Buster Keaton Elmer Dorothy Sebastian Trilby Drew Edward Earle Lionel Benmore Leila Hyams Ethyl Norcrosse William Bechtel Nussbaum Jack Byron Scarzi Joe Bordeaux Rumrunner Ray Cooke The Bellboy Mike Donlin Man in Ship's Engine Room Pat Harmon Ship Captain Sydney Jarvis Man in Audience Next to Elmer Theodore Lorch Actor as 'Union Officer' Hank Mann Stage Manager Charles Sullivan Tough Sailor Edward Sedgwick Director Buster Keaton Director Reggie Lanning Director