How can I fix this?

I was following THIS tutorial by starsburn on some of my icons, but I noticed that there was something wrong with the way they were turning out, even though I copied them down to last dot. I then tried it on the icon she used as an example, thinking there might be something wrong with the caps I was using, and still, the same problem. Here:

The way it's supposed to look:

The way mine is turning out:

Do you see what I see? There's a lot of pixel-y dots and red splotches in some places. Is this just something messed up with my Photoshop CS? How can I fix this?

Thanks in advance!

EDIT: PROBLEM SOLVED! :)