Discussions

• 5 You must be logged in to vote

  ❔

  Can I opt out of AI training altogether?

  CC-signals announced Jul 3, 2025 in FAQ

  

  

  

  

  4
• 10 You must be logged in to vote

  💡

  Why making this proposal in the first place?

  Nomys started Jun 26, 2025 in Open feedback, suggestions, and ideas

  

  

  

  

  12
• 4 You must be logged in to vote

  🚦

  No AI scraping, no entering into an LLM

  jsalmons started Jul 17, 2025 in CC signal elements

  

  

  

  

  4
• 3 You must be logged in to vote

  ❔

  What is AI? Is CC pro-AI?

  CC-signals announced Jul 9, 2025 in FAQ

  

  

  

  

  9
• 31 You must be logged in to vote

  💡

  You are burning the trust of your actual supporters

  RichiH started Jun 26, 2025 in Open feedback, suggestions, and ideas

  

  

  

  

  17
• 28 You must be logged in to vote

  💡

  Your proposal is fundamentally bad; withdraw it.

  mcclure started Jun 25, 2025 in Open feedback, suggestions, and ideas

  

  

  

  

  33
• 6 You must be logged in to vote

  ❔

  Why CC signals?

  CC-signals announced Jul 2, 2025 in FAQ

  

  

  

  

  9
• 6 You must be logged in to vote

  💡

  Nice Implementation of Something, but Not a Solution

  jcolag started Jun 27, 2025 in Open feedback, suggestions, and ideas

  

  

  

  

  2
• 3 You must be logged in to vote

  ❔

  Who is CC signals targeting?

  CC-signals announced Jul 8, 2025 in FAQ

  

  

  

  

  2
• ❔

  Creative Commons is closed the week of July 21

  CC-signals announced Jul 17, 2025 in FAQ · Closed

  

  

  0
• 2 You must be logged in to vote

  ⚖️

  Signals as opposed to legal contracts are worthless

  LonMcGregor started Jun 26, 2025 in Legal effect of CC signals

  

  

  

  

  2
• 2 You must be logged in to vote

  ❔

  What if CC signals functioned as a contract instead?

  CC-signals announced Jul 17, 2025 in FAQ

  

  

  0
• 8 You must be logged in to vote

  ⚖️

  CC license is fundamentally incompatible with generative AI.

  greg-kennedy started Jun 25, 2025 in Legal effect of CC signals

  

  

  

  

  4
• 3 You must be logged in to vote

  ❔

  Is this for creators?

  CC-signals announced Jul 9, 2025 in FAQ

  

  

  

  

  4
• 4 You must be logged in to vote

  ✅

  Do creators agree with CC-BY being satisfied if their contribution is attributed at the model level and not at the output level?

  drawnto started Jun 26, 2025 in Compliance by AI developers

  

  

  

  

  13
• 3 You must be logged in to vote

  ❔

  Why would AI developers follow this if they aren’t legally required to?

  CC-signals announced Jul 8, 2025 in FAQ

  

  

  0
• 1 You must be logged in to vote

  🚦

  CC

  linck628 started Jul 3, 2025 in CC signal elements · Closed

  

  

  2
• 1 You must be logged in to vote

  ⚖️

  enabled by the CC signals

  farshadjanu1 started Jul 6, 2025 in Legal effect of CC signals · Closed

  

  

  1
• 5 You must be logged in to vote

  ❔

  Defend CC licensed work against AI scraping! Why aren’t CC license terms enough to prevent the kind of AI training we don’t want?

  CC-signals announced Jul 3, 2025 in FAQ

  

  

  2
• 58 You must be logged in to vote

  💡

  This is all so *very* wrong.

  steph72 started Jun 26, 2025 in Open feedback, suggestions, and ideas

  

  

  

  

  25
• 2 You must be logged in to vote

  💡

  Collection of articles and blogs with reference to CC Signals

  CJS-Design started Jun 27, 2025 in Open feedback, suggestions, and ideas

  

  

  

  

  7
• 11 You must be logged in to vote

  💡

  A license option for no consent to AI training is needed

  paragonian started Jun 25, 2025 in Open feedback, suggestions, and ideas

  

  

  

  

  4
• 4 You must be logged in to vote

  ✅

  Does training on CC-BY-NC prevent use and execution for commercial purposes of the model?

  drawnto started Jun 26, 2025 in Compliance by AI developers

  

  

  

  

  4
• 4 You must be logged in to vote

  💡

  Are the authors of this going to discuss anything here, or are we talking to a wall?

  tuxwise started Jul 1, 2025 in Open feedback, suggestions, and ideas

  

  

  1
• 6 You must be logged in to vote

  🤝

  Collective Bargaining for Data

  anoanoano started Jun 29, 2025 in Collective action

  

  

  

  

  2