• Black and gray grenade made out of keyboard buttons.

    All week I’ve heard from my liberal friends that they are doing self-care, self-soothing, and self-isolation. My grief and disappointment about this country unmasked has taken the form of manic, simmering rage. I am reconciling the country that indoctrinated me into the military on cold war patriotism with one that is intent on whoring itself out to whatever dictator smiles prettiest upon our next president. I am trying to sort truth from propaganda – the pious religiosity of churchgoing monsters with their moral turpitude of worshiping a rapist, racist, and felon. How do I reconcile my desire as a woman for progress and a better future for my daughter with the vile trad wives of conservatism?

    Light skimming of the news shows that all the most malevolent, corrosive white people in America are being nominated into thrones of national power – the dog killer for Homeland Security, a Fox ghoul for Defense Secretary, Dolores Umbridge, the new Chief of Staff with Voldemort lite as deputy chief, the quivering White Fish Belly in charge of a made up government efficiency group, and the list goes on. If you’re an unqualified cult worshipper who has your lips firmly planted on the dotard’s ass, you’re in. If you like science, have high ethical standards, critical thinking skills, any morals at all, or diplomatic bonafides, there’s the exit. Welcome to the age of Authoritarian incompetency – incompetency that will erode our country domestically and destroy diplomatic ties abroad (and put us on a war footing). Not to mention the embarrassment from the jabbering old dude in charge of it all.

    Drawing of a hand holding a compass.

    I am trying to remember what good character is, what ethics truly are, and what integrity means. Having a moral compass and holding tight to it is the only way to navigate forward. What does this mean in a world run by histrionic sociopathic billionaires, white women who only want to “help”, and a large percentage of the American public who will believe whatever their creepy old uncle tells them?

    Many people will try to justify themselves, but I keep these ideas in mind:

    Men being directed to tend money tree by man standing on pile of money.
    • Having money and power doesn’t make a person intelligent. There’s a slyness at working a capitalist system and all its leaky loopholes, but that is one very particular kind of skill set.
    • Believing in god(s) gives no one inherent empathy, kindness, or decency. There is an ability when having faith in things unseen, to more easily believe that what one can see is not the truth. Conspiracy and denial are the slippery slope that many people have willingly slid down and allowed to fuel their hate-filled screeds about the others.
    • Having expertise in one area does not make one an expert in every area. Now that we have more years ahead of mentally warped mostly white people running our country into the ground, it is important to remember that the podium, platform, and loudspeaker does not lend veracity or credibility.
    • Popularity was never a barometer of good choices.
    • People lie a lot about their belief systems. To themselves and to each other.
    • Intelligence, thoughtfulness, and critical thinking is not highly valued in this country.
    • Exploitation by the wealthy and the blaming of others by the exploited is the American way.
    • Short attention spans are a gift to capitalist thieves.

    I recognize how harsh this may read, but the pragmatism of surviving an authoritarian regime begs us not to pull punches. As I read, once again, Gene Sharp’s works on nonviolent action, it is clear that the above ideas occlude and impede one’s ability to influence other humans. We don’t speak a common language, so how can we organize for a common cause or make any progress to save ourselves or the planet?

    With those things in mind, what is there to hold fast to? There is something to be said for groundlessness, the acceptance of impermanence, the ability to let go and let be. Being human was always this, no matter how we tried to anchor ourselves to belief systems to feel a degree of certainty. We all die – and no power, money, or social media traffic stats will change that. Young pretty influencers will wither away into invisible old women and buff gym bros will shrivel up into leathery loudmouths at the end of the bar. And to dust they all will go. Old people in power will pass their money to their ungrateful spawn who will strangle the rest of the world, in the desperate attempt to hold on to delusions of security and ego. That it has reached such a bloated, inequitable state is a matter of scale. More people to exploit means that more people will be exploited.

    “Authoritarianism begins when we can no longer tell the difference between the true and the appealing. At the same time, the cynic who decides that there is no truth at all is the citizen who welcomes the tyrant.”
    ― Timothy Snyder, The Road to Unfreedom: Russia, Europe, America

    Hand coming out of water to reach for life preserver that is being thrown from a boat.

    I recognize that as a human, I play a role in all of this. I grew up in poverty, but I’ve reached the illusion of a solidly middle class existence. I’m a white woman and I’ve just watched a majority of voters in my demographic once again betray all women, as they have done over the centuries. Much of this is the outcome of toxic patriarchal norms that has so begrudgingly handed autonomy to women and seeks to take any of it back. We are soaked in misogyny – fish who do not recognize that we are in water. Some women assume there will be some safety in whiteness, in maleness, in belief of an afterlife, as if any of that had inherent value beyond a history of exploitation and denial of responsibility.

    Whew. It’s a lot. As I said, manic, simmering rage. Where do I go with this?

    Graphics with the word Democracy torn up.

    In some ways, it’s very simple and in others, complicated. The golden rule is an easy one, until you recognize that some people aren’t operating in the same moral sphere or have developed such toxic self-involved habits as to be inured to the suffering of others. We speak the language of therapy now without the accompanying language of responsibility. We speak of rights, but little of obligations. We rail on about freedoms when what we mean is freedom from caring about others. It’s a Libertarian wet dream. Throw in conservative faux morality, gun fetish, and culture war wanking and it’s porn for the American power structures. And we haven’t even gotten to the actual porn which has warped some humans so much that they’d rather screw robots (and often treat other humans as if they were receptacles) than learn how to become fully-fledged humans with relationship and communication skills. P.S. I’d much prefer people screwing robots versus going on shooting rampages. That would be a great trade-in. Give us your guns and we’ll give you a Kitty-Tits-Light-Up. Women could live unimpeded.

    I thought I had a point, but no, still angry. Usually I can write myself into a circumspect, thoughtful place. I don’t want to add to the anger in the world. But I know that moving forward requires that I acknowledge this feeling that the tide has shifted in a direction where all of this has been normalized. Part of me is screaming this is not normal. This is not moral or ethical. This is not the world I want for my daughter.

    Anger is the easy part.

    What comes next is surely more difficult. What is my role in all of this? Where have I gone blithely through my life with a magic eye, seeing only what I want to see? What actions have I or am I taking to make the world any better? When has the visible and invisible hand of power and privilege in my life come at the expense of someone else’s? To what degree is learned helplessness and complacency part of my character? What do I owe to others? How do I move forward feeling a sense of distrust and in many cases, dislike, of my fellow citizens?

    Don’t mistake this for blame-shifting. I wholeheartedly blame a lot of people for the shit storm we are entering. Mostly those with money and power who have wielded it as a sword against others instead of as a shield for the most vulnerable. But unlike the conservative grievance philosophy, I know that I have little control over what others do and that blame, in and of itself, is the refuge of lazy thinking. My locus of control is how I react to them and how I conduct myself going forward. What are my priorities? What are my beliefs? What are my obligations?

    Tattered American flag.

    Perhaps someday I’ll go back to writing fluffy little essays about my garden, but today is not that day. It’s been a minute since we decided that it was time for the end of democracy. We’ve not even begun to see the outcome of handing the keys of the country to an authoritarian felon, who sexually assaulted women, and his incompetent fascist lackeys. It might be some time until I simmer down.

20 responses to “Moving Through the Sludge of Moral Equivalency”

  1.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    where can I u subscribe to this piffle

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      I’m assuming you mean “unsubscribe”. You can unsubscribe following the instructions here: https://wordpress.com/support/unsubscribe-from-a-wordpress-com-blog/#unsubscribe-without-a-wordpress-com-account

  2. maryplumbago Avatar

    This is so excellent and perfectly stated. I saved it to re read in the future..it’s an exceptional piece. Woe is the person who can’t see the writing on the wall and lives in a delusion of self denial, the darker side of man and a stubborn lack of critical thinking and empathy to others.
    I thank you.

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      Thank you for your kind comment. I am filled with self-doubt when I let my anger get the better of me and maybe I need to be more incisive about the targets of my ire. But at the heart of it is fear and anxiety about what has happened. It’s hard to process.

      1. maryplumbago Avatar

        Funny how we are all different in how we deal with ominous changes in either our society or big things like climate change. I seem to take a long view, that we are all here briefly, mankind is very often his own worst enemy, all civilizations eventually come to failure and ruin, new ones arise; often worse and we go back to the Dark Ages for a period of time, then reform or a renaissance of lofty ideals returns and on and on it goes….
        But this time I do think time is running out (climate change) and the times feel like they will be darker and longer than before. But as they say in the small or bigger picture “All good things must come to an end.” Just the way the universe and life operates. It’s always changing…
        I guess you could say I’m a fatalist.

  3. Under the mask.. Avatar

    We’re right there with you, with the exceptions of one local and more midwestern fam/-in-laws from whom, once again, i am feeling somewhat estranged. As with the global pandemic, there’s no good way to process this new, worse virus in our midst. We’ve not been here before, either — though analysts tell us we were always on our way. The question keeps coming back: How did ANYone of any sphere and demographics vote FOR him — he has insulted / slandered / endangered everyone in this nation (and well beyond). As you say, we each and all have to try to find a non-violent resistance.. 🌷

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      I’ve been skipping all the punditry related to the loss, because to me it will only make sense in the crudest, angriest way (as evidenced by this post). At least for now. I am trying to remind myself that authoritarianism works best when people are depressed and hopeless. Learning to move from hopelessness to joyful nonviolent resistance is, I think, the only way through.

  4. edyjournal Avatar

    I feel you and wish I had something smart or helpful to say that wouldn’t pour gasoline on the fire, but I don’t. Commenting just so you know others are with you, because I strongly believe the 72M (and then some) need to function as a team.

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      I don’t think I’m in the smart helpful phase yet either. Perhaps this is all to send up a flare to the like-hearted people out there that while we’ve been knocked back a bit, we’re not going away.

  5. Donna Cameron Avatar

    It seems impossible to write logically and analytically about insanity that’s spreading like a cancer. You’ve expressed the rage, despair, and bewilderment that so many of us are feeling. That’s more than I can do at this time, Michelle. I’m not able to engage with my usual media sources—the pain is too piercing, but in case you haven’t seen it, I will share what George Saunders posted to his mailing list Sunday, explaining that Story Club will remain a non-political forum, except just this once (sorry this makes my comment so long, but it’s worth reading).
    George Saunders:
    “Now, in that spirit…about the election.  (My one final overtly political post.)
    “I am, above all else, an artist.  As an artist, I am trying to be interested in what has just happened. I am trying to maintain two ideas at once: 1) Most people who voted for Trump are nice people.  (I know this because many close friends and family members voted for him and, well, more than half of voters did), and 2) Our democracy really may be in peril. Trump has repeatedly said things to indicate this and people who worked closely with him the first time have said this. 
    “So, what I’m trying to figure out is: how do the people who voted for Trump, some of whom I love, not see what I see in him?  And, also, importantly: what am I not seeing, about the way the world looks to them?  I’m not saying that the way they see it is right – I feel very strongly otherwise – but I am saying, or accepting that, yes, it really does look that way to them. 
    “If I don’t understand it, that’s on me (as a thinker, as a writer). (If trees suddenly started walking around, I’d want to understand that, once the shock died down.  Because, you know…it’s interesting. And that’s my job, to be curious about things that happen.) 
    “This is something we talk about often here and are trying to train ourselves to do: coming, via process, to a better understanding of something that we can’t, in real life, readily understand.
    “Somehow, strangely, this is going to be easier for me because the election was free and fair and because the Trump side won decisively.
    “I’m not sure why this is true, but it is.
    “For those of you who voted for Trump, I’d just say, in the most loving way: Friends, you’re on the hook. 
    “It’s your movement now.
    “It’s on us too, of course, on those of us who were and are against what he stands for – but you have a special role in whatever happens next.  No excuses: he made it very clear what he intended, and you gave him a mandate to do it.
    “So, when and if the rounding up of undocumented immigrants begins, and it’s brutal, that’s on you.  When and if he comes for those “enemies from within,” that’s on you. When and if people on the periphery (gay people, trans people) suffer, when the economy tanks, because tariffs are a terrible idea, when we jettison even our currently ineffective attempts to reverse climate change, when women’s reproductive healthcare continues to degrade…well, I’m sorry to say so, but you voted for all of that.
    “You did.”
    (George Saunders)

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      I am questioning my own judgment of posting when I’m so angry, but that anger is not going away. I’m still trying to figure out how to move forward as a creative in a world that I feel I can no longer relate to – there is a level of gaslighting in all of this – that we are supposed to think electing someone so destructive and cruel is normal or okay just because so many people think it is. At some point, though, I will return to the idea that one must perpetuate kindness and not rage, but I’m just not there.

      Thanks for sharing the George Saunders statement – I love his writing and I envy his extremely sly, but gentle way of saying a preemptive “I told you so”. Unfortunately, we will not enjoy the spoils of being right, because things will be bad for all of us except the insulated wealthy.

  6. kirizar Avatar

    While I enjoyed looking up ‘Dotard’ (a word I thought you’d coined for the circumstances we find ourselves in) and “Occlude” to make sure I understood it correctly, my favorite lines of all were these:

    “I wholeheartedly blame a lot of people for the shit storm we are entering. Mostly those with money and power who have wielded it as a sword against others instead of as a shield for the most vulnerable. “

    This is the phrase I will take with me…a shield for the storm ahead.

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      I have mixed feelings about name-calling, but that particular one, “dotard” is courtesy of the North Korean Foreign Ministry back in 2017, when they referred to Trump.

  7.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    wow..I still got it….made a copy just for myself. Loved it

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      Thanks. I’m a little embarrassed by the post, but glad that some people got something from it.

  8. Walt Walker Avatar

    Based on what you said in the follow up, I was expecting something much worse. This strikes me as appropriate for what is happening, and nothing at all to be ashamed of (which I say as someone with a lot of experience in posting in emotional states and then deleting in shame). Maybe it’s because I’m furious, too. Or maybe more numb, at this point. I think I’ve passed through all five stages of grief at this point. I’m ever so slightly encouraged, very cautiously and hesitantly encouraged, about the whispers I’m hearing regarding opposition to some appointees by those within the (very soulless and cowardly) party itself. As wise man once said, we have to be optimistic. We have no choice.

    1. Michelle at The Green Study Avatar

      I don’t know what is or isn’t appropriate at this point, but my preference would be that I keep my vitriol much more targeted and much less burdened by name-calling. I like my rage to have more precision, I guess. Also, whew, anger can get long-winded.

      I’m usually on board with an optimistic spin, but beyond this particular regime, learning what half my fellow Americans believe has been difficult. The misogyny and racism are deadly, and the proud embrace of deliberate ignorance is mystifying. I’ve been disabused of the notion of inherent good, the arc of justice, etc. Each unmasking worse than the next.

      But I am pragmatic in that moving forward is the only way to go. What that looks like for me personally and for organizational movements that I support is the question.

  9.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    i love this essay. -Diana

  10.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Hi Michelle, You write beautifully. That is as important when handling fire as anywhere. I also honor your bravery in speaking out. I am glad to call you friend.

    I have too many thoughts to put here. Maybe you will receive an email later, or not. You are still a woman of humor, I am glad to see, even when facing the after burn of speaking clearly.

    Oh god, how can I laugh?

    I also notice the Buddhist words “groundlessness, impermanence, letting go”. I do feel that there lies an answer in Buddhist concepts even in the present moment. It was not meant to be an easy journey, was it? Our shared anger is expressed in outrage, shock, and fear for the future. For me, the hardest part is falling into outrage, because my righteous mind enjoys the feeling, the rush of believing I am right! It is a drug. I don’t exactly know how to counter this with wisdom. I try desperately to see the pitiful damaged child in the people I believe have embraced evil self-interest. I am an admirer of Quan Yin’s limitless compassion. I am afraid she is an ideal well beyond my ken. I could weep for my smallness, my narrow heart. My self-interest.

    I read this aloud to my Sweetheart. He also gave a nod to your skill with words. When we talked about the question of innate goodness in humanity, what came up for him was that the true goodness in humanity is at odds with survival and the insular view of their own community. He pointed out that the sickness of greed always overwhelmed everything else.

    Now he had wandered into the other room to listen to the Hawaiian group “Hapa” (meaning part Hawaiian, seems appropriate.) We all need to find the succor that gives us strength. I watched a film on FB (first time in months), where some beachie blond white dude took an old Indian man out of his search for food in the street garbage, sat him down, cut his hair, washed him with soap and water, dried him and dressed him in new clothes. Then he shared a pizza with him. (Must have been a big city, in my three weeks in India I never saw Pizza.) I need hope. I need to honor every good intention I find.

    Thank you.

  11. kioratash Avatar

    this was from Kiora… it did not see me for some reason!

Leave a Reply