(Note: This is one of an occasional and ongoing series of assessments of my favorite albums, parsed by musical genre. Click Here for a series introduction and list of all genres covered, or to be covered, therein).
Background: I was raised in both a religious and a musical household, and those two threads of my upbringing were often interwoven. We were what I’d consider to be a conventional mainstream Southern Protestant family until my early teen years, attending different churches as we moved around the country with my father’s Marine Corps career, usually ending up at United Methodist places of worship, consistent with my dad’s upbringing. My parents experienced a strong religious awakening when I was in junior high school, and generally joined more nondenominational, Bible-based congregations in the years that followed. The church music of my Methodist years was entirely shaped by The Book of Hymns, which served as the official hymnal for that denomination from 1966 to 1989; I flipped its pages often enough over the years that I’d still be able to pretty quickly find key compositions or “Acts of Praise” when the need arises. My father typically sang in church choirs, both for regular weekly services, and for holiday presentations of Handel’s Messiah, one of his favorite works. He was also a serviceable guitar player, though he tended to strum and noodle on secular works, not spiritual ones, when he took up his acoustic axe.
Attending Methodist Youth Fellowship events in the 1970s, I was exposed to a variety of nascent “Christian Rock” acts, somewhat cynically designed to present the WORD to kids in a more engaging and palatable fashion than offered by straight scripture reading or the organ-backed choral music that shaped the actual worship services. That stuff rarely appealed to or worked for me, though, as I was already musically knowledgeable and sophisticated enough to recognize that much of it was auditory pap, with various lowest common denominators in full effect, the nature of the message deemed more important than the quality of the songs and performances. It was stiff, and staid, and sub-optimal, for sure.
I was much more taken by gospel music that was outside the traditional Methodist hymnal, but had developed organically over decades (if not centuries), rather than being created by the marketing departments of various Christian publishing houses to make religion seem more hip to the youth. The term “gospel song” is first recorded in the United States in 1874, generally to describe the types of call-and-response performances, often backed only by hand claps and toe taps (or big foot stomps), of the working songs sung by enslaved Africans, which eventually drifted into the rural churches of the Southern white communities who did the enslaving. To this day, there are two primary threads in American Gospel music, nominally Black Gospel and Southern Gospel. (The latter eventually spun off what’s generally called Country Gospel these days, which puts the WORD atop the stock and glossy sorts of arrangements deployed by popular country acts, more targeted to the modern NASCAR and pick-up truck and Cowboy-wannabe circuits than to the traditional denizens of the rural South).
Gospel publishing houses emerged in force during the 1920s to fuel the demand for appealing sacred music to be broadcast over the radio waves, with the great Thomas Dorsey arising as perhaps the finest composer within the idiom, merging spiritual texts with his own blues-based professional musical experiences, writing and publishing over 3,000 songs during his working career. After World War II, leading Black Gospel composers, conductors, and choir masters began to more fully integrate blues, R&B, soul, and jazz stylings into their arrangements, typically backing large gospel choirs with featured soloists. Reverend James Cleveland was a pioneer in this space, and his work touched or shaped the careers of many gospel artists who followed him. These rich forms of gospel music provided incubator spaces for generations of performers who went on to attain titanic levels of success, making both spiritual and secular songs, and driving the souls, minds, and hips of popular music aficionados to the present day.
Southern Gospel (of the “white” variety) tended to hew to traditional acoustic instrumentation and arrangements (guitars, banjos, fiddles, and autoharps feature regularly in such fare), and many ostensibly secular country or bluegrass artists would issue occasional gospel-specific albums mixed in with their non-religious fare. They generally did good business with such approaches, keeping one foot in the sacred space, and one in the profane, which works, because that is how most people actually live their lives, whether they’d openly admit it or not. My own chosen listening over the decades has been far less focused on Southern Gospel and far more on Black Gospel, as I prefer the joyous shout approach more than I do twangy soloists. There are, of course, exceptions to that general rule, largely driven by the Southern Gospel that both sets of my grandparents favored, often to the point of excess, when I was a child.
While Gospel Music has always been a part of my listening portfolio, I found it to be particularly comforting during the dark early days of the COVID pandemic. In May 2020, I wrote a post called No Meeting Tonight, in which I explored the concept of “Comfort Music,” described thusly:
We’re all familiar with the concept of “Comfort Food,” which we can succinctly describe as “food that provides consolation or a feeling of well-being, typically any with a high sugar or other carbohydrate content and associated with childhood or home cooking.”
I’m sure a lot of folks are turning to those comfort foods in quarantine. I am, though trying to limit consumption to avoid concomitant waist-spread. But I also find myself listening to “Comfort Music,” which I suppose I could describe by adapting the definition above: “Music that provides consolation or feeling of well-being, typically any with a highly melodic or other pleasing content and associated with childhood or music played by one’s family.”
Most of my Comfort Music is classic Southern church gospel music, Rev James Cleveland a special favorite. Not sure why he grabbed my attention as a kid, but he did, and those songs take me back to (mostly) easier times whenever I hear them. The iPod playlist we spin around the house has had a bunch of Rev James stuff on it for a few weeks now, along with some other classics of the genre by Sam Cooke and the Soul Stirrers, The Caravans, The Violinaires, Staple Singers, Shirley Caesar and others. It hits the spot, and gets the job done.
Gospel Music remains a vital and vibrant part of my listening life to this day, secular beast that I am. In that “No Meeting Tonight” post, I shared a dozen favorite gospel songs, and my Genre Delve exploration into my favorite Gospel albums features the home discs of many of those standalone cuts. Note that many of the great Gospel works of the 1920s to the 1950s were released as singles, often by small regional labels, which have been anthologized and compiled into album length formats over the past 50 years. I’ve generally avoided featuring such compilations in my list below, preferring instead to cite records that were originally intended to be long-playing discs, not single slices of spiritual solace. My Spotify playlist at the end of the post, on the other hand, includes a lot of those older single releases, should you wish to hear some of them.
MY TEN FAVORITE GOSPEL ALBUMS EVER (IN CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER)
1. Sister Rosetta Tharpe, Gospel Train (1956): An extraordinarily influential record by a singer-songwriter-guitarist who had been a radio/singles favorite for 15 years when she released this masterpiece. Credible arguments have been made to name Gospel Train as the very first rock n’ roll album (Sister Rosetta is in the Rock Hall of Fame), and its fuzzy guitar blues, jazz accompaniments, and soulful shouts are truly timeless.
2. The Caravans, The Caravans Sing (1958): The Caravans were formed by Robert Anderson in 1947, and served as one of the most formidable conduits of talent within the modern Gospel idiom. The 1958 group included singers Albertina Walker, Sarah McKissick, Inez Andrews, Shirley Caesar, backed by pianist Eddie Williams (who had just replaced James Cleveland). All of them were stars, and they shine brightly here.
3. Johnny Cash, Hymns by Johnny Cash (1959): The Man in Black began his career on Sam Phillips’ Sun Records, but soon left to sign with Columbia, because Phillips wouldn’t let him record a Gospel album. Hymns by Johnny Cash is a superb collection of original and adapted spiritual songs, the first (and best) of his religious records. The Love, God, Murder compilation (2000) summed up the importance of this canon to Cash.
4. The Staple Singers, Uncloudy Day (1959): The Staple Singers (a true family affair) released a variety of 10-inch/78-rpm singles throughout the 1950s, the best bits of which were assimilated onto this masterful debut LP. The group were titans in gospel, social justice, and pop music circles until patriarch Roebuck “Pops” Staples’ death in 2000, and daughter Mavis continues on as one of the great voices of our (or any) time.
5. Blind Gary Davis, Harlem Street Singer (1960): I learned about Gary Davis via gospel/blues aficionado Jorma Kaukonen, singer-guitarist of Jefferson Airplane/Hot Tuna, who covered a pair of Davis songs on his 1974 debut solo album, Quah. Davis’ finger-picking guitar style was hugely influential for many rock/folk artists in the 1960s-70s, and his original songs are often so perfect that they seem ancient, eternal, or timeless.
6. Rev. James Cleveland, Sings Songs of Dedication (1965): James Cleveland would be my “desert island gospel artist,” and I have more of his music than any other in the idiom. I first bought this album on cassette from a record chain’s close-out sale, and it quickly became a fave, with “Wondering” and “It’s Real” as top of the heap tracks for me. The swirly organ sounds here are magical, like attending a revival at a skating rink.
7. Elvis Presley, How Great Thou Art (1967): My paternal grandfather was essentially an invalid for the entirety of the time that my life and his overlapped. He spent most of his waking hours in his easy chair, within reach of his 8-track tape player, and How Great Thou Art played incessantly through my childhood, which I liked. Elvis released three gospel-specific albums, this one the middle (and best), but all of them are outstanding.
8. Aretha Franklin, Amazing Grace (1972): A sublime live recording of the Queen of Soul singing the songs that moved her spirit, backed by James Cleveland, The Southern California Community Choir, and rhythm beasts Chuck Rainey and Bernard Purdie. Amazing Grace was the best-selling album of Aretha’s career, and the best-selling live gospel album ever. The 2018 same-named documentary film of the set is essential.
9. The Violinaires, Greatest Hits (Recorded 1965-1971?, Released 1984?): Detroit’s Violinaires were founded in 1952, and were led by Robert Blair until his death in 2000. This excellent (but poorly documented) compilation seems to feature an assortment culled from their Checker Records catalog in the 1960s. It’s funky, forceful, timely, and topical; imagine The Temptations with a more spiritual focus for the general vibe.
10. Big Freedia, Pressing Onward (2025): I’m pleased to be able to feature a new album on a list anchored in the 1950s-70s. Big Freedia is a New Orleans legend, the “Queen Diva of Bounce,” a regional hip-hop strain. On this church-centric disc, Freedia merges massed choirs with bounce beats to awesome result. A warm, joyful, inclusive, and celebratory album, from an artist intolerant churches might damn, to their discredit.
As I will do for each installment in the Genre Delve series, I’ve linked my own personally-curated, 100-song Spotify playlist related to this article, below. You can sample songs from the albums and artists cited here, and also other Gospel favorites to give them setting and context. As always, I welcome your thoughts and reactions to my list, and your recommendations or suggestions for things that I might find interesting.










