Skip to content

"Removed knowledge of the bootloader size from BOSSA" commit is dangerously compatibility-breaking #79

@aswild

Description

@aswild

dbdd088 is great, but also dangerous to Arduino SAMx21 users who don't understand its implications.

The first time I ran my "make upload" target, which doesn't specify --offset and worked on v1.8, I bricked my chip by erasing the bootloader code. I have an SWD programmer so it was easy enough to re-flash the bootloader, but others users may not be so fortunate.

There's also a flags incompatibility issue:

Version --offset=0x0000 (default) --offset=0x2000
1.8 Correct, writes to 0x2000 Incorrect, writes to 0x4000 (but bootloader still works)
1.9 Dangerous, writes to 0x0000 and kills the bootloader Correct, writes to 0x2000

I don't have any great ideas for handling the changes to --offset, but I think it could be beneficial to print a warning and require confirmation (or an explicit --offset=0 argument) before erasing/writing anything at address 0.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions