtable-hbase-mirroring-client-1.x/src/test/java/com/google/cloud/bigtable/mirroring/hbase1_x/TestMirroringBufferedMutator.java, line 455 at r1 (raw file):
Previously, prawilny (Adam Czajkowski) wrote…
Reviewable claims (about TestMirroringBufferedMutator.java) that
File not in pull request at selected revision.
Yes, in the meanwhile this file was renamed to TestSequential...
… review comments (googleapis#3347) * chore: revert review comments * feat: add MirroringOperationException exception markers (#125) * feat: concurrent writes in MirroringBufferedMutator (#80) * refactor: implement multiple argument operations on MirroringAsyncTable with specific operations rather than batch() (#75) * feat: implement MirroringAsyncTable#getName() (#132) * feat: use Logger rather than stdout in DefaultMismatchDetector (#128) * feat: synchronous writes (#88) * fix: implement heapSize method for RowCell (#111) * feat: FlowController accounts for memory usage (#137) * refactor: remove Configuration as a base of MirroringConfiguration (#127) * feat: MirroringAsyncBufferedMutator (#81) * refactor: rename WRITE_MISMATCH to SECONDARY_WRITE_ERROR (#138) * fix: BufferedMutator close() waits for all secondary flushes to finish (#110) * feat: 2.x reads sampling (#114) * refactor: make MirroringResultScanner synchronize on itself rather than MirroringTable (#134) * ConcurrentBufferedMutator integration tests (#135) * feat: add synchronous MirroringConnection to 2.x (#109) * fix: MirroringConnection in 2.x failed to compile (#139) * fix: fix BufferedMutator ITs (#140) * feat: run 1.x integration tests on MirroringConnection etc. from 2.x (#108) * feat: 2.x - rewrite Increment and Append as Put in batch (#116) * fix: fix build (#142) * refactor: minor fixes after review (#117) * feat: MirroringAsyncTable#getScanner() (#58) * test: 2.x integration tests (#112) * feat: implement MirroringAsyncBufferedMutatorBuilder (#144) * feat: log rows and values in DefaultMismatchDetector (#129) * fix: ITs - add expected parameter to MismatchDetectors (#153) * fix: force Append and Increment to return results and discard that result before returning it to user (#136) * fix: review fixes in utils * fix: review fixes in BufferedMutator * fix: review fixes in Faillog * fix: fixed reference counting * fix: review fixes in FlowController * fix: review fixes in metrics * fix: review fixes in verification * fix: Review fixes in MirroringTable * fix: review fixes in HBase 2.x client * fix: fixes in ITs * feat: MirrorinAsyncTable: scan(), scanAll() (#131) * fix: review fixes in tests * feat: MirroringConnection: timeout in close() and abort() (#133) * feat: better mismatch detection of scan results (#130) * feat: quickstart (#105) * fix: 2.x scan ITs (#158) * fix: DefaultMismatchDetector tests (#157) * fix: ConcurrentBufferedMutator waits for both flushes to finish before closing (#161) * fix: additional minor fixes after review (#163) * fix: BufferedMutator review fixes (#164) - Simplify #flush(). - Add javadocs. - (sequential) Fix flush() exception handling. - (sequential) Move error handling to a separate inner class. * fix: PR fixes * fix: report zeroed error metrics after successful operations * fix: prepend MismatchDetectorCounter with Test to better reflect its purpose * feat: Client-side timestamping (#165) * fix: reduce timeout in TestBlocking to make the tests run faster * fix: asyncClose -> closePrimaryAndScheduleSecondaryClose * fix: remove unused Batcher#throwBatchDataExceptionIfPresent * fix: remove unused Comparators#compareRows * fix: extract failedReads from MatchingSuccessfulReadsResults to reduce confusion * feat: remove unused MirroringTracer from FailedMutationLogger * fix: MirroringAsyncBufferedMutator - test if failed mutation is passed to secondary write error consumer * fix: TestMirroringAsyncTableInputModification typo fix * fix: describe user flush() in Buffered Mutator in quickstart * fix: MirroringBufferedMutator - move flush threshold from BufferedMutations to FlushSerializer * refactor: MirroringBufferedMutator#close() - use AccumulatedExceptions insteand of List<Exception> * BufferedMutator - add close timeout * AsyncBufferedMutator - add close timeout * fix: remove stale addSecondaryMutation comment * fix: add a comment that addSecondaryMutation handles failed writes * fix: unify implementations of flushBufferedMutatorBeforeClosing * fix: BufferedMutator - throw exceptions on close * fix: BufferedMutator - add comment explaining that chain of flush operations is created * fix: BufferedMutator - clarify comments * fix: Concurrent BufferedMutator - fix throwFlushExceptionIfAvailable * fix: explain why flush is called in Sequential BufferedMutator test * fix: TestConcurrentMirroringBufferedMutator - make waiting for calls explicit * refactor: BufferedMutator rename scheduleFlushAll() to scheduleFlush() * refactor: make FlushSerializer non-static * fix: BufferedMutator - use HierarchicalReferenceCounter * feat: Add MirroringConnection constructor taking MirroringConfiguration * refactor: move releaseReservations to finally * fix: use less convoluted example in lastFlushFutures description * fix: merge small Timeestamper files into a single file * fix: add a comment explaining which exceptions are forwarded to the user and why in SequentialMirroringBufferedMutator * fix: use UnsupportedOperationException instead of RuntimeException when forbidden mutation type is encountered * fix: add comment explaining why batch is complicated * fix: add a TODO to implement point writes without batch Co-authored-by: Mateusz Walkiewicz <mwalkiewicz@unoperate.com> Co-authored-by: Adam Czajkowski <prawilny@unoperate.com> Co-authored-by: Kajetan Boroszko <kajetan@unoperate.com>
… review comments (googleapis#3347) * chore: revert review comments * feat: add MirroringOperationException exception markers (#125) * feat: concurrent writes in MirroringBufferedMutator (#80) * refactor: implement multiple argument operations on MirroringAsyncTable with specific operations rather than batch() (#75) * feat: implement MirroringAsyncTable#getName() (#132) * feat: use Logger rather than stdout in DefaultMismatchDetector (#128) * feat: synchronous writes (#88) * fix: implement heapSize method for RowCell (#111) * feat: FlowController accounts for memory usage (#137) * refactor: remove Configuration as a base of MirroringConfiguration (#127) * feat: MirroringAsyncBufferedMutator (#81) * refactor: rename WRITE_MISMATCH to SECONDARY_WRITE_ERROR (#138) * fix: BufferedMutator close() waits for all secondary flushes to finish (#110) * feat: 2.x reads sampling (#114) * refactor: make MirroringResultScanner synchronize on itself rather than MirroringTable (#134) * ConcurrentBufferedMutator integration tests (#135) * feat: add synchronous MirroringConnection to 2.x (#109) * fix: MirroringConnection in 2.x failed to compile (#139) * fix: fix BufferedMutator ITs (#140) * feat: run 1.x integration tests on MirroringConnection etc. from 2.x (#108) * feat: 2.x - rewrite Increment and Append as Put in batch (#116) * fix: fix build (#142) * refactor: minor fixes after review (#117) * feat: MirroringAsyncTable#getScanner() (#58) * test: 2.x integration tests (#112) * feat: implement MirroringAsyncBufferedMutatorBuilder (#144) * feat: log rows and values in DefaultMismatchDetector (#129) * fix: ITs - add expected parameter to MismatchDetectors (#153) * fix: force Append and Increment to return results and discard that result before returning it to user (#136) * fix: review fixes in utils * fix: review fixes in BufferedMutator * fix: review fixes in Faillog * fix: fixed reference counting * fix: review fixes in FlowController * fix: review fixes in metrics * fix: review fixes in verification * fix: Review fixes in MirroringTable * fix: review fixes in HBase 2.x client * fix: fixes in ITs * feat: MirrorinAsyncTable: scan(), scanAll() (#131) * fix: review fixes in tests * feat: MirroringConnection: timeout in close() and abort() (#133) * feat: better mismatch detection of scan results (#130) * feat: quickstart (#105) * fix: 2.x scan ITs (#158) * fix: DefaultMismatchDetector tests (#157) * fix: ConcurrentBufferedMutator waits for both flushes to finish before closing (#161) * fix: additional minor fixes after review (#163) * fix: BufferedMutator review fixes (#164) - Simplify #flush(). - Add javadocs. - (sequential) Fix flush() exception handling. - (sequential) Move error handling to a separate inner class. * fix: PR fixes * fix: report zeroed error metrics after successful operations * fix: prepend MismatchDetectorCounter with Test to better reflect its purpose * feat: Client-side timestamping (#165) * fix: reduce timeout in TestBlocking to make the tests run faster * fix: asyncClose -> closePrimaryAndScheduleSecondaryClose * fix: remove unused Batcher#throwBatchDataExceptionIfPresent * fix: remove unused Comparators#compareRows * fix: extract failedReads from MatchingSuccessfulReadsResults to reduce confusion * feat: remove unused MirroringTracer from FailedMutationLogger * fix: MirroringAsyncBufferedMutator - test if failed mutation is passed to secondary write error consumer * fix: TestMirroringAsyncTableInputModification typo fix * fix: describe user flush() in Buffered Mutator in quickstart * fix: MirroringBufferedMutator - move flush threshold from BufferedMutations to FlushSerializer * refactor: MirroringBufferedMutator#close() - use AccumulatedExceptions insteand of List<Exception> * BufferedMutator - add close timeout * AsyncBufferedMutator - add close timeout * fix: remove stale addSecondaryMutation comment * fix: add a comment that addSecondaryMutation handles failed writes * fix: unify implementations of flushBufferedMutatorBeforeClosing * fix: BufferedMutator - throw exceptions on close * fix: BufferedMutator - add comment explaining that chain of flush operations is created * fix: BufferedMutator - clarify comments * fix: Concurrent BufferedMutator - fix throwFlushExceptionIfAvailable * fix: explain why flush is called in Sequential BufferedMutator test * fix: TestConcurrentMirroringBufferedMutator - make waiting for calls explicit * refactor: BufferedMutator rename scheduleFlushAll() to scheduleFlush() * refactor: make FlushSerializer non-static * fix: BufferedMutator - use HierarchicalReferenceCounter * feat: Add MirroringConnection constructor taking MirroringConfiguration * refactor: move releaseReservations to finally * fix: use less convoluted example in lastFlushFutures description * fix: merge small Timeestamper files into a single file * fix: add a comment explaining which exceptions are forwarded to the user and why in SequentialMirroringBufferedMutator * fix: use UnsupportedOperationException instead of RuntimeException when forbidden mutation type is encountered * fix: add comment explaining why batch is complicated * fix: add a TODO to implement point writes without batch Co-authored-by: Mateusz Walkiewicz <mwalkiewicz@unoperate.com> Co-authored-by: Adam Czajkowski <prawilny@unoperate.com> Co-authored-by: Kajetan Boroszko <kajetan@unoperate.com>
This change is