Actions
Bug #46175
closedcephadm: orch apply -i: MON and MGR service specs must not have a service_id
% Done:
0%
Source:
Backport:
Regression:
No
Severity:
3 - minor
Reviewed:
Affected Versions:
ceph-qa-suite:
Pull request ID:
Tags (freeform):
Merge Commit:
Fixed In:
v16.0.0-3793-g93fca6a9e0
Released In:
v16.2.0~1885
Upkeep Timestamp:
2025-07-14T19:39:07+00:00
Description
service_spec_core.yml
---
service_type: mon
service_id: sesdev_mon_deployment
placement:
hosts:
- 'node1'
- 'node2'
- 'node3'
---
service_type: mgr
service_id: sesdev_mgr_deployment
placement:
hosts:
- 'node1'
- 'node2'
- 'node3'
Result:
master:~ # ceph orch ls --service-type mon --format json-pretty
[
{
"placement": {
"hosts": [
{
"hostname": "node1",
"name": "",
"network": ""
},
{
"hostname": "node2",
"name": "",
"network": ""
},
{
"hostname": "node3",
"name": "",
"network": ""
}
]
},
"service_id": "sesdev_mon_deployment",
"service_name": "mon.sesdev_mon_deployment",
"service_type": "mon",
"status": {
"running": 0,
"size": 3
}
},
{
"placement": {
"hosts": [
{
"hostname": "node2",
"name": "",
"network": ""
}
]
},
"service_id": "sesdev_mon_deployment.node2",
"service_name": "mon.sesdev_mon_deployment.node2",
"service_type": "mon",
"status": {
"container_image_id": "mix",
"container_image_name": "mix",
"last_refresh": "2020-06-24T11:30:40.499595",
"running": 3,
"size": 0
},
"unmanaged": true
}
]
master:~ # ceph orch ls --service-type mgr --format json-pretty
[
{
"placement": {
"hosts": [
{
"hostname": "node1",
"name": "",
"network": ""
},
{
"hostname": "node2",
"name": "",
"network": ""
},
{
"hostname": "node3",
"name": "",
"network": ""
}
]
},
"service_id": "sesdev_mgr_deployment",
"service_name": "mgr.sesdev_mgr_deployment",
"service_type": "mgr",
"status": {
"running": 0,
"size": 3
}
},
{
"placement": {
"hosts": [
{
"hostname": "node2",
"name": "",
"network": ""
}
]
},
"service_id": "sesdev_mgr_deployment.node2.usqbyy",
"service_name": "mgr.sesdev_mgr_deployment.node2.usqbyy",
"service_type": "mgr",
"status": {
"container_image_id": "a2c23ec01b1e6cf7168acdac917de31c122a0fc1f71b59124e8a585c398a07a2",
"container_image_name": "registry.opensuse.org/filesystems/ceph/octopus/upstream/images/ceph/ceph:latest",
"last_refresh": "2020-06-24T11:30:40.500111",
"running": 4,
"size": 0
},
"unmanaged": true
}
]
(Yes, I got 4 MGRs instead of 3, but that's a different known issue.)
Updated by Sebastian Wagner over 5 years ago
- Priority changed from Normal to High
Updated by Nathan Cutler over 5 years ago
If this is caused by the presence of "service_id: SOME_STRING" in the spec yaml, maybe it would make sense for cephadm to simply ignore service_id for MON and MGR?
Updated by Nathan Cutler over 5 years ago
- Subject changed from Day 1 deployment from service spec YAML results in bogus MON and MGR services to Day 1 deployment from service spec YAML results in bogus MON and MGR services if service_id specified for MON/MGR
Updated by Sebastian Wagner over 5 years ago
Nathan Cutler wrote:
If this is caused by the presence of "service_id: SOME_STRING" in the spec yaml, maybe it would make sense for cephadm to simply ignore service_id for MON and MGR?
definitively!
Updated by Sebastian Wagner over 5 years ago
- Subject changed from Day 1 deployment from service spec YAML results in bogus MON and MGR services if service_id specified for MON/MGR to cephadm: orch apply -i: MON and MGR service specs must not have a service_id
Updated by Sebastian Wagner over 5 years ago
- Related to Cleanup #46219: cephadm: remove DaemonDescription.service_id() added
Updated by Sebastian Wagner over 5 years ago
- Related to Bug #46253: OSD specs without service_id added
Updated by Michael Fritch over 5 years ago
- Status changed from New to Fix Under Review
- Pull request ID set to 35839
Updated by Sebastian Wagner over 5 years ago
- Status changed from Fix Under Review to Resolved
- Target version set to v15.2.5
Updated by Upkeep Bot 8 months ago
- Merge Commit set to 93fca6a9e045c252e6412fa36819f2424e646a1e
- Fixed In set to v16.0.0-3793-g93fca6a9e0
- Released In set to v16.2.0~1885
- Upkeep Timestamp set to 2025-07-14T19:39:07+00:00
Actions