Skip to content

feat: cross-provider uncertainty check for hallucination detection at approval gates #701

@Aureliolo

Description

@Aureliolo

Context

MIT research proposes a combined epistemic + aleatoric uncertainty metric (TU) that cross-references responses across multiple LLM providers to flag hallucinations more reliably than self-consistency alone.

Why This Matters

SynthOrg already abstracts multiple LLM providers via BaseCompletionProvider. A lightweight cross-provider consistency check at approval gates is architecturally feasible. This augments progressive trust and the LLM fallback evaluator with a concrete hallucination signal.

Action Items

  • Design cross-provider consistency check: same prompt to 2+ providers, measure agreement
  • Integrate as optional signal in approval gate logic (high disagreement = flag for human review)
  • Evaluate cost trade-off: extra provider call vs hallucination prevention value
  • Cross-reference with Rozum AI verification pattern (76.2% unsupported claims flagged)

References


Additional Research (2026-03-26)

Multi-Model Verification Data

Source: Rozum AI (2026-03-22)

Concrete validation of the cross-provider approach: Rozum AI's multi-model verification layer flagged unsupported claims in 76.2% of outputs. This demonstrates that cross-model disagreement is a strong signal for hallucination detection.

Two-Stage Classifier (related)

See #847 for a complementary approach: Anthropic's two-stage safety classifier with information stripping. The cross-provider uncertainty check (#701) and the two-stage classifier (#847) can work in tandem -- #701 for content verification, #847 for action authorization.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    prio:highImportant, should be prioritizedscope:medium1-3 days of workspec:providersDESIGN_SPEC Section 9 - Model Provider Layerspec:securityDESIGN_SPEC Section 12 - Security & Approval Systemtype:featureNew feature implementationv0.7Minor version v0.7v0.7.1Patch release v0.7.1

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions