Dearest Lovelies
This is a small thing that I've seen alot lately. However, I don't think that it is actually happening more than usual- I think that it's just because we've had more priv players than lately.
And this is no particular priv player- In fact, I think that this is something that I witnessed from a lot of priv players, maybe most priv players, and it kinda makes me go o.O.
Scenerio:
User asks question. Priv player submits answer which is basically approvable. Priv player writes his/her priv play stating listing all of the things that are needed to make the answer approvable (all are present in said priv players screened answer). So far, so good, right? Right. Priv player goes on to list "extras" or "shinies" that would make the answer better. Still good- except that not all of the shiny elements are included in the priv players screened answer.
Hmm..
Please remember that priv players are like super i2s. They're expected to answer with all of their i2ly ability (within reason- obviously all of us have some days where our answers are better than others), plus they're being asked to participate in this new level of training. And if you priv play on a request saying that you know that XYZ element would make the answer better, then it should probably be in your answer. Otherwise, it will reflect poorly on your answer writing (which of course, is still being assessed as you priv play).
Disclaimer: This is a statement of Chrissy's opinion as someone that is responsible for looking over priv players, not a statement of policy or anything from The Powers That Be
And this is no particular priv player- In fact, I think that this is something that I witnessed from a lot of priv players, maybe most priv players, and it kinda makes me go o.O.
Scenerio:
User asks question. Priv player submits answer which is basically approvable. Priv player writes his/her priv play stating listing all of the things that are needed to make the answer approvable (all are present in said priv players screened answer). So far, so good, right? Right. Priv player goes on to list "extras" or "shinies" that would make the answer better. Still good- except that not all of the shiny elements are included in the priv players screened answer.
Hmm..
Please remember that priv players are like super i2s. They're expected to answer with all of their i2ly ability (within reason- obviously all of us have some days where our answers are better than others), plus they're being asked to participate in this new level of training. And if you priv play on a request saying that you know that XYZ element would make the answer better, then it should probably be in your answer. Otherwise, it will reflect poorly on your answer writing (which of course, is still being assessed as you priv play).
Disclaimer: This is a statement of Chrissy's opinion as someone that is responsible for looking over priv players, not a statement of policy or anything from The Powers That Be