Skip to content

Feature request: --annotation flag to preload annotations (LLM review workflow) #153

@tushkanin

Description

@tushkanin

Problem

A common step in my workflow — and in many other vibe-coders' workflows — is asking an LLM to do a code review. The result is a list of comments with references to specific files and lines. To judge whether those comments are actually meaningful, I need to look at the corresponding code in my editor, comment by comment. It would be much nicer to open revdiff with that list of comments already preloaded, where I can edit them, drop the ones that don't make sense, and add my own on top — all in the same view as the diff itself.

revdiff already has the perfect surface for this (annotation gutter, @ popup, filter-by-annotated tree, hunk navigation); it just has no way to seed annotations from an external source.

Proposal

Add a repeatable --annotation <json> flag that pre-populates the annotation store at startup with comments supplied inline as JSON. Each value is either a single annotation object or a JSON array of them:

revdiff --annotation '{"file":"app/main.go","line":42,"type":"+","comment":"check error here"}' \
        --annotation '[{"file":"app/main.go","line":80,"end_line":95,"type":"+","comment":"split this"},
                       {"file":"app/main.go","comment":"file-level note"}]' \
        HEAD~1

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions