It seems like winit might not be reporting the shifted character at all in combination with CMD. If that's the case we should report it to the Winit team, since all other platforms does that, and it would be better if it's consistent. As a last resort the following code could be modified to not strip out shift (and probably not alt either) if CMD is held on macOS

Lines 119 to 134 in eeac6e7

    
               pub fn format_modifier_string(&self, is_special: bool) -> String { 
        
                   // Is special is used for special keys so that all modifiers are always included 
        
                   // It's also true with alt_is_meta is set to true. 
        
                   // When the key is not special, shift is removed, since the base character is already 
        
                   // shifted. Furthermore on macOS, meta is additionally removed when alt_is_meta is set to false 
        
                   let shift = or_empty(self.modifiers.state().shift_key() && is_special, "S-"); 
        
                   let ctrl = or_empty(self.modifiers.state().control_key(), "C-"); 
        
                   let alt = or_empty( 
        
                       self.modifiers.state().alt_key() && (use_alt() || is_special), 
        
                       "M-", 
        
                   ); 
        
                   let logo = or_empty(self.modifiers.state().super_key(), "D-"); 
        
                   shift.to_owned() + ctrl + alt + logo 
        
               } 
        
           }

	pub fn format_modifier_string(&self, is_special: bool) -> String {
	// Is special is used for special keys so that all modifiers are always included
	// It's also true with alt_is_meta is set to true.
	// When the key is not special, shift is removed, since the base character is already
	// shifted. Furthermore on macOS, meta is additionally removed when alt_is_meta is set to false
	let shift = or_empty(self.modifiers.state().shift_key() && is_special, "S-");
	let ctrl = or_empty(self.modifiers.state().control_key(), "C-");
	let alt = or_empty(
	self.modifiers.state().alt_key() && (use_alt() \|\| is_special),
	"M-",
	);
	let logo = or_empty(self.modifiers.state().super_key(), "D-");

	shift.to_owned() + ctrl + alt + logo
	}
	}

Uh oh!

CMD + SHIFT works as CMD only #1237

Description

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions