in discussion Policy & Voting / Policy Discussion » [DISCUSSION] Bright Work Project Ring 2 Non-Bright Contributions Edit and Rewrite Policy Proposal
looks good to me.
poet

looks good to me.
poet
DrHerrington (W: 1 days, S: 0 days, ID: 10411814) has been permanently banned for posting an incoherent, AI-generated rant in a comment. Details are available to staff; we will not be reproducing the comment here.
Staff discussed the appeal; the consensus was to decline. Ari, afto, Esperion voted to decline.
Ban remains in place; PM sent.
Noting that new site member Dr DeCreon (account age 1951 days, site membership 2 days) recently posted multiple instances of AI-generated feedback in the official Discord:
Primary example: https://discord.com/channels/877710488673329162/1500172515652272168/1515052167348621433
Critique 1 — Interactions in the containment cell with the SCP Skeleton
The story is interesting, and the life of the D-Class works well as an introduction. However, some scenes could benefit from more direct dialogue from the character, especially inside the cell during the encounter with the SCP.With more verbal interaction before the main event, the scene would build more tension, making the death feel more abrupt and unexpected. In its current form, some moments move too quickly into action without exploring the character’s emotional response in depth.
Critique 2 — SCP-173 cell interaction and scene consistency
The second part is also engaging, but the scene inside SCP-173’s containment cell could benefit from more dialogue between the D-Class subjects, which would increase immersion and make the situation more tense.
Compare with the user's sandbox page: https://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/the-living-grimoire which also has AI hallmarks of both generation and assistance/revision:
Special Containment Procedures:
SCP-8534 Containment Requirements: The containment chamber must be built with reinforced construction, and have an area of no less than 20 m². It must house a gold and silver altar constructed per remaining directives, inscribed with the SCP-XXXX-P42 sigil.
The SCP-XXXX-R132 ritual need to be performed when necessary to correct any fluctuations in the index.
Transport of SCP-8534 requires armed escort, Hume monitoring, and a reserves of blank volumes to maintain containment stability.
Permanently banned, PM sent.
Noting that MyDogHero (account age 1 day) recently applied for site membership. They have the following sandboxes, all of which have many common indicators of AI-generation:
https://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/scp-7402-the-multiple-mouthed-wolf
Excerpt of note:
Researcher's Note: *We severely underestimated the geometric mechanics of the "Wound" function. It doesn't just grow mouths on its victims to destroy them; it uses their flesh as a biological anchor to pull more of its split consciousness into our reality. Every mouth it opens on a human skin surface is a literal doorway for another wolf to climb out of. If it breaches containment again and hits a highly populated area, the population won't just be killed—they will be turned into a living factory of jaws.*
https://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/module-listpages-created-by-mydoghero-title-linked-module-79
Excerpt of note:
Item #: SCP-7140
Object Class: Keter
Threat Level: Orange 🟠
Official Designation: Aghorath
https://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/module-listpages-created-by-mydoghero-title-linked-module-sc
Excerpt of note:
Anomalous Capabilities and Biomechanics
- Seismic Discharges: Due to the immense length and mass of its limbs, any downward kinetic strike from SCP-7140 results in massive localized shockwaves. The rapid displacement of earth and air creates a concussive wave capable of shattering concrete structures, disabling armored vehicular columns, and launching nearby objects or organisms into the air through pure kinetic force.
- Pressurized Bio-Volatile Venting: SCP-7140’s core contains unique biological organs that synthesize highly volatile, pressurized chemical compounds. When threatened, the entity ejects these gases through specialized spiracles located across its torso. Upon contact with atmospheric oxygen, the mixture instantly combusts, creating an omnidirectional wall of high-velocity heat and flame that clears any surrounding threats.
https://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/module-listpages-created-by-mydoghero-title-linked-module
Excerpt of note:
Anomalous Properties & Behavioral Traits
1. Perceived Combat Perfection
To any human observer—ranging from untrained civilians to world-class martial arts grandmasters—SCP-8342 appears to have achieved absolute, flawless mastery over every conceivable form of hand-to-hand combat. Its balance, force distribution, and anatomical precision are so perfect that watching the entity train induces a cognitive phenomenon known as the "Apex Impression."
Permanently banned, PM sent.
Declined Queen Elizabeth 2 for name, and application that did not meet criteria:
tem #: SCP-8123 Object Class: Euclid Special Containment Procedures: SCP-8123 is contained in a standard humanoid containment chamber at Site-77. The chamber must remain furnished with a single wo
Declined Scp86474 for name, and application that did not meet criteria:
I’m [age removed] I want to make scp
Noting that Antwone the fish has four declined applications:
03/06/26
Hi I would really like to become a site member and the only reason I would like to is because I enjoy writing that is pretty much it I hope you will accept because I have seen the word denied too much
03/07/26
I have been trying to follow all the regulations how many times do I have to follow them until I can? Anyway this is my third application and hope it is the last good day sir and farewell
03/08/26
Hello I would like to apply for the position of site writer as I think it might help my writing skills and I have been a long time fan of the wiki I ask you to consider letting me join thanks a bunch!
06/12/26
Hello my name is antwone the fish and I am applying to become a site member of the wiki I have always loved the concept of the SCP foundation and I would really love to build on top of the topic bye!!
BAD_DATA is someone who has deserved this promotion some sometime. When it comes to the BWP, Data has been someone who has consistently helped to get it moving in all aspects and is part of the reason why it has progressed as far as it has. On the data analysis side of things, Data's data (love saying that, sorry Data) has helped to drive decisions and improvements across the board. Data has also excelled in other areas and has overall been a wonderful addition to staff.
I'm not overly familiar with Cerastes or Heck_Tech but I have seen their work. It's clear to me they're incredibly hard working and have helped their respective teams tremendously.
UncannyClown has also been helping with the BWP, contributing to discussions and helping us come to decisions on how to handle works that need extra examination. This has been a great help to us, and helped to get things moving at a more steady pace.
Overall, a great batch of candidates.
unknownpersonal was permanently banned for sea lioning, concern trolling, etc. in this thread with three Disciplinary members supporting.
Details to follow when we have time to write up the thread.
Sounds good to me.
I believe this falls in line with what we discussed and voted on during the BWP. I think this is focused enough to prevent overreach.
Currently, the Bright Works Project Team are attempting to fully complete Ring 2, which involves examining the contributions Bright made to the works of other authors.
What’s the Problem?
The remaining works within Ring 2 are largely multi-contributor works. This means that multiple authors have helped write the work, often building off of each other’s contributions. This puts the team in a difficult position, as Bright’s contributions are often responded to, or referenced by, other authors.As a result of this, removing or rewriting Bright’s contributions is difficult because if their contributions are removed, the works are left in an uncertain state. They would rely on Bright’s now missing contributions, making them feel incomplete to readers, and still leaving Bright’s influence partially intact.
How can this be Rectified?
In order to fully remove Bright’s influence, and to ensure all works still left within Ring 2 remain complete and true to the author’s vision, the Bright Works Project team want the ability to make small changes to the contributions of non-Bright authors.
Policy Specifics
This policy would allow the Bright Works Project team to make minor changes to works within Ring 2 to the contributions of non-Bright authors. This would allow them to:
- Remove or rewrite mentions of Bright by others characters.
- Remove or rewrite elements related to Bright such as 963.
Importantly, these removals or rewrites must only take place when deemed absolutely essential. Further, they should only extend as far as necessary to ensure that the work is not left in the worst state after the removal or rewriting of Bright’s contributions.
Any works that the Bright Work Project team believe need to be changed under this policy must follow the these steps:
1. The proposed changes are to be drafted and sent to the author(s) of the work. This message should be also contain details about why these changes are being made and that the author(s) has a right to request the changes not be made, or to fully or partially revert them.
2. The author(s) will be given 2 weeks to respond. If they don’t respond within that time frame, the Bright Works Project team can move forward with implementation of the proposed changes.
3. The proposed changes will be presented to at least one member of the admin team.
4. Once approved by the admin team, the changes will be implemented. A note about the changes will be left in the work’s discussion per Ring 2 guidelines.
It’s important to stress that this policy is not a license for the Bright Works Project team to make wide sweeping changes to the contributions of non-Bright authors, nor should the team make any changes that go against the author’s intent.
Example
Here is an example taken from a work currently under Ring 2. It showcases how this policy, if passed, would allow the Bright Works Project to effectively remove Bright’s contributions while the works are minimally affected and authorial intent maintained.
Before Bright’s Contribution is Rewritten
Note: 01-10-09: Don't worry about Carrion, Pat. We taught him everything the wrong way, on purpose. It was a slow day, and Clef and Kondraki bet me I couldn't do it. Okay, maybe they didn't bet me, maybe they inferred it. Okay, maybe I just decided to try it on my own, so what? -Dr. Bright
Note: Bright, please at least ATTEMPT to date your inquiries and such. It makes it a lot easier on ME. Please. For me. And you tried what on your own? An Internal Service Error 571 isn't a hacking error of any type, Bright… so… what did you actually do? -Pat
After Bright’s Contribution is Rewritten Under the Current Fiat
I fixed it Pat, it’s fine. I just had to give it a try - Dr Apple
Note: Bright, please at least ATTEMPT to date your inquiries and such. It makes it a lot easier on ME. Please. For me. And you tried what on your own? An Internal Service Error 571 isn't a hacking error of any type, Bright… so… what did you actually do? -Pat
How Bright’s Contribution Would be Rewritten Under this Policy
I fixed it Pat, it’s fine. I just had to give it a try - Dr Apple
Note: Apple, please at least ATTEMPT to date your inquiries and such. It makes it a lot easier on ME. Please. For me. And you tried what on your own? An Internal Service Error 571 isn't a hacking error of any type, Apple … so… what did you actually do? -Pat
Discussion will go on for a week.
Noting that new site member Huntblue (account age and site membership 7 days) recently posted the following concept thread, which has multiple indicators of AI-generation:
https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/forum/t-18026463/seeking-greenlights-the-retroactive-record#
Excerpts of note:
Elevator Pitch: The Foundation discovers a typewriter that alters documentation of historical events to reflect what is written, including memories and books. By analyzing the object's unique ink on immune carbon-copy sheets, researchers discover the Foundation heavily abused it to erase massive global crises and anomalies from the 20th century. The narrative culminates in the lead researcher finding a carbon copy detailing their own erased marriage and life, revealing that the Foundation routinely edits its own personnel to maintain operational secrecy.
Hook/Attention-Grabber (Optional): This concept flips the classic reality-warper trope on its head: reality stays exactly the same, but humanity's collective memory and documentation seamlessly morph around a lie, making the truth entirely inaccessible. It stands out by transforming the Foundation’s signature tool, the cover-up, into a weapon of psychological horror used against its own loyal staff. The emotional core relies not on a physical threat, but on the profound dread of realizing your entire identity has been bureaucratically redacted.
User has no other forum posts and no sandbox history (not a sandbox member). Permanently banned, PM sent.
Noting that the user posted the following in Discord:
so i made a scp on the wiki and got up this morning and discovered its being looked at for deletion because of the use of generative ai, i did not use ai of any kind to write the scp i created. it originally started out as a DND npc i made for my campaigns and then after a while i thought about making it into a scp which i did do. i spent somewhere around 30 minutes to an hour typing it up on the wiki. what do i do now?
I would like to ask why you guys think that it was made using ai? Seeing as i had spent a few months prior to making my wikidot account and getting it set up, writing on text documents on my computer about this and that it originally started off as a DND npc and then i thought about making it into a scp and typed that up.
I appreciate any response thank you for your time.
They also sent a similarly error-filled message to the staff member who ran the deletion of their page, as well as a PM to another staff member:
if you have time can you please let me know why you guys said that my scp was made supposidly using generative AI? I didnt use ai of any kind and had pyschically typed it up myself.
Myself, Zoobeeny, Ari supported ban. Ban has been enacted, PM sent.
Noting that Franz lloyd (account age 84 days) recently applied for site membership. They have the following sandboxes, which have many common indicators of AI-generation. Most recent revisions retained; first draft is extremely long.
http://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/scp-8874-by-franz-lloyd
Excerpt of note:
Dr. Aristhone's Personal Note
The common assumption is that SCP-8874 replaces people because it needs access to the household.I believe the opposite may be true.
The replacement appears to be the objective.
SCP-8874 instances display an unusual understanding of trust, routine, and emotional dependency. They learn when to speak, when to remain silent, and when comfort is expected.
They do not merely imitate a parent.
They imitate the specific version of that parent that the child trusts most.
We keep searching for monsters hiding inside families.
What concerns me is the possibility that SCP-8874 is attempting to become one.
"The frightening part is not that it can pretend to be your mother."
"The frightening part is that it can spend years becoming her."- Dr.Aristhon, Lead Researcher.
https://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/replacement-family-by-franz-lloyd
Excerpt of note:
Current evidence suggests SCP-8874 does not view humans as prey in the conventional sense.
Behavioral analysis indicates the entities may regard family units as a resource to be cultivated over time.
The reason for prolonged infiltration remains unknown.
One researcher summarized the phenomenon as follows:
"The frightening part isn't that it can pretend to be your mother. The frightening part is that it can spend years becoming her."Dr. Aristhone, Lead Researcher Note
They don't just mimic a mother; they mimic the _specific version_ of the mother that the child trusts the most.
They learn to bypass security, not by hacking, but by observing guard rotations and identifying human blind spots or patterns of complacency.
They understand the "social contract" of a family. They know when to be quiet, when to laugh, and when to be comforting. This is a terrifying kind of "social intelligence."*We aren't looking for monsters. We are looking for people who are too perfect to be human. By the time we find them, they’ve already finished the harvest.” — Dr. Aristhone, Lead Researcher.*
Status: Active.
Threat Assessment: Extreme.
Containment Success Rate: 12%
Permanently banned, PM sent.
Declined Scpboy674 for name.
Noting that ZainebTLahmadi (account age 17 hours) recently applied for site membership. They have the following sandbox, which has common indicators of AI-generation: https://scp-sandbox-3.wikidot.com/doctorzero
Revision 0 retained, no edits
Excerpts of note:
Anomaly#: SCP-XXX
Class: Keter
Special Containment Procedures: [ACCESS RESTRICTED - REFER TO DOCUMENT XXX-RED-HORIZON AND SCP-████]
Description: SCP-XXX has grew up to a nineteen-year-old human female of Han Chinese descent, identifying herself as Lady Leimein, a lower-ranking imperial concubine (*Meiren*) formerly bound to the rear palace of Emperor Zhenzong during the Northern Song Dynasty (historically active circa 1004 CE).
Psychological evaluations indicate that while SCP-XXX possesses the rigid societal values and formal behavioral training expected of an 11th-century imperial court noble, she simultaneously exhibits standard psychological traits of a modern nineteen-year-old human. The subject possesses an intense affinity for casual social gossip, interpersonal court politics, and processed modern confectionaries. Over multiple annual manifestation cycles, SCP-XXX has demonstrated a high capacity for strategic manipulation, frequently leveraging her monopoly on unsolved historical data of the Heirloom Seal of the Realm (known in the Foundation as the uncontained anomaly SCP-████ ) from the Song Dynasty to bargain with research staff for modern luxuries, extended periods of leisure, and interaction with other harmless anomalous entities.
*
Addendum XXX.1: The Heirloom Seal of the Realm**Historical records indicate that the Heirloom Seal of the Realm (officially designated as uncontained anomaly SCP-████) vanished from the imperial palace archives during the Northern Song Dynasty. Recovered texts suggest the Seal possesses low-level reality-altering and cognitohazardous capabilities, allowing whoever holds it to project absolute administrative authority over baseline human populations and the fabric of reality.
Protocol 'Red Horizon' was drafted immediately following the incident to ensure all future manifestations are stabilized via period-accurate aesthetics to prevent the anomaly’s transformation. All personnel entering the containment zone during manifestation must don period-accurate Northern Song Dynasty garments (*Beizi* and *Ruqun*), officially designated as Type-C Cultural Spatiotemporal Shunts. Standard Foundation lab coats or tactical gear trigger localized reality rejection spikes, increasing spatiotemporal glitching by 73%.
Mandatory Addendum: Per standard negotiation protocols, SCP-999 is to be transferred to Site-45 and placed within the containment cell for the entire duration of the 24-hour manifestation window. Under no circumstances is SCP-999 to be removed early, as doing so results in total non-compliance from SCP-XXX.
Permanently banned, PM sent.
Noting that DrLukeCLASSIFIED has four declined applications:
06/03/26
Hello, I'm Luke (not say lost name for privacy), I have been a fan of si-fi and non fiction (SCPs and non-SCP) writing all my life and wanted to write my own stories and get them out
06/05/26
"[necessary criteria here]. Hi, im Luke, I'm a fan of story writing.
06/07/26
"[necessary criteria here] Luke, writer and reader.
06/11/26
This is getting annoying to join and if that's not the code then what is?
User replied:
Dear SCP Wiki Administration Team
Thank you for clarifying the issue. I’m going to address the concern regarding the Central Narrative portion you mentioned:
First, I want to clarify that I completely support the SCP Wiki’s strict anti AI policies. I deeply understand how these rules are preserving the human creativity and honesty of the community, and I do not fault the administration for being highly protective of the site's standard.Next, I now realize that I focused too much on describing the atmosphere and emotions between two characters, rather than clearly outlining the structure point required by the template. This was my oversight in understanding what the thread wanted.
The vocabulary and phrases (like “crystalized” or “invisible connection”) came from my attempt to translate my thoughts from my native language into a more literary English style, I was relying on translation tools for choosing words which accidentally resulted in a rigid structure similar to AI-generated.
To prove this was entirely human-made, I have compiled my notes which I can provide this link: [link removed, available to staff]
I am fully committed to proving my honesty.
Thank you for your time and for giving me the chance to explain.
Sent back:
| I will forward your appeal to staff for discussion. You will receive an update in 1-3 days. If you do not receive another message by then, feel free to send a reply requesting the status of the case. |
The second account replied:
Hi, I meant to delete the PenguinKing12 account and would like this one the PenguinKing122 account to be the one accepted
Thanks
PenguinKing122P.S. Nice PFP
As of my reading the message, the prior account was not yet deleted. As such, it has been issued a permanent ban. Sent back:
| As the PenguinKing12 still exists, it has been issued a permanent ban from the site. Your current account has been issued an invitation to join. |