Skip to content

ci: split Tests workflow into 4 parallel shards (target <2min total)#11566

Closed
teknium1 wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
fix/test-reduction-batch-2
Closed

ci: split Tests workflow into 4 parallel shards (target <2min total)#11566
teknium1 wants to merge 1 commit into
mainfrom
fix/test-reduction-batch-2

Conversation

@teknium1

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Summary

Splits the main Tests workflow into 4 parallel matrix jobs via pytest-split. Each shard runs ~3,000 tests in parallel instead of one job running all 12,098.

Expected impact: CI wall time drops from ~4min to ~90-115s total. Hits the <2min target Teknium asked for.

Why this approach

Per-platform test dedup turned out to be a dead end \u2014 each platform's SDK is too different (slack-bolt / python-telegram-bot / mautrix / discord.py / Baileys JS bridge). Tests look similar in shape but use incompatible mock setups.

The biggest lever for <2min is CI parallelism, not test deletion. Matrix split gives us ~4x parallelism for free:

  • Each matrix job gets its own ubuntu-latest runner (4 cores)
  • pytest-split divides tests deterministically by hash
  • Inside each shard, -n auto (already in pyproject.toml addopts) parallelizes with xdist on the 4 cores
  • Total effective parallelism: 16 workers (4 shards \u00d7 4 xdist workers each) vs 4 today

Changes

  • pyproject.toml: add pytest-split>=0.9,<1 to dev extras
  • .github/workflows/tests.yml: test job becomes matrix-split into 4 shards. Each shard runs pytest --splits 4 --group N
  • fail-fast: false \u2014 all shards finish even if one fails, matching current behavior

Local verification

Ran shard 1 locally on the current main + this change: 37s wall time for 3,025 tests on my 16-core box. On ubuntu-latest with 4 cores, expected ~60-90s per shard. All 4 shards in parallel \u2248 max of slowest \u2248 60-90s.

3 local-only failures during the run (cross-test pollution from other test ordering) \u2014 same pattern as CI-vs-local environmental flakes. CI is the source of truth.

Timing math

Before After
Tests per job 12,098 ~3,025
Wall time per job 243s ~60-90s
Jobs 1 4 (parallel)
Total install + run 270s ~90-115s
Inside-shard parallelism -n auto = 4 -n auto = 4
Total CPU parallelism 4 workers 16 workers

Follow-ups

  • After a couple of runs, we can commit .test_durations from --store-durations for better shard balance (optional; current hash split is already within ~0.1% of equal).
  • Continue the change-detector deletion work in parallel \u2014 each 10% test cut shaves ~10s off the slowest shard.

Reduces CI wall time by running the test suite as 4 parallel matrix
jobs instead of a single job. Each shard runs ~3,000 tests in
parallel, so total wall time drops from ~4min to ~60-90s.

Changes:
- Add pytest-split to dev extras (deterministic test splitting,
  composes with pytest-xdist's -n auto inside each shard).
- Matrix-split tests.yml 'test' job into 4 groups. Each shard runs
  'pytest ... --splits 4 --group N' and parallelizes inside with
  the -n auto already in pyproject.toml's addopts.
- fail-fast: false so all shards finish even if one fails
  (consistent with current behavior when there's no matrix).

Expected CI timing:
  Before: 243s single-job (4m03s)
  After:  ~60-90s per shard in parallel + ~25s install overhead
          \u2192 total CI ~90-115s

No test-file changes. Deterministic hash-based distribution (no
.test_durations file yet; can add one later for better balance).

The e2e job is unchanged — it's already small (20s) and runs
separately.
@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

⚠️ Supply Chain Risk Detected

This PR contains patterns commonly associated with supply chain attacks. This does not mean the PR is malicious — but these patterns require careful human review before merging.

⚠️ WARNING: CI/CD workflow files modified

Changes to workflow files can alter build pipelines, inject steps, or modify permissions. Verify no unauthorized actions or secrets access were added.

Files:

.github/workflows/tests.yml

⚠️ WARNING: Dependency manifest files modified

Changes to dependency files can introduce new packages or change version pins. Verify all dependency changes are intentional and from trusted sources.

Files:

pyproject.toml

Automated scan triggered by supply-chain-audit. If this is a false positive, a maintainer can approve after manual review.

@teknium1

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Closing — matrix split surfaced pre-existing cross-test pollution that caused shard 3 to hang for 100s+ on GHA. The root cause (local-vs-CI env divergence + orphan processes) needs to be fixed first. Reopening once hermetic test infra lands.

@teknium1 teknium1 closed this Apr 17, 2026
teknium1 added a commit that referenced this pull request Apr 17, 2026
Fixes the recurring 'works locally, fails in CI' (and vice versa) class
of flakes by making tests hermetic and providing a canonical local runner
that matches CI's environment.

## Layer 1 — hermetic conftest.py (tests/conftest.py)

Autouse fixture now unsets every credential-shaped env var before every
test, so developer-local API keys can't leak into tests that assert
'auto-detect provider when key present'.

Pattern: unset any var ending in _API_KEY, _TOKEN, _SECRET, _PASSWORD,
_CREDENTIALS, _ACCESS_KEY, _PRIVATE_KEY, etc. Plus an explicit list of
credential names that don't fit the suffix pattern (AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID,
FAL_KEY, GH_TOKEN, etc.) and all the provider BASE_URL overrides that
change auto-detect behavior.

Also unsets HERMES_* behavioral vars (HERMES_YOLO_MODE, HERMES_QUIET,
HERMES_SESSION_*, etc.) that mutate agent behavior.

Also:
  - Redirects HOME to a per-test tempdir (not just HERMES_HOME), so
    code reading ~/.hermes/* directly can't touch the real dir.
  - Pins TZ=UTC, LANG=C.UTF-8, LC_ALL=C.UTF-8, PYTHONHASHSEED=0 to
    match CI's deterministic runtime.

The old _isolate_hermes_home fixture name is preserved as an alias so
any test that yields it explicitly still works.

## Layer 2 — scripts/run_tests.sh canonical runner

'Always use scripts/run_tests.sh, never call pytest directly' is the
new rule (documented in AGENTS.md). The script:
  - Unsets all credential env vars (belt-and-suspenders for callers
    who bypass conftest — e.g. IDE integrations)
  - Pins TZ/LANG/PYTHONHASHSEED
  - Uses -n 4 xdist workers (matches GHA ubuntu-latest; -n auto on
    a 20-core workstation surfaces test-ordering flakes CI will never
    see, causing the infamous 'passes in CI, fails locally' drift)
  - Finds the venv in .venv, venv, or main checkout's venv
  - Passes through arbitrary pytest args

Installs pytest-split on demand so the script can also be used to run
matrix-split subsets locally for debugging.

## Remove 3 module-level dotenv stubs that broke test isolation

tests/hermes_cli/test_{arcee,xiaomi,api_key}_provider.py each had a
module-level:

    if 'dotenv' not in sys.modules:
        fake_dotenv = types.ModuleType('dotenv')
        fake_dotenv.load_dotenv = lambda *a, **kw: None
        sys.modules['dotenv'] = fake_dotenv

This patches sys.modules['dotenv'] to a fake at import time with no
teardown. Under pytest-xdist LoadScheduling, whichever worker collected
one of these files first poisoned its sys.modules; subsequent tests in
the same worker that imported load_dotenv transitively (e.g.
test_env_loader.py via hermes_cli.env_loader) got the no-op lambda and
saw their assertions fail.

dotenv is a required dependency (python-dotenv>=1.2.1 in pyproject.toml),
so the defensive stub was never needed. Removed.

## Validation

- tests/hermes_cli/ alone: 2178 passed, 1 skipped, 0 failed (was 4
  failures in test_env_loader.py before this fix)
- tests/test_plugin_skills.py, tests/hermes_cli/test_plugins.py,
  tests/test_hermes_logging.py combined: 123 passed (the caplog
  regression tests from PR #11453 still pass)
- Local full run shows no F/E clusters in the 0-55% range that were
  previously present before the conftest hardening

## Background

See AGENTS.md 'Testing' section for the full list of drift sources
this closes. Matrix split (closed as #11566) will be re-attempted
once this foundation lands — cross-test pollution was the root cause
of the shard-3 hang in that PR.
teknium1 added a commit that referenced this pull request Apr 17, 2026
….sh (#11577)

* test: make test env hermetic; enforce CI parity via scripts/run_tests.sh

Fixes the recurring 'works locally, fails in CI' (and vice versa) class
of flakes by making tests hermetic and providing a canonical local runner
that matches CI's environment.

## Layer 1 — hermetic conftest.py (tests/conftest.py)

Autouse fixture now unsets every credential-shaped env var before every
test, so developer-local API keys can't leak into tests that assert
'auto-detect provider when key present'.

Pattern: unset any var ending in _API_KEY, _TOKEN, _SECRET, _PASSWORD,
_CREDENTIALS, _ACCESS_KEY, _PRIVATE_KEY, etc. Plus an explicit list of
credential names that don't fit the suffix pattern (AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID,
FAL_KEY, GH_TOKEN, etc.) and all the provider BASE_URL overrides that
change auto-detect behavior.

Also unsets HERMES_* behavioral vars (HERMES_YOLO_MODE, HERMES_QUIET,
HERMES_SESSION_*, etc.) that mutate agent behavior.

Also:
  - Redirects HOME to a per-test tempdir (not just HERMES_HOME), so
    code reading ~/.hermes/* directly can't touch the real dir.
  - Pins TZ=UTC, LANG=C.UTF-8, LC_ALL=C.UTF-8, PYTHONHASHSEED=0 to
    match CI's deterministic runtime.

The old _isolate_hermes_home fixture name is preserved as an alias so
any test that yields it explicitly still works.

## Layer 2 — scripts/run_tests.sh canonical runner

'Always use scripts/run_tests.sh, never call pytest directly' is the
new rule (documented in AGENTS.md). The script:
  - Unsets all credential env vars (belt-and-suspenders for callers
    who bypass conftest — e.g. IDE integrations)
  - Pins TZ/LANG/PYTHONHASHSEED
  - Uses -n 4 xdist workers (matches GHA ubuntu-latest; -n auto on
    a 20-core workstation surfaces test-ordering flakes CI will never
    see, causing the infamous 'passes in CI, fails locally' drift)
  - Finds the venv in .venv, venv, or main checkout's venv
  - Passes through arbitrary pytest args

Installs pytest-split on demand so the script can also be used to run
matrix-split subsets locally for debugging.

## Remove 3 module-level dotenv stubs that broke test isolation

tests/hermes_cli/test_{arcee,xiaomi,api_key}_provider.py each had a
module-level:

    if 'dotenv' not in sys.modules:
        fake_dotenv = types.ModuleType('dotenv')
        fake_dotenv.load_dotenv = lambda *a, **kw: None
        sys.modules['dotenv'] = fake_dotenv

This patches sys.modules['dotenv'] to a fake at import time with no
teardown. Under pytest-xdist LoadScheduling, whichever worker collected
one of these files first poisoned its sys.modules; subsequent tests in
the same worker that imported load_dotenv transitively (e.g.
test_env_loader.py via hermes_cli.env_loader) got the no-op lambda and
saw their assertions fail.

dotenv is a required dependency (python-dotenv>=1.2.1 in pyproject.toml),
so the defensive stub was never needed. Removed.

## Validation

- tests/hermes_cli/ alone: 2178 passed, 1 skipped, 0 failed (was 4
  failures in test_env_loader.py before this fix)
- tests/test_plugin_skills.py, tests/hermes_cli/test_plugins.py,
  tests/test_hermes_logging.py combined: 123 passed (the caplog
  regression tests from PR #11453 still pass)
- Local full run shows no F/E clusters in the 0-55% range that were
  previously present before the conftest hardening

## Background

See AGENTS.md 'Testing' section for the full list of drift sources
this closes. Matrix split (closed as #11566) will be re-attempted
once this foundation lands — cross-test pollution was the root cause
of the shard-3 hang in that PR.

* fix(conftest): don't redirect HOME — it broke CI subprocesses

PR #11577's autouse fixture was setting HOME to a per-test tempdir.
CI started timing out at 97% complete with dozens of E/F markers and
orphan python processes at cleanup — tests (or transitive deps)
spawn subprocesses that expect a stable HOME, and the redirect broke
them in non-obvious ways.

Env-var unsetting and TZ/LANG/hashseed pinning (the actual CI-drift
fixes) are unchanged and still in place. HERMES_HOME redirection is
also unchanged — that's the canonical way to isolate tests from
~/.hermes/, not HOME.

Any code in the codebase reading ~/.hermes/* via `Path.home() / ".hermes"`
instead of `get_hermes_home()` is a bug to fix at the callsite, not
something to paper over in conftest.
teknium1 added a commit that referenced this pull request Apr 17, 2026
Target: <2min CI test wall time.

Runs the Tests workflow as a 4-way matrix instead of one job. Each
shard runs ~3,000 tests on its own ubuntu-latest runner (4 cores) with
-n auto xdist inside. Total effective parallelism: 16 workers across
4 machines (vs 4 workers on 1 machine today).

Was previously tried in #11566 and closed — shard 3 hung at 97% complete
for 100+ seconds with dozens of E/F markers. Root cause was cross-test
pollution exposed by splitting test files across shards (e.g. the three
test files that mutated sys.modules['dotenv'] at import time poisoned
whichever shard they landed in). That's now fixed by #11453 and #11577:
conftest is hermetic, the dotenv stub bombs are removed, and tests no
longer depend on each other's env-var side effects.

Changes:
- pyproject.toml: add pytest-split>=0.9,<1 to dev extras
- .github/workflows/tests.yml: 'test' job becomes matrix-split into 4
  groups with fail-fast: false. Runs 'pytest --splits 4 --group N'.
  pytest-split composes with -n auto from pyproject addopts.

e2e job is unchanged (already small, 20s).

Expected timing:
  Before: ~4m total (243s test step + ~25s setup)
  After:  ~90-115s total (shard wall time ~60-90s + ~25s setup)

Hash-based split is deterministic; no .test_durations file needed yet.
Can add one later via --store-durations for better shard balance.
teknium1 added a commit that referenced this pull request Apr 17, 2026
Target: <2min CI test wall time.

Runs the Tests workflow as a 4-way matrix instead of one job. Each
shard runs ~3,000 tests on its own ubuntu-latest runner (4 cores) with
-n auto xdist inside. Total effective parallelism: 16 workers across
4 machines (vs 4 workers on 1 machine today).

Was previously tried in #11566 and closed — shard 3 hung at 97% complete
for 100+ seconds with dozens of E/F markers. Root cause was cross-test
pollution exposed by splitting test files across shards (e.g. the three
test files that mutated sys.modules['dotenv'] at import time poisoned
whichever shard they landed in). That's now fixed by #11453 and #11577:
conftest is hermetic, the dotenv stub bombs are removed, and tests no
longer depend on each other's env-var side effects.

Changes:
- pyproject.toml: add pytest-split>=0.9,<1 to dev extras
- .github/workflows/tests.yml: 'test' job becomes matrix-split into 4
  groups with fail-fast: false. Runs 'pytest --splits 4 --group N'.
  pytest-split composes with -n auto from pyproject addopts.

e2e job is unchanged (already small, 20s).

Expected timing:
  Before: ~4m total (243s test step + ~25s setup)
  After:  ~90-115s total (shard wall time ~60-90s + ~25s setup)

Hash-based split is deterministic; no .test_durations file needed yet.
Can add one later via --store-durations for better shard balance.
ulasbilgen pushed a commit to ulasbilgen/hermes-adhd-agent that referenced this pull request May 1, 2026
….sh (NousResearch#11577)

* test: make test env hermetic; enforce CI parity via scripts/run_tests.sh

Fixes the recurring 'works locally, fails in CI' (and vice versa) class
of flakes by making tests hermetic and providing a canonical local runner
that matches CI's environment.

## Layer 1 — hermetic conftest.py (tests/conftest.py)

Autouse fixture now unsets every credential-shaped env var before every
test, so developer-local API keys can't leak into tests that assert
'auto-detect provider when key present'.

Pattern: unset any var ending in _API_KEY, _TOKEN, _SECRET, _PASSWORD,
_CREDENTIALS, _ACCESS_KEY, _PRIVATE_KEY, etc. Plus an explicit list of
credential names that don't fit the suffix pattern (AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID,
FAL_KEY, GH_TOKEN, etc.) and all the provider BASE_URL overrides that
change auto-detect behavior.

Also unsets HERMES_* behavioral vars (HERMES_YOLO_MODE, HERMES_QUIET,
HERMES_SESSION_*, etc.) that mutate agent behavior.

Also:
  - Redirects HOME to a per-test tempdir (not just HERMES_HOME), so
    code reading ~/.hermes/* directly can't touch the real dir.
  - Pins TZ=UTC, LANG=C.UTF-8, LC_ALL=C.UTF-8, PYTHONHASHSEED=0 to
    match CI's deterministic runtime.

The old _isolate_hermes_home fixture name is preserved as an alias so
any test that yields it explicitly still works.

## Layer 2 — scripts/run_tests.sh canonical runner

'Always use scripts/run_tests.sh, never call pytest directly' is the
new rule (documented in AGENTS.md). The script:
  - Unsets all credential env vars (belt-and-suspenders for callers
    who bypass conftest — e.g. IDE integrations)
  - Pins TZ/LANG/PYTHONHASHSEED
  - Uses -n 4 xdist workers (matches GHA ubuntu-latest; -n auto on
    a 20-core workstation surfaces test-ordering flakes CI will never
    see, causing the infamous 'passes in CI, fails locally' drift)
  - Finds the venv in .venv, venv, or main checkout's venv
  - Passes through arbitrary pytest args

Installs pytest-split on demand so the script can also be used to run
matrix-split subsets locally for debugging.

## Remove 3 module-level dotenv stubs that broke test isolation

tests/hermes_cli/test_{arcee,xiaomi,api_key}_provider.py each had a
module-level:

    if 'dotenv' not in sys.modules:
        fake_dotenv = types.ModuleType('dotenv')
        fake_dotenv.load_dotenv = lambda *a, **kw: None
        sys.modules['dotenv'] = fake_dotenv

This patches sys.modules['dotenv'] to a fake at import time with no
teardown. Under pytest-xdist LoadScheduling, whichever worker collected
one of these files first poisoned its sys.modules; subsequent tests in
the same worker that imported load_dotenv transitively (e.g.
test_env_loader.py via hermes_cli.env_loader) got the no-op lambda and
saw their assertions fail.

dotenv is a required dependency (python-dotenv>=1.2.1 in pyproject.toml),
so the defensive stub was never needed. Removed.

## Validation

- tests/hermes_cli/ alone: 2178 passed, 1 skipped, 0 failed (was 4
  failures in test_env_loader.py before this fix)
- tests/test_plugin_skills.py, tests/hermes_cli/test_plugins.py,
  tests/test_hermes_logging.py combined: 123 passed (the caplog
  regression tests from PR NousResearch#11453 still pass)
- Local full run shows no F/E clusters in the 0-55% range that were
  previously present before the conftest hardening

## Background

See AGENTS.md 'Testing' section for the full list of drift sources
this closes. Matrix split (closed as NousResearch#11566) will be re-attempted
once this foundation lands — cross-test pollution was the root cause
of the shard-3 hang in that PR.

* fix(conftest): don't redirect HOME — it broke CI subprocesses

PR NousResearch#11577's autouse fixture was setting HOME to a per-test tempdir.
CI started timing out at 97% complete with dozens of E/F markers and
orphan python processes at cleanup — tests (or transitive deps)
spawn subprocesses that expect a stable HOME, and the redirect broke
them in non-obvious ways.

Env-var unsetting and TZ/LANG/hashseed pinning (the actual CI-drift
fixes) are unchanged and still in place. HERMES_HOME redirection is
also unchanged — that's the canonical way to isolate tests from
~/.hermes/, not HOME.

Any code in the codebase reading ~/.hermes/* via `Path.home() / ".hermes"`
instead of `get_hermes_home()` is a bug to fix at the callsite, not
something to paper over in conftest.
aj-nt pushed a commit to aj-nt/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 1, 2026
….sh (NousResearch#11577)

* test: make test env hermetic; enforce CI parity via scripts/run_tests.sh

Fixes the recurring 'works locally, fails in CI' (and vice versa) class
of flakes by making tests hermetic and providing a canonical local runner
that matches CI's environment.

## Layer 1 — hermetic conftest.py (tests/conftest.py)

Autouse fixture now unsets every credential-shaped env var before every
test, so developer-local API keys can't leak into tests that assert
'auto-detect provider when key present'.

Pattern: unset any var ending in _API_KEY, _TOKEN, _SECRET, _PASSWORD,
_CREDENTIALS, _ACCESS_KEY, _PRIVATE_KEY, etc. Plus an explicit list of
credential names that don't fit the suffix pattern (AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID,
FAL_KEY, GH_TOKEN, etc.) and all the provider BASE_URL overrides that
change auto-detect behavior.

Also unsets HERMES_* behavioral vars (HERMES_YOLO_MODE, HERMES_QUIET,
HERMES_SESSION_*, etc.) that mutate agent behavior.

Also:
  - Redirects HOME to a per-test tempdir (not just HERMES_HOME), so
    code reading ~/.hermes/* directly can't touch the real dir.
  - Pins TZ=UTC, LANG=C.UTF-8, LC_ALL=C.UTF-8, PYTHONHASHSEED=0 to
    match CI's deterministic runtime.

The old _isolate_hermes_home fixture name is preserved as an alias so
any test that yields it explicitly still works.

## Layer 2 — scripts/run_tests.sh canonical runner

'Always use scripts/run_tests.sh, never call pytest directly' is the
new rule (documented in AGENTS.md). The script:
  - Unsets all credential env vars (belt-and-suspenders for callers
    who bypass conftest — e.g. IDE integrations)
  - Pins TZ/LANG/PYTHONHASHSEED
  - Uses -n 4 xdist workers (matches GHA ubuntu-latest; -n auto on
    a 20-core workstation surfaces test-ordering flakes CI will never
    see, causing the infamous 'passes in CI, fails locally' drift)
  - Finds the venv in .venv, venv, or main checkout's venv
  - Passes through arbitrary pytest args

Installs pytest-split on demand so the script can also be used to run
matrix-split subsets locally for debugging.

## Remove 3 module-level dotenv stubs that broke test isolation

tests/hermes_cli/test_{arcee,xiaomi,api_key}_provider.py each had a
module-level:

    if 'dotenv' not in sys.modules:
        fake_dotenv = types.ModuleType('dotenv')
        fake_dotenv.load_dotenv = lambda *a, **kw: None
        sys.modules['dotenv'] = fake_dotenv

This patches sys.modules['dotenv'] to a fake at import time with no
teardown. Under pytest-xdist LoadScheduling, whichever worker collected
one of these files first poisoned its sys.modules; subsequent tests in
the same worker that imported load_dotenv transitively (e.g.
test_env_loader.py via hermes_cli.env_loader) got the no-op lambda and
saw their assertions fail.

dotenv is a required dependency (python-dotenv>=1.2.1 in pyproject.toml),
so the defensive stub was never needed. Removed.

## Validation

- tests/hermes_cli/ alone: 2178 passed, 1 skipped, 0 failed (was 4
  failures in test_env_loader.py before this fix)
- tests/test_plugin_skills.py, tests/hermes_cli/test_plugins.py,
  tests/test_hermes_logging.py combined: 123 passed (the caplog
  regression tests from PR NousResearch#11453 still pass)
- Local full run shows no F/E clusters in the 0-55% range that were
  previously present before the conftest hardening

## Background

See AGENTS.md 'Testing' section for the full list of drift sources
this closes. Matrix split (closed as NousResearch#11566) will be re-attempted
once this foundation lands — cross-test pollution was the root cause
of the shard-3 hang in that PR.

* fix(conftest): don't redirect HOME — it broke CI subprocesses

PR NousResearch#11577's autouse fixture was setting HOME to a per-test tempdir.
CI started timing out at 97% complete with dozens of E/F markers and
orphan python processes at cleanup — tests (or transitive deps)
spawn subprocesses that expect a stable HOME, and the redirect broke
them in non-obvious ways.

Env-var unsetting and TZ/LANG/hashseed pinning (the actual CI-drift
fixes) are unchanged and still in place. HERMES_HOME redirection is
also unchanged — that's the canonical way to isolate tests from
~/.hermes/, not HOME.

Any code in the codebase reading ~/.hermes/* via `Path.home() / ".hermes"`
instead of `get_hermes_home()` is a bug to fix at the callsite, not
something to paper over in conftest.
02356abc pushed a commit to 02356abc/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request May 14, 2026
….sh (NousResearch#11577)

* test: make test env hermetic; enforce CI parity via scripts/run_tests.sh

Fixes the recurring 'works locally, fails in CI' (and vice versa) class
of flakes by making tests hermetic and providing a canonical local runner
that matches CI's environment.

## Layer 1 — hermetic conftest.py (tests/conftest.py)

Autouse fixture now unsets every credential-shaped env var before every
test, so developer-local API keys can't leak into tests that assert
'auto-detect provider when key present'.

Pattern: unset any var ending in _API_KEY, _TOKEN, _SECRET, _PASSWORD,
_CREDENTIALS, _ACCESS_KEY, _PRIVATE_KEY, etc. Plus an explicit list of
credential names that don't fit the suffix pattern (AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID,
FAL_KEY, GH_TOKEN, etc.) and all the provider BASE_URL overrides that
change auto-detect behavior.

Also unsets HERMES_* behavioral vars (HERMES_YOLO_MODE, HERMES_QUIET,
HERMES_SESSION_*, etc.) that mutate agent behavior.

Also:
  - Redirects HOME to a per-test tempdir (not just HERMES_HOME), so
    code reading ~/.hermes/* directly can't touch the real dir.
  - Pins TZ=UTC, LANG=C.UTF-8, LC_ALL=C.UTF-8, PYTHONHASHSEED=0 to
    match CI's deterministic runtime.

The old _isolate_hermes_home fixture name is preserved as an alias so
any test that yields it explicitly still works.

## Layer 2 — scripts/run_tests.sh canonical runner

'Always use scripts/run_tests.sh, never call pytest directly' is the
new rule (documented in AGENTS.md). The script:
  - Unsets all credential env vars (belt-and-suspenders for callers
    who bypass conftest — e.g. IDE integrations)
  - Pins TZ/LANG/PYTHONHASHSEED
  - Uses -n 4 xdist workers (matches GHA ubuntu-latest; -n auto on
    a 20-core workstation surfaces test-ordering flakes CI will never
    see, causing the infamous 'passes in CI, fails locally' drift)
  - Finds the venv in .venv, venv, or main checkout's venv
  - Passes through arbitrary pytest args

Installs pytest-split on demand so the script can also be used to run
matrix-split subsets locally for debugging.

## Remove 3 module-level dotenv stubs that broke test isolation

tests/hermes_cli/test_{arcee,xiaomi,api_key}_provider.py each had a
module-level:

    if 'dotenv' not in sys.modules:
        fake_dotenv = types.ModuleType('dotenv')
        fake_dotenv.load_dotenv = lambda *a, **kw: None
        sys.modules['dotenv'] = fake_dotenv

This patches sys.modules['dotenv'] to a fake at import time with no
teardown. Under pytest-xdist LoadScheduling, whichever worker collected
one of these files first poisoned its sys.modules; subsequent tests in
the same worker that imported load_dotenv transitively (e.g.
test_env_loader.py via hermes_cli.env_loader) got the no-op lambda and
saw their assertions fail.

dotenv is a required dependency (python-dotenv>=1.2.1 in pyproject.toml),
so the defensive stub was never needed. Removed.

## Validation

- tests/hermes_cli/ alone: 2178 passed, 1 skipped, 0 failed (was 4
  failures in test_env_loader.py before this fix)
- tests/test_plugin_skills.py, tests/hermes_cli/test_plugins.py,
  tests/test_hermes_logging.py combined: 123 passed (the caplog
  regression tests from PR NousResearch#11453 still pass)
- Local full run shows no F/E clusters in the 0-55% range that were
  previously present before the conftest hardening

## Background

See AGENTS.md 'Testing' section for the full list of drift sources
this closes. Matrix split (closed as NousResearch#11566) will be re-attempted
once this foundation lands — cross-test pollution was the root cause
of the shard-3 hang in that PR.

* fix(conftest): don't redirect HOME — it broke CI subprocesses

PR NousResearch#11577's autouse fixture was setting HOME to a per-test tempdir.
CI started timing out at 97% complete with dozens of E/F markers and
orphan python processes at cleanup — tests (or transitive deps)
spawn subprocesses that expect a stable HOME, and the redirect broke
them in non-obvious ways.

Env-var unsetting and TZ/LANG/hashseed pinning (the actual CI-drift
fixes) are unchanged and still in place. HERMES_HOME redirection is
also unchanged — that's the canonical way to isolate tests from
~/.hermes/, not HOME.

Any code in the codebase reading ~/.hermes/* via `Path.home() / ".hermes"`
instead of `get_hermes_home()` is a bug to fix at the callsite, not
something to paper over in conftest.
gweeteve pushed a commit to gweeteve/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request Jun 2, 2026
….sh (NousResearch#11577)

* test: make test env hermetic; enforce CI parity via scripts/run_tests.sh

Fixes the recurring 'works locally, fails in CI' (and vice versa) class
of flakes by making tests hermetic and providing a canonical local runner
that matches CI's environment.

## Layer 1 — hermetic conftest.py (tests/conftest.py)

Autouse fixture now unsets every credential-shaped env var before every
test, so developer-local API keys can't leak into tests that assert
'auto-detect provider when key present'.

Pattern: unset any var ending in _API_KEY, _TOKEN, _SECRET, _PASSWORD,
_CREDENTIALS, _ACCESS_KEY, _PRIVATE_KEY, etc. Plus an explicit list of
credential names that don't fit the suffix pattern (AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID,
FAL_KEY, GH_TOKEN, etc.) and all the provider BASE_URL overrides that
change auto-detect behavior.

Also unsets HERMES_* behavioral vars (HERMES_YOLO_MODE, HERMES_QUIET,
HERMES_SESSION_*, etc.) that mutate agent behavior.

Also:
  - Redirects HOME to a per-test tempdir (not just HERMES_HOME), so
    code reading ~/.hermes/* directly can't touch the real dir.
  - Pins TZ=UTC, LANG=C.UTF-8, LC_ALL=C.UTF-8, PYTHONHASHSEED=0 to
    match CI's deterministic runtime.

The old _isolate_hermes_home fixture name is preserved as an alias so
any test that yields it explicitly still works.

## Layer 2 — scripts/run_tests.sh canonical runner

'Always use scripts/run_tests.sh, never call pytest directly' is the
new rule (documented in AGENTS.md). The script:
  - Unsets all credential env vars (belt-and-suspenders for callers
    who bypass conftest — e.g. IDE integrations)
  - Pins TZ/LANG/PYTHONHASHSEED
  - Uses -n 4 xdist workers (matches GHA ubuntu-latest; -n auto on
    a 20-core workstation surfaces test-ordering flakes CI will never
    see, causing the infamous 'passes in CI, fails locally' drift)
  - Finds the venv in .venv, venv, or main checkout's venv
  - Passes through arbitrary pytest args

Installs pytest-split on demand so the script can also be used to run
matrix-split subsets locally for debugging.

## Remove 3 module-level dotenv stubs that broke test isolation

tests/hermes_cli/test_{arcee,xiaomi,api_key}_provider.py each had a
module-level:

    if 'dotenv' not in sys.modules:
        fake_dotenv = types.ModuleType('dotenv')
        fake_dotenv.load_dotenv = lambda *a, **kw: None
        sys.modules['dotenv'] = fake_dotenv

This patches sys.modules['dotenv'] to a fake at import time with no
teardown. Under pytest-xdist LoadScheduling, whichever worker collected
one of these files first poisoned its sys.modules; subsequent tests in
the same worker that imported load_dotenv transitively (e.g.
test_env_loader.py via hermes_cli.env_loader) got the no-op lambda and
saw their assertions fail.

dotenv is a required dependency (python-dotenv>=1.2.1 in pyproject.toml),
so the defensive stub was never needed. Removed.

## Validation

- tests/hermes_cli/ alone: 2178 passed, 1 skipped, 0 failed (was 4
  failures in test_env_loader.py before this fix)
- tests/test_plugin_skills.py, tests/hermes_cli/test_plugins.py,
  tests/test_hermes_logging.py combined: 123 passed (the caplog
  regression tests from PR NousResearch#11453 still pass)
- Local full run shows no F/E clusters in the 0-55% range that were
  previously present before the conftest hardening

## Background

See AGENTS.md 'Testing' section for the full list of drift sources
this closes. Matrix split (closed as NousResearch#11566) will be re-attempted
once this foundation lands — cross-test pollution was the root cause
of the shard-3 hang in that PR.

* fix(conftest): don't redirect HOME — it broke CI subprocesses

PR NousResearch#11577's autouse fixture was setting HOME to a per-test tempdir.
CI started timing out at 97% complete with dozens of E/F markers and
orphan python processes at cleanup — tests (or transitive deps)
spawn subprocesses that expect a stable HOME, and the redirect broke
them in non-obvious ways.

Env-var unsetting and TZ/LANG/hashseed pinning (the actual CI-drift
fixes) are unchanged and still in place. HERMES_HOME redirection is
also unchanged — that's the canonical way to isolate tests from
~/.hermes/, not HOME.

Any code in the codebase reading ~/.hermes/* via `Path.home() / ".hermes"`
instead of `get_hermes_home()` is a bug to fix at the callsite, not
something to paper over in conftest.
Egavasyug pushed a commit to Egavasyug/hermes-agent that referenced this pull request Jun 10, 2026
….sh (NousResearch#11577)

* test: make test env hermetic; enforce CI parity via scripts/run_tests.sh

Fixes the recurring 'works locally, fails in CI' (and vice versa) class
of flakes by making tests hermetic and providing a canonical local runner
that matches CI's environment.

## Layer 1 — hermetic conftest.py (tests/conftest.py)

Autouse fixture now unsets every credential-shaped env var before every
test, so developer-local API keys can't leak into tests that assert
'auto-detect provider when key present'.

Pattern: unset any var ending in _API_KEY, _TOKEN, _SECRET, _PASSWORD,
_CREDENTIALS, _ACCESS_KEY, _PRIVATE_KEY, etc. Plus an explicit list of
credential names that don't fit the suffix pattern (AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID,
FAL_KEY, GH_TOKEN, etc.) and all the provider BASE_URL overrides that
change auto-detect behavior.

Also unsets HERMES_* behavioral vars (HERMES_YOLO_MODE, HERMES_QUIET,
HERMES_SESSION_*, etc.) that mutate agent behavior.

Also:
  - Redirects HOME to a per-test tempdir (not just HERMES_HOME), so
    code reading ~/.hermes/* directly can't touch the real dir.
  - Pins TZ=UTC, LANG=C.UTF-8, LC_ALL=C.UTF-8, PYTHONHASHSEED=0 to
    match CI's deterministic runtime.

The old _isolate_hermes_home fixture name is preserved as an alias so
any test that yields it explicitly still works.

## Layer 2 — scripts/run_tests.sh canonical runner

'Always use scripts/run_tests.sh, never call pytest directly' is the
new rule (documented in AGENTS.md). The script:
  - Unsets all credential env vars (belt-and-suspenders for callers
    who bypass conftest — e.g. IDE integrations)
  - Pins TZ/LANG/PYTHONHASHSEED
  - Uses -n 4 xdist workers (matches GHA ubuntu-latest; -n auto on
    a 20-core workstation surfaces test-ordering flakes CI will never
    see, causing the infamous 'passes in CI, fails locally' drift)
  - Finds the venv in .venv, venv, or main checkout's venv
  - Passes through arbitrary pytest args

Installs pytest-split on demand so the script can also be used to run
matrix-split subsets locally for debugging.

## Remove 3 module-level dotenv stubs that broke test isolation

tests/hermes_cli/test_{arcee,xiaomi,api_key}_provider.py each had a
module-level:

    if 'dotenv' not in sys.modules:
        fake_dotenv = types.ModuleType('dotenv')
        fake_dotenv.load_dotenv = lambda *a, **kw: None
        sys.modules['dotenv'] = fake_dotenv

This patches sys.modules['dotenv'] to a fake at import time with no
teardown. Under pytest-xdist LoadScheduling, whichever worker collected
one of these files first poisoned its sys.modules; subsequent tests in
the same worker that imported load_dotenv transitively (e.g.
test_env_loader.py via hermes_cli.env_loader) got the no-op lambda and
saw their assertions fail.

dotenv is a required dependency (python-dotenv>=1.2.1 in pyproject.toml),
so the defensive stub was never needed. Removed.

## Validation

- tests/hermes_cli/ alone: 2178 passed, 1 skipped, 0 failed (was 4
  failures in test_env_loader.py before this fix)
- tests/test_plugin_skills.py, tests/hermes_cli/test_plugins.py,
  tests/test_hermes_logging.py combined: 123 passed (the caplog
  regression tests from PR NousResearch#11453 still pass)
- Local full run shows no F/E clusters in the 0-55% range that were
  previously present before the conftest hardening

## Background

See AGENTS.md 'Testing' section for the full list of drift sources
this closes. Matrix split (closed as NousResearch#11566) will be re-attempted
once this foundation lands — cross-test pollution was the root cause
of the shard-3 hang in that PR.

* fix(conftest): don't redirect HOME — it broke CI subprocesses

PR NousResearch#11577's autouse fixture was setting HOME to a per-test tempdir.
CI started timing out at 97% complete with dozens of E/F markers and
orphan python processes at cleanup — tests (or transitive deps)
spawn subprocesses that expect a stable HOME, and the redirect broke
them in non-obvious ways.

Env-var unsetting and TZ/LANG/hashseed pinning (the actual CI-drift
fixes) are unchanged and still in place. HERMES_HOME redirection is
also unchanged — that's the canonical way to isolate tests from
~/.hermes/, not HOME.

Any code in the codebase reading ~/.hermes/* via `Path.home() / ".hermes"`
instead of `get_hermes_home()` is a bug to fix at the callsite, not
something to paper over in conftest.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant