Karmelo Anthony jury returns with guilty verdict in Austin Metcalf murder

Karmelo Anthony jury returns with guilty verdict in Austin Metcalf murder

Published June 9, 2026 4:07pm ET | Updated June 9, 2026 4:17pm ET



A Texas jury reached a guilty verdict Tuesday in the trial of Karmelo Anthony. The 19-year-old is convicted of murder in the fatal stabbing of another teenager, Austin Metcalf, 17, according to AP News. 

Anthony faced a first-degree murder charge for the Frisco, Texas, stabbing on April 2, 2025. Anthony said he acted in self-defense during a track meet. 

Several students testified that Metcalf told Anthony multiple times to leave his team’s tent. Metcalf attended Memorial High School, where Anthony was not a student. 

Anthony then reached into a bag and pulled out a knife. 

The case gained national attention partly from social media posts highlighting the racial backgrounds of the people involved. Anthony is a black student, and Metcalf was white. 

Attorneys on both sides maintained that race played no role in the incident. 

‘I JUST DON’T SEE THE OUT HERE’: JOE CONCHA ON KARMELO ANTHONY TRIAL

The jury rejected Anthony’s self-defense claim. 

He faces up to life in prison.