Skip to content

fix(skills): pin protects against deletion only, not edits#20220

Merged
teknium1 merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
hermes/hermes-eb087d76
May 5, 2026
Merged

fix(skills): pin protects against deletion only, not edits#20220
teknium1 merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
hermes/hermes-eb087d76

Conversation

@teknium1

@teknium1 teknium1 commented May 5, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Closes #18354 (@camaliagroup).

Summary

Narrows _pinned_guard in skill_manage to delete only. Previously, pinning a skill blocked every write — edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file — which forced an unpin → edit → re-pin dance whenever the agent found a pitfall in a pinned skill, and pinned skills went stale as a result.

What 'pin' means now

  • Curator — still skips pinned skills during auto-transitions and tells the LLM review pass to leave them alone (agent/curator.py unchanged).
  • skill_manage(action='delete') — still refuses on pinned skills.
  • skill_manage patch / edit / write_file / remove_file — now goes through on pinned skills so the agent can maintain them.

The agent-created check + delete refusal is the irrecoverable path worth protecting. Patches and edits are reversible via hermes curator rollback, so gating them was friction without much payoff.

Changes

  • tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring + refusal message (now says 'cannot be deleted' and notes patches/edits are allowed). Updated skill_manage model-facing tool description so the LLM knows it can patch pinned skills.
  • website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: rewrote the Pinning section to match.
  • tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped 5 refuses_pinned tests for edit/patch/patch-supporting-file/write_file/remove_file into allowed_when_pinned. Kept test_delete_refuses_pinned with a stronger assertion ('cannot be deleted' in error message). Updated test_unpinned_skills_still_editable and test_broken_sidecar_fails_open to use _delete_skill as the probe.

Validation

Targeted tests 143 passed (test_skill_manager_tool.py 86, test_skill_usage.py 40, test_curator_status.py 4, test_curator_archive_prune.py 13)
E2E with real skill_manage + real on-disk skill + real pinning 7/7: patch, edit, write_file, remove_file all succeed on pinned skill; delete refuses with 'cannot be deleted' + unpin hint; delete works after unpin; broken sidecar fails open

Credit: @camaliagroup for the report and the sharp framing ('pin should protect against deletion, not prevent edits').

Previously, pinning a skill blocked every skill_manage write action
(edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file). The 'hard fence'
design conflated two concerns:

  1. Pin as deletion protection — don't let the curator archive
     or the agent delete a stable skill.
  2. Pin as content freeze — don't let the agent rewrite it mid-conversation.

In practice (1) is what users pin for: they want a skill to survive
curator passes. (2) created friction — agents finding a new pitfall
in a pinned skill had to ask the user to unpin, then the agent
patches, then the user re-pins. The dance discouraged skill
maintenance and pinned skills went stale.

This narrows the _pinned_guard to skill_manage(action='delete') only.
Patches, edits, and supporting-file writes go through on pinned
skills so the agent can keep improving them. The curator's own
pinned-skip behavior (agent/curator.py:271 for auto-archive,
line 349 for the LLM review prompt) is unchanged — curator still
never touches pinned skills.

Changes:
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from
  _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on
  _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring and error message.
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: updated skill_manage model-facing tool
  description to reflect the new semantic.
- website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: updated pinning
  section.
- tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped refuses-pinned
  tests for edit/patch/write_file/remove_file into allowed-when-pinned;
  kept test_delete_refuses_pinned (strengthened assertion to check the
  'cannot be deleted' wording).

Closes #18354
@teknium1 teknium1 merged commit b10e38e into main May 5, 2026
10 of 12 checks passed
@teknium1 teknium1 deleted the hermes/hermes-eb087d76 branch May 5, 2026 12:43
@alt-glitch alt-glitch added type/feature New feature or request P3 Low — cosmetic, nice to have tool/skills Skills system (list, view, manage) labels May 5, 2026
teknium1 added a commit that referenced this pull request May 5, 2026
#20226)

* docs(AGENTS.md): add curator/cron/delegation/toolsets, fix plugin tree, frontmatter, auto-discovery caveat

Closes #19101 and #19107 (@pty819).

Verified 16 claims from those two issues against current main. 12 were
real gaps; 2 were generated/hallucinated (#10 unverified --now flag is
actually real and already cited in AGENTS.md; #11 stale PR refs #5587
and #4950 do not appear in AGENTS.md at all); 2 were low-prio nits
(memory provider hierarchy, --now scope enumeration) deferred.

Changes:
- Project tree: add yuanbao to platforms comment; expand plugins/
  subtree with real directory names (kanban, hermes-achievements,
  observability, image_gen) instead of vague '<others>'.
- Test-count blurb: 15k/700 Apr → 17k/900 May (verified: 17,375 test
  defs, 915 files).
- Adding New Tools: clarify that auto-discovery wires up schemas but
  the tool only reaches an agent if its name is added to a toolset in
  toolsets.py. _HERMES_CORE_TOOLS is not dead code.
- Adding Configuration: enumerate top-level config.yaml sections
  including auxiliary and curator; note auxiliary is per-task
  overrides for side-LLM work.
- SKILL.md frontmatter: add author, license, related_skills. Note
  top-level tags/category are mirrored from metadata.hermes.*.
- New section 'Toolsets' — enumerates the 30 current TOOLSETS keys
  (including yuanbao, kanban, moa, spotify, safe, debugging).
- New section 'Delegation (delegate_task)' — sync semantics, batch
  mode, leaf vs orchestrator roles, config knobs, durability caveat.
- New section 'Curator (skill lifecycle)' — core files, 11 CLI verbs,
  telemetry sidecar, invariants (pin/delete split after PR #20220,
  bundled/hub off-limits), curator.* config section.
- New section 'Cron (scheduled jobs)' — 4 schedule formats, 7 CLI
  verbs, per-job fields, 3-min hard interrupt, catchup/grace windows,
  tick.lock, cron→session isolation.

Skipped (invalid claims):
- #19107 item 10: --now is real (hermes_cli/skills_hub.py:624/966/1013/1470)
- #19107 item 11: no '#5587' or '#4950' or 'async_delegation' in AGENTS.md

* docs(AGENTS.md): add Kanban section

Adds a Kanban entry alongside Curator / Cron / Delegation so the major
durable background systems are all represented. Covers the CLI verbs,
the HERMES_KANBAN_TASK-gated worker toolset, the in-gateway dispatcher,
plugin assets, and the board/tenant isolation model. Points at the full
742-line user docs for detail.
nickdlkk pushed a commit to nickdlkk/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
…rch#20220)

Previously, pinning a skill blocked every skill_manage write action
(edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file). The 'hard fence'
design conflated two concerns:

  1. Pin as deletion protection — don't let the curator archive
     or the agent delete a stable skill.
  2. Pin as content freeze — don't let the agent rewrite it mid-conversation.

In practice (1) is what users pin for: they want a skill to survive
curator passes. (2) created friction — agents finding a new pitfall
in a pinned skill had to ask the user to unpin, then the agent
patches, then the user re-pins. The dance discouraged skill
maintenance and pinned skills went stale.

This narrows the _pinned_guard to skill_manage(action='delete') only.
Patches, edits, and supporting-file writes go through on pinned
skills so the agent can keep improving them. The curator's own
pinned-skip behavior (agent/curator.py:271 for auto-archive,
line 349 for the LLM review prompt) is unchanged — curator still
never touches pinned skills.

Changes:
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from
  _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on
  _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring and error message.
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: updated skill_manage model-facing tool
  description to reflect the new semantic.
- website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: updated pinning
  section.
- tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped refuses-pinned
  tests for edit/patch/write_file/remove_file into allowed-when-pinned;
  kept test_delete_refuses_pinned (strengthened assertion to check the
  'cannot be deleted' wording).

Closes NousResearch#18354
nickdlkk pushed a commit to nickdlkk/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
NousResearch#20226)

* docs(AGENTS.md): add curator/cron/delegation/toolsets, fix plugin tree, frontmatter, auto-discovery caveat

Closes NousResearch#19101 and NousResearch#19107 (@pty819).

Verified 16 claims from those two issues against current main. 12 were
real gaps; 2 were generated/hallucinated (NousResearch#10 unverified --now flag is
actually real and already cited in AGENTS.md; NousResearch#11 stale PR refs NousResearch#5587
and NousResearch#4950 do not appear in AGENTS.md at all); 2 were low-prio nits
(memory provider hierarchy, --now scope enumeration) deferred.

Changes:
- Project tree: add yuanbao to platforms comment; expand plugins/
  subtree with real directory names (kanban, hermes-achievements,
  observability, image_gen) instead of vague '<others>'.
- Test-count blurb: 15k/700 Apr → 17k/900 May (verified: 17,375 test
  defs, 915 files).
- Adding New Tools: clarify that auto-discovery wires up schemas but
  the tool only reaches an agent if its name is added to a toolset in
  toolsets.py. _HERMES_CORE_TOOLS is not dead code.
- Adding Configuration: enumerate top-level config.yaml sections
  including auxiliary and curator; note auxiliary is per-task
  overrides for side-LLM work.
- SKILL.md frontmatter: add author, license, related_skills. Note
  top-level tags/category are mirrored from metadata.hermes.*.
- New section 'Toolsets' — enumerates the 30 current TOOLSETS keys
  (including yuanbao, kanban, moa, spotify, safe, debugging).
- New section 'Delegation (delegate_task)' — sync semantics, batch
  mode, leaf vs orchestrator roles, config knobs, durability caveat.
- New section 'Curator (skill lifecycle)' — core files, 11 CLI verbs,
  telemetry sidecar, invariants (pin/delete split after PR NousResearch#20220,
  bundled/hub off-limits), curator.* config section.
- New section 'Cron (scheduled jobs)' — 4 schedule formats, 7 CLI
  verbs, per-job fields, 3-min hard interrupt, catchup/grace windows,
  tick.lock, cron→session isolation.

Skipped (invalid claims):
- NousResearch#19107 item 10: --now is real (hermes_cli/skills_hub.py:624/966/1013/1470)
- NousResearch#19107 item 11: no 'NousResearch#5587' or 'NousResearch#4950' or 'async_delegation' in AGENTS.md

* docs(AGENTS.md): add Kanban section

Adds a Kanban entry alongside Curator / Cron / Delegation so the major
durable background systems are all represented. Covers the CLI verbs,
the HERMES_KANBAN_TASK-gated worker toolset, the in-gateway dispatcher,
plugin assets, and the board/tenant isolation model. Points at the full
742-line user docs for detail.
rmulligan pushed a commit to rmulligan/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
…rch#20220)

Previously, pinning a skill blocked every skill_manage write action
(edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file). The 'hard fence'
design conflated two concerns:

  1. Pin as deletion protection — don't let the curator archive
     or the agent delete a stable skill.
  2. Pin as content freeze — don't let the agent rewrite it mid-conversation.

In practice (1) is what users pin for: they want a skill to survive
curator passes. (2) created friction — agents finding a new pitfall
in a pinned skill had to ask the user to unpin, then the agent
patches, then the user re-pins. The dance discouraged skill
maintenance and pinned skills went stale.

This narrows the _pinned_guard to skill_manage(action='delete') only.
Patches, edits, and supporting-file writes go through on pinned
skills so the agent can keep improving them. The curator's own
pinned-skip behavior (agent/curator.py:271 for auto-archive,
line 349 for the LLM review prompt) is unchanged — curator still
never touches pinned skills.

Changes:
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from
  _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on
  _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring and error message.
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: updated skill_manage model-facing tool
  description to reflect the new semantic.
- website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: updated pinning
  section.
- tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped refuses-pinned
  tests for edit/patch/write_file/remove_file into allowed-when-pinned;
  kept test_delete_refuses_pinned (strengthened assertion to check the
  'cannot be deleted' wording).

Closes NousResearch#18354
rmulligan pushed a commit to rmulligan/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
NousResearch#20226)

* docs(AGENTS.md): add curator/cron/delegation/toolsets, fix plugin tree, frontmatter, auto-discovery caveat

Closes NousResearch#19101 and NousResearch#19107 (@pty819).

Verified 16 claims from those two issues against current main. 12 were
real gaps; 2 were generated/hallucinated (NousResearch#10 unverified --now flag is
actually real and already cited in AGENTS.md; NousResearch#11 stale PR refs NousResearch#5587
and NousResearch#4950 do not appear in AGENTS.md at all); 2 were low-prio nits
(memory provider hierarchy, --now scope enumeration) deferred.

Changes:
- Project tree: add yuanbao to platforms comment; expand plugins/
  subtree with real directory names (kanban, hermes-achievements,
  observability, image_gen) instead of vague '<others>'.
- Test-count blurb: 15k/700 Apr → 17k/900 May (verified: 17,375 test
  defs, 915 files).
- Adding New Tools: clarify that auto-discovery wires up schemas but
  the tool only reaches an agent if its name is added to a toolset in
  toolsets.py. _HERMES_CORE_TOOLS is not dead code.
- Adding Configuration: enumerate top-level config.yaml sections
  including auxiliary and curator; note auxiliary is per-task
  overrides for side-LLM work.
- SKILL.md frontmatter: add author, license, related_skills. Note
  top-level tags/category are mirrored from metadata.hermes.*.
- New section 'Toolsets' — enumerates the 30 current TOOLSETS keys
  (including yuanbao, kanban, moa, spotify, safe, debugging).
- New section 'Delegation (delegate_task)' — sync semantics, batch
  mode, leaf vs orchestrator roles, config knobs, durability caveat.
- New section 'Curator (skill lifecycle)' — core files, 11 CLI verbs,
  telemetry sidecar, invariants (pin/delete split after PR NousResearch#20220,
  bundled/hub off-limits), curator.* config section.
- New section 'Cron (scheduled jobs)' — 4 schedule formats, 7 CLI
  verbs, per-job fields, 3-min hard interrupt, catchup/grace windows,
  tick.lock, cron→session isolation.

Skipped (invalid claims):
- NousResearch#19107 item 10: --now is real (hermes_cli/skills_hub.py:624/966/1013/1470)
- NousResearch#19107 item 11: no 'NousResearch#5587' or 'NousResearch#4950' or 'async_delegation' in AGENTS.md

* docs(AGENTS.md): add Kanban section

Adds a Kanban entry alongside Curator / Cron / Delegation so the major
durable background systems are all represented. Covers the CLI verbs,
the HERMES_KANBAN_TASK-gated worker toolset, the in-gateway dispatcher,
plugin assets, and the board/tenant isolation model. Points at the full
742-line user docs for detail.
JinyuID pushed a commit to JinyuID/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
…rch#20220)

Previously, pinning a skill blocked every skill_manage write action
(edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file). The 'hard fence'
design conflated two concerns:

  1. Pin as deletion protection — don't let the curator archive
     or the agent delete a stable skill.
  2. Pin as content freeze — don't let the agent rewrite it mid-conversation.

In practice (1) is what users pin for: they want a skill to survive
curator passes. (2) created friction — agents finding a new pitfall
in a pinned skill had to ask the user to unpin, then the agent
patches, then the user re-pins. The dance discouraged skill
maintenance and pinned skills went stale.

This narrows the _pinned_guard to skill_manage(action='delete') only.
Patches, edits, and supporting-file writes go through on pinned
skills so the agent can keep improving them. The curator's own
pinned-skip behavior (agent/curator.py:271 for auto-archive,
line 349 for the LLM review prompt) is unchanged — curator still
never touches pinned skills.

Changes:
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from
  _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on
  _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring and error message.
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: updated skill_manage model-facing tool
  description to reflect the new semantic.
- website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: updated pinning
  section.
- tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped refuses-pinned
  tests for edit/patch/write_file/remove_file into allowed-when-pinned;
  kept test_delete_refuses_pinned (strengthened assertion to check the
  'cannot be deleted' wording).

Closes NousResearch#18354
JinyuID pushed a commit to JinyuID/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 11, 2026
NousResearch#20226)

* docs(AGENTS.md): add curator/cron/delegation/toolsets, fix plugin tree, frontmatter, auto-discovery caveat

Closes NousResearch#19101 and NousResearch#19107 (@pty819).

Verified 16 claims from those two issues against current main. 12 were
real gaps; 2 were generated/hallucinated (NousResearch#10 unverified --now flag is
actually real and already cited in AGENTS.md; NousResearch#11 stale PR refs NousResearch#5587
and NousResearch#4950 do not appear in AGENTS.md at all); 2 were low-prio nits
(memory provider hierarchy, --now scope enumeration) deferred.

Changes:
- Project tree: add yuanbao to platforms comment; expand plugins/
  subtree with real directory names (kanban, hermes-achievements,
  observability, image_gen) instead of vague '<others>'.
- Test-count blurb: 15k/700 Apr → 17k/900 May (verified: 17,375 test
  defs, 915 files).
- Adding New Tools: clarify that auto-discovery wires up schemas but
  the tool only reaches an agent if its name is added to a toolset in
  toolsets.py. _HERMES_CORE_TOOLS is not dead code.
- Adding Configuration: enumerate top-level config.yaml sections
  including auxiliary and curator; note auxiliary is per-task
  overrides for side-LLM work.
- SKILL.md frontmatter: add author, license, related_skills. Note
  top-level tags/category are mirrored from metadata.hermes.*.
- New section 'Toolsets' — enumerates the 30 current TOOLSETS keys
  (including yuanbao, kanban, moa, spotify, safe, debugging).
- New section 'Delegation (delegate_task)' — sync semantics, batch
  mode, leaf vs orchestrator roles, config knobs, durability caveat.
- New section 'Curator (skill lifecycle)' — core files, 11 CLI verbs,
  telemetry sidecar, invariants (pin/delete split after PR NousResearch#20220,
  bundled/hub off-limits), curator.* config section.
- New section 'Cron (scheduled jobs)' — 4 schedule formats, 7 CLI
  verbs, per-job fields, 3-min hard interrupt, catchup/grace windows,
  tick.lock, cron→session isolation.

Skipped (invalid claims):
- NousResearch#19107 item 10: --now is real (hermes_cli/skills_hub.py:624/966/1013/1470)
- NousResearch#19107 item 11: no 'NousResearch#5587' or 'NousResearch#4950' or 'async_delegation' in AGENTS.md

* docs(AGENTS.md): add Kanban section

Adds a Kanban entry alongside Curator / Cron / Delegation so the major
durable background systems are all represented. Covers the CLI verbs,
the HERMES_KANBAN_TASK-gated worker toolset, the in-gateway dispatcher,
plugin assets, and the board/tenant isolation model. Points at the full
742-line user docs for detail.
02356abc pushed a commit to 02356abc/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 14, 2026
…rch#20220)

Previously, pinning a skill blocked every skill_manage write action
(edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file). The 'hard fence'
design conflated two concerns:

  1. Pin as deletion protection — don't let the curator archive
     or the agent delete a stable skill.
  2. Pin as content freeze — don't let the agent rewrite it mid-conversation.

In practice (1) is what users pin for: they want a skill to survive
curator passes. (2) created friction — agents finding a new pitfall
in a pinned skill had to ask the user to unpin, then the agent
patches, then the user re-pins. The dance discouraged skill
maintenance and pinned skills went stale.

This narrows the _pinned_guard to skill_manage(action='delete') only.
Patches, edits, and supporting-file writes go through on pinned
skills so the agent can keep improving them. The curator's own
pinned-skip behavior (agent/curator.py:271 for auto-archive,
line 349 for the LLM review prompt) is unchanged — curator still
never touches pinned skills.

Changes:
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from
  _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on
  _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring and error message.
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: updated skill_manage model-facing tool
  description to reflect the new semantic.
- website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: updated pinning
  section.
- tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped refuses-pinned
  tests for edit/patch/write_file/remove_file into allowed-when-pinned;
  kept test_delete_refuses_pinned (strengthened assertion to check the
  'cannot be deleted' wording).

Closes NousResearch#18354
jsboige pushed a commit to jsboige/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 14, 2026
…rch#20220)

Previously, pinning a skill blocked every skill_manage write action
(edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file). The 'hard fence'
design conflated two concerns:

  1. Pin as deletion protection — don't let the curator archive
     or the agent delete a stable skill.
  2. Pin as content freeze — don't let the agent rewrite it mid-conversation.

In practice (1) is what users pin for: they want a skill to survive
curator passes. (2) created friction — agents finding a new pitfall
in a pinned skill had to ask the user to unpin, then the agent
patches, then the user re-pins. The dance discouraged skill
maintenance and pinned skills went stale.

This narrows the _pinned_guard to skill_manage(action='delete') only.
Patches, edits, and supporting-file writes go through on pinned
skills so the agent can keep improving them. The curator's own
pinned-skip behavior (agent/curator.py:271 for auto-archive,
line 349 for the LLM review prompt) is unchanged — curator still
never touches pinned skills.

Changes:
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from
  _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on
  _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring and error message.
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: updated skill_manage model-facing tool
  description to reflect the new semantic.
- website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: updated pinning
  section.
- tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped refuses-pinned
  tests for edit/patch/write_file/remove_file into allowed-when-pinned;
  kept test_delete_refuses_pinned (strengthened assertion to check the
  'cannot be deleted' wording).

Closes NousResearch#18354
jsboige pushed a commit to jsboige/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 14, 2026
NousResearch#20226)

* docs(AGENTS.md): add curator/cron/delegation/toolsets, fix plugin tree, frontmatter, auto-discovery caveat

Closes NousResearch#19101 and NousResearch#19107 (@pty819).

Verified 16 claims from those two issues against current main. 12 were
real gaps; 2 were generated/hallucinated (NousResearch#10 unverified --now flag is
actually real and already cited in AGENTS.md; NousResearch#11 stale PR refs NousResearch#5587
and NousResearch#4950 do not appear in AGENTS.md at all); 2 were low-prio nits
(memory provider hierarchy, --now scope enumeration) deferred.

Changes:
- Project tree: add yuanbao to platforms comment; expand plugins/
  subtree with real directory names (kanban, hermes-achievements,
  observability, image_gen) instead of vague '<others>'.
- Test-count blurb: 15k/700 Apr → 17k/900 May (verified: 17,375 test
  defs, 915 files).
- Adding New Tools: clarify that auto-discovery wires up schemas but
  the tool only reaches an agent if its name is added to a toolset in
  toolsets.py. _HERMES_CORE_TOOLS is not dead code.
- Adding Configuration: enumerate top-level config.yaml sections
  including auxiliary and curator; note auxiliary is per-task
  overrides for side-LLM work.
- SKILL.md frontmatter: add author, license, related_skills. Note
  top-level tags/category are mirrored from metadata.hermes.*.
- New section 'Toolsets' — enumerates the 30 current TOOLSETS keys
  (including yuanbao, kanban, moa, spotify, safe, debugging).
- New section 'Delegation (delegate_task)' — sync semantics, batch
  mode, leaf vs orchestrator roles, config knobs, durability caveat.
- New section 'Curator (skill lifecycle)' — core files, 11 CLI verbs,
  telemetry sidecar, invariants (pin/delete split after PR NousResearch#20220,
  bundled/hub off-limits), curator.* config section.
- New section 'Cron (scheduled jobs)' — 4 schedule formats, 7 CLI
  verbs, per-job fields, 3-min hard interrupt, catchup/grace windows,
  tick.lock, cron→session isolation.

Skipped (invalid claims):
- NousResearch#19107 item 10: --now is real (hermes_cli/skills_hub.py:624/966/1013/1470)
- NousResearch#19107 item 11: no 'NousResearch#5587' or 'NousResearch#4950' or 'async_delegation' in AGENTS.md

* docs(AGENTS.md): add Kanban section

Adds a Kanban entry alongside Curator / Cron / Delegation so the major
durable background systems are all represented. Covers the CLI verbs,
the HERMES_KANBAN_TASK-gated worker toolset, the in-gateway dispatcher,
plugin assets, and the board/tenant isolation model. Points at the full
742-line user docs for detail.
gweeteve pushed a commit to gweeteve/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request Jun 2, 2026
…rch#20220)

Previously, pinning a skill blocked every skill_manage write action
(edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file). The 'hard fence'
design conflated two concerns:

  1. Pin as deletion protection — don't let the curator archive
     or the agent delete a stable skill.
  2. Pin as content freeze — don't let the agent rewrite it mid-conversation.

In practice (1) is what users pin for: they want a skill to survive
curator passes. (2) created friction — agents finding a new pitfall
in a pinned skill had to ask the user to unpin, then the agent
patches, then the user re-pins. The dance discouraged skill
maintenance and pinned skills went stale.

This narrows the _pinned_guard to skill_manage(action='delete') only.
Patches, edits, and supporting-file writes go through on pinned
skills so the agent can keep improving them. The curator's own
pinned-skip behavior (agent/curator.py:271 for auto-archive,
line 349 for the LLM review prompt) is unchanged — curator still
never touches pinned skills.

Changes:
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from
  _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on
  _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring and error message.
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: updated skill_manage model-facing tool
  description to reflect the new semantic.
- website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: updated pinning
  section.
- tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped refuses-pinned
  tests for edit/patch/write_file/remove_file into allowed-when-pinned;
  kept test_delete_refuses_pinned (strengthened assertion to check the
  'cannot be deleted' wording).

Closes NousResearch#18354
gweeteve pushed a commit to gweeteve/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request Jun 2, 2026
NousResearch#20226)

* docs(AGENTS.md): add curator/cron/delegation/toolsets, fix plugin tree, frontmatter, auto-discovery caveat

Closes NousResearch#19101 and NousResearch#19107 (@pty819).

Verified 16 claims from those two issues against current main. 12 were
real gaps; 2 were generated/hallucinated (NousResearch#10 unverified --now flag is
actually real and already cited in AGENTS.md; NousResearch#11 stale PR refs NousResearch#5587
and NousResearch#4950 do not appear in AGENTS.md at all); 2 were low-prio nits
(memory provider hierarchy, --now scope enumeration) deferred.

Changes:
- Project tree: add yuanbao to platforms comment; expand plugins/
  subtree with real directory names (kanban, hermes-achievements,
  observability, image_gen) instead of vague '<others>'.
- Test-count blurb: 15k/700 Apr → 17k/900 May (verified: 17,375 test
  defs, 915 files).
- Adding New Tools: clarify that auto-discovery wires up schemas but
  the tool only reaches an agent if its name is added to a toolset in
  toolsets.py. _HERMES_CORE_TOOLS is not dead code.
- Adding Configuration: enumerate top-level config.yaml sections
  including auxiliary and curator; note auxiliary is per-task
  overrides for side-LLM work.
- SKILL.md frontmatter: add author, license, related_skills. Note
  top-level tags/category are mirrored from metadata.hermes.*.
- New section 'Toolsets' — enumerates the 30 current TOOLSETS keys
  (including yuanbao, kanban, moa, spotify, safe, debugging).
- New section 'Delegation (delegate_task)' — sync semantics, batch
  mode, leaf vs orchestrator roles, config knobs, durability caveat.
- New section 'Curator (skill lifecycle)' — core files, 11 CLI verbs,
  telemetry sidecar, invariants (pin/delete split after PR NousResearch#20220,
  bundled/hub off-limits), curator.* config section.
- New section 'Cron (scheduled jobs)' — 4 schedule formats, 7 CLI
  verbs, per-job fields, 3-min hard interrupt, catchup/grace windows,
  tick.lock, cron→session isolation.

Skipped (invalid claims):
- NousResearch#19107 item 10: --now is real (hermes_cli/skills_hub.py:624/966/1013/1470)
- NousResearch#19107 item 11: no 'NousResearch#5587' or 'NousResearch#4950' or 'async_delegation' in AGENTS.md

* docs(AGENTS.md): add Kanban section

Adds a Kanban entry alongside Curator / Cron / Delegation so the major
durable background systems are all represented. Covers the CLI verbs,
the HERMES_KANBAN_TASK-gated worker toolset, the in-gateway dispatcher,
plugin assets, and the board/tenant isolation model. Points at the full
742-line user docs for detail.
Egavasyug pushed a commit to Egavasyug/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request Jun 10, 2026
…rch#20220)

Previously, pinning a skill blocked every skill_manage write action
(edit, patch, delete, write_file, remove_file). The 'hard fence'
design conflated two concerns:

  1. Pin as deletion protection — don't let the curator archive
     or the agent delete a stable skill.
  2. Pin as content freeze — don't let the agent rewrite it mid-conversation.

In practice (1) is what users pin for: they want a skill to survive
curator passes. (2) created friction — agents finding a new pitfall
in a pinned skill had to ask the user to unpin, then the agent
patches, then the user re-pins. The dance discouraged skill
maintenance and pinned skills went stale.

This narrows the _pinned_guard to skill_manage(action='delete') only.
Patches, edits, and supporting-file writes go through on pinned
skills so the agent can keep improving them. The curator's own
pinned-skip behavior (agent/curator.py:271 for auto-archive,
line 349 for the LLM review prompt) is unchanged — curator still
never touches pinned skills.

Changes:
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: remove _pinned_guard calls from
  _edit_skill, _patch_skill, _write_file, _remove_file; keep on
  _delete_skill. Updated _pinned_guard docstring and error message.
- tools/skill_manager_tool.py: updated skill_manage model-facing tool
  description to reflect the new semantic.
- website/docs/user-guide/features/curator.md: updated pinning
  section.
- tests/tools/test_skill_manager_tool.py: flipped refuses-pinned
  tests for edit/patch/write_file/remove_file into allowed-when-pinned;
  kept test_delete_refuses_pinned (strengthened assertion to check the
  'cannot be deleted' wording).

Closes NousResearch#18354
Egavasyug pushed a commit to Egavasyug/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request Jun 10, 2026
NousResearch#20226)

* docs(AGENTS.md): add curator/cron/delegation/toolsets, fix plugin tree, frontmatter, auto-discovery caveat

Closes NousResearch#19101 and NousResearch#19107 (@pty819).

Verified 16 claims from those two issues against current main. 12 were
real gaps; 2 were generated/hallucinated (NousResearch#10 unverified --now flag is
actually real and already cited in AGENTS.md; NousResearch#11 stale PR refs NousResearch#5587
and NousResearch#4950 do not appear in AGENTS.md at all); 2 were low-prio nits
(memory provider hierarchy, --now scope enumeration) deferred.

Changes:
- Project tree: add yuanbao to platforms comment; expand plugins/
  subtree with real directory names (kanban, hermes-achievements,
  observability, image_gen) instead of vague '<others>'.
- Test-count blurb: 15k/700 Apr → 17k/900 May (verified: 17,375 test
  defs, 915 files).
- Adding New Tools: clarify that auto-discovery wires up schemas but
  the tool only reaches an agent if its name is added to a toolset in
  toolsets.py. _HERMES_CORE_TOOLS is not dead code.
- Adding Configuration: enumerate top-level config.yaml sections
  including auxiliary and curator; note auxiliary is per-task
  overrides for side-LLM work.
- SKILL.md frontmatter: add author, license, related_skills. Note
  top-level tags/category are mirrored from metadata.hermes.*.
- New section 'Toolsets' — enumerates the 30 current TOOLSETS keys
  (including yuanbao, kanban, moa, spotify, safe, debugging).
- New section 'Delegation (delegate_task)' — sync semantics, batch
  mode, leaf vs orchestrator roles, config knobs, durability caveat.
- New section 'Curator (skill lifecycle)' — core files, 11 CLI verbs,
  telemetry sidecar, invariants (pin/delete split after PR NousResearch#20220,
  bundled/hub off-limits), curator.* config section.
- New section 'Cron (scheduled jobs)' — 4 schedule formats, 7 CLI
  verbs, per-job fields, 3-min hard interrupt, catchup/grace windows,
  tick.lock, cron→session isolation.

Skipped (invalid claims):
- NousResearch#19107 item 10: --now is real (hermes_cli/skills_hub.py:624/966/1013/1470)
- NousResearch#19107 item 11: no 'NousResearch#5587' or 'NousResearch#4950' or 'async_delegation' in AGENTS.md

* docs(AGENTS.md): add Kanban section

Adds a Kanban entry alongside Curator / Cron / Delegation so the major
durable background systems are all represented. Covers the CLI verbs,
the HERMES_KANBAN_TASK-gated worker toolset, the in-gateway dispatcher,
plugin assets, and the board/tenant isolation model. Points at the full
742-line user docs for detail.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

P3 Low — cosmetic, nice to have tool/skills Skills system (list, view, manage) type/feature New feature or request

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Pin should protect against deletion, not prevent edits

2 participants