Skip to content

The Plastic Cow

April 25, 2012

Film maker Kunal Vohra has just released The Plastic Cow, a 34-minute documentary about the widespread problem of cows consuming municipal solid waste, especially plastic, in India. The film was produced by The Karuna Society for Animals and Nature.

I regret that because of my workload I don’t have time to write an endorsement that adequately expresses my enthusiasm for The Plastic Cow. It is an outstanding and important documentary.

I post the link to it here and encourage everyone to view it.

 

My Paper on Privatisation, A Printer-Friendly Version

June 23, 2011

Due to some oversaturated images in the first edition of Privatisation: A Formula for Provision or Perversion of Municipal Solid Waste Management? That edition displayed well on computer screens, but didn’t print well. I’ve created a second edition, with images that print better.

The new edition can be downloaded here: Privatisation: Provision or Perversion of MSWM?

Privatisation: A Formula for Provision or Perversion of Municipal Solid Waste Management?

Privatisation: A Formula for Provision or Perversion of Municipal Solid Waste Management?

Young Woman Salvaging Recyclable Materials in Karuvadikuppam Dump, Pondicherry

June 18, 2011

Wanted to share this photo of Vanilla, a young woman who salvages recyclable waste materials in Karuvadikuppam dumpyard, Pondicherry.

Vanilla collecting recyclable material in Karuvadikuppam, Pondicherry

Vanilla collecting recyclable material in Karuvadikuppam, Pondicherry

Publication Announcement — Privatisation: A Formula for Provision or Perversion of Municipal Solid Waste Management?

June 17, 2011

Yesterday, I completed production of Privatisation: A Formula for Provision or Perversion of Municipal Solid Waste Management?

Privatisation: A Forumla for Provision or Perversion of Municipal Solid Waste Management?

Privatisation: A Forumla for Provision or Perversion of Municipal Solid Waste Management?

The booklet can also be downloaded here:

Privatisation of MSWM

A modified version, in which the photographs are more suitable for printing, can be downloaded here: Privatisation paper (print version)

The booklet reviews the history and performance of privatised municipal services, in order to assess the likelihood that privatisation will mitigate India’s solid waste crisis.

I am extremely grateful to people who sent me papers, exchanged thoughts or commented on drafts during the production of this report, particularly: Moshe Adler, Gerald Anderson, Kate Bayliss, Jaap Broekema, Emanuele Lobina, Suneel Pandey, Rosie Sanderson, Priya Sangameswaran, Elliott Sclar, Ravi Srivastava and David Van Slyke.

Reproduction and circulation of this booklet are encouraged.

Puducherry Municipal Services Private Limited (PMSPL): An Organized Criminal Racket?

June 6, 2011

Is there any better way to describe Puducherry Municipal Services Private Limted than, “an organized criminal racket”? What better describes the impunity with which PMSPL violates the Indian government’s municipal solid waste management rules?  Six months into their contract with Puducherry Municipality, PMSPL is still collecting, hauling and dumping mixed municipal solid waste, in violation of regulations that mandate segregation of biodegradable and non-biodegradable waste, composting and recycling, and restrict landfilling to inert materials.

Rather than taking steps to minimize landfilling, PMSPL dumps everything they get their hands on, filling Puducherry’s Karuvadaikuppam dumpyard faster than you can say, “environmental catastrophe”. Such mismanagement of Pondicherry’s garbage is not only illegal, it also violates rights and protections granted to citizens by India’s Constitution. I recognized that municipal waste mismanagement is a human rights violation when I was contacted recently by an international organization that requested permission to use my photography in a report for the UN Human Rights Council’s Special Rapporteur.

The connection between waste management and human rights become apparent immediately upon entering Karuvadaikuppam dumpyard. Children’s rights, especially, are completely disregarded by the authorities.

Last Saturday, I visited Karuvadaikuppam to see for myself. Here are some images of the situation there:

Garbage arrives in compactors, and is distributed by an earth mover

Garbage arrives in compactors, and is distributed by an earth mover at kruvadaikuppam dumpyard

A girl who resides at the dump recovers recyclables while a compactor unloads

A girl who resides at the dump recovers recyclables while a compactor unloads

Children stand back to avoid being hit by the earth mover's bucket

Children stand back to avoid being hit by the earth mover's bucket

Many children work amidst the heavy machinery

Many children work amidst the heavy machinery

A compacted Coke bottle contains a few precious drops

A compacted Coke bottle contains a few precious drops

A childhood with little time for schooling

A childhood with little time for schooling

A girl bags a recyclable item

A girl bags a recyclable item

What future is in store for such children?

What future is in store for such children?

Signs in Bangalore

June 3, 2011

I was in Bangalore over the weekend, and shot these photos of signs that make me laugh.

Parking for Awake Only

And Beware of Flimsy Concrete!

A sign announcing dormitory accommodation downstairs, with the firewood

A sign announcing dormitory accommodation downstairs, with the firewood

Pondicherry’s Truck Terminal: A Major Illegal Medical Waste Dumpsite and Source of Dioxin Related Compounds

May 18, 2011

Pondicherry’s truck terminal, a large parking lot that seems to always be entirely vacant, has become a major site for illegal dumping of municipal and biomedical waste. I have a morbid attraction to the site because one never knows what surprises it has in store, so I visit rather regularly — so regularly that I now recognize most of the cows that forage there, and they seem to recognize me.

Smoldering rubbish at Pondicherry's truck terminal

Smoldering rubbish at Pondicherry's truck terminal

The entire area is thoroughly littered with medical waste of all sorts, most of it scorched or smoldering. On Sunday, dogs and cows were tearing into the freshest bags of medical waste. By the time the dogs and cows were done, the bags were leaking like Wisconsin ballot bags after what now passes for an “election” in that American state.

Cow rummaging through fresh medical waste

Cow rummaging through fresh medical waste

Cow consuming medical waste at Pondicherry's truck terminal

Cow examining medical waste at Pondicherry's truck terminal

Cows in illegally dumped medical waste at Pondicherry's truck terminal

Cows in illegally dumped medical waste at Pondicherry's truck terminal

The situation at the truck terminal is a common sight throughout India. This is extremely alarming because research by teams of Indian and Japanese scientists has found that low-temperature burning of mixed municipal waste in open dumpsites produces dioxin-related compounds that make their way into the food system though livestock that feed in such sites.

Cow eating scorched municipal waste at Pondicherry's truck terminal

Cow eating scorched municipal waste at Pondicherry's truck terminal

Cow consuming scorched municipal waste, illustrating how dioxin contaminates India's food supply

Cow consuming scorched municipal waste, illustrating how dioxin contaminates India's food supply

Cow eating scorched waste in Pondicherry

Cow eating scorched waste in Pondicherry

Black cow with a load that appears to have come out of a trash compactor

Black cow with a load that appears to have come out of a trash compactor

Cows consuming scorched municipal waste at Pondicherry's truck terminal

Cows consuming scorched municipal waste at Pondicherry's truck terminal

A smoldering load that appears to have been dumped by a compactor

A smoldering load that appears to have been dumped by a compactor

The scientists, who have been studying this problem for over three decades, write:

“India also has a problem with the management of its varied solid wastes comprising of domestic, biomedical, agricultural and industrial wastes. Dumpsites of such wastes have been found to be the sites of production of the most dreaded pollutants of the persistent organic pollutants (POPs) group, the dioxins and furans. . . . The levels of many of the persistent toxic chemicals in the Indian environment, food stuff, wildlife and human are one among the highest in the world” (Subramanian and Tanabe 2007).

Breast milk from mothers living around dumpsites in Chennai and Kolkata was contaminated by dioxins at levels hundreds of times higher than the limit set by the World Health Organization. The scientists explain that this is bad because “in utero and lactational exposure to dioxin related compounds may adversely affect the brain development and immune systems of infants and children” (Kinisue et al. 2004).

The scientists write: “Our results suggest that residents living near the dumping site in India have been exposed to relatively high levels of these contaminants, possibly through intake of bovine milk . . . It is anticipated that pollution from dioxin related compounds may further increase and that residue levels in human breast milk may increase in the future because even now the sources of these contaminants are not regulated at all. Control measures to regulate the pollution sources of dioxin related compounds in open dumping sites in Asian developing countries are urgently needed” (Kinisue et al. 2004:423).

Bags of sorted medical waste illegally dumped beside Pondicherry's truck terminal

Bags of sorted medical waste illegally dumped beside Pondicherry's truck terminal

Will Pondicherry’s Pollution Control Committee take action to stop this illegal dumping, or will the land of the Kama Sutra become one big Love Canal?

References

Kunisue, T. et al. 2004. Dioxins and related compounds in human breast milk collected around open dumping sites in Asian developing countries: Bovine milk as a potential source.
Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 47(3):414-26

Subramanian, A., and S. Tanabe. 2007. Persistent Toxic Substances in India. Chap. 9 in Developments in Environmental Science, Volume 7. A. Li, S. Tanabe, G. Jiang, J.P. Giesy and P.K.S. Lam (Editors). Elsevier Ltd.

The Walt Disney Company (India) and Exnora Green Pammal Celebrate Earth Day with Students

April 17, 2011
Representatives of the Walt Disney Company (India) and Engineers Without Borders Australia with Dr. Bhavani Shankar and Ms. Mangalam Balasubramanian at Exnora Green Pammal's biogas plant in Pammal

Representatives of the Walt Disney Company (India) and Engineers Without Borders Australia with Dr. Bhavani Shankar and Ms. Mangalam Balasubramanian at Exnora Green Pammals biogas plant in Pammal

On Friday, April 15, I documented Exnora Green Pammal’s Earth Day celebration with the Walt Disney Company (India), Engineers Without Borders Australia, and students from schools in Chennai. We celebrated by planting trees and recycling aracia nut palm leaf into disposable picnic plates and dishes.

Walt Disney VoluntEAR Sajita (left) and Engineers Without Borders Australia Field Volunteer Rosie Sanderson plant a sapling

Walt Disney VoluntEAR Sajita (left) and Engineers Without Borders Australia Field Volunteer Rosie Sanderson plant a sapling

The tree-planting crew pauses for a portrait

The tree-planting crew pauses for a portrait

Read about it and view more photos on Exnora Green Pammal’s blog, which I manage.

PMSPL’s Illegal Garbage Dumping Relocates from Kurumbapet to Karuvadaikuppam

April 11, 2011
Pondicherry's dumpsite at Karuvadaikuppam

Pondicherry's dumpsite at Karuvadaikuppam

I feared I wouldn’t survive to tell this story, riding through Pondicherry’s Karuvadaikuppam dumpsite in the cabin of a PMSPL compactor. Lumbering across the peaks and valleys of trash, the truck lurched, slid and swayed violently. Seated precariously between me and the driver, one of my companions exclaimed, “This truck is gonna have a short life!” The driver, wearing a handkerchief over his nose and mouth, wrestled with the steering wheel to keep the vehicle from toppling. As the truck went into a nose dive, I braced myself against the dashboard and fleetingly pondered the odds of compactors being equipped with airbags. From the sweltering, fly-infested cabin, I peered through the grimy passenger window – closed to keep out the dump’s suffocating smoke and stench – at the noxious ocean of smoldering garbage that we appeared to be sinking into. Into his cellphone the driver impatiently shouted “Tell me where to go!” to a man in a yellow construction helmet beside a distant backhoe, barely visible through the haze.

I was accompanying two colleagues to Karuvadaikuppam dumpyard to document illegal dumping of mixed municipal waste by Puducherry Municipal Services Private Limited (PMSPL), a joint venture between Puducherry Urban Development Agency (PUDA) and PUDA’s co-conspirator, Kivar Environ, a Bangalore-based waste hauling outfit. Last week, PMSPL was ordered to stop dumping mixed garbage at Kurumbapet, after protests by students and faculty of the nearby Rajiv Gandhi Veterinary College. Rather than bring their waste management practices into compliance with government regulations that mandate recycling and composting, PMSPL instead predictably chose the cheaper option — relocate their illegal dumping operation to Karuvadaikuppam.

When I jumped down from the compactor’s cabin, I was greeted by a tribe of Gypsies who reside at the dump and earn their living by collecting and selling recyclable trash. The sudden inflow of approximately 275 tons of trash per day at Karuvadaikuppam is keeping them busy. They posed briefly for photos before descending upon the detritus being extruded from the compactor I’d arrived in.

PMSPL's compactor dumping 7 tons of mixed municipal waste in Karuvadaikuppam

PMSPL's compactor dumping 7 tons of mixed municipal waste in Karuvadaikuppam

Gypsies begin picking over the fresh load

Gypsies begin picking over the fresh load

A soda bottle is recovered

A soda bottle is recovered

A boy salvages a bottle of toilet bowl cleaner

A boy salvages a bottle of toilet bowl cleaner

A girl picks through the load

A girl picks through the load

The children search for plastic, metal and food

The children search for plastic, metal and food

A bottle of Pepsi is finished

A bottle of Pepsi is finished

For the Gypsies, it’s a race to rummage through each load and extract sellable waste before the next compactor arrives and dumps. In the intense sunshine, the heaps of waste soon catch fire from methane created during decomposition.

Veera found an orange

Veera found an orange

Urvasi (wearing pink blouse) with leaping boy

Urvasi (wearing pink blouse) with leaping boy

Urvasi found a Diet Coke can

Urvasi found a Diet Coke can

Urvasi pauses from her work

Urvasi pauses from her work

Little Veera's shirt says, "I Ooze Coolness"

Veera's shirt says, "I Ooze Coolness"

Gayatri pauses from her work to pose for a photo

Gayatri pauses from her work to pose for a photo

Fire reduces the waste to charred residue, which Coromandel Fertilizer is exhuming, sieving and marketing to farmers as “organic compost”.

The previous day's garbage smolders

A previous day's garbage smolders

Coromandel Fertilizer markets Pondicherry’s trash ash to farmers as “organic compost”

Coromandel Fertilizer markets Pondicherry’s trash ash to farmers as “organic compost”

Images of Pondicherry’s Main Market Shot with a Panasonic Lumix G1

April 7, 2011

I recently upgraded from a Panasonic Lumix LX3 to a Lumix DMC-G1. The G1 has a couple of great features, particularly a swiveling LCD screen, a good electronic viewfinder, and a very good battery. Yesterday afternoon, I took the camera to one of my favorite places for shooting photos, Pondicherry’s main market. Here are a few of the images captured with the G1. The photos were shot in RAW, and processed with Silkypix.

bagging flowers

bagging flowers

coriander, ginger and mint vendors

coriander, ginger and mint vendors

flower vendors

flower vendors in Pondicherry

flower vendors with customers

flower vendors with customers

flowers on display

flowers on display

flower vendor waiting for customers

flower vendor waiting for customers

flowers for sale: smiles for free

flowers for sale: smiles for free

general merchant

general merchant

paan leaf vendors

paan leaf vendors

spinach and vegetable vendors

spinach and vegetable vendors

oil and rope vendor

oil and rope vendor

amused paan leaf merchant

amused paan leaf merchant

 

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started