A few years ago, I published this essay about how I had finally quit biting my nails. I look back on it now and wrinkle my nose in distain for my younger self. How foolish! How naive! Who was I, to think I had quit this compulsion I’ve harbored for 30 years?
I confess: I am still a nail biter. That little blip in 2023 when I had stopped was a cute little respite.
Now I wear press-ons. This is probably not good for me in the long term, but they’re a lot harder to bite than my natural nails and they look way nicer.
I hate that I bite my nails. I feel so ashamed of it because I know it’s disgusting and it’s completely irrational. It never eases my nerves. In fact, it gives me more to worry about because 1) germs and 2) I assume that anyone who sees my stubby little fingers will think I’m a little nervous freak. Maybe I am a nervous little freak, come to think of it. And how could anyone—myself included—love a nervous little freak?
The only thing that comforts me in my shame is knowing that everyone has compulsions. We all do things we wish we wouldn’t, but we simply can’t help ourselves. It’s a form of self-sabotage. We are driving the car in the crash we can’t look away from.
Sometimes, these compulsions are so bad professional medical help is necessary. But there is a huge grey space below that threshold. What is the difference between a compulsion and a quirk? Or extreme dedication? Or just letting our nerves or frustrations or hurt get the best of us in an act we immediately regret? It’s a space I’ve been exploring a lot recently.
With that, welcome to this series of fictional short stories. I’m calling it Compulsions. Enjoy!
Healed.
Doug broke it off with me last March while I was doing my intervals on a treadmill. He texted me to say that after 6 months, he wasn’t sure if he’d enjoy the sex with me down the line.
This came the day after he agreed that our arrangement—without labels, of course—was working for him. Because this was the most commitment I had ever received from Doug, I rewarded him with some tasteful nudes.
“I just don’t think we’re what each other is looking for,” Siri read to me in her neutral, robotic voice. My shock caused me to lose my footing and I flew off the treadmill, bruising my elbow on the lockers behind me. Thank goodness this was Planet Fitness, a Judgement-Free Zone.
My ego? Crushed. My self-esteem? Subterranean. On top of everything, his name was Doug. What kind of 29-year-old man was named Doug? Maybe that’s why he didn’t like the sex. It’s not exactly a moan-able name.
I cried on my way home, sipping the protein shake a concerned staff member had passed to me as I hobbled away and promised not to sue. I was hurt and ashamed. Not only had I spent half a year trying to convince a Millennial man with a Gen X name to like me, but I failed.
But all that’s in the past now. I’m nine months recovered from that insult. I’m thriving. I’ve had sex with two more people, neither of whom had any complaints, and I haven’t fallen on a run—indoor or outdoor—since.
I also have a new boyfriend! Well, maybe. It’s early on—only two months. He’s in his 30s and has an age-appropriate name: Arik. He seems to like spending time with me, and I enjoy myself well enough with him, even though one of his rotating jokes is just using a Jar Jar Binks voice. I am willing to overlook that, considering his enthusiasm for cunnilingus. We’re talking hours here. That’s all time I don’t have to contend with the voice of a Gungan.
I barely even think about Doug anymore. Well, except for recently. All these memories of getting to know him kept popping up as I’ve been getting to know Arik. It’s okay, though, because I read an article that said it’s normal to have flashbacks of traumatic relationships when you’re entering a healthy one.
That may actually have been a TikTok, but I’m sure it was based on an article somewhere. The person speaking into her phone with a ring light said that it’s all part of the healing process.
And I am healing just fine! Arik recently agreed to let me come with him to buy new shoes. That’s definitely a sign that it may be serious one day.
Because I am moving into this new, recovered phase of life, I decided to unblock Doug on Instagram. I remembered it was his birthday recently. He’s a Capricorn—famous for being stubborn and blunt with squishy emotional cores. I wanted to tell him that I forgive him for what happened between us, it being the new year and all.
To my shock, I found that he had reposted several pictures on his story of his “girlfriend” Veronica wishing him a happy birthday. Or maybe girlfriend, without the quotes—he hard-launched her in one of his subsequent stories.
This was an outrage! A committed relationship, after he told me the most he could handle was coming over for a night every couple of weeks? After I was the perfect low-commitment non-exclusive girlfriend. Well, okay—“girlfriend.”
I clicked on Veronica’s Instagram page. She was beautiful. There are videos of her busking in a subway station with her open guitar case decorated with dollar bills. She curated a capital-l Look, wearing things like a statement poodle skirt or horn-rimmed glasses or a noxiously bright lip. Sure enough, there are Doug’s heart eyes emoji comments littered her posts. One even had the filthy drooling emoji. What a simp.
My first thought was he chose her over me because I’m not artsy enough. I hate this about myself. Curse my parents choosing to have sex in the new year to have a pragmatic Virgo daughter! I will always be too much for the creative types to whom I am drawn.
But then, because I am mature, I remembered that Arik liked my sensibility. He appreciated the dinner reservations I made and the offer I made to replace his boots with the hole in the sole.
A lump formed in the back of my throat. I quickly re-blocked Doug. No need to subject myself to that anymore.
But then I remembered something my favorite therapist on TikTok told me: It takes years to overcome an anxious attachment style, which Doug clearly had. It all made sense—Doug didn’t choose to be happy with Veronica instead of me, he simply wasn’t happy! This was all an Instagram facade!
Silly me. I bet Doug was doing just the same and working at that bartender job he had in between gigs. Doug was an artist, too. An actor, actually. My understanding was that his biggest role was as Gary the Snail in a nationally touring version of “Spongebob: The Musical.” I never told him I knew this because frankly, it’s embarrassing, and I wanted to protect his dignity because I am very compassionate.
I decided that I would still be the bigger person. He didn’t deserve a DM explaining my forgiveness! No—these kinds of conversations are best had in person.
I called Arik to ask if he’d like to get a drink at the Irish pub where Doug works. Of course, I didn’t tell him Doug would be there—that would be weird. Arik initially declined, but then I reminded him that it was in the same suburban strip mall as a Nordstrom Rack, so we could get him some new shoes.
He perked up instantly. “Okee-day!” he chirped, and I wasn’t even bothered. I picked him up 20 minutes later.
My astrology app said that Mars was in Libra and sure enough we were in luck! As soon as we walked into the bar, empty except for a few older men glaring at each other from afar to avoid any potential small talk, I spotted Doug wearing his uniform green bow tie and tan apron. He had cut his hair, but it was now slicked back in a weird way that heightened his widow’s peak. Sad!
Arik and I took two stools covered in a green shiny plastic on the other side of the bar from Doug. “Exsqueeze me!” Arik called, and I immediately started rummaging in my purse for nothing. I was hoping to have a little more time in between Binks outbursts.
As Doug approached us, I looked up in time to see a brief flicker of recollection on his face. Then surprise. Got ‘em! I tossed my hair, which had grown at least four inches since he last saw me, and I cricked my neck. I willed my eyes not to tear up as I made polite but determined eye contact.
“I’ll have a Guinness, please,” Arik said, mercifully in his regular voice.
Doug nodded and turned to me. “Hey, long time, no see. What will it be?”
“Oh, I didn’t realize you worked here—I’ll have the same as my boyfriend,” I said, flashing a smile and letting that sink in for effect.
Neither man responded to my words. Arik was looking around the bar curiously, as if he only realized how strange it was that we were some of the only people here on a Wednesday afternoon. Doug nodded and turned to get the drinks.
I decided that it would be better to get it all out there so we could all be adults about this. “Just so you know, I forgive you!” I blurted.
Doug turned back. “What?”
“I get that you’re still probably hurting from the way things ended between us,” I said, using my gentlest, most gracious voice. “I just wanted to know that to tell you that I forgive you in the hopes that it’ll help you move on.”
“Oh, um, thanks, “ Doug said. “I’ll get those drinks for you.” I noticed triumphantly the pink creeping up his neck as his gaze moved away from me. Good! He should feel some remorse!
Rather than leaving to go grab our drinks, though, he smiled and waved at someone behind me. I turned.
Adorned in layers of bright and mismatched outerwear, there was Veronica. Her cheeks were perfectly rosy from the cold. I was annoyed, but then I realized it was probably a calculated, exaggerated blush application.
The old me would have been flustered. Thank goodness I’m healed. I retained control of the moment.
“Hi, babe!” she called. “Thought I’d visit you at work!” I groaned inwardly. Of course she’d be sweet and peppy.
She kept her smile as she made her way toward us, noticing how we were all clustered together. She had to know we all knew each other; the sexual tension was palpable, probably.
Veronica picked the stool right next to us to sit down. “Hi, I’m Veronica,” she said as reached up to ensure her try-hard beret was in place.
“I didn’t know that,” I replied coolly, and I stood up to leave. Nice save, I thought as I confidently strode out the door, leaving my coat and my boyfriends behind.
























