In 1955 my father’s parents moved from the city of Adelaide to a house by the beach, at Grange. Their new address was within the boundaries of the Federal electorate of Port Adelaide, created in 1949.
Port Adelaide was one of Australia’s safest Labor seats, the only electorate in South Australia to have voted Labor at every federal election since it was formed. Its most notable member was Mick Young, Leader of the House under Prime Minister Bob Hawke.
Labor promoted itself as a ‘progressive’ party of the centre-left. My grandmother Kathleen Cavenagh (Cudmore) Symes (1908-2013), a conservative in politics, opposed Labor policies and, when she could, always directed her vote against the Labor candidate.
This sometimes led to a little awkwardness. What would she do if the more conservative of Australia’s two major parties did not field a candidate in her electorate? She told me that in that case, rather than voting ‘informal’ (an empty vote, the equivalent of not voting at all) or voting for Labor, she would vote for the Communist candidate.
This does not mean that she’d abandoned her conservative opinions and taken up Communism. By voting Communist she was at least withholding what might might seem to count as approval of Labor, directing it to a party opposed to the dominance of the centre-left.
I’ve been wondering when and how often she voted for the Communists.
The Communist party stood for election in Port Adelaide in all nine elections from 1949 to 1969. There was also a candidate from the party in the three elections from 1977 to 1983 and again in 1998 and 2001.
In both 1954 and 1955 only two candidates stood in Port Adelaide, the sitting member, Albert Thompson (1886–1966), and a candidate for the Communist Party. In the 1954 election the candidate was Alan Finger (1909-1985), a medical practitioner. In the 1955 election the candidate was Peter Symon (1922-2008).
Kathleen’s husband and father were both medical practitioners and probably knew Alan Finger.
A profile by the Adelaide News sets out the policies of the two candidates in 1954:
News (Adelaide, SA), Thursday 20 May 1954, page 14
Your election guide No. 5-Pt Adelaide
ALP has mortgage on this seat
Mr. A.V. Thompson, the sitting Labor member, is being opposed by a Communist, Dr. Alan Finger, in Port Adelaide.
Not by any stretch of the imagination could Dr. Finger be given a chance of success.
The LCL decided against bothering to put up a candidate in this blue ribbon Labor seat.
At the 1951 general election, Mr. Thomson was opposed by Mr. J. A. H. Caskey (endorsed LCL) and Dr. Finger. Mr. Thompson polled 20,000 more than the combined votes of his two opponents. Dr. Finger managed only 1,304 against Mr. Thompson's 33,979.
The sub-divisions of Port Adelaide are: Albert Park, Dudley Park, Kilburn, Port Adelaide, Semaphore, and Woodville.
There are 56,762 on the roll (50,460 in 1951).
24 yrs. in politics.
A lay preacher, who entered the SA Parliament in 1930, Mr. Thompson has been in politics continuously for 24 years. Before that he was in the transport industry and for many years was president of the Transport Workers' Union.
In 1947 he represented the IOOF Friendly Society at an international conference in America.
He was in the SA Parliament for 16 ½ years, representing both Port Adelaide and Semaphore.
He entered the Federal Parliament when he won Hindmarsh in 1946 and then contested Port Adelaide in 1949.
He has a family of two sons and four daughters. He has been a consistent advocate in the Federal Parliament for ameliorating the means test for social service benefits.
Mr. Thompson says: "Saturday week's election will decide the future standards of the people. For the workers, manual or clerical, the question will be one of restoring cost-of-living standards by quarterly adjustment of wages and restoring the value of margins in industry.
"I urge an increase of £4 a week for pensioners to give the same standard of purchasing power as existed when the Chifley Government was defeated in 1949."
Doctor's policy
Dr. Alan Finger, 44, is an Adelaide doctor. He became well known as medical superintendent of Northfield Infectious Diseases Hospital for 11 years. In 1947 he went into private practice at Broken Hill for a short time and returned to Adelaide to practice privately at Pennington in 1949.
Dr. Finger is married and has four children.
"Ban A-weapons"
Dr. Finger says: "I stand for a policy of peace. I am against rearming of Japan and for a total ban on all atomic and biological weapons, and for Australian independence from the US or any other Power.
"Increasing living standards, abolition of the means test, free social services, and development of Australia's resources by and for our own people could be provided by ending needless war expenditure, and by more heavily taxing the wealthy concerns as a preliminary to their nationalisation."
……………
Albert Thompson held the seat with 47,355 votes or 94%. Alan Finger received 3,045 votes, 6% of the total. There were 4,083 informal votes, 7% of the total. 96.2% of those on the roll voted.
Nationally the incumbent Liberal–Country coalition led by Prime Minister Robert Menzies (won 64 seats) defeated the opposition Labor Party led by H. V. Evatt (57 seats).
In late 1955 an early election was called to bring the House and Senate elections back in line.
Unfortunately the digitised newspapers do not cover the period so one cannot read the summary of the candidate’s policies online.
Symon had joined the Communist Party of Australia at the age of 16. In the Second World War, Symon served in the army, then the air force, and in later life worked as a waterside labourer in Adelaide.
Albert Thompson held the seat with 32,813 votes or 85%. There was a swing of 9% against him. Peter Symon received 5,918 votes, 15% of the total. There were 2,906 informal votes, 7% of the total. 96.1% of those on the roll voted.
Nationally the incumbent Liberal–Country coalition led by Prime Minister Robert Menzies increased its majority (75 seats) over the opposition Labor Party, led by H. V. Evatt (47 seats) with a Two-party-preferred swing of 4.9%.
My grandparents moved to Grange in 1955. Kathleen seems to have had in mind that year’s election, when the Communists won 15% of the vote, a surprisingly large proportion for a minor party. Perhaps other conservative voters besides my grandmother were registering the same sort of grievance. When it came to a choice between an unattractive possibility—a Labor win— and an unappealing impossibility—a Communist win—it made sense to vote for the party certain to fail. The protest might encourage the conservatives to field a candidate next time.
































