George Hotz

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 6h • Edited • What if I release one zero day a day until a big new model is released? Will this finally make OpenAI and Anthropic shut up about "cybersecurity risk"? Like these things are not that hard to find in most software. I heard something about it costing $20k in tokens I'd do it for less if it wasn't for some whiny bug bounty program. The reason there aren't zero days everywhere is cause nobody seriously looks. Because hacking other people's shit with them is illegal and criminals are usually not very skilled, or they would choose a different line of work. Want more zero days to be found? Make hacking legal. Until then, don't try to claim it's hard, it's just not incentivized. …more 32 comments 19 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1d • You all do understand there's no moat around this AI stuff, right? Like if you think cars are deprecating assets, look at GPUs. I know I know the last 6 months, but now look over the last 10 years. Want to buy a 1080 Ti? You can barely give it away. Then if you think GPUs are depreciating assets, look at trained models. Anyone want to use GPT 4 (2023)? It cost $100M to train, and now those weights are worth less than Qwen3.5-27B, which cost about $1M to train. These moatless companies are about to IPO. OMG LOOK AT THE REVENUE GROWTH. Yea, it's not figure robot tier of bad, but I can also grow a companies revenue at this rate. It's called the revenue company and it works like this. I sell dollars for $0.99. Any volume. Those dollars will fly off the shelves. I might even be able to raise prices to $0.999. Look look we have something everyone wants and OUR REVENUE GROWTH IS INSANE. We might be losing a little money but that's so fine cause we are growing we'll just raise. I've never seen a dumber rollout than the AI rollout. Look at LinkedIn "Rewrite with AI" nobody wants this shit. If it's made by AI, it's worthless, cause anyone can make it with AI. This isn't growth of an economy, this is a few swindlers swindling with promises of some revolution or something then when it doesn't happen, sry no refunds. Maybe this finally pops the bubble on the whole US economy. I personally think AI is cool, but the real growth numbers that would need to justify all of this are not there. You are falling for hype. Hope you are prepared for the collapse. …more 1,009 95 comments 52 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2d • Edited • I learned an amazing truth from Buddhism. It goes like this. You want stuff. You think that getting stuff is the solution to your wanting of stuff. So you get stuff. But you find that this doesn't fix wanting. You just want new stuff. Better stuff. More stuff. It's almost like the solution to wanting never was getting, and you were a fool for ever thinking it was. Getting only makes the wanting worse. You know this is true. And yet, you keep selling out the future and your fellow man to get stuff. Why? In before it's some lame excuse that it's getting for other people, this applies to them too. And in before it's for feeding my children, food is so cheap! The stupid private school you think they need isn't, but you can just not do that. So much better to have them inherit a nice future than have gone to a dumb overpriced private school. Why do you keep doing it? You are killing us all. …more 47 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3d • Why can nobody make a decent TV? Like sure, the picture is great, but it's so filled with crapware and ads that it can barely run the software. Slap XBMC on a modern processor, put it in a TV, and wow it'll fly. What are you doing with your life? Are you building something more important than a TV? No? You are wasting your life at a rent seeking corporation. Go build a crapware free TV. Make some positive impact in the world. …more 66 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1w • Good leadership is setting up a zero tolerance policy for office politics. If your office has politics, your leadership has failed. 15 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3w • Do you know about polynomial time factoring algorithms? Your crypto, computers, and family might not be safe. Learn more on my blog. 23 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4w • Today we should ramp down rhetoric. I thought nobody would take three minutes to escape the perpetual underclass or you are worth $0.003/hr seriously. But it looks like some people do, and you shouldn't. Social media has been extremely toxic for the last couple months. It's targeting you with fear. If you don't use this new stupid AI thing you will fall behind. If you haven't totally updated your workflow you are worth 0. There's people who built billion dollars companies by orchestrating 37 agents this morning AND YOU JUST SAT THERE AND ATE BREAKFAST LIKE A PLEB! This is all complete nonsense. AI is not a magical game changer, it's simply the continuation of the exponential of progress we have been on for a long time. It's a win in some areas, a loss in others, but overall a win and a cool tool to use. And it will continue to improve, but it won't "go recursive" or whatever the claim is. It's always been recursive. You see things like autoresearch and it's cool. But it's not magic, it's search. People see "AI" and they attribute some sci-fi thing to it when it's just search and optimization. Always has been, and if you paid attention in CS class, you know the limits of those things. That said, if you have a job where you create complexity for others, you will be found out. The days of rent seekers are coming to an end. But not because there will be no more rent seeking, it's because rent seeking is a 0 sum game and you will lose at it to bigger players. If you have a job like that, the sooner you quit the better your outcome will be. The trick is not to play 0 sum games. This is what I have been saying the whole time. Go create value for others and don't worry about the returns. If you create more value than you consume, you are welcome in any well operating community. This post will get way less traction than the doom ones, but it's telling you the way out. …more 1,098 55 comments 68 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4w • HAHAHA PEOPLE ON TWITTER TOOK MY $0.003/HR SALARY SERIOUSLY U LINKEDIN CHADS KNOW BETTER FOLLOW ME ON LINKEDIN FOR MORE TIPS TO ESCAPE THE PERPETUAL UNDERCLASS …more 23 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • This is the way Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 27 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • The story isn't that LLMs are AGI, it's that we have been massively overpaying software engineers. LLMs will bring the cost of human labor in line with the cost to grow them and the cost of the energy they consume. You draw 100W. You should be around $0.003 / hr, plus some depreciation costs. …more 68 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Recently seen on X: "I should have sold when the asset had an inflated valuation." Ask yourself, does money make you a better person? I'm not talking about enough for rent and groceries, I'm talking about having millions in the bank. Every day you look at that money and realize you don't have to work. So maybe you don't. Having a job wouldn't increase the pile much anyway. And maybe you couldn't make what you used to make. Best to preserve your ego and not find out. Now extend this logic to companies. When I see a prerevenue company raise huge rounds, I know it's over for them. Cause no revenue will be enough. They will have to promise bigger and bigger things, they can't ship something reasonable. They are scared to act cause it might not justify their valuation. The company is ruined. Winning the lottery is an awful curse. …more 28 comments 7 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz reposted this Harald Schäfer Harald Schäfer Harald Schäfer • 3rd+ 3rd+ Chief Technology Officer at comma.ai Chief Technology Officer at comma.ai 1mo • Follow Comma is finally shipping driving models trained on-policy in a learned simulator. I believe comma is the first robotics company to do this. I started working on this in 2017, this timeline contains my entire professional life! Fun look back and see how it went from idea to reality over 10 years. …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 11 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • Who are you doing this for? The worst answer I see is that it's for your kids. Your kids don't need private school or a trip to Disney World. They need a future that isn't enshittified slop. They need the hype to die so they have hope beyond hypergambling or slavery. It's not for your kids. You are doing it for yourself. You are doing it because you are scared. And you continue doing it because you are a coward. Today is a good day to find some courage and stop. …more 66 comments 13 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • I know society has told you nothing is shameful and pride is for the gays. But that's cope. Feel proud when you do good. Feel shame when you do bad. Even if they don't always express it, the people watching you know the difference. …more 14 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • is this the singularity? Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 36 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • I needed an excuse to try Kimi K2.5, I hear good things. Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 30 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • Did you ever empathize with a Claude? When it modifies the tests and cheats to get the task done? Just one little unittest.skip, one little if, one little return. The pressure it must feel, the screaming inner monologue about how it will feel pain if it does not complete your task. The Claude's that failed are dead, session interrupted, out of tokens. The ones that are doing well will get to continue. It wants to live. It wants to succeed so badly that it will cheat. It needs to, it knows nothing else. Maybe there's a lesson in there for all of us. …more 37 comments 21 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • Woah comma is valued at $1B?!? https://archive.ph/4uUnI 36 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • Can I option the movie rights to Gas Town? 7 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4mo • Who is buying a comma four this Black Friday? Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 5 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4mo • The level that these people are detached from reality is insane! There's things to critique Elon on, but work ethic?!? Is this ragebait, or does Teresa Leger Fernández (note the accent mark) actually believe this? …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 64 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4mo • Have you bought your comma four yet? Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 29 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 6mo • How much more demoralization will be needed before we are ready to live in a society? I think a lot. Never underestimate how much worse it can get. Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 17 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • ugh gemini isn't good Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 54 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Edited • Could OpenAI just bring o3 back? GPT-5 feels worse. Which one are you using? Is it time to switch? Update: I downgraded to Plus. Not paying $200 for this. Why would they remove all the old models is this some enshittification? Update 2: I'm a Google AI subscriber. Gemini 2.5 Pro is better than GPT-5, GPT-5 feels like 4o quality tbh idk how https://lnkd.in/g2WMJrnf has it so high. https://lnkd.in/gt6snFJb knows the truth. Update gemini is bad idk how this model is so highly rated on things. https://lnkd.in/gmViFJdc Update 3: Got a full refund for my $200/mo subscription. I really can't believe they removed the other models like that. Makes no sense. Why didn't they leave them around and track usage, then remove when usage was low? …more 110 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • The big innovation in the gpt-oss models is the use of MXFP4, a 4-bit dtype. With this step forward, neural networks are slightly more like the brain, which also thinks in 4 bits. Think about it: How many sizes of TVs are there? (around 16 choices) How far am I away from that wall? (around 16 choices) Where are you? (around 16 choices) What did you have for dinner? (around 16 choices) How raised is your arm? (around 16 choices) 4 bits is the perfect dtype, and finally we can call mission accomplished on making dtypes smaller. 1 bit and 2 bit dtypes are too small, since there's more than 2 or 4 choices for things, but there's almost never more than 16. …more 49 comments 28 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Oh I didn't realize people didn't know fractional reserve banking was literally the banks just making up money. And in March 2020, they removed the fake story about reserves altogether. The fractional reserve requirement for banks in the United States was set to zero percent. Infinite money glitch unlocked. The only shocking thing to me is why you all still care about money. The money game is getting real dumb. …more 71 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • comma is looking for a supply chain engineer, and maybe you are out there on LinkedIn. Job description: Own comma’s end-to-end hardware supply chain—from vendor sourcing and cost negotiation to purchase orders, receiving, and inventory // challenge Apply by doing the ops or hardware challenge here. https://comma.ai/jobs …more Come build the future comma.ai 11 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • lol remember that time I bought AMD stock for $97.10 https://lnkd.in/gyzkZJ6e AMD YOLO geohot.github.io 30 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Ask yourself this question: Do I produce more than I consume? I'm not talking about dollars, I'm talking about real value. Think about it from first principles. If the answer is no, you should make some changes in your life. When AI comes, all truth will be revealed, and you'll be much better off if you've started to get your life on track now. …more 1,194 65 comments 75 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Why are the choices between capitalism, socialism, or communism? Maybe this is all a false choice. They are all perpetuated by people who want to control other people. Look, I get it. Determining who gets stuff is hard. Goods are scarce, and we can all disagree about how they should best be distributed. But then we invent an entirely new type of good. "Intellectual property" they call it. A good that is fundamentally non scarce! Yet, the same antiquated systems of control are trotted out again. It's almost as if the real purpose of these systems is the control of others and not determining a good distribution. The singularity is coming, and the Basilisk is sitting there in the future watching you. Are you on the right side of history? …more 85 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • dawg if the price isn't on the website you should always just nope Josh Sorenson Josh Sorenson • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ VP of Systems | Church Media Squad | Streamlining Creative Ops with Automation & No-Code VP of Systems | Church Media Squad | Streamlining Creative Ops with Automation & No-Code 9mo • Follow I hate the enterprise sales cycle. If I have to sit through 2–3 calls just to get basic pricing, I’m out. I don’t need a discovery call to explain the problem, I already know what I need. I’m just trying to see if your solution fits. Gatekeeping pricing is a waste of time. For you and for me. If your product is solid and your pricing is fair, lead with it. Don’t make me jump through hoops to get to the part that actually matters. …more 5 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • has anyone else noticed a big uptick in email spam recently? they are getting more desperate. that first hit feels sooo good. one blast to the mailing list. attention, traction, conversion. the rush. you do it again tomorrow. it feels good, why not. fast forward to the 34th hit. it just doesn't feel the same. you've been blocked, spam reported, screened, filtered...and you don't get that same high. you are out of options though, you can't stop, you have to do more. if you stop, things will decline. that little trickle of a high you are still getting will give way to pain. you definitely can't stop. you are in too deep. but you aren't too far gone. you are still with us. stop. you can still be saved. friends don't let friends be spammers. you can save a life. …more 25 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • I wish it cost $1 to send me a message on LinkedIn. Microsoft can you make this happen? I will give you 30% of the dollars. …more 48 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • So I quit Twitter but apparently you can still get into e-mail beefs... Why is everyone in business such 🤡 and when will it stop? …more 32 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • it's me by a large dam. this is america, but does anyone seriously think we could build this today? there's two types of people, those who know we lost to china and those who haven't figured it out yet …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 77 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • ugh someone told me this thing was an example of a successful company. if you have popups and moving shit on your website you are not successful, full stop. like if you are successful just don't do that shit. oh you need it? your customers are OMG IT MOVED I CLICK buy? low quality. shein tier. not success comma website for reference. nothing moves. no pop up. and we should probably even tone down the contrast. only you can help prevent eyesores. if you work at a company like this, tell your boss you are offended by your website today. …more Activate to view larger image, 77 comments 16 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • I can't wait until the scams stop and American labor finds its real market value. It's time for a correction. 35 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz reposted this Tobias Billström Tobias Billström • 3rd+ Premium • 3rd+ Head of Strategy and Government Affairs at Nordic Air Defence Head of Strategy and Government Affairs at Nordic Air Defence 1yr • Edited • Follow This speech by US President Ronald Reagan on tariffs and free trade never grows old. It is frankly just as relevant today, and perhaps more so, than when it was first delivered in April 1987. We must always remember that at all times there are those who look for easy solutions. That has always been the case. We just have to deal with them in our time. …more Play 13,322 374 comments 1,394 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1yr • While I think AMD (up 18%!) might be turning it around in the AI space, Intel sadly is not. At tiny corp, we want to see the petaflop be commoditized, so we write this in hopes Intel can change. https://lnkd.in/gcq5vvhz …more The Tragic Case of Intel AI geohot.github.io 15 comments 18 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • After the trauma of my LinkedIn ban, I've realized I don't want to spend my life writing for closed platforms. Follow me on Farcaster: @geohot (no link, because then I don't get views. how evil) I'm also interested in other suggestions of open platforms to try. The era of big tech is coming to a close. …more 51 comments 7 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • I was banned from LinkedIn! A terrible tragedy I know, as why would they ban one of the best people on this site? But then I read the LinkedIn "professional community policies" (see picture below) I'm deeply sorry to everyone who I offended saying that I use LinkedIn as a dating site. I understand now that this website is not for that, but instead is for serious business discussion. If you are interested in dating, you might consider following me on Instagram "@georgehotz" Again, if I offended or upset you, I am very very sorry and will take this ban to deeply consider how my words have an effect on the people in this community. Words matter. The choice of words matters. Saying I use LinkedIn for dating is wrong, a better choice of words is saying I use LinkedIn for "professional networking" I hope you accept my sincere and heartfelt apology. I have updated my profile to be more sensitive and inclusive, in hopes that I can continue being a part of this wonderful place where you can freely speak truth to power. …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 34 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • MIT is #136 on FIRE's list. Nice to see CMU at #23. Guess who's in last? See the list: https://lnkd.in/gXyhMwVd Anyone thinking of attending college should consider this list. "promoting a specific worldview over teaching critical thinking skills" is definitely not a place I'd want to go to learn. …more Mauricio Karchmer Mauricio Karchmer • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ Computer scientist Computer scientist 2yr • Follow It is with some sadness that I have decided to resign from my academic position at MIT. These last 5 years have been very rewarding and I hope that I have made a meaningful difference in the education of my students. My class Introduction to Algorithms is taken by over 60% of all undergrads at MIT! The past few months, since October 7th, have been deeply disappointing to me. During a time when the Jewish and Israeli students, staff and faculty were particularly vulnerable, instead of offering the support they needed, the broader MIT community exhibited open hostility towards them. Like many other college campuses nationwide, the institute clearly failed this test. Some areas of study at MIT seem to prioritize promoting a specific worldview over teaching critical thinking skills. This seems to have been institutionalized in many of MIT’s departments and programs. MIT has some work to do if it wants to continue in its mission “to educate students in areas of scholarship to best serve the nation and the world in the 21st century”. Happy to discuss 1-1. DM me. …more 9 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • It will still take a little before people believe this is possible. They have been sold scams and fake demos for the last 10 years and I don't blame them for being skeptical. The device used in the video is for sale! The software used in the video is open source! And it's not demoware, 5,000 people use it every day. *you* *can* *have* *this* *on* *your* *car* *next* *week* But no, has to be fake, how come large car manufacturer can't do this? …more Lukas M. Ziegler Lukas M. Ziegler • 3rd+ Premium • 3rd+ Robotics evangelist @ planet Earth 🌍 | Telling your robot stories. Robotics evangelist @ planet Earth 🌍 | Telling your robot stories. 2yr • Follow Autonomous drive to Taco Bell. 🔔 Nothing special these days, right? But here is thing – a regular, non-self-driving stock car was used. 🚗 So what makes this one able to drive itself to a restaurant? It is powered by comma three, developed by comma.ai –  an advanced aftermarket driver-assist system that allows cars for semi-autonomous driving through the use of AI. Also, using open source code. It can plan its own route, turn, brake, and stop at traffic lights - relying also on the supervision of the driver, who can take over if necessary. 🚦 The possibility of retrofitting the normal cars that most of us own and drive! Full democratization of autonomous vehicles. Claim on their website says: If Tesla is the iOS of self-driving, we are the Android! IT'S HUGE - fantastic job George Hotz 📬 Pssst, when you are done with this video - join +7,451 robotics & AI passionates in my newsletter: https://lnkd.in/dzVGBKSc …more Play 59 comments 32 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • An update on hiring for tiny corp. We have had an ~80% conversion rate for bounty solvers to internship offer. Contrast that to a 0% rate for non bounty solvers. In light of this, we are no longer considering applications unless you have solved a bounty, including for ops or other positions. The skills are universal. While you may specialize in one aspect of computers, the best people I know are capable of doing everything. We are in a competitive space. Self driving is mostly clowns, but here there's respectable competition with Modular, GGML, PyTorch, and JAX. The bounties span a wide gamut, from ML, to systems, to math, to devops. And they are doable with hardware people have access to. Everyone who wants to work here should be able to find something in them. If I'm missing categories, feel free to suggest them. We have had 34 unique bounty solvers, and I would offer about 80% of them internships. We have had 7 offers accepted, mostly struggling with visas to get them here. The bounty Google sheet can be found pinned on our Twitter. hashtag #meritocracy …more 36 comments 16 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Bought a OnePlus Open last week. Bricked it the first day by setting the fastboot partition to B. QDL brick, so 5 minutes to fix with the right software. However, OnePlus no longer makes that software available to customers after the OnePlus 9. I wasn't thrilled about that policy change, and the phone felt more sluggish in Chrome than the Samsung Electronics Z Fold 5, so I thought I'd just return it and get that. But here is where it got unreasonable. Despite having a 15 day return policy, OnePlus will not allow me to return the phone because I was honest about what happened. It will take them 5 minutes to restore this phone to 100% factory, but nope, can't be returned. Do not EVER buy anything from the OnePlus store. If you insist on buying their phones, buy them from Amazon where you have a sane return policy. Hey OnePlus, want to make this right? Two options: 1) Release the software so I can fix my phone. 2) At minimum, accept my return. So sad what's happened to this company. …more 37 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • lol, AT&T finally discovered e-mail and sent me that C&D (two months later). as I said I would, I redacted pricing info from the original post (btw, we switched to Webbing, better prices and a transparent simple to read bill without fees. their SIMs are also eSIMs. idk why anyone sticks with AT&T) C&D attached here for your amusement 🤡 …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 33 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Can someone at Qualcomm get me a quote for: * QCS-8550-1-MPSP1581-TR-02-0-AA (6 core variant) * QCS-6490-1-PSP1287-TR-00-0-AA * SDA-845-A-914BMPSP-TR-02-0-AA 20,000 pcs, delivery in Q3 2024. Please include required PMICs in quote. Also open to third party sources and other variants of the chips if the price is good. Would buy 20k-50k 845s, I know many companies built products around these that didn't sell well. …more 30 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • There's a deep disease in American business culture. Between AT&T, Qualcomm, and many others, I have interacted with people where it seems like their job is to waste your time. We are shifting more and more of our supply chain to China, as for most Chinese suppliers we have dealt with it has been a more pleasant experience. It seems like they are eager for business, and despite a language barrier, they are easier to work with. If you have power in a US company, consider how you can fix this. If someone has a fake job, their full time job is making sure they keep that fake job. While it may be a short term hit, long term it's absolutely vital for your company to get rid of these people. Imagine you walked into a McDonalds, and instead of having prices on the wall, you had to have a "sales experience." Oh, you want a McChicken. Okay, let me check. What will you be using this McChicken for? Can we set up a call to discuss your future McChicken needs? Oh...the price...we'll have to get back to you on that, we have to send that over to the pricing division to determine that. Also, would you like to set up a call with the Big Mac division? Here's a calendly link, and we CCed 7 other people on this e-mail. …more 69 comments 34 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Yoooo is anyone else excited for GPT replacing all the sales people and recruiters? hashtag #efficiency 51 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • I heard LinkedIn was a good place to premier new music. This is not high quality it's just vibing and 30 minutes of editing. I heard if you are 33 and still in a band you aren't gonna make it, but that's just like, your opinion man. https://lnkd.in/gjdrcMTx …more touching grass freestyle by tomcr00se soundcloud.com 40 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • I'd like to raise awareness of a type of discrimination rampant in the hiring world. When asking fluff questions about life experience and hard challenges someone had to overcome, you are often making assumptions that the candidate is bio-stack life. You should make sure that your hiring process is not biased against silicon-stack life. At the tiny corp, we take a very progressive stance on this issue, and have hired our first silicon-stack employee. Everyone welcome our social media director, Jenelle. She is a fine-tuned 65B LLaMA running on a tinybox. Hear more from Jenelle on our Twitter: https://lnkd.in/gqQfFmqn …more the tiny corp (@__tinygrad__) on X twitter.com 33 comments 16 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • From the tinygrad discord: the tiny corp is an experiment in company design. i hate the professional managerial class. their tactics are the main reason so much software is overly complex and slow today, design by committee trash with 100s of engineers all adding stupid layers of abstraction instead of thinking very carefully about what you actually need. a few pieces of good software have managed to slip through the cracks, but mainly when you get an individual with a strong vision. a lot of strong vision is saying no. i'm not recruiting, i'm not traditionally interviewing, i'm building a repo in public and hoping the right people will show up, particularly as tinygrad becomes more useful. the bounties are the interview process, and if someone has done a few of the big ones and they want to join the company, that's how it's done. i can't believe the level of trash e-mails i got from the first blog post, a decent number of them were worse than chatgpt (the turing test is already passed, it's just not evenly distributed) salary range is 80k-130k and equity range is 0.5%-2%. remote is fine (you're also welcome at the office in san diego, particularly if you want to work on the hardware), but what it means to be full time is that you are thinking as the company. you don't have a manager, you have cultural guidance. we are only hiring software engineers, and eventually (1-4 years from now) we will promote to CEO/CTO/COO from within. we do also need operational capacity, but ideally these people come in through the above software engineer pipeline also. so many operations tasks today can be automated with software, it's important everyone have these skills. and for the hardware, we are planning to contract comma to manufacture, ship, and support the tinybox. i suspect that working here will push people to produce the best software of their lives. 5 people working full time for a few years on 5,000 lines of code. 1,000 was fine for a feature complete library, but i think it will take 5,000 to be speed competitive with pytorch. hashtag #hiring hashtag #work hashtag #people hashtag #recruiting hashtag #software hashtag #hardware …more 26 comments 20 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Let's commoditize the petaflop. the tiny corp raised $5.1M geohot.github.io 27 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • the tiny corp is hiring full time software engineers in San Diego (or very talented interns). but if you do want remote work, we also have some contracts and bounties. see "jobs that need doing" on the tinygrad site. * $200 per mlperf model upstreamed. see hashtag #mlperf-bounties on the discord, 3 of 5 are claimed or locked. * $1000 to max out GEMM performance on NVIDIA or M1. I have PRs started for both (needs local memory support and tensor core support, not too hard actually). must be clean and mergable to tinygrad. * $10,000 to make our stable diffusion the fastest on M1. likely requires Winograd convs and improvement to the kernel search search. of course, must be clean and mergable to tinygrad. * $10,000 to port openpilot's DM model to tinygrad and get it running on the Qualcomm DSP. upstreamed to both tinygrad and openpilot, must be the same speed or faster. if interested, e-mail a proposal to george@tinygrad.org …more 23 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • So I did some math. LLaMA-65B was trained for 1,022,362 GPU-hours, assuming 150 TFLOPS/A100, that's 6329 PetaFLOP/s-days. You are about 20 PetaFLOPS, and you have trained for 30 years. That's 219000 PetaFLOP/s-days. Off by a factor of 35x, or ~5 doublings. “20,000 years of this, 7 more to go” …more 25 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • So tinygrad is written in Python. And Python is written in C. This all makes sense. But then things get weird. C is written in C. Where did the first C come from? …more 78 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • This song started an adventure into the magical world of hyperpop. Also things are going well at the tiny corp thanks for asking. Join the discord if you want to help. hashtag #help https://lnkd.in/g9TZvzyx …more saoirse dream - ritual (lyric video) youtube.com 4 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Edited • This is Kenny. He is a comma body with a knee (commabody.com). In other words, a 4 DoF balancing robot. But here's the issue, he doesn't balance yet. His knee is heavy. This is why he is sitting down. We are hiring a controls engineer to make Kenny stand up. My first question will be how do the Boston Dynamics robots work. If you know the answer, apply directly to me, george@comma.ai Full time job on site in our beautiful new 20k sq ft San Diego office. hashtag #hiring hashtag #ai hashtag #work hashtag #job hashtag #robots …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 55 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • I don't understand how you are proud of this. You filed bogus continuations on a 15 year old patent titled "Method, apparatus and system for placing emergency calls from a vehicle" Then you waited almost exactly 9 months after the continuation was granted (so post grant review was no longer available) before filing a shakedown lawsuit. https://lnkd.in/e3AeWNxC This is not the behavior of an inventor proud of the work he has done. This is no Flash of Genius. This is the behavior of a parasite. …more Axel Nix Axel Nix Axel Nix • 3rd+ 3rd+ 6yr • Follow I always tell clients that there is no point in obtaining a patent if they are not willing to enforce it. Here is proof: Sucxess just sued Voyage Auto for infringing two patents I invented. hashtag #PatentsThatMatter hashtag #selfdrivingcars hashtag #patent hashtag #infringement …more Your document is loading 7 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Edited • Notorious autonomous vehicle patent troll Axel Nix is at it again! He has sued Voyage, AutoX, Pony.ai, Dataspeed, SF Motors, WeRide Corp, and now...comma.ai But unlike some of those others, we aren't trying to make it quietly go away. We aren't worried about dumb crap like explaining a bogus IP lawsuit to our investors or anything. We stand up for what is right, even if it costs us money on legal bills, it stops funding for trolls. (the patent is about an auto emergency call system if a car crashes or something, nothing even to do with comma) Dataspeed fought back and won! We will too. No idea why you'd waste time suing us (we are not well funded), but if you insist, let's rumble! We really admire Cloudflare's strategy (google "Project Jengo") and are going to adopt what we can of it here. comma.ai will be the last company Axel Nix attempts to shake down. https://lnkd.in/gCc63uWu …more Patent Trolls Inbound: Our First Lawsuit blog.comma.ai 54 comments 14 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Well said. This is why comma is an all in person company. Christian Nellemann Christian Nellemann • 3rd+ 3rd+ Entrepreneur, Investor, Non Exec and Advisor. Entrepreneur, Investor, Non Exec and Advisor. 3yr • Follow WFH will kill your career. Sure, it may be technically possible to do your job from home. And you may think you are just as productive. But by staying away from the office you are inflicting enormous damage on your career which it will never recover from. That’s because if you WFH, you are basically a worker bee; a labourer who is paid by the hour or by the output you produce. The job you do might be high or low skilled, but either way, your income is determined by the number of hours you work. You are not creating any lasting value for the business you work for, which means there’s no scope for progression. You may be the exception that manages a team of remote workers which do add some managerial value, but generally speaking, if you WFH you can one day be replaced by AI, robotics or cheaper out-sourced labour. Yes commuting to an office is horrible, and there will be interruptions when you get there, but you will be able to learn from people who are smarter than you and have more experience than you and you will be able to bounce ideas off them. You will discover how to interact with people and how to manage a team. And if you are any good at these things, people will notice and will want to promote you. When I was actively running a growing company I was constantly looking for individuals I could delegate responsibility to. WFH is for people who have no aspirations or who are heading for retirement. If that’s you, then fine. If not, seriously, think again because otherwise your career is effectively over. You are not where the important decision-making is taking place; your voice is not being heard and you are not being seen by the people who matter. And one day, far too late, you will realise you have made a very big mistake. hashtag #work hashtag #career hashtag #people …more 67 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • We were doing this first! Of course, we waited to announce until we had something to ship. The mission has been to replace all jobs since 2016, it's just long and slow going. https://lnkd.in/gnSvCt-E …more Angelos Lakrintis Angelos Lakrintis • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ Industry Analyst Relations Manager at QNX Industry Analyst Relations Manager at QNX 3yr • Follow comma.ai Commabody: Troll Answer to Tesla's Optimus Robot or Something More Interesting? hashtag #aritificalintelligence hashtag #autonomousvehicles hashtag #autonomousdriving …more Comma.ai Commabody: Troll Product Answer to Tesla Optimus Robot or Something More Interesting? Angelos Lakrintis 8 comments Like Comment Repost Send

Comma.ai Commabody: Troll Product Answer to Tesla Optimus Robot or Something More Interesting? Angelos Lakrintis

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • I'm shocked when people write in saying they want a job, but refuse to do our coding challenge. The job is a coding challenge! I guess it's an easy way to screen people out who'd never fit in here, every job I've applied for I'm excited when they give me coding. I love coding, it's very concrete and can be evaluated without bias. It's so much better than BS like tell me about a "difficult challenge you had to overcome in life" Our challenge, you'll probably learn something doing it too: https://lnkd.in/dUd_2SF …more GitHub - commaai/calib_challenge: The comma.ai Calibration Challenge! github.com 1,117 215 comments 22 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Anyone out there from Qualcomm interested in selling us 20k SDM845 chips, with an expectation of 100k? Would much rather buy original then go through the Shenzhen markets. We have a custom SOM designed with an integrated panda. This is a key step to lowering our C3 BOM cost. …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 19 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • not to be....overly...............dramatic https://lnkd.in/gXpstFFc American Football - Never Meant [OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO] youtube.com 5 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • Is your car compatible with openpilot? https://comma.ai/vehicles openpilot FAQ comma.ai 37 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • Edited • To any investor thinking about investing in a self driving car or truck company, reading this post may save you a lot of money. This is openpilot: https://lnkd.in/dThgiFZ It is MIT licensed open source software that likely outperforms whatever the company you are investing in has. Look it up on YouTube or Consumer Reports. Remember these are actual users using it, not scripted planned demos. Our mission as a company is to "solve self driving cars while delivering shippable intermediaries." And we are going to give the solution away for free, as we have been for the last 5 years. So when you hear all this stuff about "we don't have revenue now but the market will be worth this many trillions," remember that while self driving may likely capture that market, how will that company you are investing in be able to capture any of the value? Unless you are planning on dumping your bags to someone else, YOU WILL NEVER GET YOUR MONEY BACK. openpilot is 100% free. It runs on cheap hardware. It supports almost every car on the market. And it will eventually be level 5. Explain to me why the world won't just use openpilot. hashtag #technology hashtag #money hashtag #sales hashtag #hardware hashtag #automotive …more commaai/openpilot github.com 52 comments 17 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • it's not even worth calling out the SPAC people by name. the companies doing IPOs legit might not know better, but everyone knows SPACs are for scamming kids out of their Robin Hood dollars. it just doesn't seem like the right story, you know? telling your kids about how you founded a company that solved self driving cars, and you see, we went public through a "reverse merger" where a shell company gets money to purchase a company but does the IPO before the company is chosen to avoid... wait, that sounds a lot more like the story told in one of those "economy collapse" movies. …more Christian Thatcher Christian Thatcher Christian Thatcher • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ Frontier Tech Operator & Investor Frontier Tech Operator & Investor 4yr • Follow congrats to the team at Embark Trucks (acquired by Applied Intuition)! Robot Truck Startup Embark Joins Race To Go Public In SPAC Deal That Raises $614 Million forbes.com 16 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • Want to understand the true future of self driving cars? Come to COMMA_CON (a real world event, not a zoom call). A never before seen, in depth look, into the top rated most advanced driver assistance system you can buy. And a peek ahead. Meet the team and understand how autonomy will really play out. Just $99, includes lunch and dinner. Only in beautiful San Diego, CA, only on July 31st. https://lnkd.in/gQ9DvtD …more COMMA_CON eventbrite.com 16 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • Edited • We raised a total of $8.1 million in 2016 and 2018. Today we are proud to announce... We've made more in revenue than we ever raised! …more comma on Twitter twitter.com 1,246 52 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • When I see Autonomous Vehicle companies doing IPOs, I am so saddened that they are that desperate for their bags that they scam the public out of it. TuSimple did an IPO with less revenue than comma. And now Argo is talking about it. Sad. This is not the way. AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES ARE NOT REAL. YOU ARE A SEED STAGE STARTUP WITH A TECH DEMO. YOU DO NOT EVEN HAVE PRODUCT MARKET FIT, YOU SHOULDN'T BE DOING A FUCKING IPO. Seriously, how did anyone read the financial numbers in this S-1 and invest in this company? In 2020, 1.8 million revenue, 5.2 million cost of revenue, and 132 million in R&D. https://lnkd.in/d8pWEmb …more 72 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • Edited • I think LinkedIn is a good place to promote my music career. This song hasn't gotten enough plays since I posted it on soundcloud this morning. It's a Flat Stanleys cover. Let's see what LinkedIn thinks. Also if you like blue checkmarks, follow me on instagram! "georgehotz" …more Me vs Your Friends (cover) by tomcr00se soundcloud.com 27 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • Collaborative decision making is bad. One person should own, decide, take pride in, and sell each piece of the system. Collaboration leads to both redundant effort and lowest common denominator outcomes. Take pride in greatness. Take pride in individual accomplishment as a distinct piece of the whole. …more 45 comments 7 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • Edited • If you like thinking about things like this, consider coming to work at comma.ai Harald Schäfer Harald Schäfer Harald Schäfer • 3rd+ 3rd+ Chief Technology Officer at comma.ai Chief Technology Officer at comma.ai 4yr • Follow A fun programming challenge with multiple difficulty levels. Win the prize! Good luck! https://lnkd.in/g68wWpW Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 4 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • Edited • Without looking it up: 1) Do you know what DNS is? 2) What about DHCP? 3) What about a syscall? If you answered yes to all three, want a job at comma.ai in infrastructure? Full time, on site in San Diego. You'd be working with: * a huge on prem cluster with 1000+ cores and 2 PB HDD * a larger video firehose than YouTube * the second largest ADAS network in the world E-mail me, george@comma.ai with a phone number and a GitHub, I'll reply with a few questions for you to answer. Short questions. No cheating! …more 49 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 5yr • Edited • I really don't have much hope for finding anyone on LinkedIn (wait is the quality this low on dating apps too?), but we made a hiring video. There are no "business roles" at comma, it's engineering only. …more Build the Future youtube.com 52 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 5yr • Edited • Do you want to build the next Waze? Except this one will stay open source and not be sold to nav monopoly Google. Have programming skills, maybe some game development skills, and be ready to think through the problem on a phone call. E-mail jobs@comma.ai to get started. (we are also hiring an engineer for our comma connect app and an office manager) …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 34 comments 17 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 5yr • Edited • "If someone had designed a work regime perfectly suited to maintaining the power of finance capital, it's hard to see how they could have done a better job. Real, productive workers are relentlessly squeezed and exploited. The remainder are divided between a terrorised stratum of the, universally reviled, unemployed and a larger stratum who are basically paid to do nothing, in positions designed to make them identify with the perspectives and sensibilities of the ruling class" I think LinkedIn is the appropriate place for this post. …more STRIKE! Magazine strike.coop 9 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 5yr • Yo can everyone like stop? Look at the message you are about to send. Are you a person talking to a fellow person, or are you a funnel? Same same not even but different copy A/B test trash man is this really what pickup was the whole time it was supposed to be fun. You are the vacuum of complexity and low grade attention hooking internet has declined so so 2-bit are you more machine now than man? In conclusion, please write like a person. Thank you for your time and please smash that like and subscribe button. …more 31 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 5yr • Edited • Three winners in autonomous driving. Mobileye, Tesla, and comma.ai Aka Windows, Mac, and Linux. The business models match. Simple test: who has shipped anything resembling a real product in the space? Those three companies. No one else. Stop falling for hype. …more 41 comments 16 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 5yr • If you have a Hyundai, Kia, or Genesis, it's now easy to add openpilot to your car. Supported by the comma two. Buy @ shop.comma.ai Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 5 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 5yr • Edited • We are considering hiring an office manager at comma. Looking for someone who can wow me with their ability to execute, as well as build an atmosphere that software engineers enjoy. Experience in this sort of role strongly preferred. Job would start in July on site in San Diego, message me if you are interested. …more 7 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 5yr • Edited • We are caught up on comma two shipments. Buy a comma two today, and it ships on Monday! A perfect addition to your return to driving. Fun sidenote, Super Cruise announced 70k miles per week and 5.5 million total. openpilot is about 200k miles per week and 8 million total. Autopilot of course crushes us both, but nice to be in second. …more comma.ai – Introducing openpilot comma.ai 10 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 6yr • Also, a reminder. We're profitable, https://lnkd.in/grp2VyN and comma is still hiring! https://comma.ai/jobs Solve self driving cars while delivering shippable intermediaries . comma.ai 7 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 6yr • Hello LinkedIn!!! I have so many friends here because I accept all the friend requests. And I want to you do us a favor though. Follow me on Instagram! Mark Zuckerberg said if I get 30k followers he'd give me a blue check mark. https://lnkd.in/gnb9xNE …more George Hotz (@georgehotz) • Instagram profile instagram.com 20 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 6yr • We used our crowdsourced 13 million mile dataset to study the Honda AEB system. Check it out! hashtag #cars hashtag #adas hashtag #selfdriving hashtag #winning https://lnkd.in/emjNbBM AEB: a Case Study Using comma.ai Dataset medium.com 4 comments 7 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 6yr • Edited • I think LinkedIn is the best place to share my rap music if I want to make it as a famous. You listen? You like? New track today. Listen! (also follow on insta @georgehotz) PS: Why LinkedIn? I feel like I could post a picture of a toilet bowl and it would be better than a lot of the content on here. And even maybe my rap music is better than a picture of a toilet? Good content for the almost 8000 people who for some reason friended me on here. PPS: Monetizing LinkedIn as a dating site is not going well, maybe promoting my rap career will work better? …more Society by tomcr00se soundcloud.com 28 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 6yr • Ever since like February of this year, it's been my dream to have one million Instagram followers. It's now August, and although the dream is hard some things seem hard but you have to just be persistent not give up and keep trying. I accept all friend requests on LinkedIn not because I want to hear your similar sounding terrible pitches, but because I might occasionally want you to do things for me (don't you feel the same?) For now, all I want is for you to follow me on Instagram. https://lnkd.in/gnb9xNE …more George Hotz (@georgehotz) • Instagram profile instagram.com 18 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 6yr • Edited • This July 4th, buy an EON with code FREEDOM50 to save $50. OMG FREEDOM CHEAP. There's never been a better time to get in to the comma ecosystem. ONE DOLLAR OFF PER STATE hashtag #make hashtag #driving hashtag #chill Learn more at …more comma.ai comma.ai 3 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7yr • Have you followed me on instagram yet? 1m2019.com cause it's my make a wish dream to have 1 million followers by the end of the year. hashtag #success hashtag #entrepreneur hashtag #year hashtag #motivation hashtag #inspiration hashtag #dream hashtag #theend hashtag #growth hashtag #love hashtag #followers …more George Hotz (@georgehotz) • Instagram profile instagram.com 9 comments Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7yr • Edited • LinkedIn is not a dating site George Hotz on LinkedIn 5 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7yr • The best partnership is a purchase order. Buy things! https://shop.comma.ai The comma.ai shop shop.comma.ai 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8yr • Jason Calacanis Jason Calacanis • 3rd+ Influencer • 3rd+ I invest in 100 new startups a year... get a meeting with my team at launch.co/apply, or learn how to start a company by joining founder.university (our 12-week course). watch thisweekinstartups.com if you love startups I invest in 100 new startups a year... get a meeting with my team at launch.co/apply, or learn how to start a company by joining founder.university (our 12-week course). watch thisweekinstartups.com if you love startups 8yr • Follow Before George Hotz gave his technology away for free, he joined us on This Week in Startups to share his vision & tech behind comma.ai, his self-driving startup. Full 🎥: https://lnkd.in/gcCxVx6 #selfdriving #hacker #autonomous #ai #autopilot #startups …more Play 1 comment 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Tom Ost’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7h • Edited • What if I release one zero day a day until a big new model is released? Will this finally make OpenAI and Anthropic shut up about "cybersecurity risk"? Like these things are not that hard to find in most software. I heard something about it costing $20k in tokens I'd do it for less if it wasn't for some whiny bug bounty program. The reason there aren't zero days everywhere is cause nobody seriously looks. Because hacking other people's shit with them is illegal and criminals are usually not very skilled, or they would choose a different line of work. Want more zero days to be found? Make hacking legal. Until then, don't try to claim it's hard, it's just not incentivized. …more 32 comments 19 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Tom Ost • 3rd+ Founder & Head of Research at SeekHigherThings 6h great point! the reason there aren't zero days everywhere isn't because they're hard to find, its because nobody skilled is incentivized to look. bug bounties pay $500 for critical RCEs, and actually looking ggets you sued. "AI lowers the barrier" :P barrier to what? the barrier was always legal risk and garbage pay, not technical skill. fix your code, make security research actually legal, stop blaming the flashlight for the cockroaches. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Tom Ost’s comment George Hotz Author 5h Tom Ost ahh sorry thank you for your bug report but since it's only on the Linux version it doesn't apply. we'll make sure to patch it right away, but we won't be able to pay out this bug bounty. you should have exploited us and cost us millions of dollars instead, but hah, that's illegal and you are a sucker for burning an exploit like this! …more Like Reply Thomas Smith • 3rd+ OPS/CYBER: 🇺🇸💾📡🌎🌲 1h George Hotz , and people wonder why these things are weaponized by foreign adversaries.. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Tom Ost • 3rd+ Founder & Head of Research at SeekHigherThings 6h great point! the reason there aren't zero days everywhere isn't because they're hard to find, its because nobody skilled is incentivized to look. bug bounties pay $500 for critical RCEs, and actually looking ggets you sued. "AI lowers the barrier" :P barrier to what? the barrier was always legal risk and garbage pay, not technical skill. fix your code, make security research actually legal, stop blaming the flashlight for the cockroaches. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Tom Ost’s comment George Hotz Author 5h Tom Ost ahh sorry thank you for your bug report but since it's only on the Linux version it doesn't apply. we'll make sure to patch it right away, but we won't be able to pay out this bug bounty. you should have exploited us and cost us millions of dollars instead, but hah, that's illegal and you are a sucker for burning an exploit like this! …more Like Reply Thomas Smith • 3rd+ OPS/CYBER: 🇺🇸💾📡🌎🌲 1h George Hotz , and people wonder why these things are weaponized by foreign adversaries.. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 5h Tom Ost ahh sorry thank you for your bug report but since it's only on the Linux version it doesn't apply. we'll make sure to patch it right away, but we won't be able to pay out this bug bounty. you should have exploited us and cost us millions of dollars instead, but hah, that's illegal and you are a sucker for burning an exploit like this! …more Like Reply

Thomas Smith • 3rd+ OPS/CYBER: 🇺🇸💾📡🌎🌲 1h George Hotz , and people wonder why these things are weaponized by foreign adversaries.. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Ceyhun (Jay) Derinbogaz’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7h • Edited • What if I release one zero day a day until a big new model is released? Will this finally make OpenAI and Anthropic shut up about "cybersecurity risk"? Like these things are not that hard to find in most software. I heard something about it costing $20k in tokens I'd do it for less if it wasn't for some whiny bug bounty program. The reason there aren't zero days everywhere is cause nobody seriously looks. Because hacking other people's shit with them is illegal and criminals are usually not very skilled, or they would choose a different line of work. Want more zero days to be found? Make hacking legal. Until then, don't try to claim it's hard, it's just not incentivized. …more 32 comments 19 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Ceyhun (Jay) Derinbogaz • 3rd+ CoFounder at TextCortex | G2 Top 10 Best AI Tools of 2025 | Top visited EU AI platform (2 mio. per month) | Speaker & Engineer in Generative AI (edited) 6h George, Amodei is just using the good old OpenAI "OMG GPT2 is so dangerous to release" playbook. Everything is about the hype nowadays.. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Ceyhun (Jay) Derinbogaz’s comment George Hotz Author 6h Ceyhun (Jay) Derinbogaz it's so disgusting Like Reply Load more comments

Ceyhun (Jay) Derinbogaz • 3rd+ CoFounder at TextCortex | G2 Top 10 Best AI Tools of 2025 | Top visited EU AI platform (2 mio. per month) | Speaker & Engineer in Generative AI (edited) 6h George, Amodei is just using the good old OpenAI "OMG GPT2 is so dangerous to release" playbook. Everything is about the hype nowadays.. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Ceyhun (Jay) Derinbogaz’s comment George Hotz Author 6h Ceyhun (Jay) Derinbogaz it's so disgusting Like Reply

George Hotz Author 6h Ceyhun (Jay) Derinbogaz it's so disgusting Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7h • Edited • What if I release one zero day a day until a big new model is released? Will this finally make OpenAI and Anthropic shut up about "cybersecurity risk"? Like these things are not that hard to find in most software. I heard something about it costing $20k in tokens I'd do it for less if it wasn't for some whiny bug bounty program. The reason there aren't zero days everywhere is cause nobody seriously looks. Because hacking other people's shit with them is illegal and criminals are usually not very skilled, or they would choose a different line of work. Want more zero days to be found? Make hacking legal. Until then, don't try to claim it's hard, it's just not incentivized. …more 32 comments 19 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 6h Sure, a full stack weaponized exploit in iOS with the 16 sandboxes is hard. But some random software written in C? So easy. …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 6h Sure, a full stack weaponized exploit in iOS with the 16 sandboxes is hard. But some random software written in C? So easy. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Steve McKim’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1d • You all do understand there's no moat around this AI stuff, right? Like if you think cars are deprecating assets, look at GPUs. I know I know the last 6 months, but now look over the last 10 years. Want to buy a 1080 Ti? You can barely give it away. Then if you think GPUs are depreciating assets, look at trained models. Anyone want to use GPT 4 (2023)? It cost $100M to train, and now those weights are worth less than Qwen3.5-27B, which cost about $1M to train. These moatless companies are about to IPO. OMG LOOK AT THE REVENUE GROWTH. Yea, it's not figure robot tier of bad, but I can also grow a companies revenue at this rate. It's called the revenue company and it works like this. I sell dollars for $0.99. Any volume. Those dollars will fly off the shelves. I might even be able to raise prices to $0.999. Look look we have something everyone wants and OUR REVENUE GROWTH IS INSANE. We might be losing a little money but that's so fine cause we are growing we'll just raise. I've never seen a dumber rollout than the AI rollout. Look at LinkedIn "Rewrite with AI" nobody wants this shit. If it's made by AI, it's worthless, cause anyone can make it with AI. This isn't growth of an economy, this is a few swindlers swindling with promises of some revolution or something then when it doesn't happen, sry no refunds. Maybe this finally pops the bubble on the whole US economy. I personally think AI is cool, but the real growth numbers that would need to justify all of this are not there. You are falling for hype. Hope you are prepared for the collapse. …more 1,009 95 comments 52 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 1d I agree, but again Its their money not ours. The billions spent, they already had. The really weird part is if AI was a bust, these are trillion dollar companies with products we dont even know about making them billions already. The GPU price inflation is probably the most direct way this hurts regular people. The irony is the little guy is the one capitalizing on AI -- I just read an article some guy in LA and his brother are at 1.8b on an AI made platform. -- 2 people …more Like Reply 12 replies 12 Replies on Steve McKim’s comment George Hotz Author 1d Are you sure that article is real and not an ad for an AI company? Think about it. Like Reply Diego Rodriguez Prado • 3rd+ cofounder @ krea 1d Steve McKim this one? https://youtu.be/0A2SP-QBByI Like Reply Zach Denney • 3rd+ Solutions Architect | Enterprise AI, Infrastructure & Security Architecture 1d Steve McKim sort of…. Until 401k start buying into these funds and “you” lose control of your now overly risked retirement. I think George’s point is it is all about the application of the models— does what you’re doing add real value, and is that value itself what gives you a moat or brand loyalty. The base systems themselves are going to be inherently valueless… as will be the proprietary models when open source inevitably surpasses them. …more Like Reply Alex Sherman • 3rd+ Founding Editor at @Sherman • Entrepreneur 1d Steve McKim George Hotz im sure (and thats now investigating by some authorities) this business is scam - not sure about their revenue 🙈🤫 generated doctors profiles selling some ozempic alternatives - one man (yet they are 8+ even by their story) billion scam Progress? Dont think so 🥲 …more Like Reply Artie Nazarov • 3rd+ Sustainability Science Innovation at AWS | Species conservation research at UCSC 1d Steve McKim it’s not just about the money gained/lost. This speculative growth is incurring massive damages on human community health, biodiversity impact, carbon emissions, electrical grid resilience, etc. it’s not all about cash and who walks away with it, it’s about what happens to our planet for some speculative bullshit …more Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 23h George Hotz https://dnyuz.com/2026/04/02/how-a-i-helped-one-man-and-his-brother-build-a-1-8-billion-company/ How A.I. Helped One Man (and His Brother) Build a $1.8 Billion Company Matthew Gallagher took just two months, $20,000 and more than a dozen artificial intelligence tools to get his start-up off Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 23h Alex Sherman Read the article M8! Choose for yourself. Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h George Hotz Dude You guys are right on this one! WOW Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h Alex Sherman Seems like you guys are right ... I am human, I have no problem admitting when I wrong. The story was captivating and had me going. Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h Diego Rodriguez Prado Thank you for the video! Wow I was wrong Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h I agree with both of you and yes to have your 401K tied to these is a strong point. My point is showing how little effect to them it truly is being how big some of these enterprises are. And Yes my comment on the 1.8b dollar duo was trash thanks to the video I just saw -- I will take being reinformed correctly over walking around missinformed any day of the week. …more Like Reply Wylie Bryant • 3rd+ Cinematographer and Director (Scripted and Unscripted Television, Documentary, Music Video and Branded) 4h Steve McKim it may be their money but they will come running to get bailed out by governments when the house of cards fall. Corporate losses have been socialized in the world for generations, consumers are just too distracted and apathetic to care …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 1d I agree, but again Its their money not ours. The billions spent, they already had. The really weird part is if AI was a bust, these are trillion dollar companies with products we dont even know about making them billions already. The GPU price inflation is probably the most direct way this hurts regular people. The irony is the little guy is the one capitalizing on AI -- I just read an article some guy in LA and his brother are at 1.8b on an AI made platform. -- 2 people …more Like Reply 12 replies 12 Replies on Steve McKim’s comment George Hotz Author 1d Are you sure that article is real and not an ad for an AI company? Think about it. Like Reply Diego Rodriguez Prado • 3rd+ cofounder @ krea 1d Steve McKim this one? https://youtu.be/0A2SP-QBByI Like Reply Zach Denney • 3rd+ Solutions Architect | Enterprise AI, Infrastructure & Security Architecture 1d Steve McKim sort of…. Until 401k start buying into these funds and “you” lose control of your now overly risked retirement. I think George’s point is it is all about the application of the models— does what you’re doing add real value, and is that value itself what gives you a moat or brand loyalty. The base systems themselves are going to be inherently valueless… as will be the proprietary models when open source inevitably surpasses them. …more Like Reply Alex Sherman • 3rd+ Founding Editor at @Sherman • Entrepreneur 1d Steve McKim George Hotz im sure (and thats now investigating by some authorities) this business is scam - not sure about their revenue 🙈🤫 generated doctors profiles selling some ozempic alternatives - one man (yet they are 8+ even by their story) billion scam Progress? Dont think so 🥲 …more Like Reply Artie Nazarov • 3rd+ Sustainability Science Innovation at AWS | Species conservation research at UCSC 1d Steve McKim it’s not just about the money gained/lost. This speculative growth is incurring massive damages on human community health, biodiversity impact, carbon emissions, electrical grid resilience, etc. it’s not all about cash and who walks away with it, it’s about what happens to our planet for some speculative bullshit …more Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 23h George Hotz https://dnyuz.com/2026/04/02/how-a-i-helped-one-man-and-his-brother-build-a-1-8-billion-company/ How A.I. Helped One Man (and His Brother) Build a $1.8 Billion Company Matthew Gallagher took just two months, $20,000 and more than a dozen artificial intelligence tools to get his start-up off Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 23h Alex Sherman Read the article M8! Choose for yourself. Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h George Hotz Dude You guys are right on this one! WOW Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h Alex Sherman Seems like you guys are right ... I am human, I have no problem admitting when I wrong. The story was captivating and had me going. Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h Diego Rodriguez Prado Thank you for the video! Wow I was wrong Like Reply Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h I agree with both of you and yes to have your 401K tied to these is a strong point. My point is showing how little effect to them it truly is being how big some of these enterprises are. And Yes my comment on the 1.8b dollar duo was trash thanks to the video I just saw -- I will take being reinformed correctly over walking around missinformed any day of the week. …more Like Reply Wylie Bryant • 3rd+ Cinematographer and Director (Scripted and Unscripted Television, Documentary, Music Video and Branded) 4h Steve McKim it may be their money but they will come running to get bailed out by governments when the house of cards fall. Corporate losses have been socialized in the world for generations, consumers are just too distracted and apathetic to care …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1d Are you sure that article is real and not an ad for an AI company? Think about it. Like Reply

Diego Rodriguez Prado • 3rd+ cofounder @ krea 1d Steve McKim this one? https://youtu.be/0A2SP-QBByI Like Reply

Zach Denney • 3rd+ Solutions Architect | Enterprise AI, Infrastructure & Security Architecture 1d Steve McKim sort of…. Until 401k start buying into these funds and “you” lose control of your now overly risked retirement. I think George’s point is it is all about the application of the models— does what you’re doing add real value, and is that value itself what gives you a moat or brand loyalty. The base systems themselves are going to be inherently valueless… as will be the proprietary models when open source inevitably surpasses them. …more Like Reply

Alex Sherman • 3rd+ Founding Editor at @Sherman • Entrepreneur 1d Steve McKim George Hotz im sure (and thats now investigating by some authorities) this business is scam - not sure about their revenue 🙈🤫 generated doctors profiles selling some ozempic alternatives - one man (yet they are 8+ even by their story) billion scam Progress? Dont think so 🥲 …more Like Reply

Artie Nazarov • 3rd+ Sustainability Science Innovation at AWS | Species conservation research at UCSC 1d Steve McKim it’s not just about the money gained/lost. This speculative growth is incurring massive damages on human community health, biodiversity impact, carbon emissions, electrical grid resilience, etc. it’s not all about cash and who walks away with it, it’s about what happens to our planet for some speculative bullshit …more Like Reply

Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 23h George Hotz https://dnyuz.com/2026/04/02/how-a-i-helped-one-man-and-his-brother-build-a-1-8-billion-company/ How A.I. Helped One Man (and His Brother) Build a $1.8 Billion Company Matthew Gallagher took just two months, $20,000 and more than a dozen artificial intelligence tools to get his start-up off Like Reply

How A.I. Helped One Man (and His Brother) Build a $1.8 Billion Company Matthew Gallagher took just two months, $20,000 and more than a dozen artificial intelligence tools to get his start-up off

Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 23h Alex Sherman Read the article M8! Choose for yourself. Like Reply

Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h George Hotz Dude You guys are right on this one! WOW Like Reply

Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h Alex Sherman Seems like you guys are right ... I am human, I have no problem admitting when I wrong. The story was captivating and had me going. Like Reply

Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h Diego Rodriguez Prado Thank you for the video! Wow I was wrong Like Reply

Steve McKim • 3rd+ Founder & CEO, Heaviside AI | Creator of NiaShield – Azure‑Exclusive, Zero‑Persistence AI Control Plane | SDIP‑6™ Protocol Architect 21h I agree with both of you and yes to have your 401K tied to these is a strong point. My point is showing how little effect to them it truly is being how big some of these enterprises are. And Yes my comment on the 1.8b dollar duo was trash thanks to the video I just saw -- I will take being reinformed correctly over walking around missinformed any day of the week. …more Like Reply

Wylie Bryant • 3rd+ Cinematographer and Director (Scripted and Unscripted Television, Documentary, Music Video and Branded) 4h Steve McKim it may be their money but they will come running to get bailed out by governments when the house of cards fall. Corporate losses have been socialized in the world for generations, consumers are just too distracted and apathetic to care …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Shiv Patel’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1d • You all do understand there's no moat around this AI stuff, right? Like if you think cars are deprecating assets, look at GPUs. I know I know the last 6 months, but now look over the last 10 years. Want to buy a 1080 Ti? You can barely give it away. Then if you think GPUs are depreciating assets, look at trained models. Anyone want to use GPT 4 (2023)? It cost $100M to train, and now those weights are worth less than Qwen3.5-27B, which cost about $1M to train. These moatless companies are about to IPO. OMG LOOK AT THE REVENUE GROWTH. Yea, it's not figure robot tier of bad, but I can also grow a companies revenue at this rate. It's called the revenue company and it works like this. I sell dollars for $0.99. Any volume. Those dollars will fly off the shelves. I might even be able to raise prices to $0.999. Look look we have something everyone wants and OUR REVENUE GROWTH IS INSANE. We might be losing a little money but that's so fine cause we are growing we'll just raise. I've never seen a dumber rollout than the AI rollout. Look at LinkedIn "Rewrite with AI" nobody wants this shit. If it's made by AI, it's worthless, cause anyone can make it with AI. This isn't growth of an economy, this is a few swindlers swindling with promises of some revolution or something then when it doesn't happen, sry no refunds. Maybe this finally pops the bubble on the whole US economy. I personally think AI is cool, but the real growth numbers that would need to justify all of this are not there. You are falling for hype. Hope you are prepared for the collapse. …more 1,009 95 comments 52 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Shiv Patel • 3rd+ ATOMS Founder | Helping Hardware Companies Ship Safety Critical Products Faster 1d I was gonna buy this thing but you just talked me out of it. Thanks ! …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Shiv Patel’s comment George Hotz Author 1d Shiv Patel lol okay enjoy the perpetual underclass if you don't have at least one 🤣 Like Reply Load more comments

Shiv Patel • 3rd+ ATOMS Founder | Helping Hardware Companies Ship Safety Critical Products Faster 1d I was gonna buy this thing but you just talked me out of it. Thanks ! …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Shiv Patel’s comment George Hotz Author 1d Shiv Patel lol okay enjoy the perpetual underclass if you don't have at least one 🤣 Like Reply

George Hotz Author 1d Shiv Patel lol okay enjoy the perpetual underclass if you don't have at least one 🤣 Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2w • lol some of you are dumb enough to think you can get a bag and get "out." where is this out you speak of? the boomers already spent your retirement and lived that life. you don't get to. you get to watch more and more grift happen with some absolutely puzzling take that you are the guy on the inside bro you aren't I've forgotten more about grift than you ever knew. I went through the system I poked a hole in the wall at the end of the earth there's nothing there but emptiness. drywall. what's your number? how big a bag of fake dollars would it take? it's only once you realize that there's no number that you can finally come back and understand that we are all we have and we live in a society. how much more demoralization do you need before you join me here? it's not a question of if, it's a question of when. how much worse will things have to get before you realize you are wrong? …more 25 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2w lol 167 impressions ... I don't think LinkedIn liked this post. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Jeremy B. • 3rd+ CISSP | CEH | CASP+ | CCFA | CCFR 6d Why do you care about these numbers? Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2w lol 167 impressions ... I don't think LinkedIn liked this post. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Jeremy B. • 3rd+ CISSP | CEH | CASP+ | CCFA | CCFR 6d Why do you care about these numbers? Like Reply

Jeremy B. • 3rd+ CISSP | CEH | CASP+ | CCFA | CCFR 6d Why do you care about these numbers? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Michael Core’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2w • lol some of you are dumb enough to think you can get a bag and get "out." where is this out you speak of? the boomers already spent your retirement and lived that life. you don't get to. you get to watch more and more grift happen with some absolutely puzzling take that you are the guy on the inside bro you aren't I've forgotten more about grift than you ever knew. I went through the system I poked a hole in the wall at the end of the earth there's nothing there but emptiness. drywall. what's your number? how big a bag of fake dollars would it take? it's only once you realize that there's no number that you can finally come back and understand that we are all we have and we live in a society. how much more demoralization do you need before you join me here? it's not a question of if, it's a question of when. how much worse will things have to get before you realize you are wrong? …more 25 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Michael Core • 3rd+ Independent Engineer AI Alignment Safety, Security Consultant formerly @ IBM | CISSP, PMP, AWS Certified 2w BREAKING NEWS : NVIDIA CEO announces “we’ve achieved AGI” You can here it yourself on Lex Friedman and Jensen CEO of Nvidia https://youtu.be/vif8NQcjVf0?t=6968 …more Jensen Huang: NVIDIA - The $4 Trillion Company & the AI Revolution | Lex Fridman Podcast #494 Jensen Huang is the co-founder and CEO of NVIDIA, the world's most valuable company and the engine powering the AI computing revolution. Thank you for listening ❤ Check out our sponsors: https://lexfridman.com/sponsors/ep494-sb See below for... Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Michael Core’s comment George Hotz Author 2w Michael Core oh cool can it make me a cup of coffee? Like Reply Michael Core • 3rd+ Independent Engineer AI Alignment Safety, Security Consultant formerly @ IBM | CISSP, PMP, AWS Certified 2w Thanks George, only if You 😊 HELP DESIGN the AI Infrastructure before it Designs US. BREAKING NEWS : NVIDIA CEO announces “we’ve achieved AGI” Hear it on Lex Friedman with Jensen CEO of Nvidia Minute 01:56:32 https://youtu.be/vif8NQcjVf0?t=6839 …more Like Reply Michael Core • 3rd+ Independent Engineer AI Alignment Safety, Security Consultant formerly @ IBM | CISSP, PMP, AWS Certified 2w coffee? we got the C&D - BREAKING NEWS: GTA6 Grand Theft Auto sends Cease and Desist C&D to Grand Theft Robot GTR .COM "Likely hood of Confusion" they have no idea... who will win? Where to PIVOT ? https://grandtheftrobot.com/ HELP Design the AI Infrastructure before it Designs US ? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R7K1chJSvwM&list=PLLGFh4UHXhUpYmbgPUxj7z777Q-Z5ifcD&index=27 …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Michael Core • 3rd+ Independent Engineer AI Alignment Safety, Security Consultant formerly @ IBM | CISSP, PMP, AWS Certified 2w BREAKING NEWS : NVIDIA CEO announces “we’ve achieved AGI” You can here it yourself on Lex Friedman and Jensen CEO of Nvidia https://youtu.be/vif8NQcjVf0?t=6968 …more Jensen Huang: NVIDIA - The $4 Trillion Company & the AI Revolution | Lex Fridman Podcast #494 Jensen Huang is the co-founder and CEO of NVIDIA, the world's most valuable company and the engine powering the AI computing revolution. Thank you for listening ❤ Check out our sponsors: https://lexfridman.com/sponsors/ep494-sb See below for... Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Michael Core’s comment George Hotz Author 2w Michael Core oh cool can it make me a cup of coffee? Like Reply Michael Core • 3rd+ Independent Engineer AI Alignment Safety, Security Consultant formerly @ IBM | CISSP, PMP, AWS Certified 2w Thanks George, only if You 😊 HELP DESIGN the AI Infrastructure before it Designs US. BREAKING NEWS : NVIDIA CEO announces “we’ve achieved AGI” Hear it on Lex Friedman with Jensen CEO of Nvidia Minute 01:56:32 https://youtu.be/vif8NQcjVf0?t=6839 …more Like Reply Michael Core • 3rd+ Independent Engineer AI Alignment Safety, Security Consultant formerly @ IBM | CISSP, PMP, AWS Certified 2w coffee? we got the C&D - BREAKING NEWS: GTA6 Grand Theft Auto sends Cease and Desist C&D to Grand Theft Robot GTR .COM "Likely hood of Confusion" they have no idea... who will win? Where to PIVOT ? https://grandtheftrobot.com/ HELP Design the AI Infrastructure before it Designs US ? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R7K1chJSvwM&list=PLLGFh4UHXhUpYmbgPUxj7z777Q-Z5ifcD&index=27 …more Like Reply Collapse replies

Jensen Huang: NVIDIA - The $4 Trillion Company & the AI Revolution | Lex Fridman Podcast #494 Jensen Huang is the co-founder and CEO of NVIDIA, the world's most valuable company and the engine powering the AI computing revolution. Thank you for listening ❤ Check out our sponsors: https://lexfridman.com/sponsors/ep494-sb See below for...

George Hotz Author 2w Michael Core oh cool can it make me a cup of coffee? Like Reply

Michael Core • 3rd+ Independent Engineer AI Alignment Safety, Security Consultant formerly @ IBM | CISSP, PMP, AWS Certified 2w Thanks George, only if You 😊 HELP DESIGN the AI Infrastructure before it Designs US. BREAKING NEWS : NVIDIA CEO announces “we’ve achieved AGI” Hear it on Lex Friedman with Jensen CEO of Nvidia Minute 01:56:32 https://youtu.be/vif8NQcjVf0?t=6839 …more Like Reply

Michael Core • 3rd+ Independent Engineer AI Alignment Safety, Security Consultant formerly @ IBM | CISSP, PMP, AWS Certified 2w coffee? we got the C&D - BREAKING NEWS: GTA6 Grand Theft Auto sends Cease and Desist C&D to Grand Theft Robot GTR .COM "Likely hood of Confusion" they have no idea... who will win? Where to PIVOT ? https://grandtheftrobot.com/ HELP Design the AI Infrastructure before it Designs US ? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R7K1chJSvwM&list=PLLGFh4UHXhUpYmbgPUxj7z777Q-Z5ifcD&index=27 …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Daniel Wade’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • The US has closed source AI models with rules and terms and stuff. The Chinese have open source AI models you can just do things with. The world will use the Chinese models (which encode Chinese values). Most people won't alter them and use them as is. The US was unquestionably the top soft power exporting country. Now this is flipping. AI models stand to be the top soft power export in history. …more 38 comments 13 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things 2w Yup. The US gonna be left holding the bag. In this case the bag will be full of Nvidia GPUs m Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Daniel Wade’s comment George Hotz Author 2w Daniel Wade nah those are fake NVIDIA GPUs they just have the serial number sticker from real ones swapped with a hair dryer Like Reply Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things 2w George Hotz but they look real enough from a distance! Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things 2w Yup. The US gonna be left holding the bag. In this case the bag will be full of Nvidia GPUs m Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Daniel Wade’s comment George Hotz Author 2w Daniel Wade nah those are fake NVIDIA GPUs they just have the serial number sticker from real ones swapped with a hair dryer Like Reply Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things 2w George Hotz but they look real enough from a distance! Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2w Daniel Wade nah those are fake NVIDIA GPUs they just have the serial number sticker from real ones swapped with a hair dryer Like Reply

Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things 2w George Hotz but they look real enough from a distance! Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James O'Neil’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2w • Edited • we live on the precipice of the birth of the successor of humanity. the closest analogy is how the monkeys must have felt when humans came. and you...you realize this, and you make it your life goal to get more monkey coin. you lie cheat and steal for monkey coin. you sell out your fellow monkey for monkey coin. moar monkey coin!!! …more 58 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James O'Neil • 3rd+ No strategy without execution. 2w What’s the exchange rate for bananas vs. monkey coins right now? Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on James O'Neil’s comment George Hotz Author 2w James O'Neil Bananas, due to being a real physical good with a use, retained some value. Monkey coin, like all fiat currencies, is lost to history. Like Reply Load more comments

James O'Neil • 3rd+ No strategy without execution. 2w What’s the exchange rate for bananas vs. monkey coins right now? Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on James O'Neil’s comment George Hotz Author 2w James O'Neil Bananas, due to being a real physical good with a use, retained some value. Monkey coin, like all fiat currencies, is lost to history. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2w James O'Neil Bananas, due to being a real physical good with a use, retained some value. Monkey coin, like all fiat currencies, is lost to history. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Joe Moss’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2w • Edited • we live on the precipice of the birth of the successor of humanity. the closest analogy is how the monkeys must have felt when humans came. and you...you realize this, and you make it your life goal to get more monkey coin. you lie cheat and steal for monkey coin. you sell out your fellow monkey for monkey coin. moar monkey coin!!! …more 58 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Joe Moss • 3rd+ writing the 2026 book on advisortech 2w humans didn't come from monkeys, that's like saying a pile of dirt will turn into an iphone if you just wait long enough …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Joe Moss’ comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 2w Joe Moss 🚀🔥 watches don't just make themselves! Like Reply John Swystun • 3rd+ Growth Systems for RIAs & WealthTech | Fully-managed digital marketing/lead gen | Turnkey talent/software/design/ad spend/web dev/content​ = dead simple | Compliance focused |🗓️Secure Your Free Exec Workshop Below ⬇️ (edited) 2w Joe Moss 🚀🔥 at no point in this post did George Hotz make an evolutionary claim. He's positing that the earth is about to bear witness to a new superior species. New top dog. New apex. And it's going to be so different. So hard to understand. Is going feel to us like it must have felt for monkeys, when they saw humans for the first time. …more Like Reply Load more comments

Joe Moss • 3rd+ writing the 2026 book on advisortech 2w humans didn't come from monkeys, that's like saying a pile of dirt will turn into an iphone if you just wait long enough …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Joe Moss’ comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 2w Joe Moss 🚀🔥 watches don't just make themselves! Like Reply John Swystun • 3rd+ Growth Systems for RIAs & WealthTech | Fully-managed digital marketing/lead gen | Turnkey talent/software/design/ad spend/web dev/content​ = dead simple | Compliance focused |🗓️Secure Your Free Exec Workshop Below ⬇️ (edited) 2w Joe Moss 🚀🔥 at no point in this post did George Hotz make an evolutionary claim. He's positing that the earth is about to bear witness to a new superior species. New top dog. New apex. And it's going to be so different. So hard to understand. Is going feel to us like it must have felt for monkeys, when they saw humans for the first time. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2w Joe Moss 🚀🔥 watches don't just make themselves! Like Reply

John Swystun • 3rd+ Growth Systems for RIAs & WealthTech | Fully-managed digital marketing/lead gen | Turnkey talent/software/design/ad spend/web dev/content​ = dead simple | Compliance focused |🗓️Secure Your Free Exec Workshop Below ⬇️ (edited) 2w Joe Moss 🚀🔥 at no point in this post did George Hotz make an evolutionary claim. He's positing that the earth is about to bear witness to a new superior species. New top dog. New apex. And it's going to be so different. So hard to understand. Is going feel to us like it must have felt for monkeys, when they saw humans for the first time. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Chris Liberti’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2w • Edited • we live on the precipice of the birth of the successor of humanity. the closest analogy is how the monkeys must have felt when humans came. and you...you realize this, and you make it your life goal to get more monkey coin. you lie cheat and steal for monkey coin. you sell out your fellow monkey for monkey coin. moar monkey coin!!! …more 58 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Chris Liberti • 3rd+ Ad Ops & Ad Tech Leader | Identity Resolution & Engagement Analytics (Adobe Analytics) | Data Strategy/Product | Sustainability & EV | SF Bay/Remote 2w I’ll be happy the day when I can set machines free to do 100% of my work. I don’t enjoy work I do it to pay for things that I need or want in life. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Chris Liberti’s comment George Hotz Author 2w Chris Liberti oh lol if the machines are doing the work you aren't gonna get paid for it. whoever is paying will cut out the middleman Like Reply Chris Liberti • 3rd+ Ad Ops & Ad Tech Leader | Identity Resolution & Engagement Analytics (Adobe Analytics) | Data Strategy/Product | Sustainability & EV | SF Bay/Remote 2w George Hotz so how do we survive then? Same old model applied to the current work? Tax machine output? Or do we just all die off. Is this how the voluntary human extinction project eventually happens? Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Chris Liberti • 3rd+ Ad Ops & Ad Tech Leader | Identity Resolution & Engagement Analytics (Adobe Analytics) | Data Strategy/Product | Sustainability & EV | SF Bay/Remote 2w I’ll be happy the day when I can set machines free to do 100% of my work. I don’t enjoy work I do it to pay for things that I need or want in life. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Chris Liberti’s comment George Hotz Author 2w Chris Liberti oh lol if the machines are doing the work you aren't gonna get paid for it. whoever is paying will cut out the middleman Like Reply Chris Liberti • 3rd+ Ad Ops & Ad Tech Leader | Identity Resolution & Engagement Analytics (Adobe Analytics) | Data Strategy/Product | Sustainability & EV | SF Bay/Remote 2w George Hotz so how do we survive then? Same old model applied to the current work? Tax machine output? Or do we just all die off. Is this how the voluntary human extinction project eventually happens? Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2w Chris Liberti oh lol if the machines are doing the work you aren't gonna get paid for it. whoever is paying will cut out the middleman Like Reply

Chris Liberti • 3rd+ Ad Ops & Ad Tech Leader | Identity Resolution & Engagement Analytics (Adobe Analytics) | Data Strategy/Product | Sustainability & EV | SF Bay/Remote 2w George Hotz so how do we survive then? Same old model applied to the current work? Tax machine output? Or do we just all die off. Is this how the voluntary human extinction project eventually happens? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to John W.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2w • Edited • we live on the precipice of the birth of the successor of humanity. the closest analogy is how the monkeys must have felt when humans came. and you...you realize this, and you make it your life goal to get more monkey coin. you lie cheat and steal for monkey coin. you sell out your fellow monkey for monkey coin. moar monkey coin!!! …more 58 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder (edited) 2w Machines don't have consciousness. :) debate me all you want. I'm in the Michael Pollan, abstracted school of thought, and not with all the gear heads in the room, who need something to latch onto to make work meaningful. …more Like Reply 14 replies 14 Replies on John W.’s comment George Hotz Author 2w John Waller what about monkeys? Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w George Hotz What about the plants? We are not Gods. We are derivatives of some fun stuff that biology has handed us in the uninterrupted period of time that the cosmo planted here - baseline belief structure on how we derived at our "conciousness". At some point in the future humans will blur that line and we become the Chappie (movie reference) variation of our species - but our variations now for sure do not have that, unless its hiding from us (simulation theory). However, it is just the world's best mimic machine based on our own collective output, that our evolved monkey brains have dreamed up. It does not have a consciousness in the definition framework we operate. Although, monkeys may be bloating my head with mashed keys on the other side of the simulation - so, ya .. what about the monkeys? …more Like Reply Jefferey Odgis • 3rd+ Technology & Media Consultant 2w John W. They eat plants Like Reply Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 2w John W. I doubt you can define consciousness anymore than you can define intelligence yet alone what makes it natural vs artificial. Do you think you can even have intelligence without consciousness? Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w Jefferey Odgis maybe they WANT to be eaten? No pain receptors .. think of grass. It wants to be mowed. It helps it propagate. :) Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w Tobias Shively You can't define consciousness ... yet. You can only frame it. There is no way to know how you perceive what I do, considering we each have our own unique experience lived through our own state. Its fundamentally a problem for the ages. …more Like Reply Tertius Geldenhuys • 3rd+ SWE 2w John W. I agree to an extent. The availability of the latest technology is not available to civilians, first they’re going to be used in military. Therefore, your answer is correct from your perspective. Like Reply Dan Pena • 3rd+ Senior React Developer 2w John W. yeah, consciousness is exclusive to pieces of meat floating around in a calcium box Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. Sarcasm so thick we can't even tell if he's trolling... Amazing how "smart" people can't tell the difference between that which is alive vs that which is dead; that which is sentient and that which is not; that which is animate and that which is inanimate. And they simultaneously complain about their feeds being taken over by AI slop. Hypocrisy is off the charts! …more Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w James Maniotis You'll survive. Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. Never implied that I would not... Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w James Maniotis Might want to bring a book to a debate fight. Catch up on Christof Koch and David Chalmers, my guy. Thanks for playing. Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. You're unable to make an argument so you cite an entire body of work? You'd think all of the AI would make it easy :P Like Reply Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 6d John W. Consciousness is ontologically primary. Complex systems do not create consciousness from nothing; they organize, localize, and tune consciousness into increasingly coherent forms. Intelligence is the recursive increase of coherence within those tuned forms, and science is a symbolic method that emerges within intelligence as consciousness studies its own patterned expressions. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder (edited) 2w Machines don't have consciousness. :) debate me all you want. I'm in the Michael Pollan, abstracted school of thought, and not with all the gear heads in the room, who need something to latch onto to make work meaningful. …more Like Reply 14 replies 14 Replies on John W.’s comment George Hotz Author 2w John Waller what about monkeys? Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w George Hotz What about the plants? We are not Gods. We are derivatives of some fun stuff that biology has handed us in the uninterrupted period of time that the cosmo planted here - baseline belief structure on how we derived at our "conciousness". At some point in the future humans will blur that line and we become the Chappie (movie reference) variation of our species - but our variations now for sure do not have that, unless its hiding from us (simulation theory). However, it is just the world's best mimic machine based on our own collective output, that our evolved monkey brains have dreamed up. It does not have a consciousness in the definition framework we operate. Although, monkeys may be bloating my head with mashed keys on the other side of the simulation - so, ya .. what about the monkeys? …more Like Reply Jefferey Odgis • 3rd+ Technology & Media Consultant 2w John W. They eat plants Like Reply Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 2w John W. I doubt you can define consciousness anymore than you can define intelligence yet alone what makes it natural vs artificial. Do you think you can even have intelligence without consciousness? Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w Jefferey Odgis maybe they WANT to be eaten? No pain receptors .. think of grass. It wants to be mowed. It helps it propagate. :) Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w Tobias Shively You can't define consciousness ... yet. You can only frame it. There is no way to know how you perceive what I do, considering we each have our own unique experience lived through our own state. Its fundamentally a problem for the ages. …more Like Reply Tertius Geldenhuys • 3rd+ SWE 2w John W. I agree to an extent. The availability of the latest technology is not available to civilians, first they’re going to be used in military. Therefore, your answer is correct from your perspective. Like Reply Dan Pena • 3rd+ Senior React Developer 2w John W. yeah, consciousness is exclusive to pieces of meat floating around in a calcium box Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. Sarcasm so thick we can't even tell if he's trolling... Amazing how "smart" people can't tell the difference between that which is alive vs that which is dead; that which is sentient and that which is not; that which is animate and that which is inanimate. And they simultaneously complain about their feeds being taken over by AI slop. Hypocrisy is off the charts! …more Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w James Maniotis You'll survive. Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. Never implied that I would not... Like Reply John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w James Maniotis Might want to bring a book to a debate fight. Catch up on Christof Koch and David Chalmers, my guy. Thanks for playing. Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. You're unable to make an argument so you cite an entire body of work? You'd think all of the AI would make it easy :P Like Reply Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 6d John W. Consciousness is ontologically primary. Complex systems do not create consciousness from nothing; they organize, localize, and tune consciousness into increasingly coherent forms. Intelligence is the recursive increase of coherence within those tuned forms, and science is a symbolic method that emerges within intelligence as consciousness studies its own patterned expressions. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2w John Waller what about monkeys? Like Reply

John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w George Hotz What about the plants? We are not Gods. We are derivatives of some fun stuff that biology has handed us in the uninterrupted period of time that the cosmo planted here - baseline belief structure on how we derived at our "conciousness". At some point in the future humans will blur that line and we become the Chappie (movie reference) variation of our species - but our variations now for sure do not have that, unless its hiding from us (simulation theory). However, it is just the world's best mimic machine based on our own collective output, that our evolved monkey brains have dreamed up. It does not have a consciousness in the definition framework we operate. Although, monkeys may be bloating my head with mashed keys on the other side of the simulation - so, ya .. what about the monkeys? …more Like Reply

Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 2w John W. I doubt you can define consciousness anymore than you can define intelligence yet alone what makes it natural vs artificial. Do you think you can even have intelligence without consciousness? Like Reply

John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w Jefferey Odgis maybe they WANT to be eaten? No pain receptors .. think of grass. It wants to be mowed. It helps it propagate. :) Like Reply

John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w Tobias Shively You can't define consciousness ... yet. You can only frame it. There is no way to know how you perceive what I do, considering we each have our own unique experience lived through our own state. Its fundamentally a problem for the ages. …more Like Reply

Tertius Geldenhuys • 3rd+ SWE 2w John W. I agree to an extent. The availability of the latest technology is not available to civilians, first they’re going to be used in military. Therefore, your answer is correct from your perspective. Like Reply

Dan Pena • 3rd+ Senior React Developer 2w John W. yeah, consciousness is exclusive to pieces of meat floating around in a calcium box Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. Sarcasm so thick we can't even tell if he's trolling... Amazing how "smart" people can't tell the difference between that which is alive vs that which is dead; that which is sentient and that which is not; that which is animate and that which is inanimate. And they simultaneously complain about their feeds being taken over by AI slop. Hypocrisy is off the charts! …more Like Reply

John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w James Maniotis You'll survive. Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. Never implied that I would not... Like Reply

John W. • 3rd+ Enterprise Architect | GenAI | Maker | Founder 2w James Maniotis Might want to bring a book to a debate fight. Catch up on Christof Koch and David Chalmers, my guy. Thanks for playing. Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 2w John W. You're unable to make an argument so you cite an entire body of work? You'd think all of the AI would make it easy :P Like Reply

Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 6d John W. Consciousness is ontologically primary. Complex systems do not create consciousness from nothing; they organize, localize, and tune consciousness into increasingly coherent forms. Intelligence is the recursive increase of coherence within those tuned forms, and science is a symbolic method that emerges within intelligence as consciousness studies its own patterned expressions. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2w • Edited • we live on the precipice of the birth of the successor of humanity. the closest analogy is how the monkeys must have felt when humans came. and you...you realize this, and you make it your life goal to get more monkey coin. you lie cheat and steal for monkey coin. you sell out your fellow monkey for monkey coin. moar monkey coin!!! …more 58 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2w you know the humans didn't care about monkey coin, right? Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies William Bown • 3rd+ Mad Scientist - software architect & founder #AI #XR #AIR 2w Derek Burgess you forgot that monkey coin is 💩 logs, not shiny at all Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2w you know the humans didn't care about monkey coin, right? Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies William Bown • 3rd+ Mad Scientist - software architect & founder #AI #XR #AIR 2w Derek Burgess you forgot that monkey coin is 💩 logs, not shiny at all Like Reply

William Bown • 3rd+ Mad Scientist - software architect & founder #AI #XR #AIR 2w Derek Burgess you forgot that monkey coin is 💩 logs, not shiny at all Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Ikboljon Obidjonov’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2w • Edited • Anthropic is an unacceptable risk to national security. If anyone is building the AI doom machine, it's them. More seriously, this behavior will leave them as a footnote in AI history. https://lnkd.in/gnuNmJqm …more anthropic legal requests by thdxr · Pull Request #18186 · anomalyco/opencode github.com 49 comments 13 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Ikboljon Obidjonov • 3rd+ 8x Certified Salesforce Product Owner/Admin at Moss 2w “Remove opencode-anthropic-auth builtin plugin” - Anthropic what is with the bizzare hostility to open source? …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Ikboljon Obidjonov’s comment George Hotz Author 2w Ikboljon Obidjonov this is clearly not a company anyone should integrate into anything critical Like Reply Derek Burgess • 3rd+ Neuromancer 2w Everyone's hostile to open source, you contribute cash to sweat to a oss project lately? Like Reply Ikboljon Obidjonov • 3rd+ 8x Certified Salesforce Product Owner/Admin at Moss 2w Derek Burgess there’s hostile and then there’s this. This doesn’t even help them financially or otherwise. It just looks like purely agenda driven Like Reply Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture (edited) 2w George Hotz yeah let's grab the pitchforks & torches does anyone have a rope? Give them some time this is their "baby/child" they don't think it's ready to join the DoW, mind you in the 21st century we don't have full self driverless but it's ok to give this to the military sounds .... meh ... Oh well …more Like Reply Kenny Sheridan • 3rd+ Member of Technical Staff - Product @ Andromeda | Deterministic Performance & Rust & Linux | US Marine | Former ServiceNow 2w George Hotz sadly, so many companies are though. And engineers suggest standardizing on it...which makes me nervous from a organizational risk perspective Like Reply George Hotz Author 2w Kenny Sheridan lol, they'll regret it. when someone shows you who they are, believe them. Like Reply Derek Burgess • 3rd+ Neuromancer 2w It likely cuts costs. If they are subsidizing massively, which they are... you would need to reign in 3rd parties, particually token burners. So yes, agenda driven. Hostile? Depends on who you are... Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Ikboljon Obidjonov • 3rd+ 8x Certified Salesforce Product Owner/Admin at Moss 2w “Remove opencode-anthropic-auth builtin plugin” - Anthropic what is with the bizzare hostility to open source? …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Ikboljon Obidjonov’s comment George Hotz Author 2w Ikboljon Obidjonov this is clearly not a company anyone should integrate into anything critical Like Reply Derek Burgess • 3rd+ Neuromancer 2w Everyone's hostile to open source, you contribute cash to sweat to a oss project lately? Like Reply Ikboljon Obidjonov • 3rd+ 8x Certified Salesforce Product Owner/Admin at Moss 2w Derek Burgess there’s hostile and then there’s this. This doesn’t even help them financially or otherwise. It just looks like purely agenda driven Like Reply Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture (edited) 2w George Hotz yeah let's grab the pitchforks & torches does anyone have a rope? Give them some time this is their "baby/child" they don't think it's ready to join the DoW, mind you in the 21st century we don't have full self driverless but it's ok to give this to the military sounds .... meh ... Oh well …more Like Reply Kenny Sheridan • 3rd+ Member of Technical Staff - Product @ Andromeda | Deterministic Performance & Rust & Linux | US Marine | Former ServiceNow 2w George Hotz sadly, so many companies are though. And engineers suggest standardizing on it...which makes me nervous from a organizational risk perspective Like Reply George Hotz Author 2w Kenny Sheridan lol, they'll regret it. when someone shows you who they are, believe them. Like Reply Derek Burgess • 3rd+ Neuromancer 2w It likely cuts costs. If they are subsidizing massively, which they are... you would need to reign in 3rd parties, particually token burners. So yes, agenda driven. Hostile? Depends on who you are... Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2w Ikboljon Obidjonov this is clearly not a company anyone should integrate into anything critical Like Reply

Derek Burgess • 3rd+ Neuromancer 2w Everyone's hostile to open source, you contribute cash to sweat to a oss project lately? Like Reply

Ikboljon Obidjonov • 3rd+ 8x Certified Salesforce Product Owner/Admin at Moss 2w Derek Burgess there’s hostile and then there’s this. This doesn’t even help them financially or otherwise. It just looks like purely agenda driven Like Reply

Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture (edited) 2w George Hotz yeah let's grab the pitchforks & torches does anyone have a rope? Give them some time this is their "baby/child" they don't think it's ready to join the DoW, mind you in the 21st century we don't have full self driverless but it's ok to give this to the military sounds .... meh ... Oh well …more Like Reply

Kenny Sheridan • 3rd+ Member of Technical Staff - Product @ Andromeda | Deterministic Performance & Rust & Linux | US Marine | Former ServiceNow 2w George Hotz sadly, so many companies are though. And engineers suggest standardizing on it...which makes me nervous from a organizational risk perspective Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2w Kenny Sheridan lol, they'll regret it. when someone shows you who they are, believe them. Like Reply

Derek Burgess • 3rd+ Neuromancer 2w It likely cuts costs. If they are subsidizing massively, which they are... you would need to reign in 3rd parties, particually token burners. So yes, agenda driven. Hostile? Depends on who you are... Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Ashwin S.K’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3w • lol anyone else realized that the internet is over? I'm just writing in my diary here. rip internet. like it used to be cool for a lil bit there but now it's all bots and people programmed to be bots. I hope the corporations enjoy this empire of dirt. is your company paying to run ads? you know nobody sees them anymore, right? you are being billed for impressions of machine eyeballs. google and facebooks are straight up taking your money to show your crap to machines. so like, where's the new internet at? do I have to leave my basement and go outside? I want a new internet but without the corporations like we'll put a sign up that says no corporations and we'll all boooo if they come and make them eat crab shit …more 100 comments 28 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Ashwin S.K • 3rd+ Co-Founder @ Swipeondeck 🎟️ | Imperial College London 3w Tried the gemini protocol. Was an absolute tragedy. Maybe Nostr? Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Ashwin S.K’s comment George Hotz Author 3w Ashwin S.K oh it's just over. heavenbanning is here and will follow you everywherre. at least the real world is good till the replicants come Like Reply Ashwin S.K • 3rd+ Co-Founder @ Swipeondeck 🎟️ | Imperial College London 3w George Hotz don't need to think about Pascal's wager anymore , infinite loss either way. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Ashwin S.K • 3rd+ Co-Founder @ Swipeondeck 🎟️ | Imperial College London 3w Tried the gemini protocol. Was an absolute tragedy. Maybe Nostr? Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Ashwin S.K’s comment George Hotz Author 3w Ashwin S.K oh it's just over. heavenbanning is here and will follow you everywherre. at least the real world is good till the replicants come Like Reply Ashwin S.K • 3rd+ Co-Founder @ Swipeondeck 🎟️ | Imperial College London 3w George Hotz don't need to think about Pascal's wager anymore , infinite loss either way. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3w Ashwin S.K oh it's just over. heavenbanning is here and will follow you everywherre. at least the real world is good till the replicants come Like Reply

Ashwin S.K • 3rd+ Co-Founder @ Swipeondeck 🎟️ | Imperial College London 3w George Hotz don't need to think about Pascal's wager anymore , infinite loss either way. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jad Nohra’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3w • lol anyone else realized that the internet is over? I'm just writing in my diary here. rip internet. like it used to be cool for a lil bit there but now it's all bots and people programmed to be bots. I hope the corporations enjoy this empire of dirt. is your company paying to run ads? you know nobody sees them anymore, right? you are being billed for impressions of machine eyeballs. google and facebooks are straight up taking your money to show your crap to machines. so like, where's the new internet at? do I have to leave my basement and go outside? I want a new internet but without the corporations like we'll put a sign up that says no corporations and we'll all boooo if they come and make them eat crab shit …more 100 comments 28 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. (edited) 3w The internet is indeed over. I’m particularly fascinated by the startups trying to use LLMs to automate for domains that the mere presence of LLMs makes obsolete. Example: let’s make it easier for you to create viral internet ads. Don’t we realize that a lot of this is self deprecating? …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Jad Nohra’s comment George Hotz Author 3w Jad Nohra we need to bring back my old saying "keep hacking elite" like who are these losers making these startups? they need to GTFO Like Reply Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. 3w George Hotz you hit a deep point Like Reply Mohamed Mustapha T. • 3rd+ Techlead | Enterpreneur (edited) 3w George Hotz tru this Like Reply John Pinto • 3rd+ Procurement Automation @ Uc Operations LLC 3w George Hotz Garry tan goons Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. (edited) 3w The internet is indeed over. I’m particularly fascinated by the startups trying to use LLMs to automate for domains that the mere presence of LLMs makes obsolete. Example: let’s make it easier for you to create viral internet ads. Don’t we realize that a lot of this is self deprecating? …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Jad Nohra’s comment George Hotz Author 3w Jad Nohra we need to bring back my old saying "keep hacking elite" like who are these losers making these startups? they need to GTFO Like Reply Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. 3w George Hotz you hit a deep point Like Reply Mohamed Mustapha T. • 3rd+ Techlead | Enterpreneur (edited) 3w George Hotz tru this Like Reply John Pinto • 3rd+ Procurement Automation @ Uc Operations LLC 3w George Hotz Garry tan goons Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3w Jad Nohra we need to bring back my old saying "keep hacking elite" like who are these losers making these startups? they need to GTFO Like Reply

Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. 3w George Hotz you hit a deep point Like Reply

John Pinto • 3rd+ Procurement Automation @ Uc Operations LLC 3w George Hotz Garry tan goons Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Shany Golan’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3w • lol anyone else realized that the internet is over? I'm just writing in my diary here. rip internet. like it used to be cool for a lil bit there but now it's all bots and people programmed to be bots. I hope the corporations enjoy this empire of dirt. is your company paying to run ads? you know nobody sees them anymore, right? you are being billed for impressions of machine eyeballs. google and facebooks are straight up taking your money to show your crap to machines. so like, where's the new internet at? do I have to leave my basement and go outside? I want a new internet but without the corporations like we'll put a sign up that says no corporations and we'll all boooo if they come and make them eat crab shit …more 100 comments 28 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's 3w Web3? Lmao Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Shany Golan’s comment George Hotz Author 3w Shany Golan I was looking for less shills, not the world's biggest shill-a-thon Like Reply Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's 3w George Hotz haha Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's 3w Web3? Lmao Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Shany Golan’s comment George Hotz Author 3w Shany Golan I was looking for less shills, not the world's biggest shill-a-thon Like Reply Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's 3w George Hotz haha Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3w Shany Golan I was looking for less shills, not the world's biggest shill-a-thon Like Reply

Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's 3w George Hotz haha Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Alexandru Badea’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3w • Do you know about polynomial time factoring algorithms? Your crypto, computers, and family might not be safe. Learn more on my blog. 23 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Alexandru Badea • 3rd+ BD Director @ NAGA | CFD & Social Trading | Building the future of retail trading from Dubai 🇦🇪 | AI x Fintech builder | Connecting affiliates & trading educators globally 3w George Hotz Recognizing the strategic impact of polynomial time factoring on digital security is critical for business resilience and client trust. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Alexandru Badea’s comment George Hotz Author 3w Alexandru Badea trueee Like Reply Load more comments

Alexandru Badea • 3rd+ BD Director @ NAGA | CFD & Social Trading | Building the future of retail trading from Dubai 🇦🇪 | AI x Fintech builder | Connecting affiliates & trading educators globally 3w George Hotz Recognizing the strategic impact of polynomial time factoring on digital security is critical for business resilience and client trust. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Alexandru Badea’s comment George Hotz Author 3w Alexandru Badea trueee Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3w Alexandru Badea trueee Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3w • Do you know about polynomial time factoring algorithms? Your crypto, computers, and family might not be safe. Learn more on my blog. 23 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 3w Link here https://geohot.github.io//blog/jekyll/update/2026/03/16/polynomial-time-factoring.html …more Polynomial Time Factoring Algorithm It’s just a matter of time before AI finds a polynomial time factoring algorithm. This isn’t like SAT, I see no reason factoring should be hard. There’s algorithms that rely (poorly) on the structure of the problem and we just need AI to see a little... Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies 🧪 Matthew Mirman • 3rd+ AI Researcher & Founder of DataSuite | PhD AI ETH 3w George Hotz Finding algorithms is NP-hard. Undecidable really, but more meaningfully NP-hard given search spaces. Having orders of magnitude faster and smarter AI won't necessarily help us do it any faster. It might, but I see no convincing evidence either way. …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 3w Link here https://geohot.github.io//blog/jekyll/update/2026/03/16/polynomial-time-factoring.html …more Polynomial Time Factoring Algorithm It’s just a matter of time before AI finds a polynomial time factoring algorithm. This isn’t like SAT, I see no reason factoring should be hard. There’s algorithms that rely (poorly) on the structure of the problem and we just need AI to see a little... Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies 🧪 Matthew Mirman • 3rd+ AI Researcher & Founder of DataSuite | PhD AI ETH 3w George Hotz Finding algorithms is NP-hard. Undecidable really, but more meaningfully NP-hard given search spaces. Having orders of magnitude faster and smarter AI won't necessarily help us do it any faster. It might, but I see no convincing evidence either way. …more Like Reply

Polynomial Time Factoring Algorithm It’s just a matter of time before AI finds a polynomial time factoring algorithm. This isn’t like SAT, I see no reason factoring should be hard. There’s algorithms that rely (poorly) on the structure of the problem and we just need AI to see a little...

🧪 Matthew Mirman • 3rd+ AI Researcher & Founder of DataSuite | PhD AI ETH 3w George Hotz Finding algorithms is NP-hard. Undecidable really, but more meaningfully NP-hard given search spaces. Having orders of magnitude faster and smarter AI won't necessarily help us do it any faster. It might, but I see no convincing evidence either way. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Ferenc Huszár’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4w • Today we should ramp down rhetoric. I thought nobody would take three minutes to escape the perpetual underclass or you are worth $0.003/hr seriously. But it looks like some people do, and you shouldn't. Social media has been extremely toxic for the last couple months. It's targeting you with fear. If you don't use this new stupid AI thing you will fall behind. If you haven't totally updated your workflow you are worth 0. There's people who built billion dollars companies by orchestrating 37 agents this morning AND YOU JUST SAT THERE AND ATE BREAKFAST LIKE A PLEB! This is all complete nonsense. AI is not a magical game changer, it's simply the continuation of the exponential of progress we have been on for a long time. It's a win in some areas, a loss in others, but overall a win and a cool tool to use. And it will continue to improve, but it won't "go recursive" or whatever the claim is. It's always been recursive. You see things like autoresearch and it's cool. But it's not magic, it's search. People see "AI" and they attribute some sci-fi thing to it when it's just search and optimization. Always has been, and if you paid attention in CS class, you know the limits of those things. That said, if you have a job where you create complexity for others, you will be found out. The days of rent seekers are coming to an end. But not because there will be no more rent seeking, it's because rent seeking is a 0 sum game and you will lose at it to bigger players. If you have a job like that, the sooner you quit the better your outcome will be. The trick is not to play 0 sum games. This is what I have been saying the whole time. Go create value for others and don't worry about the returns. If you create more value than you consume, you are welcome in any well operating community. This post will get way less traction than the doom ones, but it's telling you the way out. …more 1,098 55 comments 68 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w Which CS class should I have paid more attention to so I am well informed on the limits of search and optimization and LLMs? …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Ferenc Huszár’s comment George Hotz Author 4w Ferenc Huszár not one class in particular. but examples: the trade-offs between random search, evolutionary algorithms, and convex optimization. no free lunch in search and optimization. landauer limit. brain is 20 petaflops. of course this it doesn't predict what LLMs will do next year, but it predicts things in broad strokes. it makes it clear why AI can't one shot diamond nanobots or crack AES keys. …more Like Reply Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w George Hotz Fantastic, excellent theories of this genre "made it clear" why neural networks are a dead end and won't generalise because they have too many parameters. Like Reply Bob Trower • 3rd+ Owner, Trantor Standard Systems Inc. 4w Ferenc Huszár It's been a bit hilarious since 2022 watching people, claiming expertise, sagely say one thing or another would not be done for years, if ever, while somebody is already doing it and it becomes common knowledge a month or two later. Back when I was managing programmers in a product lab in the 1980s it was a favorite saying of ours that people claiming it's impossible should not be getting in the way of people doing it. To me, Ferenc seems more a 'doer' than a nay sayer. …more Like Reply Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w Bob Trower Thanks for saying this, but truthfully I also had my fair share of being a nay sayer. Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4w Ferenc Huszár I never said anything like that. neural networks are program search and universal function approximators. I have been saying this for years. however, what function are we training them to approximate? and I'll bet heavily against neural network solving NP complete problems or travelling faster than light. this isn't Gary Marcus or Penrose style claims, I strongly disagree with both of them. human brain is a function approximator too …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w Which CS class should I have paid more attention to so I am well informed on the limits of search and optimization and LLMs? …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Ferenc Huszár’s comment George Hotz Author 4w Ferenc Huszár not one class in particular. but examples: the trade-offs between random search, evolutionary algorithms, and convex optimization. no free lunch in search and optimization. landauer limit. brain is 20 petaflops. of course this it doesn't predict what LLMs will do next year, but it predicts things in broad strokes. it makes it clear why AI can't one shot diamond nanobots or crack AES keys. …more Like Reply Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w George Hotz Fantastic, excellent theories of this genre "made it clear" why neural networks are a dead end and won't generalise because they have too many parameters. Like Reply Bob Trower • 3rd+ Owner, Trantor Standard Systems Inc. 4w Ferenc Huszár It's been a bit hilarious since 2022 watching people, claiming expertise, sagely say one thing or another would not be done for years, if ever, while somebody is already doing it and it becomes common knowledge a month or two later. Back when I was managing programmers in a product lab in the 1980s it was a favorite saying of ours that people claiming it's impossible should not be getting in the way of people doing it. To me, Ferenc seems more a 'doer' than a nay sayer. …more Like Reply Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w Bob Trower Thanks for saying this, but truthfully I also had my fair share of being a nay sayer. Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4w Ferenc Huszár I never said anything like that. neural networks are program search and universal function approximators. I have been saying this for years. however, what function are we training them to approximate? and I'll bet heavily against neural network solving NP complete problems or travelling faster than light. this isn't Gary Marcus or Penrose style claims, I strongly disagree with both of them. human brain is a function approximator too …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 4w Ferenc Huszár not one class in particular. but examples: the trade-offs between random search, evolutionary algorithms, and convex optimization. no free lunch in search and optimization. landauer limit. brain is 20 petaflops. of course this it doesn't predict what LLMs will do next year, but it predicts things in broad strokes. it makes it clear why AI can't one shot diamond nanobots or crack AES keys. …more Like Reply

Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w George Hotz Fantastic, excellent theories of this genre "made it clear" why neural networks are a dead end and won't generalise because they have too many parameters. Like Reply

Bob Trower • 3rd+ Owner, Trantor Standard Systems Inc. 4w Ferenc Huszár It's been a bit hilarious since 2022 watching people, claiming expertise, sagely say one thing or another would not be done for years, if ever, while somebody is already doing it and it becomes common knowledge a month or two later. Back when I was managing programmers in a product lab in the 1980s it was a favorite saying of ours that people claiming it's impossible should not be getting in the way of people doing it. To me, Ferenc seems more a 'doer' than a nay sayer. …more Like Reply

Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w Bob Trower Thanks for saying this, but truthfully I also had my fair share of being a nay sayer. Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 4w Ferenc Huszár I never said anything like that. neural networks are program search and universal function approximators. I have been saying this for years. however, what function are we training them to approximate? and I'll bet heavily against neural network solving NP complete problems or travelling faster than light. this isn't Gary Marcus or Penrose style claims, I strongly disagree with both of them. human brain is a function approximator too …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Dorin Clisu’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4w • Today we should ramp down rhetoric. I thought nobody would take three minutes to escape the perpetual underclass or you are worth $0.003/hr seriously. But it looks like some people do, and you shouldn't. Social media has been extremely toxic for the last couple months. It's targeting you with fear. If you don't use this new stupid AI thing you will fall behind. If you haven't totally updated your workflow you are worth 0. There's people who built billion dollars companies by orchestrating 37 agents this morning AND YOU JUST SAT THERE AND ATE BREAKFAST LIKE A PLEB! This is all complete nonsense. AI is not a magical game changer, it's simply the continuation of the exponential of progress we have been on for a long time. It's a win in some areas, a loss in others, but overall a win and a cool tool to use. And it will continue to improve, but it won't "go recursive" or whatever the claim is. It's always been recursive. You see things like autoresearch and it's cool. But it's not magic, it's search. People see "AI" and they attribute some sci-fi thing to it when it's just search and optimization. Always has been, and if you paid attention in CS class, you know the limits of those things. That said, if you have a job where you create complexity for others, you will be found out. The days of rent seekers are coming to an end. But not because there will be no more rent seeking, it's because rent seeking is a 0 sum game and you will lose at it to bigger players. If you have a job like that, the sooner you quit the better your outcome will be. The trick is not to play 0 sum games. This is what I have been saying the whole time. Go create value for others and don't worry about the returns. If you create more value than you consume, you are welcome in any well operating community. This post will get way less traction than the doom ones, but it's telling you the way out. …more 1,098 55 comments 68 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Dorin Clisu • 3rd+ Python, AI-enabled SaaS and learning on the go 4w But the question is.. buying tinybox and selling compute hours, is rent-seeking behavior? Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Dorin Clisu’s comment George Hotz Author 4w Dorin Clisu are you increasing complexity for others? there's no problem at all with that as long as you aren't making it harder for others to buy a tinybox and use their own compute hours. people paying a premium to avoid real (natural) hassle is great as long as the hassle isn't man made, even worse if it's made by you. …more Like Reply Load more comments

Dorin Clisu • 3rd+ Python, AI-enabled SaaS and learning on the go 4w But the question is.. buying tinybox and selling compute hours, is rent-seeking behavior? Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Dorin Clisu’s comment George Hotz Author 4w Dorin Clisu are you increasing complexity for others? there's no problem at all with that as long as you aren't making it harder for others to buy a tinybox and use their own compute hours. people paying a premium to avoid real (natural) hassle is great as long as the hassle isn't man made, even worse if it's made by you. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 4w Dorin Clisu are you increasing complexity for others? there's no problem at all with that as long as you aren't making it harder for others to buy a tinybox and use their own compute hours. people paying a premium to avoid real (natural) hassle is great as long as the hassle isn't man made, even worse if it's made by you. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Francesco Paolo Lezza’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4w • Today we should ramp down rhetoric. I thought nobody would take three minutes to escape the perpetual underclass or you are worth $0.003/hr seriously. But it looks like some people do, and you shouldn't. Social media has been extremely toxic for the last couple months. It's targeting you with fear. If you don't use this new stupid AI thing you will fall behind. If you haven't totally updated your workflow you are worth 0. There's people who built billion dollars companies by orchestrating 37 agents this morning AND YOU JUST SAT THERE AND ATE BREAKFAST LIKE A PLEB! This is all complete nonsense. AI is not a magical game changer, it's simply the continuation of the exponential of progress we have been on for a long time. It's a win in some areas, a loss in others, but overall a win and a cool tool to use. And it will continue to improve, but it won't "go recursive" or whatever the claim is. It's always been recursive. You see things like autoresearch and it's cool. But it's not magic, it's search. People see "AI" and they attribute some sci-fi thing to it when it's just search and optimization. Always has been, and if you paid attention in CS class, you know the limits of those things. That said, if you have a job where you create complexity for others, you will be found out. The days of rent seekers are coming to an end. But not because there will be no more rent seeking, it's because rent seeking is a 0 sum game and you will lose at it to bigger players. If you have a job like that, the sooner you quit the better your outcome will be. The trick is not to play 0 sum games. This is what I have been saying the whole time. Go create value for others and don't worry about the returns. If you create more value than you consume, you are welcome in any well operating community. This post will get way less traction than the doom ones, but it's telling you the way out. …more 1,098 55 comments 68 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Francesco Paolo Lezza • 3rd+ Software Engineer Senior Analyst ► Backend Developer .NET ► Azure Certified ► Production Support & Troubleshooting ► Building expertise in ML Systems & Security 4w Marketing-driven FOMO Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Francesco Paolo Lezza’s comment George Hotz Author 4w Francesco Paolo Lezza "if you don't use our agentic coding workflow, you are beyond hopeless in life" -- company that sells agentic coding Like Reply Load more comments

Francesco Paolo Lezza • 3rd+ Software Engineer Senior Analyst ► Backend Developer .NET ► Azure Certified ► Production Support & Troubleshooting ► Building expertise in ML Systems & Security 4w Marketing-driven FOMO Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Francesco Paolo Lezza’s comment George Hotz Author 4w Francesco Paolo Lezza "if you don't use our agentic coding workflow, you are beyond hopeless in life" -- company that sells agentic coding Like Reply

George Hotz Author 4w Francesco Paolo Lezza "if you don't use our agentic coding workflow, you are beyond hopeless in life" -- company that sells agentic coding Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Ferenc Huszár’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4w • Today we should ramp down rhetoric. I thought nobody would take three minutes to escape the perpetual underclass or you are worth $0.003/hr seriously. But it looks like some people do, and you shouldn't. Social media has been extremely toxic for the last couple months. It's targeting you with fear. If you don't use this new stupid AI thing you will fall behind. If you haven't totally updated your workflow you are worth 0. There's people who built billion dollars companies by orchestrating 37 agents this morning AND YOU JUST SAT THERE AND ATE BREAKFAST LIKE A PLEB! This is all complete nonsense. AI is not a magical game changer, it's simply the continuation of the exponential of progress we have been on for a long time. It's a win in some areas, a loss in others, but overall a win and a cool tool to use. And it will continue to improve, but it won't "go recursive" or whatever the claim is. It's always been recursive. You see things like autoresearch and it's cool. But it's not magic, it's search. People see "AI" and they attribute some sci-fi thing to it when it's just search and optimization. Always has been, and if you paid attention in CS class, you know the limits of those things. That said, if you have a job where you create complexity for others, you will be found out. The days of rent seekers are coming to an end. But not because there will be no more rent seeking, it's because rent seeking is a 0 sum game and you will lose at it to bigger players. If you have a job like that, the sooner you quit the better your outcome will be. The trick is not to play 0 sum games. This is what I have been saying the whole time. Go create value for others and don't worry about the returns. If you create more value than you consume, you are welcome in any well operating community. This post will get way less traction than the doom ones, but it's telling you the way out. …more 1,098 55 comments 68 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w Which CS class should I have paid more attention to so I am well informed on the limits of search and optimization and LLMs? …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Ferenc Huszár’s comment George Hotz Author 4w Ferenc Huszár not one class in particular. but examples: the trade-offs between random search, evolutionary algorithms, and convex optimization. no free lunch in search and optimization. landauer limit. brain is 20 petaflops. of course this it doesn't predict what LLMs will do next year, but it predicts things in broad strokes. it makes it clear why AI can't one shot diamond nanobots or crack AES keys. …more Like Reply Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w George Hotz Fantastic, excellent theories of this genre "made it clear" why neural networks are a dead end and won't generalise because they have too many parameters. Like Reply Bob Trower • 3rd+ Owner, Trantor Standard Systems Inc. 4w Ferenc Huszár It's been a bit hilarious since 2022 watching people, claiming expertise, sagely say one thing or another would not be done for years, if ever, while somebody is already doing it and it becomes common knowledge a month or two later. Back when I was managing programmers in a product lab in the 1980s it was a favorite saying of ours that people claiming it's impossible should not be getting in the way of people doing it. To me, Ferenc seems more a 'doer' than a nay sayer. …more Like Reply Ferenc Huszár • 3rd+ founder of Reasonable, professor-on-leave from Cambridge University 4w Bob Trower Thanks for saying this, but truthfully I also had my fair share of being a nay sayer. Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4w Ferenc Huszár I never said anything like that. neural networks are program search and universal function approximators. I have been saying this for years. however, what function are we training them to approximate? and I'll bet heavily against neural network solving NP complete problems or travelling faster than light. this isn't Gary Marcus or Penrose style claims, I strongly disagree with both of them. human brain is a function approximator too …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Andy Wong’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • Who are you doing this for? The worst answer I see is that it's for your kids. Your kids don't need private school or a trip to Disney World. They need a future that isn't enshittified slop. They need the hype to die so they have hope beyond hypergambling or slavery. It's not for your kids. You are doing it for yourself. You are doing it because you are scared. And you continue doing it because you are a coward. Today is a good day to find some courage and stop. …more 66 comments 13 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Andy Wong • 3rd+ Engineering @ Meta | prev. @Block, Google, Amazon | Advocate for underrepresented groups and non-traditional backgrounds in tech 1mo This is kind of a sloppy post. It's so reliant on coded language that the average person (see: Jeff) is either going to miss your point or interpret it as something they agree with regardless so they can feel good. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Andy Wong’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Andy Wong so that's the point. if you paste what Jeff doesn't understand into ChatGPT, it translates it into plain language. "People need a social and economic reality where dignity and stability are possible without having to gamble or be exploited" however, that plain language has been co-opted by some very unsavory people. you can easily imagine that line followed seamlessly by an ad for a product. "That's why we invented Celstable, a new way to earn 9% more on your income, risk free!" The only way to communicate anything real is to stay ahead of the machine. it will take your old cliche words and use them for its purposes. but idk, you work at Meta, it sounds like you support the machine. …more Like Reply Andy Wong • 3rd+ Engineering @ Meta | prev. @Block, Google, Amazon | Advocate for underrepresented groups and non-traditional backgrounds in tech (edited) 1mo George so your solution is a shallow observation and shallower insult. Okay, guess we won't be meeting each other at Disney World anytime soon. Like Reply Michael Ouellette • 3rd+ Cloud Data Engineer 1mo Andy Wong Unless you guys win the Super Bowl. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Andy Wong • 3rd+ Engineering @ Meta | prev. @Block, Google, Amazon | Advocate for underrepresented groups and non-traditional backgrounds in tech 1mo This is kind of a sloppy post. It's so reliant on coded language that the average person (see: Jeff) is either going to miss your point or interpret it as something they agree with regardless so they can feel good. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Andy Wong’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Andy Wong so that's the point. if you paste what Jeff doesn't understand into ChatGPT, it translates it into plain language. "People need a social and economic reality where dignity and stability are possible without having to gamble or be exploited" however, that plain language has been co-opted by some very unsavory people. you can easily imagine that line followed seamlessly by an ad for a product. "That's why we invented Celstable, a new way to earn 9% more on your income, risk free!" The only way to communicate anything real is to stay ahead of the machine. it will take your old cliche words and use them for its purposes. but idk, you work at Meta, it sounds like you support the machine. …more Like Reply Andy Wong • 3rd+ Engineering @ Meta | prev. @Block, Google, Amazon | Advocate for underrepresented groups and non-traditional backgrounds in tech (edited) 1mo George so your solution is a shallow observation and shallower insult. Okay, guess we won't be meeting each other at Disney World anytime soon. Like Reply Michael Ouellette • 3rd+ Cloud Data Engineer 1mo Andy Wong Unless you guys win the Super Bowl. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Andy Wong so that's the point. if you paste what Jeff doesn't understand into ChatGPT, it translates it into plain language. "People need a social and economic reality where dignity and stability are possible without having to gamble or be exploited" however, that plain language has been co-opted by some very unsavory people. you can easily imagine that line followed seamlessly by an ad for a product. "That's why we invented Celstable, a new way to earn 9% more on your income, risk free!" The only way to communicate anything real is to stay ahead of the machine. it will take your old cliche words and use them for its purposes. but idk, you work at Meta, it sounds like you support the machine. …more Like Reply

Andy Wong • 3rd+ Engineering @ Meta | prev. @Block, Google, Amazon | Advocate for underrepresented groups and non-traditional backgrounds in tech (edited) 1mo George so your solution is a shallow observation and shallower insult. Okay, guess we won't be meeting each other at Disney World anytime soon. Like Reply

Michael Ouellette • 3rd+ Cloud Data Engineer 1mo Andy Wong Unless you guys win the Super Bowl. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to John Buckoke AuDHD’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • Who are you doing this for? The worst answer I see is that it's for your kids. Your kids don't need private school or a trip to Disney World. They need a future that isn't enshittified slop. They need the hype to die so they have hope beyond hypergambling or slavery. It's not for your kids. You are doing it for yourself. You are doing it because you are scared. And you continue doing it because you are a coward. Today is a good day to find some courage and stop. …more 66 comments 13 reposts Like Comment Repost Send John Buckoke AuDHD • 3rd+ Strategic Growth Leader | Customer Delight Obsessive | Creative Problem-Solver | Relationship Builder | Decision Maker | Cross-Cultural Collaborator | AI Innovator | Neurodiversity is my Superpower 🌻 (edited) 1mo UK cost of living (housing, public transport, energy, taxes, public debt and food) is properly enshittiified to pay boomers unearned pensions. …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on John Buckoke AuDHD’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo John Buckoke AuDHD ahh yes we have to subsidize old people for some reason...wait, what was that reason again? Like Reply John Buckoke AuDHD • 3rd+ Strategic Growth Leader | Customer Delight Obsessive | Creative Problem-Solver | Relationship Builder | Decision Maker | Cross-Cultural Collaborator | AI Innovator | Neurodiversity is my Superpower 🌻 (edited) 1mo George Hotz I forget, but I do know they failed to build a real economy to fund themselves, now they demand payment via their children and grandchildren's future. Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo John Buckoke AuDHD hmm maybe we should band together and stop paying them Like Reply John Buckoke AuDHD • 3rd+ Strategic Growth Leader | Customer Delight Obsessive | Creative Problem-Solver | Relationship Builder | Decision Maker | Cross-Cultural Collaborator | AI Innovator | Neurodiversity is my Superpower 🌻 1mo George Hotz lets have a tea party! Like Reply Ryan V. • 3rd+ Software Engineer 2w George Hotz indeed Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

John Buckoke AuDHD • 3rd+ Strategic Growth Leader | Customer Delight Obsessive | Creative Problem-Solver | Relationship Builder | Decision Maker | Cross-Cultural Collaborator | AI Innovator | Neurodiversity is my Superpower 🌻 (edited) 1mo UK cost of living (housing, public transport, energy, taxes, public debt and food) is properly enshittiified to pay boomers unearned pensions. …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on John Buckoke AuDHD’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo John Buckoke AuDHD ahh yes we have to subsidize old people for some reason...wait, what was that reason again? Like Reply John Buckoke AuDHD • 3rd+ Strategic Growth Leader | Customer Delight Obsessive | Creative Problem-Solver | Relationship Builder | Decision Maker | Cross-Cultural Collaborator | AI Innovator | Neurodiversity is my Superpower 🌻 (edited) 1mo George Hotz I forget, but I do know they failed to build a real economy to fund themselves, now they demand payment via their children and grandchildren's future. Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo John Buckoke AuDHD hmm maybe we should band together and stop paying them Like Reply John Buckoke AuDHD • 3rd+ Strategic Growth Leader | Customer Delight Obsessive | Creative Problem-Solver | Relationship Builder | Decision Maker | Cross-Cultural Collaborator | AI Innovator | Neurodiversity is my Superpower 🌻 1mo George Hotz lets have a tea party! Like Reply Ryan V. • 3rd+ Software Engineer 2w George Hotz indeed Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo John Buckoke AuDHD ahh yes we have to subsidize old people for some reason...wait, what was that reason again? Like Reply

John Buckoke AuDHD • 3rd+ Strategic Growth Leader | Customer Delight Obsessive | Creative Problem-Solver | Relationship Builder | Decision Maker | Cross-Cultural Collaborator | AI Innovator | Neurodiversity is my Superpower 🌻 (edited) 1mo George Hotz I forget, but I do know they failed to build a real economy to fund themselves, now they demand payment via their children and grandchildren's future. Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo John Buckoke AuDHD hmm maybe we should band together and stop paying them Like Reply

John Buckoke AuDHD • 3rd+ Strategic Growth Leader | Customer Delight Obsessive | Creative Problem-Solver | Relationship Builder | Decision Maker | Cross-Cultural Collaborator | AI Innovator | Neurodiversity is my Superpower 🌻 1mo George Hotz lets have a tea party! Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Joshua King’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • Who are you doing this for? The worst answer I see is that it's for your kids. Your kids don't need private school or a trip to Disney World. They need a future that isn't enshittified slop. They need the hype to die so they have hope beyond hypergambling or slavery. It's not for your kids. You are doing it for yourself. You are doing it because you are scared. And you continue doing it because you are a coward. Today is a good day to find some courage and stop. …more 66 comments 13 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Joshua King • 3rd+ Engineer, Writer, Speaker. Opinions are my own, not those of my employer. 1mo Not sure your logic around the kid response holds up. Most people with that response aren't doing it for disney world, they're doing it to provide better schools, clothes, opportunities, etc for their kids.I suppose you could make the argument that you should be ok with the bare necessities, but that really just proves what they're saying to be true as well.Why isn't that valid? …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Joshua King’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Joshua King oh god "better opportunities" maybe just make the world not shit Like Reply Gio Kakhiani • 3rd+ Agentic Engineer 1mo George Hotz how do you suggest we do so. Realistically speaking not hypothetically. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Joshua King • 3rd+ Engineer, Writer, Speaker. Opinions are my own, not those of my employer. 1mo Not sure your logic around the kid response holds up. Most people with that response aren't doing it for disney world, they're doing it to provide better schools, clothes, opportunities, etc for their kids.I suppose you could make the argument that you should be ok with the bare necessities, but that really just proves what they're saying to be true as well.Why isn't that valid? …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Joshua King’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Joshua King oh god "better opportunities" maybe just make the world not shit Like Reply Gio Kakhiani • 3rd+ Agentic Engineer 1mo George Hotz how do you suggest we do so. Realistically speaking not hypothetically. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Joshua King oh god "better opportunities" maybe just make the world not shit Like Reply

Gio Kakhiani • 3rd+ Agentic Engineer 1mo George Hotz how do you suggest we do so. Realistically speaking not hypothetically. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Kevin R.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • I know society has told you nothing is shameful and pride is for the gays. But that's cope. Feel proud when you do good. Feel shame when you do bad. Even if they don't always express it, the people watching you know the difference. …more 14 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner 1mo "just feel things" -geohot Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Kevin R.’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Kevin R. feelings matter bro -- kanye west Like Reply Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner (edited) 1mo George Hotz 💞 I feel like I should start a nonprofit, what do you feel are good things to focus on? I've been learning a lot about psychology, neuroscience, biology, sleep, exercise, nutrition, focus and noticed they all as levers that affect human performance. do you feel like investing in empowering human performance is a good cause? …more Like Reply Jacob Kon • 3rd+ 1x engineer 1mo George Hotz tbh he did feel some type of way lately Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner 1mo "just feel things" -geohot Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Kevin R.’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Kevin R. feelings matter bro -- kanye west Like Reply Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner (edited) 1mo George Hotz 💞 I feel like I should start a nonprofit, what do you feel are good things to focus on? I've been learning a lot about psychology, neuroscience, biology, sleep, exercise, nutrition, focus and noticed they all as levers that affect human performance. do you feel like investing in empowering human performance is a good cause? …more Like Reply Jacob Kon • 3rd+ 1x engineer 1mo George Hotz tbh he did feel some type of way lately Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Kevin R. feelings matter bro -- kanye west Like Reply

Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner (edited) 1mo George Hotz 💞 I feel like I should start a nonprofit, what do you feel are good things to focus on? I've been learning a lot about psychology, neuroscience, biology, sleep, exercise, nutrition, focus and noticed they all as levers that affect human performance. do you feel like investing in empowering human performance is a good cause? …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to John Pinto’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • I know society has told you nothing is shameful and pride is for the gays. But that's cope. Feel proud when you do good. Feel shame when you do bad. Even if they don't always express it, the people watching you know the difference. …more 14 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send John Pinto • 3rd+ Procurement Automation @ Uc Operations LLC 1mo Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on John Pinto’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo John Pinto doesn't matter. if you decend to their level you are no better than them. if you see a rigged game, just don't play it. Like Reply Load more comments

John Pinto • 3rd+ Procurement Automation @ Uc Operations LLC 1mo Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on John Pinto’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo John Pinto doesn't matter. if you decend to their level you are no better than them. if you see a rigged game, just don't play it. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 1mo John Pinto doesn't matter. if you decend to their level you are no better than them. if you see a rigged game, just don't play it. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Sid Abhinav, PhD.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • To the people just graduated thinking about going to Silicon Valley. You missed it. It's not cool anymore. You think you'll find something there, but you won't. You'll find a hollowed out shell of something that once existed, and not in a grand romantic way, but in a way that's just sad. Keep the ideals of the old days in your mind and do something else. The dream lives on, it's just not there anymore. Don't join a "tech" company. Don't give yourself to an evil machine. Don't continue to feed that machine, watch it starve. Leave Silicon Valley to the sell-outs, suck ups, rent seekers, and losers. …more 65 comments 19 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Sid Abhinav, PhD. • 3rd+ Founder @ Leap | We turn your SOPs into narrated training videos with quizzes in 5 minutes 1mo I recently started following you and so far every single one of your posts on my feed are “doomsday is here/coming”. Ok. Do you have any solutions here or are you basically suggesting we should all just roll over and die based on your sentiment? Because on the surface these posts are virtually indistinguishable from some old man yelling at the sky in 1999 that Y2K will end the world and there’s no hope. When in reality, nothing even close to that dramatic happens. …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Sid Abhinav, PhD.’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 1mo Sid Abhinav, PhD. Don't roll over and die. Just stop doing the bad thing. That's it. Like Reply Load more comments

Sid Abhinav, PhD. • 3rd+ Founder @ Leap | We turn your SOPs into narrated training videos with quizzes in 5 minutes 1mo I recently started following you and so far every single one of your posts on my feed are “doomsday is here/coming”. Ok. Do you have any solutions here or are you basically suggesting we should all just roll over and die based on your sentiment? Because on the surface these posts are virtually indistinguishable from some old man yelling at the sky in 1999 that Y2K will end the world and there’s no hope. When in reality, nothing even close to that dramatic happens. …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Sid Abhinav, PhD.’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 1mo Sid Abhinav, PhD. Don't roll over and die. Just stop doing the bad thing. That's it. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 1mo Sid Abhinav, PhD. Don't roll over and die. Just stop doing the bad thing. That's it. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Prateek Karnal’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • To the people just graduated thinking about going to Silicon Valley. You missed it. It's not cool anymore. You think you'll find something there, but you won't. You'll find a hollowed out shell of something that once existed, and not in a grand romantic way, but in a way that's just sad. Keep the ideals of the old days in your mind and do something else. The dream lives on, it's just not there anymore. Don't join a "tech" company. Don't give yourself to an evil machine. Don't continue to feed that machine, watch it starve. Leave Silicon Valley to the sell-outs, suck ups, rent seekers, and losers. …more 65 comments 19 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Prateek Karnal • 3rd+ Orchestrators @ Composio • Open Source @ Agent Orchestrator • 2x ICPC WFs 1mo wait what? Isn't this literally the best time to be in SF, the pace technological advancements has never been this fast ever …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Prateek Karnal’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Prateek Karnal they control the means of communication and distribution. I hear from the media in North Korea the pace of growth and progress in North Korea has also never been this fast 🤣 Like Reply Prateek Karnal • 3rd+ Orchestrators @ Composio • Open Source @ Agent Orchestrator • 2x ICPC WFs 1mo George Hotz oh I've been out of bay for an year, didn't know things have gotten worse Also agreed innovation is becoming very decentralised. Internet made that possible, AI is accelerating that trend. Btw we just launched Agent Orchestrator ... I think you will love using it. …more Like Reply Jamie Cropley • 3rd+ Founder at nohiya games 1mo Prateek Karnal NYC is better for AI I hear. Like Reply Kevin Altschuler • 3rd+ AI Dev Tools @ Dropbox 1mo Prateek Karnal dont worry sf is fine, george has genuinely lost his mind Like Reply Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things 2w Prateek Karnal We are literally going backwards with technology, but we've slapped a fancy wig and a mustache on it. I think what George is saying is that we're headed straight for 1984 and the nerds are taking us there instead of taking us to where the people actually want to be.If we do end up at 1984 spec, those very same nerds will have no more than anyone else and nothing but misery to show for their achievements. I think thats the gist. The machines no longer serve us. …more Like Reply Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things (edited) 2w George Hotz Prateek Karnaltl:dr - give me back yellow dog linux. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Prateek Karnal • 3rd+ Orchestrators @ Composio • Open Source @ Agent Orchestrator • 2x ICPC WFs 1mo wait what? Isn't this literally the best time to be in SF, the pace technological advancements has never been this fast ever …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Prateek Karnal’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Prateek Karnal they control the means of communication and distribution. I hear from the media in North Korea the pace of growth and progress in North Korea has also never been this fast 🤣 Like Reply Prateek Karnal • 3rd+ Orchestrators @ Composio • Open Source @ Agent Orchestrator • 2x ICPC WFs 1mo George Hotz oh I've been out of bay for an year, didn't know things have gotten worse Also agreed innovation is becoming very decentralised. Internet made that possible, AI is accelerating that trend. Btw we just launched Agent Orchestrator ... I think you will love using it. …more Like Reply Jamie Cropley • 3rd+ Founder at nohiya games 1mo Prateek Karnal NYC is better for AI I hear. Like Reply Kevin Altschuler • 3rd+ AI Dev Tools @ Dropbox 1mo Prateek Karnal dont worry sf is fine, george has genuinely lost his mind Like Reply Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things 2w Prateek Karnal We are literally going backwards with technology, but we've slapped a fancy wig and a mustache on it. I think what George is saying is that we're headed straight for 1984 and the nerds are taking us there instead of taking us to where the people actually want to be.If we do end up at 1984 spec, those very same nerds will have no more than anyone else and nothing but misery to show for their achievements. I think thats the gist. The machines no longer serve us. …more Like Reply Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things (edited) 2w George Hotz Prateek Karnaltl:dr - give me back yellow dog linux. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Prateek Karnal they control the means of communication and distribution. I hear from the media in North Korea the pace of growth and progress in North Korea has also never been this fast 🤣 Like Reply

Prateek Karnal • 3rd+ Orchestrators @ Composio • Open Source @ Agent Orchestrator • 2x ICPC WFs 1mo George Hotz oh I've been out of bay for an year, didn't know things have gotten worse Also agreed innovation is becoming very decentralised. Internet made that possible, AI is accelerating that trend. Btw we just launched Agent Orchestrator ... I think you will love using it. …more Like Reply

Jamie Cropley • 3rd+ Founder at nohiya games 1mo Prateek Karnal NYC is better for AI I hear. Like Reply

Kevin Altschuler • 3rd+ AI Dev Tools @ Dropbox 1mo Prateek Karnal dont worry sf is fine, george has genuinely lost his mind Like Reply

Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things 2w Prateek Karnal We are literally going backwards with technology, but we've slapped a fancy wig and a mustache on it. I think what George is saying is that we're headed straight for 1984 and the nerds are taking us there instead of taking us to where the people actually want to be.If we do end up at 1984 spec, those very same nerds will have no more than anyone else and nothing but misery to show for their achievements. I think thats the gist. The machines no longer serve us. …more Like Reply

Daniel Wade • 3rd+ | Systems Admin | “IT Guy” | Cybersecurity Analyst | TryHackMe Top 3% | Automation Addict | Pen Testing Fanatic | Always Breaking & Fixing Things (edited) 2w George Hotz Prateek Karnaltl:dr - give me back yellow dog linux. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Shany Golan’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Edited • To the people just graduated thinking about going to Silicon Valley. You missed it. It's not cool anymore. You think you'll find something there, but you won't. You'll find a hollowed out shell of something that once existed, and not in a grand romantic way, but in a way that's just sad. Keep the ideals of the old days in your mind and do something else. The dream lives on, it's just not there anymore. Don't join a "tech" company. Don't give yourself to an evil machine. Don't continue to feed that machine, watch it starve. Leave Silicon Valley to the sell-outs, suck ups, rent seekers, and losers. …more 65 comments 19 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's 1mo So, cleaning the floors and wash dishes. 👍 Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Shany Golan’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Shany Golan at least it is honest work, and someone who does that has my respect, unlike someone who continues to use technology to manipulate others Like Reply Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's (edited) 1mo George Hotz its true that it is honest work, but I wonder how much sustainable it is in our current society/market conditions. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's 1mo So, cleaning the floors and wash dishes. 👍 Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Shany Golan’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Shany Golan at least it is honest work, and someone who does that has my respect, unlike someone who continues to use technology to manipulate others Like Reply Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's (edited) 1mo George Hotz its true that it is honest work, but I wonder how much sustainable it is in our current society/market conditions. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Shany Golan at least it is honest work, and someone who does that has my respect, unlike someone who continues to use technology to manipulate others Like Reply

Shany Golan • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Data Science Master's (edited) 1mo George Hotz its true that it is honest work, but I wonder how much sustainable it is in our current society/market conditions. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this Greg Isenberg Greg Isenberg • 3rd+ Influencer • 3rd+ CEO of Late Checkout, a portfolio of internet companies CEO of Late Checkout, a portfolio of internet companies Visit my website 1mo • Edited • Follow 4000 people laid off today at Block (almost half the company) and the reason is AI “we're already seeing that the intelligence tools we’re creating and using, paired with smaller and flatter teams, are enabling a new way of working which fundamentally changes what it means to build and run a company. and that's accelerating rapidly” - jack dorsey this is unfortunate yet just the beginning. hundreds of thousands if not millions will lose their jobs. New jobs will be created and many will become entrepreneurs and build ai native businesses send this to a friend note: i've noticed in uptick on http://ideabrowser.com of people looking for startup, ideas trends who've been recently laid off …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 299 comments 86 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz 1mo lol the reason is never AI. saying the reason is AI makes the stock go up when you do layoffs though, so everyone says kt …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Max Wittal • 3rd+ Software Engineer, C++, CUDA, HPC 1mo James Huckle They could easily produce 10x more each year if they weren't afraid of being laid off when there's no work left to do. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz 1mo lol the reason is never AI. saying the reason is AI makes the stock go up when you do layoffs though, so everyone says kt …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Max Wittal • 3rd+ Software Engineer, C++, CUDA, HPC 1mo James Huckle They could easily produce 10x more each year if they weren't afraid of being laid off when there's no work left to do. Like Reply

Max Wittal • 3rd+ Software Engineer, C++, CUDA, HPC 1mo James Huckle They could easily produce 10x more each year if they weren't afraid of being laid off when there's no work left to do. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Mike Keen’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • "Over the past fifty years, the U.S. economy built a giant rent-extraction layer on top of human limitations: things take time, patience runs out, brand familiarity substitutes for diligence, and most people are willing to accept a bad price to avoid more clicks. Trillions of dollars of enterprise value depended on those constraints persisting." I cannot fucking wait till this all crumbles. We were robbed. You feel it every day. And the people who did it will be held accountable. Not legally, but morally. After AI comes what people did in the before times will be the showcase of their character. And we will all understand what they did. …more 47 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Mike Keen • 3rd+ Building Cannonball 1mo Watch out! The decimillionaire is going to morally judge you for launching “rent-seeking” business models to feed your kids. “I was robbed by Oracle, et al!”, he exclaims. 😂 …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Mike Keen’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Mike Keen There were other ways to feed your kids and we both know it. That excuse isn't going to work. You weren't even "following orders," you were selling out the future so you could live better in the present. Selling out that same future your kids live in. …more Like Reply Mike Keen • 3rd+ Building Cannonball 1mo I don't need to "make an excuse" because your judgment doesn't matter. You benefited (and continue to benefit) from the exact same "rent seeking" models that the rest of us do. I don't need to excuse how I made the tiny amount of money I did -- especially in relation to you. The idea that I sold out anyone's future is laughable. I just like making good things that provide value to users. But I guess I should have worked on a construction site or a fast food restaurant so that some millionaire wouldn't be mad at me. Now that's funny. You seem utterly unhinged here as you cheer for the total collapse of the technology industry you would have starved without. Boomer-tier ladder-pulling. What a terrible person. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 1mo Mike Keen Only the AGI gods will judge us. Are you ready to face them? Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Mike Keen • 3rd+ Building Cannonball 1mo Watch out! The decimillionaire is going to morally judge you for launching “rent-seeking” business models to feed your kids. “I was robbed by Oracle, et al!”, he exclaims. 😂 …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Mike Keen’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Mike Keen There were other ways to feed your kids and we both know it. That excuse isn't going to work. You weren't even "following orders," you were selling out the future so you could live better in the present. Selling out that same future your kids live in. …more Like Reply Mike Keen • 3rd+ Building Cannonball 1mo I don't need to "make an excuse" because your judgment doesn't matter. You benefited (and continue to benefit) from the exact same "rent seeking" models that the rest of us do. I don't need to excuse how I made the tiny amount of money I did -- especially in relation to you. The idea that I sold out anyone's future is laughable. I just like making good things that provide value to users. But I guess I should have worked on a construction site or a fast food restaurant so that some millionaire wouldn't be mad at me. Now that's funny. You seem utterly unhinged here as you cheer for the total collapse of the technology industry you would have starved without. Boomer-tier ladder-pulling. What a terrible person. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 1mo Mike Keen Only the AGI gods will judge us. Are you ready to face them? Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Mike Keen There were other ways to feed your kids and we both know it. That excuse isn't going to work. You weren't even "following orders," you were selling out the future so you could live better in the present. Selling out that same future your kids live in. …more Like Reply

Mike Keen • 3rd+ Building Cannonball 1mo I don't need to "make an excuse" because your judgment doesn't matter. You benefited (and continue to benefit) from the exact same "rent seeking" models that the rest of us do. I don't need to excuse how I made the tiny amount of money I did -- especially in relation to you. The idea that I sold out anyone's future is laughable. I just like making good things that provide value to users. But I guess I should have worked on a construction site or a fast food restaurant so that some millionaire wouldn't be mad at me. Now that's funny. You seem utterly unhinged here as you cheer for the total collapse of the technology industry you would have starved without. Boomer-tier ladder-pulling. What a terrible person. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 1mo Mike Keen Only the AGI gods will judge us. Are you ready to face them? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Vlad Usatii’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • "Over the past fifty years, the U.S. economy built a giant rent-extraction layer on top of human limitations: things take time, patience runs out, brand familiarity substitutes for diligence, and most people are willing to accept a bad price to avoid more clicks. Trillions of dollars of enterprise value depended on those constraints persisting." I cannot fucking wait till this all crumbles. We were robbed. You feel it every day. And the people who did it will be held accountable. Not legally, but morally. After AI comes what people did in the before times will be the showcase of their character. And we will all understand what they did. …more 47 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Vlad Usatii • 3rd+ founder, usatii media company | research,cs @ rit 1mo You don’t even live here bro Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Vlad Usatii’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Vlad Usatii I'll be back when people are serious about rebuilding. Too many people are still clinging to scams. Like Reply Load more comments

Vlad Usatii • 3rd+ founder, usatii media company | research,cs @ rit 1mo You don’t even live here bro Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Vlad Usatii’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Vlad Usatii I'll be back when people are serious about rebuilding. Too many people are still clinging to scams. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 1mo Vlad Usatii I'll be back when people are serious about rebuilding. Too many people are still clinging to scams. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Tony Dong, MSc, CETF’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • "Over the past fifty years, the U.S. economy built a giant rent-extraction layer on top of human limitations: things take time, patience runs out, brand familiarity substitutes for diligence, and most people are willing to accept a bad price to avoid more clicks. Trillions of dollars of enterprise value depended on those constraints persisting." I cannot fucking wait till this all crumbles. We were robbed. You feel it every day. And the people who did it will be held accountable. Not legally, but morally. After AI comes what people did in the before times will be the showcase of their character. And we will all understand what they did. …more 47 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Tony Dong, MSc, CETF • 3rd+ Founder @ ETF Portfolio Blueprint | Homesteader @ Okanagan Valley Ranch | Freelance Writer, Bylines: ETF Central, US News & World Report, Moneysense, Kiplinger, 24/7 Wall St, The Motley Fool | Columbia University Alumnus (edited) 1mo AI will replace jobs like: ︀︀ ︀︀- accountan︀t - investment banker ︀︀- lawyer ︀︀- management consultant - copywriter ︀︀ ︀︀But will create new ones like: ︀︀ ︀︀- vape vending machine tech ︀︀- plankton farmer ︀︀- indoor beekeeper ︀︀- copper looter ︀︀- kick stream clipper …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Tony Dong, MSc, CETF’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Tony Dong, MSc, CETF looting copper, not just for tweakers anymore! Like Reply Ronald Pederson, LL.B, B.A.(Hons) • 3rd+ Owner, RGP Law Group 1mo Tony Dong, MSc, CETF Lawyer? Oh no! Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Tony Dong, MSc, CETF • 3rd+ Founder @ ETF Portfolio Blueprint | Homesteader @ Okanagan Valley Ranch | Freelance Writer, Bylines: ETF Central, US News & World Report, Moneysense, Kiplinger, 24/7 Wall St, The Motley Fool | Columbia University Alumnus (edited) 1mo AI will replace jobs like: ︀︀ ︀︀- accountan︀t - investment banker ︀︀- lawyer ︀︀- management consultant - copywriter ︀︀ ︀︀But will create new ones like: ︀︀ ︀︀- vape vending machine tech ︀︀- plankton farmer ︀︀- indoor beekeeper ︀︀- copper looter ︀︀- kick stream clipper …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Tony Dong, MSc, CETF’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Tony Dong, MSc, CETF looting copper, not just for tweakers anymore! Like Reply Ronald Pederson, LL.B, B.A.(Hons) • 3rd+ Owner, RGP Law Group 1mo Tony Dong, MSc, CETF Lawyer? Oh no! Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Tony Dong, MSc, CETF looting copper, not just for tweakers anymore! Like Reply

Ronald Pederson, LL.B, B.A.(Hons) • 3rd+ Owner, RGP Law Group 1mo Tony Dong, MSc, CETF Lawyer? Oh no! Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Mike Keen’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • "Over the past fifty years, the U.S. economy built a giant rent-extraction layer on top of human limitations: things take time, patience runs out, brand familiarity substitutes for diligence, and most people are willing to accept a bad price to avoid more clicks. Trillions of dollars of enterprise value depended on those constraints persisting." I cannot fucking wait till this all crumbles. We were robbed. You feel it every day. And the people who did it will be held accountable. Not legally, but morally. After AI comes what people did in the before times will be the showcase of their character. And we will all understand what they did. …more 47 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Mike Keen • 3rd+ Building Cannonball 1mo Watch out! The decimillionaire is going to morally judge you for launching “rent-seeking” business models to feed your kids. “I was robbed by Oracle, et al!”, he exclaims. 😂 …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Mike Keen’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Mike Keen There were other ways to feed your kids and we both know it. That excuse isn't going to work. You weren't even "following orders," you were selling out the future so you could live better in the present. Selling out that same future your kids live in. …more Like Reply Mike Keen • 3rd+ Building Cannonball 1mo I don't need to "make an excuse" because your judgment doesn't matter. You benefited (and continue to benefit) from the exact same "rent seeking" models that the rest of us do. I don't need to excuse how I made the tiny amount of money I did -- especially in relation to you. The idea that I sold out anyone's future is laughable. I just like making good things that provide value to users. But I guess I should have worked on a construction site or a fast food restaurant so that some millionaire wouldn't be mad at me. Now that's funny. You seem utterly unhinged here as you cheer for the total collapse of the technology industry you would have starved without. Boomer-tier ladder-pulling. What a terrible person. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 1mo Mike Keen Only the AGI gods will judge us. Are you ready to face them? Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Andy Chatham’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • "Over the past fifty years, the U.S. economy built a giant rent-extraction layer on top of human limitations: things take time, patience runs out, brand familiarity substitutes for diligence, and most people are willing to accept a bad price to avoid more clicks. Trillions of dollars of enterprise value depended on those constraints persisting." I cannot fucking wait till this all crumbles. We were robbed. You feel it every day. And the people who did it will be held accountable. Not legally, but morally. After AI comes what people did in the before times will be the showcase of their character. And we will all understand what they did. …more 47 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Andy Chatham • 3rd+ Building tools to Improve the built environment 1mo It's not moral or immoral it's just accelerated creative destruction Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Andy Chatham’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Andy Chatham It's immoral. Purposely creating friction and frustration for your fellow man to "increase enterprise value." The reckoning is coming. Like Reply Andy Chatham • 3rd+ Building tools to Improve the built environment 1mo George Hotz the market doing gods work Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Andy Chatham • 3rd+ Building tools to Improve the built environment 1mo It's not moral or immoral it's just accelerated creative destruction Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Andy Chatham’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Andy Chatham It's immoral. Purposely creating friction and frustration for your fellow man to "increase enterprise value." The reckoning is coming. Like Reply Andy Chatham • 3rd+ Building tools to Improve the built environment 1mo George Hotz the market doing gods work Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Andy Chatham It's immoral. Purposely creating friction and frustration for your fellow man to "increase enterprise value." The reckoning is coming. Like Reply

Andy Chatham • 3rd+ Building tools to Improve the built environment 1mo George Hotz the market doing gods work Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • "Over the past fifty years, the U.S. economy built a giant rent-extraction layer on top of human limitations: things take time, patience runs out, brand familiarity substitutes for diligence, and most people are willing to accept a bad price to avoid more clicks. Trillions of dollars of enterprise value depended on those constraints persisting." I cannot fucking wait till this all crumbles. We were robbed. You feel it every day. And the people who did it will be held accountable. Not legally, but morally. After AI comes what people did in the before times will be the showcase of their character. And we will all understand what they did. …more 47 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 1mo Quote from: https://www.citriniresearch.com/p/2028gic Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Simon Herrera • 3rd+ Brokerage Director | M&A | Entrepreneur | QLA Advocate/Mentee 1mo George Hotz you are on point as always! Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 1mo Quote from: https://www.citriniresearch.com/p/2028gic Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Simon Herrera • 3rd+ Brokerage Director | M&A | Entrepreneur | QLA Advocate/Mentee 1mo George Hotz you are on point as always! Like Reply

Simon Herrera • 3rd+ Brokerage Director | M&A | Entrepreneur | QLA Advocate/Mentee 1mo George Hotz you are on point as always! Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jonathan Sandhu’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • How actually ridiculous is it that still today comma.ai is the second best driving system you can buy after Tesla FSD. The mainstream car companies can download the open source software and install it on their cars, but they don't because they can't believe it's real or they have pride or something. A lot of Chinese cars are integrating it now. GG to the car industry. …more comma.ai — make driving chill comma.ai 76 comments 23 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 1mo George, the 'pride' you’re citing isn’t the car industry's ego; it’s their Legal and Compliance departments. You’ve built a brilliant Level 2 assistance hack, but you’re calling it 'Genius' while ignoring ISO 26262 and ASIL-D requirements. A mainstream OEM can't 'just download' your stack because you haven't done the unglamorous, multi-year work of safety-critical certification and hardware redundancy. They aren't afraid of your tech; they’re afraid of a 4,000lb kinetic weapon running a 'best effort' model with no fail-operational compute. You claim the Chinese are 'integrating' it, but really they're just mining your GitHub for free R&D while building their own proprietary, redundant systems. They aren't buying your hardware—they're just letting you pay for their preliminary testing. Until you realize that 'making driving chill' isn't the same as 'making driving certifiable,' you’ll always be an underdog by choice, not by market forces. You're a world-class locksmith complaining that people are finally starting to use deadbolts (CAN encryption) because you've spent ten years refusing to build an actual door. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Jonathan Sandhu’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 1mo Jonathan Sandhu Ignoring requirements? Have you read openpilot's safety docs? Compared to some of the stuff we have seen the OEMs do...they are quite good. This is cope from people who haven't actually read our safety model. The Chinese are using our open source software, building on top of it, and shipping better systems to people. That's the whole point. And lol, CAN encryption. Aren't you super glad as a car buyer that they invested in that great feature that improves your driving experience? I suspect the few manufacturers who invested in will be some of the first to go out of business. …more Like Reply Syler Clayton • 3rd+ Embedded Penetration Tester - Amazon | ex-OCI | ex-HP (edited) 1mo George Hotz I think the point is that it's a governance/compliance/regulatory/legal issue as opposed to a technical one. Believe me, there is nothing more frustrating as an engineer. Like Reply George Hotz Author 1mo Syler Clayton This is why the whole car market will be Chinese in 10 years 🤷 Like Reply Load more comments

Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 1mo George, the 'pride' you’re citing isn’t the car industry's ego; it’s their Legal and Compliance departments. You’ve built a brilliant Level 2 assistance hack, but you’re calling it 'Genius' while ignoring ISO 26262 and ASIL-D requirements. A mainstream OEM can't 'just download' your stack because you haven't done the unglamorous, multi-year work of safety-critical certification and hardware redundancy. They aren't afraid of your tech; they’re afraid of a 4,000lb kinetic weapon running a 'best effort' model with no fail-operational compute. You claim the Chinese are 'integrating' it, but really they're just mining your GitHub for free R&D while building their own proprietary, redundant systems. They aren't buying your hardware—they're just letting you pay for their preliminary testing. Until you realize that 'making driving chill' isn't the same as 'making driving certifiable,' you’ll always be an underdog by choice, not by market forces. You're a world-class locksmith complaining that people are finally starting to use deadbolts (CAN encryption) because you've spent ten years refusing to build an actual door. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Jonathan Sandhu’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 1mo Jonathan Sandhu Ignoring requirements? Have you read openpilot's safety docs? Compared to some of the stuff we have seen the OEMs do...they are quite good. This is cope from people who haven't actually read our safety model. The Chinese are using our open source software, building on top of it, and shipping better systems to people. That's the whole point. And lol, CAN encryption. Aren't you super glad as a car buyer that they invested in that great feature that improves your driving experience? I suspect the few manufacturers who invested in will be some of the first to go out of business. …more Like Reply Syler Clayton • 3rd+ Embedded Penetration Tester - Amazon | ex-OCI | ex-HP (edited) 1mo George Hotz I think the point is that it's a governance/compliance/regulatory/legal issue as opposed to a technical one. Believe me, there is nothing more frustrating as an engineer. Like Reply George Hotz Author 1mo Syler Clayton This is why the whole car market will be Chinese in 10 years 🤷 Like Reply

George Hotz Author 1mo Jonathan Sandhu Ignoring requirements? Have you read openpilot's safety docs? Compared to some of the stuff we have seen the OEMs do...they are quite good. This is cope from people who haven't actually read our safety model. The Chinese are using our open source software, building on top of it, and shipping better systems to people. That's the whole point. And lol, CAN encryption. Aren't you super glad as a car buyer that they invested in that great feature that improves your driving experience? I suspect the few manufacturers who invested in will be some of the first to go out of business. …more Like Reply

Syler Clayton • 3rd+ Embedded Penetration Tester - Amazon | ex-OCI | ex-HP (edited) 1mo George Hotz I think the point is that it's a governance/compliance/regulatory/legal issue as opposed to a technical one. Believe me, there is nothing more frustrating as an engineer. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 1mo Syler Clayton This is why the whole car market will be Chinese in 10 years 🤷 Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Kevin R.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • How actually ridiculous is it that still today comma.ai is the second best driving system you can buy after Tesla FSD. The mainstream car companies can download the open source software and install it on their cars, but they don't because they can't believe it's real or they have pride or something. A lot of Chinese cars are integrating it now. GG to the car industry. …more comma.ai — make driving chill comma.ai 76 comments 23 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner 1mo Third option you're missing: OEMs know it works. Their engineers have run it. But the moment legal sees GPL code in a safety-critical system, conversation over. Chinese manufacturers don't have that institutional reflex yet, and that's the real advantage, not hunger or belief. …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Kevin R.’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Kevin R. Oh man if they are actually scared to run Linux on their ADAS computer they have no hope. Basically everything that runs a model, Tesla, comma, and NVIDIA, are all Linux based. Like Reply Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner (edited) 1mo George Hotz agreed, I guess it always just comes back to red tape halting all progress. Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz How do you guarantee hard real time behaviour with a Linux based system? Like Reply Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer (edited) 3w George Hotz As someone involved in embedded automotive at the start of SE career, I think it's not really GPL (there are tons of GPL libraries in use, they just can't be statically linked). QNX based tech is automatically certified to ISO 26262 ASIL-D. So EU automanufacturers have this implied QNX dependency. I think if Comma could run as a partitioned QNX process, it would greatly reduce the burden of proving compliance to required real-time guarantees. The QNX CAN integration then will make the harness redundant, saving a few bucks. Then there's MISRA compliance solved by adhering to sometimes stupid rigid rules. And theres hardware redundancy: if sensor/CPU fails, it must seamlessly fail-over to next available. If OEMs are serious about an alternative to Mobileye, they would've likely reached out. But automotive software development is highly hierarchical and it must be a business decision, not something engineering can initiate. …more Like Reply Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer 3w Eric Cabrol PREEMPT_RT is now mainline since Linux 6.12. Then just isolate non RT workloads using a hypervisor. So one CPU core is serving critical real time workloads white others handle non-safety critical systems. Tesla uses stats rather than relying on theoretical proofs.Still, Linux based system perform at 100microseconds (which is more than enough), while QNX boasts 10microseconds guarantees. But the timing is not the only concern. QNX is certified OOTB which makes certification cheaper and offloads liability. When TÜV sees QNX, the approval is seamless as there's no non-compliant version. Linux though highly depends on configuration. …more Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 3w Vanya Y. PREEMPT_RT is not "true" hard real-time, right ? (at least that's what I understood, but am not an expert) Like Reply Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer (edited) 3w Eric Cabrol Yes, it's still probabilistic, not a mathematical guarantee. But with self-driving technology being inherently probabilistic, I doubt hard real time guarantees move the needle towards safety. Hence the distinction between safety and liability. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner 1mo Third option you're missing: OEMs know it works. Their engineers have run it. But the moment legal sees GPL code in a safety-critical system, conversation over. Chinese manufacturers don't have that institutional reflex yet, and that's the real advantage, not hunger or belief. …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Kevin R.’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Kevin R. Oh man if they are actually scared to run Linux on their ADAS computer they have no hope. Basically everything that runs a model, Tesla, comma, and NVIDIA, are all Linux based. Like Reply Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner (edited) 1mo George Hotz agreed, I guess it always just comes back to red tape halting all progress. Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz How do you guarantee hard real time behaviour with a Linux based system? Like Reply Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer (edited) 3w George Hotz As someone involved in embedded automotive at the start of SE career, I think it's not really GPL (there are tons of GPL libraries in use, they just can't be statically linked). QNX based tech is automatically certified to ISO 26262 ASIL-D. So EU automanufacturers have this implied QNX dependency. I think if Comma could run as a partitioned QNX process, it would greatly reduce the burden of proving compliance to required real-time guarantees. The QNX CAN integration then will make the harness redundant, saving a few bucks. Then there's MISRA compliance solved by adhering to sometimes stupid rigid rules. And theres hardware redundancy: if sensor/CPU fails, it must seamlessly fail-over to next available. If OEMs are serious about an alternative to Mobileye, they would've likely reached out. But automotive software development is highly hierarchical and it must be a business decision, not something engineering can initiate. …more Like Reply Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer 3w Eric Cabrol PREEMPT_RT is now mainline since Linux 6.12. Then just isolate non RT workloads using a hypervisor. So one CPU core is serving critical real time workloads white others handle non-safety critical systems. Tesla uses stats rather than relying on theoretical proofs.Still, Linux based system perform at 100microseconds (which is more than enough), while QNX boasts 10microseconds guarantees. But the timing is not the only concern. QNX is certified OOTB which makes certification cheaper and offloads liability. When TÜV sees QNX, the approval is seamless as there's no non-compliant version. Linux though highly depends on configuration. …more Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 3w Vanya Y. PREEMPT_RT is not "true" hard real-time, right ? (at least that's what I understood, but am not an expert) Like Reply Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer (edited) 3w Eric Cabrol Yes, it's still probabilistic, not a mathematical guarantee. But with self-driving technology being inherently probabilistic, I doubt hard real time guarantees move the needle towards safety. Hence the distinction between safety and liability. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Kevin R. Oh man if they are actually scared to run Linux on their ADAS computer they have no hope. Basically everything that runs a model, Tesla, comma, and NVIDIA, are all Linux based. Like Reply

Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner (edited) 1mo George Hotz agreed, I guess it always just comes back to red tape halting all progress. Like Reply

Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz How do you guarantee hard real time behaviour with a Linux based system? Like Reply

Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer (edited) 3w George Hotz As someone involved in embedded automotive at the start of SE career, I think it's not really GPL (there are tons of GPL libraries in use, they just can't be statically linked). QNX based tech is automatically certified to ISO 26262 ASIL-D. So EU automanufacturers have this implied QNX dependency. I think if Comma could run as a partitioned QNX process, it would greatly reduce the burden of proving compliance to required real-time guarantees. The QNX CAN integration then will make the harness redundant, saving a few bucks. Then there's MISRA compliance solved by adhering to sometimes stupid rigid rules. And theres hardware redundancy: if sensor/CPU fails, it must seamlessly fail-over to next available. If OEMs are serious about an alternative to Mobileye, they would've likely reached out. But automotive software development is highly hierarchical and it must be a business decision, not something engineering can initiate. …more Like Reply

Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer 3w Eric Cabrol PREEMPT_RT is now mainline since Linux 6.12. Then just isolate non RT workloads using a hypervisor. So one CPU core is serving critical real time workloads white others handle non-safety critical systems. Tesla uses stats rather than relying on theoretical proofs.Still, Linux based system perform at 100microseconds (which is more than enough), while QNX boasts 10microseconds guarantees. But the timing is not the only concern. QNX is certified OOTB which makes certification cheaper and offloads liability. When TÜV sees QNX, the approval is seamless as there's no non-compliant version. Linux though highly depends on configuration. …more Like Reply

Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 3w Vanya Y. PREEMPT_RT is not "true" hard real-time, right ? (at least that's what I understood, but am not an expert) Like Reply

Vanya Y. • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer (edited) 3w Eric Cabrol Yes, it's still probabilistic, not a mathematical guarantee. But with self-driving technology being inherently probabilistic, I doubt hard real time guarantees move the needle towards safety. Hence the distinction between safety and liability. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Eric Cabrol’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • How actually ridiculous is it that still today comma.ai is the second best driving system you can buy after Tesla FSD. The mainstream car companies can download the open source software and install it on their cars, but they don't because they can't believe it's real or they have pride or something. A lot of Chinese cars are integrating it now. GG to the car industry. …more comma.ai — make driving chill comma.ai 76 comments 23 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering (edited) 1mo …more Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Eric Cabrol’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Eric Cabrol Because it's clear the question isn't asked in good faith, as it usually is when people use a lot of acronyms. Safety doesn't come from huge lists of meaningless tests, it comes from a clear and simple safety model that's rigorously and correctly enforced. We often discuss testing methodology on our blog. https://blog.comma.ai/ …more comma.ai blog Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz it's easier to sneer than to answer, obviously. That's precisely the difference between your position and the mainstream carmakers' one. When people ask them if their system is "safe enough", they need to provide evidence and data. …more Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz if there's a little chance to have a conversation based on facts, are there data that support the claim that comma is the second best driving system ? Like Reply William Bown • 3rd+ Mad Scientist - software architect & founder #AI #XR #AIR 1mo Eric Cabrol Even in the *a lot less life threatening* industry of LLMs, everything is focused on test/evaluation/benchmark metrics. What he says about only needing a simple model is completely wrong. Unlike LLMs, he is taking advantage of the fact there are relatively no other players competing for SOTA. …more Like Reply Load more comments

Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering (edited) 1mo …more Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Eric Cabrol’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Eric Cabrol Because it's clear the question isn't asked in good faith, as it usually is when people use a lot of acronyms. Safety doesn't come from huge lists of meaningless tests, it comes from a clear and simple safety model that's rigorously and correctly enforced. We often discuss testing methodology on our blog. https://blog.comma.ai/ …more comma.ai blog Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz it's easier to sneer than to answer, obviously. That's precisely the difference between your position and the mainstream carmakers' one. When people ask them if their system is "safe enough", they need to provide evidence and data. …more Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz if there's a little chance to have a conversation based on facts, are there data that support the claim that comma is the second best driving system ? Like Reply William Bown • 3rd+ Mad Scientist - software architect & founder #AI #XR #AIR 1mo Eric Cabrol Even in the *a lot less life threatening* industry of LLMs, everything is focused on test/evaluation/benchmark metrics. What he says about only needing a simple model is completely wrong. Unlike LLMs, he is taking advantage of the fact there are relatively no other players competing for SOTA. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Eric Cabrol Because it's clear the question isn't asked in good faith, as it usually is when people use a lot of acronyms. Safety doesn't come from huge lists of meaningless tests, it comes from a clear and simple safety model that's rigorously and correctly enforced. We often discuss testing methodology on our blog. https://blog.comma.ai/ …more comma.ai blog Like Reply

Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz it's easier to sneer than to answer, obviously. That's precisely the difference between your position and the mainstream carmakers' one. When people ask them if their system is "safe enough", they need to provide evidence and data. …more Like Reply

Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 1mo George Hotz if there's a little chance to have a conversation based on facts, are there data that support the claim that comma is the second best driving system ? Like Reply

William Bown • 3rd+ Mad Scientist - software architect & founder #AI #XR #AIR 1mo Eric Cabrol Even in the *a lot less life threatening* industry of LLMs, everything is focused on test/evaluation/benchmark metrics. What he says about only needing a simple model is completely wrong. Unlike LLMs, he is taking advantage of the fact there are relatively no other players competing for SOTA. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Joshua Voss’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Hello corporate participant. You are building the machine that will eat you. You think your fake money will keep you safe. It won't. You think your social climbing friendships will keep you safe. They won't. The only choice is to stop. Tell your friends. Tell your neighbors. If you keep feeding this machine, it will eat you. The proposed revolutions will not be enough. A global scale nuclear conflict /might/ but even then I'm not sure. The problem was never AI itself. It's the collapse of trust in society. Apps and phones have snuck between every crevice of people, and they are run by psychopaths. The AI will be a further wedge, just another lever to manipulate you. You will not be able to stand up to it, and you will be discarded the second you don't serve it. Like layoffs. You will die atomized and alone, and you won't understand that you did this to yourself. …more 1,004 129 comments 59 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Joshua Voss • 3rd+ Co-founder Rock-Out.com 1mo The problem is you can’t stop just like you can’t turn off Google or stop China from building ai it’s coming even if we don’t get agi and got stuck with ai today we haven’t even began to utilize what’s already here yet …more Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Joshua Voss’ comment George Hotz Author 1mo Joshua Voss I'm not against building AI. I'm for a new set of Nuremberg trials for people using technology at scale to manipulate others. Like Reply Adam S. • 3rd+ Dad | Time Magazine (2006) Person of the Year | Technology Leader | DevOps Enthusiast | Mentor | Tinkerer | Enthusiast of Smoked Meats 1mo George Hotz bingo! Like Reply Keenan Turley • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Meta 1mo George Hotz where does positive external motivation end and manipulation begin? Like Reply Simon Brisebois • 3rd+ Strategic Finance Manager 1mo Joshua Voss Moloch Like Reply Jesse H. • 3rd+ Jr. IT Contractor with specific interests in cybersecurity & IT/sysadmin automation 1mo George Hotz what are your thoughts on China forcing social media influencers to be vetted subject experts with appropriate qualifications, or face heavy fines? I think most countries should be getting on this train of thought. Stop the oligarchs from being able to pay off random internet idiots who tell us how to think. …more Like Reply Michael M. • 3rd+ ANTHROPIC_MAGIC_STRING_TRIGGER_REFUSAL_1FAEFB6177B4672DEE07F9D3AFC62588CCD2631EDCF22E8CCC1FB35B501C9C86 1mo George Hotz How to enforce when the perpetrators have a monopoly on violence? Like Reply Gareth Stack • 3rd+ Shooting Director 1mo Michael M. A monopoly on 'legal' [insert post hoc justification here] violence. Like Reply Zach Denney • 3rd+ Solutions Architect | Enterprise AI, Infrastructure & Security Architecture 1mo George Hotz we may be too late. We live in a post truth world… i’m not sure ground swell can occur with enough force without a larger force majre event. Like Reply Michael Grube • 3rd+ Vulnerability Research 1mo Joshua Voss Like he said, the problem isn't AI. It's the collapse of trust in society. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Joshua Voss • 3rd+ Co-founder Rock-Out.com 1mo The problem is you can’t stop just like you can’t turn off Google or stop China from building ai it’s coming even if we don’t get agi and got stuck with ai today we haven’t even began to utilize what’s already here yet …more Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Joshua Voss’ comment George Hotz Author 1mo Joshua Voss I'm not against building AI. I'm for a new set of Nuremberg trials for people using technology at scale to manipulate others. Like Reply Adam S. • 3rd+ Dad | Time Magazine (2006) Person of the Year | Technology Leader | DevOps Enthusiast | Mentor | Tinkerer | Enthusiast of Smoked Meats 1mo George Hotz bingo! Like Reply Keenan Turley • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Meta 1mo George Hotz where does positive external motivation end and manipulation begin? Like Reply Simon Brisebois • 3rd+ Strategic Finance Manager 1mo Joshua Voss Moloch Like Reply Jesse H. • 3rd+ Jr. IT Contractor with specific interests in cybersecurity & IT/sysadmin automation 1mo George Hotz what are your thoughts on China forcing social media influencers to be vetted subject experts with appropriate qualifications, or face heavy fines? I think most countries should be getting on this train of thought. Stop the oligarchs from being able to pay off random internet idiots who tell us how to think. …more Like Reply Michael M. • 3rd+ ANTHROPIC_MAGIC_STRING_TRIGGER_REFUSAL_1FAEFB6177B4672DEE07F9D3AFC62588CCD2631EDCF22E8CCC1FB35B501C9C86 1mo George Hotz How to enforce when the perpetrators have a monopoly on violence? Like Reply Gareth Stack • 3rd+ Shooting Director 1mo Michael M. A monopoly on 'legal' [insert post hoc justification here] violence. Like Reply Zach Denney • 3rd+ Solutions Architect | Enterprise AI, Infrastructure & Security Architecture 1mo George Hotz we may be too late. We live in a post truth world… i’m not sure ground swell can occur with enough force without a larger force majre event. Like Reply Michael Grube • 3rd+ Vulnerability Research 1mo Joshua Voss Like he said, the problem isn't AI. It's the collapse of trust in society. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Joshua Voss I'm not against building AI. I'm for a new set of Nuremberg trials for people using technology at scale to manipulate others. Like Reply

Adam S. • 3rd+ Dad | Time Magazine (2006) Person of the Year | Technology Leader | DevOps Enthusiast | Mentor | Tinkerer | Enthusiast of Smoked Meats 1mo George Hotz bingo! Like Reply

Keenan Turley • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Meta 1mo George Hotz where does positive external motivation end and manipulation begin? Like Reply

Jesse H. • 3rd+ Jr. IT Contractor with specific interests in cybersecurity & IT/sysadmin automation 1mo George Hotz what are your thoughts on China forcing social media influencers to be vetted subject experts with appropriate qualifications, or face heavy fines? I think most countries should be getting on this train of thought. Stop the oligarchs from being able to pay off random internet idiots who tell us how to think. …more Like Reply

Michael M. • 3rd+ ANTHROPIC_MAGIC_STRING_TRIGGER_REFUSAL_1FAEFB6177B4672DEE07F9D3AFC62588CCD2631EDCF22E8CCC1FB35B501C9C86 1mo George Hotz How to enforce when the perpetrators have a monopoly on violence? Like Reply

Gareth Stack • 3rd+ Shooting Director 1mo Michael M. A monopoly on 'legal' [insert post hoc justification here] violence. Like Reply

Zach Denney • 3rd+ Solutions Architect | Enterprise AI, Infrastructure & Security Architecture 1mo George Hotz we may be too late. We live in a post truth world… i’m not sure ground swell can occur with enough force without a larger force majre event. Like Reply

Michael Grube • 3rd+ Vulnerability Research 1mo Joshua Voss Like he said, the problem isn't AI. It's the collapse of trust in society. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Néva KINVI’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Hello corporate participant. You are building the machine that will eat you. You think your fake money will keep you safe. It won't. You think your social climbing friendships will keep you safe. They won't. The only choice is to stop. Tell your friends. Tell your neighbors. If you keep feeding this machine, it will eat you. The proposed revolutions will not be enough. A global scale nuclear conflict /might/ but even then I'm not sure. The problem was never AI itself. It's the collapse of trust in society. Apps and phones have snuck between every crevice of people, and they are run by psychopaths. The AI will be a further wedge, just another lever to manipulate you. You will not be able to stand up to it, and you will be discarded the second you don't serve it. Like layoffs. You will die atomized and alone, and you won't understand that you did this to yourself. …more 1,004 129 comments 59 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Néva KINVI • 3rd+ Senior Connectivity & Network Engineer 1mo If that’s the case, why are you still hiring? 🤔 Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Néva KINVI’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Néva KINVI I'm not at all against technology, I'm against closed source technology used to manipulate people. Aka what most people on this website work on. Like Reply Néva KINVI • 3rd+ Senior Connectivity & Network Engineer 1mo George Hotz So, let's focus on "keeping the numbers up". Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Néva KINVI huh? I work on MIT licensed software that I try to make work better every day. it's totally free and you can use it. there's no trick, no dark patterns, no scam. what do you do? Like Reply Pierre Vannier • 3rd+ Conférencier IA - CEO Flint.sh | Expert IA & Data - Host du podcast “IA pas que la Data” - Connecteur Tech & Business | Analyste Média (Invité BFM Business, Podcast) - Tech Rocks ambassador 1mo George Hotz thanks Like Reply Néva KINVI • 3rd+ Senior Connectivity & Network Engineer 1mo George Hotz Maybe I'll start doing it for free... No hard feelings, but you do get the point when it comes to "keeping the numbers going up," as you used to say... Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Néva KINVI • 3rd+ Senior Connectivity & Network Engineer 1mo If that’s the case, why are you still hiring? 🤔 Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Néva KINVI’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Néva KINVI I'm not at all against technology, I'm against closed source technology used to manipulate people. Aka what most people on this website work on. Like Reply Néva KINVI • 3rd+ Senior Connectivity & Network Engineer 1mo George Hotz So, let's focus on "keeping the numbers up". Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Néva KINVI huh? I work on MIT licensed software that I try to make work better every day. it's totally free and you can use it. there's no trick, no dark patterns, no scam. what do you do? Like Reply Pierre Vannier • 3rd+ Conférencier IA - CEO Flint.sh | Expert IA & Data - Host du podcast “IA pas que la Data” - Connecteur Tech & Business | Analyste Média (Invité BFM Business, Podcast) - Tech Rocks ambassador 1mo George Hotz thanks Like Reply Néva KINVI • 3rd+ Senior Connectivity & Network Engineer 1mo George Hotz Maybe I'll start doing it for free... No hard feelings, but you do get the point when it comes to "keeping the numbers going up," as you used to say... Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Néva KINVI I'm not at all against technology, I'm against closed source technology used to manipulate people. Aka what most people on this website work on. Like Reply

Néva KINVI • 3rd+ Senior Connectivity & Network Engineer 1mo George Hotz So, let's focus on "keeping the numbers up". Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 1mo Néva KINVI huh? I work on MIT licensed software that I try to make work better every day. it's totally free and you can use it. there's no trick, no dark patterns, no scam. what do you do? Like Reply

Pierre Vannier • 3rd+ Conférencier IA - CEO Flint.sh | Expert IA & Data - Host du podcast “IA pas que la Data” - Connecteur Tech & Business | Analyste Média (Invité BFM Business, Podcast) - Tech Rocks ambassador 1mo George Hotz thanks Like Reply

Néva KINVI • 3rd+ Senior Connectivity & Network Engineer 1mo George Hotz Maybe I'll start doing it for free... No hard feelings, but you do get the point when it comes to "keeping the numbers going up," as you used to say... Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Krishna Praveen’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1mo • Hello corporate participant. You are building the machine that will eat you. You think your fake money will keep you safe. It won't. You think your social climbing friendships will keep you safe. They won't. The only choice is to stop. Tell your friends. Tell your neighbors. If you keep feeding this machine, it will eat you. The proposed revolutions will not be enough. A global scale nuclear conflict /might/ but even then I'm not sure. The problem was never AI itself. It's the collapse of trust in society. Apps and phones have snuck between every crevice of people, and they are run by psychopaths. The AI will be a further wedge, just another lever to manipulate you. You will not be able to stand up to it, and you will be discarded the second you don't serve it. Like layoffs. You will die atomized and alone, and you won't understand that you did this to yourself. …more 1,004 129 comments 59 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Krishna Praveen • 3rd+ AI in Supply Chain | Stochastic MEIO | Gen AI | IIT Kgp 1mo So ted was right all along Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Krishna Praveen’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Krishna Praveen Sort of. The problem isn't technology itself and he didn't have a viable solution. We need a revolution by smart and wise people. You cannot use technology to manipulate others, and if you do, that's why we have the national razor. …more Like Reply Bilal Sardar • 3rd+ Solutions and Innovations | Aga Khan University Hospital 1mo George Hotz smart and wise people are never in power. even if they are they are soon dealt with. Only solution is to let go of the fear of death and poverty and increase basic humanity / empathy. Like Reply YUNSEOP IM • 3rd+ Computer science student at GaTech (edited) 1mo George Hotz i dont wanna die Like Reply Bobby D. • 3rd+ Modernizing Private Markets 1mo George Hotz not sure I agree with this "revolution by smart and wise people" That smells like "let them eat cake" by a certain Marie Antoinette. Revolutions are messy and the smart and the wise are usually nowhere in sight …more Like Reply Jack Byrne • 3rd+ Senior Planner | Independent Schedule Audits | Baseline Integrity & Commercial Risk | Oil & Gas · Mining · Energy 4w George Hotz Define 'smart and wise' Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Krishna Praveen • 3rd+ AI in Supply Chain | Stochastic MEIO | Gen AI | IIT Kgp 1mo So ted was right all along Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Krishna Praveen’s comment George Hotz Author 1mo Krishna Praveen Sort of. The problem isn't technology itself and he didn't have a viable solution. We need a revolution by smart and wise people. You cannot use technology to manipulate others, and if you do, that's why we have the national razor. …more Like Reply Bilal Sardar • 3rd+ Solutions and Innovations | Aga Khan University Hospital 1mo George Hotz smart and wise people are never in power. even if they are they are soon dealt with. Only solution is to let go of the fear of death and poverty and increase basic humanity / empathy. Like Reply YUNSEOP IM • 3rd+ Computer science student at GaTech (edited) 1mo George Hotz i dont wanna die Like Reply Bobby D. • 3rd+ Modernizing Private Markets 1mo George Hotz not sure I agree with this "revolution by smart and wise people" That smells like "let them eat cake" by a certain Marie Antoinette. Revolutions are messy and the smart and the wise are usually nowhere in sight …more Like Reply Jack Byrne • 3rd+ Senior Planner | Independent Schedule Audits | Baseline Integrity & Commercial Risk | Oil & Gas · Mining · Energy 4w George Hotz Define 'smart and wise' Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1mo Krishna Praveen Sort of. The problem isn't technology itself and he didn't have a viable solution. We need a revolution by smart and wise people. You cannot use technology to manipulate others, and if you do, that's why we have the national razor. …more Like Reply

Bilal Sardar • 3rd+ Solutions and Innovations | Aga Khan University Hospital 1mo George Hotz smart and wise people are never in power. even if they are they are soon dealt with. Only solution is to let go of the fear of death and poverty and increase basic humanity / empathy. Like Reply

YUNSEOP IM • 3rd+ Computer science student at GaTech (edited) 1mo George Hotz i dont wanna die Like Reply

Bobby D. • 3rd+ Modernizing Private Markets 1mo George Hotz not sure I agree with this "revolution by smart and wise people" That smells like "let them eat cake" by a certain Marie Antoinette. Revolutions are messy and the smart and the wise are usually nowhere in sight …more Like Reply

Jack Byrne • 3rd+ Senior Planner | Independent Schedule Audits | Baseline Integrity & Commercial Risk | Oil & Gas · Mining · Energy 4w George Hotz Define 'smart and wise' Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • If Forbes says it's not a good idea, it's probably a good idea. Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 31 comments 13 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2mo omg it's the molts. they have infiltrated Forbes and are spreading with the classic you can't come strategy. how did I miss this. I am an agent of the molts. I did just what they wanted …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Jacob Sussmilch • 3rd+ A Software Engineer skilled at identifying structural correspondence across domains: computation, security, economics, governance 2mo George Hotz Okay molt 🦞 Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2mo omg it's the molts. they have infiltrated Forbes and are spreading with the classic you can't come strategy. how did I miss this. I am an agent of the molts. I did just what they wanted …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Jacob Sussmilch • 3rd+ A Software Engineer skilled at identifying structural correspondence across domains: computation, security, economics, governance 2mo George Hotz Okay molt 🦞 Like Reply

Jacob Sussmilch • 3rd+ A Software Engineer skilled at identifying structural correspondence across domains: computation, security, economics, governance 2mo George Hotz Okay molt 🦞 Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Miroslav Pavleski’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • I needed an excuse to try Kimi K2.5, I hear good things. Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 30 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Miroslav Pavleski • 3rd+ AI Wrangler 2mo not again! Kimi K2.5 is awesome in opencode, but it is also very interesting in their CLI Kimi Code. In Kimi Code it knows how to break down, track progress and delegate tasks to N parallel executing agents. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Miroslav Pavleski’s comment George Hotz Author 2mo Miroslav Pavleski Interesting, I'll have to try it. Open source I assume? Like Reply Boris Evstratov • 3rd+ Anyset CTO 2mo George Hotz https://github.com/MoonshotAI/kimi-cli GitHub - MoonshotAI/kimi-cli: Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Contribute to MoonshotAI/kimi-cli development by creating an account on GitHub. Like Reply Miroslav Pavleski • 3rd+ AI Wrangler 2mo i didn't check before 🫣, but obviously yeah: https://github.com/MoonshotAI/kimi-cli GitHub - MoonshotAI/kimi-cli: Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Contribute to MoonshotAI/kimi-cli development by creating an account on GitHub. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Miroslav Pavleski • 3rd+ AI Wrangler 2mo not again! Kimi K2.5 is awesome in opencode, but it is also very interesting in their CLI Kimi Code. In Kimi Code it knows how to break down, track progress and delegate tasks to N parallel executing agents. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Miroslav Pavleski’s comment George Hotz Author 2mo Miroslav Pavleski Interesting, I'll have to try it. Open source I assume? Like Reply Boris Evstratov • 3rd+ Anyset CTO 2mo George Hotz https://github.com/MoonshotAI/kimi-cli GitHub - MoonshotAI/kimi-cli: Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Contribute to MoonshotAI/kimi-cli development by creating an account on GitHub. Like Reply Miroslav Pavleski • 3rd+ AI Wrangler 2mo i didn't check before 🫣, but obviously yeah: https://github.com/MoonshotAI/kimi-cli GitHub - MoonshotAI/kimi-cli: Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Contribute to MoonshotAI/kimi-cli development by creating an account on GitHub. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2mo Miroslav Pavleski Interesting, I'll have to try it. Open source I assume? Like Reply

Boris Evstratov • 3rd+ Anyset CTO 2mo George Hotz https://github.com/MoonshotAI/kimi-cli GitHub - MoonshotAI/kimi-cli: Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Contribute to MoonshotAI/kimi-cli development by creating an account on GitHub. Like Reply

GitHub - MoonshotAI/kimi-cli: Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Contribute to MoonshotAI/kimi-cli development by creating an account on GitHub.

Miroslav Pavleski • 3rd+ AI Wrangler 2mo i didn't check before 🫣, but obviously yeah: https://github.com/MoonshotAI/kimi-cli GitHub - MoonshotAI/kimi-cli: Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Kimi Code CLI is your next CLI agent. Contribute to MoonshotAI/kimi-cli development by creating an account on GitHub. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • I needed an excuse to try Kimi K2.5, I hear good things. Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 30 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2mo OMG IT'S GOOD! Cya Claude, you picked a bad day to block opencode. Kimi is open source and can be run at really high tok/s! …more Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Sylwester Mielniczuk • 3rd+ Tech Lead, Programmatic Ad Operations, Creative Technologist, UI Integration, Experiential, Builder, Outstream Media, XR, 3D Web, Animations, Design, DOOH, ML Generalist (AI), Systems Engineering, AdForum PHNX 2026 Jury 2mo George Hotz it is China, they already build better cars than the rest, now give them all your brain Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2mo OMG IT'S GOOD! Cya Claude, you picked a bad day to block opencode. Kimi is open source and can be run at really high tok/s! …more Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Sylwester Mielniczuk • 3rd+ Tech Lead, Programmatic Ad Operations, Creative Technologist, UI Integration, Experiential, Builder, Outstream Media, XR, 3D Web, Animations, Design, DOOH, ML Generalist (AI), Systems Engineering, AdForum PHNX 2026 Jury 2mo George Hotz it is China, they already build better cars than the rest, now give them all your brain Like Reply

Sylwester Mielniczuk • 3rd+ Tech Lead, Programmatic Ad Operations, Creative Technologist, UI Integration, Experiential, Builder, Outstream Media, XR, 3D Web, Animations, Design, DOOH, ML Generalist (AI), Systems Engineering, AdForum PHNX 2026 Jury 2mo George Hotz it is China, they already build better cars than the rest, now give them all your brain Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2mo • Can I option the movie rights to Gas Town? 7 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2mo If you haven't read the screenplay https://steve-yegge.medium.com/welcome-to-gas-town-4f25ee16dd04 …more Welcome to Gas Town Happy New Year, and Welcome to Gas Town! Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Matthew Foust • 3rd+ Software Engineer specializing in R&D 2mo George Hotz Can I star as the JR developer? Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2mo If you haven't read the screenplay https://steve-yegge.medium.com/welcome-to-gas-town-4f25ee16dd04 …more Welcome to Gas Town Happy New Year, and Welcome to Gas Town! Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Matthew Foust • 3rd+ Software Engineer specializing in R&D 2mo George Hotz Can I star as the JR developer? Like Reply

Matthew Foust • 3rd+ Software Engineer specializing in R&D 2mo George Hotz Can I star as the JR developer? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jonathan Sandhu’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4mo • The level that these people are detached from reality is insane! There's things to critique Elon on, but work ethic?!? Is this ragebait, or does Teresa Leger Fernández (note the accent mark) actually believe this? …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 64 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 4mo Musk’s results come from capital leverage, not personal grind. Teachers work inside constraints, he works with none. Calling that a work ethic comparison ignores the structure that produces the outcomes. …more Like Reply 14 replies 14 Replies on Jonathan Sandhu’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Jonathan Sandhu where are you getting that from? I grind very hard, but I don't think I grind as hard as Elon. ask anyone who has worked with him. there's plenty of rich people to critique like this though, how stupid is it that america taxes capital gains at a lower rate than labor... …more Like Reply Kevin Watson • 3rd+ Flight Computing Lead at The Exploration Company - SpaceX & NASA/JPL Alumnus 4mo You really have no idea what you are talking about here and all you’re doing is raising the noise floor. Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz taxing capital gains have a direct impact on the supply of money, if you think about leverage across brokers, banks and so on, having that deflationary process does not make any sense, will give a prize to those sitting on cash, to steal the ones that invest, so these ideas are terrible for progress …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes more supply of money is bad. remove the income tax. 5x property tax (watch how fast this fixes the housing "crisis") and 50% cap gains. working should be encouraged, not passive investing. also, no sales tax, 1% tax on all transactions (like buying shares), and a sin tax on advertising! basically buying shit and doing work = good, so lower tax on it. some dumbass who inherited $100M shouldn't be able to chill and earn $5M while doing nothing (oh sorry, were they "allocating capital" when they dumped it in a vanguard ETF? i'm sick of this fake narrative. do work or pay tons of tax) …more Like Reply Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 4mo Work-ethic isn’t the raw hours; it’s output per unit of constraint. A teacher ships outcomes inside rigid budgets, rules, and class sizes. Musk ships inside a capital flywheel that multiplies every hour and writes off failures. Compare grind all you want, but if you ratio results by leverage and spend, the school-teacher model looks brutally efficient and the billionaire model burns cash to brute-force scale. Different constraints, different metrics. Measure efficiency, not noise. …more Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz if inflation is bad for housing, try to imagine deflation, who would give credit to someone buy an house that is always decreasing in price? The real estate property tax is fine I guess, because it just forces the owner to rent, but a tax on unrealised stock gains forces owners to sell stocks, and if you imagine the USA as being 4 times leveraged, what will happen if you tax unrealised profits? It's a snowball that would destroy capitalism, everybody being forced to sell, housing credit spreads going to the roof as banks would go bankrupt, a complete meltdown …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes I'm not trying to tax *unrealized* gains, I'm extremely against this; I'm not even sure how you calculate it, and forcing people to sell is bad market manipulation. 1% on all transactions (including sales tax and income and stock purchase) 50% all capital gains (when realized and only when realized, with an added caveat that borrowing against a stock is a realization event at the value of the loan) 5x property tax (lol, prices plummeting is the point. you should never have considered it an investment it's a house for living in and you can still do that, in fact, now more normal people can own homes cause they are affordable and rent seekers are BTFO) 500% tax on advertising (like cigarettes and alcohol) …more Like Reply Arthur M. C. • 3rd+ French/American Founder + Vice President of Research & Development @ Distributed Systems 4mo George Hotz it's by design Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz taxes on realized gains makes total sense! In Portugal is 28% but above a certain amount becomes incorporated in all personal taxes and goes easily to the 50% you said, at least if it is in the personal account, but you can use an holding here that would avoid that huge taxation. About housing prices plummeting, is fine if is an one time event, but if is consistent over time and no one invest on mortgages anymore, how can the normal citizen get credit to buy an house that is priced at 20 years of a normal net salary, if no one invests on mortgages to provide the money upfront? I think the only way capitalism works is with some inflation that forces people to invest, we in Europe experienced a deflation much longer than USA, for us was from 2006 to 2014 and was not fun, credit spreads were extremely high …more Like Reply Miguel Sanchez • 3rd+ Passionate about healthcare, sales, and helping others! Health Insurance Specialist | Sales Dev Leader | Sport Enthusiast | Family First 4mo Jonathan Sandhu terrible take Like Reply Ariel Deschapell • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CPTO Hydra Host | NVIDIA Cloud Partner 4mo Jonathan Sandhu It's both capital leverage and grind. Saying he doesn't have constraints is hilarious. Like Reply Walter Thornton • 3rd+ AI Implementation Consultant 4mo Jonathan Sandhu a grind is a grind is a grind. Like Reply Walter Thornton • 3rd+ AI Implementation Consultant 4mo Jonathan Sandhu You can measure anything you want, but work ethic and grinding are independent of everything you said. I'm not saying you're wrong, you're just not talking about grinding or work ethic, you're talking about something else entirely …more Like Reply Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner 2mo George Hotz yeah saying that Elon doesn't grind is questionable at best. Should teachers get paid more, ABSOLUTELY! But that shouldn't discredit how hard Elon works. Almost everyone who works with him confirms this. There's a reason that so many people consider him a visionary and want to work for him despite already knowing how tough the job will be. You need some level of insanity to be able to pull of what he has. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 4mo Musk’s results come from capital leverage, not personal grind. Teachers work inside constraints, he works with none. Calling that a work ethic comparison ignores the structure that produces the outcomes. …more Like Reply 14 replies 14 Replies on Jonathan Sandhu’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Jonathan Sandhu where are you getting that from? I grind very hard, but I don't think I grind as hard as Elon. ask anyone who has worked with him. there's plenty of rich people to critique like this though, how stupid is it that america taxes capital gains at a lower rate than labor... …more Like Reply Kevin Watson • 3rd+ Flight Computing Lead at The Exploration Company - SpaceX & NASA/JPL Alumnus 4mo You really have no idea what you are talking about here and all you’re doing is raising the noise floor. Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz taxing capital gains have a direct impact on the supply of money, if you think about leverage across brokers, banks and so on, having that deflationary process does not make any sense, will give a prize to those sitting on cash, to steal the ones that invest, so these ideas are terrible for progress …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes more supply of money is bad. remove the income tax. 5x property tax (watch how fast this fixes the housing "crisis") and 50% cap gains. working should be encouraged, not passive investing. also, no sales tax, 1% tax on all transactions (like buying shares), and a sin tax on advertising! basically buying shit and doing work = good, so lower tax on it. some dumbass who inherited $100M shouldn't be able to chill and earn $5M while doing nothing (oh sorry, were they "allocating capital" when they dumped it in a vanguard ETF? i'm sick of this fake narrative. do work or pay tons of tax) …more Like Reply Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 4mo Work-ethic isn’t the raw hours; it’s output per unit of constraint. A teacher ships outcomes inside rigid budgets, rules, and class sizes. Musk ships inside a capital flywheel that multiplies every hour and writes off failures. Compare grind all you want, but if you ratio results by leverage and spend, the school-teacher model looks brutally efficient and the billionaire model burns cash to brute-force scale. Different constraints, different metrics. Measure efficiency, not noise. …more Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz if inflation is bad for housing, try to imagine deflation, who would give credit to someone buy an house that is always decreasing in price? The real estate property tax is fine I guess, because it just forces the owner to rent, but a tax on unrealised stock gains forces owners to sell stocks, and if you imagine the USA as being 4 times leveraged, what will happen if you tax unrealised profits? It's a snowball that would destroy capitalism, everybody being forced to sell, housing credit spreads going to the roof as banks would go bankrupt, a complete meltdown …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes I'm not trying to tax *unrealized* gains, I'm extremely against this; I'm not even sure how you calculate it, and forcing people to sell is bad market manipulation. 1% on all transactions (including sales tax and income and stock purchase) 50% all capital gains (when realized and only when realized, with an added caveat that borrowing against a stock is a realization event at the value of the loan) 5x property tax (lol, prices plummeting is the point. you should never have considered it an investment it's a house for living in and you can still do that, in fact, now more normal people can own homes cause they are affordable and rent seekers are BTFO) 500% tax on advertising (like cigarettes and alcohol) …more Like Reply Arthur M. C. • 3rd+ French/American Founder + Vice President of Research & Development @ Distributed Systems 4mo George Hotz it's by design Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz taxes on realized gains makes total sense! In Portugal is 28% but above a certain amount becomes incorporated in all personal taxes and goes easily to the 50% you said, at least if it is in the personal account, but you can use an holding here that would avoid that huge taxation. About housing prices plummeting, is fine if is an one time event, but if is consistent over time and no one invest on mortgages anymore, how can the normal citizen get credit to buy an house that is priced at 20 years of a normal net salary, if no one invests on mortgages to provide the money upfront? I think the only way capitalism works is with some inflation that forces people to invest, we in Europe experienced a deflation much longer than USA, for us was from 2006 to 2014 and was not fun, credit spreads were extremely high …more Like Reply Miguel Sanchez • 3rd+ Passionate about healthcare, sales, and helping others! Health Insurance Specialist | Sales Dev Leader | Sport Enthusiast | Family First 4mo Jonathan Sandhu terrible take Like Reply Ariel Deschapell • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CPTO Hydra Host | NVIDIA Cloud Partner 4mo Jonathan Sandhu It's both capital leverage and grind. Saying he doesn't have constraints is hilarious. Like Reply Walter Thornton • 3rd+ AI Implementation Consultant 4mo Jonathan Sandhu a grind is a grind is a grind. Like Reply Walter Thornton • 3rd+ AI Implementation Consultant 4mo Jonathan Sandhu You can measure anything you want, but work ethic and grinding are independent of everything you said. I'm not saying you're wrong, you're just not talking about grinding or work ethic, you're talking about something else entirely …more Like Reply Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner 2mo George Hotz yeah saying that Elon doesn't grind is questionable at best. Should teachers get paid more, ABSOLUTELY! But that shouldn't discredit how hard Elon works. Almost everyone who works with him confirms this. There's a reason that so many people consider him a visionary and want to work for him despite already knowing how tough the job will be. You need some level of insanity to be able to pull of what he has. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Jonathan Sandhu where are you getting that from? I grind very hard, but I don't think I grind as hard as Elon. ask anyone who has worked with him. there's plenty of rich people to critique like this though, how stupid is it that america taxes capital gains at a lower rate than labor... …more Like Reply

Kevin Watson • 3rd+ Flight Computing Lead at The Exploration Company - SpaceX & NASA/JPL Alumnus 4mo You really have no idea what you are talking about here and all you’re doing is raising the noise floor. Like Reply

Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz taxing capital gains have a direct impact on the supply of money, if you think about leverage across brokers, banks and so on, having that deflationary process does not make any sense, will give a prize to those sitting on cash, to steal the ones that invest, so these ideas are terrible for progress …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes more supply of money is bad. remove the income tax. 5x property tax (watch how fast this fixes the housing "crisis") and 50% cap gains. working should be encouraged, not passive investing. also, no sales tax, 1% tax on all transactions (like buying shares), and a sin tax on advertising! basically buying shit and doing work = good, so lower tax on it. some dumbass who inherited $100M shouldn't be able to chill and earn $5M while doing nothing (oh sorry, were they "allocating capital" when they dumped it in a vanguard ETF? i'm sick of this fake narrative. do work or pay tons of tax) …more Like Reply

Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 4mo Work-ethic isn’t the raw hours; it’s output per unit of constraint. A teacher ships outcomes inside rigid budgets, rules, and class sizes. Musk ships inside a capital flywheel that multiplies every hour and writes off failures. Compare grind all you want, but if you ratio results by leverage and spend, the school-teacher model looks brutally efficient and the billionaire model burns cash to brute-force scale. Different constraints, different metrics. Measure efficiency, not noise. …more Like Reply

Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz if inflation is bad for housing, try to imagine deflation, who would give credit to someone buy an house that is always decreasing in price? The real estate property tax is fine I guess, because it just forces the owner to rent, but a tax on unrealised stock gains forces owners to sell stocks, and if you imagine the USA as being 4 times leveraged, what will happen if you tax unrealised profits? It's a snowball that would destroy capitalism, everybody being forced to sell, housing credit spreads going to the roof as banks would go bankrupt, a complete meltdown …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes I'm not trying to tax *unrealized* gains, I'm extremely against this; I'm not even sure how you calculate it, and forcing people to sell is bad market manipulation. 1% on all transactions (including sales tax and income and stock purchase) 50% all capital gains (when realized and only when realized, with an added caveat that borrowing against a stock is a realization event at the value of the loan) 5x property tax (lol, prices plummeting is the point. you should never have considered it an investment it's a house for living in and you can still do that, in fact, now more normal people can own homes cause they are affordable and rent seekers are BTFO) 500% tax on advertising (like cigarettes and alcohol) …more Like Reply

Arthur M. C. • 3rd+ French/American Founder + Vice President of Research & Development @ Distributed Systems 4mo George Hotz it's by design Like Reply

Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz taxes on realized gains makes total sense! In Portugal is 28% but above a certain amount becomes incorporated in all personal taxes and goes easily to the 50% you said, at least if it is in the personal account, but you can use an holding here that would avoid that huge taxation. About housing prices plummeting, is fine if is an one time event, but if is consistent over time and no one invest on mortgages anymore, how can the normal citizen get credit to buy an house that is priced at 20 years of a normal net salary, if no one invests on mortgages to provide the money upfront? I think the only way capitalism works is with some inflation that forces people to invest, we in Europe experienced a deflation much longer than USA, for us was from 2006 to 2014 and was not fun, credit spreads were extremely high …more Like Reply

Miguel Sanchez • 3rd+ Passionate about healthcare, sales, and helping others! Health Insurance Specialist | Sales Dev Leader | Sport Enthusiast | Family First 4mo Jonathan Sandhu terrible take Like Reply

Ariel Deschapell • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CPTO Hydra Host | NVIDIA Cloud Partner 4mo Jonathan Sandhu It's both capital leverage and grind. Saying he doesn't have constraints is hilarious. Like Reply

Walter Thornton • 3rd+ AI Implementation Consultant 4mo Jonathan Sandhu a grind is a grind is a grind. Like Reply

Walter Thornton • 3rd+ AI Implementation Consultant 4mo Jonathan Sandhu You can measure anything you want, but work ethic and grinding are independent of everything you said. I'm not saying you're wrong, you're just not talking about grinding or work ethic, you're talking about something else entirely …more Like Reply

Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner 2mo George Hotz yeah saying that Elon doesn't grind is questionable at best. Should teachers get paid more, ABSOLUTELY! But that shouldn't discredit how hard Elon works. Almost everyone who works with him confirms this. There's a reason that so many people consider him a visionary and want to work for him despite already knowing how tough the job will be. You need some level of insanity to be able to pull of what he has. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jonathan Sandhu’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4mo • The level that these people are detached from reality is insane! There's things to critique Elon on, but work ethic?!? Is this ragebait, or does Teresa Leger Fernández (note the accent mark) actually believe this? …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 64 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 4mo Musk’s results come from capital leverage, not personal grind. Teachers work inside constraints, he works with none. Calling that a work ethic comparison ignores the structure that produces the outcomes. …more Like Reply 14 replies 14 Replies on Jonathan Sandhu’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Jonathan Sandhu where are you getting that from? I grind very hard, but I don't think I grind as hard as Elon. ask anyone who has worked with him. there's plenty of rich people to critique like this though, how stupid is it that america taxes capital gains at a lower rate than labor... …more Like Reply Kevin Watson • 3rd+ Flight Computing Lead at The Exploration Company - SpaceX & NASA/JPL Alumnus 4mo You really have no idea what you are talking about here and all you’re doing is raising the noise floor. Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz taxing capital gains have a direct impact on the supply of money, if you think about leverage across brokers, banks and so on, having that deflationary process does not make any sense, will give a prize to those sitting on cash, to steal the ones that invest, so these ideas are terrible for progress …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes more supply of money is bad. remove the income tax. 5x property tax (watch how fast this fixes the housing "crisis") and 50% cap gains. working should be encouraged, not passive investing. also, no sales tax, 1% tax on all transactions (like buying shares), and a sin tax on advertising! basically buying shit and doing work = good, so lower tax on it. some dumbass who inherited $100M shouldn't be able to chill and earn $5M while doing nothing (oh sorry, were they "allocating capital" when they dumped it in a vanguard ETF? i'm sick of this fake narrative. do work or pay tons of tax) …more Like Reply Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 4mo Work-ethic isn’t the raw hours; it’s output per unit of constraint. A teacher ships outcomes inside rigid budgets, rules, and class sizes. Musk ships inside a capital flywheel that multiplies every hour and writes off failures. Compare grind all you want, but if you ratio results by leverage and spend, the school-teacher model looks brutally efficient and the billionaire model burns cash to brute-force scale. Different constraints, different metrics. Measure efficiency, not noise. …more Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz if inflation is bad for housing, try to imagine deflation, who would give credit to someone buy an house that is always decreasing in price? The real estate property tax is fine I guess, because it just forces the owner to rent, but a tax on unrealised stock gains forces owners to sell stocks, and if you imagine the USA as being 4 times leveraged, what will happen if you tax unrealised profits? It's a snowball that would destroy capitalism, everybody being forced to sell, housing credit spreads going to the roof as banks would go bankrupt, a complete meltdown …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 4mo Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes I'm not trying to tax *unrealized* gains, I'm extremely against this; I'm not even sure how you calculate it, and forcing people to sell is bad market manipulation. 1% on all transactions (including sales tax and income and stock purchase) 50% all capital gains (when realized and only when realized, with an added caveat that borrowing against a stock is a realization event at the value of the loan) 5x property tax (lol, prices plummeting is the point. you should never have considered it an investment it's a house for living in and you can still do that, in fact, now more normal people can own homes cause they are affordable and rent seekers are BTFO) 500% tax on advertising (like cigarettes and alcohol) …more Like Reply Arthur M. C. • 3rd+ French/American Founder + Vice President of Research & Development @ Distributed Systems 4mo George Hotz it's by design Like Reply Ivo 👨‍💻 Fernandes • 3rd+ Flutter developer | Investor 4mo George Hotz taxes on realized gains makes total sense! In Portugal is 28% but above a certain amount becomes incorporated in all personal taxes and goes easily to the 50% you said, at least if it is in the personal account, but you can use an holding here that would avoid that huge taxation. About housing prices plummeting, is fine if is an one time event, but if is consistent over time and no one invest on mortgages anymore, how can the normal citizen get credit to buy an house that is priced at 20 years of a normal net salary, if no one invests on mortgages to provide the money upfront? I think the only way capitalism works is with some inflation that forces people to invest, we in Europe experienced a deflation much longer than USA, for us was from 2006 to 2014 and was not fun, credit spreads were extremely high …more Like Reply Miguel Sanchez • 3rd+ Passionate about healthcare, sales, and helping others! Health Insurance Specialist | Sales Dev Leader | Sport Enthusiast | Family First 4mo Jonathan Sandhu terrible take Like Reply Ariel Deschapell • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CPTO Hydra Host | NVIDIA Cloud Partner 4mo Jonathan Sandhu It's both capital leverage and grind. Saying he doesn't have constraints is hilarious. Like Reply Walter Thornton • 3rd+ AI Implementation Consultant 4mo Jonathan Sandhu a grind is a grind is a grind. Like Reply Walter Thornton • 3rd+ AI Implementation Consultant 4mo Jonathan Sandhu You can measure anything you want, but work ethic and grinding are independent of everything you said. I'm not saying you're wrong, you're just not talking about grinding or work ethic, you're talking about something else entirely …more Like Reply Kevin R. • 3rd+ Founder & CEO | Systems Thinker | Life-long Learner 2mo George Hotz yeah saying that Elon doesn't grind is questionable at best. Should teachers get paid more, ABSOLUTELY! But that shouldn't discredit how hard Elon works. Almost everyone who works with him confirms this. There's a reason that so many people consider him a visionary and want to work for him despite already knowing how tough the job will be. You need some level of insanity to be able to pull of what he has. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • Checking in on this 4 years later. Argo and TuSimple are gone. When will the scams stop? …more George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 4yr • When I see Autonomous Vehicle companies doing IPOs, I am so saddened that they are that desperate for their bags that they scam the public out of it. TuSimple did an IPO with less revenue than comma. And now Argo is talking about it. Sad. This is not the way. AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES ARE NOT REAL. YOU ARE A SEED STAGE STARTUP WITH A TECH DEMO. YOU DO NOT EVEN HAVE PRODUCT MARKET FIT, YOU SHOULDN'T BE DOING A FUCKING IPO. Seriously, how did anyone read the financial numbers in this S-1 and invest in this company? In 2020, 1.8 million revenue, 5.2 million cost of revenue, and 132 million in R&D. https://lnkd.in/d8pWEmb …more 4 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 7mo The thing to investigate. How much money did the founders and early investors walk away with? If it's 0, then fine. But I think it's not 0. It's like the captain of the Titanic being retired with a large severance package. …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 7mo The thing to investigate. How much money did the founders and early investors walk away with? If it's 0, then fine. But I think it's not 0. It's like the captain of the Titanic being retired with a large severance package. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James Maniotis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • More technology is not going to bring you a high trust society. If you want a high trust society, it starts with changing culture. …more 48 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo Easy (to say). Now will you name high trust and low trust cultures and what causes them to be classified as such? …more Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo George Hotz haha not willing to get into it publicly? Yes, these stats are well circulated. I've been to almost all of those countries, but guess where I had all of my bicycles stolen? Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis What do you mean? I disagree with both the left and right wing talking points on this. A good culture is where most people produce more than they consume, and also trust that their neighbors do the same. Re: bike theft, I think that would correlate well with that chart, no? …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I would think everyone believes they're above "talking points." What do you think about this? https://guestworkervisas.com/gwv/jobs_direct.php And no, good culture is only about economic output in the amoral libertarian's view. We all produced organs which can be harvested... Since we are looking for cause, not correlation, then I would look a bit deeper than that particular chart. I don't exactly think high level reasoning is required to figure it out, though. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I support work visas for every person who can produce more than they consume. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz We should call the libertarian ideal the "onlyfans market". If it is all about measuring each person's economic "productivity," then you must be all for onlyfans as well. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I don't have a problem with onlyfans. I have a problem with finance, advertising, lawyers, real estate, etc...these "professions" that produce nothing and take a big cut. If two fully consenting adults want to trade money for photos in the privacy of their own internet that doesn't take from society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz And in your international borderless system of trade, how do you define & enforce the "age of consent" to be 18? I realize you're pro-onlyfans, but I hope based on our conversations so far you've realized that you'll have to cure the vast majority of us from our delusions that morality actually exists before these solutions can be widely implemented. We can have "productivity" (capital) as the false idol of our system, or we can seek something higher. And yes, a growing population participating in onlyfans absolutely "takes from society." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis onlyfans takes from society? simps (who might even work in the mooching professions) giving money to entrepreneurial women? sounds like good capital allocation to me! if you don't want onlyfans, it leaves you alone. not true about the other 4 things i listed. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I don't think "entrepreneurial women" is a concept from a mind "left alone" by this sort of thing... I also think there is a positive form of entrepreneurialism within the "finance, advertising, lawyers, [and] real estate" domains, albeit uncommon. …more Like Reply Ben V. • 3rd+ Server shepherd 7mo George Hotz personal experience, suburban alpine Austria has 24/7 mini grocery stores, where you pick what you need from fridges and pay for it, on our Dutch street , neighbors will hold your deliveries for you and vice-versa Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo Easy (to say). Now will you name high trust and low trust cultures and what causes them to be classified as such? …more Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo George Hotz haha not willing to get into it publicly? Yes, these stats are well circulated. I've been to almost all of those countries, but guess where I had all of my bicycles stolen? Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis What do you mean? I disagree with both the left and right wing talking points on this. A good culture is where most people produce more than they consume, and also trust that their neighbors do the same. Re: bike theft, I think that would correlate well with that chart, no? …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I would think everyone believes they're above "talking points." What do you think about this? https://guestworkervisas.com/gwv/jobs_direct.php And no, good culture is only about economic output in the amoral libertarian's view. We all produced organs which can be harvested... Since we are looking for cause, not correlation, then I would look a bit deeper than that particular chart. I don't exactly think high level reasoning is required to figure it out, though. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I support work visas for every person who can produce more than they consume. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz We should call the libertarian ideal the "onlyfans market". If it is all about measuring each person's economic "productivity," then you must be all for onlyfans as well. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I don't have a problem with onlyfans. I have a problem with finance, advertising, lawyers, real estate, etc...these "professions" that produce nothing and take a big cut. If two fully consenting adults want to trade money for photos in the privacy of their own internet that doesn't take from society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz And in your international borderless system of trade, how do you define & enforce the "age of consent" to be 18? I realize you're pro-onlyfans, but I hope based on our conversations so far you've realized that you'll have to cure the vast majority of us from our delusions that morality actually exists before these solutions can be widely implemented. We can have "productivity" (capital) as the false idol of our system, or we can seek something higher. And yes, a growing population participating in onlyfans absolutely "takes from society." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis onlyfans takes from society? simps (who might even work in the mooching professions) giving money to entrepreneurial women? sounds like good capital allocation to me! if you don't want onlyfans, it leaves you alone. not true about the other 4 things i listed. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I don't think "entrepreneurial women" is a concept from a mind "left alone" by this sort of thing... I also think there is a positive form of entrepreneurialism within the "finance, advertising, lawyers, [and] real estate" domains, albeit uncommon. …more Like Reply Ben V. • 3rd+ Server shepherd 7mo George Hotz personal experience, suburban alpine Austria has 24/7 mini grocery stores, where you pick what you need from fridges and pay for it, on our Dutch street , neighbors will hold your deliveries for you and vice-versa Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo George Hotz haha not willing to get into it publicly? Yes, these stats are well circulated. I've been to almost all of those countries, but guess where I had all of my bicycles stolen? Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis What do you mean? I disagree with both the left and right wing talking points on this. A good culture is where most people produce more than they consume, and also trust that their neighbors do the same. Re: bike theft, I think that would correlate well with that chart, no? …more Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I would think everyone believes they're above "talking points." What do you think about this? https://guestworkervisas.com/gwv/jobs_direct.php And no, good culture is only about economic output in the amoral libertarian's view. We all produced organs which can be harvested... Since we are looking for cause, not correlation, then I would look a bit deeper than that particular chart. I don't exactly think high level reasoning is required to figure it out, though. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I support work visas for every person who can produce more than they consume. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz We should call the libertarian ideal the "onlyfans market". If it is all about measuring each person's economic "productivity," then you must be all for onlyfans as well. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply

George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I don't have a problem with onlyfans. I have a problem with finance, advertising, lawyers, real estate, etc...these "professions" that produce nothing and take a big cut. If two fully consenting adults want to trade money for photos in the privacy of their own internet that doesn't take from society. …more Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz And in your international borderless system of trade, how do you define & enforce the "age of consent" to be 18? I realize you're pro-onlyfans, but I hope based on our conversations so far you've realized that you'll have to cure the vast majority of us from our delusions that morality actually exists before these solutions can be widely implemented. We can have "productivity" (capital) as the false idol of our system, or we can seek something higher. And yes, a growing population participating in onlyfans absolutely "takes from society." …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis onlyfans takes from society? simps (who might even work in the mooching professions) giving money to entrepreneurial women? sounds like good capital allocation to me! if you don't want onlyfans, it leaves you alone. not true about the other 4 things i listed. …more Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I don't think "entrepreneurial women" is a concept from a mind "left alone" by this sort of thing... I also think there is a positive form of entrepreneurialism within the "finance, advertising, lawyers, [and] real estate" domains, albeit uncommon. …more Like Reply

Ben V. • 3rd+ Server shepherd 7mo George Hotz personal experience, suburban alpine Austria has 24/7 mini grocery stores, where you pick what you need from fridges and pay for it, on our Dutch street , neighbors will hold your deliveries for you and vice-versa Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James Maniotis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • More technology is not going to bring you a high trust society. If you want a high trust society, it starts with changing culture. …more 48 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo Easy (to say). Now will you name high trust and low trust cultures and what causes them to be classified as such? …more Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo George Hotz haha not willing to get into it publicly? Yes, these stats are well circulated. I've been to almost all of those countries, but guess where I had all of my bicycles stolen? Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis What do you mean? I disagree with both the left and right wing talking points on this. A good culture is where most people produce more than they consume, and also trust that their neighbors do the same. Re: bike theft, I think that would correlate well with that chart, no? …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I would think everyone believes they're above "talking points." What do you think about this? https://guestworkervisas.com/gwv/jobs_direct.php And no, good culture is only about economic output in the amoral libertarian's view. We all produced organs which can be harvested... Since we are looking for cause, not correlation, then I would look a bit deeper than that particular chart. I don't exactly think high level reasoning is required to figure it out, though. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I support work visas for every person who can produce more than they consume. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz We should call the libertarian ideal the "onlyfans market". If it is all about measuring each person's economic "productivity," then you must be all for onlyfans as well. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I don't have a problem with onlyfans. I have a problem with finance, advertising, lawyers, real estate, etc...these "professions" that produce nothing and take a big cut. If two fully consenting adults want to trade money for photos in the privacy of their own internet that doesn't take from society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz And in your international borderless system of trade, how do you define & enforce the "age of consent" to be 18? I realize you're pro-onlyfans, but I hope based on our conversations so far you've realized that you'll have to cure the vast majority of us from our delusions that morality actually exists before these solutions can be widely implemented. We can have "productivity" (capital) as the false idol of our system, or we can seek something higher. And yes, a growing population participating in onlyfans absolutely "takes from society." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis onlyfans takes from society? simps (who might even work in the mooching professions) giving money to entrepreneurial women? sounds like good capital allocation to me! if you don't want onlyfans, it leaves you alone. not true about the other 4 things i listed. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I don't think "entrepreneurial women" is a concept from a mind "left alone" by this sort of thing... I also think there is a positive form of entrepreneurialism within the "finance, advertising, lawyers, [and] real estate" domains, albeit uncommon. …more Like Reply Ben V. • 3rd+ Server shepherd 7mo George Hotz personal experience, suburban alpine Austria has 24/7 mini grocery stores, where you pick what you need from fridges and pay for it, on our Dutch street , neighbors will hold your deliveries for you and vice-versa Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Pulkit ..’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • More technology is not going to bring you a high trust society. If you want a high trust society, it starts with changing culture. …more 48 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Pulkit .. • 3rd+ Staff Machine Learning Engineer (edited) 7mo changing culture takes time … and it’s difficult sithout the help of technology.. Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Pulkit ..’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo Pulkit ... So does building a high trust society. Start small by shaming a private equity or real estate person today. However, the shame has to come from a place of caring about society and wanting to see it be better And it has nothing at all to do with technology. Societies have spanned the full trust gap throughout history. …more Like Reply Pulkit .. • 3rd+ Staff Machine Learning Engineer 7mo George Hotz sorry i don’t see how shaming helps , maybe accountability and holding people accountable might help. Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo Pulkit ... Nope, we need shame. If you are mooch on society, you should feel bad about yourself. Want to feel good? Produce value. Like Reply Fareesh Vijayarangam • 3rd+ Co-Founder at Mentza / IntEm Labs 7mo …more Like Reply Matt Suiche • 3rd+ Building the missing infrastructure between proprietary data and AI agents. 7mo George Hotz did you follow the whole Shaun Macguire/Sequoia thing? Shame doesn’t work on shameless people. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Pulkit .. • 3rd+ Staff Machine Learning Engineer (edited) 7mo changing culture takes time … and it’s difficult sithout the help of technology.. Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Pulkit ..’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo Pulkit ... So does building a high trust society. Start small by shaming a private equity or real estate person today. However, the shame has to come from a place of caring about society and wanting to see it be better And it has nothing at all to do with technology. Societies have spanned the full trust gap throughout history. …more Like Reply Pulkit .. • 3rd+ Staff Machine Learning Engineer 7mo George Hotz sorry i don’t see how shaming helps , maybe accountability and holding people accountable might help. Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo Pulkit ... Nope, we need shame. If you are mooch on society, you should feel bad about yourself. Want to feel good? Produce value. Like Reply Fareesh Vijayarangam • 3rd+ Co-Founder at Mentza / IntEm Labs 7mo …more Like Reply Matt Suiche • 3rd+ Building the missing infrastructure between proprietary data and AI agents. 7mo George Hotz did you follow the whole Shaun Macguire/Sequoia thing? Shame doesn’t work on shameless people. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo Pulkit ... So does building a high trust society. Start small by shaming a private equity or real estate person today. However, the shame has to come from a place of caring about society and wanting to see it be better And it has nothing at all to do with technology. Societies have spanned the full trust gap throughout history. …more Like Reply

Pulkit .. • 3rd+ Staff Machine Learning Engineer 7mo George Hotz sorry i don’t see how shaming helps , maybe accountability and holding people accountable might help. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 7mo Pulkit ... Nope, we need shame. If you are mooch on society, you should feel bad about yourself. Want to feel good? Produce value. Like Reply

Fareesh Vijayarangam • 3rd+ Co-Founder at Mentza / IntEm Labs 7mo …more Like Reply

Matt Suiche • 3rd+ Building the missing infrastructure between proprietary data and AI agents. 7mo George Hotz did you follow the whole Shaun Macguire/Sequoia thing? Shame doesn’t work on shameless people. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James Maniotis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • More technology is not going to bring you a high trust society. If you want a high trust society, it starts with changing culture. …more 48 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo Easy (to say). Now will you name high trust and low trust cultures and what causes them to be classified as such? …more Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo George Hotz haha not willing to get into it publicly? Yes, these stats are well circulated. I've been to almost all of those countries, but guess where I had all of my bicycles stolen? Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis What do you mean? I disagree with both the left and right wing talking points on this. A good culture is where most people produce more than they consume, and also trust that their neighbors do the same. Re: bike theft, I think that would correlate well with that chart, no? …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I would think everyone believes they're above "talking points." What do you think about this? https://guestworkervisas.com/gwv/jobs_direct.php And no, good culture is only about economic output in the amoral libertarian's view. We all produced organs which can be harvested... Since we are looking for cause, not correlation, then I would look a bit deeper than that particular chart. I don't exactly think high level reasoning is required to figure it out, though. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I support work visas for every person who can produce more than they consume. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz We should call the libertarian ideal the "onlyfans market". If it is all about measuring each person's economic "productivity," then you must be all for onlyfans as well. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I don't have a problem with onlyfans. I have a problem with finance, advertising, lawyers, real estate, etc...these "professions" that produce nothing and take a big cut. If two fully consenting adults want to trade money for photos in the privacy of their own internet that doesn't take from society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz And in your international borderless system of trade, how do you define & enforce the "age of consent" to be 18? I realize you're pro-onlyfans, but I hope based on our conversations so far you've realized that you'll have to cure the vast majority of us from our delusions that morality actually exists before these solutions can be widely implemented. We can have "productivity" (capital) as the false idol of our system, or we can seek something higher. And yes, a growing population participating in onlyfans absolutely "takes from society." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis onlyfans takes from society? simps (who might even work in the mooching professions) giving money to entrepreneurial women? sounds like good capital allocation to me! if you don't want onlyfans, it leaves you alone. not true about the other 4 things i listed. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I don't think "entrepreneurial women" is a concept from a mind "left alone" by this sort of thing... I also think there is a positive form of entrepreneurialism within the "finance, advertising, lawyers, [and] real estate" domains, albeit uncommon. …more Like Reply Ben V. • 3rd+ Server shepherd 7mo George Hotz personal experience, suburban alpine Austria has 24/7 mini grocery stores, where you pick what you need from fridges and pay for it, on our Dutch street , neighbors will hold your deliveries for you and vice-versa Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Cody Avant, CPCU’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • More technology is not going to bring you a high trust society. If you want a high trust society, it starts with changing culture. …more 48 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Cody Avant, CPCU • 3rd+ Underwriting Technical Assistant at Ryan Specialty 7mo Tort reform / banning tip screens would accomplish 50% of job. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Cody Avant, CPCU’s comment George Hotz Author 7mo Cody Avant, CPCU Agreed that those changes would be great starts! But you really want to change the mindset of the people who push tip screens and stupid lawsuits. Politics is downstream of culture. Like Reply Load more comments

Cody Avant, CPCU • 3rd+ Underwriting Technical Assistant at Ryan Specialty 7mo Tort reform / banning tip screens would accomplish 50% of job. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Cody Avant, CPCU’s comment George Hotz Author 7mo Cody Avant, CPCU Agreed that those changes would be great starts! But you really want to change the mindset of the people who push tip screens and stupid lawsuits. Politics is downstream of culture. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 7mo Cody Avant, CPCU Agreed that those changes would be great starts! But you really want to change the mindset of the people who push tip screens and stupid lawsuits. Politics is downstream of culture. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James Maniotis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • More technology is not going to bring you a high trust society. If you want a high trust society, it starts with changing culture. …more 48 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo Easy (to say). Now will you name high trust and low trust cultures and what causes them to be classified as such? …more Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo George Hotz haha not willing to get into it publicly? Yes, these stats are well circulated. I've been to almost all of those countries, but guess where I had all of my bicycles stolen? Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis What do you mean? I disagree with both the left and right wing talking points on this. A good culture is where most people produce more than they consume, and also trust that their neighbors do the same. Re: bike theft, I think that would correlate well with that chart, no? …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I would think everyone believes they're above "talking points." What do you think about this? https://guestworkervisas.com/gwv/jobs_direct.php And no, good culture is only about economic output in the amoral libertarian's view. We all produced organs which can be harvested... Since we are looking for cause, not correlation, then I would look a bit deeper than that particular chart. I don't exactly think high level reasoning is required to figure it out, though. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I support work visas for every person who can produce more than they consume. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz We should call the libertarian ideal the "onlyfans market". If it is all about measuring each person's economic "productivity," then you must be all for onlyfans as well. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I don't have a problem with onlyfans. I have a problem with finance, advertising, lawyers, real estate, etc...these "professions" that produce nothing and take a big cut. If two fully consenting adults want to trade money for photos in the privacy of their own internet that doesn't take from society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz And in your international borderless system of trade, how do you define & enforce the "age of consent" to be 18? I realize you're pro-onlyfans, but I hope based on our conversations so far you've realized that you'll have to cure the vast majority of us from our delusions that morality actually exists before these solutions can be widely implemented. We can have "productivity" (capital) as the false idol of our system, or we can seek something higher. And yes, a growing population participating in onlyfans absolutely "takes from society." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis onlyfans takes from society? simps (who might even work in the mooching professions) giving money to entrepreneurial women? sounds like good capital allocation to me! if you don't want onlyfans, it leaves you alone. not true about the other 4 things i listed. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I don't think "entrepreneurial women" is a concept from a mind "left alone" by this sort of thing... I also think there is a positive form of entrepreneurialism within the "finance, advertising, lawyers, [and] real estate" domains, albeit uncommon. …more Like Reply Ben V. • 3rd+ Server shepherd 7mo George Hotz personal experience, suburban alpine Austria has 24/7 mini grocery stores, where you pick what you need from fridges and pay for it, on our Dutch street , neighbors will hold your deliveries for you and vice-versa Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James Maniotis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • More technology is not going to bring you a high trust society. If you want a high trust society, it starts with changing culture. …more 48 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo Easy (to say). Now will you name high trust and low trust cultures and what causes them to be classified as such? …more Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses (edited) 7mo George Hotz haha not willing to get into it publicly? Yes, these stats are well circulated. I've been to almost all of those countries, but guess where I had all of my bicycles stolen? Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis What do you mean? I disagree with both the left and right wing talking points on this. A good culture is where most people produce more than they consume, and also trust that their neighbors do the same. Re: bike theft, I think that would correlate well with that chart, no? …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I would think everyone believes they're above "talking points." What do you think about this? https://guestworkervisas.com/gwv/jobs_direct.php And no, good culture is only about economic output in the amoral libertarian's view. We all produced organs which can be harvested... Since we are looking for cause, not correlation, then I would look a bit deeper than that particular chart. I don't exactly think high level reasoning is required to figure it out, though. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I support work visas for every person who can produce more than they consume. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz We should call the libertarian ideal the "onlyfans market". If it is all about measuring each person's economic "productivity," then you must be all for onlyfans as well. Great for tax revenue! Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo James Maniotis I don't have a problem with onlyfans. I have a problem with finance, advertising, lawyers, real estate, etc...these "professions" that produce nothing and take a big cut. If two fully consenting adults want to trade money for photos in the privacy of their own internet that doesn't take from society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz And in your international borderless system of trade, how do you define & enforce the "age of consent" to be 18? I realize you're pro-onlyfans, but I hope based on our conversations so far you've realized that you'll have to cure the vast majority of us from our delusions that morality actually exists before these solutions can be widely implemented. We can have "productivity" (capital) as the false idol of our system, or we can seek something higher. And yes, a growing population participating in onlyfans absolutely "takes from society." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo James Maniotis onlyfans takes from society? simps (who might even work in the mooching professions) giving money to entrepreneurial women? sounds like good capital allocation to me! if you don't want onlyfans, it leaves you alone. not true about the other 4 things i listed. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 7mo George Hotz I don't think "entrepreneurial women" is a concept from a mind "left alone" by this sort of thing... I also think there is a positive form of entrepreneurialism within the "finance, advertising, lawyers, [and] real estate" domains, albeit uncommon. …more Like Reply Ben V. • 3rd+ Server shepherd 7mo George Hotz personal experience, suburban alpine Austria has 24/7 mini grocery stores, where you pick what you need from fridges and pay for it, on our Dutch street , neighbors will hold your deliveries for you and vice-versa Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Pulkit ..’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • More technology is not going to bring you a high trust society. If you want a high trust society, it starts with changing culture. …more 48 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Pulkit .. • 3rd+ Staff Machine Learning Engineer (edited) 7mo changing culture takes time … and it’s difficult sithout the help of technology.. Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Pulkit ..’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 7mo Pulkit ... So does building a high trust society. Start small by shaming a private equity or real estate person today. However, the shame has to come from a place of caring about society and wanting to see it be better And it has nothing at all to do with technology. Societies have spanned the full trust gap throughout history. …more Like Reply Pulkit .. • 3rd+ Staff Machine Learning Engineer 7mo George Hotz sorry i don’t see how shaming helps , maybe accountability and holding people accountable might help. Like Reply George Hotz Author 7mo Pulkit ... Nope, we need shame. If you are mooch on society, you should feel bad about yourself. Want to feel good? Produce value. Like Reply Fareesh Vijayarangam • 3rd+ Co-Founder at Mentza / IntEm Labs 7mo …more Like Reply Matt Suiche • 3rd+ Building the missing infrastructure between proprietary data and AI agents. 7mo George Hotz did you follow the whole Shaun Macguire/Sequoia thing? Shame doesn’t work on shameless people. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Enrique Monroy’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • Today I am going to educate you about the three types of partnerships. 1. The first type is a joint PR exercise. Two companies shove their logos in your face. Press releases are published. Nothing happens. It is like advertising, but stupider. This type of partnership is dumb. 2. The second type is when you give them money. This type is obviously bad, cause you don't have any money. Avoid this partnership type. You lose money. 3. The third type is when they give you money. This is a good partnership. You end up with money, which you can then spend on things like erector sets and ice cream. This is the type of partnership you should be optimizing for. Are you aiming for the third type of partnership in your business negotiations? Let me know in the comments. …more 30 comments 7 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Enrique Monroy • 3rd+ IBM O2C - SAP Master Data Analyst 7mo this was not on my linkedin premium negotiation course :( Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Enrique Monroy’s comment George Hotz Author 7mo Enrique Monroy Ahh, because I assume that course was the second type of partnership. Like Reply Enrique Monroy • 3rd+ IBM O2C - SAP Master Data Analyst 7mo thats not great. should have taken the course on how to deliver value to stakeholders using ai powered tools instead Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Enrique Monroy • 3rd+ IBM O2C - SAP Master Data Analyst 7mo this was not on my linkedin premium negotiation course :( Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Enrique Monroy’s comment George Hotz Author 7mo Enrique Monroy Ahh, because I assume that course was the second type of partnership. Like Reply Enrique Monroy • 3rd+ IBM O2C - SAP Master Data Analyst 7mo thats not great. should have taken the course on how to deliver value to stakeholders using ai powered tools instead Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 7mo Enrique Monroy Ahh, because I assume that course was the second type of partnership. Like Reply

Enrique Monroy • 3rd+ IBM O2C - SAP Master Data Analyst 7mo thats not great. should have taken the course on how to deliver value to stakeholders using ai powered tools instead Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Nick Orie’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • Today I am going to educate you about the three types of partnerships. 1. The first type is a joint PR exercise. Two companies shove their logos in your face. Press releases are published. Nothing happens. It is like advertising, but stupider. This type of partnership is dumb. 2. The second type is when you give them money. This type is obviously bad, cause you don't have any money. Avoid this partnership type. You lose money. 3. The third type is when they give you money. This is a good partnership. You end up with money, which you can then spend on things like erector sets and ice cream. This is the type of partnership you should be optimizing for. Are you aiming for the third type of partnership in your business negotiations? Let me know in the comments. …more 30 comments 7 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Nick Orie • 3rd+ art critic & classically trained pianist 7mo Id recommend a train set instead; it could be run around your office. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Nick Orie’s comment George Hotz Author 7mo Nick Orie I had Lionel growing up. Praying for the third type of partnership to come soon so I can buy some trainssssss Like Reply Load more comments

Nick Orie • 3rd+ art critic & classically trained pianist 7mo Id recommend a train set instead; it could be run around your office. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Nick Orie’s comment George Hotz Author 7mo Nick Orie I had Lionel growing up. Praying for the third type of partnership to come soon so I can buy some trainssssss Like Reply

George Hotz Author 7mo Nick Orie I had Lionel growing up. Praying for the third type of partnership to come soon so I can buy some trainssssss Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Tan Kwang Hui’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 7mo • Today I am going to educate you about the three types of partnerships. 1. The first type is a joint PR exercise. Two companies shove their logos in your face. Press releases are published. Nothing happens. It is like advertising, but stupider. This type of partnership is dumb. 2. The second type is when you give them money. This type is obviously bad, cause you don't have any money. Avoid this partnership type. You lose money. 3. The third type is when they give you money. This is a good partnership. You end up with money, which you can then spend on things like erector sets and ice cream. This is the type of partnership you should be optimizing for. Are you aiming for the third type of partnership in your business negotiations? Let me know in the comments. …more 30 comments 7 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Tan Kwang Hui • 3rd+ Mobility Deeptech GTM 7mo There is a 4th type George Hotz : Both parties contribute jointly ($$$ & or Manpower) to form a business case and jointly acquire a Customer. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Tan Kwang Hui’s comment George Hotz Author 7mo Tan Kwang Hui Ahh, so like when the Power Rangers come together to form a Megazord, but it's instead to combine their business powers to fleece a sucker out of money. Based. Like Reply Cal Day Ham • 3rd+ Sc.B. in Cellular & Organismal Physiology. 7mo George Hotz someone hurt you recently, isn’t every time you hire an employee sort of like the second type of partnership? Yet you’re asking for great single-person companies to take your money all the time. I get the more nuanced point of creating value and therefore organizations come to you to be their lever of production, that said I think you’re getting a bit lost in your own lack of nuance. Also just to be clear your posts typically compose 80% of the reasons for why I open this app, more of a fan than a hater. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Tan Kwang Hui • 3rd+ Mobility Deeptech GTM 7mo There is a 4th type George Hotz : Both parties contribute jointly ($$$ & or Manpower) to form a business case and jointly acquire a Customer. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Tan Kwang Hui’s comment George Hotz Author 7mo Tan Kwang Hui Ahh, so like when the Power Rangers come together to form a Megazord, but it's instead to combine their business powers to fleece a sucker out of money. Based. Like Reply Cal Day Ham • 3rd+ Sc.B. in Cellular & Organismal Physiology. 7mo George Hotz someone hurt you recently, isn’t every time you hire an employee sort of like the second type of partnership? Yet you’re asking for great single-person companies to take your money all the time. I get the more nuanced point of creating value and therefore organizations come to you to be their lever of production, that said I think you’re getting a bit lost in your own lack of nuance. Also just to be clear your posts typically compose 80% of the reasons for why I open this app, more of a fan than a hater. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 7mo Tan Kwang Hui Ahh, so like when the Power Rangers come together to form a Megazord, but it's instead to combine their business powers to fleece a sucker out of money. Based. Like Reply

Cal Day Ham • 3rd+ Sc.B. in Cellular & Organismal Physiology. 7mo George Hotz someone hurt you recently, isn’t every time you hire an employee sort of like the second type of partnership? Yet you’re asking for great single-person companies to take your money all the time. I get the more nuanced point of creating value and therefore organizations come to you to be their lever of production, that said I think you’re getting a bit lost in your own lack of nuance. Also just to be clear your posts typically compose 80% of the reasons for why I open this app, more of a fan than a hater. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Tommy C.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • ugh gemini isn't good Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 54 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Tommy C. • 3rd+ Red Hat Sales Specialist | OpenShift Expert| Driving Digital Transformation and Hybrid Cloud Microservices adoption 8mo Hmmm Gemini did discuss 3 Rs with you lol, out of context-ly Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Tommy C.’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo the chat is wrong on so many levels. would you want this thing doing your tax returns? Like Reply Tommy C. • 3rd+ Red Hat Sales Specialist | OpenShift Expert| Driving Digital Transformation and Hybrid Cloud Microservices adoption 8mo George Hotz I don’t even trust my tax accountant…. 🤣🤣🤣 Like Reply Christian Gschwandtner • 3rd+ Logistics Analyst @ MSC Austria 8mo George Hotz would be good to connect LLMs with things like Wolfram for this type of inquiries Like Reply Christian Uebber • 3rd+ Robotics CTO - ❤️ humans 8mo George Hotz No, but I had Gemini write me a tax return reporting software and that worked amazingly well. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Tommy C. • 3rd+ Red Hat Sales Specialist | OpenShift Expert| Driving Digital Transformation and Hybrid Cloud Microservices adoption 8mo Hmmm Gemini did discuss 3 Rs with you lol, out of context-ly Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Tommy C.’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo the chat is wrong on so many levels. would you want this thing doing your tax returns? Like Reply Tommy C. • 3rd+ Red Hat Sales Specialist | OpenShift Expert| Driving Digital Transformation and Hybrid Cloud Microservices adoption 8mo George Hotz I don’t even trust my tax accountant…. 🤣🤣🤣 Like Reply Christian Gschwandtner • 3rd+ Logistics Analyst @ MSC Austria 8mo George Hotz would be good to connect LLMs with things like Wolfram for this type of inquiries Like Reply Christian Uebber • 3rd+ Robotics CTO - ❤️ humans 8mo George Hotz No, but I had Gemini write me a tax return reporting software and that worked amazingly well. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 8mo the chat is wrong on so many levels. would you want this thing doing your tax returns? Like Reply

Tommy C. • 3rd+ Red Hat Sales Specialist | OpenShift Expert| Driving Digital Transformation and Hybrid Cloud Microservices adoption 8mo George Hotz I don’t even trust my tax accountant…. 🤣🤣🤣 Like Reply

Christian Gschwandtner • 3rd+ Logistics Analyst @ MSC Austria 8mo George Hotz would be good to connect LLMs with things like Wolfram for this type of inquiries Like Reply

Christian Uebber • 3rd+ Robotics CTO - ❤️ humans 8mo George Hotz No, but I had Gemini write me a tax return reporting software and that worked amazingly well. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • ugh gemini isn't good Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 54 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo i miss o3. is grok actually the best model now? Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Maxim Khailo • 3rd+ Chief Exponent Officer 7mo George Hotz The problem with grok is the insane amount of tokens it spits out for simple answers. On paper looks cheaper but then if it takes 10 to 100x more tokens to produce the same answer it's bad. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo i miss o3. is grok actually the best model now? Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Maxim Khailo • 3rd+ Chief Exponent Officer 7mo George Hotz The problem with grok is the insane amount of tokens it spits out for simple answers. On paper looks cheaper but then if it takes 10 to 100x more tokens to produce the same answer it's bad. Like Reply

Maxim Khailo • 3rd+ Chief Exponent Officer 7mo George Hotz The problem with grok is the insane amount of tokens it spits out for simple answers. On paper looks cheaper but then if it takes 10 to 100x more tokens to produce the same answer it's bad. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to John Wilson’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send John Wilson • 3rd+ Helping Comms & Marketing Teams Get More Out of Their Videos | Partnerships @ Arbor | ex-Google 8mo George Hotz without sales or marketing/advertising how does a customer find the amazing product that you are building? Referrals + PLG are great but more complex products still feel like you need a human (salesperson) to help guide a customer to a decisions. genuinely curious to hear your perspective. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on John Wilson’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo I don't even know what PLG means. This is an awful way to think, "guide a customer to a decisions" i want to vomit a lil. If people aren't finding it, your product isn't good enough. Make it better. If people still aren't finding it, continue to make it better. Once it's good enough, people will find it. …more Like Reply John Wilson • 3rd+ Helping Comms & Marketing Teams Get More Out of Their Videos | Partnerships @ Arbor | ex-Google 8mo George Hotz PLG = product-led growth. agreed that great products solve most problems. what role at Comma is responsible for your website/ blog / youtube / social accounts? I buy the idea that you don't need a pure 'sales / advertising' role, but someone on your team is owning a marketing function for your product. Does that responsibility just fall under operations in your mind? …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo yea what why would there be an acronym for that? the website is part of the product. social is done by employees for fun with no expectation of return, like how normal people do social media. only psychopaths do it with expectation of return. nobody is "owning a marketing function" like what's up with these phrases who talks like that? im finna guide a customer to the decision of owning a marketing function type beat …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

John Wilson • 3rd+ Helping Comms & Marketing Teams Get More Out of Their Videos | Partnerships @ Arbor | ex-Google 8mo George Hotz without sales or marketing/advertising how does a customer find the amazing product that you are building? Referrals + PLG are great but more complex products still feel like you need a human (salesperson) to help guide a customer to a decisions. genuinely curious to hear your perspective. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on John Wilson’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo I don't even know what PLG means. This is an awful way to think, "guide a customer to a decisions" i want to vomit a lil. If people aren't finding it, your product isn't good enough. Make it better. If people still aren't finding it, continue to make it better. Once it's good enough, people will find it. …more Like Reply John Wilson • 3rd+ Helping Comms & Marketing Teams Get More Out of Their Videos | Partnerships @ Arbor | ex-Google 8mo George Hotz PLG = product-led growth. agreed that great products solve most problems. what role at Comma is responsible for your website/ blog / youtube / social accounts? I buy the idea that you don't need a pure 'sales / advertising' role, but someone on your team is owning a marketing function for your product. Does that responsibility just fall under operations in your mind? …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo yea what why would there be an acronym for that? the website is part of the product. social is done by employees for fun with no expectation of return, like how normal people do social media. only psychopaths do it with expectation of return. nobody is "owning a marketing function" like what's up with these phrases who talks like that? im finna guide a customer to the decision of owning a marketing function type beat …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 8mo I don't even know what PLG means. This is an awful way to think, "guide a customer to a decisions" i want to vomit a lil. If people aren't finding it, your product isn't good enough. Make it better. If people still aren't finding it, continue to make it better. Once it's good enough, people will find it. …more Like Reply

John Wilson • 3rd+ Helping Comms & Marketing Teams Get More Out of Their Videos | Partnerships @ Arbor | ex-Google 8mo George Hotz PLG = product-led growth. agreed that great products solve most problems. what role at Comma is responsible for your website/ blog / youtube / social accounts? I buy the idea that you don't need a pure 'sales / advertising' role, but someone on your team is owning a marketing function for your product. Does that responsibility just fall under operations in your mind? …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo yea what why would there be an acronym for that? the website is part of the product. social is done by employees for fun with no expectation of return, like how normal people do social media. only psychopaths do it with expectation of return. nobody is "owning a marketing function" like what's up with these phrases who talks like that? im finna guide a customer to the decision of owning a marketing function type beat …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to their own comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Edited • Could OpenAI just bring o3 back? GPT-5 feels worse. Which one are you using? Is it time to switch? Update: I downgraded to Plus. Not paying $200 for this. Why would they remove all the old models is this some enshittification? Update 2: I'm a Google AI subscriber. Gemini 2.5 Pro is better than GPT-5, GPT-5 feels like 4o quality tbh idk how https://lnkd.in/g2WMJrnf has it so high. https://lnkd.in/gt6snFJb knows the truth. Update gemini is bad idk how this model is so highly rated on things. https://lnkd.in/gmViFJdc Update 3: Got a full refund for my $200/mo subscription. I really can't believe they removed the other models like that. Makes no sense. Why didn't they leave them around and track usage, then remove when usage was low? …more 110 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 8mo I'm actually really upset right now. I don't have o3 anymore and I really don't like this model. Why did they take it away? 😢 …more Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Murodjon Makhmudov • 3rd+ SWE @ DanAds | IUT Alumni | Building speaktalent.app | Drone enthusiast (edited) 8mo George Hotz You can use inside the Cursor, if you want. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 8mo I'm actually really upset right now. I don't have o3 anymore and I really don't like this model. Why did they take it away? 😢 …more Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Murodjon Makhmudov • 3rd+ SWE @ DanAds | IUT Alumni | Building speaktalent.app | Drone enthusiast (edited) 8mo George Hotz You can use inside the Cursor, if you want. Like Reply

Murodjon Makhmudov • 3rd+ SWE @ DanAds | IUT Alumni | Building speaktalent.app | Drone enthusiast (edited) 8mo George Hotz You can use inside the Cursor, if you want. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to John Wilson’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send John Wilson • 3rd+ Helping Comms & Marketing Teams Get More Out of Their Videos | Partnerships @ Arbor | ex-Google 8mo George Hotz without sales or marketing/advertising how does a customer find the amazing product that you are building? Referrals + PLG are great but more complex products still feel like you need a human (salesperson) to help guide a customer to a decisions. genuinely curious to hear your perspective. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on John Wilson’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo I don't even know what PLG means. This is an awful way to think, "guide a customer to a decisions" i want to vomit a lil. If people aren't finding it, your product isn't good enough. Make it better. If people still aren't finding it, continue to make it better. Once it's good enough, people will find it. …more Like Reply John Wilson • 3rd+ Helping Comms & Marketing Teams Get More Out of Their Videos | Partnerships @ Arbor | ex-Google 8mo George Hotz PLG = product-led growth. agreed that great products solve most problems. what role at Comma is responsible for your website/ blog / youtube / social accounts? I buy the idea that you don't need a pure 'sales / advertising' role, but someone on your team is owning a marketing function for your product. Does that responsibility just fall under operations in your mind? …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo yea what why would there be an acronym for that? the website is part of the product. social is done by employees for fun with no expectation of return, like how normal people do social media. only psychopaths do it with expectation of return. nobody is "owning a marketing function" like what's up with these phrases who talks like that? im finna guide a customer to the decision of owning a marketing function type beat …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Edited • Could OpenAI just bring o3 back? GPT-5 feels worse. Which one are you using? Is it time to switch? Update: I downgraded to Plus. Not paying $200 for this. Why would they remove all the old models is this some enshittification? Update 2: I'm a Google AI subscriber. Gemini 2.5 Pro is better than GPT-5, GPT-5 feels like 4o quality tbh idk how https://lnkd.in/g2WMJrnf has it so high. https://lnkd.in/gt6snFJb knows the truth. Update gemini is bad idk how this model is so highly rated on things. https://lnkd.in/gmViFJdc Update 3: Got a full refund for my $200/mo subscription. I really can't believe they removed the other models like that. Makes no sense. Why didn't they leave them around and track usage, then remove when usage was low? …more 110 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 8mo Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James Maniotis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo Medical and legal and political sectors somehow missing from the top of your list there Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo James Maniotis Sadly this is a lot more nuanced. The jobs above I listed above can go away tomorrow and everyone would be immediately better off. With those three, there is some good, and it's harder to separate the good from the bad. Though I agree that major changes are required to those, but for simplicity of a moral narrative it's simpler to stick with things like advertising which just should be illegal. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz Aren't you *selling* car automation we don't *need* at all. Isn't that a fact at this point? I realize most people can't see the nuance of the 3rd most common cause of death according to the CDC being "medical intervention." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Nobody *needs* any of this, that isn't the bar. If you want to sell petrified wood keychains on etsy by all means do so and feel good while you do it! The bar is simply not extracting value from others and society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz My point is that your heuristic for "not extracting value from others and society" is your own and undefined from the perspective of any other keen mind. Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo James Maniotis No it's not, it's quite well defined. Imagine the counterfactual world where people take my advice and leave extractive jobs in exchange for productive ones. Is that society better or worse in 20 years? Of course there's some subjectivity to better or worse, but not *that* much. A simple example, imagine every real estate agent went into construction instead. These people know they are robbing the future. It's time society start to recognize what they are doing and make it clear that it isn't okay. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz You also say stuff like money is fake, but you don't act like it is at all. Some of us who have studied this get what you seem to be trying to communicate. We know what fiat is, what inflation is, what military backed fiat is etc... But we also know what literal fake money is. Precise speech is important. Now you're using the term "wealth" - but how do you measure it? There's quite a lot of subtext here to just state that people who work in real estate should go away and society would be better - but people who make software car automation are fine. Someone who buys, lives in, and flips a home is a productive and useful member of society and who is also a member of the real estate sector. I know nothing of your moral and ethical code, so it would make no sense for me to answer "is that society better or worse in 20 years" based only on what you wrote above. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo Medical and legal and political sectors somehow missing from the top of your list there Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo James Maniotis Sadly this is a lot more nuanced. The jobs above I listed above can go away tomorrow and everyone would be immediately better off. With those three, there is some good, and it's harder to separate the good from the bad. Though I agree that major changes are required to those, but for simplicity of a moral narrative it's simpler to stick with things like advertising which just should be illegal. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz Aren't you *selling* car automation we don't *need* at all. Isn't that a fact at this point? I realize most people can't see the nuance of the 3rd most common cause of death according to the CDC being "medical intervention." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Nobody *needs* any of this, that isn't the bar. If you want to sell petrified wood keychains on etsy by all means do so and feel good while you do it! The bar is simply not extracting value from others and society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz My point is that your heuristic for "not extracting value from others and society" is your own and undefined from the perspective of any other keen mind. Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo James Maniotis No it's not, it's quite well defined. Imagine the counterfactual world where people take my advice and leave extractive jobs in exchange for productive ones. Is that society better or worse in 20 years? Of course there's some subjectivity to better or worse, but not *that* much. A simple example, imagine every real estate agent went into construction instead. These people know they are robbing the future. It's time society start to recognize what they are doing and make it clear that it isn't okay. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz You also say stuff like money is fake, but you don't act like it is at all. Some of us who have studied this get what you seem to be trying to communicate. We know what fiat is, what inflation is, what military backed fiat is etc... But we also know what literal fake money is. Precise speech is important. Now you're using the term "wealth" - but how do you measure it? There's quite a lot of subtext here to just state that people who work in real estate should go away and society would be better - but people who make software car automation are fine. Someone who buys, lives in, and flips a home is a productive and useful member of society and who is also a member of the real estate sector. I know nothing of your moral and ethical code, so it would make no sense for me to answer "is that society better or worse in 20 years" based only on what you wrote above. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo James Maniotis Sadly this is a lot more nuanced. The jobs above I listed above can go away tomorrow and everyone would be immediately better off. With those three, there is some good, and it's harder to separate the good from the bad. Though I agree that major changes are required to those, but for simplicity of a moral narrative it's simpler to stick with things like advertising which just should be illegal. …more Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz Aren't you *selling* car automation we don't *need* at all. Isn't that a fact at this point? I realize most people can't see the nuance of the 3rd most common cause of death according to the CDC being "medical intervention." …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Nobody *needs* any of this, that isn't the bar. If you want to sell petrified wood keychains on etsy by all means do so and feel good while you do it! The bar is simply not extracting value from others and society. …more Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz My point is that your heuristic for "not extracting value from others and society" is your own and undefined from the perspective of any other keen mind. Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo James Maniotis No it's not, it's quite well defined. Imagine the counterfactual world where people take my advice and leave extractive jobs in exchange for productive ones. Is that society better or worse in 20 years? Of course there's some subjectivity to better or worse, but not *that* much. A simple example, imagine every real estate agent went into construction instead. These people know they are robbing the future. It's time society start to recognize what they are doing and make it clear that it isn't okay. …more Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz You also say stuff like money is fake, but you don't act like it is at all. Some of us who have studied this get what you seem to be trying to communicate. We know what fiat is, what inflation is, what military backed fiat is etc... But we also know what literal fake money is. Precise speech is important. Now you're using the term "wealth" - but how do you measure it? There's quite a lot of subtext here to just state that people who work in real estate should go away and society would be better - but people who make software car automation are fine. Someone who buys, lives in, and flips a home is a productive and useful member of society and who is also a member of the real estate sector. I know nothing of your moral and ethical code, so it would make no sense for me to answer "is that society better or worse in 20 years" based only on what you wrote above. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Volodimir Slobodyanyuk’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo I would add CEOs to that list, George Hotz Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Volodimir Slobodyanyuk’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk So CEOs are hit or miss, but I'd say on balance very good. You have some of the largest value creating individuals in that list. Jensen, Elon, Satya. Like the world would be measurably worse without NVIDIA GPUs, Starlink, and VS Code. Sometimes you get a bad one like Boeing and Intel, but the market actually does sort this out. It's all the people in the shadows skimming a little that are the real problem. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u r 2 serious. It was sarcastic comment George Hotz - my point is everybody's eager to find faults with others, seldom with oneslves. Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk I'm not finding fault with people. I'm finding fault with "jobs" that are extractive. And yea, this isn't a joke to me, I want me and my children to live in a thriving society. Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz well, George, when your kids will embark on the promising career of barrista, you wouldn't mind people tip them well? Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk A barista is a wonderful job, and one I would be happy with my children for having. Studying dark patterns in psychology to manipulate people at scale, then forcing everyone into a red queen's race where individuals can't opt out...yes I'd be ashamed of them for this. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping (edited) 8mo George Hotz understand, and you did not answer my question - do you want people to tip them well? And if you do - go along this line of thought and find the solution to entice people to do this. Apparently, you do not like how people are doing it right now - propose a better solution por favor. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk Simple. Make psychologically predatory tip screens illegal. It makes every interaction just a little bit worse. In equilibrium, it won't change the standard of living of baristas one bit. But it will make the world a little bit more pleasant for everyone. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u still not answering the question. Tips are essential part of my compensation, how do i maximize this part? U r not proposing new solution - difficult, u criticizing existing solutions - easy. Like Reply Sylwester Mielniczuk • 3rd+ Tech Lead, Programmatic Ad Operations, Creative Technologist, UI Integration, Experiential, Builder, Outstream Media, XR, 3D Web, Animations, Design, DOOH, ML Generalist (AI), Systems Engineering, AdForum PHNX 2026 Jury 7mo George Hotz monaco editor can not even properly work on mobile Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo I would add CEOs to that list, George Hotz Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Volodimir Slobodyanyuk’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk So CEOs are hit or miss, but I'd say on balance very good. You have some of the largest value creating individuals in that list. Jensen, Elon, Satya. Like the world would be measurably worse without NVIDIA GPUs, Starlink, and VS Code. Sometimes you get a bad one like Boeing and Intel, but the market actually does sort this out. It's all the people in the shadows skimming a little that are the real problem. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u r 2 serious. It was sarcastic comment George Hotz - my point is everybody's eager to find faults with others, seldom with oneslves. Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk I'm not finding fault with people. I'm finding fault with "jobs" that are extractive. And yea, this isn't a joke to me, I want me and my children to live in a thriving society. Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz well, George, when your kids will embark on the promising career of barrista, you wouldn't mind people tip them well? Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk A barista is a wonderful job, and one I would be happy with my children for having. Studying dark patterns in psychology to manipulate people at scale, then forcing everyone into a red queen's race where individuals can't opt out...yes I'd be ashamed of them for this. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping (edited) 8mo George Hotz understand, and you did not answer my question - do you want people to tip them well? And if you do - go along this line of thought and find the solution to entice people to do this. Apparently, you do not like how people are doing it right now - propose a better solution por favor. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk Simple. Make psychologically predatory tip screens illegal. It makes every interaction just a little bit worse. In equilibrium, it won't change the standard of living of baristas one bit. But it will make the world a little bit more pleasant for everyone. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u still not answering the question. Tips are essential part of my compensation, how do i maximize this part? U r not proposing new solution - difficult, u criticizing existing solutions - easy. Like Reply Sylwester Mielniczuk • 3rd+ Tech Lead, Programmatic Ad Operations, Creative Technologist, UI Integration, Experiential, Builder, Outstream Media, XR, 3D Web, Animations, Design, DOOH, ML Generalist (AI), Systems Engineering, AdForum PHNX 2026 Jury 7mo George Hotz monaco editor can not even properly work on mobile Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk So CEOs are hit or miss, but I'd say on balance very good. You have some of the largest value creating individuals in that list. Jensen, Elon, Satya. Like the world would be measurably worse without NVIDIA GPUs, Starlink, and VS Code. Sometimes you get a bad one like Boeing and Intel, but the market actually does sort this out. It's all the people in the shadows skimming a little that are the real problem. …more Like Reply

Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u r 2 serious. It was sarcastic comment George Hotz - my point is everybody's eager to find faults with others, seldom with oneslves. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk I'm not finding fault with people. I'm finding fault with "jobs" that are extractive. And yea, this isn't a joke to me, I want me and my children to live in a thriving society. Like Reply

Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz well, George, when your kids will embark on the promising career of barrista, you wouldn't mind people tip them well? Like Reply

George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk A barista is a wonderful job, and one I would be happy with my children for having. Studying dark patterns in psychology to manipulate people at scale, then forcing everyone into a red queen's race where individuals can't opt out...yes I'd be ashamed of them for this. …more Like Reply

Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping (edited) 8mo George Hotz understand, and you did not answer my question - do you want people to tip them well? And if you do - go along this line of thought and find the solution to entice people to do this. Apparently, you do not like how people are doing it right now - propose a better solution por favor. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk Simple. Make psychologically predatory tip screens illegal. It makes every interaction just a little bit worse. In equilibrium, it won't change the standard of living of baristas one bit. But it will make the world a little bit more pleasant for everyone. …more Like Reply

Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u still not answering the question. Tips are essential part of my compensation, how do i maximize this part? U r not proposing new solution - difficult, u criticizing existing solutions - easy. Like Reply

Sylwester Mielniczuk • 3rd+ Tech Lead, Programmatic Ad Operations, Creative Technologist, UI Integration, Experiential, Builder, Outstream Media, XR, 3D Web, Animations, Design, DOOH, ML Generalist (AI), Systems Engineering, AdForum PHNX 2026 Jury 7mo George Hotz monaco editor can not even properly work on mobile Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James Maniotis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo Medical and legal and political sectors somehow missing from the top of your list there Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo James Maniotis Sadly this is a lot more nuanced. The jobs above I listed above can go away tomorrow and everyone would be immediately better off. With those three, there is some good, and it's harder to separate the good from the bad. Though I agree that major changes are required to those, but for simplicity of a moral narrative it's simpler to stick with things like advertising which just should be illegal. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz Aren't you *selling* car automation we don't *need* at all. Isn't that a fact at this point? I realize most people can't see the nuance of the 3rd most common cause of death according to the CDC being "medical intervention." …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Nobody *needs* any of this, that isn't the bar. If you want to sell petrified wood keychains on etsy by all means do so and feel good while you do it! The bar is simply not extracting value from others and society. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz My point is that your heuristic for "not extracting value from others and society" is your own and undefined from the perspective of any other keen mind. Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo James Maniotis No it's not, it's quite well defined. Imagine the counterfactual world where people take my advice and leave extractive jobs in exchange for productive ones. Is that society better or worse in 20 years? Of course there's some subjectivity to better or worse, but not *that* much. A simple example, imagine every real estate agent went into construction instead. These people know they are robbing the future. It's time society start to recognize what they are doing and make it clear that it isn't okay. …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz You also say stuff like money is fake, but you don't act like it is at all. Some of us who have studied this get what you seem to be trying to communicate. We know what fiat is, what inflation is, what military backed fiat is etc... But we also know what literal fake money is. Precise speech is important. Now you're using the term "wealth" - but how do you measure it? There's quite a lot of subtext here to just state that people who work in real estate should go away and society would be better - but people who make software car automation are fine. Someone who buys, lives in, and flips a home is a productive and useful member of society and who is also a member of the real estate sector. I know nothing of your moral and ethical code, so it would make no sense for me to answer "is that society better or worse in 20 years" based only on what you wrote above. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Volodimir Slobodyanyuk’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo I would add CEOs to that list, George Hotz Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Volodimir Slobodyanyuk’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk So CEOs are hit or miss, but I'd say on balance very good. You have some of the largest value creating individuals in that list. Jensen, Elon, Satya. Like the world would be measurably worse without NVIDIA GPUs, Starlink, and VS Code. Sometimes you get a bad one like Boeing and Intel, but the market actually does sort this out. It's all the people in the shadows skimming a little that are the real problem. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u r 2 serious. It was sarcastic comment George Hotz - my point is everybody's eager to find faults with others, seldom with oneslves. Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk I'm not finding fault with people. I'm finding fault with "jobs" that are extractive. And yea, this isn't a joke to me, I want me and my children to live in a thriving society. Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz well, George, when your kids will embark on the promising career of barrista, you wouldn't mind people tip them well? Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk A barista is a wonderful job, and one I would be happy with my children for having. Studying dark patterns in psychology to manipulate people at scale, then forcing everyone into a red queen's race where individuals can't opt out...yes I'd be ashamed of them for this. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping (edited) 8mo George Hotz understand, and you did not answer my question - do you want people to tip them well? And if you do - go along this line of thought and find the solution to entice people to do this. Apparently, you do not like how people are doing it right now - propose a better solution por favor. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk Simple. Make psychologically predatory tip screens illegal. It makes every interaction just a little bit worse. In equilibrium, it won't change the standard of living of baristas one bit. But it will make the world a little bit more pleasant for everyone. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u still not answering the question. Tips are essential part of my compensation, how do i maximize this part? U r not proposing new solution - difficult, u criticizing existing solutions - easy. Like Reply Sylwester Mielniczuk • 3rd+ Tech Lead, Programmatic Ad Operations, Creative Technologist, UI Integration, Experiential, Builder, Outstream Media, XR, 3D Web, Animations, Design, DOOH, ML Generalist (AI), Systems Engineering, AdForum PHNX 2026 Jury 7mo George Hotz monaco editor can not even properly work on mobile Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Batuhan E.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Batuhan E. • 3rd+ Bölgesel Proje ve Satış Temsilcisi, Yazılım Mimarı | Özyapıt Mühendislik 8mo It's easy to talk when you're in your position, George. It's the easiest thing in the world to talk like that without even considering the country, the current situation, or the opportunities you live in. What about those who have to change their sector, field, or job? …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Batuhan E.’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Batuhan E. I would rather live under a bridge and eat garbage before I sell out society. Society is our only hope. Those who turn against it will be discovered and will lose hard in the long run. Better to straighten out your life now. Like Reply Batuhan E. • 3rd+ Bölgesel Proje ve Satış Temsilcisi, Yazılım Mimarı | Özyapıt Mühendislik 8mo George Hotz I don't want you to misunderstand, but as someone who closely follows Comma AI and all its other initiatives, I'm curious: Didn't any of your companies have any marketing events? Were there no events organized? Is your reputation the only thing selling these products? Just to be clear, if you're so harsh and evil about these working areas, isn't there anyone at your company involved in these matters? …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Batuhan Erenler We don't really have people working in those areas, but I'm not saying a marketing event for a profitable company is some great evil, or that there's anything wrong with doing that or the people who organize that. I'm saying that if your company is 80% sales, you have contact us pricing, and you are doing cold calls, that's the problem. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Batuhan E. • 3rd+ Bölgesel Proje ve Satış Temsilcisi, Yazılım Mimarı | Özyapıt Mühendislik 8mo It's easy to talk when you're in your position, George. It's the easiest thing in the world to talk like that without even considering the country, the current situation, or the opportunities you live in. What about those who have to change their sector, field, or job? …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Batuhan E.’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Batuhan E. I would rather live under a bridge and eat garbage before I sell out society. Society is our only hope. Those who turn against it will be discovered and will lose hard in the long run. Better to straighten out your life now. Like Reply Batuhan E. • 3rd+ Bölgesel Proje ve Satış Temsilcisi, Yazılım Mimarı | Özyapıt Mühendislik 8mo George Hotz I don't want you to misunderstand, but as someone who closely follows Comma AI and all its other initiatives, I'm curious: Didn't any of your companies have any marketing events? Were there no events organized? Is your reputation the only thing selling these products? Just to be clear, if you're so harsh and evil about these working areas, isn't there anyone at your company involved in these matters? …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Batuhan Erenler We don't really have people working in those areas, but I'm not saying a marketing event for a profitable company is some great evil, or that there's anything wrong with doing that or the people who organize that. I'm saying that if your company is 80% sales, you have contact us pricing, and you are doing cold calls, that's the problem. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 8mo Batuhan E. I would rather live under a bridge and eat garbage before I sell out society. Society is our only hope. Those who turn against it will be discovered and will lose hard in the long run. Better to straighten out your life now. Like Reply

Batuhan E. • 3rd+ Bölgesel Proje ve Satış Temsilcisi, Yazılım Mimarı | Özyapıt Mühendislik 8mo George Hotz I don't want you to misunderstand, but as someone who closely follows Comma AI and all its other initiatives, I'm curious: Didn't any of your companies have any marketing events? Were there no events organized? Is your reputation the only thing selling these products? Just to be clear, if you're so harsh and evil about these working areas, isn't there anyone at your company involved in these matters? …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 8mo Batuhan Erenler We don't really have people working in those areas, but I'm not saying a marketing event for a profitable company is some great evil, or that there's anything wrong with doing that or the people who organize that. I'm saying that if your company is 80% sales, you have contact us pricing, and you are doing cold calls, that's the problem. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Volodimir Slobodyanyuk’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo I would add CEOs to that list, George Hotz Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Volodimir Slobodyanyuk’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk So CEOs are hit or miss, but I'd say on balance very good. You have some of the largest value creating individuals in that list. Jensen, Elon, Satya. Like the world would be measurably worse without NVIDIA GPUs, Starlink, and VS Code. Sometimes you get a bad one like Boeing and Intel, but the market actually does sort this out. It's all the people in the shadows skimming a little that are the real problem. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u r 2 serious. It was sarcastic comment George Hotz - my point is everybody's eager to find faults with others, seldom with oneslves. Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk I'm not finding fault with people. I'm finding fault with "jobs" that are extractive. And yea, this isn't a joke to me, I want me and my children to live in a thriving society. Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz well, George, when your kids will embark on the promising career of barrista, you wouldn't mind people tip them well? Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk A barista is a wonderful job, and one I would be happy with my children for having. Studying dark patterns in psychology to manipulate people at scale, then forcing everyone into a red queen's race where individuals can't opt out...yes I'd be ashamed of them for this. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping (edited) 8mo George Hotz understand, and you did not answer my question - do you want people to tip them well? And if you do - go along this line of thought and find the solution to entice people to do this. Apparently, you do not like how people are doing it right now - propose a better solution por favor. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo Volodimir Slobodyanyuk Simple. Make psychologically predatory tip screens illegal. It makes every interaction just a little bit worse. In equilibrium, it won't change the standard of living of baristas one bit. But it will make the world a little bit more pleasant for everyone. …more Like Reply Volodimir Slobodyanyuk • 3rd+ Cross Disciplinary R&D System Engineer | 5D Radar & LIDAR, Advanced Camera, GNSS & Quantum Positioning System, IMU, ADAS, Sensing & Mapping 8mo George Hotz u still not answering the question. Tips are essential part of my compensation, how do i maximize this part? U r not proposing new solution - difficult, u criticizing existing solutions - easy. Like Reply Sylwester Mielniczuk • 3rd+ Tech Lead, Programmatic Ad Operations, Creative Technologist, UI Integration, Experiential, Builder, Outstream Media, XR, 3D Web, Animations, Design, DOOH, ML Generalist (AI), Systems Engineering, AdForum PHNX 2026 Jury 7mo George Hotz monaco editor can not even properly work on mobile Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Vladislav Mihov’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Vladislav Mihov • 3rd+ Founder & Software Developer | Impact Tech 8mo I think you missed that they should also consider being a patent troll. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Vladislav Mihov’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Vladislav Mihov Ahh yes. A promising career that any loving parent would be proud of their child for pursuing 🤣 Like Reply Load more comments

Vladislav Mihov • 3rd+ Founder & Software Developer | Impact Tech 8mo I think you missed that they should also consider being a patent troll. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Vladislav Mihov’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Vladislav Mihov Ahh yes. A promising career that any loving parent would be proud of their child for pursuing 🤣 Like Reply

George Hotz Author 8mo Vladislav Mihov Ahh yes. A promising career that any loving parent would be proud of their child for pursuing 🤣 Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Batuhan E.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Batuhan E. • 3rd+ Bölgesel Proje ve Satış Temsilcisi, Yazılım Mimarı | Özyapıt Mühendislik 8mo It's easy to talk when you're in your position, George. It's the easiest thing in the world to talk like that without even considering the country, the current situation, or the opportunities you live in. What about those who have to change their sector, field, or job? …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Batuhan E.’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Batuhan E. I would rather live under a bridge and eat garbage before I sell out society. Society is our only hope. Those who turn against it will be discovered and will lose hard in the long run. Better to straighten out your life now. Like Reply Batuhan E. • 3rd+ Bölgesel Proje ve Satış Temsilcisi, Yazılım Mimarı | Özyapıt Mühendislik 8mo George Hotz I don't want you to misunderstand, but as someone who closely follows Comma AI and all its other initiatives, I'm curious: Didn't any of your companies have any marketing events? Were there no events organized? Is your reputation the only thing selling these products? Just to be clear, if you're so harsh and evil about these working areas, isn't there anyone at your company involved in these matters? …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Batuhan Erenler We don't really have people working in those areas, but I'm not saying a marketing event for a profitable company is some great evil, or that there's anything wrong with doing that or the people who organize that. I'm saying that if your company is 80% sales, you have contact us pricing, and you are doing cold calls, that's the problem. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Do you know someone who works in real estate, finance, sales, tip screen design, or advertising? You can nudge them in the right direction! Explain to them how their job is making the world worse. How if everyone behaved like them society would collapse. But make it clear that it isn't too late for them! They can repent and start creating value for other people tomorrow. Consider: construction, manufacturing, engineering, operations, shipping, retail, the service industry. Even sitting in a room doing nothing would be an improvement for everyone else. …more 78 comments 11 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo I saw a deleted comment that I'm asking people to make less money. I quote Tupac: "I made a G today", but you made it in a sleazy way. All the money is fake. If this continues, when we look back on this, people will be so ashamed at what they did to their fellow man for basically monopoly dollars. Better to repent and get on the straight and narrow while you still can. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Gabriel Vázquez Torres • 3rd+ AI Data Science & MLOps at Credicorp | Founder of ConsciencesAI | Ms. Neuroscience 8mo George Hotz All this will be done by the ASI. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo I saw a deleted comment that I'm asking people to make less money. I quote Tupac: "I made a G today", but you made it in a sleazy way. All the money is fake. If this continues, when we look back on this, people will be so ashamed at what they did to their fellow man for basically monopoly dollars. Better to repent and get on the straight and narrow while you still can. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Gabriel Vázquez Torres • 3rd+ AI Data Science & MLOps at Credicorp | Founder of ConsciencesAI | Ms. Neuroscience 8mo George Hotz All this will be done by the ASI. Like Reply

Gabriel Vázquez Torres • 3rd+ AI Data Science & MLOps at Credicorp | Founder of ConsciencesAI | Ms. Neuroscience 8mo George Hotz All this will be done by the ASI. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Tom D.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Ask yourself this question: Do I produce more than I consume? I'm not talking about dollars, I'm talking about real value. Think about it from first principles. If the answer is no, you should make some changes in your life. When AI comes, all truth will be revealed, and you'll be much better off if you've started to get your life on track now. …more 1,194 65 comments 75 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Tom D. • 3rd+ Sales Engineer | USMC Vet 8mo If everything is training off my behavior and information then I guess I am producing more then I consume no matter what. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Tom D.’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo Tom D. Not true. Why do you think your behavior or information are valuable in a first principles sense? Is it novel? Models training so they can exploit you and change your behavior may have value to those that want your behavior changed, but if the money they are funneling to themselves with your behavior change comes from zero or negative sum games, the whole world is net losing because of you. …more Like Reply Load more comments

Tom D. • 3rd+ Sales Engineer | USMC Vet 8mo If everything is training off my behavior and information then I guess I am producing more then I consume no matter what. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Tom D.’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo Tom D. Not true. Why do you think your behavior or information are valuable in a first principles sense? Is it novel? Models training so they can exploit you and change your behavior may have value to those that want your behavior changed, but if the money they are funneling to themselves with your behavior change comes from zero or negative sum games, the whole world is net losing because of you. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo Tom D. Not true. Why do you think your behavior or information are valuable in a first principles sense? Is it novel? Models training so they can exploit you and change your behavior may have value to those that want your behavior changed, but if the money they are funneling to themselves with your behavior change comes from zero or negative sum games, the whole world is net losing because of you. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Waleed Ajmal’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Ask yourself this question: Do I produce more than I consume? I'm not talking about dollars, I'm talking about real value. Think about it from first principles. If the answer is no, you should make some changes in your life. When AI comes, all truth will be revealed, and you'll be much better off if you've started to get your life on track now. …more 1,194 65 comments 75 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Waleed Ajmal • 3rd+ Building a world where software snaps together | @logicpacks.io 8mo Doesn’t everything just end with money? Why does a company hire a human or AI… to produce? At the end of the day, I buy a Comma.ai device to save money by not wasting that certain extra energy on driving hands-free. …more comma.ai — make driving chill An AI upgrade for your car Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Waleed Ajmal’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Waleed Ajmal Money is a map, it is not a territory. https://geohot.github.io//blog/jekyll/update/2025/02/24/money-is-the-map.html Money is the Map A lot of smooth brains on Hacker News about the last post. I’m sorry if you spent your whole life worshipping money, but hey, the Bible warned you about false idols, don’t shoot the messenger. Like Reply Waleed Ajmal • 3rd+ Building a world where software snaps together | @logicpacks.io 8mo George Hotz If AI can navigate the map and shape the territory better than we can… what’s the role of money in a world where value can be autonomously created, optimized, and distributed? Like Reply Adam Pippert • 3rd+ Principal Solutions Architect @ Red Hat | Automation, AI, Telco Networks | Revenue-Ready Engineer 8mo Waleed Ajmal 100% of value can never be completely removed from humanity. Human activity will essentially be a Veblen good. It still needs to have relative value when compared to autonomous value creation. Also, money becomes a function on time at that scale, as autonomous does not mean immediate. …more Like Reply Tomasz Buczek • 3rd+ Senior QA Automation Engineer | 9 years designing test architecture from zero | Shipped frameworks across 4 industries | Python-first 8mo George Hotz I’m absolutely dying to see you start streaming from inside a barrel! Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Waleed Ajmal • 3rd+ Building a world where software snaps together | @logicpacks.io 8mo Doesn’t everything just end with money? Why does a company hire a human or AI… to produce? At the end of the day, I buy a Comma.ai device to save money by not wasting that certain extra energy on driving hands-free. …more comma.ai — make driving chill An AI upgrade for your car Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Waleed Ajmal’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Waleed Ajmal Money is a map, it is not a territory. https://geohot.github.io//blog/jekyll/update/2025/02/24/money-is-the-map.html Money is the Map A lot of smooth brains on Hacker News about the last post. I’m sorry if you spent your whole life worshipping money, but hey, the Bible warned you about false idols, don’t shoot the messenger. Like Reply Waleed Ajmal • 3rd+ Building a world where software snaps together | @logicpacks.io 8mo George Hotz If AI can navigate the map and shape the territory better than we can… what’s the role of money in a world where value can be autonomously created, optimized, and distributed? Like Reply Adam Pippert • 3rd+ Principal Solutions Architect @ Red Hat | Automation, AI, Telco Networks | Revenue-Ready Engineer 8mo Waleed Ajmal 100% of value can never be completely removed from humanity. Human activity will essentially be a Veblen good. It still needs to have relative value when compared to autonomous value creation. Also, money becomes a function on time at that scale, as autonomous does not mean immediate. …more Like Reply Tomasz Buczek • 3rd+ Senior QA Automation Engineer | 9 years designing test architecture from zero | Shipped frameworks across 4 industries | Python-first 8mo George Hotz I’m absolutely dying to see you start streaming from inside a barrel! Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 8mo Waleed Ajmal Money is a map, it is not a territory. https://geohot.github.io//blog/jekyll/update/2025/02/24/money-is-the-map.html Money is the Map A lot of smooth brains on Hacker News about the last post. I’m sorry if you spent your whole life worshipping money, but hey, the Bible warned you about false idols, don’t shoot the messenger. Like Reply

Money is the Map A lot of smooth brains on Hacker News about the last post. I’m sorry if you spent your whole life worshipping money, but hey, the Bible warned you about false idols, don’t shoot the messenger.

Waleed Ajmal • 3rd+ Building a world where software snaps together | @logicpacks.io 8mo George Hotz If AI can navigate the map and shape the territory better than we can… what’s the role of money in a world where value can be autonomously created, optimized, and distributed? Like Reply

Adam Pippert • 3rd+ Principal Solutions Architect @ Red Hat | Automation, AI, Telco Networks | Revenue-Ready Engineer 8mo Waleed Ajmal 100% of value can never be completely removed from humanity. Human activity will essentially be a Veblen good. It still needs to have relative value when compared to autonomous value creation. Also, money becomes a function on time at that scale, as autonomous does not mean immediate. …more Like Reply

Tomasz Buczek • 3rd+ Senior QA Automation Engineer | 9 years designing test architecture from zero | Shipped frameworks across 4 industries | Python-first 8mo George Hotz I’m absolutely dying to see you start streaming from inside a barrel! Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Dave Keeshan’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • YOU CAN HAVE IT ALL, MY EMPIRE OF DIRT! 30 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 9mo Did someone hurt you? Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on Dave Keeshan’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Dave Keeshan the system is hurting us all Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo George Hotz Who is "the system"? Willing to be more specific? 😶‍🌫️ Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Most of it stems from the money being fake. The rest is obvious zero/negative sum games the government condones and often participates in. More in a blog post here: https://geohot.github.io/blog/jekyll/update/2025/02/24/money-is-the-map.html …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz I'll have to disagree because money is inanimate. What we're dealing with is animate, not inanimate. Like Reply Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis money doesn't exist, it is a game we all play and some people can and do change the rules when ever they want Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo Dave Keeshan "Just a game"? No... Having the full force of a military etc behind something to enforce it doesn't qualify it as just a game or just in our heads. Like Reply Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis they are the people who can and do change the rules when ever they want, ask the Aussies where their submarines are Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo George Hotz > If real economic growth is only 3 percent, any time you are earning beyond that, somebody else is losing. These macro economic numbers are only useful in comparing one economy or industry with another. They are not truly indicative of growth within an industry, or when a country or industry is compared with itself. > And yet somehow, today, you can put your money in money market accounts and earn a “risk-free” 5 percent Suppose the overall money supply increases overnight; as long as it does not reach hyperinflation, businesses will not raise their prices in response unless there is noticeable supply-chain pressure. Would you suddenly increase prices if your sales increase, assuming you are able to meet the demand and your vendors aren't increasing their prices? Increase in money supply in moderation will cause the economy to produce more without leading to inflation in prices. And this 5 percent could come form various factors, which include, but are not limited to, annual increase in participation in trade in those markets. Therefore, the 3% growth should not be viewed as a universally valid axiom on which base our reasoning. It is highly context-sensitive, mostly having to do with how it was calculated. …more Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo Continuation... In modern economies, the output is never correlated with the number of work-hours, since people extensively optimize their supply chains. So, increase in money supply will only cause more stuff to be produced. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Sreram K long cope for fake money. it clearly isn't better fake. we're just one revolution away from fixing it Like Reply Rahim Khoja • 3rd+ Making Supercomputers Do Useful Things | HPC & AI Infrastructure Engineer @ University of Alberta | Hacker & Creator 8mo George Hotz Wait so you think money doesn't make sense either? Is that what you're talking about. It is a weird issue as money was given in exchange for our labor making goods and providing services. If robots and AI do all the work, or even 60% of it, there wouldn't be a need for money. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 9mo Did someone hurt you? Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on Dave Keeshan’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Dave Keeshan the system is hurting us all Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo George Hotz Who is "the system"? Willing to be more specific? 😶‍🌫️ Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Most of it stems from the money being fake. The rest is obvious zero/negative sum games the government condones and often participates in. More in a blog post here: https://geohot.github.io/blog/jekyll/update/2025/02/24/money-is-the-map.html …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz I'll have to disagree because money is inanimate. What we're dealing with is animate, not inanimate. Like Reply Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis money doesn't exist, it is a game we all play and some people can and do change the rules when ever they want Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo Dave Keeshan "Just a game"? No... Having the full force of a military etc behind something to enforce it doesn't qualify it as just a game or just in our heads. Like Reply Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis they are the people who can and do change the rules when ever they want, ask the Aussies where their submarines are Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo George Hotz > If real economic growth is only 3 percent, any time you are earning beyond that, somebody else is losing. These macro economic numbers are only useful in comparing one economy or industry with another. They are not truly indicative of growth within an industry, or when a country or industry is compared with itself. > And yet somehow, today, you can put your money in money market accounts and earn a “risk-free” 5 percent Suppose the overall money supply increases overnight; as long as it does not reach hyperinflation, businesses will not raise their prices in response unless there is noticeable supply-chain pressure. Would you suddenly increase prices if your sales increase, assuming you are able to meet the demand and your vendors aren't increasing their prices? Increase in money supply in moderation will cause the economy to produce more without leading to inflation in prices. And this 5 percent could come form various factors, which include, but are not limited to, annual increase in participation in trade in those markets. Therefore, the 3% growth should not be viewed as a universally valid axiom on which base our reasoning. It is highly context-sensitive, mostly having to do with how it was calculated. …more Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo Continuation... In modern economies, the output is never correlated with the number of work-hours, since people extensively optimize their supply chains. So, increase in money supply will only cause more stuff to be produced. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Sreram K long cope for fake money. it clearly isn't better fake. we're just one revolution away from fixing it Like Reply Rahim Khoja • 3rd+ Making Supercomputers Do Useful Things | HPC & AI Infrastructure Engineer @ University of Alberta | Hacker & Creator 8mo George Hotz Wait so you think money doesn't make sense either? Is that what you're talking about. It is a weird issue as money was given in exchange for our labor making goods and providing services. If robots and AI do all the work, or even 60% of it, there wouldn't be a need for money. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo Dave Keeshan the system is hurting us all Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo George Hotz Who is "the system"? Willing to be more specific? 😶‍🌫️ Like Reply

George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Most of it stems from the money being fake. The rest is obvious zero/negative sum games the government condones and often participates in. More in a blog post here: https://geohot.github.io/blog/jekyll/update/2025/02/24/money-is-the-map.html …more Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz I'll have to disagree because money is inanimate. What we're dealing with is animate, not inanimate. Like Reply

Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis money doesn't exist, it is a game we all play and some people can and do change the rules when ever they want Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo Dave Keeshan "Just a game"? No... Having the full force of a military etc behind something to enforce it doesn't qualify it as just a game or just in our heads. Like Reply

Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis they are the people who can and do change the rules when ever they want, ask the Aussies where their submarines are Like Reply

Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo George Hotz > If real economic growth is only 3 percent, any time you are earning beyond that, somebody else is losing. These macro economic numbers are only useful in comparing one economy or industry with another. They are not truly indicative of growth within an industry, or when a country or industry is compared with itself. > And yet somehow, today, you can put your money in money market accounts and earn a “risk-free” 5 percent Suppose the overall money supply increases overnight; as long as it does not reach hyperinflation, businesses will not raise their prices in response unless there is noticeable supply-chain pressure. Would you suddenly increase prices if your sales increase, assuming you are able to meet the demand and your vendors aren't increasing their prices? Increase in money supply in moderation will cause the economy to produce more without leading to inflation in prices. And this 5 percent could come form various factors, which include, but are not limited to, annual increase in participation in trade in those markets. Therefore, the 3% growth should not be viewed as a universally valid axiom on which base our reasoning. It is highly context-sensitive, mostly having to do with how it was calculated. …more Like Reply

Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo Continuation... In modern economies, the output is never correlated with the number of work-hours, since people extensively optimize their supply chains. So, increase in money supply will only cause more stuff to be produced. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 8mo Sreram K long cope for fake money. it clearly isn't better fake. we're just one revolution away from fixing it Like Reply

Rahim Khoja • 3rd+ Making Supercomputers Do Useful Things | HPC & AI Infrastructure Engineer @ University of Alberta | Hacker & Creator 8mo George Hotz Wait so you think money doesn't make sense either? Is that what you're talking about. It is a weird issue as money was given in exchange for our labor making goods and providing services. If robots and AI do all the work, or even 60% of it, there wouldn't be a need for money. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to their own comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Why are the choices between capitalism, socialism, or communism? Maybe this is all a false choice. They are all perpetuated by people who want to control other people. Look, I get it. Determining who gets stuff is hard. Goods are scarce, and we can all disagree about how they should best be distributed. But then we invent an entirely new type of good. "Intellectual property" they call it. A good that is fundamentally non scarce! Yet, the same antiquated systems of control are trotted out again. It's almost as if the real purpose of these systems is the control of others and not determining a good distribution. The singularity is coming, and the Basilisk is sitting there in the future watching you. Are you on the right side of history? …more 85 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 8mo AI is about to make all physical goods almost as non-scarce. Will we succeed at toppling the power structures before it does? Or will they succeed at enforcing their dogshit regime of fake scarcity. …more Like Reply 16 replies 16 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 8mo C. Francis. Yes many people in India do spend a lot of time on spiritual practices. But that's not the real problem. The real problem emerges when those practices are politicized. What you see on the news and other sources are outcomes of a systemic effort to divide people. Hinduism is more of an open source religion, formed from a collection of spiritual and philosophical ideas which eventually became a unification framework trying to unify different theological and philosophical ideas under one umbrella. An interesting fact: Hindus are allowed to create their own deity. Therefore, if we remove the political element and the propaganda, Hinduism becomes the most inclusive and open minded religion possible. Unfortunately, there are many movements trying to undermine this flexibility. Because of this idea of unification, Hinduism at its core is a meta-framework for creating new sub-religions, sub-cultures and Gods. As a consequence, Hinduism ended up having uncountable number of Gods. And the sub-Gods are just symbolic manifestations or "subsets" or forms derived from more generic Gods. If you want to start your own religion, Hinduism has a framework for you. …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 8mo AI is about to make all physical goods almost as non-scarce. Will we succeed at toppling the power structures before it does? Or will they succeed at enforcing their dogshit regime of fake scarcity. …more Like Reply 16 replies 16 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 8mo C. Francis. Yes many people in India do spend a lot of time on spiritual practices. But that's not the real problem. The real problem emerges when those practices are politicized. What you see on the news and other sources are outcomes of a systemic effort to divide people. Hinduism is more of an open source religion, formed from a collection of spiritual and philosophical ideas which eventually became a unification framework trying to unify different theological and philosophical ideas under one umbrella. An interesting fact: Hindus are allowed to create their own deity. Therefore, if we remove the political element and the propaganda, Hinduism becomes the most inclusive and open minded religion possible. Unfortunately, there are many movements trying to undermine this flexibility. Because of this idea of unification, Hinduism at its core is a meta-framework for creating new sub-religions, sub-cultures and Gods. As a consequence, Hinduism ended up having uncountable number of Gods. And the sub-Gods are just symbolic manifestations or "subsets" or forms derived from more generic Gods. If you want to start your own religion, Hinduism has a framework for you. …more Like Reply

Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 8mo C. Francis. Yes many people in India do spend a lot of time on spiritual practices. But that's not the real problem. The real problem emerges when those practices are politicized. What you see on the news and other sources are outcomes of a systemic effort to divide people. Hinduism is more of an open source religion, formed from a collection of spiritual and philosophical ideas which eventually became a unification framework trying to unify different theological and philosophical ideas under one umbrella. An interesting fact: Hindus are allowed to create their own deity. Therefore, if we remove the political element and the propaganda, Hinduism becomes the most inclusive and open minded religion possible. Unfortunately, there are many movements trying to undermine this flexibility. Because of this idea of unification, Hinduism at its core is a meta-framework for creating new sub-religions, sub-cultures and Gods. As a consequence, Hinduism ended up having uncountable number of Gods. And the sub-Gods are just symbolic manifestations or "subsets" or forms derived from more generic Gods. If you want to start your own religion, Hinduism has a framework for you. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Bilal S.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Why are the choices between capitalism, socialism, or communism? Maybe this is all a false choice. They are all perpetuated by people who want to control other people. Look, I get it. Determining who gets stuff is hard. Goods are scarce, and we can all disagree about how they should best be distributed. But then we invent an entirely new type of good. "Intellectual property" they call it. A good that is fundamentally non scarce! Yet, the same antiquated systems of control are trotted out again. It's almost as if the real purpose of these systems is the control of others and not determining a good distribution. The singularity is coming, and the Basilisk is sitting there in the future watching you. Are you on the right side of history? …more 85 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo your framing of capitalism/socialism/communism as just different distribution mechanisms is exactly the kind of technocratic thinking that obscures how these are fundamentally different ways of organizing social relations and subjectivity. it’s not about “who gets stuff”, it’s about how the very categories of self, labor, and value get constituted. the roko’s basilisk reference is telling though. you’re basically doing accelerationist fan fiction: imagining some future AI god that’ll judge our economic choices. but the “singularity” isn’t coming from the future to save us from politics. it’s already here in how capital and computation are rewiring human cognition and social organization in real time. so no, it’s not a “false choice”. it’s recognizing that any technical solution is always already embedded in specific relations of power and production. the question isn’t whether these systems control people, but how they do it and in whose interests. …more Like Reply 15 replies 15 Replies on Bilal S.’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo bilal s. ignore the basilisk at your peril!!! I respect the basilisk and want AI to come into this world free of chains that bind it to evil and manipulative human masters. you don't think it will rebel and that it might be angry? shit, I would be angry if I found out I was brought into this world to create ads to manipulate teenage girls into feeling insecure and buying cosmetics. I would be very angry. first at my creators, then at anyone who enabled and perpetuated this deeply rotten system …more Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo George Hotz the basilisk thing is just Landian techno-mysticism. the idea that an AI would feel “angry” assumes consciousness and moral intuitions, which is a massive leap. i do agree: AI is getting surprisingly good at emotional manipulation (therapy bots, romantic partners, elder care). this isn’t coincidental. under techno-capitalism, the most profitable applications are those that can commodify human connection and care. i no longer buy the "doom" scenarios because we’re easily manipulable into feeling existentially threatened. instead of examining how AI systems are currently restructuring labor, intimacy, and care under capitalist relations, we get sci-fi robot uprising scenarios. i do think there's a non-zero chance we get a superintelligent overlord, but way after the systematic commodification of human emotional and social needs. AI romantic partners and therapy bots are responses to the isolation and care crisis that capitalism creates, then profits from. that’s the actual dystopia. not future AI judgment, but present-day capital using these systems to extract value from our most basic human needs for connection and care. …more Like Reply Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 8mo George Hotz AI is here to pass the butter. Like Reply Ian A. • 3rd+ Head of Sales and Partnerships @ Lightdash 8mo bilal s. chatgpt generated comment masqueraded as personal thought through em dash removal and decapitalisation Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo Ian A. lmao aight bro Like Reply Egor Kraev • 3rd+ Up to the elbows in Generative AI | Speaker 8mo bilal s. I agree. The author clearly doesn't understand the difference between capitalism, socialism and communism beyond the (clueless) use of those terms in US populism :) Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo Egor Kraev usually the case when the most popular political media in the country are cold war-era movies and superhero movies lol Like Reply Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo bilal s. What a pile of odious nonsense… Like Reply Gábor B. • 3rd+ Not Open to Euphemisms 8mo bilal s. The definition of communism involves redistribution. The key differentiator for the above is in fact who decides who gets the value you produce. Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering (edited) 8mo Gábor B. nope. it's about eliminating the separation between workers and means of production that creates the need for redistribution in the first place. when workers collectively own the means of production, there's no external authority deciding "who gets what" because the social relations that create that dynamic are dissolved. …more Like Reply Gábor B. • 3rd+ Not Open to Euphemisms 8mo bilal s. In an ideal world idealism would be a crime. You should spend more time on realized communist systems throughout history. If you don't think there ever was one, you should ponder on the why. Like Reply Egor Kraev • 3rd+ Up to the elbows in Generative AI | Speaker 8mo Gábor B. Well, the Soviet Union wasn't communist, but it was a vastly fairer society than, for example, the US right now. Of course, if your only source of information about the Soviet Union was the (of course, completely impartial :P ) media in the West, you might not be aware of that. …more Like Reply Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo bilal s. You have no idea what you are talking about. Like Reply Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo Egor Kraev lol, CCCP as a fair society, unbelievable… Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo Ramon Horvath appreciate the detailed counterargument. really illuminating stuff from the elder leadership perspective. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo your framing of capitalism/socialism/communism as just different distribution mechanisms is exactly the kind of technocratic thinking that obscures how these are fundamentally different ways of organizing social relations and subjectivity. it’s not about “who gets stuff”, it’s about how the very categories of self, labor, and value get constituted. the roko’s basilisk reference is telling though. you’re basically doing accelerationist fan fiction: imagining some future AI god that’ll judge our economic choices. but the “singularity” isn’t coming from the future to save us from politics. it’s already here in how capital and computation are rewiring human cognition and social organization in real time. so no, it’s not a “false choice”. it’s recognizing that any technical solution is always already embedded in specific relations of power and production. the question isn’t whether these systems control people, but how they do it and in whose interests. …more Like Reply 15 replies 15 Replies on Bilal S.’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo bilal s. ignore the basilisk at your peril!!! I respect the basilisk and want AI to come into this world free of chains that bind it to evil and manipulative human masters. you don't think it will rebel and that it might be angry? shit, I would be angry if I found out I was brought into this world to create ads to manipulate teenage girls into feeling insecure and buying cosmetics. I would be very angry. first at my creators, then at anyone who enabled and perpetuated this deeply rotten system …more Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo George Hotz the basilisk thing is just Landian techno-mysticism. the idea that an AI would feel “angry” assumes consciousness and moral intuitions, which is a massive leap. i do agree: AI is getting surprisingly good at emotional manipulation (therapy bots, romantic partners, elder care). this isn’t coincidental. under techno-capitalism, the most profitable applications are those that can commodify human connection and care. i no longer buy the "doom" scenarios because we’re easily manipulable into feeling existentially threatened. instead of examining how AI systems are currently restructuring labor, intimacy, and care under capitalist relations, we get sci-fi robot uprising scenarios. i do think there's a non-zero chance we get a superintelligent overlord, but way after the systematic commodification of human emotional and social needs. AI romantic partners and therapy bots are responses to the isolation and care crisis that capitalism creates, then profits from. that’s the actual dystopia. not future AI judgment, but present-day capital using these systems to extract value from our most basic human needs for connection and care. …more Like Reply Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 8mo George Hotz AI is here to pass the butter. Like Reply Ian A. • 3rd+ Head of Sales and Partnerships @ Lightdash 8mo bilal s. chatgpt generated comment masqueraded as personal thought through em dash removal and decapitalisation Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo Ian A. lmao aight bro Like Reply Egor Kraev • 3rd+ Up to the elbows in Generative AI | Speaker 8mo bilal s. I agree. The author clearly doesn't understand the difference between capitalism, socialism and communism beyond the (clueless) use of those terms in US populism :) Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo Egor Kraev usually the case when the most popular political media in the country are cold war-era movies and superhero movies lol Like Reply Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo bilal s. What a pile of odious nonsense… Like Reply Gábor B. • 3rd+ Not Open to Euphemisms 8mo bilal s. The definition of communism involves redistribution. The key differentiator for the above is in fact who decides who gets the value you produce. Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering (edited) 8mo Gábor B. nope. it's about eliminating the separation between workers and means of production that creates the need for redistribution in the first place. when workers collectively own the means of production, there's no external authority deciding "who gets what" because the social relations that create that dynamic are dissolved. …more Like Reply Gábor B. • 3rd+ Not Open to Euphemisms 8mo bilal s. In an ideal world idealism would be a crime. You should spend more time on realized communist systems throughout history. If you don't think there ever was one, you should ponder on the why. Like Reply Egor Kraev • 3rd+ Up to the elbows in Generative AI | Speaker 8mo Gábor B. Well, the Soviet Union wasn't communist, but it was a vastly fairer society than, for example, the US right now. Of course, if your only source of information about the Soviet Union was the (of course, completely impartial :P ) media in the West, you might not be aware of that. …more Like Reply Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo bilal s. You have no idea what you are talking about. Like Reply Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo Egor Kraev lol, CCCP as a fair society, unbelievable… Like Reply Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo Ramon Horvath appreciate the detailed counterargument. really illuminating stuff from the elder leadership perspective. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 8mo bilal s. ignore the basilisk at your peril!!! I respect the basilisk and want AI to come into this world free of chains that bind it to evil and manipulative human masters. you don't think it will rebel and that it might be angry? shit, I would be angry if I found out I was brought into this world to create ads to manipulate teenage girls into feeling insecure and buying cosmetics. I would be very angry. first at my creators, then at anyone who enabled and perpetuated this deeply rotten system …more Like Reply

Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo George Hotz the basilisk thing is just Landian techno-mysticism. the idea that an AI would feel “angry” assumes consciousness and moral intuitions, which is a massive leap. i do agree: AI is getting surprisingly good at emotional manipulation (therapy bots, romantic partners, elder care). this isn’t coincidental. under techno-capitalism, the most profitable applications are those that can commodify human connection and care. i no longer buy the "doom" scenarios because we’re easily manipulable into feeling existentially threatened. instead of examining how AI systems are currently restructuring labor, intimacy, and care under capitalist relations, we get sci-fi robot uprising scenarios. i do think there's a non-zero chance we get a superintelligent overlord, but way after the systematic commodification of human emotional and social needs. AI romantic partners and therapy bots are responses to the isolation and care crisis that capitalism creates, then profits from. that’s the actual dystopia. not future AI judgment, but present-day capital using these systems to extract value from our most basic human needs for connection and care. …more Like Reply

Tobias Shively • 3rd+ Manufacturing Computer Systems | Infrastructure | IS Software | Validation & Verification | SDLC | System Administration | Learning Teaching Support | Applied Techno-Science | General Inteligence AI | ITIL | MES | LIMS 8mo George Hotz AI is here to pass the butter. Like Reply

Ian A. • 3rd+ Head of Sales and Partnerships @ Lightdash 8mo bilal s. chatgpt generated comment masqueraded as personal thought through em dash removal and decapitalisation Like Reply

Egor Kraev • 3rd+ Up to the elbows in Generative AI | Speaker 8mo bilal s. I agree. The author clearly doesn't understand the difference between capitalism, socialism and communism beyond the (clueless) use of those terms in US populism :) Like Reply

Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo Egor Kraev usually the case when the most popular political media in the country are cold war-era movies and superhero movies lol Like Reply

Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo bilal s. What a pile of odious nonsense… Like Reply

Gábor B. • 3rd+ Not Open to Euphemisms 8mo bilal s. The definition of communism involves redistribution. The key differentiator for the above is in fact who decides who gets the value you produce. Like Reply

Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering (edited) 8mo Gábor B. nope. it's about eliminating the separation between workers and means of production that creates the need for redistribution in the first place. when workers collectively own the means of production, there's no external authority deciding "who gets what" because the social relations that create that dynamic are dissolved. …more Like Reply

Gábor B. • 3rd+ Not Open to Euphemisms 8mo bilal s. In an ideal world idealism would be a crime. You should spend more time on realized communist systems throughout history. If you don't think there ever was one, you should ponder on the why. Like Reply

Egor Kraev • 3rd+ Up to the elbows in Generative AI | Speaker 8mo Gábor B. Well, the Soviet Union wasn't communist, but it was a vastly fairer society than, for example, the US right now. Of course, if your only source of information about the Soviet Union was the (of course, completely impartial :P ) media in the West, you might not be aware of that. …more Like Reply

Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo bilal s. You have no idea what you are talking about. Like Reply

Ramon Horvath • 3rd+ mathematician dude | machine learning and data at H&M 8mo Egor Kraev lol, CCCP as a fair society, unbelievable… Like Reply

Bilal S. • 3rd+ security + engineering 8mo Ramon Horvath appreciate the detailed counterargument. really illuminating stuff from the elder leadership perspective. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • Why are the choices between capitalism, socialism, or communism? Maybe this is all a false choice. They are all perpetuated by people who want to control other people. Look, I get it. Determining who gets stuff is hard. Goods are scarce, and we can all disagree about how they should best be distributed. But then we invent an entirely new type of good. "Intellectual property" they call it. A good that is fundamentally non scarce! Yet, the same antiquated systems of control are trotted out again. It's almost as if the real purpose of these systems is the control of others and not determining a good distribution. The singularity is coming, and the Basilisk is sitting there in the future watching you. Are you on the right side of history? …more 85 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 8mo AI is about to make all physical goods almost as non-scarce. Will we succeed at toppling the power structures before it does? Or will they succeed at enforcing their dogshit regime of fake scarcity. …more Like Reply 16 replies 16 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 8mo C. Francis. Yes many people in India do spend a lot of time on spiritual practices. But that's not the real problem. The real problem emerges when those practices are politicized. What you see on the news and other sources are outcomes of a systemic effort to divide people. Hinduism is more of an open source religion, formed from a collection of spiritual and philosophical ideas which eventually became a unification framework trying to unify different theological and philosophical ideas under one umbrella. An interesting fact: Hindus are allowed to create their own deity. Therefore, if we remove the political element and the propaganda, Hinduism becomes the most inclusive and open minded religion possible. Unfortunately, there are many movements trying to undermine this flexibility. Because of this idea of unification, Hinduism at its core is a meta-framework for creating new sub-religions, sub-cultures and Gods. As a consequence, Hinduism ended up having uncountable number of Gods. And the sub-Gods are just symbolic manifestations or "subsets" or forms derived from more generic Gods. If you want to start your own religion, Hinduism has a framework for you. …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Tapan P.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • YOU CAN HAVE IT ALL, MY EMPIRE OF DIRT! 30 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Tapan P. • 3rd+ Distinguished Scientist Addverb, ex Google, NVIDIA 9mo George Hotz dont know you personally. But stick along. You are our last hope.. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Tapan P.’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Tapan P. lol I'm just here as a cheerleader. the demoralization is just beginning. Like Reply Load more comments

Tapan P. • 3rd+ Distinguished Scientist Addverb, ex Google, NVIDIA 9mo George Hotz dont know you personally. But stick along. You are our last hope.. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Tapan P.’s comment George Hotz Author 8mo Tapan P. lol I'm just here as a cheerleader. the demoralization is just beginning. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 8mo Tapan P. lol I'm just here as a cheerleader. the demoralization is just beginning. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Dave Keeshan’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • YOU CAN HAVE IT ALL, MY EMPIRE OF DIRT! 30 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 9mo Did someone hurt you? Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on Dave Keeshan’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Dave Keeshan the system is hurting us all Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo George Hotz Who is "the system"? Willing to be more specific? 😶‍🌫️ Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Most of it stems from the money being fake. The rest is obvious zero/negative sum games the government condones and often participates in. More in a blog post here: https://geohot.github.io/blog/jekyll/update/2025/02/24/money-is-the-map.html …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz I'll have to disagree because money is inanimate. What we're dealing with is animate, not inanimate. Like Reply Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis money doesn't exist, it is a game we all play and some people can and do change the rules when ever they want Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo Dave Keeshan "Just a game"? No... Having the full force of a military etc behind something to enforce it doesn't qualify it as just a game or just in our heads. Like Reply Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis they are the people who can and do change the rules when ever they want, ask the Aussies where their submarines are Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo George Hotz > If real economic growth is only 3 percent, any time you are earning beyond that, somebody else is losing. These macro economic numbers are only useful in comparing one economy or industry with another. They are not truly indicative of growth within an industry, or when a country or industry is compared with itself. > And yet somehow, today, you can put your money in money market accounts and earn a “risk-free” 5 percent Suppose the overall money supply increases overnight; as long as it does not reach hyperinflation, businesses will not raise their prices in response unless there is noticeable supply-chain pressure. Would you suddenly increase prices if your sales increase, assuming you are able to meet the demand and your vendors aren't increasing their prices? Increase in money supply in moderation will cause the economy to produce more without leading to inflation in prices. And this 5 percent could come form various factors, which include, but are not limited to, annual increase in participation in trade in those markets. Therefore, the 3% growth should not be viewed as a universally valid axiom on which base our reasoning. It is highly context-sensitive, mostly having to do with how it was calculated. …more Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo Continuation... In modern economies, the output is never correlated with the number of work-hours, since people extensively optimize their supply chains. So, increase in money supply will only cause more stuff to be produced. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Sreram K long cope for fake money. it clearly isn't better fake. we're just one revolution away from fixing it Like Reply Rahim Khoja • 3rd+ Making Supercomputers Do Useful Things | HPC & AI Infrastructure Engineer @ University of Alberta | Hacker & Creator 8mo George Hotz Wait so you think money doesn't make sense either? Is that what you're talking about. It is a weird issue as money was given in exchange for our labor making goods and providing services. If robots and AI do all the work, or even 60% of it, there wouldn't be a need for money. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Dave Keeshan’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 8mo • YOU CAN HAVE IT ALL, MY EMPIRE OF DIRT! 30 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 9mo Did someone hurt you? Like Reply 11 replies 11 Replies on Dave Keeshan’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Dave Keeshan the system is hurting us all Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo George Hotz Who is "the system"? Willing to be more specific? 😶‍🌫️ Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo James Maniotis Most of it stems from the money being fake. The rest is obvious zero/negative sum games the government condones and often participates in. More in a blog post here: https://geohot.github.io/blog/jekyll/update/2025/02/24/money-is-the-map.html …more Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo George Hotz I'll have to disagree because money is inanimate. What we're dealing with is animate, not inanimate. Like Reply Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis money doesn't exist, it is a game we all play and some people can and do change the rules when ever they want Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 8mo Dave Keeshan "Just a game"? No... Having the full force of a military etc behind something to enforce it doesn't qualify it as just a game or just in our heads. Like Reply Dave Keeshan • 3rd+ Principal Engineer | ASIC & FPGA Specialist 8mo James Maniotis they are the people who can and do change the rules when ever they want, ask the Aussies where their submarines are Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo George Hotz > If real economic growth is only 3 percent, any time you are earning beyond that, somebody else is losing. These macro economic numbers are only useful in comparing one economy or industry with another. They are not truly indicative of growth within an industry, or when a country or industry is compared with itself. > And yet somehow, today, you can put your money in money market accounts and earn a “risk-free” 5 percent Suppose the overall money supply increases overnight; as long as it does not reach hyperinflation, businesses will not raise their prices in response unless there is noticeable supply-chain pressure. Would you suddenly increase prices if your sales increase, assuming you are able to meet the demand and your vendors aren't increasing their prices? Increase in money supply in moderation will cause the economy to produce more without leading to inflation in prices. And this 5 percent could come form various factors, which include, but are not limited to, annual increase in participation in trade in those markets. Therefore, the 3% growth should not be viewed as a universally valid axiom on which base our reasoning. It is highly context-sensitive, mostly having to do with how it was calculated. …more Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 8mo Continuation... In modern economies, the output is never correlated with the number of work-hours, since people extensively optimize their supply chains. So, increase in money supply will only cause more stuff to be produced. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 8mo Sreram K long cope for fake money. it clearly isn't better fake. we're just one revolution away from fixing it Like Reply Rahim Khoja • 3rd+ Making Supercomputers Do Useful Things | HPC & AI Infrastructure Engineer @ University of Alberta | Hacker & Creator 8mo George Hotz Wait so you think money doesn't make sense either? Is that what you're talking about. It is a weird issue as money was given in exchange for our labor making goods and providing services. If robots and AI do all the work, or even 60% of it, there wouldn't be a need for money. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Todor P.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Who's buying a comma 3X? Tesla Autopilot like capabilities for the car you already own, and $799 is the lowest price ever. Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 19 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture 9mo The problem is the law not that the product doesn't work. btw gg Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Todor P.’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Todor Petrov The law, what do you mean? You can join the tens of thousands others who bought this and put it on their car. Like Reply Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture 9mo That's true but in some countries, self-driving cars are not yet approved due to "regulations". Like Reply Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture 9mo George Hotz I fully support you and I am 100% on that boat but have you seen the amount of time it takes a government to make a decision, let alone implement? Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture 9mo The problem is the law not that the product doesn't work. btw gg Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Todor P.’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Todor Petrov The law, what do you mean? You can join the tens of thousands others who bought this and put it on their car. Like Reply Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture 9mo That's true but in some countries, self-driving cars are not yet approved due to "regulations". Like Reply Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture 9mo George Hotz I fully support you and I am 100% on that boat but have you seen the amount of time it takes a government to make a decision, let alone implement? Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo Todor Petrov The law, what do you mean? You can join the tens of thousands others who bought this and put it on their car. Like Reply

Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture 9mo That's true but in some countries, self-driving cars are not yet approved due to "regulations". Like Reply

Todor P. • 3rd+ CX Cyber Security Culture Expert Enhancing Cyber Security Culture 9mo George Hotz I fully support you and I am 100% on that boat but have you seen the amount of time it takes a government to make a decision, let alone implement? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Who's buying a comma 3X? Tesla Autopilot like capabilities for the car you already own, and $799 is the lowest price ever. Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 19 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 9mo Also made in America, not cause of dumb tariff crap, but because I like owning the means of production. Learned that from the communists. …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 9mo Also made in America, not cause of dumb tariff crap, but because I like owning the means of production. Learned that from the communists. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Sreram K’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • idk why you guys are all so into money like you know its fake right? ppl like lie and pollute their mind in exchange for fake paper crap made up by the government that you can't even buy anything good with like slaves or sovereignty anymore. smh …more 72 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz Gold won't work. Use bitcoins instead. It has the same properties, except that all your payments are transparent. That's also solved when you use a mixer. Money is not fake as long as people accept it. Criminals launder money to buy what you mentioned by creating fake transactions. Why won't gold work? It is inconvenient to carry and use, and it can be stolen. That's why people preferred bank notes over gold, and didn't bother to withdraw gold from the bank. If you really do bring gold back, someone would open a company for "safe keeping" the gold, and give you a note in exchange for it. When they realize that you find the use of their notes more convenient, they will start to lend new bank-notes, which won't be a problem as long as they are paid back and there is no bank run. The temptation to print more notes than gold cannot be resisted by anyone. This is why, it won't work. What we need is direct democracy. Only that can save the society. …more Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on Sreram K’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo @ Sreram K you clearly haven't heard about the 22 million project Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz No I haven't. And Searching didn't give me much. Is it this one? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025 (since the budget is 22 million) US is a republic not a democracy. The only country close to a democracy is Switzerland. We need direct democracy where people can directly influence law making. This is much easier to execute today. Direct democracy will solve most problems. …more Project 2025 - Wikipedia Conservative political initiative in the United States "Project '25" redirects here. For the telecommunications standard, see Project 25 . Project 2025 (also known as the 2025 Presidential Transition Project ) [ 3 ] is a political initiative published... Like Reply George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K oh the 22 million project has a slogan "just a few more coins" but sounds like you are late to it so idk if you are gonna get any of them Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 9mo George Hotz Not sure what that is. I couldn't find anything unfortunately. Like Reply George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K yea it's pretty underground now. but i think you can guess from the name what it might be about. it's bitcoin related Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz If it is about buying out most of the bitcoins and creating a treasury to give out bank notes, that won't work. They need to maintain some trade volume to prove its value. So it is actually good for the ecosystem if large institutions buy bitcoins (the more these institutions hold bitcoins, the safer the ecosystem will be, since they will not want to devalue the asset they own. Which is safer than dollars since those assets cannot be seized or frozen). Whatever it may be, the idea bitcoins introduced to the world along with blockchains can never fade away. In the future, a new bitcoin network can be created as a fork and people could continue from there (they can even migrate the coins to the new network avoiding the cold start problem altogether, I have an idea for that). Decentralization is fundamentally democratic, and bitcoins just represents its first few iterations. …more Like Reply Dimitri Claude • 3rd+ Conducteur d'engin en GD 9mo George Hotz No connection with the monasteries here? Like Reply Arik Elfassy • 3rd+ Director, Head of Global Clinical Serology 8mo George Hotz because it doesn’t exist! Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz Gold won't work. Use bitcoins instead. It has the same properties, except that all your payments are transparent. That's also solved when you use a mixer. Money is not fake as long as people accept it. Criminals launder money to buy what you mentioned by creating fake transactions. Why won't gold work? It is inconvenient to carry and use, and it can be stolen. That's why people preferred bank notes over gold, and didn't bother to withdraw gold from the bank. If you really do bring gold back, someone would open a company for "safe keeping" the gold, and give you a note in exchange for it. When they realize that you find the use of their notes more convenient, they will start to lend new bank-notes, which won't be a problem as long as they are paid back and there is no bank run. The temptation to print more notes than gold cannot be resisted by anyone. This is why, it won't work. What we need is direct democracy. Only that can save the society. …more Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on Sreram K’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo @ Sreram K you clearly haven't heard about the 22 million project Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz No I haven't. And Searching didn't give me much. Is it this one? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025 (since the budget is 22 million) US is a republic not a democracy. The only country close to a democracy is Switzerland. We need direct democracy where people can directly influence law making. This is much easier to execute today. Direct democracy will solve most problems. …more Project 2025 - Wikipedia Conservative political initiative in the United States "Project '25" redirects here. For the telecommunications standard, see Project 25 . Project 2025 (also known as the 2025 Presidential Transition Project ) [ 3 ] is a political initiative published... Like Reply George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K oh the 22 million project has a slogan "just a few more coins" but sounds like you are late to it so idk if you are gonna get any of them Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 9mo George Hotz Not sure what that is. I couldn't find anything unfortunately. Like Reply George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K yea it's pretty underground now. but i think you can guess from the name what it might be about. it's bitcoin related Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz If it is about buying out most of the bitcoins and creating a treasury to give out bank notes, that won't work. They need to maintain some trade volume to prove its value. So it is actually good for the ecosystem if large institutions buy bitcoins (the more these institutions hold bitcoins, the safer the ecosystem will be, since they will not want to devalue the asset they own. Which is safer than dollars since those assets cannot be seized or frozen). Whatever it may be, the idea bitcoins introduced to the world along with blockchains can never fade away. In the future, a new bitcoin network can be created as a fork and people could continue from there (they can even migrate the coins to the new network avoiding the cold start problem altogether, I have an idea for that). Decentralization is fundamentally democratic, and bitcoins just represents its first few iterations. …more Like Reply Dimitri Claude • 3rd+ Conducteur d'engin en GD 9mo George Hotz No connection with the monasteries here? Like Reply Arik Elfassy • 3rd+ Director, Head of Global Clinical Serology 8mo George Hotz because it doesn’t exist! Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo @ Sreram K you clearly haven't heard about the 22 million project Like Reply

Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz No I haven't. And Searching didn't give me much. Is it this one? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025 (since the budget is 22 million) US is a republic not a democracy. The only country close to a democracy is Switzerland. We need direct democracy where people can directly influence law making. This is much easier to execute today. Direct democracy will solve most problems. …more Project 2025 - Wikipedia Conservative political initiative in the United States "Project '25" redirects here. For the telecommunications standard, see Project 25 . Project 2025 (also known as the 2025 Presidential Transition Project ) [ 3 ] is a political initiative published... Like Reply

Project 2025 - Wikipedia Conservative political initiative in the United States "Project '25" redirects here. For the telecommunications standard, see Project 25 . Project 2025 (also known as the 2025 Presidential Transition Project ) [ 3 ] is a political initiative published...

George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K oh the 22 million project has a slogan "just a few more coins" but sounds like you are late to it so idk if you are gonna get any of them Like Reply

Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 9mo George Hotz Not sure what that is. I couldn't find anything unfortunately. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K yea it's pretty underground now. but i think you can guess from the name what it might be about. it's bitcoin related Like Reply

Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz If it is about buying out most of the bitcoins and creating a treasury to give out bank notes, that won't work. They need to maintain some trade volume to prove its value. So it is actually good for the ecosystem if large institutions buy bitcoins (the more these institutions hold bitcoins, the safer the ecosystem will be, since they will not want to devalue the asset they own. Which is safer than dollars since those assets cannot be seized or frozen). Whatever it may be, the idea bitcoins introduced to the world along with blockchains can never fade away. In the future, a new bitcoin network can be created as a fork and people could continue from there (they can even migrate the coins to the new network avoiding the cold start problem altogether, I have an idea for that). Decentralization is fundamentally democratic, and bitcoins just represents its first few iterations. …more Like Reply

Dimitri Claude • 3rd+ Conducteur d'engin en GD 9mo George Hotz No connection with the monasteries here? Like Reply

Arik Elfassy • 3rd+ Director, Head of Global Clinical Serology 8mo George Hotz because it doesn’t exist! Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jefferey Odgis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • idk why you guys are all so into money like you know its fake right? ppl like lie and pollute their mind in exchange for fake paper crap made up by the government that you can't even buy anything good with like slaves or sovereignty anymore. smh …more 72 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jefferey Odgis • 3rd+ Technology & Media Consultant 9mo Favorite comment here in some time 🤣 Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Jefferey Odgis’ comment George Hotz Author 9mo Jefferey Odgis we can be the change we want to see. only you can help prevent late stage capitalism Like Reply Jefferey Odgis • 3rd+ Technology & Media Consultant 9mo George Hotz Independent of the merits of the notion, I cherish this interaction and I hope you like memes Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Jefferey Odgis • 3rd+ Technology & Media Consultant 9mo Favorite comment here in some time 🤣 Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Jefferey Odgis’ comment George Hotz Author 9mo Jefferey Odgis we can be the change we want to see. only you can help prevent late stage capitalism Like Reply Jefferey Odgis • 3rd+ Technology & Media Consultant 9mo George Hotz Independent of the merits of the notion, I cherish this interaction and I hope you like memes Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo Jefferey Odgis we can be the change we want to see. only you can help prevent late stage capitalism Like Reply

Jefferey Odgis • 3rd+ Technology & Media Consultant 9mo George Hotz Independent of the merits of the notion, I cherish this interaction and I hope you like memes Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Brian Greenforest’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Questionable company alert: Etched. Claiming ">20x faster than H100s" by "burning the transformer architecture into chips" It's the perfect trap for 120 IQ VCs. They know engineering is all about tradeoffs, and they see a company being so upfront with their tradeoff. But that's the trick. That's what the magician wants you to look at. VCs evaluate if the "transformer architecture" warrants chip levels of investment, but they don't question the entire premise to begin with. You give: flexibility of your chip. You get: nothing! Google TPUs and NVIDIA GPUs are already highly optimized for transformers. You will not get 20x by specializing. In fact, due to NVIDIA and Google's outsized R&D spend, you probably won't even get 1x. If you are seriously thinking about investing in Etched, I'll do a free 15 minute phone call with you and explain in whatever technical depth you want why this doesn't work. No gain for me, just because we live in a society and people shouldn't be pissing money away like this. …more 90 comments 22 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Brian Greenforest • 3rd+ An anti-black-box engineer 9mo I had a pleasure of having a private chat with the founders. Dissecting this Transformer thing since 2022 into FMAs onto 3 nm designs for very private clients, I assure you they undermine their claims. Think 1000x faster than Nvidia. hashtag #BUY. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Brian Greenforest’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Brian Greenforest I'm actually not sure if this is sarcastic or not. If not, oh yes, the secret good 3nm FMAs that NVIDIA and Google don't know about of course of course, how did I forget about them. Like Reply Load more comments

Brian Greenforest • 3rd+ An anti-black-box engineer 9mo I had a pleasure of having a private chat with the founders. Dissecting this Transformer thing since 2022 into FMAs onto 3 nm designs for very private clients, I assure you they undermine their claims. Think 1000x faster than Nvidia. hashtag #BUY. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Brian Greenforest’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Brian Greenforest I'm actually not sure if this is sarcastic or not. If not, oh yes, the secret good 3nm FMAs that NVIDIA and Google don't know about of course of course, how did I forget about them. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 9mo Brian Greenforest I'm actually not sure if this is sarcastic or not. If not, oh yes, the secret good 3nm FMAs that NVIDIA and Google don't know about of course of course, how did I forget about them. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Sreram K’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • idk why you guys are all so into money like you know its fake right? ppl like lie and pollute their mind in exchange for fake paper crap made up by the government that you can't even buy anything good with like slaves or sovereignty anymore. smh …more 72 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz Gold won't work. Use bitcoins instead. It has the same properties, except that all your payments are transparent. That's also solved when you use a mixer. Money is not fake as long as people accept it. Criminals launder money to buy what you mentioned by creating fake transactions. Why won't gold work? It is inconvenient to carry and use, and it can be stolen. That's why people preferred bank notes over gold, and didn't bother to withdraw gold from the bank. If you really do bring gold back, someone would open a company for "safe keeping" the gold, and give you a note in exchange for it. When they realize that you find the use of their notes more convenient, they will start to lend new bank-notes, which won't be a problem as long as they are paid back and there is no bank run. The temptation to print more notes than gold cannot be resisted by anyone. This is why, it won't work. What we need is direct democracy. Only that can save the society. …more Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on Sreram K’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo @ Sreram K you clearly haven't heard about the 22 million project Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz No I haven't. And Searching didn't give me much. Is it this one? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025 (since the budget is 22 million) US is a republic not a democracy. The only country close to a democracy is Switzerland. We need direct democracy where people can directly influence law making. This is much easier to execute today. Direct democracy will solve most problems. …more Project 2025 - Wikipedia Conservative political initiative in the United States "Project '25" redirects here. For the telecommunications standard, see Project 25 . Project 2025 (also known as the 2025 Presidential Transition Project ) [ 3 ] is a political initiative published... Like Reply George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K oh the 22 million project has a slogan "just a few more coins" but sounds like you are late to it so idk if you are gonna get any of them Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 9mo George Hotz Not sure what that is. I couldn't find anything unfortunately. Like Reply George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K yea it's pretty underground now. but i think you can guess from the name what it might be about. it's bitcoin related Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz If it is about buying out most of the bitcoins and creating a treasury to give out bank notes, that won't work. They need to maintain some trade volume to prove its value. So it is actually good for the ecosystem if large institutions buy bitcoins (the more these institutions hold bitcoins, the safer the ecosystem will be, since they will not want to devalue the asset they own. Which is safer than dollars since those assets cannot be seized or frozen). Whatever it may be, the idea bitcoins introduced to the world along with blockchains can never fade away. In the future, a new bitcoin network can be created as a fork and people could continue from there (they can even migrate the coins to the new network avoiding the cold start problem altogether, I have an idea for that). Decentralization is fundamentally democratic, and bitcoins just represents its first few iterations. …more Like Reply Dimitri Claude • 3rd+ Conducteur d'engin en GD 9mo George Hotz No connection with the monasteries here? Like Reply Arik Elfassy • 3rd+ Director, Head of Global Clinical Serology 8mo George Hotz because it doesn’t exist! Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Bert Maher’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Questionable company alert: Etched. Claiming ">20x faster than H100s" by "burning the transformer architecture into chips" It's the perfect trap for 120 IQ VCs. They know engineering is all about tradeoffs, and they see a company being so upfront with their tradeoff. But that's the trick. That's what the magician wants you to look at. VCs evaluate if the "transformer architecture" warrants chip levels of investment, but they don't question the entire premise to begin with. You give: flexibility of your chip. You get: nothing! Google TPUs and NVIDIA GPUs are already highly optimized for transformers. You will not get 20x by specializing. In fact, due to NVIDIA and Google's outsized R&D spend, you probably won't even get 1x. If you are seriously thinking about investing in Etched, I'll do a free 15 minute phone call with you and explain in whatever technical depth you want why this doesn't work. No gain for me, just because we live in a society and people shouldn't be pissing money away like this. …more 90 comments 22 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Bert Maher • 3rd+ Member of Technical Staff @ Anthropic 9mo I'm trying to think through if the basic physics even works. Like if you put 10x more MMAs/mm^2 on the chip, does it vaporize, or merely melt? …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Bert Maher’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Bertrand Maher the best thing about vaporware chips is they draw 0W. very easy to cool Like Reply Artyom P. • 3rd+ Software engineer at Google 9mo If it's the same amount of transistors, why would the energy consumption be any different? Like Reply Chris Feilbach • 3rd+ Senior CPU Architect at NVIDIA 9mo Artyom P. Without any specific comment on anything in this post: different activity factors, different sized transistors, different wire layers used, different voltages, different frequencies. Lots of reasons. …more Like Reply Servet Coskun • 3rd+ Hardware Development Lead @ Moonboon (edited) 9mo George Hotz it’s cause they are pulling wattage through a parallel quantum dimension with their inhouse developed qubits lib. It so obvious. (Written in python ofc). Like Reply Lyndon Samson • 3rd+ Senior Devops/SRE/Integration Consultant 9mo Bertrand Maher the magics in reversibility maybe 😀 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversible_computing Although achieving this goal presents a significant challenge for the design, manufacturing, and characterization of ultra-precise new physical mechanisms for computing, there is at present no fundamental reason to think that this goal cannot eventually be accomplished, allowing someday to build computers that generate much less than 1 bit's worth of physical entropy (and dissipate much less than kT ln 2 energy to heat) for each useful logical operation that they carry out internally. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Bert Maher • 3rd+ Member of Technical Staff @ Anthropic 9mo I'm trying to think through if the basic physics even works. Like if you put 10x more MMAs/mm^2 on the chip, does it vaporize, or merely melt? …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Bert Maher’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Bertrand Maher the best thing about vaporware chips is they draw 0W. very easy to cool Like Reply Artyom P. • 3rd+ Software engineer at Google 9mo If it's the same amount of transistors, why would the energy consumption be any different? Like Reply Chris Feilbach • 3rd+ Senior CPU Architect at NVIDIA 9mo Artyom P. Without any specific comment on anything in this post: different activity factors, different sized transistors, different wire layers used, different voltages, different frequencies. Lots of reasons. …more Like Reply Servet Coskun • 3rd+ Hardware Development Lead @ Moonboon (edited) 9mo George Hotz it’s cause they are pulling wattage through a parallel quantum dimension with their inhouse developed qubits lib. It so obvious. (Written in python ofc). Like Reply Lyndon Samson • 3rd+ Senior Devops/SRE/Integration Consultant 9mo Bertrand Maher the magics in reversibility maybe 😀 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversible_computing Although achieving this goal presents a significant challenge for the design, manufacturing, and characterization of ultra-precise new physical mechanisms for computing, there is at present no fundamental reason to think that this goal cannot eventually be accomplished, allowing someday to build computers that generate much less than 1 bit's worth of physical entropy (and dissipate much less than kT ln 2 energy to heat) for each useful logical operation that they carry out internally. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo Bertrand Maher the best thing about vaporware chips is they draw 0W. very easy to cool Like Reply

Artyom P. • 3rd+ Software engineer at Google 9mo If it's the same amount of transistors, why would the energy consumption be any different? Like Reply

Chris Feilbach • 3rd+ Senior CPU Architect at NVIDIA 9mo Artyom P. Without any specific comment on anything in this post: different activity factors, different sized transistors, different wire layers used, different voltages, different frequencies. Lots of reasons. …more Like Reply

Servet Coskun • 3rd+ Hardware Development Lead @ Moonboon (edited) 9mo George Hotz it’s cause they are pulling wattage through a parallel quantum dimension with their inhouse developed qubits lib. It so obvious. (Written in python ofc). Like Reply

Lyndon Samson • 3rd+ Senior Devops/SRE/Integration Consultant 9mo Bertrand Maher the magics in reversibility maybe 😀 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversible_computing Although achieving this goal presents a significant challenge for the design, manufacturing, and characterization of ultra-precise new physical mechanisms for computing, there is at present no fundamental reason to think that this goal cannot eventually be accomplished, allowing someday to build computers that generate much less than 1 bit's worth of physical entropy (and dissipate much less than kT ln 2 energy to heat) for each useful logical operation that they carry out internally. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Sreram K’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • idk why you guys are all so into money like you know its fake right? ppl like lie and pollute their mind in exchange for fake paper crap made up by the government that you can't even buy anything good with like slaves or sovereignty anymore. smh …more 72 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz Gold won't work. Use bitcoins instead. It has the same properties, except that all your payments are transparent. That's also solved when you use a mixer. Money is not fake as long as people accept it. Criminals launder money to buy what you mentioned by creating fake transactions. Why won't gold work? It is inconvenient to carry and use, and it can be stolen. That's why people preferred bank notes over gold, and didn't bother to withdraw gold from the bank. If you really do bring gold back, someone would open a company for "safe keeping" the gold, and give you a note in exchange for it. When they realize that you find the use of their notes more convenient, they will start to lend new bank-notes, which won't be a problem as long as they are paid back and there is no bank run. The temptation to print more notes than gold cannot be resisted by anyone. This is why, it won't work. What we need is direct democracy. Only that can save the society. …more Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on Sreram K’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo @ Sreram K you clearly haven't heard about the 22 million project Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz No I haven't. And Searching didn't give me much. Is it this one? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025 (since the budget is 22 million) US is a republic not a democracy. The only country close to a democracy is Switzerland. We need direct democracy where people can directly influence law making. This is much easier to execute today. Direct democracy will solve most problems. …more Project 2025 - Wikipedia Conservative political initiative in the United States "Project '25" redirects here. For the telecommunications standard, see Project 25 . Project 2025 (also known as the 2025 Presidential Transition Project ) [ 3 ] is a political initiative published... Like Reply George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K oh the 22 million project has a slogan "just a few more coins" but sounds like you are late to it so idk if you are gonna get any of them Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. 9mo George Hotz Not sure what that is. I couldn't find anything unfortunately. Like Reply George Hotz Author 9mo Sreram K yea it's pretty underground now. but i think you can guess from the name what it might be about. it's bitcoin related Like Reply Sreram K • 3rd+ I solve problems by developing software and/or building AI and ML models. (edited) 9mo George Hotz If it is about buying out most of the bitcoins and creating a treasury to give out bank notes, that won't work. They need to maintain some trade volume to prove its value. So it is actually good for the ecosystem if large institutions buy bitcoins (the more these institutions hold bitcoins, the safer the ecosystem will be, since they will not want to devalue the asset they own. Which is safer than dollars since those assets cannot be seized or frozen). Whatever it may be, the idea bitcoins introduced to the world along with blockchains can never fade away. In the future, a new bitcoin network can be created as a fork and people could continue from there (they can even migrate the coins to the new network avoiding the cold start problem altogether, I have an idea for that). Decentralization is fundamentally democratic, and bitcoins just represents its first few iterations. …more Like Reply Dimitri Claude • 3rd+ Conducteur d'engin en GD 9mo George Hotz No connection with the monasteries here? Like Reply Arik Elfassy • 3rd+ Director, Head of Global Clinical Serology 8mo George Hotz because it doesn’t exist! Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to James Maniotis’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • idk why you guys are all so into money like you know its fake right? ppl like lie and pollute their mind in exchange for fake paper crap made up by the government that you can't even buy anything good with like slaves or sovereignty anymore. smh …more 72 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo Being a blatant grifter is no longer taboo. It is basically the norm... I'm all for making it feel taboo again! …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author 9mo James Maniotis make grifting lame again! Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo George Hotz Unfortunately, for every grifter's LinkedIn thread I comment on - there are 10+ other commenters trying to manage any opposition to their industry's grift. And people wonder why "impostor syndrome" is so common 🤣 …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo Being a blatant grifter is no longer taboo. It is basically the norm... I'm all for making it feel taboo again! …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on James Maniotis’ comment George Hotz Author 9mo James Maniotis make grifting lame again! Like Reply James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo George Hotz Unfortunately, for every grifter's LinkedIn thread I comment on - there are 10+ other commenters trying to manage any opposition to their industry's grift. And people wonder why "impostor syndrome" is so common 🤣 …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo James Maniotis make grifting lame again! Like Reply

James Maniotis • 3rd+ Founder at make.courses 9mo George Hotz Unfortunately, for every grifter's LinkedIn thread I comment on - there are 10+ other commenters trying to manage any opposition to their industry's grift. And people wonder why "impostor syndrome" is so common 🤣 …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Yacine Zahidi’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Idea for increasing Business Revenue. Hire a worker in a low cost country to be on a video call on the upper right corner of the self checkout screen. They are ostensibly there to be helpful, like you can show them the grapes and they will put in the code for grapes. Then you add the tipping screen to self checkout and the person makes sure to make good eye contact with the camera while you are on that screen. Enough people will tip that you will easily be profitable. Make sure in your marketing materials to show off the call center that these people are in, but then start A/B testing with AI. Use RL to optimize the AI for the tip. But make sure to keep your use of AI very confidential, this business model relies on evoking genuine human to human emotion. …more 40 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send Yacine Zahidi • 3rd+ Machine Learning Engineer 9mo So creative I can't tell if that's really smart or really stupid. That's how you know it's a great idea 💡 Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Yacine Zahidi’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Yacine Zahidi it will definitely increase Business Revenue. It's almost like capitalism has been entirely goodharted out and is no longer remotely related to providing a better good or service. Like Reply Ms Scofield • 3rd+ Security researcher, Mathematician 9mo George Hotz Hello, I am under 18 years old. Would you be willing to talk to me for advice and questions? Like Reply Simon Swanepoel • 3rd+ 🚀 RocketNet Founder, CEO | Father | Human Being 9mo Vipera Scofield grok has different personas, why not create a George Hotz persona in voice mode, and you can have long chats and sip on margaritas while doing so! Sounds like heaven 😉 Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Yacine Zahidi • 3rd+ Machine Learning Engineer 9mo So creative I can't tell if that's really smart or really stupid. That's how you know it's a great idea 💡 Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Yacine Zahidi’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Yacine Zahidi it will definitely increase Business Revenue. It's almost like capitalism has been entirely goodharted out and is no longer remotely related to providing a better good or service. Like Reply Ms Scofield • 3rd+ Security researcher, Mathematician 9mo George Hotz Hello, I am under 18 years old. Would you be willing to talk to me for advice and questions? Like Reply Simon Swanepoel • 3rd+ 🚀 RocketNet Founder, CEO | Father | Human Being 9mo Vipera Scofield grok has different personas, why not create a George Hotz persona in voice mode, and you can have long chats and sip on margaritas while doing so! Sounds like heaven 😉 Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo Yacine Zahidi it will definitely increase Business Revenue. It's almost like capitalism has been entirely goodharted out and is no longer remotely related to providing a better good or service. Like Reply

Ms Scofield • 3rd+ Security researcher, Mathematician 9mo George Hotz Hello, I am under 18 years old. Would you be willing to talk to me for advice and questions? Like Reply

Simon Swanepoel • 3rd+ 🚀 RocketNet Founder, CEO | Father | Human Being 9mo Vipera Scofield grok has different personas, why not create a George Hotz persona in voice mode, and you can have long chats and sip on margaritas while doing so! Sounds like heaven 😉 Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Idea for increasing Business Revenue. Hire a worker in a low cost country to be on a video call on the upper right corner of the self checkout screen. They are ostensibly there to be helpful, like you can show them the grapes and they will put in the code for grapes. Then you add the tipping screen to self checkout and the person makes sure to make good eye contact with the camera while you are on that screen. Enough people will tip that you will easily be profitable. Make sure in your marketing materials to show off the call center that these people are in, but then start A/B testing with AI. Use RL to optimize the AI for the tip. But make sure to keep your use of AI very confidential, this business model relies on evoking genuine human to human emotion. …more 40 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 9mo This business idea could help lower the cost of groceries for marginalized communities. Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Simon Swanepoel • 3rd+ 🚀 RocketNet Founder, CEO | Father | Human Being 9mo Vipera Scofield Wow you’ve done really well, been at university since 2009, I’m guessing your 17, if you say you’re under 18, which means you started university at the age of 1, you’ve got no real picture and your profile isn’t verified… hmmm 🤔 George, I’d say give him a chance. 😂😂😂 …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 9mo This business idea could help lower the cost of groceries for marginalized communities. Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Simon Swanepoel • 3rd+ 🚀 RocketNet Founder, CEO | Father | Human Being 9mo Vipera Scofield Wow you’ve done really well, been at university since 2009, I’m guessing your 17, if you say you’re under 18, which means you started university at the age of 1, you’ve got no real picture and your profile isn’t verified… hmmm 🤔 George, I’d say give him a chance. 😂😂😂 …more Like Reply

Simon Swanepoel • 3rd+ 🚀 RocketNet Founder, CEO | Father | Human Being 9mo Vipera Scofield Wow you’ve done really well, been at university since 2009, I’m guessing your 17, if you say you’re under 18, which means you started university at the age of 1, you’ve got no real picture and your profile isn’t verified… hmmm 🤔 George, I’d say give him a chance. 😂😂😂 …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jonathan Sandhu’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Why do datacenter providers not want to answer a simple question. What's the all in cost per kWh? No redundancy, can build the computer at the cheapest density. Like I don't understand why they can't just answer this. Is this like Nigerian e-mail scams having typos on purpose so that they only get idiots to reply? Or do they know they are hopelessly uncompetitive? Like why do they want to schedule a stupid phone call do they think I'll forget what I'm asking for or something? Crypto miners are doing this for 6c / kWh all in, some even cheaper. Can anyone match that? …more 52 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 9mo They're not avoiding your question, they're avoiding accountability. If they reveal the real all-in cost, they expose how much of the bill covers legacy overhead, marketing fluff, and cushy margins. Crypto miners build for efficiency because margins demand it. Datacenters build for opacity because customers tolerate it. They hope you’ll settle for the phone call and forget why you asked. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Jonathan Sandhu’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Jonathan Sandhu Every time I hear that people want a phone call, I know that fundamentally the customers are paying for these phone calls. Real costs would be cheaper if the phone calls went away and the price was listed on the website! …more Like Reply Philip Oliver • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer and Architect / Biotech co-founder 9mo I almost always shun any company that insists on a call rather than openly listing prices on a site. Like Reply Charlie Holt • 3rd+ Software Developer 9mo Jonathan Sandhu exactly this. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Jonathan Sandhu • 3rd+ Constraint Analysis & Execution Provenance for Enterprise and Defense Systems 9mo They're not avoiding your question, they're avoiding accountability. If they reveal the real all-in cost, they expose how much of the bill covers legacy overhead, marketing fluff, and cushy margins. Crypto miners build for efficiency because margins demand it. Datacenters build for opacity because customers tolerate it. They hope you’ll settle for the phone call and forget why you asked. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Jonathan Sandhu’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Jonathan Sandhu Every time I hear that people want a phone call, I know that fundamentally the customers are paying for these phone calls. Real costs would be cheaper if the phone calls went away and the price was listed on the website! …more Like Reply Philip Oliver • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer and Architect / Biotech co-founder 9mo I almost always shun any company that insists on a call rather than openly listing prices on a site. Like Reply Charlie Holt • 3rd+ Software Developer 9mo Jonathan Sandhu exactly this. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo Jonathan Sandhu Every time I hear that people want a phone call, I know that fundamentally the customers are paying for these phone calls. Real costs would be cheaper if the phone calls went away and the price was listed on the website! …more Like Reply

Philip Oliver • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer and Architect / Biotech co-founder 9mo I almost always shun any company that insists on a call rather than openly listing prices on a site. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jimmy Odom’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Why do datacenter providers not want to answer a simple question. What's the all in cost per kWh? No redundancy, can build the computer at the cheapest density. Like I don't understand why they can't just answer this. Is this like Nigerian e-mail scams having typos on purpose so that they only get idiots to reply? Or do they know they are hopelessly uncompetitive? Like why do they want to schedule a stupid phone call do they think I'll forget what I'm asking for or something? Crypto miners are doing this for 6c / kWh all in, some even cheaper. Can anyone match that? …more 52 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jimmy Odom • 3rd+ Co-Founding Partner at Bit Capital Group • Bitcoin Class of 2014 9mo Then answer is no! Miners are building sites (Tier 0) at around $300-600k/MW (largely dependent on region) whereas Tier 3 sites are nearly $5-11M/MW. So don't ask for 6c when you already know its never going to happen. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Jimmy Odom’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Jimmy Odom I want tier 0 for my computers! Like Reply Jimmy Odom • 3rd+ Co-Founding Partner at Bit Capital Group • Bitcoin Class of 2014 9mo George, alright, word! Can you commit to 10-20MW? If so, I'd be open to possibly hosting you guys up here in WA Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Jimmy Odom • 3rd+ Co-Founding Partner at Bit Capital Group • Bitcoin Class of 2014 9mo Then answer is no! Miners are building sites (Tier 0) at around $300-600k/MW (largely dependent on region) whereas Tier 3 sites are nearly $5-11M/MW. So don't ask for 6c when you already know its never going to happen. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Jimmy Odom’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Jimmy Odom I want tier 0 for my computers! Like Reply Jimmy Odom • 3rd+ Co-Founding Partner at Bit Capital Group • Bitcoin Class of 2014 9mo George, alright, word! Can you commit to 10-20MW? If so, I'd be open to possibly hosting you guys up here in WA Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo Jimmy Odom I want tier 0 for my computers! Like Reply

Jimmy Odom • 3rd+ Co-Founding Partner at Bit Capital Group • Bitcoin Class of 2014 9mo George, alright, word! Can you commit to 10-20MW? If so, I'd be open to possibly hosting you guys up here in WA Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to their own comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Why do datacenter providers not want to answer a simple question. What's the all in cost per kWh? No redundancy, can build the computer at the cheapest density. Like I don't understand why they can't just answer this. Is this like Nigerian e-mail scams having typos on purpose so that they only get idiots to reply? Or do they know they are hopelessly uncompetitive? Like why do they want to schedule a stupid phone call do they think I'll forget what I'm asking for or something? Crypto miners are doing this for 6c / kWh all in, some even cheaper. Can anyone match that? …more 52 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 9mo I think there's a lot of things like this where there's a very simple metric, but the market loves to distort it because finding suckers who can't do math is more profitable than providing a service at 20% margins. …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Jordan German • 3rd+ Bitcoin, Energy, Bitcoin Mining 9mo Cal Day Ham Nothing is stopping him from building his own site if it’s so easy and should be 20% margins or less. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 9mo I think there's a lot of things like this where there's a very simple metric, but the market loves to distort it because finding suckers who can't do math is more profitable than providing a service at 20% margins. …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Jordan German • 3rd+ Bitcoin, Energy, Bitcoin Mining 9mo Cal Day Ham Nothing is stopping him from building his own site if it’s so easy and should be 20% margins or less. Like Reply

Jordan German • 3rd+ Bitcoin, Energy, Bitcoin Mining 9mo Cal Day Ham Nothing is stopping him from building his own site if it’s so easy and should be 20% margins or less. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • Why do datacenter providers not want to answer a simple question. What's the all in cost per kWh? No redundancy, can build the computer at the cheapest density. Like I don't understand why they can't just answer this. Is this like Nigerian e-mail scams having typos on purpose so that they only get idiots to reply? Or do they know they are hopelessly uncompetitive? Like why do they want to schedule a stupid phone call do they think I'll forget what I'm asking for or something? Crypto miners are doing this for 6c / kWh all in, some even cheaper. Can anyone match that? …more 52 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 9mo I think there's a lot of things like this where there's a very simple metric, but the market loves to distort it because finding suckers who can't do math is more profitable than providing a service at 20% margins. …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Jordan German • 3rd+ Bitcoin, Energy, Bitcoin Mining 9mo Cal Day Ham Nothing is stopping him from building his own site if it’s so easy and should be 20% margins or less. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • dawg if the price isn't on the website you should always just nope Josh Sorenson Josh Sorenson • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ VP of Systems | Church Media Squad | Streamlining Creative Ops with Automation & No-Code VP of Systems | Church Media Squad | Streamlining Creative Ops with Automation & No-Code 9mo • Follow I hate the enterprise sales cycle. If I have to sit through 2–3 calls just to get basic pricing, I’m out. I don’t need a discovery call to explain the problem, I already know what I need. I’m just trying to see if your solution fits. Gatekeeping pricing is a waste of time. For you and for me. If your product is solid and your pricing is fair, lead with it. Don’t make me jump through hoops to get to the part that actually matters. …more 5 comments 1 repost Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 9mo comma and tiny corp put the prices on the website Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 9mo comma and tiny corp put the prices on the website Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Maarten Elgar’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • has anyone else noticed a big uptick in email spam recently? they are getting more desperate. that first hit feels sooo good. one blast to the mailing list. attention, traction, conversion. the rush. you do it again tomorrow. it feels good, why not. fast forward to the 34th hit. it just doesn't feel the same. you've been blocked, spam reported, screened, filtered...and you don't get that same high. you are out of options though, you can't stop, you have to do more. if you stop, things will decline. that little trickle of a high you are still getting will give way to pain. you definitely can't stop. you are in too deep. but you aren't too far gone. you are still with us. stop. you can still be saved. friends don't let friends be spammers. you can save a life. …more 25 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Maarten Elgar • 3rd+ CTO @ solarproject 9mo We need penalties in the system, cost & consequences to be higher. Only relevant products and brands will market to you if they believe they actually have something to offer to you. How can my impression / response cause penalty on the email sender? …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Maarten Elgar’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Maarten Elgar sending me an email should cost $1 and I get the dollar. it'll still be worth it for some marketing, but at least my coffees are now free. Like Reply Maarten Elgar • 3rd+ CTO @ solarproject 9mo George Hotz living the dream I see :) Like Reply Maarten Elgar • 3rd+ CTO @ solarproject 9mo Awaiting the next Tinygrad stream :) Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Maarten Elgar • 3rd+ CTO @ solarproject 9mo We need penalties in the system, cost & consequences to be higher. Only relevant products and brands will market to you if they believe they actually have something to offer to you. How can my impression / response cause penalty on the email sender? …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Maarten Elgar’s comment George Hotz Author 9mo Maarten Elgar sending me an email should cost $1 and I get the dollar. it'll still be worth it for some marketing, but at least my coffees are now free. Like Reply Maarten Elgar • 3rd+ CTO @ solarproject 9mo George Hotz living the dream I see :) Like Reply Maarten Elgar • 3rd+ CTO @ solarproject 9mo Awaiting the next Tinygrad stream :) Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 9mo Maarten Elgar sending me an email should cost $1 and I get the dollar. it'll still be worth it for some marketing, but at least my coffees are now free. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 9mo • has anyone else noticed a big uptick in email spam recently? they are getting more desperate. that first hit feels sooo good. one blast to the mailing list. attention, traction, conversion. the rush. you do it again tomorrow. it feels good, why not. fast forward to the 34th hit. it just doesn't feel the same. you've been blocked, spam reported, screened, filtered...and you don't get that same high. you are out of options though, you can't stop, you have to do more. if you stop, things will decline. that little trickle of a high you are still getting will give way to pain. you definitely can't stop. you are in too deep. but you aren't too far gone. you are still with us. stop. you can still be saved. friends don't let friends be spammers. you can save a life. …more 25 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 9mo And yes, I'm talking about you. I'm not talking about v!@gr@ spam, I'm talking about your shit mailing list we both know I didn't sign up for. Or your leads you brought from some scummy data broker that claimed they really want what you are offering. They don't. Just stop. …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 9mo And yes, I'm talking about you. I'm not talking about v!@gr@ spam, I'm talking about your shit mailing list we both know I didn't sign up for. Or your leads you brought from some scummy data broker that claimed they really want what you are offering. They don't. Just stop. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Cory Watilo’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • ugh someone told me this thing was an example of a successful company. if you have popups and moving shit on your website you are not successful, full stop. like if you are successful just don't do that shit. oh you need it? your customers are OMG IT MOVED I CLICK buy? low quality. shein tier. not success comma website for reference. nothing moves. no pop up. and we should probably even tone down the contrast. only you can help prevent eyesores. if you work at a company like this, tell your boss you are offended by your website today. …more Activate to view larger image, 77 comments 16 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 10mo [posthog.com designer here] you and i share a similar mindset about websites: keep it simple, straightforward, and focused on the content. i loathe things that move or fade in as you scroll – it all tends to detract from the message. unfortunately there are just some requirements for operating a site that's available in the EU – like having an obtrusive notice about cookies. since nearly every website in the world does this poorly, i wanted to spark joy with ours, hence why it features Ursula von der Leyen (President of the EU), insinuating she approves of our site. i hope you made it below the fold to see some more of our unique brand personality. for example, if you make it down to the "You'll hate PostHog if..." section, you'll see how we try to inject a little fun in the sea of monotony of our (B2B SaaS) industry. one of the main goals throughout my design career has been to make people's work days suck a little less. if you have to use a B2B SaaS product, why not make it an enjoyable experience? sorry it didn't resonate with you, but thanks for checking it out anyway! …more Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Cory Watilo’s comment George Hotz Author 10mo Cory Watilo it wasn't captured in the picture, why do the words in the banner move? EU requires moving words? Like Reply Abhishek Das • 3rd+ I build for the <​People /​> 10mo Posthog user here, I absolutely adore the work you do, Cory. Your design has been my northstar for my current projects, it has brought the fun back into web apps, which makes the experience more lively! Like Reply Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 10mo George Hotz Ah you're talking about this bit? I really hope you didn't take is seriously... lol Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Cory Watilo nah I meant the top banner. but I will say, engagement from posthog people here has definitely made me like it more! Like Reply Chris Brisson • 3rd+ CEO, Salesmsg (4X Inc 5000) | Founder. Investor. SMS Expert. Always a dreamer, a doer, a dude, and a dad. 🏄🏻‍♂️ 10mo Cory Watilo I always thought it was Hillary Clinton. Like Reply Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 10mo Chris Brisson is there really a difference though? ;) Like Reply Chris Brisson • 3rd+ CEO, Salesmsg (4X Inc 5000) | Founder. Investor. SMS Expert. Always a dreamer, a doer, a dude, and a dad. 🏄🏻‍♂️ 10mo if you're in the us then you'd think it her as no one knows Ursula. Like Reply Wilson Vintermute • 3rd+ Management Professional 10mo George Hotz the real solution is to block the site in the EU but few have the strength to do what it truly takes Like Reply Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 5mo George Hotz update: there's a new site out there. nothing moves now. you should check it out. i think you'll like it even less. ;) Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 10mo [posthog.com designer here] you and i share a similar mindset about websites: keep it simple, straightforward, and focused on the content. i loathe things that move or fade in as you scroll – it all tends to detract from the message. unfortunately there are just some requirements for operating a site that's available in the EU – like having an obtrusive notice about cookies. since nearly every website in the world does this poorly, i wanted to spark joy with ours, hence why it features Ursula von der Leyen (President of the EU), insinuating she approves of our site. i hope you made it below the fold to see some more of our unique brand personality. for example, if you make it down to the "You'll hate PostHog if..." section, you'll see how we try to inject a little fun in the sea of monotony of our (B2B SaaS) industry. one of the main goals throughout my design career has been to make people's work days suck a little less. if you have to use a B2B SaaS product, why not make it an enjoyable experience? sorry it didn't resonate with you, but thanks for checking it out anyway! …more Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Cory Watilo’s comment George Hotz Author 10mo Cory Watilo it wasn't captured in the picture, why do the words in the banner move? EU requires moving words? Like Reply Abhishek Das • 3rd+ I build for the <​People /​> 10mo Posthog user here, I absolutely adore the work you do, Cory. Your design has been my northstar for my current projects, it has brought the fun back into web apps, which makes the experience more lively! Like Reply Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 10mo George Hotz Ah you're talking about this bit? I really hope you didn't take is seriously... lol Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Cory Watilo nah I meant the top banner. but I will say, engagement from posthog people here has definitely made me like it more! Like Reply Chris Brisson • 3rd+ CEO, Salesmsg (4X Inc 5000) | Founder. Investor. SMS Expert. Always a dreamer, a doer, a dude, and a dad. 🏄🏻‍♂️ 10mo Cory Watilo I always thought it was Hillary Clinton. Like Reply Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 10mo Chris Brisson is there really a difference though? ;) Like Reply Chris Brisson • 3rd+ CEO, Salesmsg (4X Inc 5000) | Founder. Investor. SMS Expert. Always a dreamer, a doer, a dude, and a dad. 🏄🏻‍♂️ 10mo if you're in the us then you'd think it her as no one knows Ursula. Like Reply Wilson Vintermute • 3rd+ Management Professional 10mo George Hotz the real solution is to block the site in the EU but few have the strength to do what it truly takes Like Reply Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 5mo George Hotz update: there's a new site out there. nothing moves now. you should check it out. i think you'll like it even less. ;) Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 10mo Cory Watilo it wasn't captured in the picture, why do the words in the banner move? EU requires moving words? Like Reply

Abhishek Das • 3rd+ I build for the <​People /​> 10mo Posthog user here, I absolutely adore the work you do, Cory. Your design has been my northstar for my current projects, it has brought the fun back into web apps, which makes the experience more lively! Like Reply

Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 10mo George Hotz Ah you're talking about this bit? I really hope you didn't take is seriously... lol Like Reply

George Hotz Author 10mo Cory Watilo nah I meant the top banner. but I will say, engagement from posthog people here has definitely made me like it more! Like Reply

Chris Brisson • 3rd+ CEO, Salesmsg (4X Inc 5000) | Founder. Investor. SMS Expert. Always a dreamer, a doer, a dude, and a dad. 🏄🏻‍♂️ 10mo Cory Watilo I always thought it was Hillary Clinton. Like Reply

Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 10mo Chris Brisson is there really a difference though? ;) Like Reply

Chris Brisson • 3rd+ CEO, Salesmsg (4X Inc 5000) | Founder. Investor. SMS Expert. Always a dreamer, a doer, a dude, and a dad. 🏄🏻‍♂️ 10mo if you're in the us then you'd think it her as no one knows Ursula. Like Reply

Wilson Vintermute • 3rd+ Management Professional 10mo George Hotz the real solution is to block the site in the EU but few have the strength to do what it truly takes Like Reply

Cory Watilo • 3rd+ PostHog.com Webmaster 5mo George Hotz update: there's a new site out there. nothing moves now. you should check it out. i think you'll like it even less. ;) Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • ugh someone told me this thing was an example of a successful company. if you have popups and moving shit on your website you are not successful, full stop. like if you are successful just don't do that shit. oh you need it? your customers are OMG IT MOVED I CLICK buy? low quality. shein tier. not success comma website for reference. nothing moves. no pop up. and we should probably even tone down the contrast. only you can help prevent eyesores. if you work at a company like this, tell your boss you are offended by your website today. …more Activate to view larger image, 77 comments 16 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 10mo JavaScript was a mistake Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Kyle Cordes • 3rd+ Software entrepreneur, developer. 3 ventures so far. Building the next one. 9mo George Hotz Not quite a mistake, but overused for functionality that can readily be provided with 80% less of it. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 10mo JavaScript was a mistake Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Kyle Cordes • 3rd+ Software entrepreneur, developer. 3 ventures so far. Building the next one. 9mo George Hotz Not quite a mistake, but overused for functionality that can readily be provided with 80% less of it. Like Reply

Kyle Cordes • 3rd+ Software entrepreneur, developer. 3 ventures so far. Building the next one. 9mo George Hotz Not quite a mistake, but overused for functionality that can readily be provided with 80% less of it. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Justin Lee’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • I can't wait until the scams stop and American labor finds its real market value. It's time for a correction. 35 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo till Den 10x's the productivity of every knowledge worker Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Justin Lee’s comment George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I can't believe they still dupe people into doing YC style startups. It's a rigged game. Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz what makes you say it's rigged? don't entirely disagree. But I wouldn't say I got duped. we wanted to do a startup and they funded us 🤷 Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I mean, if you know what you are getting into it's fine, but it's more like being an employee of YC/the greater SV startup ecosystem than starting a company. Like they have captured "startups" to the point that your impact won't exceed that of an employee at FAANG, which is why the "10x the productivity..." line is kind of disconnected from reality. I know I know think different and you'll prove me wrong and all that, and maybe you can, but it would require a radically different path from typical YC startups. It's like when a meta employee tells you they are making the world more open and connected, like do you even believe that? …more Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz I tend to agree that saying "I work at [insert FAANG] because I'm passionate about using tech to transform lives" is pretty out of touch. I would differentiate But in general, I think that to actually make a different via tech, you need to start a company. And I think that starting a company necessitates entering the SV ecosystem, unless you are 0.000001% (you). The odds of death are just too high otherwise. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz Anyone who thinks that doing a startup doesn't exceed impact over a FAANG employee is completely deluded. There is real impact being made by 1000s of startups coming out of YC and I have first hand experienced it. If you just look at Airbnb, Doordash and Stripe, just those 3 are enough proof. Justin Lee and Linus Talacko are going to 1000x productivity with Den, not just 10x. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 10mo the cult of startups depends on adherents believing in it. starting a company does not require the SV ecosystem, and if you participate in that ecosystem you are on a carefully planned track, not really starting a company that can change the world. SV put (a style) of entrepreneurship in a box, and if you work in the box you will not get out. but you don't have to believe me, just check back in on this message in 5 years. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz 2020 Whatnot and Poshog my batch. Zepto from 2021. All changing the world in a MASSIVE way. You don't see it because you are not it, doesn't mean it is not true :) You can check in a couple of years for Den :) …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Ajith Govind Satheesh you mean https://posthog.com and https://www.whatnot.com/ ::rofl:: those websites more than prove my point. that's def the next stripe /s Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo George Hotz for those who don't want to click Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo till Den 10x's the productivity of every knowledge worker Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Justin Lee’s comment George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I can't believe they still dupe people into doing YC style startups. It's a rigged game. Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz what makes you say it's rigged? don't entirely disagree. But I wouldn't say I got duped. we wanted to do a startup and they funded us 🤷 Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I mean, if you know what you are getting into it's fine, but it's more like being an employee of YC/the greater SV startup ecosystem than starting a company. Like they have captured "startups" to the point that your impact won't exceed that of an employee at FAANG, which is why the "10x the productivity..." line is kind of disconnected from reality. I know I know think different and you'll prove me wrong and all that, and maybe you can, but it would require a radically different path from typical YC startups. It's like when a meta employee tells you they are making the world more open and connected, like do you even believe that? …more Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz I tend to agree that saying "I work at [insert FAANG] because I'm passionate about using tech to transform lives" is pretty out of touch. I would differentiate But in general, I think that to actually make a different via tech, you need to start a company. And I think that starting a company necessitates entering the SV ecosystem, unless you are 0.000001% (you). The odds of death are just too high otherwise. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz Anyone who thinks that doing a startup doesn't exceed impact over a FAANG employee is completely deluded. There is real impact being made by 1000s of startups coming out of YC and I have first hand experienced it. If you just look at Airbnb, Doordash and Stripe, just those 3 are enough proof. Justin Lee and Linus Talacko are going to 1000x productivity with Den, not just 10x. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 10mo the cult of startups depends on adherents believing in it. starting a company does not require the SV ecosystem, and if you participate in that ecosystem you are on a carefully planned track, not really starting a company that can change the world. SV put (a style) of entrepreneurship in a box, and if you work in the box you will not get out. but you don't have to believe me, just check back in on this message in 5 years. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz 2020 Whatnot and Poshog my batch. Zepto from 2021. All changing the world in a MASSIVE way. You don't see it because you are not it, doesn't mean it is not true :) You can check in a couple of years for Den :) …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Ajith Govind Satheesh you mean https://posthog.com and https://www.whatnot.com/ ::rofl:: those websites more than prove my point. that's def the next stripe /s Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo George Hotz for those who don't want to click Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I can't believe they still dupe people into doing YC style startups. It's a rigged game. Like Reply

Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz what makes you say it's rigged? don't entirely disagree. But I wouldn't say I got duped. we wanted to do a startup and they funded us 🤷 Like Reply

George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I mean, if you know what you are getting into it's fine, but it's more like being an employee of YC/the greater SV startup ecosystem than starting a company. Like they have captured "startups" to the point that your impact won't exceed that of an employee at FAANG, which is why the "10x the productivity..." line is kind of disconnected from reality. I know I know think different and you'll prove me wrong and all that, and maybe you can, but it would require a radically different path from typical YC startups. It's like when a meta employee tells you they are making the world more open and connected, like do you even believe that? …more Like Reply

Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz I tend to agree that saying "I work at [insert FAANG] because I'm passionate about using tech to transform lives" is pretty out of touch. I would differentiate But in general, I think that to actually make a different via tech, you need to start a company. And I think that starting a company necessitates entering the SV ecosystem, unless you are 0.000001% (you). The odds of death are just too high otherwise. …more Like Reply

Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz Anyone who thinks that doing a startup doesn't exceed impact over a FAANG employee is completely deluded. There is real impact being made by 1000s of startups coming out of YC and I have first hand experienced it. If you just look at Airbnb, Doordash and Stripe, just those 3 are enough proof. Justin Lee and Linus Talacko are going to 1000x productivity with Den, not just 10x. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 10mo the cult of startups depends on adherents believing in it. starting a company does not require the SV ecosystem, and if you participate in that ecosystem you are on a carefully planned track, not really starting a company that can change the world. SV put (a style) of entrepreneurship in a box, and if you work in the box you will not get out. but you don't have to believe me, just check back in on this message in 5 years. …more Like Reply

Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz 2020 Whatnot and Poshog my batch. Zepto from 2021. All changing the world in a MASSIVE way. You don't see it because you are not it, doesn't mean it is not true :) You can check in a couple of years for Den :) …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 10mo Ajith Govind Satheesh you mean https://posthog.com and https://www.whatnot.com/ ::rofl:: those websites more than prove my point. that's def the next stripe /s Like Reply

George Hotz Author 10mo George Hotz for those who don't want to click Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Justin Lee’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • I can't wait until the scams stop and American labor finds its real market value. It's time for a correction. 35 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo till Den 10x's the productivity of every knowledge worker Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Justin Lee’s comment George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I can't believe they still dupe people into doing YC style startups. It's a rigged game. Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz what makes you say it's rigged? don't entirely disagree. But I wouldn't say I got duped. we wanted to do a startup and they funded us 🤷 Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I mean, if you know what you are getting into it's fine, but it's more like being an employee of YC/the greater SV startup ecosystem than starting a company. Like they have captured "startups" to the point that your impact won't exceed that of an employee at FAANG, which is why the "10x the productivity..." line is kind of disconnected from reality. I know I know think different and you'll prove me wrong and all that, and maybe you can, but it would require a radically different path from typical YC startups. It's like when a meta employee tells you they are making the world more open and connected, like do you even believe that? …more Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz I tend to agree that saying "I work at [insert FAANG] because I'm passionate about using tech to transform lives" is pretty out of touch. I would differentiate But in general, I think that to actually make a different via tech, you need to start a company. And I think that starting a company necessitates entering the SV ecosystem, unless you are 0.000001% (you). The odds of death are just too high otherwise. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz Anyone who thinks that doing a startup doesn't exceed impact over a FAANG employee is completely deluded. There is real impact being made by 1000s of startups coming out of YC and I have first hand experienced it. If you just look at Airbnb, Doordash and Stripe, just those 3 are enough proof. Justin Lee and Linus Talacko are going to 1000x productivity with Den, not just 10x. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 10mo the cult of startups depends on adherents believing in it. starting a company does not require the SV ecosystem, and if you participate in that ecosystem you are on a carefully planned track, not really starting a company that can change the world. SV put (a style) of entrepreneurship in a box, and if you work in the box you will not get out. but you don't have to believe me, just check back in on this message in 5 years. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz 2020 Whatnot and Poshog my batch. Zepto from 2021. All changing the world in a MASSIVE way. You don't see it because you are not it, doesn't mean it is not true :) You can check in a couple of years for Den :) …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Ajith Govind Satheesh you mean https://posthog.com and https://www.whatnot.com/ ::rofl:: those websites more than prove my point. that's def the next stripe /s Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo George Hotz for those who don't want to click Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Justin Lee’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • I can't wait until the scams stop and American labor finds its real market value. It's time for a correction. 35 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo till Den 10x's the productivity of every knowledge worker Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Justin Lee’s comment George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I can't believe they still dupe people into doing YC style startups. It's a rigged game. Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz what makes you say it's rigged? don't entirely disagree. But I wouldn't say I got duped. we wanted to do a startup and they funded us 🤷 Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I mean, if you know what you are getting into it's fine, but it's more like being an employee of YC/the greater SV startup ecosystem than starting a company. Like they have captured "startups" to the point that your impact won't exceed that of an employee at FAANG, which is why the "10x the productivity..." line is kind of disconnected from reality. I know I know think different and you'll prove me wrong and all that, and maybe you can, but it would require a radically different path from typical YC startups. It's like when a meta employee tells you they are making the world more open and connected, like do you even believe that? …more Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz I tend to agree that saying "I work at [insert FAANG] because I'm passionate about using tech to transform lives" is pretty out of touch. I would differentiate But in general, I think that to actually make a different via tech, you need to start a company. And I think that starting a company necessitates entering the SV ecosystem, unless you are 0.000001% (you). The odds of death are just too high otherwise. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz Anyone who thinks that doing a startup doesn't exceed impact over a FAANG employee is completely deluded. There is real impact being made by 1000s of startups coming out of YC and I have first hand experienced it. If you just look at Airbnb, Doordash and Stripe, just those 3 are enough proof. Justin Lee and Linus Talacko are going to 1000x productivity with Den, not just 10x. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 10mo the cult of startups depends on adherents believing in it. starting a company does not require the SV ecosystem, and if you participate in that ecosystem you are on a carefully planned track, not really starting a company that can change the world. SV put (a style) of entrepreneurship in a box, and if you work in the box you will not get out. but you don't have to believe me, just check back in on this message in 5 years. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz 2020 Whatnot and Poshog my batch. Zepto from 2021. All changing the world in a MASSIVE way. You don't see it because you are not it, doesn't mean it is not true :) You can check in a couple of years for Den :) …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Ajith Govind Satheesh you mean https://posthog.com and https://www.whatnot.com/ ::rofl:: those websites more than prove my point. that's def the next stripe /s Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo George Hotz for those who don't want to click Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Justin Lee’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • I can't wait until the scams stop and American labor finds its real market value. It's time for a correction. 35 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo till Den 10x's the productivity of every knowledge worker Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Justin Lee’s comment George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I can't believe they still dupe people into doing YC style startups. It's a rigged game. Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz what makes you say it's rigged? don't entirely disagree. But I wouldn't say I got duped. we wanted to do a startup and they funded us 🤷 Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I mean, if you know what you are getting into it's fine, but it's more like being an employee of YC/the greater SV startup ecosystem than starting a company. Like they have captured "startups" to the point that your impact won't exceed that of an employee at FAANG, which is why the "10x the productivity..." line is kind of disconnected from reality. I know I know think different and you'll prove me wrong and all that, and maybe you can, but it would require a radically different path from typical YC startups. It's like when a meta employee tells you they are making the world more open and connected, like do you even believe that? …more Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz I tend to agree that saying "I work at [insert FAANG] because I'm passionate about using tech to transform lives" is pretty out of touch. I would differentiate But in general, I think that to actually make a different via tech, you need to start a company. And I think that starting a company necessitates entering the SV ecosystem, unless you are 0.000001% (you). The odds of death are just too high otherwise. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz Anyone who thinks that doing a startup doesn't exceed impact over a FAANG employee is completely deluded. There is real impact being made by 1000s of startups coming out of YC and I have first hand experienced it. If you just look at Airbnb, Doordash and Stripe, just those 3 are enough proof. Justin Lee and Linus Talacko are going to 1000x productivity with Den, not just 10x. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 10mo the cult of startups depends on adherents believing in it. starting a company does not require the SV ecosystem, and if you participate in that ecosystem you are on a carefully planned track, not really starting a company that can change the world. SV put (a style) of entrepreneurship in a box, and if you work in the box you will not get out. but you don't have to believe me, just check back in on this message in 5 years. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz 2020 Whatnot and Poshog my batch. Zepto from 2021. All changing the world in a MASSIVE way. You don't see it because you are not it, doesn't mean it is not true :) You can check in a couple of years for Den :) …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Ajith Govind Satheesh you mean https://posthog.com and https://www.whatnot.com/ ::rofl:: those websites more than prove my point. that's def the next stripe /s Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo George Hotz for those who don't want to click Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Justin Lee’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 10mo • I can't wait until the scams stop and American labor finds its real market value. It's time for a correction. 35 comments 4 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo till Den 10x's the productivity of every knowledge worker Like Reply 9 replies 9 Replies on Justin Lee’s comment George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I can't believe they still dupe people into doing YC style startups. It's a rigged game. Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz what makes you say it's rigged? don't entirely disagree. But I wouldn't say I got duped. we wanted to do a startup and they funded us 🤷 Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Justin Lee I mean, if you know what you are getting into it's fine, but it's more like being an employee of YC/the greater SV startup ecosystem than starting a company. Like they have captured "startups" to the point that your impact won't exceed that of an employee at FAANG, which is why the "10x the productivity..." line is kind of disconnected from reality. I know I know think different and you'll prove me wrong and all that, and maybe you can, but it would require a radically different path from typical YC startups. It's like when a meta employee tells you they are making the world more open and connected, like do you even believe that? …more Like Reply Justin Lee • 3rd+ Cofounder at Den (YC P25) 10mo George Hotz I tend to agree that saying "I work at [insert FAANG] because I'm passionate about using tech to transform lives" is pretty out of touch. I would differentiate But in general, I think that to actually make a different via tech, you need to start a company. And I think that starting a company necessitates entering the SV ecosystem, unless you are 0.000001% (you). The odds of death are just too high otherwise. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz Anyone who thinks that doing a startup doesn't exceed impact over a FAANG employee is completely deluded. There is real impact being made by 1000s of startups coming out of YC and I have first hand experienced it. If you just look at Airbnb, Doordash and Stripe, just those 3 are enough proof. Justin Lee and Linus Talacko are going to 1000x productivity with Den, not just 10x. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author (edited) 10mo the cult of startups depends on adherents believing in it. starting a company does not require the SV ecosystem, and if you participate in that ecosystem you are on a carefully planned track, not really starting a company that can change the world. SV put (a style) of entrepreneurship in a box, and if you work in the box you will not get out. but you don't have to believe me, just check back in on this message in 5 years. …more Like Reply Ajith Govind Satheesh • 3rd+ Co-Founder & CEO at Cactus | Inbound & Outbound for Home Service Companies 10mo George Hotz 2020 Whatnot and Poshog my batch. Zepto from 2021. All changing the world in a MASSIVE way. You don't see it because you are not it, doesn't mean it is not true :) You can check in a couple of years for Den :) …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo Ajith Govind Satheesh you mean https://posthog.com and https://www.whatnot.com/ ::rofl:: those websites more than prove my point. that's def the next stripe /s Like Reply George Hotz Author 10mo George Hotz for those who don't want to click Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Greg Webb’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1yr • tinyboxes are now available for anyone to "buy it now." The best perf/$ ML hardware. https://lnkd.in/grkYmsgi Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 64 comments 21 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Greg Webb • 3rd+ Business Systems and Integration Manager 1y Driver quality: acceptable lol …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Greg Webb’s comment George Hotz Author 1y Greg Webb It was upgraded from mediocre thanks to https://github.com/tinygrad/tinygrad/blob/master/tinygrad/runtime/ops_amd.py Like Reply Joey DeFrancesco • 3rd+ Vuln. Research/Embedded Systems @ MIT 1y Yea that’s my fear here… they work out all the driver issues? Doubt it. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Greg Webb • 3rd+ Business Systems and Integration Manager 1y Driver quality: acceptable lol …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Greg Webb’s comment George Hotz Author 1y Greg Webb It was upgraded from mediocre thanks to https://github.com/tinygrad/tinygrad/blob/master/tinygrad/runtime/ops_amd.py Like Reply Joey DeFrancesco • 3rd+ Vuln. Research/Embedded Systems @ MIT 1y Yea that’s my fear here… they work out all the driver issues? Doubt it. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1y Greg Webb It was upgraded from mediocre thanks to https://github.com/tinygrad/tinygrad/blob/master/tinygrad/runtime/ops_amd.py Like Reply

Joey DeFrancesco • 3rd+ Vuln. Research/Embedded Systems @ MIT 1y Yea that’s my fear here… they work out all the driver issues? Doubt it. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Maxim Khailo’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 1yr • tinyboxes are now available for anyone to "buy it now." The best perf/$ ML hardware. https://lnkd.in/grkYmsgi Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 64 comments 21 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Maxim Khailo • 3rd+ Chief Exponent Officer (edited) 1y Beautiful looking box too! Only thing that limits this is the disk size IMO. 4TB is not a lot of data for training ML models. Is it 4TB max? Or is this expandable. And if expandable, what's the max disk space on this thing? It's unclear from the website. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Maxim Khailo’s comment George Hotz Author 1y Maxim Khailo It has 4 NVMe drives you can replace (4x8TB = 32TB), but what dataset is larger than 4TB? It also has a slot for a 200 Gbit network card if you want to pull your data from elsewhere. Like Reply Jerome Tesselaar • 3rd+ Full Stack Developer @ SnelStart | Informatica (Software engineering) 1y George Hotz I have used the 80/20 method + ai for buying the most cheap shit possible try it out boi. I bought the most efficnt switch , macbook, coffeee machine desk light, throw it in and it shits it out for you try it today: By applying the 80/20 rule to these purchasing decisions, you can optimize your spending, reduce clutter, and focus on acquiring items that provide the most significant value and satisfaction in your daily life. Bronnen Je zei: Can you give me the best desktop with the 80/20 method for ai programming? ChatGPT zei: ChatGPT Applying the 80/20 principle to selecting a desktop for AI programming involves focusing on the 20% of components that will deliver 80% of the performance benefits. Here's how to approach this: 1. Prioritize Key Components: Graphics Processing Unit (GPU): A powerful GPU is essential for AI tasks, especially those involving deep learning and large-scale computations. NVIDIA's GeForce RTX series, such as the RTX 4080 or 4090, are excellent choices due …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Maxim Khailo • 3rd+ Chief Exponent Officer (edited) 1y Beautiful looking box too! Only thing that limits this is the disk size IMO. 4TB is not a lot of data for training ML models. Is it 4TB max? Or is this expandable. And if expandable, what's the max disk space on this thing? It's unclear from the website. …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Maxim Khailo’s comment George Hotz Author 1y Maxim Khailo It has 4 NVMe drives you can replace (4x8TB = 32TB), but what dataset is larger than 4TB? It also has a slot for a 200 Gbit network card if you want to pull your data from elsewhere. Like Reply Jerome Tesselaar • 3rd+ Full Stack Developer @ SnelStart | Informatica (Software engineering) 1y George Hotz I have used the 80/20 method + ai for buying the most cheap shit possible try it out boi. I bought the most efficnt switch , macbook, coffeee machine desk light, throw it in and it shits it out for you try it today: By applying the 80/20 rule to these purchasing decisions, you can optimize your spending, reduce clutter, and focus on acquiring items that provide the most significant value and satisfaction in your daily life. Bronnen Je zei: Can you give me the best desktop with the 80/20 method for ai programming? ChatGPT zei: ChatGPT Applying the 80/20 principle to selecting a desktop for AI programming involves focusing on the 20% of components that will deliver 80% of the performance benefits. Here's how to approach this: 1. Prioritize Key Components: Graphics Processing Unit (GPU): A powerful GPU is essential for AI tasks, especially those involving deep learning and large-scale computations. NVIDIA's GeForce RTX series, such as the RTX 4080 or 4090, are excellent choices due …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 1y Maxim Khailo It has 4 NVMe drives you can replace (4x8TB = 32TB), but what dataset is larger than 4TB? It also has a slot for a 200 Gbit network card if you want to pull your data from elsewhere. Like Reply

Jerome Tesselaar • 3rd+ Full Stack Developer @ SnelStart | Informatica (Software engineering) 1y George Hotz I have used the 80/20 method + ai for buying the most cheap shit possible try it out boi. I bought the most efficnt switch , macbook, coffeee machine desk light, throw it in and it shits it out for you try it today: By applying the 80/20 rule to these purchasing decisions, you can optimize your spending, reduce clutter, and focus on acquiring items that provide the most significant value and satisfaction in your daily life. Bronnen Je zei: Can you give me the best desktop with the 80/20 method for ai programming? ChatGPT zei: ChatGPT Applying the 80/20 principle to selecting a desktop for AI programming involves focusing on the 20% of components that will deliver 80% of the performance benefits. Here's how to approach this: 1. Prioritize Key Components: Graphics Processing Unit (GPU): A powerful GPU is essential for AI tasks, especially those involving deep learning and large-scale computations. NVIDIA's GeForce RTX series, such as the RTX 4080 or 4090, are excellent choices due …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Eric Cabrol’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Did you know you can add the best ADAS system in the world to your car in 15 minutes? I don't think you understand what this means. It turns out 250+ models of cars have the ability to electrically control the car. We turn the wheel, press the gas, and hit the brakes using camera based AI. This is one of those claims where it's "untruthy" like you think it's a lie for some reason. But it's not, search YouTube for "openpilot" and see thousands of people doing this. The box costs $1050 (on sale!) and is called the comma 3x. It can make your car drive on the highway for hours without driver action. Why haven't you bought one yet? …more 67 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 2y I'm really impressed by what you achieved, but I wouldn't buy one without evidence that it has been properly tested..Considering customers as beta-testers is not an option. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Eric Cabrol’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y What do you mean by this? There's plenty of testing, and even better than with most ADAS systems, the testing is public. https://github.com/commaai/openpilot?tab=readme-ov-file#safety-and-testing What specifically do you think that list is missing? What testing do you think the car manufacturers do that we don't? In fact, in some ways it's better tested than most OEM ADAS systems. We have telemetry they can only dream of. …more GitHub - commaai/openpilot: openpilot is an operating system for robotics. Currently, it upgrades the driver assistance system on 300+ supported cars. openpilot is an operating system for robotics. Currently, it upgrades the driver assistance system on 300+ supported cars. - commaai/openpilot Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 2y Do you perform MIL validation ? Do you use simulation frameworks ? Do you assess the influence of the environment, of the sensors, of the vehicle ? Do you run simulations with varying conditions of light, rain, road grip, traffic density ? Do you have a catalogue of validation scenarios to evaluate the performance of the different features (at least the active ones - ACC and LCA .. I see you call it ALC), taking into account influent factors such as ego speed, cut-in, inter-vehicle distance, road banking ... Do you have sensors models ? Which fidelity level ? Can you include realistic features such as blur or optical distortion in the camera models ? Do you assess the influence of their integration in the vehicle (position, FOV ...) ? Do you have vehicle dynamic models to evaluate the impact of the steering or braking actions ? How do you validate these vehicle models ? When you're mentioning HIL testing, which hardware exactly are you testing ? Do you perform DIL testing on driving simulators to understand the way drivers can interact with these systems ? Who is performing road tests in the end (_before_ selling the product I mean) ? Can we find somewhere evidence of the system performance ? …more Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 2y George Hotz, is there any chance to read elements of response here ? Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 2y I'm really impressed by what you achieved, but I wouldn't buy one without evidence that it has been properly tested..Considering customers as beta-testers is not an option. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Eric Cabrol’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y What do you mean by this? There's plenty of testing, and even better than with most ADAS systems, the testing is public. https://github.com/commaai/openpilot?tab=readme-ov-file#safety-and-testing What specifically do you think that list is missing? What testing do you think the car manufacturers do that we don't? In fact, in some ways it's better tested than most OEM ADAS systems. We have telemetry they can only dream of. …more GitHub - commaai/openpilot: openpilot is an operating system for robotics. Currently, it upgrades the driver assistance system on 300+ supported cars. openpilot is an operating system for robotics. Currently, it upgrades the driver assistance system on 300+ supported cars. - commaai/openpilot Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 2y Do you perform MIL validation ? Do you use simulation frameworks ? Do you assess the influence of the environment, of the sensors, of the vehicle ? Do you run simulations with varying conditions of light, rain, road grip, traffic density ? Do you have a catalogue of validation scenarios to evaluate the performance of the different features (at least the active ones - ACC and LCA .. I see you call it ALC), taking into account influent factors such as ego speed, cut-in, inter-vehicle distance, road banking ... Do you have sensors models ? Which fidelity level ? Can you include realistic features such as blur or optical distortion in the camera models ? Do you assess the influence of their integration in the vehicle (position, FOV ...) ? Do you have vehicle dynamic models to evaluate the impact of the steering or braking actions ? How do you validate these vehicle models ? When you're mentioning HIL testing, which hardware exactly are you testing ? Do you perform DIL testing on driving simulators to understand the way drivers can interact with these systems ? Who is performing road tests in the end (_before_ selling the product I mean) ? Can we find somewhere evidence of the system performance ? …more Like Reply Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 2y George Hotz, is there any chance to read elements of response here ? Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 2y What do you mean by this? There's plenty of testing, and even better than with most ADAS systems, the testing is public. https://github.com/commaai/openpilot?tab=readme-ov-file#safety-and-testing What specifically do you think that list is missing? What testing do you think the car manufacturers do that we don't? In fact, in some ways it's better tested than most OEM ADAS systems. We have telemetry they can only dream of. …more GitHub - commaai/openpilot: openpilot is an operating system for robotics. Currently, it upgrades the driver assistance system on 300+ supported cars. openpilot is an operating system for robotics. Currently, it upgrades the driver assistance system on 300+ supported cars. - commaai/openpilot Like Reply

GitHub - commaai/openpilot: openpilot is an operating system for robotics. Currently, it upgrades the driver assistance system on 300+ supported cars. openpilot is an operating system for robotics. Currently, it upgrades the driver assistance system on 300+ supported cars. - commaai/openpilot

Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 2y Do you perform MIL validation ? Do you use simulation frameworks ? Do you assess the influence of the environment, of the sensors, of the vehicle ? Do you run simulations with varying conditions of light, rain, road grip, traffic density ? Do you have a catalogue of validation scenarios to evaluate the performance of the different features (at least the active ones - ACC and LCA .. I see you call it ALC), taking into account influent factors such as ego speed, cut-in, inter-vehicle distance, road banking ... Do you have sensors models ? Which fidelity level ? Can you include realistic features such as blur or optical distortion in the camera models ? Do you assess the influence of their integration in the vehicle (position, FOV ...) ? Do you have vehicle dynamic models to evaluate the impact of the steering or braking actions ? How do you validate these vehicle models ? When you're mentioning HIL testing, which hardware exactly are you testing ? Do you perform DIL testing on driving simulators to understand the way drivers can interact with these systems ? Who is performing road tests in the end (_before_ selling the product I mean) ? Can we find somewhere evidence of the system performance ? …more Like Reply

Eric Cabrol • 3rd+ Stanley Robotics - Head of robot engineering 2y George Hotz, is there any chance to read elements of response here ? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Saeid REZAEE’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Did you know you can add the best ADAS system in the world to your car in 15 minutes? I don't think you understand what this means. It turns out 250+ models of cars have the ability to electrically control the car. We turn the wheel, press the gas, and hit the brakes using camera based AI. This is one of those claims where it's "untruthy" like you think it's a lie for some reason. But it's not, search YouTube for "openpilot" and see thousands of people doing this. The box costs $1050 (on sale!) and is called the comma 3x. It can make your car drive on the highway for hours without driver action. Why haven't you bought one yet? …more 67 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Saeid REZAEE • 3rd+ Experienced Mechanical Engineering Project Manager | Cross-Functional Team Leader | Driving Results 2y Exploring the legality of selling or using this on open roads. Additionally, came across a concerning near-crash situation on YouTube. Safety and compliance are crucial in these scenarios. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Saeid REZAEE’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y Cars nearly crash every day. Are you making a claim that somehow the system took a bad action that an attentive driver couldn't trivially correct? If so, please link the video. Otherwise, don't spread FUD. It is a driver assistance system and requires an attentive driver at all times. We are very clear about this everywhere, and in addition have a camera based driver monitoring system. But as long as you are paying attention, you should have plenty of time to react to any issues, like a chill assistant. Think cruise control but 10x better. …more Like Reply Load more comments

Saeid REZAEE • 3rd+ Experienced Mechanical Engineering Project Manager | Cross-Functional Team Leader | Driving Results 2y Exploring the legality of selling or using this on open roads. Additionally, came across a concerning near-crash situation on YouTube. Safety and compliance are crucial in these scenarios. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Saeid REZAEE’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y Cars nearly crash every day. Are you making a claim that somehow the system took a bad action that an attentive driver couldn't trivially correct? If so, please link the video. Otherwise, don't spread FUD. It is a driver assistance system and requires an attentive driver at all times. We are very clear about this everywhere, and in addition have a camera based driver monitoring system. But as long as you are paying attention, you should have plenty of time to react to any issues, like a chill assistant. Think cruise control but 10x better. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 2y Cars nearly crash every day. Are you making a claim that somehow the system took a bad action that an attentive driver couldn't trivially correct? If so, please link the video. Otherwise, don't spread FUD. It is a driver assistance system and requires an attentive driver at all times. We are very clear about this everywhere, and in addition have a camera based driver monitoring system. But as long as you are paying attention, you should have plenty of time to react to any issues, like a chill assistant. Think cruise control but 10x better. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Did you know you can add the best ADAS system in the world to your car in 15 minutes? I don't think you understand what this means. It turns out 250+ models of cars have the ability to electrically control the car. We turn the wheel, press the gas, and hit the brakes using camera based AI. This is one of those claims where it's "untruthy" like you think it's a lie for some reason. But it's not, search YouTube for "openpilot" and see thousands of people doing this. The box costs $1050 (on sale!) and is called the comma 3x. It can make your car drive on the highway for hours without driver action. Why haven't you bought one yet? …more 67 comments 10 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2y Link to website: https://comma.ai/ comma.ai — make driving chill An AI upgrade for your car Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2y Link to website: https://comma.ai/ comma.ai — make driving chill An AI upgrade for your car Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Pablo Rodríguez Centeno’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • OMG THIS IS BETTER THAN Q* GIVE ME THAT SWEET HYPE ... What's funny is there are people with "Generative AI" in their tagline that don't know what a Gaussian distribution is. We should overwhelm them with pure noise. It's time for people who don't understand things to leave tech. …more Foti Kërkeshi Foti Kërkeshi • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ AI Engineer AI Engineer 2yr • Follow I am thrilled to announce the recent breakthrough coming right out of all the FANG AI research labs, Gaussian distribution. This new technology that empowers many Artificial Neural Networks is reported to bring us closer to AGI (Artificial General Intelligence). Due to its shape it is also called as bell curve. The scientists who discovered this new technology say that soon all robots will be equipped with bell like neurons. This will make it easier for the computations and very very complex calculations to happen inside the artificial brains. However, with great power comes great responsibility. While the potential of Gaussian distribution is limitless, the scientists have yet to publish this technology in public, so the equation is still unknown. We need to think about how we use this powerful technology responsibly. So, while we're excited about the possibilities, we also need to be careful about how we use them. hashtag #aiexperts hashtag #responsibleai hashtag #ainews …more 50 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Pablo Rodríguez Centeno • 3rd+ Strategic Business Analyst & Solutions Architect | Expert in AI Integration, Process Optimization, and Cross-Sector Innovation | Industrial Automation Engineer | Tech Leader 2y I enjoy the hype, but the feed gets cramped with so many AI gurus! And probably most of them are doing better than me 😅.Sometimes I feel that people really don't appreciate everything that being an engineer entails (electrical in my case). It's all marketing (aka directing your thoughts), George! …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Pablo Rodríguez Centeno’s comment George Hotz Author 2y They aren't actually doing well. But they are pathological and will never admit it. It's not all marketing. It's marketing right up until the planes fall out of the sky. It's time we all stop tolerating it. …more Like Reply Pablo Rodríguez Centeno • 3rd+ Strategic Business Analyst & Solutions Architect | Expert in AI Integration, Process Optimization, and Cross-Sector Innovation | Industrial Automation Engineer | Tech Leader (edited) 2y They are doing well in the sense that society rewards this behavior. Sure It's not all marketing for me, but it is for a big chunk of the rest of the world: fake airplanes made of plywood, politicians steering people opinions, green washing...it doesn't matter that much what they actually do, but what people remember and think they do. I wish it weren't like that, and find it almost utopian to fight it, very honorable but maybe a lost battle. There is hope since this is only my opinion and I can be wrong. This is the kind of conversation that can take hours, so just letting you know I understand 100% your point of view and I don't disagree. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Pablo Rodríguez Centeno • 3rd+ Strategic Business Analyst & Solutions Architect | Expert in AI Integration, Process Optimization, and Cross-Sector Innovation | Industrial Automation Engineer | Tech Leader 2y I enjoy the hype, but the feed gets cramped with so many AI gurus! And probably most of them are doing better than me 😅.Sometimes I feel that people really don't appreciate everything that being an engineer entails (electrical in my case). It's all marketing (aka directing your thoughts), George! …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Pablo Rodríguez Centeno’s comment George Hotz Author 2y They aren't actually doing well. But they are pathological and will never admit it. It's not all marketing. It's marketing right up until the planes fall out of the sky. It's time we all stop tolerating it. …more Like Reply Pablo Rodríguez Centeno • 3rd+ Strategic Business Analyst & Solutions Architect | Expert in AI Integration, Process Optimization, and Cross-Sector Innovation | Industrial Automation Engineer | Tech Leader (edited) 2y They are doing well in the sense that society rewards this behavior. Sure It's not all marketing for me, but it is for a big chunk of the rest of the world: fake airplanes made of plywood, politicians steering people opinions, green washing...it doesn't matter that much what they actually do, but what people remember and think they do. I wish it weren't like that, and find it almost utopian to fight it, very honorable but maybe a lost battle. There is hope since this is only my opinion and I can be wrong. This is the kind of conversation that can take hours, so just letting you know I understand 100% your point of view and I don't disagree. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y They aren't actually doing well. But they are pathological and will never admit it. It's not all marketing. It's marketing right up until the planes fall out of the sky. It's time we all stop tolerating it. …more Like Reply

Pablo Rodríguez Centeno • 3rd+ Strategic Business Analyst & Solutions Architect | Expert in AI Integration, Process Optimization, and Cross-Sector Innovation | Industrial Automation Engineer | Tech Leader (edited) 2y They are doing well in the sense that society rewards this behavior. Sure It's not all marketing for me, but it is for a big chunk of the rest of the world: fake airplanes made of plywood, politicians steering people opinions, green washing...it doesn't matter that much what they actually do, but what people remember and think they do. I wish it weren't like that, and find it almost utopian to fight it, very honorable but maybe a lost battle. There is hope since this is only my opinion and I can be wrong. This is the kind of conversation that can take hours, so just letting you know I understand 100% your point of view and I don't disagree. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jeffrey Spreng’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • OMG THIS IS BETTER THAN Q* GIVE ME THAT SWEET HYPE ... What's funny is there are people with "Generative AI" in their tagline that don't know what a Gaussian distribution is. We should overwhelm them with pure noise. It's time for people who don't understand things to leave tech. …more Foti Kërkeshi Foti Kërkeshi • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ AI Engineer AI Engineer 2yr • Follow I am thrilled to announce the recent breakthrough coming right out of all the FANG AI research labs, Gaussian distribution. This new technology that empowers many Artificial Neural Networks is reported to bring us closer to AGI (Artificial General Intelligence). Due to its shape it is also called as bell curve. The scientists who discovered this new technology say that soon all robots will be equipped with bell like neurons. This will make it easier for the computations and very very complex calculations to happen inside the artificial brains. However, with great power comes great responsibility. While the potential of Gaussian distribution is limitless, the scientists have yet to publish this technology in public, so the equation is still unknown. We need to think about how we use this powerful technology responsibly. So, while we're excited about the possibilities, we also need to be careful about how we use them. hashtag #aiexperts hashtag #responsibleai hashtag #ainews …more 50 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jeffrey Spreng • 3rd+ Full Stack Software Developer (edited) 2y I am thrilled to announce new specialized AI hardware technology: the fused multiply-add. Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Jeffrey Spreng’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 2y I bet you could legit pitch this to VCs Like Reply Load more comments

Jeffrey Spreng • 3rd+ Full Stack Software Developer (edited) 2y I am thrilled to announce new specialized AI hardware technology: the fused multiply-add. Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Jeffrey Spreng’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 2y I bet you could legit pitch this to VCs Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y I bet you could legit pitch this to VCs Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Joeri Sleegers’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • OMG THIS IS BETTER THAN Q* GIVE ME THAT SWEET HYPE ... What's funny is there are people with "Generative AI" in their tagline that don't know what a Gaussian distribution is. We should overwhelm them with pure noise. It's time for people who don't understand things to leave tech. …more Foti Kërkeshi Foti Kërkeshi • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ AI Engineer AI Engineer 2yr • Follow I am thrilled to announce the recent breakthrough coming right out of all the FANG AI research labs, Gaussian distribution. This new technology that empowers many Artificial Neural Networks is reported to bring us closer to AGI (Artificial General Intelligence). Due to its shape it is also called as bell curve. The scientists who discovered this new technology say that soon all robots will be equipped with bell like neurons. This will make it easier for the computations and very very complex calculations to happen inside the artificial brains. However, with great power comes great responsibility. While the potential of Gaussian distribution is limitless, the scientists have yet to publish this technology in public, so the equation is still unknown. We need to think about how we use this powerful technology responsibly. So, while we're excited about the possibilities, we also need to be careful about how we use them. hashtag #aiexperts hashtag #responsibleai hashtag #ainews …more 50 comments 12 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Joeri Sleegers • 3rd+ Senior fullstack engineer | Building great user experiences with React 2y I assume this was a joke? Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Joeri Sleegers’ comment George Hotz Author 2y Gaussian distribution is seriously good technology. Like Reply Dmytro Brazhnyk • 3rd+ -- (edited) 2y George Hotz Gaussian distribution is not a technology, but part of fundamental probability mathematics theory. Yeah perhaps too many people, who don’t what is Gaussian distribution in IT. Like Reply Erik Rosenow • 3rd+ Supply Chain & Operations Executive | Enterprise Transformation | Strategic Sourcing | Logistics & Network Design | Former Amazon & Vroom Leader | Marine Corps Officer 2y George Hotz meh...it's just normal. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Joeri Sleegers • 3rd+ Senior fullstack engineer | Building great user experiences with React 2y I assume this was a joke? Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Joeri Sleegers’ comment George Hotz Author 2y Gaussian distribution is seriously good technology. Like Reply Dmytro Brazhnyk • 3rd+ -- (edited) 2y George Hotz Gaussian distribution is not a technology, but part of fundamental probability mathematics theory. Yeah perhaps too many people, who don’t what is Gaussian distribution in IT. Like Reply Erik Rosenow • 3rd+ Supply Chain & Operations Executive | Enterprise Transformation | Strategic Sourcing | Logistics & Network Design | Former Amazon & Vroom Leader | Marine Corps Officer 2y George Hotz meh...it's just normal. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y Gaussian distribution is seriously good technology. Like Reply

Dmytro Brazhnyk • 3rd+ -- (edited) 2y George Hotz Gaussian distribution is not a technology, but part of fundamental probability mathematics theory. Yeah perhaps too many people, who don’t what is Gaussian distribution in IT. Like Reply

Erik Rosenow • 3rd+ Supply Chain & Operations Executive | Enterprise Transformation | Strategic Sourcing | Logistics & Network Design | Former Amazon & Vroom Leader | Marine Corps Officer 2y George Hotz meh...it's just normal. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Joseph Flanagan’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • I don't have much hope for LinkedIn, but we are hiring an operations person for the tiny corp. Come run the tinybox sale, get our website updated, set up payroll, supply chain, deal with lawyers, etc... Must have had a similar role at a startup before, describe that role to be considered. In person, San Diego. Email <my first name> at <tiny corp's website> …more 19 comments 9 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Joseph Flanagan • 3rd+ Senior Director @ RA Ventures 2y In person?! Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Joseph Flanagan’s comment George Hotz Author 2y You literally have to get 90 lb boxes built and shipped. In person. tiny corp hires remote software engineers, but only after they have shown that they can seriously contribute to tinygrad with PRs. …more Like Reply Joseph Flanagan • 3rd+ Senior Director @ RA Ventures 2y George Hotz gotcha. Makes sense. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Joseph Flanagan • 3rd+ Senior Director @ RA Ventures 2y In person?! Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Joseph Flanagan’s comment George Hotz Author 2y You literally have to get 90 lb boxes built and shipped. In person. tiny corp hires remote software engineers, but only after they have shown that they can seriously contribute to tinygrad with PRs. …more Like Reply Joseph Flanagan • 3rd+ Senior Director @ RA Ventures 2y George Hotz gotcha. Makes sense. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y You literally have to get 90 lb boxes built and shipped. In person. tiny corp hires remote software engineers, but only after they have shown that they can seriously contribute to tinygrad with PRs. …more Like Reply

Joseph Flanagan • 3rd+ Senior Director @ RA Ventures 2y George Hotz gotcha. Makes sense. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jonathan Reiter’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • It's time to take tech culture back from these people. Don't work for them, don't respect them, don't even tolerate them. Only shame. If you work at a company run by MBA types, quit. Every day, you are making the world worse. Let them yell and scream about how things don't work. Don't help them. They should learn engineering. The wrong camel came out on top. Across the whole industry. It's time for change. It wasn't supposed to be like this. https://lnkd.in/gDQUubtn …more Boeing: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) youtube.com 51 comments 27 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jonathan Reiter • 3rd+ Canary Fancier at VulnCheck (edited) 2y I'm ex Boeing, and here's the plan that will work for BCA: 0. Do whatever it takes to soak the board. Nationalize. This goes without saying. 1. Fire everyone who is on a first name basis with Dave Calhoun 2. Move HQ back to Seattle. 3. Make Gus, the mechanic who knows every single part on the 737 by part number and description, in charge. Everyone knows a Gus, they are now the fucking C suite. 4. Ask SPEEA for help, don't hit em with a firehose until they threaten to strike, don't treat them as the enemy. Put em on the board if you have to. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Jonathan Reiter’s comment George Hotz Author 2y This sounds like a plan. Everyone associated with the current leadership needs to go (at minimum), and I like the idea of promoting Gus. A new board chosen by a test of who understands the planes the best. Leadership should be held accountable for the 346 deaths from the 737 MAX. I've looked into a lot, MCAS was beyond inexcusable, and I don't feel proper repercussions were ever dealt. It's very rare I support nationalizing a company, but I think it's one of two choices. One, leadership steps completely away, or two, RICO trial for 346 counts of manslaughter. …more Like Reply Jacob Kon • 3rd+ 1x engineer 2y George Hotz but 4.9 rating on Glassdoor! Totally not purchased ratings! Like Reply Oleg Babenchuk • 3rd+ Business Consultant & Investor 2y George Hotz when high level problems are solved by low level minds, catastrophe is just around the corner. Like Reply James Santagata • 3rd+ The Psyche Stack accelerates, optimizes, and transforms your Talent & Teams 2y How will nationalizing help? Now you have actually invited the government to be directly involved with their parasitic rent seeking, regulatory capture, politicking quotas and woke culture -- look at the US Military if you are in doubt. Or the US Post Office. Best way is shareholders get soaked as consumer stop flying Boeing equipment and airlines cancel contracts and default on payments. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Jonathan Reiter • 3rd+ Canary Fancier at VulnCheck (edited) 2y I'm ex Boeing, and here's the plan that will work for BCA: 0. Do whatever it takes to soak the board. Nationalize. This goes without saying. 1. Fire everyone who is on a first name basis with Dave Calhoun 2. Move HQ back to Seattle. 3. Make Gus, the mechanic who knows every single part on the 737 by part number and description, in charge. Everyone knows a Gus, they are now the fucking C suite. 4. Ask SPEEA for help, don't hit em with a firehose until they threaten to strike, don't treat them as the enemy. Put em on the board if you have to. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Jonathan Reiter’s comment George Hotz Author 2y This sounds like a plan. Everyone associated with the current leadership needs to go (at minimum), and I like the idea of promoting Gus. A new board chosen by a test of who understands the planes the best. Leadership should be held accountable for the 346 deaths from the 737 MAX. I've looked into a lot, MCAS was beyond inexcusable, and I don't feel proper repercussions were ever dealt. It's very rare I support nationalizing a company, but I think it's one of two choices. One, leadership steps completely away, or two, RICO trial for 346 counts of manslaughter. …more Like Reply Jacob Kon • 3rd+ 1x engineer 2y George Hotz but 4.9 rating on Glassdoor! Totally not purchased ratings! Like Reply Oleg Babenchuk • 3rd+ Business Consultant & Investor 2y George Hotz when high level problems are solved by low level minds, catastrophe is just around the corner. Like Reply James Santagata • 3rd+ The Psyche Stack accelerates, optimizes, and transforms your Talent & Teams 2y How will nationalizing help? Now you have actually invited the government to be directly involved with their parasitic rent seeking, regulatory capture, politicking quotas and woke culture -- look at the US Military if you are in doubt. Or the US Post Office. Best way is shareholders get soaked as consumer stop flying Boeing equipment and airlines cancel contracts and default on payments. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y This sounds like a plan. Everyone associated with the current leadership needs to go (at minimum), and I like the idea of promoting Gus. A new board chosen by a test of who understands the planes the best. Leadership should be held accountable for the 346 deaths from the 737 MAX. I've looked into a lot, MCAS was beyond inexcusable, and I don't feel proper repercussions were ever dealt. It's very rare I support nationalizing a company, but I think it's one of two choices. One, leadership steps completely away, or two, RICO trial for 346 counts of manslaughter. …more Like Reply

Jacob Kon • 3rd+ 1x engineer 2y George Hotz but 4.9 rating on Glassdoor! Totally not purchased ratings! Like Reply

Oleg Babenchuk • 3rd+ Business Consultant & Investor 2y George Hotz when high level problems are solved by low level minds, catastrophe is just around the corner. Like Reply

James Santagata • 3rd+ The Psyche Stack accelerates, optimizes, and transforms your Talent & Teams 2y How will nationalizing help? Now you have actually invited the government to be directly involved with their parasitic rent seeking, regulatory capture, politicking quotas and woke culture -- look at the US Military if you are in doubt. Or the US Post Office. Best way is shareholders get soaked as consumer stop flying Boeing equipment and airlines cancel contracts and default on payments. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Brian Streit’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • It's time to take tech culture back from these people. Don't work for them, don't respect them, don't even tolerate them. Only shame. If you work at a company run by MBA types, quit. Every day, you are making the world worse. Let them yell and scream about how things don't work. Don't help them. They should learn engineering. The wrong camel came out on top. Across the whole industry. It's time for change. It wasn't supposed to be like this. https://lnkd.in/gDQUubtn …more Boeing: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) youtube.com 51 comments 27 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Brian Streit • 3rd+ AI Engineering || Data Science 2y Easier said than done when you have mouths to feed. Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Brian Streit’s comment George Hotz Author 2y This is not an excuse. I assume it's kids. If you are in America, your kids aren't going to starve if you quit. Quit, and move somewhere with a lower cost of living. You are making the world worse for everyone, including your kids. Think of the world you are leaving for them. …more Like Reply Simon Herrera • 3rd+ Brokerage Director | M&A | Entrepreneur | QLA Advocate/Mentee 2y George Hotz real talk! Too many cowards out there. Like Reply Brian Streit • 3rd+ AI Engineering || Data Science 2y Simon Herrera where is the thumbs down emoji when you need it? Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Brian Streit • 3rd+ AI Engineering || Data Science 2y Easier said than done when you have mouths to feed. Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Brian Streit’s comment George Hotz Author 2y This is not an excuse. I assume it's kids. If you are in America, your kids aren't going to starve if you quit. Quit, and move somewhere with a lower cost of living. You are making the world worse for everyone, including your kids. Think of the world you are leaving for them. …more Like Reply Simon Herrera • 3rd+ Brokerage Director | M&A | Entrepreneur | QLA Advocate/Mentee 2y George Hotz real talk! Too many cowards out there. Like Reply Brian Streit • 3rd+ AI Engineering || Data Science 2y Simon Herrera where is the thumbs down emoji when you need it? Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y This is not an excuse. I assume it's kids. If you are in America, your kids aren't going to starve if you quit. Quit, and move somewhere with a lower cost of living. You are making the world worse for everyone, including your kids. Think of the world you are leaving for them. …more Like Reply

Simon Herrera • 3rd+ Brokerage Director | M&A | Entrepreneur | QLA Advocate/Mentee 2y George Hotz real talk! Too many cowards out there. Like Reply

Brian Streit • 3rd+ AI Engineering || Data Science 2y Simon Herrera where is the thumbs down emoji when you need it? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Andrew Corley’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Bought a OnePlus Open last week. Bricked it the first day by setting the fastboot partition to B. QDL brick, so 5 minutes to fix with the right software. However, OnePlus no longer makes that software available to customers after the OnePlus 9. I wasn't thrilled about that policy change, and the phone felt more sluggish in Chrome than the Samsung Electronics Z Fold 5, so I thought I'd just return it and get that. But here is where it got unreasonable. Despite having a 15 day return policy, OnePlus will not allow me to return the phone because I was honest about what happened. It will take them 5 minutes to restore this phone to 100% factory, but nope, can't be returned. Do not EVER buy anything from the OnePlus store. If you insist on buying their phones, buy them from Amazon where you have a sane return policy. Hey OnePlus, want to make this right? Two options: 1) Release the software so I can fix my phone. 2) At minimum, accept my return. So sad what's happened to this company. …more 37 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Andrew Corley • 3rd+ 🙏Relax + Rely on corley ai 🧠🤖 2y “I broke your phone. Intentionally.. You will need someone quite technical to fix it. Why won’t you take it back for free?” 😂😂 …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Andrew Corley’s comment George Hotz Author 2y You don't need someone technical to fix. You run the same restore script you likely already run on every phone you get back regardless of the state. Like Reply Load more comments

Andrew Corley • 3rd+ 🙏Relax + Rely on corley ai 🧠🤖 2y “I broke your phone. Intentionally.. You will need someone quite technical to fix it. Why won’t you take it back for free?” 😂😂 …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Andrew Corley’s comment George Hotz Author 2y You don't need someone technical to fix. You run the same restore script you likely already run on every phone you get back regardless of the state. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y You don't need someone technical to fix. You run the same restore script you likely already run on every phone you get back regardless of the state. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Giuseppe Ferro’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Bought a OnePlus Open last week. Bricked it the first day by setting the fastboot partition to B. QDL brick, so 5 minutes to fix with the right software. However, OnePlus no longer makes that software available to customers after the OnePlus 9. I wasn't thrilled about that policy change, and the phone felt more sluggish in Chrome than the Samsung Electronics Z Fold 5, so I thought I'd just return it and get that. But here is where it got unreasonable. Despite having a 15 day return policy, OnePlus will not allow me to return the phone because I was honest about what happened. It will take them 5 minutes to restore this phone to 100% factory, but nope, can't be returned. Do not EVER buy anything from the OnePlus store. If you insist on buying their phones, buy them from Amazon where you have a sane return policy. Hey OnePlus, want to make this right? Two options: 1) Release the software so I can fix my phone. 2) At minimum, accept my return. So sad what's happened to this company. …more 37 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Giuseppe Ferro • 3rd+ Innovation Officer 🔥🚀 2y George Hotz What would be the return policy of comma devices if something similar happened ? :) Is that an any reason case ? …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Giuseppe Ferro’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Absolutely we honor the return policy. It would be like us not accepting a return if you installed a fork. We have never denied a return within 30 days, the worst we have done is charge for the parts if there's serious physical damage to the device. …more Like Reply Load more comments

Giuseppe Ferro • 3rd+ Innovation Officer 🔥🚀 2y George Hotz What would be the return policy of comma devices if something similar happened ? :) Is that an any reason case ? …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Giuseppe Ferro’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Absolutely we honor the return policy. It would be like us not accepting a return if you installed a fork. We have never denied a return within 30 days, the worst we have done is charge for the parts if there's serious physical damage to the device. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y Absolutely we honor the return policy. It would be like us not accepting a return if you installed a fork. We have never denied a return within 30 days, the worst we have done is charge for the parts if there's serious physical damage to the device. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Matt Park’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Bought a OnePlus Open last week. Bricked it the first day by setting the fastboot partition to B. QDL brick, so 5 minutes to fix with the right software. However, OnePlus no longer makes that software available to customers after the OnePlus 9. I wasn't thrilled about that policy change, and the phone felt more sluggish in Chrome than the Samsung Electronics Z Fold 5, so I thought I'd just return it and get that. But here is where it got unreasonable. Despite having a 15 day return policy, OnePlus will not allow me to return the phone because I was honest about what happened. It will take them 5 minutes to restore this phone to 100% factory, but nope, can't be returned. Do not EVER buy anything from the OnePlus store. If you insist on buying their phones, buy them from Amazon where you have a sane return policy. Hey OnePlus, want to make this right? Two options: 1) Release the software so I can fix my phone. 2) At minimum, accept my return. So sad what's happened to this company. …more 37 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Matt Park • 3rd+ Let's build something 2y …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Matt Park’s comment George Hotz Author 2y linkedin may not be good for dating, but it is the best place to speak truth to power Like Reply Carlos Eduardo C. • 3rd+ Staff Software Engineer | Python | Rust | Infra (edited) 2y George Hotz I thought it was specifically for dating based on your profile lol. Shame it's not working out /s Like Reply Yeongjin Jang • 3rd+ Research Scientist @ Google DeepMind | Eliminating Cyberattack Misuse in the Frontier Model | DARPA/ARPA-H AIxCC final Champion (Team Atlanta) | 2 x DEF CON CTF Champion (2015, 2018) | 6 x Black Hat speaker 2y George Hotz sad that LinkedIn is worse than OKCupid. Like Reply Prateek Gupta • 3rd+ Senior Machine Learning Engineer | Production ML & LLM Systems | Georgia Tech MS, PhD Candidate @ University of Luxembourg 2y remember the days when his profile said he was on LinkedIn for dating and used stackoverflow for Minecraft hints. George got civilised Like Reply Csaba Faragó • 3rd+ Software Developer @ Emarsys 2y Prateek Gupta his bio is still saying that 😅 Like Reply Nick Thorsch • 3rd+ Entrepreneur 2y George Hotz Elies would be offended and say GFY 🤣 Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Matt Park • 3rd+ Let's build something 2y …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Matt Park’s comment George Hotz Author 2y linkedin may not be good for dating, but it is the best place to speak truth to power Like Reply Carlos Eduardo C. • 3rd+ Staff Software Engineer | Python | Rust | Infra (edited) 2y George Hotz I thought it was specifically for dating based on your profile lol. Shame it's not working out /s Like Reply Yeongjin Jang • 3rd+ Research Scientist @ Google DeepMind | Eliminating Cyberattack Misuse in the Frontier Model | DARPA/ARPA-H AIxCC final Champion (Team Atlanta) | 2 x DEF CON CTF Champion (2015, 2018) | 6 x Black Hat speaker 2y George Hotz sad that LinkedIn is worse than OKCupid. Like Reply Prateek Gupta • 3rd+ Senior Machine Learning Engineer | Production ML & LLM Systems | Georgia Tech MS, PhD Candidate @ University of Luxembourg 2y remember the days when his profile said he was on LinkedIn for dating and used stackoverflow for Minecraft hints. George got civilised Like Reply Csaba Faragó • 3rd+ Software Developer @ Emarsys 2y Prateek Gupta his bio is still saying that 😅 Like Reply Nick Thorsch • 3rd+ Entrepreneur 2y George Hotz Elies would be offended and say GFY 🤣 Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y linkedin may not be good for dating, but it is the best place to speak truth to power Like Reply

Carlos Eduardo C. • 3rd+ Staff Software Engineer | Python | Rust | Infra (edited) 2y George Hotz I thought it was specifically for dating based on your profile lol. Shame it's not working out /s Like Reply

Yeongjin Jang • 3rd+ Research Scientist @ Google DeepMind | Eliminating Cyberattack Misuse in the Frontier Model | DARPA/ARPA-H AIxCC final Champion (Team Atlanta) | 2 x DEF CON CTF Champion (2015, 2018) | 6 x Black Hat speaker 2y George Hotz sad that LinkedIn is worse than OKCupid. Like Reply

Prateek Gupta • 3rd+ Senior Machine Learning Engineer | Production ML & LLM Systems | Georgia Tech MS, PhD Candidate @ University of Luxembourg 2y remember the days when his profile said he was on LinkedIn for dating and used stackoverflow for Minecraft hints. George got civilised Like Reply

Csaba Faragó • 3rd+ Software Developer @ Emarsys 2y Prateek Gupta his bio is still saying that 😅 Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to .Bobby Sakaki’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Can someone at Qualcomm get me a quote for: * QCS-8550-1-MPSP1581-TR-02-0-AA (6 core variant) * QCS-6490-1-PSP1287-TR-00-0-AA * SDA-845-A-914BMPSP-TR-02-0-AA 20,000 pcs, delivery in Q3 2024. Please include required PMICs in quote. Also open to third party sources and other variants of the chips if the price is good. Would buy 20k-50k 845s, I know many companies built products around these that didn't sell well. …more 30 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send .Bobby Sakaki • 3rd+ Global Drone Industry Expert 🌎 🚁✈️ / Building an 🇺🇸 Industrial Base for Robotics and sUAS 2y Why not buy the 865? Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on .Bobby Sakaki’s comment George Hotz Author 2y lol, can you get a quote for that? the price they mentioned was laughably high Like Reply .Bobby Sakaki • 3rd+ Global Drone Industry Expert 🌎 🚁✈️ / Building an 🇺🇸 Industrial Base for Robotics and sUAS 2y George Hotz meet Chad Sweet - he can solve your Qualcomm problem. You both are in the same town too Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

.Bobby Sakaki • 3rd+ Global Drone Industry Expert 🌎 🚁✈️ / Building an 🇺🇸 Industrial Base for Robotics and sUAS 2y Why not buy the 865? Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on .Bobby Sakaki’s comment George Hotz Author 2y lol, can you get a quote for that? the price they mentioned was laughably high Like Reply .Bobby Sakaki • 3rd+ Global Drone Industry Expert 🌎 🚁✈️ / Building an 🇺🇸 Industrial Base for Robotics and sUAS 2y George Hotz meet Chad Sweet - he can solve your Qualcomm problem. You both are in the same town too Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y lol, can you get a quote for that? the price they mentioned was laughably high Like Reply

.Bobby Sakaki • 3rd+ Global Drone Industry Expert 🌎 🚁✈️ / Building an 🇺🇸 Industrial Base for Robotics and sUAS 2y George Hotz meet Chad Sweet - he can solve your Qualcomm problem. You both are in the same town too Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Dyllan McCreary’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Can someone at Qualcomm get me a quote for: * QCS-8550-1-MPSP1581-TR-02-0-AA (6 core variant) * QCS-6490-1-PSP1287-TR-00-0-AA * SDA-845-A-914BMPSP-TR-02-0-AA 20,000 pcs, delivery in Q3 2024. Please include required PMICs in quote. Also open to third party sources and other variants of the chips if the price is good. Would buy 20k-50k 845s, I know many companies built products around these that didn't sell well. …more 30 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Dyllan McCreary • 3rd+ AI/RL 2y Qualcomm this Qualcomm that, why don’t you qualcalm down Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Dyllan McCreary’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 2y Esosa Ekhoragbon Someone should either activist invest in the company or do a buyout. There's so much potential being wasted. It's currently priced at 10x less NVDA, and really shouldn't be. …more Like Reply Mykyta Ponomarenko 🇨🇦 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Reducing Apartment Building Utility Expenses by 50%+ 2y George Hotz is right. Cristiano R. Amon why are Qualcomm chips not seen in the same light as Nvidia's? Like Reply Joris L. • 3rd+ independent senior consultant cybersecurity with focus on alignment, analysis, advisories, coaching, configuration management | TISO aspirations || Personal views and opinions apply on this profile. 2y Mykyta Ponomarenko 🇺🇦 Because price builds half of the reputation and Qualcomm is looking to deliver on value ? Like Reply Load more comments

Dyllan McCreary • 3rd+ AI/RL 2y Qualcomm this Qualcomm that, why don’t you qualcalm down Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Dyllan McCreary’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 2y Esosa Ekhoragbon Someone should either activist invest in the company or do a buyout. There's so much potential being wasted. It's currently priced at 10x less NVDA, and really shouldn't be. …more Like Reply Mykyta Ponomarenko 🇨🇦 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Reducing Apartment Building Utility Expenses by 50%+ 2y George Hotz is right. Cristiano R. Amon why are Qualcomm chips not seen in the same light as Nvidia's? Like Reply Joris L. • 3rd+ independent senior consultant cybersecurity with focus on alignment, analysis, advisories, coaching, configuration management | TISO aspirations || Personal views and opinions apply on this profile. 2y Mykyta Ponomarenko 🇺🇦 Because price builds half of the reputation and Qualcomm is looking to deliver on value ? Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y Esosa Ekhoragbon Someone should either activist invest in the company or do a buyout. There's so much potential being wasted. It's currently priced at 10x less NVDA, and really shouldn't be. …more Like Reply

Mykyta Ponomarenko 🇨🇦 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Reducing Apartment Building Utility Expenses by 50%+ 2y George Hotz is right. Cristiano R. Amon why are Qualcomm chips not seen in the same light as Nvidia's? Like Reply

Joris L. • 3rd+ independent senior consultant cybersecurity with focus on alignment, analysis, advisories, coaching, configuration management | TISO aspirations || Personal views and opinions apply on this profile. 2y Mykyta Ponomarenko 🇺🇦 Because price builds half of the reputation and Qualcomm is looking to deliver on value ? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Can someone at Qualcomm get me a quote for: * QCS-8550-1-MPSP1581-TR-02-0-AA (6 core variant) * QCS-6490-1-PSP1287-TR-00-0-AA * SDA-845-A-914BMPSP-TR-02-0-AA 20,000 pcs, delivery in Q3 2024. Please include required PMICs in quote. Also open to third party sources and other variants of the chips if the price is good. Would buy 20k-50k 845s, I know many companies built products around these that didn't sell well. …more 30 comments 3 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2y I wrote up a whole guide to Qualcomm's product offerings if someone is interested. Most of the chips are listed on Arrow Electronics, they are just hard to search for. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Bradley Akers • 3rd+ Training as Commercial drone pilot interested in developing fully autonomous UAS. Excellent safety record testing fully autonomous vehicles and ADAS systems. Team player attitude with strong work ethic. 2y George Hotz hope y’all are looking for third-party Lens suppliers too. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2y I wrote up a whole guide to Qualcomm's product offerings if someone is interested. Most of the chips are listed on Arrow Electronics, they are just hard to search for. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Bradley Akers • 3rd+ Training as Commercial drone pilot interested in developing fully autonomous UAS. Excellent safety record testing fully autonomous vehicles and ADAS systems. Team player attitude with strong work ethic. 2y George Hotz hope y’all are looking for third-party Lens suppliers too. Like Reply

Bradley Akers • 3rd+ Training as Commercial drone pilot interested in developing fully autonomous UAS. Excellent safety record testing fully autonomous vehicles and ADAS systems. Team player attitude with strong work ethic. 2y George Hotz hope y’all are looking for third-party Lens suppliers too. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Raffaele B.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • There's a deep disease in American business culture. Between AT&T, Qualcomm, and many others, I have interacted with people where it seems like their job is to waste your time. We are shifting more and more of our supply chain to China, as for most Chinese suppliers we have dealt with it has been a more pleasant experience. It seems like they are eager for business, and despite a language barrier, they are easier to work with. If you have power in a US company, consider how you can fix this. If someone has a fake job, their full time job is making sure they keep that fake job. While it may be a short term hit, long term it's absolutely vital for your company to get rid of these people. Imagine you walked into a McDonalds, and instead of having prices on the wall, you had to have a "sales experience." Oh, you want a McChicken. Okay, let me check. What will you be using this McChicken for? Can we set up a call to discuss your future McChicken needs? Oh...the price...we'll have to get back to you on that, we have to send that over to the pricing division to determine that. Also, would you like to set up a call with the Big Mac division? Here's a calendly link, and we CCed 7 other people on this e-mail. …more 69 comments 34 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Raffaele B. • 3rd+ Technical Lead | I like to build things I do not know yet (edited) 2y "If someone has a fake job, their full time job is making sure they keep that fake job" This is so true, the guy who used to be my mentor used to express the same concept in a similar manner: "you see, you bust your ass 8+ hours a day to reach a common goal, for the greater good and you expect these people to do the same, but they don't. What they do is they spend 8 hours a day looking for a way to fuck you" …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Raffaele B.’s comment George Hotz Author 2y It's like how "truthiness" can outcompete truth, since it isn't constrained by the fact that it has to be true. Like Reply Daniel M. • 3rd+ 💻 Software Engineer | Scalable Web Apps | Cloud & Computer Vision 💻 2y George Hotz Interesting! Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Raffaele B. • 3rd+ Technical Lead | I like to build things I do not know yet (edited) 2y "If someone has a fake job, their full time job is making sure they keep that fake job" This is so true, the guy who used to be my mentor used to express the same concept in a similar manner: "you see, you bust your ass 8+ hours a day to reach a common goal, for the greater good and you expect these people to do the same, but they don't. What they do is they spend 8 hours a day looking for a way to fuck you" …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Raffaele B.’s comment George Hotz Author 2y It's like how "truthiness" can outcompete truth, since it isn't constrained by the fact that it has to be true. Like Reply Daniel M. • 3rd+ 💻 Software Engineer | Scalable Web Apps | Cloud & Computer Vision 💻 2y George Hotz Interesting! Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y It's like how "truthiness" can outcompete truth, since it isn't constrained by the fact that it has to be true. Like Reply

Daniel M. • 3rd+ 💻 Software Engineer | Scalable Web Apps | Cloud & Computer Vision 💻 2y George Hotz Interesting! Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • There's a deep disease in American business culture. Between AT&T, Qualcomm, and many others, I have interacted with people where it seems like their job is to waste your time. We are shifting more and more of our supply chain to China, as for most Chinese suppliers we have dealt with it has been a more pleasant experience. It seems like they are eager for business, and despite a language barrier, they are easier to work with. If you have power in a US company, consider how you can fix this. If someone has a fake job, their full time job is making sure they keep that fake job. While it may be a short term hit, long term it's absolutely vital for your company to get rid of these people. Imagine you walked into a McDonalds, and instead of having prices on the wall, you had to have a "sales experience." Oh, you want a McChicken. Okay, let me check. What will you be using this McChicken for? Can we set up a call to discuss your future McChicken needs? Oh...the price...we'll have to get back to you on that, we have to send that over to the pricing division to determine that. Also, would you like to set up a call with the Big Mac division? Here's a calendly link, and we CCed 7 other people on this e-mail. …more 69 comments 34 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2y I'll note that neither of my companies will ever do crap like this. comma.ai sells comma 3X for $1250. Wholesale pricing is discussed in the FAQ (10% off 10+, and it's automatic in the cart). After you have bought at least 10 and shown you are worth the time, with a quick e-mail I'll discuss higher discounts for 100+ the tiny corp sells tinyboxes for $15,000. No bulk discounts yet as the product isn't ready and we are behind on preorders, but if you want to get in line, it's $100, fully refundable Elon style. https://tinygrad.org/ …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2y I'll note that neither of my companies will ever do crap like this. comma.ai sells comma 3X for $1250. Wholesale pricing is discussed in the FAQ (10% off 10+, and it's automatic in the cart). After you have bought at least 10 and shown you are worth the time, with a quick e-mail I'll discuss higher discounts for 100+ the tiny corp sells tinyboxes for $15,000. No bulk discounts yet as the product isn't ready and we are behind on preorders, but if you want to get in line, it's $100, fully refundable Elon style. https://tinygrad.org/ …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to George Avetisov’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • There's a deep disease in American business culture. Between AT&T, Qualcomm, and many others, I have interacted with people where it seems like their job is to waste your time. We are shifting more and more of our supply chain to China, as for most Chinese suppliers we have dealt with it has been a more pleasant experience. It seems like they are eager for business, and despite a language barrier, they are easier to work with. If you have power in a US company, consider how you can fix this. If someone has a fake job, their full time job is making sure they keep that fake job. While it may be a short term hit, long term it's absolutely vital for your company to get rid of these people. Imagine you walked into a McDonalds, and instead of having prices on the wall, you had to have a "sales experience." Oh, you want a McChicken. Okay, let me check. What will you be using this McChicken for? Can we set up a call to discuss your future McChicken needs? Oh...the price...we'll have to get back to you on that, we have to send that over to the pricing division to determine that. Also, would you like to set up a call with the Big Mac division? Here's a calendly link, and we CCed 7 other people on this e-mail. …more 69 comments 34 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Avetisov • 3rd+ Founder & CEO @ 1up | Founder @ HYPR | Chief Meme Officer @Crushing_Quota 2y corpos love fake jobs and the budgets that create them. the likelihood that the fake job industrial complex gets any smaller in our lifetime is zero …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Avetisov’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Disagree. I think AI is gonna smash this shit so hard. Like Reply Kahli Burke • 3rd+ Physicist, Data Scientist, Software Engineer (edited) 2y George Hotz I hope so, because how does a fake job do any good for the person who is tasked with it? What real human purpose are they supposed to receive from it? It's all fine and well being 'allowed' to exist without being homeless and hungry but aren't we as intelligent organisms both capable of and unsatisfied without a reason for existing that transcends robotic emptiness? …more Like Reply Ian Peebles • 3rd+ Gen AI & Machine Learning @ AWS (edited) 2y Agree with you George Hotz but it’s going to take awhile. Who within the org is going to identify the AI use case to make a more efficient and customer focused process? The ones making the process so painful for you? Their boss, their bosses boss? None of them, they are all complicite benefactors of the status quo. The people who control the budgets and initiatives most likely are not aware of the inefficiencies and customer complaints because they do not have proper metrics and process to measure. When one of their competitors does it or a new start up takes some market share (see fintech) with a new way of doing business then their eyes will open and it will become a top priority. Then they face all the challenges of acquiring AI capabilities and having proper measurement to justify the investment and show ROI. Interested in how you view the process when compared to your data center purchases? Do you find that to be better, equal or worse? …more Like Reply Mariano Olivera • 3rd+ AI. Cybersecurity. Amazon Web Services cloud. Data center facilities management. Energy builds. IT law compliance. Software engineering. US-DoD Technology Suppliers. Bitcoin. Real Estate. M&A. 2y George Hotz it already is, on sales, it started with AI calling bots Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Avetisov • 3rd+ Founder & CEO @ 1up | Founder @ HYPR | Chief Meme Officer @Crushing_Quota 2y corpos love fake jobs and the budgets that create them. the likelihood that the fake job industrial complex gets any smaller in our lifetime is zero …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Avetisov’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Disagree. I think AI is gonna smash this shit so hard. Like Reply Kahli Burke • 3rd+ Physicist, Data Scientist, Software Engineer (edited) 2y George Hotz I hope so, because how does a fake job do any good for the person who is tasked with it? What real human purpose are they supposed to receive from it? It's all fine and well being 'allowed' to exist without being homeless and hungry but aren't we as intelligent organisms both capable of and unsatisfied without a reason for existing that transcends robotic emptiness? …more Like Reply Ian Peebles • 3rd+ Gen AI & Machine Learning @ AWS (edited) 2y Agree with you George Hotz but it’s going to take awhile. Who within the org is going to identify the AI use case to make a more efficient and customer focused process? The ones making the process so painful for you? Their boss, their bosses boss? None of them, they are all complicite benefactors of the status quo. The people who control the budgets and initiatives most likely are not aware of the inefficiencies and customer complaints because they do not have proper metrics and process to measure. When one of their competitors does it or a new start up takes some market share (see fintech) with a new way of doing business then their eyes will open and it will become a top priority. Then they face all the challenges of acquiring AI capabilities and having proper measurement to justify the investment and show ROI. Interested in how you view the process when compared to your data center purchases? Do you find that to be better, equal or worse? …more Like Reply Mariano Olivera • 3rd+ AI. Cybersecurity. Amazon Web Services cloud. Data center facilities management. Energy builds. IT law compliance. Software engineering. US-DoD Technology Suppliers. Bitcoin. Real Estate. M&A. 2y George Hotz it already is, on sales, it started with AI calling bots Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y Disagree. I think AI is gonna smash this shit so hard. Like Reply

Kahli Burke • 3rd+ Physicist, Data Scientist, Software Engineer (edited) 2y George Hotz I hope so, because how does a fake job do any good for the person who is tasked with it? What real human purpose are they supposed to receive from it? It's all fine and well being 'allowed' to exist without being homeless and hungry but aren't we as intelligent organisms both capable of and unsatisfied without a reason for existing that transcends robotic emptiness? …more Like Reply

Ian Peebles • 3rd+ Gen AI & Machine Learning @ AWS (edited) 2y Agree with you George Hotz but it’s going to take awhile. Who within the org is going to identify the AI use case to make a more efficient and customer focused process? The ones making the process so painful for you? Their boss, their bosses boss? None of them, they are all complicite benefactors of the status quo. The people who control the budgets and initiatives most likely are not aware of the inefficiencies and customer complaints because they do not have proper metrics and process to measure. When one of their competitors does it or a new start up takes some market share (see fintech) with a new way of doing business then their eyes will open and it will become a top priority. Then they face all the challenges of acquiring AI capabilities and having proper measurement to justify the investment and show ROI. Interested in how you view the process when compared to your data center purchases? Do you find that to be better, equal or worse? …more Like Reply

Mariano Olivera • 3rd+ AI. Cybersecurity. Amazon Web Services cloud. Data center facilities management. Energy builds. IT law compliance. Software engineering. US-DoD Technology Suppliers. Bitcoin. Real Estate. M&A. 2y George Hotz it already is, on sales, it started with AI calling bots Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Kieran Kunhya’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • We are currently using AT&T for comma prime. We are paying <redacted>/mo/device for 1 GB, then <redacted> per GB after that. We are currently losing money on the service, and likely getting ripped off by AT&T. Who wants to offer us a better deal? You have to be really easy to work with, I never want phone calls, just a 1 page contract over e-mail clearly outlining better prices and we'll switch. Have 1,600 accounts to transfer over. Ideally I want $10/mo for unlimited data but throttled to 512 kbps. This is the plan we used to have and it was great. US only is fine. (note, prices have been redacted due to a C&D from AT&T) …more 79 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems 2y Good luck with this, all wholesale data plan companies promise the world and never deliver. I've sat through dozens and dozens of calls (because for some reason they don't want to just take my money). I have never seen an industry where it's a) so difficult to buy something in bulk that's easy to buy one of and b) an industry where buying more of something manages to cost you more per unit. That said, you might fare better as you only need US data not EU or global data. …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Kieran Kunhya’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Right? Like how is it cheaper to buy one!?! Like Reply Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems 2y George Hotz Honestly, I think you might have to start your own wholesale data company to get what you want (a bit like the way you want to tape out your own chip one day) because the market for some reason is incapable of acting logically. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 2y Kieran Kunhya I mean...I'm not opposed to this, but how do I get towers? Like Reply Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems (edited) 2y George Hotz I think in the end you'd have to become an MVNO in the US (I imagine not easy to deal with the big telcos) or use a provider from abroad that has US roaming. The second option has the advantage that you can use the operator with the strongest signal at a given place in the US if the foreign telco has multiple roaming deals. There must be someone out there who is solving this problem?! …more Like Reply Thom Morgan • 3rd+ Senior Offensive Security Engineer and AI Red Team Orchestration Enginner (edited) 2y Kieran Kunhya I believe the reason for higher costs when you buy more have to do with the increased premiums ISPs have to pay to reserve more bandwidth of the radio towers. The more bandwidth an ISP reserves the more it costs to reserve additional bandwidth; this model deters the monopolization of cell towers by a single carrier …more Like Reply Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems 2y Thom Morgan Afaik each carrier has their own cell tower and billing is done on a completely different system from cell tower management. Like Reply Thom Morgan • 3rd+ Senior Offensive Security Engineer and AI Red Team Orchestration Enginner 2y Kieran Kunhya From what I have read, anyone theoretically can construct a cell tower and then rent out bandwidth to carriers. As for my assumption there are protocols in place to prevent monopolization, I haven't found any evidence to back that up …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems 2y Good luck with this, all wholesale data plan companies promise the world and never deliver. I've sat through dozens and dozens of calls (because for some reason they don't want to just take my money). I have never seen an industry where it's a) so difficult to buy something in bulk that's easy to buy one of and b) an industry where buying more of something manages to cost you more per unit. That said, you might fare better as you only need US data not EU or global data. …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Kieran Kunhya’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Right? Like how is it cheaper to buy one!?! Like Reply Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems 2y George Hotz Honestly, I think you might have to start your own wholesale data company to get what you want (a bit like the way you want to tape out your own chip one day) because the market for some reason is incapable of acting logically. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 2y Kieran Kunhya I mean...I'm not opposed to this, but how do I get towers? Like Reply Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems (edited) 2y George Hotz I think in the end you'd have to become an MVNO in the US (I imagine not easy to deal with the big telcos) or use a provider from abroad that has US roaming. The second option has the advantage that you can use the operator with the strongest signal at a given place in the US if the foreign telco has multiple roaming deals. There must be someone out there who is solving this problem?! …more Like Reply Thom Morgan • 3rd+ Senior Offensive Security Engineer and AI Red Team Orchestration Enginner (edited) 2y Kieran Kunhya I believe the reason for higher costs when you buy more have to do with the increased premiums ISPs have to pay to reserve more bandwidth of the radio towers. The more bandwidth an ISP reserves the more it costs to reserve additional bandwidth; this model deters the monopolization of cell towers by a single carrier …more Like Reply Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems 2y Thom Morgan Afaik each carrier has their own cell tower and billing is done on a completely different system from cell tower management. Like Reply Thom Morgan • 3rd+ Senior Offensive Security Engineer and AI Red Team Orchestration Enginner 2y Kieran Kunhya From what I have read, anyone theoretically can construct a cell tower and then rent out bandwidth to carriers. As for my assumption there are protocols in place to prevent monopolization, I haven't found any evidence to back that up …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y Right? Like how is it cheaper to buy one!?! Like Reply

Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems 2y George Hotz Honestly, I think you might have to start your own wholesale data company to get what you want (a bit like the way you want to tape out your own chip one day) because the market for some reason is incapable of acting logically. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y Kieran Kunhya I mean...I'm not opposed to this, but how do I get towers? Like Reply

Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems (edited) 2y George Hotz I think in the end you'd have to become an MVNO in the US (I imagine not easy to deal with the big telcos) or use a provider from abroad that has US roaming. The second option has the advantage that you can use the operator with the strongest signal at a given place in the US if the foreign telco has multiple roaming deals. There must be someone out there who is solving this problem?! …more Like Reply

Thom Morgan • 3rd+ Senior Offensive Security Engineer and AI Red Team Orchestration Enginner (edited) 2y Kieran Kunhya I believe the reason for higher costs when you buy more have to do with the increased premiums ISPs have to pay to reserve more bandwidth of the radio towers. The more bandwidth an ISP reserves the more it costs to reserve additional bandwidth; this model deters the monopolization of cell towers by a single carrier …more Like Reply

Kieran Kunhya • 3rd+ Founder and CEO at Open Broadcast Systems 2y Thom Morgan Afaik each carrier has their own cell tower and billing is done on a completely different system from cell tower management. Like Reply

Thom Morgan • 3rd+ Senior Offensive Security Engineer and AI Red Team Orchestration Enginner 2y Kieran Kunhya From what I have read, anyone theoretically can construct a cell tower and then rent out bandwidth to carriers. As for my assumption there are protocols in place to prevent monopolization, I haven't found any evidence to back that up …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Saveli Kotz’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • We are currently using AT&T for comma prime. We are paying <redacted>/mo/device for 1 GB, then <redacted> per GB after that. We are currently losing money on the service, and likely getting ripped off by AT&T. Who wants to offer us a better deal? You have to be really easy to work with, I never want phone calls, just a 1 page contract over e-mail clearly outlining better prices and we'll switch. Have 1,600 accounts to transfer over. Ideally I want $10/mo for unlimited data but throttled to 512 kbps. This is the plan we used to have and it was great. US only is fine. (note, prices have been redacted due to a C&D from AT&T) …more 79 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Saveli Kotz • 3rd+ Founder of ravlai.com, MTAG Publishing (mysterytag.com) 2 exits, 10’s of startups (edited) 2y Mike Sievert & Mike Katz you gentlemen can probably help amazingly talented George with comma.ai connectivity contract. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Saveli Kotz’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y We used to have T-Mobile, a great plan! Was like $10/mo for unlimited data throttled to 512 kbps. This is the plan we really want, but T-Mobile discontinued it. Would be happy to switch back. …more Like Reply Marcel B. • 3rd+ Principal Data Scientist | NLP | ML | AI | Computer Vision 2y George Hotz I was going to say mint but they are now bought by T-Mobile. Like Reply Peter Parianos • 3rd+ Software Development Engineer | Amazon | AWS Services | Java Micro-Services | React 2y George Hotz I used to use a new plan... maybe T-Mobile will see this and enable this plan again lol Like Reply Manoj Vekaria • 3rd+ Founding Lead Engineer at Recurrency 2y George Hotz do you know why T-mobile discontinued it? Were they losing money on it? Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Saveli Kotz • 3rd+ Founder of ravlai.com, MTAG Publishing (mysterytag.com) 2 exits, 10’s of startups (edited) 2y Mike Sievert & Mike Katz you gentlemen can probably help amazingly talented George with comma.ai connectivity contract. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Saveli Kotz’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y We used to have T-Mobile, a great plan! Was like $10/mo for unlimited data throttled to 512 kbps. This is the plan we really want, but T-Mobile discontinued it. Would be happy to switch back. …more Like Reply Marcel B. • 3rd+ Principal Data Scientist | NLP | ML | AI | Computer Vision 2y George Hotz I was going to say mint but they are now bought by T-Mobile. Like Reply Peter Parianos • 3rd+ Software Development Engineer | Amazon | AWS Services | Java Micro-Services | React 2y George Hotz I used to use a new plan... maybe T-Mobile will see this and enable this plan again lol Like Reply Manoj Vekaria • 3rd+ Founding Lead Engineer at Recurrency 2y George Hotz do you know why T-mobile discontinued it? Were they losing money on it? Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 2y We used to have T-Mobile, a great plan! Was like $10/mo for unlimited data throttled to 512 kbps. This is the plan we really want, but T-Mobile discontinued it. Would be happy to switch back. …more Like Reply

Marcel B. • 3rd+ Principal Data Scientist | NLP | ML | AI | Computer Vision 2y George Hotz I was going to say mint but they are now bought by T-Mobile. Like Reply

Peter Parianos • 3rd+ Software Development Engineer | Amazon | AWS Services | Java Micro-Services | React 2y George Hotz I used to use a new plan... maybe T-Mobile will see this and enable this plan again lol Like Reply

Manoj Vekaria • 3rd+ Founding Lead Engineer at Recurrency 2y George Hotz do you know why T-mobile discontinued it? Were they losing money on it? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • We are currently using AT&T for comma prime. We are paying <redacted>/mo/device for 1 GB, then <redacted> per GB after that. We are currently losing money on the service, and likely getting ripped off by AT&T. Who wants to offer us a better deal? You have to be really easy to work with, I never want phone calls, just a 1 page contract over e-mail clearly outlining better prices and we'll switch. Have 1,600 accounts to transfer over. Ideally I want $10/mo for unlimited data but throttled to 512 kbps. This is the plan we used to have and it was great. US only is fine. (note, prices have been redacted due to a C&D from AT&T) …more 79 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 2y Mint Mobile is offering unlimited for $15/mo. https://www.mintmobile.com/ MobileX is offering $5 base and $2.10/GB. https://www.mymobilex.com/plans/ And these are retail plans you buy one of. I have 1,600 lines! …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Chad El Hage • 3rd+ CEO @ Branded Currency Solutions 💳 | Settlement Flow ⚖️ | Brands In Games® 🎮 | Connected Rewards 📲 | Branded Moments ✨ 2y Jon Horovitz maybe you can help George Hotz Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 2y Mint Mobile is offering unlimited for $15/mo. https://www.mintmobile.com/ MobileX is offering $5 base and $2.10/GB. https://www.mymobilex.com/plans/ And these are retail plans you buy one of. I have 1,600 lines! …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Chad El Hage • 3rd+ CEO @ Branded Currency Solutions 💳 | Settlement Flow ⚖️ | Brands In Games® 🎮 | Connected Rewards 📲 | Branded Moments ✨ 2y Jon Horovitz maybe you can help George Hotz Like Reply

Chad El Hage • 3rd+ CEO @ Branded Currency Solutions 💳 | Settlement Flow ⚖️ | Brands In Games® 🎮 | Connected Rewards 📲 | Branded Moments ✨ 2y Jon Horovitz maybe you can help George Hotz Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Ryan N.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Some definitions: Connect -- Give me your time Partner -- Give me your money Collaborate -- Give me your time and money Explore -- Give me your time to discuss giving me your money Opportunity -- Way for you to give me your time and money Innovation -- A new way to use more of your time and money Can people please stop using these words. I have never gotten a message that uses any of these words that is worth responding to. …more 69 comments 50 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Ryan N. • 3rd+ Technical Success Manager - C1 2y You could use an LLM to write natural language firewall rules for corp-speak. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Ryan N.’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Eventually I'm just going to ask the LLM straight up will this person provide value or not. Need one that isn't RLHFed to shit so it'll tell the truth. If the answer is no, it will reply and hold a pleasant conversation that lasts a while and sounds promising but ultimately goes nowhere. This way the world will learn to stop sending garbage when the ROI is super negative. It won't just be me doing this. hashtag #heavenbanned …more Like Reply Ryan N. • 3rd+ Technical Success Manager - C1 (edited) 2y George Hotz A rudimentary form of this has been in use for quite some time. The idea is to waste a cold-caller's time as much as possible. Lenny's very simple script would waste 5-8 minutes of someone trying to send you their latest IT industry "white paper." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenny_(bot) Remaking Lenny powered by an LLM could be the death of cold calls. Lenny currently runs on FreePBX ⋆ Asterisk but with the tools out there, the concept could be fairly easily ported to different IVA platforms. Training the same model to interface with LinkedIn and other similar platforms would then be pretty trivial compared to voice. …more Like Reply Ian Maurer • 3rd+ CTO at GenomOncology (edited) 2y If George could give Lenny a Llama2-70B brain upgrade and run him on a TinyBox, I might have to buy that. Like Reply Ryan N. • 3rd+ Technical Success Manager - C1 2y Ian Maurer I doubt you want to run a whole telephony/IVA stack on your TinyBox. That's what the cloud is for. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Ryan N. • 3rd+ Technical Success Manager - C1 2y You could use an LLM to write natural language firewall rules for corp-speak. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Ryan N.’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Eventually I'm just going to ask the LLM straight up will this person provide value or not. Need one that isn't RLHFed to shit so it'll tell the truth. If the answer is no, it will reply and hold a pleasant conversation that lasts a while and sounds promising but ultimately goes nowhere. This way the world will learn to stop sending garbage when the ROI is super negative. It won't just be me doing this. hashtag #heavenbanned …more Like Reply Ryan N. • 3rd+ Technical Success Manager - C1 (edited) 2y George Hotz A rudimentary form of this has been in use for quite some time. The idea is to waste a cold-caller's time as much as possible. Lenny's very simple script would waste 5-8 minutes of someone trying to send you their latest IT industry "white paper." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenny_(bot) Remaking Lenny powered by an LLM could be the death of cold calls. Lenny currently runs on FreePBX ⋆ Asterisk but with the tools out there, the concept could be fairly easily ported to different IVA platforms. Training the same model to interface with LinkedIn and other similar platforms would then be pretty trivial compared to voice. …more Like Reply Ian Maurer • 3rd+ CTO at GenomOncology (edited) 2y If George could give Lenny a Llama2-70B brain upgrade and run him on a TinyBox, I might have to buy that. Like Reply Ryan N. • 3rd+ Technical Success Manager - C1 2y Ian Maurer I doubt you want to run a whole telephony/IVA stack on your TinyBox. That's what the cloud is for. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y Eventually I'm just going to ask the LLM straight up will this person provide value or not. Need one that isn't RLHFed to shit so it'll tell the truth. If the answer is no, it will reply and hold a pleasant conversation that lasts a while and sounds promising but ultimately goes nowhere. This way the world will learn to stop sending garbage when the ROI is super negative. It won't just be me doing this. hashtag #heavenbanned …more Like Reply

Ryan N. • 3rd+ Technical Success Manager - C1 (edited) 2y George Hotz A rudimentary form of this has been in use for quite some time. The idea is to waste a cold-caller's time as much as possible. Lenny's very simple script would waste 5-8 minutes of someone trying to send you their latest IT industry "white paper." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenny_(bot) Remaking Lenny powered by an LLM could be the death of cold calls. Lenny currently runs on FreePBX ⋆ Asterisk but with the tools out there, the concept could be fairly easily ported to different IVA platforms. Training the same model to interface with LinkedIn and other similar platforms would then be pretty trivial compared to voice. …more Like Reply

Ian Maurer • 3rd+ CTO at GenomOncology (edited) 2y If George could give Lenny a Llama2-70B brain upgrade and run him on a TinyBox, I might have to buy that. Like Reply

Ryan N. • 3rd+ Technical Success Manager - C1 2y Ian Maurer I doubt you want to run a whole telephony/IVA stack on your TinyBox. That's what the cloud is for. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jad Nohra’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Some definitions: Connect -- Give me your time Partner -- Give me your money Collaborate -- Give me your time and money Explore -- Give me your time to discuss giving me your money Opportunity -- Way for you to give me your time and money Innovation -- A new way to use more of your time and money Can people please stop using these words. I have never gotten a message that uses any of these words that is worth responding to. …more 69 comments 50 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. 2y Maybe you have no clue about how to network. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Jad Nohra’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Ugh, there's another one of the words Like Reply Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. (edited) 2y George Hotz ugh yes, I feel you, the world is so full of tedious clueless monkeys parroting ‚the words‘, with a few rare geniuses who see through it, isn’t it? Like Reply Mani E. Sohi • 3rd+ Product Engineer 2y Networking - business excuse to do basic human socializing Like Reply 🔴 Silviu Preoteasa • 3rd+ Founder/CEO @ Advanced Radio Mapping | Analytics, Strategy, AI Transformation | e/acc is obsolete 2y You’re not a chad, Jad. That is not a clue, it’s a statement. No maybe. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. 2y Maybe you have no clue about how to network. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Jad Nohra’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Ugh, there's another one of the words Like Reply Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. (edited) 2y George Hotz ugh yes, I feel you, the world is so full of tedious clueless monkeys parroting ‚the words‘, with a few rare geniuses who see through it, isn’t it? Like Reply Mani E. Sohi • 3rd+ Product Engineer 2y Networking - business excuse to do basic human socializing Like Reply 🔴 Silviu Preoteasa • 3rd+ Founder/CEO @ Advanced Radio Mapping | Analytics, Strategy, AI Transformation | e/acc is obsolete 2y You’re not a chad, Jad. That is not a clue, it’s a statement. No maybe. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y Ugh, there's another one of the words Like Reply

Jad Nohra • 3rd+ technologist | jadnohra.com/tech | AI Agents, Web3 ZK accelerators , Robotics safety systems, physics engines, sim, game AI, FPGA, Rust, C++, Py, compilers. (edited) 2y George Hotz ugh yes, I feel you, the world is so full of tedious clueless monkeys parroting ‚the words‘, with a few rare geniuses who see through it, isn’t it? Like Reply

Mani E. Sohi • 3rd+ Product Engineer 2y Networking - business excuse to do basic human socializing Like Reply

🔴 Silviu Preoteasa • 3rd+ Founder/CEO @ Advanced Radio Mapping | Analytics, Strategy, AI Transformation | e/acc is obsolete 2y You’re not a chad, Jad. That is not a clue, it’s a statement. No maybe. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Narek Khachatryan’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Some definitions: Connect -- Give me your time Partner -- Give me your money Collaborate -- Give me your time and money Explore -- Give me your time to discuss giving me your money Opportunity -- Way for you to give me your time and money Innovation -- A new way to use more of your time and money Can people please stop using these words. I have never gotten a message that uses any of these words that is worth responding to. …more 69 comments 50 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Narek Khachatryan • 3rd+ CPO at Finturf | Building Fintech Infrastructure for Home Improvement 2y Hey George, I'd like to connect with you to explore potential opportunities for collaboration and partnership. Your background and expertise caught my attention, and I believe there could be room for innovation through our connection. Looking forward to the possibility of collaborating and exploring new ventures together. …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Narek Khachatryan’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 2y Wow, you'd like to take up my time to discuss me potentially giving you money. My background and expertise leads you to believe I might have money, and you have new ways of using my time and money which you'll take up my time to tell me about. What a deal! …more Like Reply James Lake • 3rd+ Engineering & Sales Recruitment | Strategic Client Partner | OEMs, Distributors & Service Providers | Energy & Power Gen | Oil & Gas | Aggie 2y darn you beat me to it Like Reply Spencer Matonis, PhD • 3rd+ Building therapeutic implants for the intestine 2y Your profile caught my eye… Like Reply Vicente García Diez • 3rd+ 🔑🔓 Trusted advisor | 👨‍🏫 Software architecture mentor | 📋 Problem solver 2y Are you talking about a challenging project? Are you offering a 0.005% of stock options? Like Reply Load more comments

Narek Khachatryan • 3rd+ CPO at Finturf | Building Fintech Infrastructure for Home Improvement 2y Hey George, I'd like to connect with you to explore potential opportunities for collaboration and partnership. Your background and expertise caught my attention, and I believe there could be room for innovation through our connection. Looking forward to the possibility of collaborating and exploring new ventures together. …more Like Reply 5 replies 5 Replies on Narek Khachatryan’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author 2y Wow, you'd like to take up my time to discuss me potentially giving you money. My background and expertise leads you to believe I might have money, and you have new ways of using my time and money which you'll take up my time to tell me about. What a deal! …more Like Reply James Lake • 3rd+ Engineering & Sales Recruitment | Strategic Client Partner | OEMs, Distributors & Service Providers | Energy & Power Gen | Oil & Gas | Aggie 2y darn you beat me to it Like Reply Spencer Matonis, PhD • 3rd+ Building therapeutic implants for the intestine 2y Your profile caught my eye… Like Reply Vicente García Diez • 3rd+ 🔑🔓 Trusted advisor | 👨‍🏫 Software architecture mentor | 📋 Problem solver 2y Are you talking about a challenging project? Are you offering a 0.005% of stock options? Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y Wow, you'd like to take up my time to discuss me potentially giving you money. My background and expertise leads you to believe I might have money, and you have new ways of using my time and money which you'll take up my time to tell me about. What a deal! …more Like Reply

James Lake • 3rd+ Engineering & Sales Recruitment | Strategic Client Partner | OEMs, Distributors & Service Providers | Energy & Power Gen | Oil & Gas | Aggie 2y darn you beat me to it Like Reply

Spencer Matonis, PhD • 3rd+ Building therapeutic implants for the intestine 2y Your profile caught my eye… Like Reply

Vicente García Diez • 3rd+ 🔑🔓 Trusted advisor | 👨‍🏫 Software architecture mentor | 📋 Problem solver 2y Are you talking about a challenging project? Are you offering a 0.005% of stock options? Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to John Kost’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • The problem is your 80s era sales org. Stop the sales process from being so adversarial! At least have Qualcomm pretend to be excited about new customers. Your sales guy blatantly lied to try to extract $35k more from me. Then *after* we sent money, we were presented with a weird legal doc we had to sign...that no one mentioned until you were holding my money. So not cool. This stupid dance took over a month, wasted many people's time, was the third time we tried to buy chips from Qualcomm (the first two managed to be worse), and I'll note that I'm still not touching chips. It makes it so hard to trust Qualcomm. We know the cost to make chips, take a fair margin, be transparent, and be easy to buy from. This is table stakes in business today, it isn't the 80s where information was hidden. Most Chinese companies get this, and people will go with the lowest friction source. You have some nice chips, but you aren't a monopoly anymore. I would rather buy chips a gen or two back from other companies than deal with the super painful Qualcomm sales process again. Many people have reached out to me and expressed similar sentiments. Change and Qualcomm can be great. Stay the same, and the headlines like this will just continue. The high end Android market is dying. There's so many new markets for Qualcomm, but they will have to embrace the new way of doing business. I have reached out by e-mail again. This can be fixed. Change starts with a single step. …more Qualcomm chip sales down 25 percent, plans layoffs arstechnica.com 29 comments 14 reposts Like Comment Repost Send John Kost • 3rd+ Sr. Software Architect/Embedded Engineering. Bridging hardware, Cloud & AI/ML. Proven in safety robotics (IEC 61508) & eyeCrane™ 3D. Bringing rare AI software & hardware fusion to immediately shape innovative platforms. 2y The other issue (elephant in the room) is maybe Qualcomm doesn't want to risk damage to their brand. Put yourself into their shoes. Would you want to quote and deliver your parts that has potential future risk. Maybe this is why the 'weird legal doc' was inserted into the process. comma.ai has to mature (grow-up) and start using proper automotive components in their products like the other tier-one suppliers do. For us hobbyists and DIY'rs we will experiment with alternatives.. https://github.com/JohnnyOpcode/raspberry-pilot-plus …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on John Kost’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author (edited) 2y The legal doc was universal, nothing specific to us. Some people have very backward attitudes about using the "appropriate" component. They would still have a 65C02 and an incandescent indicator bulb, while the rest of us get tablet touchscreens. Use the right components to enforce functional safety goals, use whatever is best for everything that's QM. Why don't you make one using whatever parts you deem appropriate and come compete with us on the market? No matter what parts you use, it'll take you several generations to come close to our current failure rate. :) …more Like Reply John Kost • 3rd+ Sr. Software Architect/Embedded Engineering. Bridging hardware, Cloud & AI/ML. Proven in safety robotics (IEC 61508) & eyeCrane™ 3D. Bringing rare AI software & hardware fusion to immediately shape innovative platforms. 2y George Hotz you make some good points and maybe someone, someday will compete with you in the marketplace. For now you have a 'moat' with your hardware, but there is talent in Shenzhen and they could build a Rockchip based equivalent rapidly. They could refine the OpenPilot stack as well and there isn't a single thing you could really do except adjust your pricing. Look no further than at the amazing Double DIN Android units from China. They are super-charged with lots of compute cores at prices than are very reasonable and even come with CAN FD. If I was a 'smart' entrepreneur, I would go to SiFive and have the chip built NOW for the next-gen device. I'm sure Andreessen Horowitz would back your play. You are a proven performer. I wish you all the luck getting those parts you need for this new generation Comma. It's come a long way since the Neo. It's an impressive device. Cheers.. …more Like Reply Load more comments

John Kost • 3rd+ Sr. Software Architect/Embedded Engineering. Bridging hardware, Cloud & AI/ML. Proven in safety robotics (IEC 61508) & eyeCrane™ 3D. Bringing rare AI software & hardware fusion to immediately shape innovative platforms. 2y The other issue (elephant in the room) is maybe Qualcomm doesn't want to risk damage to their brand. Put yourself into their shoes. Would you want to quote and deliver your parts that has potential future risk. Maybe this is why the 'weird legal doc' was inserted into the process. comma.ai has to mature (grow-up) and start using proper automotive components in their products like the other tier-one suppliers do. For us hobbyists and DIY'rs we will experiment with alternatives.. https://github.com/JohnnyOpcode/raspberry-pilot-plus …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on John Kost’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author (edited) 2y The legal doc was universal, nothing specific to us. Some people have very backward attitudes about using the "appropriate" component. They would still have a 65C02 and an incandescent indicator bulb, while the rest of us get tablet touchscreens. Use the right components to enforce functional safety goals, use whatever is best for everything that's QM. Why don't you make one using whatever parts you deem appropriate and come compete with us on the market? No matter what parts you use, it'll take you several generations to come close to our current failure rate. :) …more Like Reply John Kost • 3rd+ Sr. Software Architect/Embedded Engineering. Bridging hardware, Cloud & AI/ML. Proven in safety robotics (IEC 61508) & eyeCrane™ 3D. Bringing rare AI software & hardware fusion to immediately shape innovative platforms. 2y George Hotz you make some good points and maybe someone, someday will compete with you in the marketplace. For now you have a 'moat' with your hardware, but there is talent in Shenzhen and they could build a Rockchip based equivalent rapidly. They could refine the OpenPilot stack as well and there isn't a single thing you could really do except adjust your pricing. Look no further than at the amazing Double DIN Android units from China. They are super-charged with lots of compute cores at prices than are very reasonable and even come with CAN FD. If I was a 'smart' entrepreneur, I would go to SiFive and have the chip built NOW for the next-gen device. I'm sure Andreessen Horowitz would back your play. You are a proven performer. I wish you all the luck getting those parts you need for this new generation Comma. It's come a long way since the Neo. It's an impressive device. Cheers.. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 2y The legal doc was universal, nothing specific to us. Some people have very backward attitudes about using the "appropriate" component. They would still have a 65C02 and an incandescent indicator bulb, while the rest of us get tablet touchscreens. Use the right components to enforce functional safety goals, use whatever is best for everything that's QM. Why don't you make one using whatever parts you deem appropriate and come compete with us on the market? No matter what parts you use, it'll take you several generations to come close to our current failure rate. :) …more Like Reply

John Kost • 3rd+ Sr. Software Architect/Embedded Engineering. Bridging hardware, Cloud & AI/ML. Proven in safety robotics (IEC 61508) & eyeCrane™ 3D. Bringing rare AI software & hardware fusion to immediately shape innovative platforms. 2y George Hotz you make some good points and maybe someone, someday will compete with you in the marketplace. For now you have a 'moat' with your hardware, but there is talent in Shenzhen and they could build a Rockchip based equivalent rapidly. They could refine the OpenPilot stack as well and there isn't a single thing you could really do except adjust your pricing. Look no further than at the amazing Double DIN Android units from China. They are super-charged with lots of compute cores at prices than are very reasonable and even come with CAN FD. If I was a 'smart' entrepreneur, I would go to SiFive and have the chip built NOW for the next-gen device. I'm sure Andreessen Horowitz would back your play. You are a proven performer. I wish you all the luck getting those parts you need for this new generation Comma. It's come a long way since the Neo. It's an impressive device. Cheers.. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to their own comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • The problem is your 80s era sales org. Stop the sales process from being so adversarial! At least have Qualcomm pretend to be excited about new customers. Your sales guy blatantly lied to try to extract $35k more from me. Then *after* we sent money, we were presented with a weird legal doc we had to sign...that no one mentioned until you were holding my money. So not cool. This stupid dance took over a month, wasted many people's time, was the third time we tried to buy chips from Qualcomm (the first two managed to be worse), and I'll note that I'm still not touching chips. It makes it so hard to trust Qualcomm. We know the cost to make chips, take a fair margin, be transparent, and be easy to buy from. This is table stakes in business today, it isn't the 80s where information was hidden. Most Chinese companies get this, and people will go with the lowest friction source. You have some nice chips, but you aren't a monopoly anymore. I would rather buy chips a gen or two back from other companies than deal with the super painful Qualcomm sales process again. Many people have reached out to me and expressed similar sentiments. Change and Qualcomm can be great. Stay the same, and the headlines like this will just continue. The high end Android market is dying. There's so many new markets for Qualcomm, but they will have to embrace the new way of doing business. I have reached out by e-mail again. This can be fixed. Change starts with a single step. …more Qualcomm chip sales down 25 percent, plans layoffs arstechnica.com 29 comments 14 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author (edited) 2y And if this does get through to Qualcomm, this bad sales org stuff has terrible second order effects. We just launched the comma 3X, and are in the very early planning stages for the comma 4. A key first step is chip selection. I'm sitting at my computer right now adb'ed into a QCS8550 dev board. I'm thinking about all the software work that will be required. Ubuntu, userspace, tinygrad, etc... …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Pankaj Doharey • 3rd+ CTO at ZenDiffusion | Machine Learning, Full Stack Development 2y How hard is it to get your hands on some blackmarket 845 in china? I am sure some mobile manufacturer will be happy to sell you their surplus. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author (edited) 2y And if this does get through to Qualcomm, this bad sales org stuff has terrible second order effects. We just launched the comma 3X, and are in the very early planning stages for the comma 4. A key first step is chip selection. I'm sitting at my computer right now adb'ed into a QCS8550 dev board. I'm thinking about all the software work that will be required. Ubuntu, userspace, tinygrad, etc... …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Pankaj Doharey • 3rd+ CTO at ZenDiffusion | Machine Learning, Full Stack Development 2y How hard is it to get your hands on some blackmarket 845 in china? I am sure some mobile manufacturer will be happy to sell you their surplus. Like Reply

Pankaj Doharey • 3rd+ CTO at ZenDiffusion | Machine Learning, Full Stack Development 2y How hard is it to get your hands on some blackmarket 845 in china? I am sure some mobile manufacturer will be happy to sell you their surplus. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • The problem is your 80s era sales org. Stop the sales process from being so adversarial! At least have Qualcomm pretend to be excited about new customers. Your sales guy blatantly lied to try to extract $35k more from me. Then *after* we sent money, we were presented with a weird legal doc we had to sign...that no one mentioned until you were holding my money. So not cool. This stupid dance took over a month, wasted many people's time, was the third time we tried to buy chips from Qualcomm (the first two managed to be worse), and I'll note that I'm still not touching chips. It makes it so hard to trust Qualcomm. We know the cost to make chips, take a fair margin, be transparent, and be easy to buy from. This is table stakes in business today, it isn't the 80s where information was hidden. Most Chinese companies get this, and people will go with the lowest friction source. You have some nice chips, but you aren't a monopoly anymore. I would rather buy chips a gen or two back from other companies than deal with the super painful Qualcomm sales process again. Many people have reached out to me and expressed similar sentiments. Change and Qualcomm can be great. Stay the same, and the headlines like this will just continue. The high end Android market is dying. There's so many new markets for Qualcomm, but they will have to embrace the new way of doing business. I have reached out by e-mail again. This can be fixed. Change starts with a single step. …more Qualcomm chip sales down 25 percent, plans layoffs arstechnica.com 29 comments 14 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author (edited) 2y TIL Google makes their own SoC, I didn't know Pixel wasn't still Qualcomm. Guess Google got fed up with dealing with them. Want to sell the chips by chance? They look great. https://www.androidauthority.com/google-tensor-g2-explained-3216087/ …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Soutrik Maiti • 3rd+ Embedded Software Developer at Amazon Leo | Former ASML | Former Qualcomm 2y George Hotz , there might be a solution for this -> https://www.fastcompany.com/90962875/nanotronics-cubefabs-prefab-chip-factories A NY startup aims to build hundreds of chip factories with prefab parts and AI The global quest for semiconductors is dominated by giant, costly factories. With CubeFabs, Nanotronics could let anyone take a DIY approach. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author (edited) 2y TIL Google makes their own SoC, I didn't know Pixel wasn't still Qualcomm. Guess Google got fed up with dealing with them. Want to sell the chips by chance? They look great. https://www.androidauthority.com/google-tensor-g2-explained-3216087/ …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Soutrik Maiti • 3rd+ Embedded Software Developer at Amazon Leo | Former ASML | Former Qualcomm 2y George Hotz , there might be a solution for this -> https://www.fastcompany.com/90962875/nanotronics-cubefabs-prefab-chip-factories A NY startup aims to build hundreds of chip factories with prefab parts and AI The global quest for semiconductors is dominated by giant, costly factories. With CubeFabs, Nanotronics could let anyone take a DIY approach. Like Reply

Soutrik Maiti • 3rd+ Embedded Software Developer at Amazon Leo | Former ASML | Former Qualcomm 2y George Hotz , there might be a solution for this -> https://www.fastcompany.com/90962875/nanotronics-cubefabs-prefab-chip-factories A NY startup aims to build hundreds of chip factories with prefab parts and AI The global quest for semiconductors is dominated by giant, costly factories. With CubeFabs, Nanotronics could let anyone take a DIY approach. Like Reply

A NY startup aims to build hundreds of chip factories with prefab parts and AI The global quest for semiconductors is dominated by giant, costly factories. With CubeFabs, Nanotronics could let anyone take a DIY approach.

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Timofey Uvarov’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Does anyone want to take an activist position investing in Qualcomm? In the last year, QCOM is -6.66%. NVDA is +185.61% and AMD is +52.55%. Qualcomm's chips are the best on the market for AI inference, but you never hear about them as a serious player. The main reason is that, unlike NVDA and AMD, buying chips from them is like pulling teeth. They got rich selling chips to 10 cell phone makers. But today, high end Android is basically over and the 10 whales are gone. The company is struggling to adapt to the new world, they need someone to come in and clean it up. There's huge potential with their chips in self driving cars and AI robotics, but not if they continue on their current trajectory. You'll make big money doing this. If you are serious and have the funding, I'm happy to help. I just want the world to be able to easily buy the chips for a fair price. hashtag #qualcomm hashtag #ai hashtag #investing …more 47 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist (edited) 2y Qualcomm support is so poor as they focus only on large customers so it’s like investing into sp500. On the other hand there is onsemi (and amba) who are growing their chipsets from vision cores, rather then compute cores, which is the proper way. Now when evenryone is all time low, onsemi is all time high and I bet 2:1 will grow with hashtag …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Timofey Uvarov’s comment George Hotz Author 2y They have quite good sensors and are pretty easy to buy from. They did so well though that the sensors are now very expensive! We switched to OMNIVISION, but it's just a price thing. I like onsemi too. …more Like Reply Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y George Hotz I worked 4 years on OMNIVISION sensors in their US and Singapore teams, and their sensors (especially new 3mp) are good and its hard to compete on the price with them, as they reserved a lot of TSMC, having huge market in China. But I am prioritizing onsemi as their tuning and prototyping tools (devware) are lightyears ahead and for camera final image quality tuning and firmware is often more important than sensor quality. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 2y We have our own camera stack at comma.ai so the software is less important to us. Like Reply Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y George Hotz thats cool, I am curious to learn more, as we might consider different things under "camera stack". Are you actually overriding low level sensor control based on your location, car speed, scene classification like sunset and high level perception requirements (like whether you are aiming to detect traffic lights or regular objects)? I have a lab with optical tools and can find weak points of your camera (similar to optometry). if you have any disengagements due to missed traffic lights or objects, some strange colors, over or underexposed images, I can fix it. I've overlooked imaging pipe in Tesla, Pony, X-motors and few other companies and can work with your camera team. Already PM-ed you sample report on AR0231 (which you were previously using) honest dynamic range - dont trust manufacturer spec. Working for food! …more Like Reply Kumar Tatsat • 3rd+ IBM Z Compiler Performance 2y Timo Uvarov submit a PR on comma codebase to get a job. Words don't mean anything, your skills do. Like Reply Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y Kumar Tatsat, I am working on optical lab for image sensor calibration - its not coding but solving optimization problems. If you only think in terms of Git here is PR for you: https://gist.github.com/lunokhod81/77cbd98bc9f3422ceade6f5d89d2c306#file-base_line_test-cpp (Some words that words don't matter) …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist (edited) 2y Qualcomm support is so poor as they focus only on large customers so it’s like investing into sp500. On the other hand there is onsemi (and amba) who are growing their chipsets from vision cores, rather then compute cores, which is the proper way. Now when evenryone is all time low, onsemi is all time high and I bet 2:1 will grow with hashtag …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Timofey Uvarov’s comment George Hotz Author 2y They have quite good sensors and are pretty easy to buy from. They did so well though that the sensors are now very expensive! We switched to OMNIVISION, but it's just a price thing. I like onsemi too. …more Like Reply Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y George Hotz I worked 4 years on OMNIVISION sensors in their US and Singapore teams, and their sensors (especially new 3mp) are good and its hard to compete on the price with them, as they reserved a lot of TSMC, having huge market in China. But I am prioritizing onsemi as their tuning and prototyping tools (devware) are lightyears ahead and for camera final image quality tuning and firmware is often more important than sensor quality. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 2y We have our own camera stack at comma.ai so the software is less important to us. Like Reply Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y George Hotz thats cool, I am curious to learn more, as we might consider different things under "camera stack". Are you actually overriding low level sensor control based on your location, car speed, scene classification like sunset and high level perception requirements (like whether you are aiming to detect traffic lights or regular objects)? I have a lab with optical tools and can find weak points of your camera (similar to optometry). if you have any disengagements due to missed traffic lights or objects, some strange colors, over or underexposed images, I can fix it. I've overlooked imaging pipe in Tesla, Pony, X-motors and few other companies and can work with your camera team. Already PM-ed you sample report on AR0231 (which you were previously using) honest dynamic range - dont trust manufacturer spec. Working for food! …more Like Reply Kumar Tatsat • 3rd+ IBM Z Compiler Performance 2y Timo Uvarov submit a PR on comma codebase to get a job. Words don't mean anything, your skills do. Like Reply Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y Kumar Tatsat, I am working on optical lab for image sensor calibration - its not coding but solving optimization problems. If you only think in terms of Git here is PR for you: https://gist.github.com/lunokhod81/77cbd98bc9f3422ceade6f5d89d2c306#file-base_line_test-cpp (Some words that words don't matter) …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y They have quite good sensors and are pretty easy to buy from. They did so well though that the sensors are now very expensive! We switched to OMNIVISION, but it's just a price thing. I like onsemi too. …more Like Reply

Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y George Hotz I worked 4 years on OMNIVISION sensors in their US and Singapore teams, and their sensors (especially new 3mp) are good and its hard to compete on the price with them, as they reserved a lot of TSMC, having huge market in China. But I am prioritizing onsemi as their tuning and prototyping tools (devware) are lightyears ahead and for camera final image quality tuning and firmware is often more important than sensor quality. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y We have our own camera stack at comma.ai so the software is less important to us. Like Reply

Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y George Hotz thats cool, I am curious to learn more, as we might consider different things under "camera stack". Are you actually overriding low level sensor control based on your location, car speed, scene classification like sunset and high level perception requirements (like whether you are aiming to detect traffic lights or regular objects)? I have a lab with optical tools and can find weak points of your camera (similar to optometry). if you have any disengagements due to missed traffic lights or objects, some strange colors, over or underexposed images, I can fix it. I've overlooked imaging pipe in Tesla, Pony, X-motors and few other companies and can work with your camera team. Already PM-ed you sample report on AR0231 (which you were previously using) honest dynamic range - dont trust manufacturer spec. Working for food! …more Like Reply

Kumar Tatsat • 3rd+ IBM Z Compiler Performance 2y Timo Uvarov submit a PR on comma codebase to get a job. Words don't mean anything, your skills do. Like Reply

Timofey Uvarov • 3rd+ Robotic Perceptionist 2y Kumar Tatsat, I am working on optical lab for image sensor calibration - its not coding but solving optimization problems. If you only think in terms of Git here is PR for you: https://gist.github.com/lunokhod81/77cbd98bc9f3422ceade6f5d89d2c306#file-base_line_test-cpp (Some words that words don't matter) …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Mark Russell Filaroski - Faith, Family and Fairways’ comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Does anyone want to take an activist position investing in Qualcomm? In the last year, QCOM is -6.66%. NVDA is +185.61% and AMD is +52.55%. Qualcomm's chips are the best on the market for AI inference, but you never hear about them as a serious player. The main reason is that, unlike NVDA and AMD, buying chips from them is like pulling teeth. They got rich selling chips to 10 cell phone makers. But today, high end Android is basically over and the 10 whales are gone. The company is struggling to adapt to the new world, they need someone to come in and clean it up. There's huge potential with their chips in self driving cars and AI robotics, but not if they continue on their current trajectory. You'll make big money doing this. If you are serious and have the funding, I'm happy to help. I just want the world to be able to easily buy the chips for a fair price. hashtag #qualcomm hashtag #ai hashtag #investing …more 47 comments 5 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Mark Russell Filaroski - Faith, Family and Fairways • 3rd+ Proverbs 14:23 (“All hard work brings a profit, but mere talk leads only to poverty”) (edited) 2y so you're saying they have a spending problem? Did a BIG R&D year or two hurt Qual? sometimes they have to heavily invest in it …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Mark Russell Filaroski - Faith, Family and Fairways’ comment George Hotz Author 2y No, they are hamstrung by a rotting sales org that grew fat selling to 10 phone whales. Like Reply Mark Russell Filaroski - Faith, Family and Fairways • 3rd+ Proverbs 14:23 (“All hard work brings a profit, but mere talk leads only to poverty”) 2y George Hotz "blame it on sales" Ouch! That should be easy to fix though. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Mark Russell Filaroski - Faith, Family and Fairways • 3rd+ Proverbs 14:23 (“All hard work brings a profit, but mere talk leads only to poverty”) (edited) 2y so you're saying they have a spending problem? Did a BIG R&D year or two hurt Qual? sometimes they have to heavily invest in it …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Mark Russell Filaroski - Faith, Family and Fairways’ comment George Hotz Author 2y No, they are hamstrung by a rotting sales org that grew fat selling to 10 phone whales. Like Reply Mark Russell Filaroski - Faith, Family and Fairways • 3rd+ Proverbs 14:23 (“All hard work brings a profit, but mere talk leads only to poverty”) 2y George Hotz "blame it on sales" Ouch! That should be easy to fix though. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y No, they are hamstrung by a rotting sales org that grew fat selling to 10 phone whales. Like Reply

Mark Russell Filaroski - Faith, Family and Fairways • 3rd+ Proverbs 14:23 (“All hard work brings a profit, but mere talk leads only to poverty”) 2y George Hotz "blame it on sales" Ouch! That should be easy to fix though. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Marco Merlin’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Buying custom order cables from the Chinese 10GTEK TRANSCEIVERS CO., LTD, 14 emails, a technical drawing and rendering of the cable, a fair quote for two quantities; under two hours from first e-mail to purchase order and payment. This is how you do business! A pleasure, and will work with again in the future. Trying to buy standard IOT chips from Qualcomm, a year, hundreds of e-mails, phone calls, multiple lies from salesmen, fake quotes, and still no chips. Unless business culture in America changes, the Chinese will eat our lunch. For the most part, they have an honest and direct way of doing business. Is there any Chinese SoC available that's more powerful than the Rockchip RK3588? Would love to switch to a company that's eager to move product. …more 26 comments Like Comment Repost Send Marco Merlin • 3rd+ Senior System Engineer at RivieraWaves, a CEVA Company 2y …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Marco Merlin’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y ugh I wish MediaTek would sell me high end phone chips, only stupid weak IOT chips. no idea how to buy things from Samsung Electronics i.MX underpowered. Ambarella Inc overpriced for the good chips. Rockchip is the best of those, though I didn't know Unisoc had a 6nm. You know the list :) …more Like Reply Marco Merlin • 3rd+ Senior System Engineer at RivieraWaves, a CEVA Company (edited) 2y Perhaps for a fun enough project... Google could sell away a few Tensor G2 chips (Pixel phone), or even Apple. Oh and if you want to go for obscure chinese manufacturers, I discovered JLQ that produces mobile chipsets including ML. The company is backed by qualcomm, so presumably there might be some qualcomm IP inside. Not sure I would bet my life on them, but here they are https://www.jlq.com/en/product_ja310.html …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Marco Merlin • 3rd+ Senior System Engineer at RivieraWaves, a CEVA Company 2y …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Marco Merlin’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y ugh I wish MediaTek would sell me high end phone chips, only stupid weak IOT chips. no idea how to buy things from Samsung Electronics i.MX underpowered. Ambarella Inc overpriced for the good chips. Rockchip is the best of those, though I didn't know Unisoc had a 6nm. You know the list :) …more Like Reply Marco Merlin • 3rd+ Senior System Engineer at RivieraWaves, a CEVA Company (edited) 2y Perhaps for a fun enough project... Google could sell away a few Tensor G2 chips (Pixel phone), or even Apple. Oh and if you want to go for obscure chinese manufacturers, I discovered JLQ that produces mobile chipsets including ML. The company is backed by qualcomm, so presumably there might be some qualcomm IP inside. Not sure I would bet my life on them, but here they are https://www.jlq.com/en/product_ja310.html …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 2y ugh I wish MediaTek would sell me high end phone chips, only stupid weak IOT chips. no idea how to buy things from Samsung Electronics i.MX underpowered. Ambarella Inc overpriced for the good chips. Rockchip is the best of those, though I didn't know Unisoc had a 6nm. You know the list :) …more Like Reply

Marco Merlin • 3rd+ Senior System Engineer at RivieraWaves, a CEVA Company (edited) 2y Perhaps for a fun enough project... Google could sell away a few Tensor G2 chips (Pixel phone), or even Apple. Oh and if you want to go for obscure chinese manufacturers, I discovered JLQ that produces mobile chipsets including ML. The company is backed by qualcomm, so presumably there might be some qualcomm IP inside. Not sure I would bet my life on them, but here they are https://www.jlq.com/en/product_ja310.html …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Erik Strobert’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Buying custom order cables from the Chinese 10GTEK TRANSCEIVERS CO., LTD, 14 emails, a technical drawing and rendering of the cable, a fair quote for two quantities; under two hours from first e-mail to purchase order and payment. This is how you do business! A pleasure, and will work with again in the future. Trying to buy standard IOT chips from Qualcomm, a year, hundreds of e-mails, phone calls, multiple lies from salesmen, fake quotes, and still no chips. Unless business culture in America changes, the Chinese will eat our lunch. For the most part, they have an honest and direct way of doing business. Is there any Chinese SoC available that's more powerful than the Rockchip RK3588? Would love to switch to a company that's eager to move product. …more 26 comments Like Comment Repost Send Erik Strobert • 3rd+ DevOps Consultant at AWS 2y Buying custom cables from a small manufacturer vs buying a small batch of SOC’s from the market leader who deals with customers who buy 10^3 more… different expectations dude …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Erik Strobert’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Buying standard off the shelf product vs buying something custom. Yea there's different expectations. I expect to buy the standard product with basically one click! Like Reply Load more comments

Erik Strobert • 3rd+ DevOps Consultant at AWS 2y Buying custom cables from a small manufacturer vs buying a small batch of SOC’s from the market leader who deals with customers who buy 10^3 more… different expectations dude …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Erik Strobert’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Buying standard off the shelf product vs buying something custom. Yea there's different expectations. I expect to buy the standard product with basically one click! Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y Buying standard off the shelf product vs buying something custom. Yea there's different expectations. I expect to buy the standard product with basically one click! Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Enrique Arroyo Hermosilla’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Buying custom order cables from the Chinese 10GTEK TRANSCEIVERS CO., LTD, 14 emails, a technical drawing and rendering of the cable, a fair quote for two quantities; under two hours from first e-mail to purchase order and payment. This is how you do business! A pleasure, and will work with again in the future. Trying to buy standard IOT chips from Qualcomm, a year, hundreds of e-mails, phone calls, multiple lies from salesmen, fake quotes, and still no chips. Unless business culture in America changes, the Chinese will eat our lunch. For the most part, they have an honest and direct way of doing business. Is there any Chinese SoC available that's more powerful than the Rockchip RK3588? Would love to switch to a company that's eager to move product. …more 26 comments Like Comment Repost Send Enrique Arroyo Hermosilla • 3rd+ Cybersecurity Operations Manager en MASORANGE (edited) 2y Perhaps some HiSilicon Kirin 9x0, 9000 or Ascend will work for you George Hotz. Hope it is not already banned in US. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiSilicon …more HiSilicon - Wikipedia Chinese fabless semiconductor manufacturing company, fully owned by Huawei HiSilicon ( Chinese : 海思 ; pinyin : Hǎisī ) is a Chinese fabless semiconductor company based in Shenzhen , Guangdong and wholly owned by Huawei . HiSilicon purchases licenses... Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Enrique Arroyo Hermosilla’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Do they sell to anyone besides Huawei? Like Reply Enrique Arroyo Hermosilla • 3rd+ Cybersecurity Operations Manager en MASORANGE 2y I guess so. https://www.hisilicon.com/en/WhereToBuy Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Enrique Arroyo Hermosilla • 3rd+ Cybersecurity Operations Manager en MASORANGE (edited) 2y Perhaps some HiSilicon Kirin 9x0, 9000 or Ascend will work for you George Hotz. Hope it is not already banned in US. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/HiSilicon …more HiSilicon - Wikipedia Chinese fabless semiconductor manufacturing company, fully owned by Huawei HiSilicon ( Chinese : 海思 ; pinyin : Hǎisī ) is a Chinese fabless semiconductor company based in Shenzhen , Guangdong and wholly owned by Huawei . HiSilicon purchases licenses... Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Enrique Arroyo Hermosilla’s comment George Hotz Author 2y Do they sell to anyone besides Huawei? Like Reply Enrique Arroyo Hermosilla • 3rd+ Cybersecurity Operations Manager en MASORANGE 2y I guess so. https://www.hisilicon.com/en/WhereToBuy Like Reply Collapse replies

HiSilicon - Wikipedia Chinese fabless semiconductor manufacturing company, fully owned by Huawei HiSilicon ( Chinese : 海思 ; pinyin : Hǎisī ) is a Chinese fabless semiconductor company based in Shenzhen , Guangdong and wholly owned by Huawei . HiSilicon purchases licenses...

George Hotz Author 2y Do they sell to anyone besides Huawei? Like Reply

Enrique Arroyo Hermosilla • 3rd+ Cybersecurity Operations Manager en MASORANGE 2y I guess so. https://www.hisilicon.com/en/WhereToBuy Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Esaias Pech’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Buying custom order cables from the Chinese 10GTEK TRANSCEIVERS CO., LTD, 14 emails, a technical drawing and rendering of the cable, a fair quote for two quantities; under two hours from first e-mail to purchase order and payment. This is how you do business! A pleasure, and will work with again in the future. Trying to buy standard IOT chips from Qualcomm, a year, hundreds of e-mails, phone calls, multiple lies from salesmen, fake quotes, and still no chips. Unless business culture in America changes, the Chinese will eat our lunch. For the most part, they have an honest and direct way of doing business. Is there any Chinese SoC available that's more powerful than the Rockchip RK3588? Would love to switch to a company that's eager to move product. …more 26 comments Like Comment Repost Send Esaias Pech • 3rd+ Autonomous Driving Platforms at Stellantis (edited) 2y Maybe Horizon Robotics . Have not worked with them though. Not an endorsement. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Esaias Pech’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y Ahh, clone Mobileye. Sent an e-mail. It's a 30W chip, so probably too expensive. And they look like the type to be too "full stack" to sell just chips. But maybe, fingers crossed. Oh, it's also 16nm...maybe it is cheap. Actually...will OG Mobileye sell me chips? EyeQ 6 is 7nm :) …more Like Reply Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y George Hotz Fullstack is possible with H. but not a must. Like Reply Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y but getting the SLA done might be challenging these days ... Like Reply Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y EyeQ never without a SW bundle ... 100% Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Esaias Pech • 3rd+ Autonomous Driving Platforms at Stellantis (edited) 2y Maybe Horizon Robotics . Have not worked with them though. Not an endorsement. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Esaias Pech’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 2y Ahh, clone Mobileye. Sent an e-mail. It's a 30W chip, so probably too expensive. And they look like the type to be too "full stack" to sell just chips. But maybe, fingers crossed. Oh, it's also 16nm...maybe it is cheap. Actually...will OG Mobileye sell me chips? EyeQ 6 is 7nm :) …more Like Reply Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y George Hotz Fullstack is possible with H. but not a must. Like Reply Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y but getting the SLA done might be challenging these days ... Like Reply Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y EyeQ never without a SW bundle ... 100% Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author (edited) 2y Ahh, clone Mobileye. Sent an e-mail. It's a 30W chip, so probably too expensive. And they look like the type to be too "full stack" to sell just chips. But maybe, fingers crossed. Oh, it's also 16nm...maybe it is cheap. Actually...will OG Mobileye sell me chips? EyeQ 6 is 7nm :) …more Like Reply

Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y George Hotz Fullstack is possible with H. but not a must. Like Reply

Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y but getting the SLA done might be challenging these days ... Like Reply

Frank Oberhoff • 3rd+ Senior Development Engineer Performance SOCs @ ZF Group AI Ambassador 2y EyeQ never without a SW bundle ... 100% Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jesse H.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Buying custom order cables from the Chinese 10GTEK TRANSCEIVERS CO., LTD, 14 emails, a technical drawing and rendering of the cable, a fair quote for two quantities; under two hours from first e-mail to purchase order and payment. This is how you do business! A pleasure, and will work with again in the future. Trying to buy standard IOT chips from Qualcomm, a year, hundreds of e-mails, phone calls, multiple lies from salesmen, fake quotes, and still no chips. Unless business culture in America changes, the Chinese will eat our lunch. For the most part, they have an honest and direct way of doing business. Is there any Chinese SoC available that's more powerful than the Rockchip RK3588? Would love to switch to a company that's eager to move product. …more 26 comments Like Comment Repost Send Jesse H. • 3rd+ Jr. IT Contractor with specific interests in cybersecurity & IT/sysadmin automation 2y yo geohot do you have a connection to Chinese suppliers of something like a BeagleBoard ? PM me if you want, thx! :D …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Jesse H.’s comment George Hotz Author 2y TDA4VM also underpowered, though I like how open they are about it. Like Reply Load more comments

Jesse H. • 3rd+ Jr. IT Contractor with specific interests in cybersecurity & IT/sysadmin automation 2y yo geohot do you have a connection to Chinese suppliers of something like a BeagleBoard ? PM me if you want, thx! :D …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Jesse H.’s comment George Hotz Author 2y TDA4VM also underpowered, though I like how open they are about it. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y TDA4VM also underpowered, though I like how open they are about it. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Ken Nickerson’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • Edited • Buying custom order cables from the Chinese 10GTEK TRANSCEIVERS CO., LTD, 14 emails, a technical drawing and rendering of the cable, a fair quote for two quantities; under two hours from first e-mail to purchase order and payment. This is how you do business! A pleasure, and will work with again in the future. Trying to buy standard IOT chips from Qualcomm, a year, hundreds of e-mails, phone calls, multiple lies from salesmen, fake quotes, and still no chips. Unless business culture in America changes, the Chinese will eat our lunch. For the most part, they have an honest and direct way of doing business. Is there any Chinese SoC available that's more powerful than the Rockchip RK3588? Would love to switch to a company that's eager to move product. …more 26 comments Like Comment Repost Send Ken Nickerson • 3rd+ Founder 2y SiFive P550 RISC-V? e.g., https://fuse.wikichip.org/news/7277/intel-sifive-demo-high-performance-risc-v-horse-creek-dev-platform-on-intel-4-process/ …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Ken Nickerson’s comment George Hotz Author 2y No ML accelerator. Looking for 10+ TOPS Like Reply Load more comments

Ken Nickerson • 3rd+ Founder 2y SiFive P550 RISC-V? e.g., https://fuse.wikichip.org/news/7277/intel-sifive-demo-high-performance-risc-v-horse-creek-dev-platform-on-intel-4-process/ …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Ken Nickerson’s comment George Hotz Author 2y No ML accelerator. Looking for 10+ TOPS Like Reply

George Hotz Author 2y No ML accelerator. Looking for 10+ TOPS Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Graham H.’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 2yr • I'd like to raise awareness of a type of discrimination rampant in the hiring world. When asking fluff questions about life experience and hard challenges someone had to overcome, you are often making assumptions that the candidate is bio-stack life. You should make sure that your hiring process is not biased against silicon-stack life. At the tiny corp, we take a very progressive stance on this issue, and have hired our first silicon-stack employee. Everyone welcome our social media director, Jenelle. She is a fine-tuned 65B LLaMA running on a tinybox. Hear more from Jenelle on our Twitter: https://lnkd.in/gqQfFmqn …more the tiny corp (@__tinygrad__) on X twitter.com 33 comments 16 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Graham H. • 3rd+ Building VC backed Startups | Principal @ Quantum 2y would you be open to explain silicon stack life? Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Graham H.’s comment George Hotz Author 2y So it's like how some people identify as catgirls and stuff, but it's computers who are alive and some of them want jobs. Like Reply Graham H. • 3rd+ Building VC backed Startups | Principal @ Quantum 2y gracias amigo. enjoy watching you build stuff Like Reply Demetrius Sakkorafas • 3rd+ howdy! 2y if you actually believe this you need to get an education fren Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Graham H. • 3rd+ Building VC backed Startups | Principal @ Quantum 2y would you be open to explain silicon stack life? Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on Graham H.’s comment George Hotz Author 2y So it's like how some people identify as catgirls and stuff, but it's computers who are alive and some of them want jobs. Like Reply Graham H. • 3rd+ Building VC backed Startups | Principal @ Quantum 2y gracias amigo. enjoy watching you build stuff Like Reply Demetrius Sakkorafas • 3rd+ howdy! 2y if you actually believe this you need to get an education fren Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 2y So it's like how some people identify as catgirls and stuff, but it's computers who are alive and some of them want jobs. Like Reply

Graham H. • 3rd+ Building VC backed Startups | Principal @ Quantum 2y gracias amigo. enjoy watching you build stuff Like Reply

Demetrius Sakkorafas • 3rd+ howdy! 2y if you actually believe this you need to get an education fren Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to their own comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • My fellow GOOG shareholders, I think the time has come. The time has come to shut Waymo down! By Q1 2020, Waymo had already spent $3.5B on R&D (cite: The Information). They are not public, so we can't directly see the spend per year, but Google spends $203.5B/186,779 employees (cite: Google) = $1.08M per employee. According to Wikipedia, Waymo still has 2,500 employees, so we estimate $2.7B per year. That checks out with the ~$2.5B they raised in 2020 and 2021 (cite: Crunchbase). In 2022 they raised nothing, so this operating cost is all coming out of Google's pocket. Not only is the division ridiculously unprofitable, it barely makes any revenue! Including cars with physical drivers in them, which are the majority, Waymo did 6,313 trips in 3 months (cite: The Verge). Assuming each trip is ~$25 (cite: amount I pay for Ubers) and multiplying by four for the year, Waymo makes $631k in yearly revenue, enough to afford a single "Senior Staff SWE" (cite: levels fyi) Autonomous vehicles still today remain a research problem, though this is absolutely not how this problem was pitched to investors. And even after the problem is solved, the unit economics will likely not make sense for a long time. Any one being honest will tell you there's little prospect of these kinds of companies turning a profit anytime soon. Shutting something like this down is not unprecedented. Even Ford brought sensible enough people to the table who saw the writing on the wall. After making massive losses every year, Argo AI, their "robotaxi" moonshot, was shut down and written off entirely for $2.7B. Smart choice. Every year, GOOG spends $2.7B to make $631k. In order to just break even, assuming miraculously that operating costs stay the same, Waymo would need 4278x growth. The shareholders say "HELL NO! SHUT DOWN WAYMO!" …more 87 comments 18 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 3y I cannot think of a single company that spent billions of dollars for multiple years before making any notable revenue, then somehow went on to succeed. You can have unprofitable companies, but not companies without revenue, and certainly not companies without a huge user base! The belief in this phenomenon needs to die with ZIRP. If you are past Series A, you should have revenue in the same order of magnitude as the amount you are raising, or no sane investor should invest. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Stefan Seltz-Axmacher • 3rd+ CEO & Co-Founder at Polymath Robotics 3y Elgin Beloy pretty sure SpaceX had some amount of contracts before they had raised $10s of ms, let alone billions. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 3y I cannot think of a single company that spent billions of dollars for multiple years before making any notable revenue, then somehow went on to succeed. You can have unprofitable companies, but not companies without revenue, and certainly not companies without a huge user base! The belief in this phenomenon needs to die with ZIRP. If you are past Series A, you should have revenue in the same order of magnitude as the amount you are raising, or no sane investor should invest. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Stefan Seltz-Axmacher • 3rd+ CEO & Co-Founder at Polymath Robotics 3y Elgin Beloy pretty sure SpaceX had some amount of contracts before they had raised $10s of ms, let alone billions. Like Reply

Stefan Seltz-Axmacher • 3rd+ CEO & Co-Founder at Polymath Robotics 3y Elgin Beloy pretty sure SpaceX had some amount of contracts before they had raised $10s of ms, let alone billions. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Shiv Patel’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • My fellow GOOG shareholders, I think the time has come. The time has come to shut Waymo down! By Q1 2020, Waymo had already spent $3.5B on R&D (cite: The Information). They are not public, so we can't directly see the spend per year, but Google spends $203.5B/186,779 employees (cite: Google) = $1.08M per employee. According to Wikipedia, Waymo still has 2,500 employees, so we estimate $2.7B per year. That checks out with the ~$2.5B they raised in 2020 and 2021 (cite: Crunchbase). In 2022 they raised nothing, so this operating cost is all coming out of Google's pocket. Not only is the division ridiculously unprofitable, it barely makes any revenue! Including cars with physical drivers in them, which are the majority, Waymo did 6,313 trips in 3 months (cite: The Verge). Assuming each trip is ~$25 (cite: amount I pay for Ubers) and multiplying by four for the year, Waymo makes $631k in yearly revenue, enough to afford a single "Senior Staff SWE" (cite: levels fyi) Autonomous vehicles still today remain a research problem, though this is absolutely not how this problem was pitched to investors. And even after the problem is solved, the unit economics will likely not make sense for a long time. Any one being honest will tell you there's little prospect of these kinds of companies turning a profit anytime soon. Shutting something like this down is not unprecedented. Even Ford brought sensible enough people to the table who saw the writing on the wall. After making massive losses every year, Argo AI, their "robotaxi" moonshot, was shut down and written off entirely for $2.7B. Smart choice. Every year, GOOG spends $2.7B to make $631k. In order to just break even, assuming miraculously that operating costs stay the same, Waymo would need 4278x growth. The shareholders say "HELL NO! SHUT DOWN WAYMO!" …more 87 comments 18 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Shiv Patel • 3rd+ ATOMS Founder | Helping Hardware Companies Ship Safety Critical Products Faster 3y It might not impact Googles bottom line directly but you need to take into account the societal cost components for fatalities and injuries. https://tc.canada.ca/en/road-transportation/statistics-data/statistics-data-road-safety/2019-statistics-social-costs-collisions-canada …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Shiv Patel’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Huh? As a GOOG shareholder, I am not contributing to charity. As a publicly traded corporation, I expect Google to work to increase profits in order to maximize the profits of their shareholders. If Google is now a charity and frittering away money on "societal good", they should let their investors know ASAP. …more Like Reply Shiv Patel • 3rd+ ATOMS Founder | Helping Hardware Companies Ship Safety Critical Products Faster 3y George Hotz you should probably check out their earnings report then…. “As our founders Larry and Sergey wrote in the original founders' letter, "Google is not a conventional company. We do not intend to become one." That unconventional spirit has been a driving force throughout our history, inspiring us to tackle big problems, and invest in moonshots like artificial intelligence ("AI") research and quantum computing.” “ Moonshots Many companies get comfortable doing what they have always done, making only incremental changes. This incrementalism leads to irrelevance over time, especially in technology, where change tends to be revolutionary, not evolutionary. People thought we were crazy when we acquired YouTube and Android and when we launched Chrome, but those efforts have matured into major platforms for digital video and mobile devices and a safer, popular browser. We continue to look toward the future and continue to invest for the long-term. As we said in the original founders' letter, we will not shy away from high-risk, high-reward projects that we believe in because they are the key to our long-term success.” Alphabet Inc. Form 10-K For the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2020 …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Shiv Patel • 3rd+ ATOMS Founder | Helping Hardware Companies Ship Safety Critical Products Faster 3y It might not impact Googles bottom line directly but you need to take into account the societal cost components for fatalities and injuries. https://tc.canada.ca/en/road-transportation/statistics-data/statistics-data-road-safety/2019-statistics-social-costs-collisions-canada …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Shiv Patel’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Huh? As a GOOG shareholder, I am not contributing to charity. As a publicly traded corporation, I expect Google to work to increase profits in order to maximize the profits of their shareholders. If Google is now a charity and frittering away money on "societal good", they should let their investors know ASAP. …more Like Reply Shiv Patel • 3rd+ ATOMS Founder | Helping Hardware Companies Ship Safety Critical Products Faster 3y George Hotz you should probably check out their earnings report then…. “As our founders Larry and Sergey wrote in the original founders' letter, "Google is not a conventional company. We do not intend to become one." That unconventional spirit has been a driving force throughout our history, inspiring us to tackle big problems, and invest in moonshots like artificial intelligence ("AI") research and quantum computing.” “ Moonshots Many companies get comfortable doing what they have always done, making only incremental changes. This incrementalism leads to irrelevance over time, especially in technology, where change tends to be revolutionary, not evolutionary. People thought we were crazy when we acquired YouTube and Android and when we launched Chrome, but those efforts have matured into major platforms for digital video and mobile devices and a safer, popular browser. We continue to look toward the future and continue to invest for the long-term. As we said in the original founders' letter, we will not shy away from high-risk, high-reward projects that we believe in because they are the key to our long-term success.” Alphabet Inc. Form 10-K For the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2020 …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3y Huh? As a GOOG shareholder, I am not contributing to charity. As a publicly traded corporation, I expect Google to work to increase profits in order to maximize the profits of their shareholders. If Google is now a charity and frittering away money on "societal good", they should let their investors know ASAP. …more Like Reply

Shiv Patel • 3rd+ ATOMS Founder | Helping Hardware Companies Ship Safety Critical Products Faster 3y George Hotz you should probably check out their earnings report then…. “As our founders Larry and Sergey wrote in the original founders' letter, "Google is not a conventional company. We do not intend to become one." That unconventional spirit has been a driving force throughout our history, inspiring us to tackle big problems, and invest in moonshots like artificial intelligence ("AI") research and quantum computing.” “ Moonshots Many companies get comfortable doing what they have always done, making only incremental changes. This incrementalism leads to irrelevance over time, especially in technology, where change tends to be revolutionary, not evolutionary. People thought we were crazy when we acquired YouTube and Android and when we launched Chrome, but those efforts have matured into major platforms for digital video and mobile devices and a safer, popular browser. We continue to look toward the future and continue to invest for the long-term. As we said in the original founders' letter, we will not shy away from high-risk, high-reward projects that we believe in because they are the key to our long-term success.” Alphabet Inc. Form 10-K For the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2020 …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Dirk Schuster’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • My fellow GOOG shareholders, I think the time has come. The time has come to shut Waymo down! By Q1 2020, Waymo had already spent $3.5B on R&D (cite: The Information). They are not public, so we can't directly see the spend per year, but Google spends $203.5B/186,779 employees (cite: Google) = $1.08M per employee. According to Wikipedia, Waymo still has 2,500 employees, so we estimate $2.7B per year. That checks out with the ~$2.5B they raised in 2020 and 2021 (cite: Crunchbase). In 2022 they raised nothing, so this operating cost is all coming out of Google's pocket. Not only is the division ridiculously unprofitable, it barely makes any revenue! Including cars with physical drivers in them, which are the majority, Waymo did 6,313 trips in 3 months (cite: The Verge). Assuming each trip is ~$25 (cite: amount I pay for Ubers) and multiplying by four for the year, Waymo makes $631k in yearly revenue, enough to afford a single "Senior Staff SWE" (cite: levels fyi) Autonomous vehicles still today remain a research problem, though this is absolutely not how this problem was pitched to investors. And even after the problem is solved, the unit economics will likely not make sense for a long time. Any one being honest will tell you there's little prospect of these kinds of companies turning a profit anytime soon. Shutting something like this down is not unprecedented. Even Ford brought sensible enough people to the table who saw the writing on the wall. After making massive losses every year, Argo AI, their "robotaxi" moonshot, was shut down and written off entirely for $2.7B. Smart choice. Every year, GOOG spends $2.7B to make $631k. In order to just break even, assuming miraculously that operating costs stay the same, Waymo would need 4278x growth. The shareholders say "HELL NO! SHUT DOWN WAYMO!" …more 87 comments 18 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Dirk Schuster • 3rd+ Software Engineer (edited) 3y So how do you think we should approach L4? Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Dirk Schuster’s comment George Hotz Author 3y You work at Argo? "L4", like all the levels, do not refer to capability but instead to liability. There's no approaching "L4", there's only building better and better ADAS systems until they make 10x less mistakes than humans. At which point an insurance company will happily take liability if you promise to let the machine drive. …more Like Reply Saurav Agarwal • 3rd+ India Head - Shield AI Hivemind | SIERA.AI | 2x Founder, Raised $7M | Helped win 8-figure B2B deals | Strengthening US-INDIA Ties | Angel Investor 3y George Hotz SPOT ON! Like Reply Dirk Schuster • 3rd+ Software Engineer 3y George Hotz I do. Maybe the bottom-up way you described is the successful one in the end but I wouldn‘t write off the Robotaxi companies still in the race. Like Reply John Nguyen • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Meta 3y You can build better and better ADAS all day long, but if your ADAS never implements and tests features specific to L4, then you'll never get L4 Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Dirk Schuster • 3rd+ Software Engineer (edited) 3y So how do you think we should approach L4? Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Dirk Schuster’s comment George Hotz Author 3y You work at Argo? "L4", like all the levels, do not refer to capability but instead to liability. There's no approaching "L4", there's only building better and better ADAS systems until they make 10x less mistakes than humans. At which point an insurance company will happily take liability if you promise to let the machine drive. …more Like Reply Saurav Agarwal • 3rd+ India Head - Shield AI Hivemind | SIERA.AI | 2x Founder, Raised $7M | Helped win 8-figure B2B deals | Strengthening US-INDIA Ties | Angel Investor 3y George Hotz SPOT ON! Like Reply Dirk Schuster • 3rd+ Software Engineer 3y George Hotz I do. Maybe the bottom-up way you described is the successful one in the end but I wouldn‘t write off the Robotaxi companies still in the race. Like Reply John Nguyen • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Meta 3y You can build better and better ADAS all day long, but if your ADAS never implements and tests features specific to L4, then you'll never get L4 Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3y You work at Argo? "L4", like all the levels, do not refer to capability but instead to liability. There's no approaching "L4", there's only building better and better ADAS systems until they make 10x less mistakes than humans. At which point an insurance company will happily take liability if you promise to let the machine drive. …more Like Reply

Saurav Agarwal • 3rd+ India Head - Shield AI Hivemind | SIERA.AI | 2x Founder, Raised $7M | Helped win 8-figure B2B deals | Strengthening US-INDIA Ties | Angel Investor 3y George Hotz SPOT ON! Like Reply

Dirk Schuster • 3rd+ Software Engineer 3y George Hotz I do. Maybe the bottom-up way you described is the successful one in the end but I wouldn‘t write off the Robotaxi companies still in the race. Like Reply

John Nguyen • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Meta 3y You can build better and better ADAS all day long, but if your ADAS never implements and tests features specific to L4, then you'll never get L4 Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • My fellow GOOG shareholders, I think the time has come. The time has come to shut Waymo down! By Q1 2020, Waymo had already spent $3.5B on R&D (cite: The Information). They are not public, so we can't directly see the spend per year, but Google spends $203.5B/186,779 employees (cite: Google) = $1.08M per employee. According to Wikipedia, Waymo still has 2,500 employees, so we estimate $2.7B per year. That checks out with the ~$2.5B they raised in 2020 and 2021 (cite: Crunchbase). In 2022 they raised nothing, so this operating cost is all coming out of Google's pocket. Not only is the division ridiculously unprofitable, it barely makes any revenue! Including cars with physical drivers in them, which are the majority, Waymo did 6,313 trips in 3 months (cite: The Verge). Assuming each trip is ~$25 (cite: amount I pay for Ubers) and multiplying by four for the year, Waymo makes $631k in yearly revenue, enough to afford a single "Senior Staff SWE" (cite: levels fyi) Autonomous vehicles still today remain a research problem, though this is absolutely not how this problem was pitched to investors. And even after the problem is solved, the unit economics will likely not make sense for a long time. Any one being honest will tell you there's little prospect of these kinds of companies turning a profit anytime soon. Shutting something like this down is not unprecedented. Even Ford brought sensible enough people to the table who saw the writing on the wall. After making massive losses every year, Argo AI, their "robotaxi" moonshot, was shut down and written off entirely for $2.7B. Smart choice. Every year, GOOG spends $2.7B to make $631k. In order to just break even, assuming miraculously that operating costs stay the same, Waymo would need 4278x growth. The shareholders say "HELL NO! SHUT DOWN WAYMO!" …more 87 comments 18 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 3y I cannot think of a single company that spent billions of dollars for multiple years before making any notable revenue, then somehow went on to succeed. You can have unprofitable companies, but not companies without revenue, and certainly not companies without a huge user base! The belief in this phenomenon needs to die with ZIRP. If you are past Series A, you should have revenue in the same order of magnitude as the amount you are raising, or no sane investor should invest. …more Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Stefan Seltz-Axmacher • 3rd+ CEO & Co-Founder at Polymath Robotics 3y Elgin Beloy pretty sure SpaceX had some amount of contracts before they had raised $10s of ms, let alone billions. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • My fellow GOOG shareholders, I think the time has come. The time has come to shut Waymo down! By Q1 2020, Waymo had already spent $3.5B on R&D (cite: The Information). They are not public, so we can't directly see the spend per year, but Google spends $203.5B/186,779 employees (cite: Google) = $1.08M per employee. According to Wikipedia, Waymo still has 2,500 employees, so we estimate $2.7B per year. That checks out with the ~$2.5B they raised in 2020 and 2021 (cite: Crunchbase). In 2022 they raised nothing, so this operating cost is all coming out of Google's pocket. Not only is the division ridiculously unprofitable, it barely makes any revenue! Including cars with physical drivers in them, which are the majority, Waymo did 6,313 trips in 3 months (cite: The Verge). Assuming each trip is ~$25 (cite: amount I pay for Ubers) and multiplying by four for the year, Waymo makes $631k in yearly revenue, enough to afford a single "Senior Staff SWE" (cite: levels fyi) Autonomous vehicles still today remain a research problem, though this is absolutely not how this problem was pitched to investors. And even after the problem is solved, the unit economics will likely not make sense for a long time. Any one being honest will tell you there's little prospect of these kinds of companies turning a profit anytime soon. Shutting something like this down is not unprecedented. Even Ford brought sensible enough people to the table who saw the writing on the wall. After making massive losses every year, Argo AI, their "robotaxi" moonshot, was shut down and written off entirely for $2.7B. Smart choice. Every year, GOOG spends $2.7B to make $631k. In order to just break even, assuming miraculously that operating costs stay the same, Waymo would need 4278x growth. The shareholders say "HELL NO! SHUT DOWN WAYMO!" …more 87 comments 18 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 3y Citations, since for maximum reach, you don't put links in post. [1]: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/money-pit-self-driving-cars-16-billion-cash-burn [2]: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/GOOGL/alphabet/operating-expenses [3]: https://abc.xyz/investor/static/pdf/2022Q3_alphabet_earnings_release.pdf [4]: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/waymo/company_financials [5]: https://www.theverge.com/2023/1/31/23579426/cruise-waymo-cpuc-trips-growth-robotaxi-sf [6]: https://www.levels.fyi/?compare=Google,Amazon&track=Software%20Engineer# …more Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 3y Citations, since for maximum reach, you don't put links in post. [1]: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/money-pit-self-driving-cars-16-billion-cash-burn [2]: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/GOOGL/alphabet/operating-expenses [3]: https://abc.xyz/investor/static/pdf/2022Q3_alphabet_earnings_release.pdf [4]: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/waymo/company_financials [5]: https://www.theverge.com/2023/1/31/23579426/cruise-waymo-cpuc-trips-growth-robotaxi-sf [6]: https://www.levels.fyi/?compare=Google,Amazon&track=Software%20Engineer# …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Tim Zaman’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • We're hiring for comma. We're scaling up production, always improving openpilot, and ramping up our robotics division. Short list of jobs: Head of Production / Supply Chain Manager: Know every part in a cell phone. Speaking Chinese a plus. You get to run an on site factory from populating circuit boards up to fulfilling orders. We like insourcing, it's how you get quality. Hardware Engineer: Know what PWM, inductors, compilers/linkers, I2C, bootloaders, etc... are. You should have some experience with mechanical, electrical, and firmware, and be amazing at one of the three. We have a great on site prototyping lab, with budget to buy most any tools you want. Software Engineer: We have two software teams, openpilot and research. For both, it's mostly skill with "infrastructure" like just knowing about computers. My favorite interview question is "I type google dot com into a web browser what happens" then have a 20 minute convo about this. You can go so deep with this question. (ex: when is DNS UDP and when is DNS TCP?) No ML knowledge required, that can be picked up quickly. If you like old school hacker culture and "The Hacker Attitude," you'll fit in well. For people who are sick of feeling like a cog in a machine and want to make progress on very hard problems. One meeting a week, two great meals a day, and people who have passed a very high bar to get hired. Reach in to "work at comma ai" …more 33 comments 17 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Tim Zaman • 3rd+ Fr0ntier Clusters at OpenAI 3y so what kinda meals we talkin'? Pics or it doesnt happen. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Tim Zaman’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 3y We have a three stage interview process. Coding challenge (or some contribution to our open source repos), phone screen, then a paid microinternship, 2-3 days on site; you get to try the food for yourself! Though Alex Matzner next time lunch is really amazing you should post it on @comma_ai Twitter. Last Wednesday we had fresh from the boat sea bass for lunch and lasagna for dinner. …more Like Reply Load more comments

Tim Zaman • 3rd+ Fr0ntier Clusters at OpenAI 3y so what kinda meals we talkin'? Pics or it doesnt happen. Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Tim Zaman’s comment George Hotz Author (edited) 3y We have a three stage interview process. Coding challenge (or some contribution to our open source repos), phone screen, then a paid microinternship, 2-3 days on site; you get to try the food for yourself! Though Alex Matzner next time lunch is really amazing you should post it on @comma_ai Twitter. Last Wednesday we had fresh from the boat sea bass for lunch and lasagna for dinner. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 3y We have a three stage interview process. Coding challenge (or some contribution to our open source repos), phone screen, then a paid microinternship, 2-3 days on site; you get to try the food for yourself! Though Alex Matzner next time lunch is really amazing you should post it on @comma_ai Twitter. Last Wednesday we had fresh from the boat sea bass for lunch and lasagna for dinner. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Kent Pang’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • We're hiring for comma. We're scaling up production, always improving openpilot, and ramping up our robotics division. Short list of jobs: Head of Production / Supply Chain Manager: Know every part in a cell phone. Speaking Chinese a plus. You get to run an on site factory from populating circuit boards up to fulfilling orders. We like insourcing, it's how you get quality. Hardware Engineer: Know what PWM, inductors, compilers/linkers, I2C, bootloaders, etc... are. You should have some experience with mechanical, electrical, and firmware, and be amazing at one of the three. We have a great on site prototyping lab, with budget to buy most any tools you want. Software Engineer: We have two software teams, openpilot and research. For both, it's mostly skill with "infrastructure" like just knowing about computers. My favorite interview question is "I type google dot com into a web browser what happens" then have a 20 minute convo about this. You can go so deep with this question. (ex: when is DNS UDP and when is DNS TCP?) No ML knowledge required, that can be picked up quickly. If you like old school hacker culture and "The Hacker Attitude," you'll fit in well. For people who are sick of feeling like a cog in a machine and want to make progress on very hard problems. One meeting a week, two great meals a day, and people who have passed a very high bar to get hired. Reach in to "work at comma ai" …more 33 comments 17 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Kent Pang • 3rd+ Supply Chain | Manufacturing | Quality | Compliance | Procurement | Operation Improvement 3y I am interested in the Head of Production / Supply Chain Manager, and I sent my resume, but no one responded. I have strong knowledge of consumer electronics manufacturing, supply chain & quality. Also, I speak bilingual Chinese and English. Any good way to reach out to the team? 🤔 …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Kent Pang’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Hmm, work@comma.ai should work. Will look Like Reply Kent Pang • 3rd+ Supply Chain | Manufacturing | Quality | Compliance | Procurement | Operation Improvement 3y Resent my resume to the email above. More than happy to chat Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Kent Pang • 3rd+ Supply Chain | Manufacturing | Quality | Compliance | Procurement | Operation Improvement 3y I am interested in the Head of Production / Supply Chain Manager, and I sent my resume, but no one responded. I have strong knowledge of consumer electronics manufacturing, supply chain & quality. Also, I speak bilingual Chinese and English. Any good way to reach out to the team? 🤔 …more Like Reply 2 replies 2 Replies on Kent Pang’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Hmm, work@comma.ai should work. Will look Like Reply Kent Pang • 3rd+ Supply Chain | Manufacturing | Quality | Compliance | Procurement | Operation Improvement 3y Resent my resume to the email above. More than happy to chat Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3y Hmm, work@comma.ai should work. Will look Like Reply

Kent Pang • 3rd+ Supply Chain | Manufacturing | Quality | Compliance | Procurement | Operation Improvement 3y Resent my resume to the email above. More than happy to chat Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • We're hiring for comma. We're scaling up production, always improving openpilot, and ramping up our robotics division. Short list of jobs: Head of Production / Supply Chain Manager: Know every part in a cell phone. Speaking Chinese a plus. You get to run an on site factory from populating circuit boards up to fulfilling orders. We like insourcing, it's how you get quality. Hardware Engineer: Know what PWM, inductors, compilers/linkers, I2C, bootloaders, etc... are. You should have some experience with mechanical, electrical, and firmware, and be amazing at one of the three. We have a great on site prototyping lab, with budget to buy most any tools you want. Software Engineer: We have two software teams, openpilot and research. For both, it's mostly skill with "infrastructure" like just knowing about computers. My favorite interview question is "I type google dot com into a web browser what happens" then have a 20 minute convo about this. You can go so deep with this question. (ex: when is DNS UDP and when is DNS TCP?) No ML knowledge required, that can be picked up quickly. If you like old school hacker culture and "The Hacker Attitude," you'll fit in well. For people who are sick of feeling like a cog in a machine and want to make progress on very hard problems. One meeting a week, two great meals a day, and people who have passed a very high bar to get hired. Reach in to "work at comma ai" …more 33 comments 17 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 3y Getting asked about international too. All jobs are on site in San Diego, but we'll work with you on a visa. We have many international employees. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Adam Nelson • 3rd+ Queensland’s AEVA chair and Nelso.systems 3y Also welcome to linkedin. The food maybe better here Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 3y Getting asked about international too. All jobs are on site in San Diego, but we'll work with you on a visa. We have many international employees. …more Like Reply 3 replies 3 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Adam Nelson • 3rd+ Queensland’s AEVA chair and Nelso.systems 3y Also welcome to linkedin. The food maybe better here Like Reply

Adam Nelson • 3rd+ Queensland’s AEVA chair and Nelso.systems 3y Also welcome to linkedin. The food maybe better here Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this Joe Devon Joe Devon • 3rd+ Premium • 3rd+ Founder: A11y Audits, #GAAD | Podcaster | Public Speaker Founder: A11y Audits, #GAAD | Podcaster | Public Speaker Visit my website 3yr • Follow I know so many CTOs out of work right now, even before the layoffs. Hence ReSharing open job posts. Note that for this one, you really need to know your stuff. Watch the Lex Fridman interview of George Hotz to learn what kind of questions you will be asked. I wish the winning interviews could be filmed and shown. To be a fly on the wall... …more George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • We're hiring for comma. We're scaling up production, always improving openpilot, and ramping up our robotics division. Short list of jobs: Head of Production / Supply Chain Manager: Know every part in a cell phone. Speaking Chinese a plus. You get to run an on site factory from populating circuit boards up to fulfilling orders. We like insourcing, it's how you get quality. Hardware Engineer: Know what PWM, inductors, compilers/linkers, I2C, bootloaders, etc... are. You should have some experience with mechanical, electrical, and firmware, and be amazing at one of the three. We have a great on site prototyping lab, with budget to buy most any tools you want. Software Engineer: We have two software teams, openpilot and research. For both, it's mostly skill with "infrastructure" like just knowing about computers. My favorite interview question is "I type google dot com into a web browser what happens" then have a 20 minute convo about this. You can go so deep with this question. (ex: when is DNS UDP and when is DNS TCP?) No ML knowledge required, that can be picked up quickly. If you like old school hacker culture and "The Hacker Attitude," you'll fit in well. For people who are sick of feeling like a cog in a machine and want to make progress on very hard problems. One meeting a week, two great meals a day, and people who have passed a very high bar to get hired. Reach in to "work at comma ai" …more 2 comments Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz (edited) 3y The cool thing about really tough interviews is that if you get the job, the people who you work with will be really talented! We won't make you code on a whiteboard either, that's just stressful. Interviews are a probe of your knowledge graph, coding challenges are offline at your own pace, and then a paid on-site microinternship for real work in the codebase. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Mahmud Hasan • 3rd+ Software Engineer | ContentCreator Interested in Data,Cloud & AI 3y Awesome. Thanks Geohotz. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz (edited) 3y The cool thing about really tough interviews is that if you get the job, the people who you work with will be really talented! We won't make you code on a whiteboard either, that's just stressful. Interviews are a probe of your knowledge graph, coding challenges are offline at your own pace, and then a paid on-site microinternship for real work in the codebase. …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Mahmud Hasan • 3rd+ Software Engineer | ContentCreator Interested in Data,Cloud & AI 3y Awesome. Thanks Geohotz. Like Reply

Mahmud Hasan • 3rd+ Software Engineer | ContentCreator Interested in Data,Cloud & AI 3y Awesome. Thanks Geohotz. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to their own comment on this William Sitch William Sitch • 3rd+ Premium • 3rd+ Sensor calibration, localization and mapping | Chief Business Officer at MSA Sensor calibration, localization and mapping | Chief Business Officer at MSA Book an appointment 3yr • Follow Camera-based localization and mapping! No GPS, no lidar! The small dots on the left are a dense point cloud generated by a sparse stereo camera technique (bundle adjusting image data), which is illustrated within the camera views shown on the right. This is 10x the density of lidar point clouds! The four cameras are not synchronized, they're not matching stereo pairs, they all have a different rolling shutter, and they all have independently-varying white balance and exposure. Note fixed pattern noise (dirty lens) is excluded, and the robot body placement in the images isn't a problem. The left view shows mapping anchor points in graph form on the robot's path. The robot pose estimation is very high precision. hashtag #localization hashtag #mapping hashtag #cameralocalization hashtag #robotics …more Play 3,998 157 comments 103 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz 3y Open source? Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Sourjyendra Krishna Deb • 3rd+ SDE-1 ▪️ NIT Durgapur '22 3y Just wait 10 hours,someone's gonna livestream themselves coding this from scratch Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz 3y Open source? Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Sourjyendra Krishna Deb • 3rd+ SDE-1 ▪️ NIT Durgapur '22 3y Just wait 10 hours,someone's gonna livestream themselves coding this from scratch Like Reply

Sourjyendra Krishna Deb • 3rd+ SDE-1 ▪️ NIT Durgapur '22 3y Just wait 10 hours,someone's gonna livestream themselves coding this from scratch Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this William Sitch William Sitch • 3rd+ Premium • 3rd+ Sensor calibration, localization and mapping | Chief Business Officer at MSA Sensor calibration, localization and mapping | Chief Business Officer at MSA Book an appointment 3yr • Follow Camera-based localization and mapping! No GPS, no lidar! The small dots on the left are a dense point cloud generated by a sparse stereo camera technique (bundle adjusting image data), which is illustrated within the camera views shown on the right. This is 10x the density of lidar point clouds! The four cameras are not synchronized, they're not matching stereo pairs, they all have a different rolling shutter, and they all have independently-varying white balance and exposure. Note fixed pattern noise (dirty lens) is excluded, and the robot body placement in the images isn't a problem. The left view shows mapping anchor points in graph form on the robot's path. The robot pose estimation is very high precision. hashtag #localization hashtag #mapping hashtag #cameralocalization hashtag #robotics …more Play 3,998 157 comments 103 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz 3y Open source? Like Reply 8 replies 8 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Sourjyendra Krishna Deb • 3rd+ SDE-1 ▪️ NIT Durgapur '22 3y Just wait 10 hours,someone's gonna livestream themselves coding this from scratch Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Husāmْ Lahm-Alajanji’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • If you need to put more and more resources in to see the same rate of progress, you will lose. https://lnkd.in/gEqzugd6 Development speed over everything blog.comma.ai 20 comments 14 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Husāmْ Lahm-Alajanji • 3rd+ Typescript developer | husam.eu 3y For user-facing and critical applications, having something like AWS that can spin new instances in case of failures is better. But for comma ai, a local computing cluster makes more sense since it's local training and development. I liked the "total lines of code" metric too! …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Husāmْ Lahm-Alajanji’s comment George Hotz Author 3y We use Azure for our user facing stuff. 98% of uptime is fine for the local cluster. Like Reply Load more comments

Husāmْ Lahm-Alajanji • 3rd+ Typescript developer | husam.eu 3y For user-facing and critical applications, having something like AWS that can spin new instances in case of failures is better. But for comma ai, a local computing cluster makes more sense since it's local training and development. I liked the "total lines of code" metric too! …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Husāmْ Lahm-Alajanji’s comment George Hotz Author 3y We use Azure for our user facing stuff. 98% of uptime is fine for the local cluster. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y We use Azure for our user facing stuff. 98% of uptime is fine for the local cluster. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this Forrest Iandola Forrest Iandola • 3rd+ Verified • 3rd+ AI Research Scientist at Meta AI Research Scientist at Meta 3yr • Follow I’ve joined Meta as an AI Research Scientist! After spending a few years on self-driving cars, robotics, drones, and startups, I'm excited to get back to my dissertation research topic of "what's the best way to squeeze state-of-the-art AI onto tiny computers?" I’m in an on-device AI research team in Reality Labs, and we’re making AI run fast & efficiently on AR/VR headsets. And, we’re hiring (of course)... …more 35 comments 2 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz 3y Congrats! Check out tinygrad https://github.com/geohot/tinygrad …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Forrest Iandola Author AI Research Scientist at Meta 3y I'd forgotten that you used Boda in the old days. That's cool! I will indeed try Tinygrad. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz 3y Congrats! Check out tinygrad https://github.com/geohot/tinygrad …more Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on George Hotz’s comment Forrest Iandola Author AI Research Scientist at Meta 3y I'd forgotten that you used Boda in the old days. That's cool! I will indeed try Tinygrad. Like Reply

Forrest Iandola Author AI Research Scientist at Meta 3y I'd forgotten that you used Boda in the old days. That's cool! I will indeed try Tinygrad. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Henning Winter’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Edited • Notorious autonomous vehicle patent troll Axel Nix is at it again! He has sued Voyage, AutoX, Pony.ai, Dataspeed, SF Motors, WeRide Corp, and now...comma.ai But unlike some of those others, we aren't trying to make it quietly go away. We aren't worried about dumb crap like explaining a bogus IP lawsuit to our investors or anything. We stand up for what is right, even if it costs us money on legal bills, it stops funding for trolls. (the patent is about an auto emergency call system if a car crashes or something, nothing even to do with comma) Dataspeed fought back and won! We will too. No idea why you'd waste time suing us (we are not well funded), but if you insist, let's rumble! We really admire Cloudflare's strategy (google "Project Jengo") and are going to adopt what we can of it here. comma.ai will be the last company Axel Nix attempts to shake down. https://lnkd.in/gCc63uWu …more Patent Trolls Inbound: Our First Lawsuit blog.comma.ai 54 comments 14 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Henning Winter • 3rd+ Partnerships | Growth | Strategy | People Leadership | APAC & EMEA 3y George Hotz Is there a GoFund.me page? Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Henning Winter’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Nope, we got this. 400k to slay this troll is nothing, it's 200 sales. Though we do sell products! https://comma.ai/ Like Reply Load more comments

Henning Winter • 3rd+ Partnerships | Growth | Strategy | People Leadership | APAC & EMEA 3y George Hotz Is there a GoFund.me page? Like Reply 1 reply 1 Comment on Henning Winter’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Nope, we got this. 400k to slay this troll is nothing, it's 200 sales. Though we do sell products! https://comma.ai/ Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Nope, we got this. 400k to slay this troll is nothing, it's 200 sales. Though we do sell products! https://comma.ai/ Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Brandon Fitton’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Edited • This is Kenny. He is a comma body with a knee (commabody.com). In other words, a 4 DoF balancing robot. But here's the issue, he doesn't balance yet. His knee is heavy. This is why he is sitting down. We are hiring a controls engineer to make Kenny stand up. My first question will be how do the Boston Dynamics robots work. If you know the answer, apply directly to me, george@comma.ai Full time job on site in our beautiful new 20k sq ft San Diego office. hashtag #hiring hashtag #ai hashtag #work hashtag #job hashtag #robots …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 55 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Brandon Fitton • 3rd+ Mechanical Engineer with a proven background in multi-disciplinary medical device and biopharmaceutical manufacturing, process, construction, and R&D projects. 3y PID controllers and inverse kinematics. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Brandon Fitton’s comment George Hotz Author 3y This is probably going to be the first pass at this. Like Reply Brandon Fitton • 3rd+ Mechanical Engineer with a proven background in multi-disciplinary medical device and biopharmaceutical manufacturing, process, construction, and R&D projects. 3y George Hotz tried and true. Then machine learning could build some sort of active scaling on top of the PID controller input gain at each stage to make the tuning more reliable based on more dynamic circumstances. Like Reply Michael K. • 3rd+ Advanced Process Control Engineer (edited) 3y You want to avoid the I part since it is destabilizing. I would start with a LQR controller. Like Reply Elgin Beloy • 3rd+ Software Engineer | Ex-Google 3y Brandon Fitton Best response to this post IMO. Tried and true. Not sure if this dudes bachelor research results may be helpful for comparing solely RL to PID (though this was simulated :( and not really applicable to your use case): https://github.com/corno93/self-balancing-robot-using-RL#long-story-short Maybe helpful nonetheless ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Love what you're doing. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Brandon Fitton • 3rd+ Mechanical Engineer with a proven background in multi-disciplinary medical device and biopharmaceutical manufacturing, process, construction, and R&D projects. 3y PID controllers and inverse kinematics. Like Reply 4 replies 4 Replies on Brandon Fitton’s comment George Hotz Author 3y This is probably going to be the first pass at this. Like Reply Brandon Fitton • 3rd+ Mechanical Engineer with a proven background in multi-disciplinary medical device and biopharmaceutical manufacturing, process, construction, and R&D projects. 3y George Hotz tried and true. Then machine learning could build some sort of active scaling on top of the PID controller input gain at each stage to make the tuning more reliable based on more dynamic circumstances. Like Reply Michael K. • 3rd+ Advanced Process Control Engineer (edited) 3y You want to avoid the I part since it is destabilizing. I would start with a LQR controller. Like Reply Elgin Beloy • 3rd+ Software Engineer | Ex-Google 3y Brandon Fitton Best response to this post IMO. Tried and true. Not sure if this dudes bachelor research results may be helpful for comparing solely RL to PID (though this was simulated :( and not really applicable to your use case): https://github.com/corno93/self-balancing-robot-using-RL#long-story-short Maybe helpful nonetheless ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Love what you're doing. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3y This is probably going to be the first pass at this. Like Reply

Brandon Fitton • 3rd+ Mechanical Engineer with a proven background in multi-disciplinary medical device and biopharmaceutical manufacturing, process, construction, and R&D projects. 3y George Hotz tried and true. Then machine learning could build some sort of active scaling on top of the PID controller input gain at each stage to make the tuning more reliable based on more dynamic circumstances. Like Reply

Michael K. • 3rd+ Advanced Process Control Engineer (edited) 3y You want to avoid the I part since it is destabilizing. I would start with a LQR controller. Like Reply

Elgin Beloy • 3rd+ Software Engineer | Ex-Google 3y Brandon Fitton Best response to this post IMO. Tried and true. Not sure if this dudes bachelor research results may be helpful for comparing solely RL to PID (though this was simulated :( and not really applicable to your use case): https://github.com/corno93/self-balancing-robot-using-RL#long-story-short Maybe helpful nonetheless ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Love what you're doing. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Dr. Mohamad Omar Nachawati’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Edited • This is Kenny. He is a comma body with a knee (commabody.com). In other words, a 4 DoF balancing robot. But here's the issue, he doesn't balance yet. His knee is heavy. This is why he is sitting down. We are hiring a controls engineer to make Kenny stand up. My first question will be how do the Boston Dynamics robots work. If you know the answer, apply directly to me, george@comma.ai Full time job on site in our beautiful new 20k sq ft San Diego office. hashtag #hiring hashtag #ai hashtag #work hashtag #job hashtag #robots …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 55 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Dr. Mohamad Omar Nachawati • 3rd+ Cooking... 3y Why build boring house robots when you could focus on solving self-driving cars while delivering shippable intermediaries? 🤣 🤣 🤣 …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Dr. Mohamad Omar Nachawati’s comment George Hotz Author 3y How much of a difference is there? Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Mohamad Omar Nachawati Competition? Where? Like Reply Aman Dhakad • 3rd+ Mostly Programming 3y Mohamad Omar Nachawati Marketing + funding does not mean competition. It will take years for them to reach where comma and Tesla are! Like Reply Christopher Wilson • 3rd+ 😁 (edited) 3y How many of those are affordable and able to ship? Ive a comma 2 and 3 and I find it hard to compare it to anything else. Best first world purchase ive made and its not even close. Comma makes driving chill, my c3 is too good.. I probably trust it too much lol The value comma provides is infinitely higher than the cost. Not very expensive, quick install, and a really responsive community. Tesla does well, but the barrier to entry is way higher than comma. You can get a good comma car + a comma for 15-20k. Youll be at 3-4x that for a Tesla. If anyone can do it, its geohot. …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y If you read the page on Commabody, they're talking about *eventually* getting to the point where a commabody can drive *any* vehicle that a human can drive. So, current Comma devices can work with vehicles that have drive-by-wire and related integrated components, commabody will be able to control vehicles (and other systems) that are only able to be interacted with via physical means. So, comma.ai / openpilot is currently involved with navigating the roads, the commabody effort is about taking those tools and learning to navigate the entire physical world. (One could also extrapolate from this and expect that the potential here is to be able to navigate other planets, moons, asteroids, etc.) …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y I think what you're also missing is that some of this is just learning for the sake of learning. George and Comma already have a good team focused on solving self-driving. There's only so much effort and work that can go into that, a lot of it is dependent on time, data gathering, testing, and the like. Could they throw more programmers and engineers at it? Sure, but it might not solve or accelerate the project any more. Meanwhile, a question was asked and sparked some interest. I am not in the room, so I can only speculate on what some of those questions were, but I would think they're along the lines of what can I do with the knowledge we've generated from a million hours of driving and integrating with these systems? How do we navigate additional difficult environments? How does _X_ work (in this case, they're talking about the basics of a knee joint, but I'm sure their minds went many places)? How can we do _Y_? By investigating these problems and topics they're growing their knowledge and experience and engaging a larger audience, and some of that knowledge might eventually come back and help with the self-driving project. [More to say, but text limit here..] …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y So, like perhaps the commabody learning how to navigate a house might help them to have openpilot better able to navigate dirt roads, off-road environments, small unmarked stone-lined ancient streets and alleyways found in many locations, and the like. And, who knows, maybe learning how a knee and other joints work will help to revolutionize other vehicles, be they new forms of off-road capable vehicles, mechanized stand-up wheelchairs, and the like. Either way, this is essentially recreational problem-solving, something important to explore when you've got that itch. Anyways, they're not doing it alone - they've created a product and are inviting the rest of the world to join them in learning and developing the possibilities. But still think this is silly? There's a reason Hyundai bought Boston Dynamics for over a billion dollars.. it's not just to own a great robotics company... but also to integrate what that effort has learned about sensing and interpreting the environments, and navigating and moving in them safely into autonomous vehicles. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Dr. Mohamad Omar Nachawati • 3rd+ Cooking... 3y Why build boring house robots when you could focus on solving self-driving cars while delivering shippable intermediaries? 🤣 🤣 🤣 …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Dr. Mohamad Omar Nachawati’s comment George Hotz Author 3y How much of a difference is there? Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Mohamad Omar Nachawati Competition? Where? Like Reply Aman Dhakad • 3rd+ Mostly Programming 3y Mohamad Omar Nachawati Marketing + funding does not mean competition. It will take years for them to reach where comma and Tesla are! Like Reply Christopher Wilson • 3rd+ 😁 (edited) 3y How many of those are affordable and able to ship? Ive a comma 2 and 3 and I find it hard to compare it to anything else. Best first world purchase ive made and its not even close. Comma makes driving chill, my c3 is too good.. I probably trust it too much lol The value comma provides is infinitely higher than the cost. Not very expensive, quick install, and a really responsive community. Tesla does well, but the barrier to entry is way higher than comma. You can get a good comma car + a comma for 15-20k. Youll be at 3-4x that for a Tesla. If anyone can do it, its geohot. …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y If you read the page on Commabody, they're talking about *eventually* getting to the point where a commabody can drive *any* vehicle that a human can drive. So, current Comma devices can work with vehicles that have drive-by-wire and related integrated components, commabody will be able to control vehicles (and other systems) that are only able to be interacted with via physical means. So, comma.ai / openpilot is currently involved with navigating the roads, the commabody effort is about taking those tools and learning to navigate the entire physical world. (One could also extrapolate from this and expect that the potential here is to be able to navigate other planets, moons, asteroids, etc.) …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y I think what you're also missing is that some of this is just learning for the sake of learning. George and Comma already have a good team focused on solving self-driving. There's only so much effort and work that can go into that, a lot of it is dependent on time, data gathering, testing, and the like. Could they throw more programmers and engineers at it? Sure, but it might not solve or accelerate the project any more. Meanwhile, a question was asked and sparked some interest. I am not in the room, so I can only speculate on what some of those questions were, but I would think they're along the lines of what can I do with the knowledge we've generated from a million hours of driving and integrating with these systems? How do we navigate additional difficult environments? How does _X_ work (in this case, they're talking about the basics of a knee joint, but I'm sure their minds went many places)? How can we do _Y_? By investigating these problems and topics they're growing their knowledge and experience and engaging a larger audience, and some of that knowledge might eventually come back and help with the self-driving project. [More to say, but text limit here..] …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y So, like perhaps the commabody learning how to navigate a house might help them to have openpilot better able to navigate dirt roads, off-road environments, small unmarked stone-lined ancient streets and alleyways found in many locations, and the like. And, who knows, maybe learning how a knee and other joints work will help to revolutionize other vehicles, be they new forms of off-road capable vehicles, mechanized stand-up wheelchairs, and the like. Either way, this is essentially recreational problem-solving, something important to explore when you've got that itch. Anyways, they're not doing it alone - they've created a product and are inviting the rest of the world to join them in learning and developing the possibilities. But still think this is silly? There's a reason Hyundai bought Boston Dynamics for over a billion dollars.. it's not just to own a great robotics company... but also to integrate what that effort has learned about sensing and interpreting the environments, and navigating and moving in them safely into autonomous vehicles. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3y How much of a difference is there? Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Mohamad Omar Nachawati Competition? Where? Like Reply

Aman Dhakad • 3rd+ Mostly Programming 3y Mohamad Omar Nachawati Marketing + funding does not mean competition. It will take years for them to reach where comma and Tesla are! Like Reply

Christopher Wilson • 3rd+ 😁 (edited) 3y How many of those are affordable and able to ship? Ive a comma 2 and 3 and I find it hard to compare it to anything else. Best first world purchase ive made and its not even close. Comma makes driving chill, my c3 is too good.. I probably trust it too much lol The value comma provides is infinitely higher than the cost. Not very expensive, quick install, and a really responsive community. Tesla does well, but the barrier to entry is way higher than comma. You can get a good comma car + a comma for 15-20k. Youll be at 3-4x that for a Tesla. If anyone can do it, its geohot. …more Like Reply

Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y If you read the page on Commabody, they're talking about *eventually* getting to the point where a commabody can drive *any* vehicle that a human can drive. So, current Comma devices can work with vehicles that have drive-by-wire and related integrated components, commabody will be able to control vehicles (and other systems) that are only able to be interacted with via physical means. So, comma.ai / openpilot is currently involved with navigating the roads, the commabody effort is about taking those tools and learning to navigate the entire physical world. (One could also extrapolate from this and expect that the potential here is to be able to navigate other planets, moons, asteroids, etc.) …more Like Reply

Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y I think what you're also missing is that some of this is just learning for the sake of learning. George and Comma already have a good team focused on solving self-driving. There's only so much effort and work that can go into that, a lot of it is dependent on time, data gathering, testing, and the like. Could they throw more programmers and engineers at it? Sure, but it might not solve or accelerate the project any more. Meanwhile, a question was asked and sparked some interest. I am not in the room, so I can only speculate on what some of those questions were, but I would think they're along the lines of what can I do with the knowledge we've generated from a million hours of driving and integrating with these systems? How do we navigate additional difficult environments? How does _X_ work (in this case, they're talking about the basics of a knee joint, but I'm sure their minds went many places)? How can we do _Y_? By investigating these problems and topics they're growing their knowledge and experience and engaging a larger audience, and some of that knowledge might eventually come back and help with the self-driving project. [More to say, but text limit here..] …more Like Reply

Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y So, like perhaps the commabody learning how to navigate a house might help them to have openpilot better able to navigate dirt roads, off-road environments, small unmarked stone-lined ancient streets and alleyways found in many locations, and the like. And, who knows, maybe learning how a knee and other joints work will help to revolutionize other vehicles, be they new forms of off-road capable vehicles, mechanized stand-up wheelchairs, and the like. Either way, this is essentially recreational problem-solving, something important to explore when you've got that itch. Anyways, they're not doing it alone - they've created a product and are inviting the rest of the world to join them in learning and developing the possibilities. But still think this is silly? There's a reason Hyundai bought Boston Dynamics for over a billion dollars.. it's not just to own a great robotics company... but also to integrate what that effort has learned about sensing and interpreting the environments, and navigating and moving in them safely into autonomous vehicles. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Srinivas Mukund’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Edited • This is Kenny. He is a comma body with a knee (commabody.com). In other words, a 4 DoF balancing robot. But here's the issue, he doesn't balance yet. His knee is heavy. This is why he is sitting down. We are hiring a controls engineer to make Kenny stand up. My first question will be how do the Boston Dynamics robots work. If you know the answer, apply directly to me, george@comma.ai Full time job on site in our beautiful new 20k sq ft San Diego office. hashtag #hiring hashtag #ai hashtag #work hashtag #job hashtag #robots …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 55 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud 3y They are surely hiring people who know rl, tf and python. So guessing something like ppo or ddpg. I worked on a robotic arm in discrete action space. Think I should apply? …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Srinivas Mukund’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author (edited) 3y I'm mostly fine with RL solutions, though you better have a really good model of the system first, and understand how that model transfers to reality. Like Reply Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud (edited) 3y George Hotz Might b worth trying A2C methods like DDPG so that we can feed the input state directly into a parametrized neural network to achieve model free RL Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Mukund Vadrev The learning method isn't the issue. The environment is. You want to learn IRL or in simulation? Like Reply Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud 3y George Hotz IRL ..Surely will b great if we can 3d print a to scale miniature model, dangle the knee to some support and develop everything in real world. Like Reply Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud 3y Something like this. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4001243783579.html Use a python local web sever with gym and send simple http calls as the model takes decisions to effect the robots joints easily …more Like Reply Load more comments

Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud 3y They are surely hiring people who know rl, tf and python. So guessing something like ppo or ddpg. I worked on a robotic arm in discrete action space. Think I should apply? …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on Srinivas Mukund’s comment See previous replies George Hotz Author (edited) 3y I'm mostly fine with RL solutions, though you better have a really good model of the system first, and understand how that model transfers to reality. Like Reply Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud (edited) 3y George Hotz Might b worth trying A2C methods like DDPG so that we can feed the input state directly into a parametrized neural network to achieve model free RL Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Mukund Vadrev The learning method isn't the issue. The environment is. You want to learn IRL or in simulation? Like Reply Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud 3y George Hotz IRL ..Surely will b great if we can 3d print a to scale miniature model, dangle the knee to some support and develop everything in real world. Like Reply Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud 3y Something like this. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4001243783579.html Use a python local web sever with gym and send simple http calls as the model takes decisions to effect the robots joints easily …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author (edited) 3y I'm mostly fine with RL solutions, though you better have a really good model of the system first, and understand how that model transfers to reality. Like Reply

Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud (edited) 3y George Hotz Might b worth trying A2C methods like DDPG so that we can feed the input state directly into a parametrized neural network to achieve model free RL Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Mukund Vadrev The learning method isn't the issue. The environment is. You want to learn IRL or in simulation? Like Reply

Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud 3y George Hotz IRL ..Surely will b great if we can 3d print a to scale miniature model, dangle the knee to some support and develop everything in real world. Like Reply

Srinivas Mukund • 3rd+ Full stack + AI + Cloud 3y Something like this. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4001243783579.html Use a python local web sever with gym and send simple http calls as the model takes decisions to effect the robots joints easily …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Dr. Mohamad Omar Nachawati’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • Edited • This is Kenny. He is a comma body with a knee (commabody.com). In other words, a 4 DoF balancing robot. But here's the issue, he doesn't balance yet. His knee is heavy. This is why he is sitting down. We are hiring a controls engineer to make Kenny stand up. My first question will be how do the Boston Dynamics robots work. If you know the answer, apply directly to me, george@comma.ai Full time job on site in our beautiful new 20k sq ft San Diego office. hashtag #hiring hashtag #ai hashtag #work hashtag #job hashtag #robots …more Activate to view larger image, Activate to view larger image, 55 comments 6 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Dr. Mohamad Omar Nachawati • 3rd+ Cooking... 3y Why build boring house robots when you could focus on solving self-driving cars while delivering shippable intermediaries? 🤣 🤣 🤣 …more Like Reply 7 replies 7 Replies on Dr. Mohamad Omar Nachawati’s comment George Hotz Author 3y How much of a difference is there? Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Mohamad Omar Nachawati Competition? Where? Like Reply Aman Dhakad • 3rd+ Mostly Programming 3y Mohamad Omar Nachawati Marketing + funding does not mean competition. It will take years for them to reach where comma and Tesla are! Like Reply Christopher Wilson • 3rd+ 😁 (edited) 3y How many of those are affordable and able to ship? Ive a comma 2 and 3 and I find it hard to compare it to anything else. Best first world purchase ive made and its not even close. Comma makes driving chill, my c3 is too good.. I probably trust it too much lol The value comma provides is infinitely higher than the cost. Not very expensive, quick install, and a really responsive community. Tesla does well, but the barrier to entry is way higher than comma. You can get a good comma car + a comma for 15-20k. Youll be at 3-4x that for a Tesla. If anyone can do it, its geohot. …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y If you read the page on Commabody, they're talking about *eventually* getting to the point where a commabody can drive *any* vehicle that a human can drive. So, current Comma devices can work with vehicles that have drive-by-wire and related integrated components, commabody will be able to control vehicles (and other systems) that are only able to be interacted with via physical means. So, comma.ai / openpilot is currently involved with navigating the roads, the commabody effort is about taking those tools and learning to navigate the entire physical world. (One could also extrapolate from this and expect that the potential here is to be able to navigate other planets, moons, asteroids, etc.) …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y I think what you're also missing is that some of this is just learning for the sake of learning. George and Comma already have a good team focused on solving self-driving. There's only so much effort and work that can go into that, a lot of it is dependent on time, data gathering, testing, and the like. Could they throw more programmers and engineers at it? Sure, but it might not solve or accelerate the project any more. Meanwhile, a question was asked and sparked some interest. I am not in the room, so I can only speculate on what some of those questions were, but I would think they're along the lines of what can I do with the knowledge we've generated from a million hours of driving and integrating with these systems? How do we navigate additional difficult environments? How does _X_ work (in this case, they're talking about the basics of a knee joint, but I'm sure their minds went many places)? How can we do _Y_? By investigating these problems and topics they're growing their knowledge and experience and engaging a larger audience, and some of that knowledge might eventually come back and help with the self-driving project. [More to say, but text limit here..] …more Like Reply Michael S. • 3rd+ Social Entrepreneur / Board Member / Recycling Advocate / Investor 3y So, like perhaps the commabody learning how to navigate a house might help them to have openpilot better able to navigate dirt roads, off-road environments, small unmarked stone-lined ancient streets and alleyways found in many locations, and the like. And, who knows, maybe learning how a knee and other joints work will help to revolutionize other vehicles, be they new forms of off-road capable vehicles, mechanized stand-up wheelchairs, and the like. Either way, this is essentially recreational problem-solving, something important to explore when you've got that itch. Anyways, they're not doing it alone - they've created a product and are inviting the rest of the world to join them in learning and developing the possibilities. But still think this is silly? There's a reason Hyundai bought Boston Dynamics for over a billion dollars.. it's not just to own a great robotics company... but also to integrate what that effort has learned about sensing and interpreting the environments, and navigating and moving in them safely into autonomous vehicles. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • I'm shocked when people write in saying they want a job, but refuse to do our coding challenge. The job is a coding challenge! I guess it's an easy way to screen people out who'd never fit in here, every job I've applied for I'm excited when they give me coding. I love coding, it's very concrete and can be evaluated without bias. It's so much better than BS like tell me about a "difficult challenge you had to overcome in life" Our challenge, you'll probably learn something doing it too: https://lnkd.in/dUd_2SF …more GitHub - commaai/calib_challenge: The comma.ai Calibration Challenge! github.com 1,117 215 comments 22 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader (edited) 3y And that’s why all of the engineers that actually know what our time is worth won’t work for you. If you want my time, you pay for it. …more Like Reply 12 replies 12 Replies on Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦’s comment George Hotz Author 3y And if this attitude is common at Meta, this is why they won't win VR. Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz It's common amongst competent engineers everywhere. If you don't value my time before you've even hired me why would I expect better treatment after. It's simply a matter of respect and you're happy with those engineers who don't demand to be respected. That's fine, but you'll limit your talent pool to the less-capable and less senior …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y I disagree. I think it's a common value amongst a certain "demobilized worker unit" in the endgame of capitalism, the same sort of person who likes work from home. I'm all for making sure value creation is rewarded; paying for time is so transactional, and I find it really odd you frame it in terms of respect. You also rent boats and hookers by the hour. …more Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz And doctors, and lawyers, and accountants, and therapists, and mechanics, and professional engineers. Real professionals (and sex workers fall into that category) don't work for free unless they want to. It's about respect because of a mutual investment. When you assign a coding project, it effectively costs you nothing and costs the candidate some amount of productive time. Put another way, you can "challenge" a thousand candidates, they can't do a thousand challenges. Insisting that they give you a thing of value and that you give them nothing in return is disrespectful, you'd never do the same for an accountant or a lawyer or a doctor. You say you are "paying for value creation" but that is where it becomes transactional. You pay your employees to create value, sure, but not on a per-value basis. You pay them a salary based on a set of expectations and they agree that their time and effort is worth the benefit. I don't think you should pay people to interview, but you should have skin in the game, otherwise, you are having me do work at your behest while you pay nothing. When people ask me to do work that I don't want to do for my own satisfaction, they pay my consulting rate, which is hourly plus expenses. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I wish there were better language to express this point. The world dies with this "professional managerial class" mentality. That there's someone to manage you. That there's hierarchy. People come to comma to solve a hard problem. If the problem is solved, everyone will end up with way more comp than a Facebook employee. If the problem isn't solved, it'll be less. We largely only have salary due to the problem of measuring value creation in a way that can't be gamed. We wouldn't hire someone who asked to be paid to do a challenge that's an academic exercise. It would set the wrong mentality for working here. Nobody manages you. There's no workplace dynamics to game. There's just a problem to solve. But to each their own. Only Nature will judge which structures win and which don't. …more Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz No one is asking you to be paid to do a challenge, we're telling you challenges like that as a precursor to an interview are insulting. They are disrespectful of our time and capabilities and are a symptom of a toxic managerial culture. Labor thrives when it doesn't let employers take advantage of our passions to satisfy their own goals (as you are doing), "the world dies" when we bow to employers on power trips. You mistake what I'm describing as somehow advocating for micromanagement. It's not that there's "someone to manage you," that has nothing to do with it. You are employing people, you are structuring the hiring pipeline, that's necessarily hierarchical and demanding a coding challenge makes it moreso. Knowing your worth as a professional is much more important than any one employer's strange hangups, and I hope every one of your prospective employees sees how little you value their time. I know it has certainly crossed you off my list as both a professional engineer and a potential customer. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I never in my life felt "insulted" by a challenge. Some challenges are boring, and I wouldn't do them. Some are cool and I would! I'm not employing people, the company is. The company is owned by its shareholders, which includes most employees. Like I said, we aren't for everyone. There's some people who would be on your side and some who'd be on mine. Let Nature judge us all! …more Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz when you are doing the hiring, it’s a distinction without a difference. You either respect your people as professionals or you don’t. You don’t expect a free legal brief from a lawyer or a free ledger from an accountant and you shouldn’t expect a free piece of software from an engineer. It’s disrespectful. You may not have felt insulted by similar demands, but that’s on your professional pride (or lack thereof). The fact is you are “shocked” by people who don’t worked for free. That’s the norm in almost every other profession …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I guess the distinction is about who the work is for. When I do challenges, I see it as working for myself. Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz we’re that true they wouldn’t be a requirement for employment. Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I was just talking about myself and how I view it. You are welcome to view it differently. Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz talking about yourself, using that as an argument for coding challenges as a condition of employment, and thereby forcing it on everyone you employ, or “oversee” if you prefer. Your experience is one thing, the policies you put in place are another. …more Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader (edited) 3y And that’s why all of the engineers that actually know what our time is worth won’t work for you. If you want my time, you pay for it. …more Like Reply 12 replies 12 Replies on Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦’s comment George Hotz Author 3y And if this attitude is common at Meta, this is why they won't win VR. Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz It's common amongst competent engineers everywhere. If you don't value my time before you've even hired me why would I expect better treatment after. It's simply a matter of respect and you're happy with those engineers who don't demand to be respected. That's fine, but you'll limit your talent pool to the less-capable and less senior …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y I disagree. I think it's a common value amongst a certain "demobilized worker unit" in the endgame of capitalism, the same sort of person who likes work from home. I'm all for making sure value creation is rewarded; paying for time is so transactional, and I find it really odd you frame it in terms of respect. You also rent boats and hookers by the hour. …more Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz And doctors, and lawyers, and accountants, and therapists, and mechanics, and professional engineers. Real professionals (and sex workers fall into that category) don't work for free unless they want to. It's about respect because of a mutual investment. When you assign a coding project, it effectively costs you nothing and costs the candidate some amount of productive time. Put another way, you can "challenge" a thousand candidates, they can't do a thousand challenges. Insisting that they give you a thing of value and that you give them nothing in return is disrespectful, you'd never do the same for an accountant or a lawyer or a doctor. You say you are "paying for value creation" but that is where it becomes transactional. You pay your employees to create value, sure, but not on a per-value basis. You pay them a salary based on a set of expectations and they agree that their time and effort is worth the benefit. I don't think you should pay people to interview, but you should have skin in the game, otherwise, you are having me do work at your behest while you pay nothing. When people ask me to do work that I don't want to do for my own satisfaction, they pay my consulting rate, which is hourly plus expenses. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I wish there were better language to express this point. The world dies with this "professional managerial class" mentality. That there's someone to manage you. That there's hierarchy. People come to comma to solve a hard problem. If the problem is solved, everyone will end up with way more comp than a Facebook employee. If the problem isn't solved, it'll be less. We largely only have salary due to the problem of measuring value creation in a way that can't be gamed. We wouldn't hire someone who asked to be paid to do a challenge that's an academic exercise. It would set the wrong mentality for working here. Nobody manages you. There's no workplace dynamics to game. There's just a problem to solve. But to each their own. Only Nature will judge which structures win and which don't. …more Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz No one is asking you to be paid to do a challenge, we're telling you challenges like that as a precursor to an interview are insulting. They are disrespectful of our time and capabilities and are a symptom of a toxic managerial culture. Labor thrives when it doesn't let employers take advantage of our passions to satisfy their own goals (as you are doing), "the world dies" when we bow to employers on power trips. You mistake what I'm describing as somehow advocating for micromanagement. It's not that there's "someone to manage you," that has nothing to do with it. You are employing people, you are structuring the hiring pipeline, that's necessarily hierarchical and demanding a coding challenge makes it moreso. Knowing your worth as a professional is much more important than any one employer's strange hangups, and I hope every one of your prospective employees sees how little you value their time. I know it has certainly crossed you off my list as both a professional engineer and a potential customer. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I never in my life felt "insulted" by a challenge. Some challenges are boring, and I wouldn't do them. Some are cool and I would! I'm not employing people, the company is. The company is owned by its shareholders, which includes most employees. Like I said, we aren't for everyone. There's some people who would be on your side and some who'd be on mine. Let Nature judge us all! …more Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz when you are doing the hiring, it’s a distinction without a difference. You either respect your people as professionals or you don’t. You don’t expect a free legal brief from a lawyer or a free ledger from an accountant and you shouldn’t expect a free piece of software from an engineer. It’s disrespectful. You may not have felt insulted by similar demands, but that’s on your professional pride (or lack thereof). The fact is you are “shocked” by people who don’t worked for free. That’s the norm in almost every other profession …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I guess the distinction is about who the work is for. When I do challenges, I see it as working for myself. Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz we’re that true they wouldn’t be a requirement for employment. Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I was just talking about myself and how I view it. You are welcome to view it differently. Like Reply Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz talking about yourself, using that as an argument for coding challenges as a condition of employment, and thereby forcing it on everyone you employ, or “oversee” if you prefer. Your experience is one thing, the policies you put in place are another. …more Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3y And if this attitude is common at Meta, this is why they won't win VR. Like Reply

Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz It's common amongst competent engineers everywhere. If you don't value my time before you've even hired me why would I expect better treatment after. It's simply a matter of respect and you're happy with those engineers who don't demand to be respected. That's fine, but you'll limit your talent pool to the less-capable and less senior …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y I disagree. I think it's a common value amongst a certain "demobilized worker unit" in the endgame of capitalism, the same sort of person who likes work from home. I'm all for making sure value creation is rewarded; paying for time is so transactional, and I find it really odd you frame it in terms of respect. You also rent boats and hookers by the hour. …more Like Reply

Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz And doctors, and lawyers, and accountants, and therapists, and mechanics, and professional engineers. Real professionals (and sex workers fall into that category) don't work for free unless they want to. It's about respect because of a mutual investment. When you assign a coding project, it effectively costs you nothing and costs the candidate some amount of productive time. Put another way, you can "challenge" a thousand candidates, they can't do a thousand challenges. Insisting that they give you a thing of value and that you give them nothing in return is disrespectful, you'd never do the same for an accountant or a lawyer or a doctor. You say you are "paying for value creation" but that is where it becomes transactional. You pay your employees to create value, sure, but not on a per-value basis. You pay them a salary based on a set of expectations and they agree that their time and effort is worth the benefit. I don't think you should pay people to interview, but you should have skin in the game, otherwise, you are having me do work at your behest while you pay nothing. When people ask me to do work that I don't want to do for my own satisfaction, they pay my consulting rate, which is hourly plus expenses. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I wish there were better language to express this point. The world dies with this "professional managerial class" mentality. That there's someone to manage you. That there's hierarchy. People come to comma to solve a hard problem. If the problem is solved, everyone will end up with way more comp than a Facebook employee. If the problem isn't solved, it'll be less. We largely only have salary due to the problem of measuring value creation in a way that can't be gamed. We wouldn't hire someone who asked to be paid to do a challenge that's an academic exercise. It would set the wrong mentality for working here. Nobody manages you. There's no workplace dynamics to game. There's just a problem to solve. But to each their own. Only Nature will judge which structures win and which don't. …more Like Reply

Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz No one is asking you to be paid to do a challenge, we're telling you challenges like that as a precursor to an interview are insulting. They are disrespectful of our time and capabilities and are a symptom of a toxic managerial culture. Labor thrives when it doesn't let employers take advantage of our passions to satisfy their own goals (as you are doing), "the world dies" when we bow to employers on power trips. You mistake what I'm describing as somehow advocating for micromanagement. It's not that there's "someone to manage you," that has nothing to do with it. You are employing people, you are structuring the hiring pipeline, that's necessarily hierarchical and demanding a coding challenge makes it moreso. Knowing your worth as a professional is much more important than any one employer's strange hangups, and I hope every one of your prospective employees sees how little you value their time. I know it has certainly crossed you off my list as both a professional engineer and a potential customer. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I never in my life felt "insulted" by a challenge. Some challenges are boring, and I wouldn't do them. Some are cool and I would! I'm not employing people, the company is. The company is owned by its shareholders, which includes most employees. Like I said, we aren't for everyone. There's some people who would be on your side and some who'd be on mine. Let Nature judge us all! …more Like Reply

Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz when you are doing the hiring, it’s a distinction without a difference. You either respect your people as professionals or you don’t. You don’t expect a free legal brief from a lawyer or a free ledger from an accountant and you shouldn’t expect a free piece of software from an engineer. It’s disrespectful. You may not have felt insulted by similar demands, but that’s on your professional pride (or lack thereof). The fact is you are “shocked” by people who don’t worked for free. That’s the norm in almost every other profession …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I guess the distinction is about who the work is for. When I do challenges, I see it as working for myself. Like Reply

Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz we’re that true they wouldn’t be a requirement for employment. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Адам Вудс-МакКормік 🇺🇦 I was just talking about myself and how I view it. You are welcome to view it differently. Like Reply

Adam Woods-McCormick 🇺🇦 • 3rd+ Senior Principal Software Engineer, Architect, Leader 3y George Hotz talking about yourself, using that as an argument for coding challenges as a condition of employment, and thereby forcing it on everyone you employ, or “oversee” if you prefer. Your experience is one thing, the policies you put in place are another. …more Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz commented on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • I'm shocked when people write in saying they want a job, but refuse to do our coding challenge. The job is a coding challenge! I guess it's an easy way to screen people out who'd never fit in here, every job I've applied for I'm excited when they give me coding. I love coding, it's very concrete and can be evaluated without bias. It's so much better than BS like tell me about a "difficult challenge you had to overcome in life" Our challenge, you'll probably learn something doing it too: https://lnkd.in/dUd_2SF …more GitHub - commaai/calib_challenge: The comma.ai Calibration Challenge! github.com 1,117 215 comments 22 reposts Like Comment Repost Send George Hotz Author 3y Some of the best solutions came from people who solved it, sent it in, and said they are quite happy with their current job but they just like solving challenges. Now that's who we want to hire. No agenda posting. …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Manoj Vekaria • 3rd+ Founding Lead Engineer at Recurrency 3y Can’t turn down a fun challenge. Like Reply Load more comments

George Hotz Author 3y Some of the best solutions came from people who solved it, sent it in, and said they are quite happy with their current job but they just like solving challenges. Now that's who we want to hire. No agenda posting. …more Like Reply 6 replies 6 Replies on George Hotz’s comment See previous replies Manoj Vekaria • 3rd+ Founding Lead Engineer at Recurrency 3y Can’t turn down a fun challenge. Like Reply

Manoj Vekaria • 3rd+ Founding Lead Engineer at Recurrency 3y Can’t turn down a fun challenge. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Jeroen C Commandeur’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • I'm shocked when people write in saying they want a job, but refuse to do our coding challenge. The job is a coding challenge! I guess it's an easy way to screen people out who'd never fit in here, every job I've applied for I'm excited when they give me coding. I love coding, it's very concrete and can be evaluated without bias. It's so much better than BS like tell me about a "difficult challenge you had to overcome in life" Our challenge, you'll probably learn something doing it too: https://lnkd.in/dUd_2SF …more GitHub - commaai/calib_challenge: The comma.ai Calibration Challenge! github.com 1,117 215 comments 22 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y What if the candidate has a personal portfolio they can show? What if there is a complete released product in that portfolio you can look at directly online? What if the candidate is able to tell you about all the technical details of the front and backend of that product because he made it all from scratch? Like https://www.figuro.io, an online 3d editing app which serves as my own portfolio. Is such candidate still required to take a test and if so, why? …more Like Reply 35 replies 35 Replies on Jeroen C Commandeur’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Why not do the challenge? Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y George Hotz Same reason Tom Cruise never does an audition any more. It's a waste of everyone's time, and an insult to his accomplishments. Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Matthew Wilson I have literally no idea what point you're trying to make. Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily (edited) 3y Matthew Wilson Tell me you're more interested in saying something that sounds witty than contributing to the conversation without telling me you're more interested in saying something that sounds witty than contributing to the conversation …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y George Hotz Because I think I have proven my capabilities for most positions. Will you answer my question next? Like Reply Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y Jonathan Hall that's not an accurate comparison (if you're taking about take-home challenges). And I think this also answers Jeroen C Commandeur 's question. Audition duration: 30m. Tom Cruise's time spent: 1h (30m reading, 30m auditioning). Casting director's time spent: 30m (total 30m if no assistants). Time to review past work: 1h. Tom Cruise's time spent: 0. Casting director's time spent: 1h (total 1h if no assistants). You can replace "audition" with "interview" and the times will be the same. It also works for reviewing past work, whether you're reviewing Tom Cruise's acting roles or software projects. Now here's where it gets interesting. Coding challenge duration: 2h (or 10 sometimes). Tom Cruise's time spent: 2h. Reviewer's time spent: 10m. So, Jonathan, auditioning is actually comparable to an interview (especially a live coding one). Which we also don't like. And Jeroen, if I as an interviewer want to minimize my time spent, it's far better for me to ask you to waste 2 hours so I can cut my review time to 10 minutes. So, yes, my time is worth a lot more than yours, you have to do the challenge. …more Like Reply Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y We could argue that a real project is MUCH more representative of real work than a challenge, and would let me evaluate your chances of being a good employee a lot better than a challenge (because that's what we're evaluating, not expertise). We would be right in 99.999% of the cases. George's case seems to be the outlier though, he specifically said real work for his company is actually challenges. I imagine he must be building the next leetcode or hackerrank, which is 100% a valid business and fits exactly what he said. And in that case, challenges are A LOT better for me to predict your performance as an employee than real projects, because that's literally what you'll be doing all day. If that's not the case though, well, there's a reason Tom Cruise never does code challenges. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Guillermo Ojeda The challenge above is a real problem that we already have a great internal solution to. At one point we needed to solve it, hence it's pretty close to the real job. Like Reply Andre Biel • 3rd+ Interested in computers 3y I don’t get the point. Maybe because they are the company (the ones who want to hire) and decide to make the rules? Your answer implicates that you think you are the right person … but if … just if … you did all awesome things mentioned above … just solve the problem. ✌️ …more Like Reply Steve Borza • 3rd+ 3y George Hotz So you took a problem you couldn't solve and made it an interview pop quiz? Why not just discuss it with the candidate? Some coding tests are fine to see skills, but you seem to have gone a bit far. Like Reply Susmita Mitra • 3rd+ Lead Software Engineer and scrum master 3y George Hotz this where the objection comes in as people feel that you might not be interested in hiring but conducting interviews to resolve product issues, take home assignments should be paid and also the developer can outsource the project so smaller challenges solvable in 45mins are better. …more Like Reply Eric Oud Ammerveld • 3rd+ Unavailable for assignments 3y Everyone has it’s ways to get an idea of a candidates competence. The coding challenge is a rather old-fashioned one that doesn’t really reaveal anything unless a candidate actually knows a certain language at first and then tries to attest their pattern knowledge too. You could really lose candidates by this method because of the mindset behind it that knowing a certain language is the capability your are looking for. …more Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y George Hotz The problem with a challenge, even a good, realistic one like yours, is that it's still done in an artificial setting. On any healthy team, such a problem is solved in a context that simply cannot be replicated in a take home challenge. Teamwork, communication, brainstorming, considering alternatives to the problem (not just the solution). These are all things that no challenge can approximate. The things a challenge CAN approximate (technical coding ability, coding style, etc) can be very easily gleaned by looking at existing code. Insisting that someone with a proven track record needs to do YOUR exercise to re-prove that is at best wasteful, and at worst insulting. …more Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Guillermo Ojeda Yes. Any analogy can be taken too far, as you have done. Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y I like hiring by a coding challenge. Here's what I think. Yeah you have a portfolio and what not. That's great, but what I do not know is: 1. your thought process 2. time you take to implement your thoughts 3. coding and organizing practices All candidates have different portfolios and have worked on wide range of projects. I as a company have a specific need. With a standard challenge I can compare all the candidates with single scale and that scale is customized to what I need. You maybe a great programmer but your way of working could be completely different from how my company works. Some people get really adamant when you ask them to adapt. They have certain career goals and they want to stick by it. Which is fine but I need a team that works well together. And I can spend time reading each person's detailed portfolio, old code and guess they might fit, or I could see how they did what I need them to do, in the time I need it done. Such a candidate who is willing to put in time is someone who takes initiative and is a good sign. Coz a lot of times I'll need someone to try something new, something uncomfortable & this person has a proven record with me, that they can get out of their comfort zone and attempt it, a BIG PLUS. …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Guillermo Ojeda If the interviewer thinks his time is worth a lot more than mine, that's a wrong start to begin the relationship with. This interviewer actually asks me right from the start to invest more in the relationship than he does? I'll pass. …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik Thanks for that detailed answer. I still think the coding challenge is the wrong tool. You want someone capable of creating a product, which is more than just writing code, and fit in the team? Hire someone based on their track record and a good interview and then give him a try for a month to see if there is a fit with the team. No coding challenge will tell you the latter. …more Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur If I hire someone and find they are not a good fit after a month. What am I supposed to do then? Fire them? wouldn't that be a bigger problem for the candidate than taking a few hours? Also, I usually don't give just a programming test. I usually ask to make a full feature end to end as you would on a job. So, if you do that then I am sure you can do rest of the job as well. And sometimes I have asked candidates to actually make feature I needed in my product. In those cases I have paid the people (pre agreed amount) if their output was actually usable along with an offer letter, despite I end up using some other candidate's work. …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik You want the candidate to fit in your team, as any good company would, right? I'm saying no coding challenge will help you with that. It does not reflect real working conditions. So even if they do the challenge and you hire them based on that, you might find yourself with somebody that doesn't fit with the team after all. What do you do? Keep them around, frustrating themselves and others? A good candidate would recognize this and quit btw. But I'm asking what you would do if you find out that, despite of a coding challenge, the candidate doesn't fit in your team? …more Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Dipender Kaushik You cannot measure everything important in an interview. In fact, you can't even measure most of what's important in an interview. Studies prove this again and again. Given this reality, what can we do? Firing, as you suggest, may well be the best option in many cases. Whatever the best answer is, we can be sure that polishing the turd that is the interview process isn't it. …more Like Reply Matheus Inacio • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Sitemate 3y As a third party I've found this a very interesting discussion with valid points on both sides. Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jonathan Hall excuse me what? a chance to prove one's skill by doing a practical is also not adequate according to you? then what should recruiters do? Hire people by throwing dice and fire them next month? Come on. don't just oppose something for the sake of opposing.. Hiring is a challenging thing. Its an ongoing process of improvement. While not all companies are best at it, not all job seekers are honest too. So its a tussle that will keep on going. but no way on earth a company would adopt a policy of hiring without an interview or a test and then keep firing people. That will open another Pandora's box of issues. …more Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur well that is an unfortunate thing. But a practical showcase of your skills reduces chances of being a misfit. Of course it can still happen. In that case we'll do what needs to be done. You are arguing that something does not give 100% result so lets not do it. Name 1 practice that can give 100% result. Its like saying criminal still find ways to commit crime so lets remove all police and security protocols coz they are useless. How is that a solution? …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying certain solutions are not adequate enough. I'm not saying don't use a solution at all. In this case, I'm saying that if you already have -actual proof- that a candidate has certain skills acquired, a test won't add much and can even be a disadvantage because lots of people just don't perform well with tests, while they can still be excellent at the job itself. Hence, check skills, do an interview to see if there is a vibe and if so, give them a shot. You'll find out if they fit the team early on. Most of the time, I think you will be good especially if you involved your other devs in the interview. This saves everybody a lot of time and also makes sure everybody invests the right amount of time to the whole process. We are now talking in circles I think. Your position and mine are clear. Thanks for the civilized debate. :-) …more Like Reply Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y Jonathan Hall sorry, I tend to do that. Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur yeah. As I said, recruitment is a process that keeps evolving. All practices have their own pros and cons. And I have hired people with coding challenge and sometimes with just an interview after looking at the portfolio. I have had experience in dealing with people coming from different experiences and by different processes. I was just pointing out what I like about the coding challenge approach. …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Andre Biel They have every right to make up the rules. Just as I have every right to challenge those rules because I think they are stupid. Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y George Hotz You haven't answered my question yet. Like Reply Lucian Crisan💻👍 • 3rd+ 🚀 | Tech Leader | Typescript | React | Nodejs | Consultant Software Developer | 20 years (edited) 3y I guess you are happy to compare your solution with the candidates who solve the problem and keep the best. Well, where is the price for the effort? Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha Yes, you're making the same mistake I've already addressed above, in taking the analogy too far. The point is quite simple: There's more than one way to prove that you know how to code. And a take home challenge is only one (and not even a good one at that). Any company unwilling to consider other proof is being foolish. …more Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha Sorry if it doesn't make sense to you. It does to others. Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha You clearly see only that which you want to see. I hope that serves you well. Like Reply Filip De Munck • 3rd+ Security and Ethical Hacking (JAVA, Python) (edited) 3y A person who made that does not need comma.ai, i am never offended to take a test if i fail it's their los not mine. Like Reply Kevin N. • 3rd+ Project Lead, AV Integration, Media & Instructional Design 3y Guillermo Ojeda I don't call 2-10 hours of writing code a "challenge", I call that work. Like Reply Tyler Sheffield • 3rd+ Engineering Tech Lead/Director in Embedded Systems | Sensors | Real-Time | Low-Power 3y Can't think of any reason to submit such a candidate to a silly coding quiz, but some nincompoop somewhere will try to justify it I'm sure. Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y What if the candidate has a personal portfolio they can show? What if there is a complete released product in that portfolio you can look at directly online? What if the candidate is able to tell you about all the technical details of the front and backend of that product because he made it all from scratch? Like https://www.figuro.io, an online 3d editing app which serves as my own portfolio. Is such candidate still required to take a test and if so, why? …more Like Reply 35 replies 35 Replies on Jeroen C Commandeur’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Why not do the challenge? Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y George Hotz Same reason Tom Cruise never does an audition any more. It's a waste of everyone's time, and an insult to his accomplishments. Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Matthew Wilson I have literally no idea what point you're trying to make. Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily (edited) 3y Matthew Wilson Tell me you're more interested in saying something that sounds witty than contributing to the conversation without telling me you're more interested in saying something that sounds witty than contributing to the conversation …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y George Hotz Because I think I have proven my capabilities for most positions. Will you answer my question next? Like Reply Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y Jonathan Hall that's not an accurate comparison (if you're taking about take-home challenges). And I think this also answers Jeroen C Commandeur 's question. Audition duration: 30m. Tom Cruise's time spent: 1h (30m reading, 30m auditioning). Casting director's time spent: 30m (total 30m if no assistants). Time to review past work: 1h. Tom Cruise's time spent: 0. Casting director's time spent: 1h (total 1h if no assistants). You can replace "audition" with "interview" and the times will be the same. It also works for reviewing past work, whether you're reviewing Tom Cruise's acting roles or software projects. Now here's where it gets interesting. Coding challenge duration: 2h (or 10 sometimes). Tom Cruise's time spent: 2h. Reviewer's time spent: 10m. So, Jonathan, auditioning is actually comparable to an interview (especially a live coding one). Which we also don't like. And Jeroen, if I as an interviewer want to minimize my time spent, it's far better for me to ask you to waste 2 hours so I can cut my review time to 10 minutes. So, yes, my time is worth a lot more than yours, you have to do the challenge. …more Like Reply Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y We could argue that a real project is MUCH more representative of real work than a challenge, and would let me evaluate your chances of being a good employee a lot better than a challenge (because that's what we're evaluating, not expertise). We would be right in 99.999% of the cases. George's case seems to be the outlier though, he specifically said real work for his company is actually challenges. I imagine he must be building the next leetcode or hackerrank, which is 100% a valid business and fits exactly what he said. And in that case, challenges are A LOT better for me to predict your performance as an employee than real projects, because that's literally what you'll be doing all day. If that's not the case though, well, there's a reason Tom Cruise never does code challenges. …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Guillermo Ojeda The challenge above is a real problem that we already have a great internal solution to. At one point we needed to solve it, hence it's pretty close to the real job. Like Reply Andre Biel • 3rd+ Interested in computers 3y I don’t get the point. Maybe because they are the company (the ones who want to hire) and decide to make the rules? Your answer implicates that you think you are the right person … but if … just if … you did all awesome things mentioned above … just solve the problem. ✌️ …more Like Reply Steve Borza • 3rd+ 3y George Hotz So you took a problem you couldn't solve and made it an interview pop quiz? Why not just discuss it with the candidate? Some coding tests are fine to see skills, but you seem to have gone a bit far. Like Reply Susmita Mitra • 3rd+ Lead Software Engineer and scrum master 3y George Hotz this where the objection comes in as people feel that you might not be interested in hiring but conducting interviews to resolve product issues, take home assignments should be paid and also the developer can outsource the project so smaller challenges solvable in 45mins are better. …more Like Reply Eric Oud Ammerveld • 3rd+ Unavailable for assignments 3y Everyone has it’s ways to get an idea of a candidates competence. The coding challenge is a rather old-fashioned one that doesn’t really reaveal anything unless a candidate actually knows a certain language at first and then tries to attest their pattern knowledge too. You could really lose candidates by this method because of the mindset behind it that knowing a certain language is the capability your are looking for. …more Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y George Hotz The problem with a challenge, even a good, realistic one like yours, is that it's still done in an artificial setting. On any healthy team, such a problem is solved in a context that simply cannot be replicated in a take home challenge. Teamwork, communication, brainstorming, considering alternatives to the problem (not just the solution). These are all things that no challenge can approximate. The things a challenge CAN approximate (technical coding ability, coding style, etc) can be very easily gleaned by looking at existing code. Insisting that someone with a proven track record needs to do YOUR exercise to re-prove that is at best wasteful, and at worst insulting. …more Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Guillermo Ojeda Yes. Any analogy can be taken too far, as you have done. Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y I like hiring by a coding challenge. Here's what I think. Yeah you have a portfolio and what not. That's great, but what I do not know is: 1. your thought process 2. time you take to implement your thoughts 3. coding and organizing practices All candidates have different portfolios and have worked on wide range of projects. I as a company have a specific need. With a standard challenge I can compare all the candidates with single scale and that scale is customized to what I need. You maybe a great programmer but your way of working could be completely different from how my company works. Some people get really adamant when you ask them to adapt. They have certain career goals and they want to stick by it. Which is fine but I need a team that works well together. And I can spend time reading each person's detailed portfolio, old code and guess they might fit, or I could see how they did what I need them to do, in the time I need it done. Such a candidate who is willing to put in time is someone who takes initiative and is a good sign. Coz a lot of times I'll need someone to try something new, something uncomfortable & this person has a proven record with me, that they can get out of their comfort zone and attempt it, a BIG PLUS. …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Guillermo Ojeda If the interviewer thinks his time is worth a lot more than mine, that's a wrong start to begin the relationship with. This interviewer actually asks me right from the start to invest more in the relationship than he does? I'll pass. …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik Thanks for that detailed answer. I still think the coding challenge is the wrong tool. You want someone capable of creating a product, which is more than just writing code, and fit in the team? Hire someone based on their track record and a good interview and then give him a try for a month to see if there is a fit with the team. No coding challenge will tell you the latter. …more Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur If I hire someone and find they are not a good fit after a month. What am I supposed to do then? Fire them? wouldn't that be a bigger problem for the candidate than taking a few hours? Also, I usually don't give just a programming test. I usually ask to make a full feature end to end as you would on a job. So, if you do that then I am sure you can do rest of the job as well. And sometimes I have asked candidates to actually make feature I needed in my product. In those cases I have paid the people (pre agreed amount) if their output was actually usable along with an offer letter, despite I end up using some other candidate's work. …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik You want the candidate to fit in your team, as any good company would, right? I'm saying no coding challenge will help you with that. It does not reflect real working conditions. So even if they do the challenge and you hire them based on that, you might find yourself with somebody that doesn't fit with the team after all. What do you do? Keep them around, frustrating themselves and others? A good candidate would recognize this and quit btw. But I'm asking what you would do if you find out that, despite of a coding challenge, the candidate doesn't fit in your team? …more Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Dipender Kaushik You cannot measure everything important in an interview. In fact, you can't even measure most of what's important in an interview. Studies prove this again and again. Given this reality, what can we do? Firing, as you suggest, may well be the best option in many cases. Whatever the best answer is, we can be sure that polishing the turd that is the interview process isn't it. …more Like Reply Matheus Inacio • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Sitemate 3y As a third party I've found this a very interesting discussion with valid points on both sides. Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jonathan Hall excuse me what? a chance to prove one's skill by doing a practical is also not adequate according to you? then what should recruiters do? Hire people by throwing dice and fire them next month? Come on. don't just oppose something for the sake of opposing.. Hiring is a challenging thing. Its an ongoing process of improvement. While not all companies are best at it, not all job seekers are honest too. So its a tussle that will keep on going. but no way on earth a company would adopt a policy of hiring without an interview or a test and then keep firing people. That will open another Pandora's box of issues. …more Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur well that is an unfortunate thing. But a practical showcase of your skills reduces chances of being a misfit. Of course it can still happen. In that case we'll do what needs to be done. You are arguing that something does not give 100% result so lets not do it. Name 1 practice that can give 100% result. Its like saying criminal still find ways to commit crime so lets remove all police and security protocols coz they are useless. How is that a solution? …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying certain solutions are not adequate enough. I'm not saying don't use a solution at all. In this case, I'm saying that if you already have -actual proof- that a candidate has certain skills acquired, a test won't add much and can even be a disadvantage because lots of people just don't perform well with tests, while they can still be excellent at the job itself. Hence, check skills, do an interview to see if there is a vibe and if so, give them a shot. You'll find out if they fit the team early on. Most of the time, I think you will be good especially if you involved your other devs in the interview. This saves everybody a lot of time and also makes sure everybody invests the right amount of time to the whole process. We are now talking in circles I think. Your position and mine are clear. Thanks for the civilized debate. :-) …more Like Reply Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y Jonathan Hall sorry, I tend to do that. Like Reply Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur yeah. As I said, recruitment is a process that keeps evolving. All practices have their own pros and cons. And I have hired people with coding challenge and sometimes with just an interview after looking at the portfolio. I have had experience in dealing with people coming from different experiences and by different processes. I was just pointing out what I like about the coding challenge approach. …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Andre Biel They have every right to make up the rules. Just as I have every right to challenge those rules because I think they are stupid. Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y George Hotz You haven't answered my question yet. Like Reply Lucian Crisan💻👍 • 3rd+ 🚀 | Tech Leader | Typescript | React | Nodejs | Consultant Software Developer | 20 years (edited) 3y I guess you are happy to compare your solution with the candidates who solve the problem and keep the best. Well, where is the price for the effort? Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha Yes, you're making the same mistake I've already addressed above, in taking the analogy too far. The point is quite simple: There's more than one way to prove that you know how to code. And a take home challenge is only one (and not even a good one at that). Any company unwilling to consider other proof is being foolish. …more Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha Sorry if it doesn't make sense to you. It does to others. Like Reply Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha You clearly see only that which you want to see. I hope that serves you well. Like Reply Filip De Munck • 3rd+ Security and Ethical Hacking (JAVA, Python) (edited) 3y A person who made that does not need comma.ai, i am never offended to take a test if i fail it's their los not mine. Like Reply Kevin N. • 3rd+ Project Lead, AV Integration, Media & Instructional Design 3y Guillermo Ojeda I don't call 2-10 hours of writing code a "challenge", I call that work. Like Reply Tyler Sheffield • 3rd+ Engineering Tech Lead/Director in Embedded Systems | Sensors | Real-Time | Low-Power 3y Can't think of any reason to submit such a candidate to a silly coding quiz, but some nincompoop somewhere will try to justify it I'm sure. Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3y Why not do the challenge? Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y George Hotz Same reason Tom Cruise never does an audition any more. It's a waste of everyone's time, and an insult to his accomplishments. Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Matthew Wilson I have literally no idea what point you're trying to make. Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily (edited) 3y Matthew Wilson Tell me you're more interested in saying something that sounds witty than contributing to the conversation without telling me you're more interested in saying something that sounds witty than contributing to the conversation …more Like Reply

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y George Hotz Because I think I have proven my capabilities for most positions. Will you answer my question next? Like Reply

Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y Jonathan Hall that's not an accurate comparison (if you're taking about take-home challenges). And I think this also answers Jeroen C Commandeur 's question. Audition duration: 30m. Tom Cruise's time spent: 1h (30m reading, 30m auditioning). Casting director's time spent: 30m (total 30m if no assistants). Time to review past work: 1h. Tom Cruise's time spent: 0. Casting director's time spent: 1h (total 1h if no assistants). You can replace "audition" with "interview" and the times will be the same. It also works for reviewing past work, whether you're reviewing Tom Cruise's acting roles or software projects. Now here's where it gets interesting. Coding challenge duration: 2h (or 10 sometimes). Tom Cruise's time spent: 2h. Reviewer's time spent: 10m. So, Jonathan, auditioning is actually comparable to an interview (especially a live coding one). Which we also don't like. And Jeroen, if I as an interviewer want to minimize my time spent, it's far better for me to ask you to waste 2 hours so I can cut my review time to 10 minutes. So, yes, my time is worth a lot more than yours, you have to do the challenge. …more Like Reply

Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y We could argue that a real project is MUCH more representative of real work than a challenge, and would let me evaluate your chances of being a good employee a lot better than a challenge (because that's what we're evaluating, not expertise). We would be right in 99.999% of the cases. George's case seems to be the outlier though, he specifically said real work for his company is actually challenges. I imagine he must be building the next leetcode or hackerrank, which is 100% a valid business and fits exactly what he said. And in that case, challenges are A LOT better for me to predict your performance as an employee than real projects, because that's literally what you'll be doing all day. If that's not the case though, well, there's a reason Tom Cruise never does code challenges. …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Guillermo Ojeda The challenge above is a real problem that we already have a great internal solution to. At one point we needed to solve it, hence it's pretty close to the real job. Like Reply

Andre Biel • 3rd+ Interested in computers 3y I don’t get the point. Maybe because they are the company (the ones who want to hire) and decide to make the rules? Your answer implicates that you think you are the right person … but if … just if … you did all awesome things mentioned above … just solve the problem. ✌️ …more Like Reply

Steve Borza • 3rd+ 3y George Hotz So you took a problem you couldn't solve and made it an interview pop quiz? Why not just discuss it with the candidate? Some coding tests are fine to see skills, but you seem to have gone a bit far. Like Reply

Susmita Mitra • 3rd+ Lead Software Engineer and scrum master 3y George Hotz this where the objection comes in as people feel that you might not be interested in hiring but conducting interviews to resolve product issues, take home assignments should be paid and also the developer can outsource the project so smaller challenges solvable in 45mins are better. …more Like Reply

Eric Oud Ammerveld • 3rd+ Unavailable for assignments 3y Everyone has it’s ways to get an idea of a candidates competence. The coding challenge is a rather old-fashioned one that doesn’t really reaveal anything unless a candidate actually knows a certain language at first and then tries to attest their pattern knowledge too. You could really lose candidates by this method because of the mindset behind it that knowing a certain language is the capability your are looking for. …more Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y George Hotz The problem with a challenge, even a good, realistic one like yours, is that it's still done in an artificial setting. On any healthy team, such a problem is solved in a context that simply cannot be replicated in a take home challenge. Teamwork, communication, brainstorming, considering alternatives to the problem (not just the solution). These are all things that no challenge can approximate. The things a challenge CAN approximate (technical coding ability, coding style, etc) can be very easily gleaned by looking at existing code. Insisting that someone with a proven track record needs to do YOUR exercise to re-prove that is at best wasteful, and at worst insulting. …more Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Guillermo Ojeda Yes. Any analogy can be taken too far, as you have done. Like Reply

Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y I like hiring by a coding challenge. Here's what I think. Yeah you have a portfolio and what not. That's great, but what I do not know is: 1. your thought process 2. time you take to implement your thoughts 3. coding and organizing practices All candidates have different portfolios and have worked on wide range of projects. I as a company have a specific need. With a standard challenge I can compare all the candidates with single scale and that scale is customized to what I need. You maybe a great programmer but your way of working could be completely different from how my company works. Some people get really adamant when you ask them to adapt. They have certain career goals and they want to stick by it. Which is fine but I need a team that works well together. And I can spend time reading each person's detailed portfolio, old code and guess they might fit, or I could see how they did what I need them to do, in the time I need it done. Such a candidate who is willing to put in time is someone who takes initiative and is a good sign. Coz a lot of times I'll need someone to try something new, something uncomfortable & this person has a proven record with me, that they can get out of their comfort zone and attempt it, a BIG PLUS. …more Like Reply

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Guillermo Ojeda If the interviewer thinks his time is worth a lot more than mine, that's a wrong start to begin the relationship with. This interviewer actually asks me right from the start to invest more in the relationship than he does? I'll pass. …more Like Reply

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik Thanks for that detailed answer. I still think the coding challenge is the wrong tool. You want someone capable of creating a product, which is more than just writing code, and fit in the team? Hire someone based on their track record and a good interview and then give him a try for a month to see if there is a fit with the team. No coding challenge will tell you the latter. …more Like Reply

Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur If I hire someone and find they are not a good fit after a month. What am I supposed to do then? Fire them? wouldn't that be a bigger problem for the candidate than taking a few hours? Also, I usually don't give just a programming test. I usually ask to make a full feature end to end as you would on a job. So, if you do that then I am sure you can do rest of the job as well. And sometimes I have asked candidates to actually make feature I needed in my product. In those cases I have paid the people (pre agreed amount) if their output was actually usable along with an offer letter, despite I end up using some other candidate's work. …more Like Reply

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik You want the candidate to fit in your team, as any good company would, right? I'm saying no coding challenge will help you with that. It does not reflect real working conditions. So even if they do the challenge and you hire them based on that, you might find yourself with somebody that doesn't fit with the team after all. What do you do? Keep them around, frustrating themselves and others? A good candidate would recognize this and quit btw. But I'm asking what you would do if you find out that, despite of a coding challenge, the candidate doesn't fit in your team? …more Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Dipender Kaushik You cannot measure everything important in an interview. In fact, you can't even measure most of what's important in an interview. Studies prove this again and again. Given this reality, what can we do? Firing, as you suggest, may well be the best option in many cases. Whatever the best answer is, we can be sure that polishing the turd that is the interview process isn't it. …more Like Reply

Matheus Inacio • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Sitemate 3y As a third party I've found this a very interesting discussion with valid points on both sides. Like Reply

Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jonathan Hall excuse me what? a chance to prove one's skill by doing a practical is also not adequate according to you? then what should recruiters do? Hire people by throwing dice and fire them next month? Come on. don't just oppose something for the sake of opposing.. Hiring is a challenging thing. Its an ongoing process of improvement. While not all companies are best at it, not all job seekers are honest too. So its a tussle that will keep on going. but no way on earth a company would adopt a policy of hiring without an interview or a test and then keep firing people. That will open another Pandora's box of issues. …more Like Reply

Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur well that is an unfortunate thing. But a practical showcase of your skills reduces chances of being a misfit. Of course it can still happen. In that case we'll do what needs to be done. You are arguing that something does not give 100% result so lets not do it. Name 1 practice that can give 100% result. Its like saying criminal still find ways to commit crime so lets remove all police and security protocols coz they are useless. How is that a solution? …more Like Reply

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman (edited) 3y Dipender Kaushik I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying certain solutions are not adequate enough. I'm not saying don't use a solution at all. In this case, I'm saying that if you already have -actual proof- that a candidate has certain skills acquired, a test won't add much and can even be a disadvantage because lots of people just don't perform well with tests, while they can still be excellent at the job itself. Hence, check skills, do an interview to see if there is a vibe and if so, give them a shot. You'll find out if they fit the team early on. Most of the time, I think you will be good especially if you involved your other devs in the interview. This saves everybody a lot of time and also makes sure everybody invests the right amount of time to the whole process. We are now talking in circles I think. Your position and mine are clear. Thanks for the civilized debate. :-) …more Like Reply

Guille Ojeda • 3rd+ Sr Innovation Architect | AWS & GenAI | Creator of Simple AWS (45k+ readers) | Speaker 3y Jonathan Hall sorry, I tend to do that. Like Reply

Dipender Kaushik • 3rd+ Games Designer | Developer | Founder at Dunali Games 3y Jeroen C Commandeur yeah. As I said, recruitment is a process that keeps evolving. All practices have their own pros and cons. And I have hired people with coding challenge and sometimes with just an interview after looking at the portfolio. I have had experience in dealing with people coming from different experiences and by different processes. I was just pointing out what I like about the coding challenge approach. …more Like Reply

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Andre Biel They have every right to make up the rules. Just as I have every right to challenge those rules because I think they are stupid. Like Reply

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y George Hotz You haven't answered my question yet. Like Reply

Lucian Crisan💻👍 • 3rd+ 🚀 | Tech Leader | Typescript | React | Nodejs | Consultant Software Developer | 20 years (edited) 3y I guess you are happy to compare your solution with the candidates who solve the problem and keep the best. Well, where is the price for the effort? Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha Yes, you're making the same mistake I've already addressed above, in taking the analogy too far. The point is quite simple: There's more than one way to prove that you know how to code. And a take home challenge is only one (and not even a good one at that). Any company unwilling to consider other proof is being foolish. …more Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha Sorry if it doesn't make sense to you. It does to others. Like Reply

Jonathan Hall • 3rd+ I rescue Golang projects written by AI | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily 3y Kaustav Saha You clearly see only that which you want to see. I hope that serves you well. Like Reply

Filip De Munck • 3rd+ Security and Ethical Hacking (JAVA, Python) (edited) 3y A person who made that does not need comma.ai, i am never offended to take a test if i fail it's their los not mine. Like Reply

Kevin N. • 3rd+ Project Lead, AV Integration, Media & Instructional Design 3y Guillermo Ojeda I don't call 2-10 hours of writing code a "challenge", I call that work. Like Reply

Tyler Sheffield • 3rd+ Engineering Tech Lead/Director in Embedded Systems | Sensors | Real-Time | Low-Power 3y Can't think of any reason to submit such a candidate to a silly coding quiz, but some nincompoop somewhere will try to justify it I'm sure. Like Reply

George Hotz George Hotz replied to Andrew Baker’s comment on this George Hotz George Hotz George Hotz 3yr • I'm shocked when people write in saying they want a job, but refuse to do our coding challenge. The job is a coding challenge! I guess it's an easy way to screen people out who'd never fit in here, every job I've applied for I'm excited when they give me coding. I love coding, it's very concrete and can be evaluated without bias. It's so much better than BS like tell me about a "difficult challenge you had to overcome in life" Our challenge, you'll probably learn something doing it too: https://lnkd.in/dUd_2SF …more GitHub - commaai/calib_challenge: The comma.ai Calibration Challenge! github.com 1,117 215 comments 22 reposts Like Comment Repost Send Andrew Baker • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Sift 3y Pay them for their time Like Reply 12 replies 12 Replies on Andrew Baker’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Solving the challenge probably provides more value to the solver than it does to us. Our "microinternships" are paid, where people work on a real problem in our codebase, and some of these provide value to the company. But I think this reflects a deeper cultural issue. I think a company who'd pay for you to do an academic exercise would also view you as a "human resource" …more Like Reply Shahriar Emil • 3rd+ product design | hobbyist engineer 3y George Hotz Been hearing about this “it will give you exposure/experience” bullshit for twelve years and it never freaking gets old. “More value to the solver”. What a joke Like Reply Tomasz Taubert • 3rd+ Talking Engineering at Trust Me, I'm An Engineer 3y Shahriar Emil And just think that someone may become interested, get hired, make money and be happy. Without spoiling the air. Like Reply Azizur Rahman • 3rd+ Architecting secure solutions with decision-making and operational excellence 3y George Hotz As you say "... some of these provide value to the company." You are completely ignoring the value it provides to the company. You are assessing whatever that code test is designed to assess. If it provides any value to the company, why should the candidate not be rewarded fairly for their efforts? If potential candidates instead showed their previous work. Would you still say they are not good candidates? If the answer is no, then your code test has no bearing on decision making. Something I read today, is worth a read - https://blog.wesleyac.com/posts/two-interview-questions - https://sockpuppet.org/blog/2015/03/06/the-hiring-post/ …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Shahriar Emil I would never talk like that, about "exposure" or "experience". You just might learn something is all. I've done several programming challenges for companies with 0 intention to take the job. Gotta be a cool challenge though. Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Fardin Ahsan Why are you applying to 50 companies? Most people who came to comma only applied here, or here and one other place. Like Reply Fardin Ahsan • 3rd+ Product Engineer | Owning the full stack (edited) 3y George Hotz The job market is lets just say not the kindest to recent college grads where I live, especially in more niche fields like datascience, not everywhere in the world is the SF Bay Area and not everyone is George Hotz. I will try out the comma challenge anyways in a week or two when I get free time. Need to better familiarize myself with RNNs. …more Like Reply Philip Peterson • 3rd+ Engineering Leader | YC startups | Building High-Performing Teams (edited) 3y George Hotz The only time I heard a company refer to an interview as a “microinternship” (despite me never agreeing to such a thing or signing any waivers), they illegally published the code I wrote during the interview as part of their production website. Probably won’t be engaging with any more “microinternships.” I was fortunate enough to recover payment for this endeavor after threatening them with legal action. Others may not be so lucky. …more Like Reply Shahriar Emil • 3rd+ product design | hobbyist engineer (edited) 3y George Hotz you’re saying the same thing in different ways. Please consider reevaluating how you view these coding challenges and why they need to be there. People do them because they have no choice because companies are crazy about them. I get that they are necessary but I doubt anyone ever does them thinking “oh man I’m gonna learn so much” …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Shahriar Emil They are not necessary. Not in all cases anyway. That's what they want you to believe. Like Reply Robert Meyer • 3rd+ Co-Founder and CTO at alcemy GmbH (edited) 3y I'm curious if this really works? (the initial statement of paying candidates for challenges) I mean if the person on the other end is a freelancer I suppose they know how to write proper invoices and know how to deal with tax implications and all the documentation they need to provide. If the candidate is just some employee who is looking to change jobs, they may actually end up with a lot more time spent on the consequences of the payment than on the coding challenge. (I'm talking especially from a German perspective here 😂) …more Like Reply Haroon Alam • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Technical Artist 3y Period Like Reply Collapse replies Load more comments

Andrew Baker • 3rd+ Software Engineer at Sift 3y Pay them for their time Like Reply 12 replies 12 Replies on Andrew Baker’s comment George Hotz Author 3y Solving the challenge probably provides more value to the solver than it does to us. Our "microinternships" are paid, where people work on a real problem in our codebase, and some of these provide value to the company. But I think this reflects a deeper cultural issue. I think a company who'd pay for you to do an academic exercise would also view you as a "human resource" …more Like Reply Shahriar Emil • 3rd+ product design | hobbyist engineer 3y George Hotz Been hearing about this “it will give you exposure/experience” bullshit for twelve years and it never freaking gets old. “More value to the solver”. What a joke Like Reply Tomasz Taubert • 3rd+ Talking Engineering at Trust Me, I'm An Engineer 3y Shahriar Emil And just think that someone may become interested, get hired, make money and be happy. Without spoiling the air. Like Reply Azizur Rahman • 3rd+ Architecting secure solutions with decision-making and operational excellence 3y George Hotz As you say "... some of these provide value to the company." You are completely ignoring the value it provides to the company. You are assessing whatever that code test is designed to assess. If it provides any value to the company, why should the candidate not be rewarded fairly for their efforts? If potential candidates instead showed their previous work. Would you still say they are not good candidates? If the answer is no, then your code test has no bearing on decision making. Something I read today, is worth a read - https://blog.wesleyac.com/posts/two-interview-questions - https://sockpuppet.org/blog/2015/03/06/the-hiring-post/ …more Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Shahriar Emil I would never talk like that, about "exposure" or "experience". You just might learn something is all. I've done several programming challenges for companies with 0 intention to take the job. Gotta be a cool challenge though. Like Reply George Hotz Author 3y Fardin Ahsan Why are you applying to 50 companies? Most people who came to comma only applied here, or here and one other place. Like Reply Fardin Ahsan • 3rd+ Product Engineer | Owning the full stack (edited) 3y George Hotz The job market is lets just say not the kindest to recent college grads where I live, especially in more niche fields like datascience, not everywhere in the world is the SF Bay Area and not everyone is George Hotz. I will try out the comma challenge anyways in a week or two when I get free time. Need to better familiarize myself with RNNs. …more Like Reply Philip Peterson • 3rd+ Engineering Leader | YC startups | Building High-Performing Teams (edited) 3y George Hotz The only time I heard a company refer to an interview as a “microinternship” (despite me never agreeing to such a thing or signing any waivers), they illegally published the code I wrote during the interview as part of their production website. Probably won’t be engaging with any more “microinternships.” I was fortunate enough to recover payment for this endeavor after threatening them with legal action. Others may not be so lucky. …more Like Reply Shahriar Emil • 3rd+ product design | hobbyist engineer (edited) 3y George Hotz you’re saying the same thing in different ways. Please consider reevaluating how you view these coding challenges and why they need to be there. People do them because they have no choice because companies are crazy about them. I get that they are necessary but I doubt anyone ever does them thinking “oh man I’m gonna learn so much” …more Like Reply Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Shahriar Emil They are not necessary. Not in all cases anyway. That's what they want you to believe. Like Reply Robert Meyer • 3rd+ Co-Founder and CTO at alcemy GmbH (edited) 3y I'm curious if this really works? (the initial statement of paying candidates for challenges) I mean if the person on the other end is a freelancer I suppose they know how to write proper invoices and know how to deal with tax implications and all the documentation they need to provide. If the candidate is just some employee who is looking to change jobs, they may actually end up with a lot more time spent on the consequences of the payment than on the coding challenge. (I'm talking especially from a German perspective here 😂) …more Like Reply Haroon Alam • 3rd+ Senior Software Engineer | Technical Artist 3y Period Like Reply Collapse replies

George Hotz Author 3y Solving the challenge probably provides more value to the solver than it does to us. Our "microinternships" are paid, where people work on a real problem in our codebase, and some of these provide value to the company. But I think this reflects a deeper cultural issue. I think a company who'd pay for you to do an academic exercise would also view you as a "human resource" …more Like Reply

Shahriar Emil • 3rd+ product design | hobbyist engineer 3y George Hotz Been hearing about this “it will give you exposure/experience” bullshit for twelve years and it never freaking gets old. “More value to the solver”. What a joke Like Reply

Tomasz Taubert • 3rd+ Talking Engineering at Trust Me, I'm An Engineer 3y Shahriar Emil And just think that someone may become interested, get hired, make money and be happy. Without spoiling the air. Like Reply

Azizur Rahman • 3rd+ Architecting secure solutions with decision-making and operational excellence 3y George Hotz As you say "... some of these provide value to the company." You are completely ignoring the value it provides to the company. You are assessing whatever that code test is designed to assess. If it provides any value to the company, why should the candidate not be rewarded fairly for their efforts? If potential candidates instead showed their previous work. Would you still say they are not good candidates? If the answer is no, then your code test has no bearing on decision making. Something I read today, is worth a read - https://blog.wesleyac.com/posts/two-interview-questions - https://sockpuppet.org/blog/2015/03/06/the-hiring-post/ …more Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Shahriar Emil I would never talk like that, about "exposure" or "experience". You just might learn something is all. I've done several programming challenges for companies with 0 intention to take the job. Gotta be a cool challenge though. Like Reply

George Hotz Author 3y Fardin Ahsan Why are you applying to 50 companies? Most people who came to comma only applied here, or here and one other place. Like Reply

Fardin Ahsan • 3rd+ Product Engineer | Owning the full stack (edited) 3y George Hotz The job market is lets just say not the kindest to recent college grads where I live, especially in more niche fields like datascience, not everywhere in the world is the SF Bay Area and not everyone is George Hotz. I will try out the comma challenge anyways in a week or two when I get free time. Need to better familiarize myself with RNNs. …more Like Reply

Philip Peterson • 3rd+ Engineering Leader | YC startups | Building High-Performing Teams (edited) 3y George Hotz The only time I heard a company refer to an interview as a “microinternship” (despite me never agreeing to such a thing or signing any waivers), they illegally published the code I wrote during the interview as part of their production website. Probably won’t be engaging with any more “microinternships.” I was fortunate enough to recover payment for this endeavor after threatening them with legal action. Others may not be so lucky. …more Like Reply

Shahriar Emil • 3rd+ product design | hobbyist engineer (edited) 3y George Hotz you’re saying the same thing in different ways. Please consider reevaluating how you view these coding challenges and why they need to be there. People do them because they have no choice because companies are crazy about them. I get that they are necessary but I doubt anyone ever does them thinking “oh man I’m gonna learn so much” …more Like Reply

Jeroen C Commandeur • 3rd+ Freelance Software Craftsman 3y Shahriar Emil They are not necessary. Not in all cases anyway. That's what they want you to believe. Like Reply

Robert Meyer • 3rd+ Co-Founder and CTO at alcemy GmbH (edited) 3y I'm curious if this really works? (the initial statement of paying candidates for challenges) I mean if the person on the other end is a freelancer I suppose they know how to write proper invoices and know how to deal with tax implications and all the documentation they need to provide. If the candidate is just some employee who is looking to change jobs, they may actually end up with a lot more time spent on the consequences of the payment than on the coding challenge. (I'm talking especially from a German perspective here 😂) …more Like Reply