Conversation
As discussed in [1], the implicit creation of bindings through the setglobal! intrinsic was accidentally added in 1.9 unintentionally and will be removed (ideally) or at the very least deprecated in 1.11. The recommended replacement syntax is `Core.eval(mod, Expr(:global, sym))` to introduce the binding and `invokelatest(setglobal!, mod, sym, val)` to set it. The invokelatest is not presently required, but may be required for JuliaLang/julia#54654, so it's included in the recommendation. [1] JuliaLang/julia#54607
Member
Author
|
Also needs a 1.11 backport. |
Keno
added a commit
to JuliaLang/julia
that referenced
this pull request
Jun 5, 2024
PR #44231 (part of Julia 1.9) introduced the ability to modify globals with `Mod.sym = val` syntax. However, the intention of this syntax was always to modify *existing* globals in other modules. Unfortunately, as implemented, it also implicitly creates new bindings in the other module, even if the binding was not previously declared. This was not intended, but it's a bit of a syntax corner case, so nobody caught it at the time. After some extensive discussions and taking into account the near future direction we want to go with bindings (#54654 for both), the consensus was reached that we should try to undo the implicit creation of bindings (but not the ability to assign the *value* of globals in other modules). Note that this was always an error until Julia 1.9, so hopefully it hasn't crept into too many packages yet. We'll see what pkgeval says. If use is extensive, we may want to consider a softer removal strategy. Across base and stdlib, there's two cases affected by this change: 1. A left over debug statement in `precompile` that wanted to assign a new variable in Base for debugging. Removed in this PR. 2. Distributed wanting to create new bindings. This is a legimitate use case for wanting to create bindings in other modules. This is fixed in JuliaLang/Distributed.jl#102. As noted in that PR, the recommended replacement where implicit binding creation is desired is: ``` Core.eval(mod, Expr(:global, sym)) invokelatest(setglobal!, mod, sym, val) ``` The `invokelatest` is not presently required, but may be needed by #54654, so it's included in the recommendation now. Fixes #54607
vtjnash
reviewed
Jun 5, 2024
Member
vtjnash
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
SGTM. It feels a little premature to say that invokelatest will definitely work in exactly this way, but seems generally plausible
Member
|
For my own reference pre-1.9 this was a direct ccall JuliaLang/julia#44753 |
Member
Author
That's why I said |
vtjnash
approved these changes
Jun 5, 2024
Keno
added a commit
to JuliaLang/julia
that referenced
this pull request
Jun 5, 2024
PR #44231 (part of Julia 1.9) introduced the ability to modify globals with `Mod.sym = val` syntax. However, the intention of this syntax was always to modify *existing* globals in other modules. Unfortunately, as implemented, it also implicitly creates new bindings in the other module, even if the binding was not previously declared. This was not intended, but it's a bit of a syntax corner case, so nobody caught it at the time. After some extensive discussions and taking into account the near future direction we want to go with bindings (#54654 for both), the consensus was reached that we should try to undo the implicit creation of bindings (but not the ability to assign the *value* of globals in other modules). Note that this was always an error until Julia 1.9, so hopefully it hasn't crept into too many packages yet. We'll see what pkgeval says. If use is extensive, we may want to consider a softer removal strategy. Across base and stdlib, there's two cases affected by this change: 1. A left over debug statement in `precompile` that wanted to assign a new variable in Base for debugging. Removed in this PR. 2. Distributed wanting to create new bindings. This is a legimitate use case for wanting to create bindings in other modules. This is fixed in JuliaLang/Distributed.jl#102. As noted in that PR, the recommended replacement where implicit binding creation is desired is: ``` Core.eval(mod, Expr(:global, sym)) invokelatest(setglobal!, mod, sym, val) ``` The `invokelatest` is not presently required, but may be needed by #54654, so it's included in the recommendation now. Fixes #54607
Keno
added a commit
to JuliaLang/julia
that referenced
this pull request
Jun 5, 2024
PR #44231 (part of Julia 1.9) introduced the ability to modify globals with `Mod.sym = val` syntax. However, the intention of this syntax was always to modify *existing* globals in other modules. Unfortunately, as implemented, it also implicitly creates new bindings in the other module, even if the binding was not previously declared. This was not intended, but it's a bit of a syntax corner case, so nobody caught it at the time. After some extensive discussions and taking into account the near future direction we want to go with bindings (#54654 for both), the consensus was reached that we should try to undo the implicit creation of bindings (but not the ability to assign the *value* of globals in other modules). Note that this was always an error until Julia 1.9, so hopefully it hasn't crept into too many packages yet. We'll see what pkgeval says. If use is extensive, we may want to consider a softer removal strategy. Across base and stdlib, there's two cases affected by this change: 1. A left over debug statement in `precompile` that wanted to assign a new variable in Base for debugging. Removed in this PR. 2. Distributed wanting to create new bindings. This is a legimitate use case for wanting to create bindings in other modules. This is fixed in JuliaLang/Distributed.jl#102. As noted in that PR, the recommended replacement where implicit binding creation is desired is: ``` Core.eval(mod, Expr(:global, sym)) invokelatest(setglobal!, mod, sym, val) ``` The `invokelatest` is not presently required, but may be needed by #54654, so it's included in the recommendation now. Fixes #54607
Keno
added a commit
to JuliaLang/julia
that referenced
this pull request
Jun 8, 2024
PR #44231 (part of Julia 1.9) introduced the ability to modify globals with `Mod.sym = val` syntax. However, the intention of this syntax was always to modify *existing* globals in other modules. Unfortunately, as implemented, it also implicitly creates new bindings in the other module, even if the binding was not previously declared. This was not intended, but it's a bit of a syntax corner case, so nobody caught it at the time. After some extensive discussions and taking into account the near future direction we want to go with bindings (#54654 for both), the consensus was reached that we should try to undo the implicit creation of bindings (but not the ability to assign the *value* of globals in other modules). Note that this was always an error until Julia 1.9, so hopefully it hasn't crept into too many packages yet. We'll see what pkgeval says. If use is extensive, we may want to consider a softer removal strategy. Across base and stdlib, there's two cases affected by this change: 1. A left over debug statement in `precompile` that wanted to assign a new variable in Base for debugging. Removed in this PR. 2. Distributed wanting to create new bindings. This is a legimitate use case for wanting to create bindings in other modules. This is fixed in JuliaLang/Distributed.jl#102. As noted in that PR, the recommended replacement where implicit binding creation is desired is: ``` Core.eval(mod, Expr(:global, sym)) invokelatest(setglobal!, mod, sym, val) ``` The `invokelatest` is not presently required, but may be needed by #54654, so it's included in the recommendation now. Fixes #54607
Keno
added a commit
to JuliaLang/julia
that referenced
this pull request
Jun 8, 2024
PR #44231 (part of Julia 1.9) introduced the ability to modify globals with `Mod.sym = val` syntax. However, the intention of this syntax was always to modify *existing* globals in other modules. Unfortunately, as implemented, it also implicitly creates new bindings in the other module, even if the binding was not previously declared. This was not intended, but it's a bit of a syntax corner case, so nobody caught it at the time. After some extensive discussions and taking into account the near future direction we want to go with bindings (#54654 for both), the consensus was reached that we should try to undo the implicit creation of bindings (but not the ability to assign the *value* of globals in other modules). Note that this was always an error until Julia 1.9, so hopefully it hasn't crept into too many packages yet. We'll see what pkgeval says. If use is extensive, we may want to consider a softer removal strategy. Across base and stdlib, there's two cases affected by this change: 1. A left over debug statement in `precompile` that wanted to assign a new variable in Base for debugging. Removed in this PR. 2. Distributed wanting to create new bindings. This is a legimitate use case for wanting to create bindings in other modules. This is fixed in JuliaLang/Distributed.jl#102. As noted in that PR, the recommended replacement where implicit binding creation is desired is: ``` Core.eval(mod, Expr(:global, sym)) invokelatest(setglobal!, mod, sym, val) ``` The `invokelatest` is not presently required, but may be needed by #54654, so it's included in the recommendation now. Fixes #54607
KristofferC
pushed a commit
to JuliaLang/julia
that referenced
this pull request
Jun 13, 2024
PR #44231 (part of Julia 1.9) introduced the ability to modify globals with `Mod.sym = val` syntax. However, the intention of this syntax was always to modify *existing* globals in other modules. Unfortunately, as implemented, it also implicitly creates new bindings in the other module, even if the binding was not previously declared. This was not intended, but it's a bit of a syntax corner case, so nobody caught it at the time. After some extensive discussions and taking into account the near future direction we want to go with bindings (#54654 for both), the consensus was reached that we should try to undo the implicit creation of bindings (but not the ability to assign the *value* of globals in other modules). Note that this was always an error until Julia 1.9, so hopefully it hasn't crept into too many packages yet. We'll see what pkgeval says. If use is extensive, we may want to consider a softer removal strategy. Across base and stdlib, there's two cases affected by this change: 1. A left over debug statement in `precompile` that wanted to assign a new variable in Base for debugging. Removed in this PR. 2. Distributed wanting to create new bindings. This is a legimitate use case for wanting to create bindings in other modules. This is fixed in JuliaLang/Distributed.jl#102. As noted in that PR, the recommended replacement where implicit binding creation is desired is: ``` Core.eval(mod, Expr(:global, sym)) invokelatest(setglobal!, mod, sym, val) ``` The `invokelatest` is not presently required, but may be needed by #54654, so it's included in the recommendation now. Fixes #54607 (cherry picked from commit b7e7232)
63 tasks
64 tasks
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
As discussed in [1], the implicit creation of bindings through the setglobal! intrinsic was accidentally added in 1.9 unintentionally and will be removed (ideally) or at the very least deprecated in 1.11.
The recommended replacement syntax is
Core.eval(mod, Expr(:global, sym))to introduce the binding andinvokelatest(setglobal!, mod, sym, val)to set it. The invokelatest is not presently required, but may be required for JuliaLang/julia#54654, so it's included in the recommendation.[1] JuliaLang/julia#54607