A few thoughts about branding and marketing
Why we seem to have forgotten what a brand actually is, and how to remember
I have been thinking about the ideas in this essay for a while, and deliberately waited to write them down. The idea was that this would serve as a backgrounder of sorts for the last two essays, which were more practical and immediately usable frameworks (I’ll share links below if you want to go back to them, keep reading for now).
Why is this backgrounder important, though? Because I think we seem to have forgotten what a real brand actually is. and why we actually set about constructing one in the first place. And regular readers know that it’s a bit of a theme of our newsletter, and something I believe in, that the answer is usually in the fundamentals, the basics.
Let’s get to it then. So what is a brand, and what does it do? The word comes from Old Norse, brandr, referring to the mark that horse and cattle owners used to burn onto their livestock so they could distinguish one pack from another and verify ownership. And the traditional industry definition, the one the American Marketing Association gives us, is something that identifies one seller’s goods or services as distinct and different from another’s. Simple enough. But what does a brand do in our context? Like with the horses, it clarifies ownership, and therefore helps make a decision. For us, that’s usually a buying decision.
This is what we are trying to do as startups as well, aren’t we? We want to construct an identity and manufacture a certain credibility, one that comes from looking and feeling a certain way. Why? So that customers can trust us to do the job they are hiring us for. And in an age of AI, our brand, they way we look and feel, the way we are perceived, the way that the product feels recommend-able, cool, become extremely important. They are the only way to gain an upper hand in a world where the barriers to entry have fallen, and the cost of build, though not zero, has become stupidly accessible to every developer.
It is with this understanding that we have to go back to the basics and actually ask ourselves what brand means for us in our category and industry. And because this is different for different founders and marketers, there is no specific answer. You have to find it for yourself.
What I can do is show you my mental model as a template.
When I was a young boy, I realised that my father, when ready to go to work, always smelled of Old Spice. It is the scent, to me, of what it means to be a man. And therefore it is the aftershave I have always used. Will it be easy to break this association? No, it will be almost impossible. But if this is the insight across a lot of Old Spice’s user demographic, it gives Old Spice the idea of how to keep me as a customer, and how to pass it on to the next generation. But the insight could also help new startups (like The Man Company or Beardo) attack Old Spice, or choose to win a different demographic, like Gen Z.
In the 2010s at Freshworks, when we were considering whether we should buy a tool for social media scheduling, I immediately chose Buffer. And I stuck to that choice even though there were other, even cheaper alternatives. Buffer as a brand, their superiority in content marketing, their design: All of this told me that I was the kind of marketer who would choose Buffer. And I did. Later, in Seth Godin’s book This is Marketing, I read one of the most important lessons of my career: People like us do things like this. I understood it immediately because that was how I was making decisions. Your job as a founder and marketer is to make your product the exact solution your kind of customer will choose.
One of the earliest brand plays I remember was when Pepsi, during the 1996 Cricket World Cup, were outbid by Coca-Cola for official sponsorship rights. And they responded with the Nothing Official About It campaign featuring a boyish Sachin. The ads instantly turned heads and put Pepsi on the map that season. It is a touchstone in modern Indian marketing and also lives rent-free in the heads of a certain kind of millennial, including me. It taught me how to be seen as a rebel brand, something startups understand. It’s a learning I use often.
Why did I tell you these stories? Because these explain how I as a marketer think about brand. And because I feel we have been overthinking brand and brand-building.
As marketers, we are probably the only department that’s closer to art than science in the modern org chart. And where does most good art come from? It comes from the personal. This is also what I’m saying here. I think we have to unwrap the jargon and other bubble wrap around branding as founders/marketers, and ask ourselves over and over again, what is the insight here, what is the story, who are we telling it to. And finally, the most important question: Are we building the kind of brand we actually want to be?
If we attempt to answer these questions, I think we will build better, greater, and much more effective brands.
I would encourage you to read the previous two essays that I wrote here, both of which deal with different aspects of startup branding.
The Rapid-Fire Brand framework for startups (a 5 step system for startup branding)
4 hard questions on brand building for startups (how to make sure your ideas survive organisational realities)
And finally, a quiet milestone. It is now 6 years since I’ve started writing this newsletter. There is a bit of a celebration on the way, but I’ll wait until next month to share it with you all. :)
Until then, read on, and if you are new here, do join 5,200+ marketers who choose to get The CMO Journal in their inbox every week. Subscribe!








