removing glare

Program: PSP9

Question: Is there a way to remove a bright glare from one area of your screencap withouth affecting the look of the entire image. I'm trying to make an icon of the the women in the cap and one of them has a bright glare on her right side.

Cap:

What I have so far:

I wasn't sure what topic this would be under, so if it is in the memories, a link is fine.

Thanks!