Summary

When Codex OAuth refresh starts timing out or a profile later returns 401 Unauthorized: Your authentication token has been invalidated, OpenClaw can keep retrying inside the same provider/auth lane for hours without surfacing a clear operator-visible incident and without rotating aggressively enough across other valid profiles.

Observed behavior

On my local OpenClaw runtime, Dev was effectively down for about a day even though some Codex subscriptions were still valid. The system did retry and sometimes fell back from openai/gpt-5.5 to openai/gpt-5.4, but that was still inside the same Codex auth path and did not resolve the incident.

What it did wrong:

• kept retrying a failing Codex OAuth refresh path for many hours
• did not raise a clear operator-visible alert saying a subscription/auth profile was failing
• did not rotate hard enough across other configured valid profiles after repeated refresh timeouts
• later encountered a hard 401 invalidated on one profile after the prolonged timeout loop

Expected behavior

After repeated refresh timeouts or an invalidated-token response, OpenClaw should:

• classify this as an auth-profile/subscription incident, not a generic long-running retry
• surface a visible alert to the operator
• quarantine the failing profile/provider path sooner
• rotate across other valid configured profiles more aggressively
• avoid leaving an agent effectively down for hours while only logging internal fallback churn

Concrete evidence

From ~/.openclaw/logs/gateway.err.log:

• 2026-05-23T12:42:10.723-07:00
embedded run failover decision ... rawError=auth refresh request timed out after 10s
• 2026-05-23T12:43:19.371-07:00
Embedded agent failed before reply: All models failed (2): openai/gpt-5.5: auth refresh request timed out after 10s (timeout) | openai/gpt-5.4: auth refresh request timed out after 10s (timeout)
• this same pattern repeats across cron and direct session runs through 2026-05-24T13:27:55.170-07:00
• 2026-05-24T14:28:22.074-07:00
embedded run failover decision ... reason=auth ... rawError=unexpected status 401 Unauthorized: Your authentication token has been invalidated. Please try signing in again.

Current runtime state after restart/reauth showed multiple configured openai-codex OAuth profiles, including both Pro and Free accounts, but the outage path was not surfaced as a clear profile-selection/auth incident.

Environment

• OpenClaw 2026.5.22
• runtime from local gateway logs
• Codex provider via OAuth profiles
• Discord-triggered agent plus cron-triggered runs both affected

Why this matters

This failure mode makes the system look like the model or subscription is just "down" while the actual problem is auth refresh/profile management. The current behavior costs hours of silent degraded service and forces manual log spelunking to understand what happened.

Suggested fix areas

• auth failure classification for repeated Codex refresh timeouts
• provider/profile quarantine and rotation policy
• operator-visible incident/alert path
• session status surface making it obvious which auth profile is failing and why