• It’s been a good few months since I’ve written here. I kept meaning to return, intending to make it part of my regular writing practice again. It’s funny to think that I started this blog in 2012, the same year that I participated in National Novel Writing Month. Since then, NaNoWriMo has bitten the dust, WordPress no longer has centralized community features like Freshly Pressed while shoving AI up its own ass, and blogs have become these free-floating spaces – placeholders for those of us who seek publication in case anyone asks us, god forbid, about our platforms.

    Cowardly lion drawn in black and white with an aqua blue mane. 
By William Wallace Denslow - The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=7274995

    I couldn’t write about politics, because I truly did not have the agility to navigate the shitstorm that has blasted our country over the last 9 months. Seasoned journalists were barely up to the task. Mainstream media sources, educational institutions, and corporate entities flinched in cowardice. What could I possibly contribute that wouldn’t just be more noise? I have a tiny (but beloved) readership and have no wish to monetize, so this little space began to collect dustballs. Every time I returned to it, I wrote yet another draft that would not see the light of day.

    It would be easy to call it writer’s block, but I tend not to use that phrase. If I’m not writing, there’s a reason. Perhaps it is because I feel incapable of enunciating the depression, anxiety, and righteous anger in a way that wouldn’t be a spluttering of curse words and ad hominem attacks. But if I’m to take the job of writer seriously, I’d better get over that and get on with things.

    While I deride the institutions that have bowed down, I have more control over whether or not I obey in advance. I am self-censoring more than I used to and I recognize that it might be time for me to gird my loins, stand up straight, and speak clearly, instead of muttering angrily in the corner. I’ve never been great on social media, because I’m always a month late with a witticism or thoughtful comment. It is not a place for slow discourse and the world itself, warp-speeding into destruction, is not going to wait for or be remotely impacted by my words.

    Black and white drawing of the scarecrow, holding a list. 
By William Wallace Denslow, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

    I find myself turning to moral philosophers and to writers who have lived through authoritarian times, desperate to find a deeper meaning or sense of purpose. What I’ve found most rattling and consequential is that there are no rewards for staying silent. You suffer the indignity of being a coward on top of whatever fascist bulldozer eventually rolls over you.

    There’s no magic answer to any of this. We know history. We know what happens to people under pressure, people who are taught to be afraid, people who are hungry, people who thirst for hope and light but who cannot see beyond the obstacles in front of them. What we don’t know is who we will be under those circumstances. Right now, I’m a coward, sitting quietly, trying to process what my priorities should be, where my attention should land, who needs the help I could offer, and realizing that as each minute and second passes, someone else is suffering from my inability to act.

    Silence, however, comes in different forms. There are people doing the hard work of protection, defiance, support, resistance, and empowerment without announcing it to the world. The problem is representation. We need representation of opposition, of understanding that we are not alone in our fears and anger. Of seeing people who share our ideals out in the world. To know that there are things we can do, believe in, and pursue. That requires some of us to show ourselves and be seen.

    I believe the old adage that courage is not the absence of fear, but rather acting in spite of fear. I can’t imagine living the rest of my life guided only by fear. At the moment, I feel a bit like a fly caught in a spider web. All these threads of chaos holding me in place, not allowing me to escape, to change direction, to believe that anything I do matters, just a constant, tiring struggle. It is a deadly powerlessness which must be challenged.

    A lifelong polite activist, I’ve shown up to volunteer at food banks, worked at nonprofits, donated to causes, even brought my introvert self to several protests. These are the polite things that nice middle class white ladies do. The protests in the middle of the afternoon in a suburb where people don’t step on the grass and let others through. Shouts are call and response murmurs, signs aren’t vulgar or violent. We smile, wave at honkers, and then hustle off to our daily chores at the appointed hour.

    I shouldn’t mock it – people are showing up how they can, but seeing protesters in Chicago coldcocked by government-appointed thugs and sprayed with gas and rubber bullets – or the pictures from the 60s in Selma, Alabama – well, you can see why sanitized protests seem a little empty. But one must be careful what they wish for – the utilization of military might and police brutality against protesting citizens is happening now. It’s just a matter of time before the most anodyne protest becomes a risk one must decide to take.

    The warnings are dire, a four-alarm fire for our democracy, moves straight out of every dictator’s playbook. Inch by depressing inch. We’ve been taught to view each other as the enemy, while our pockets are picked and our rights diminished. The “fringe” groups are becoming a creepingly larger category until it will eventually envelop anyone who thinks this administration is bad for the country.

    Black and white drawing of the tin woodman with his hands over his heart. 
By William Wallace Denslow - The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=7274871

    The meaning of words is quickly losing its foothold in reality. The opinion that racism and misogyny is a bad foundational policy is now being called radical. It will be the first time in my life I will be extremist anything. Hearing and reading the language being abused and manipulated by high-ranking members of government behooves us as writers and readers and bearers of history to hold our ground.

    It is critical to keep writing and to keep talking to each other and to keep reminding ourselves that it is good to imagine and fight for a better, more equitable world.

    It is also good to laugh, to find joy, to say to one another, we are not alone. Love is radical. Peace is radical. Creativity is radical. Showing up in solidarity is radical. There are monsters in the world who seek only to dominate, control, and diminish others, because they themselves are small human beings. We must challenge ourselves to grow, to learn, and to say aloud there is a better way.

    Perhaps my opening salvo after such a long period of silence is a rallying cry. For myself. To stop being frozen and overwhelmed and scared. My reach is small; my language, underdeveloped for the times. Here begins the first lesson.

    Hello, my name is Michelle. I am a writer. This is my voice.

14 responses to “Silence”

  1.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    It’s good to see you back, and this piece demonstrates the value—and necessity—of taking that occasional time off. It’s beautifully written and inspiring. The best thing we can do at this critical time is raise consciousness. At the risk of sounding trite, “the pen is mightier than the sword.”
    Love your use of the wizard of Oz characters!

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      Thanks! It’s been hard to convince myself to return to writing in the public sphere, but I know that we each have whatever skills, resources, time that we have and from that have to make some choices. For me, I know that means writing, reading, and continuing to foster connection. So I’m glad to have this little corner of the internet still.

  2. Nancy Avatar

    Once again, a post from The Green Study makes me feel a little more hopeful that there’s a tribe I’d be proud to be a part of out there somewhere. May voices like yours continue to reach out.

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      That’s nice to hear, Nancy. We’re so siloed these days from each other. I realize that connection becomes even more important when we’re under pressure. Just to acknowledge where we’re at, that we might be scared, and to move forward regardless.

  3. Walt Walker Avatar

    Words are meaningless now. There are too many of them out there, and no one is listening. Protests are meaningless, whether peaceful or otherwise. Whatever power they once had is gone. Only action matters now. People who care must take action in whatever way they can.

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      I’m not quite willing to give up the ghost. Still will be attending protests, still will be getting out in my community to help where I can. Where do words play a role? How do you inspire people to action without them? And how do people know there’s a strong opposition to what is happening unless they see others gathered in solidarity?

      Authoritarianism is designed to isolate and make people feel defeated. They don’t want us to live our lives fully, talk to each other, find strength and joy and cooperation, even on a local level. That’s where I’m starting – in the spaces available to me. Most of us aren’t grand strategists about where and when and how we take action, so we start where we are.

      1. Walt Walker Avatar

        I don’t disagree. I’m just not seeing traditional methods working anymore. The current administration and the right wing don’t give two shits about organized protest. There has to be organized action. Committed action. New kinds of action. I don’t know what that looks like, but if it’s going to work it’s going to be a new approach to confront a new reality.

  4. Lucinda E Clarke Avatar

    I’ve found with all the changes that I feel totally disconnected and unable to write. It’s like watching a sinking ship you cannot take your eyes off. I also feel betrayed as we had such admiration for your country before and now ask if it was all an illusion?

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      Hi Lucinda. You’re asking a complicated question! It was not all an illusion, but propaganda plays a huge role. Like any country, there are a lot of things to admire about the US, but we also have history – a history that has not been adequately reconciled with. If you build a country on bigotry (racism, misogyny, etc.), the foundation will eventually erode and will have to be shored up.

      We are in the uncomfortable stage of erosion, where people have acquired just enough freedom and rights to understand what the country could be, while living with the dysfunction of a corrupt system weighted for white wealthy cis males. Add in the huge and growing economic disparities, easy access to weapons, and the internet as both an organizing and/or radicalizing tool and it’s a real shitshow.

      The holders of power are playing the long game to hold onto that power (since the 1970s). This administration is a mere continuation – openly pursuing racist and sexist policies, using the military and law enforcement to intimidate and scare us into acquiescence. They’ve pried open every societal schism to divide us – immigration, reproductive rights, civil rights – in order to keep us in conflict with each other. It’s working at the moment.

      Did not mean to write an entire essay as comment and there are other people better suited to explaining what is happening!

  5. Mike McCabe Avatar

    I loved the article. I think what I like most is the fact that you don’t speak specifcally on any certain thing. And honestly, at the end of the day, are any of those certain things really worth fighting for?

    The real enemy, I believe, is the puppet masters starting all the squabbles between us. Making any individual with an open mind and an opinion that is likened to common sense be demonized.

    Basically, I’d roll with ya. We could be cowards together. The real enemy is not flesh and blood…

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      I don’t think I did myself any favors being vague. I’m one of those “radical” liberals who believes a lot of things are worth fighting for.

  6. Mike McCabe Avatar

    Until we all look past our differences and can see the humanity in each other; we’re fucked. Will just be in this bullshit game they want us to play.

    It’s ignorant. There’s so many of us and so few of them. It would take a small portion to stand up say we’ve had enough time for shit to change.

    But no, we’re still pretending racism is a problem, or any other ism you like.

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      You are absolutely correct in that the there are more people who are against what is happening than those for it.

      I do disagree about the dismissal of racism or other -isms. Listening to the lived experiences of others as well as looking at stats/data suggests that we far from being an equitable society and bigotry plays a huge role in that. In my lived experience as a woman veteran and parent of a daughter, I can tell you sexism is alive and well. Reproductive rights are not some ideological mind game – there are real world consequences and women suffering as a result.

      The current administration has seized the opportunity by applying crowbars to cracks that were already there, but they are making substantive policy changes. Even if it is an intentional on their part to distract us, the underlying issues remain. Regardless, we can fight on a lot of fronts – and people are – from individual issues to being anti-authoritarian.

  7. kirizar Avatar

    I fear confrontation on even the most benign issues. The larger issues give me fits/hyperventilation. But, you can be afraid and still do what you can to fight for what you believe it. Even it is simply stating an opinion in a world where that opinion can put a target on you. When you wrote the following, it was a warning as well as a truth becoming more true every day:

    “The “fringe” groups are becoming a creepingly larger category until it will eventually envelop anyone who thinks this administration is bad for the country.”

Leave a Reply