-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2k
Description
Different metadata sources (be it MusicBrainz, Discogs, or something else) have different coverage and users might have to use both for tagging their music. As an example, very often, I cannot find metadata on MusicBrainz and I end up using Discogs instead, and this, as #604 mentions, pollutes the MBID tag space.
In general, it will be great to to make tagging approach more generic and agnostic to metadata sources because:
- Mixing metadata from different sources using the same ID3 tags makes the database inconsistent and this will be a disadvantage in the long term.
- More metadata sources is better (different sources might bring complementary information, why not to store it all? Some users will want this)
This can be achieved by adding an option to allow mining metadata from multiple sources simultaneously having a custom TXXX namespace for each one. To select which source metadata is used as a "master" source for the main ID3 tags, a user should be able to define his own order of preference (similar to a proposal in #2686). The TXXX namespaces for each source could be all customizable by a user too.